r/JamesEllroy • • Jul 02 '26

Looking for some non-white male author recos

0 Upvotes

Trying to expand my horizons a bit, and thought I’d see if my fellow Ellroy enjoyers could recommend some good crime/thriller novels not written by white guys

Edit: thanks for all the recos! I’m currently 50 pages into A Brief History of Seven Killings and am enjoying it so far, definitely see the American Tabloid comparisons


r/JamesEllroy • • Oct 19 '26

Does anyone else find White Jazz boring and meandering?

0 Upvotes

Dave Klein is not as compelling as Bucky or Ed Exeley


r/JamesEllroy • • Sep 16 '26

Hi, I just bought the LA Quartet (never read anything by Ellroy), just wondering what I can expect from it. Appreciate all responses.

1 Upvotes

Basically the title, let me know what I can expect.

Edit: all of yall bitch about how I should “just read it” need to stfu. I don’t have the books yet I’m getting them this Sunday. I was excited to see what I had in store and the few sour grapes in here need to chill out.


r/JamesEllroy • • Aug 30 '26

Are any of Ellroy’s noir books set in places OTHER than L.A.?

0 Upvotes

Here me out, I know that’s basically his thing, but while I’ve only just started reading his work, before him, most of the detective fiction I’ve been reading has been set in Los Angeles, Hollywood, and was wondering if he ever did anything in, say, New York, or Chicago?

Was kind of hoping maybe he wrote something in something like Probibition Chicago or something.


r/JamesEllroy • • Oct 01 '26

American Tabloid

Post image
0 Upvotes

Pablo Schreiber as Big Pete
Robert Pattinson as Kemper
Jeremy Strong as Ward

… and a 5 second AI snapshot to see how they fit the bill. too bad it will never happen ;)


r/JamesEllroy • • Jul 17 '26

Pages not properly cut?

Post image
7 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I bought Red Sheet, and I notice that not all the pages are neatly cut. Is that supposed to be like that? Do you have that too? I see it in the books in this photo as well.


r/JamesEllroy • • Nov 19 '25

American Tabloid hard to follow or just me?

4 Upvotes

I'm about 115 pages into the book and it feels hard to follow to me. I don't really know where the story is going or if it's supposed to be going anywhere. People are spying on people that are spying on them, etc. It also makes it difficult that people have similar names and are called by both first and last names.

Does it get easier to follow and is there a main plot point that is revealed or is it like this the whole time. I'm enjoying it for what it is but I feel like I'm missing something. Almost like I should've group up in the '60s to really get it.


r/JamesEllroy • • Aug 04 '26

Who wins

0 Upvotes

Sorry for spam posts but just discovered this forum. Dumb question but locked in a room,
Dudley Smith
Danny Upshaw,
Buzz Meeks
Bud White
Bucky Bliechart
Lee Blanchard
Dave Klien
Scotty Bennet
no .38s no weapons just good old fists who’s walking out?
Disclaimers im yet to read the cold six thousand and American Tabloid I am familiar with Pete perhaps I haven’t gotten to much of his feats yet. Sorry about the spelling


r/JamesEllroy • • Aug 04 '26

Updated fight list

1 Upvotes

Trimmed the fat for my who wins, Danny is a scrapper but does feel out of his depth with these other guys, I love Meeks to death but he probably would get gassed out early. I’ll include Dudley he’s my favorite I have a slight bias but I will admit he’s no spring chicken when all these other characters would be present.

Updated list
Lee
Bucky
Bud White
Scotty Bennet
Dave Klien
And of course
BIG PETE HIMSELF
sorry I haven’t read the two books that feature him the most yet but I’m aware of the character Leaving him out of this fight is a crime!


r/JamesEllroy • • Oct 18 '23

Perfidia: L.A. Confidential 2

0 Upvotes

I'm halfway through Perfidia. Does anyone else feel like this is just L.A. Confidential all over again? Scotty is Bud. Parker is Exley. Kay is Lynn. Dudley is still Dudley I guess.

The plot is different (though I have very little memory of the intricacies of the LAC plot), but the character arcs are the same thing all over again. No one's going to accuse Ellroy of being wholly original with every book, but this one really feels like a "reboot."


r/JamesEllroy • • Nov 17 '24

Typo in LA Quartet Everyman edition? Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

Sad to see. Thoroughly enjoying it otherwise though.


r/JamesEllroy • • Sep 24 '25

Can I read The cold six thousand before American tabloid ?

3 Upvotes

I went to my favorite used book store and they had TCST for 2 bucks but I know it’s a sequel to American tabloid and part of that trilogy. I started reading it and there’s nothing explicitly in the first chapter that makes it feel directly connected to any other story however I feel maybe you guys would know better about stuff that picks up later on in the book.


r/JamesEllroy • • Sep 15 '26

Did anybody think THE BIG NOWHERE was Ellroy’s Weaker Books ? And, it came nowhere close to the quality Black Dahlia or LA confidential, or Red Sheet.

0 Upvotes

r/JamesEllroy • • Dec 27 '25

Reinventing The Wheel?

4 Upvotes

Not sure how I feel about this. If you think about 50’s LA crime, well, it’s sort of Ellroy, and before him, Chandler.

I suppose you can’t copyright an era based on writing about it, but this series seems redundant.

