Forgive me for the lengthy post, but I couldn't find fewer words to describe what I'm thinking.
I have followed the content James has produced for years and enjoy the breath of fresh air and non-snobby vibe that he brings to the industry. I enjoyed the last video and don't disagree with it, but I have a feeling that the whole picture isn't being explored.
Most of the YouTube comments seem to converge on the notion that it is okay to pay more for coffee if that is what it takes, but I would like to expand more on the subject. One of the channel's aims is to make people enjoy and value coffee more, which can be interpreted in 2 ways - either the appreciation of coffee or the price of coffee, which seems to be more prevalent now.
Some of you may share the sentiment that with rising coffee prices, drinking coffee is on the border of general affordability for some of us. Even if you live in a developed country, your wage may not be indicative of the value you provide, thus making coffee seem more expensive for some than others. In a case of someone asking for the further raising of prices, I think that if that is based on some transparency of the supply chain, then the whole supply chain should be transparent. Otherwise, you are left with the feeling that only you are leveraged towards the benefit of others. If drinking less coffee is a potential answer - how much less than 1 cup of coffee per day should it be?
If you are going to tell the truth, you have to tell the whole truth, because it would seem disingenuous if, say, 20% of the price of your favorite drink is overanalyzed, but the other 80% is a mystery - it creates the feeling that it is opaque, because if it wasn't, then it would seem that it should be lower - either it shouldn't be 80%, or we should get an adequate explanation why it is 80%.
Here are my interpretations of the value of coffee - generally you have the green beans, the roasting, and the brewing. I'm going to focus on the last 2, since the video was focused on the first.
When a roaster roasts coffee, let's say that it generally loses 20% of its weight. If you add another 20% of the green beans price for the roasting process + packaging, say 20% for taxes and 20% profit, you get around 2x the price of green beans per kg of roasted coffee before shipping (keep in mind that businesses can write off some of those things, along with the initial green coffee, as tax deductibles). The numbers can be different, and I'm using them to have something for practical calculation, but the principle should apply nonetheless. There are some costs along with dialing in the roast before stepping into mass roasting, but after that the process can be highly automatable and scalable relative to the coffee producer's workload.
Very few roasters list the price at which they bought the green beans, and some of the ones that do have a selling price of 4-5-6 times the price of the raw coffee (at 1 kg bags, at lower weights the ratio is higher, understandably). The ones that don't show the price could have an even higher ratio potentially. This scales the same with more expensive green beans, which means that either even the cheap beans make a profit (which means the expensive ones make massive profits), or they are subsidized and the roaster hopes that you buy expensive beans rather than having it be somewhat a flat rate after a certain point, leaving mostly the tax and loss by weight from roasting.
So in this example, if a coffee roaster decides to give 2x (2x15 = 30) the price for the green beans, some of that increased price should go back to the coffee producer based on their % cut in the price, and the roaster would still have 20% for profit if the price was 2x (2x30 = 60) the new price, against the old 4x (4x15 = 60) but undervalued green beans, and this wouldn't affect the consumer price at all. Whether or not the coffee roasters would do that rather than pass along the price to you is another thing. Because adjusting to the situation requires effort from all parties involved. The businesses should become more intelligent rather than staying the same and expecting consumers to bear the cost like in every other opaque sector.
Some of you may say that this wouldn't be viable for all coffee roasters, but I have something to tell you - that is okay. Not every business venture is destined to be a success, there are failures as well. It is the business owner's responsibility to make a viable business, not yours, and if such doesn't exist, then it shouldn't. If you want to sell, you have 2 general options - sell at a lower price with higher volume or at a higher price with a lower volume. But if you want to be on the moral high ground that you are supporting producers, you have to accept both the positives and the negatives - that means that if you are selling at a higher price, you are basically saying that the work you have put into roasting the coffee is more valuable than the work the farmer put into producing it - which is ultimately up to the potential buyer to decide.
As the alternative meaning of the word "value", you can value the coffee by roasting it yourself. Some of the aroma during roasting can be very pleasant and give you an additional experience out of the beans you have purchased. As a bonus, you can have another ritual and skill to hone, since you can't always have roasted coffee at the level you like.
Will it be better than the one produced by a business? Probably not, but unless you turn the beans into charcoal, you will enjoy them nonetheless, and the producer would get their fair share. Also, not all roasters are created equal, and depending on the equipment you have and the experience you gain along the way, you could potentially beat the quality of some businesses. On top of that, there would be less waste from packaging, and you always get fresh coffee (since some roasters roast in batches, and you may not always get 1 week or less old coffee if you want to, and shipping potentially delays that further). You could argue that everyone would need a roasting machine, which is also waste, but comparatively to coffee machines, there are fewer junk roasting machines, so it is subjective.
Also as a side note, I didn't hear even a ballpark number of how much 1 kg of green coffee should cost so that the farmers could support themselves, because "hard work" is a subjective term without a clear monetary expression. I have a feeling that it either wasn't calculated or that it was, and it might be so high that it wasn't said, because it could be used speculatively by people in the supply chain to raise prices without any of the additional proceeds going back to the farmers.
A potential step towards transparency/traceability could be that there is an organization that gives coffee roasters a symbolic discount over green coffee purchase pricing, but only if the roasters list on their packaging what is the purchase price of the green beans. It could also include how much actual green coffee is used for 1 kg of roasted coffee based on the roasting profile for the specific package, along with the green bean price multiplied by it, so that it is clear on the package how much the green coffee costs to produce it. This way consumers can decide whether the price the roaster sets is adequate. Also, roasters that offer higher prices but free shipping should disclose how much shipping costs so that you know how much of it is subsidized and what is clear profit when you purchase a lot of packages but don't get an extra discount. This way you would have a small incentive as a business owner to list these details, and once many do and customers expect it, others might catch on to the trend and make it universal.
The other part is the coffee brewing. Gordon Ramsay has famously said that his pricing for meals is such that what the customer pays could be split in 3 parts: 1/3 covers the raw materials; 1/3 covers the labor cost; 1/3 is overhead and profit. Should the coffee industry implement a similar approach? Should a cup of coffee (barring additives like milk, etc.) cost no more than 3-4x the price of the roasted coffee that went into creating it? I added up to 4x because there could be specialty water involved and/or consumables like paper filters. Another case is that often a coffee roaster would have a cafe, which would make their margin potentially even higher.
The counterpoint is brewing at home, where your coffee making can be seen as a ritual and something that brings you extra joy in the day, along with cost savings. Also, depending on your region, you could potentially be making better coffee at home than 80-90% of the places around you.
I don't mean for this to be against anyone in particular, just how the state of coffee seems these times. I would rather that the value is redistributed in the supply chain proportionately before being asked for more money. This is a problem of exploitation in many countries in the world for even basic things like milk from cows versus the price in stores or the price of cheese made from said milk - the value seems to be always captured from the final processing step and the store selling the goods, rather than the initial raw material producer who has the highest investment and risk involved.
I think people would be more accepting of a higher final price for them if they know that the value assigned to each of the steps their coffee takes while reaching them is proportional to the work done. Even then probably most of us wouldn't be happy, but at least we would know that it couldn't be cheaper than that, because everything is transparent.
Ultimately what dictates the price should be the quality of the cup, and having character and lore around it should be a nice bit of information that you can read when you want to know more - I bet even people who don't drink coffee would be very interested in that, because after all it is a story about people. We all know that most/all of us would never be able to visit their farms, but when passionate people work and produce quality goods, they should be valued accordingly.
Lastly, here are some thoughts/questions about the future:
- Will coffee enjoyers ultimately start buying only green beans on principle to support the farmers and/or because that will be the only way they can afford to drink coffee at least once per day?
- Should coffee roasters transform into shops that essentially offer different types of green coffee beans with the option to roast them for a flat fee and give you what is produced from the roast with the ability to use your own packaging if you are in-store to reduce waste?
- Will it be considered a luxury in the future to have more than 4 cups of coffee per month?
If you have stayed till now, thank you so much for reading, and I hope you have a great day!
Edit: TL;DR copied kindly from omz13
Growers get screwed over. The middle-men in the supply chain do nicely. Those at retail end plead thin margins but somehow do very well. Life sucks at either end of the chain for different reasons. Thank you for listening to my TED talk.