The only saving grace, I suppose is doesn’t allow a Rings Of Power-style butchering of JE’s work.

https://www.themovieblog.com/2025/12/kurt-sutters-new-1950s-noir-drama-sparks-excitement-on-mgm/


r/JamesEllroy • • Aug 13 '26

Having hard time getting into Ellroy. Suggestions

5 Upvotes

Was gifted Red Sheet. Never read any his works before; have seen LA Confidential and enjoyed, for what that’s worth. i Consider myself fairly strong reader, and having hard time getting into RS. Read about 90 pages from beginning, found myself losing interest, then skipped around in book.

Any suggestions on what might make me more interested in Ellroy? Even if it means putting this book down and buying anotger of his works? Or any personal stories about how you got into Ellroy? Thanks!


r/JamesEllroy • • Nov 21 '23

Signed copy of The Enchanters

1 Upvotes

Hey, I have two signed copies of "The Enchanters." One I'm not willing to part with, but the other I may have to get rid of due to lack of funds. If you're interested, let me know and I can send pictures.


r/JamesEllroy • • 8d ago

Red Sheet is an embarrassingly bad effort from Ellroy Spoiler

11 Upvotes

Like most of us, I got hooked on James Ellroy after reading his LA Quartet and Underworld Trilogies. I love his kinetic style, the way he overloads us with information, the language, the violence and everything else.

You will find all the elements here, but what is missing is the magic that made an Ellroy book.

Ellroy has always made his readers work hard to follow his plots. The payoffs have usually been worth it. Not in this case. Here, complexity has become confusion, eccentricity has become caricature, and his trademark prose feels less like a stylistic achievement than an obstacle to understanding the story.

The writing is just not convincing at all. Ellroy tries to make his characters weird... and this time pushes things too far. Characters like to dress up and burn effigies! Communists dress up like fascists! And vice versa! Hugh Hefner is gay and gets bullied by his own bunnies! Richard Nixon is actually a sweet old grandfather who really likes to take care of the poor! It all feels very strained and artificial.

There is a major structural flaw in the plot construction. The characters seem to share a common, author-controlled pool of knowledge. Fred O'Tash, the main character, either deduces or figures out a complex plot point/conspiracy. Immediately, every single character who interacts with him brings up the same plot point in a very generic way, as it, doesn't everyone know this already? Alternately, as soon as he figures it out, other characters somehow deduce that he has figured out and take actions accordingly.

And then there are the reveals... or should we say the non-reveals? There is this so called gang of communist killers who are deep cover... but it turns out they are the face of the communist party all along?

Charles Lindberg gives one of the characters a bunch of money in old gold notes. Somehow the evil commie killers immediately deduce that this has happened and ambush the character that night itself. How did they find out? And how did they organize the ambush so quickly?

What or earth is the point of the gold notes? Do they have any value? The gold notes are being counterfeited... or are they? They have value only if they are returned to Charles Lindbergh? WTF? Are there no gold notes extant that did not come from Lindbergh? Perhaps there are one-liners here or there that might answer these questions, but in my opinion the novel completely fails in establishing a coherent relationship between the notes, their value and the motivations of the characters pursuing them.

Ellroy's Madonna-Whore complex is on full display here... every main character (all the way from Peter Bondurant to now O'Tash) falls in love with some 'quirky' woman at first site, and behaves so weirdly with them that most regular women would get the 'Ick' immediately. And what do they see in him anyway? And what is with the weird dialog between them? Cringeworthy in the extreme.

The writing towards the end is so bad that it was extremely difficult to figure out what the author was trying to convey. I am talking about the basic plot, not some metaphysical hidden meaning.

I wish I hadn't read this book. It's bad enough that Ellroy has written something so disappointing. What's worse is that it has made me wonder whether some of the flaws I found so unbearable here were present in his earlier novels all along, and I was simply too enthralled to notice.


r/JamesEllroy • • Mar 03 '26

Anyone watch Rampant, the movie starring Woody Harrelson and written by Ellroy?

8 Upvotes

picked up a copy for a couple of bucks from Goodwill and wondering if other people have watched it


r/JamesEllroy • • Apr 08 '26

Lost steam. What happened? Ideas?

5 Upvotes

Stopped halfway through Blood's a Rover and haven't picked up since. And I'm a guy who loved the Lloyd Hopkins and, well, appreciated Silent Terror/Killer on the Road. What am I missing?


r/JamesEllroy • • Sep 25 '26

Should I read Widespread Panic?

2 Upvotes

r/JamesEllroy • • Aug 11 '26

Is LA confidential worth reading if you’ve seen the movie, if so why ?

18 Upvotes

r/JamesEllroy • • Oct 12 '26

What is your Ellroy hot take?

25 Upvotes

Here's mine: The Black Dahlia just isn't very good.

The prose drags, Bucky is a snoozefest of a protagonist, while each book can be read independtly Black Dahlia nevertheless has the least connection to the others, Dudley Smith is nowhere to be found, and it helped popularize harmful misconceptions about Elizabeth Short such as her doing porn, being promiscious, and other bullshit.

Short isn't JFK, Mickey Cohen, Chief Parker, or other public figures who, on some level, had to know and accept that their legacy and image would no longer entirely be in their hands. She was a random woman who was brutally murdered. The book was published less than 50 years after her death and dominates how the case is discussed to this day. It's tasteless to take a real victim and use them as a prop, atleast while their family is still alive. Short's youngest sister died in 2023!

The Big Nowhere, L.A Confidential, and White Jazz form a trilogy in my eyes. I skip over The Black Dahlia.


r/JamesEllroy • • Oct 12 '25

Is Perfida a way back into Ellroy?

14 Upvotes

I need to lay out the context. I worshiped at the grungy shrine of JE when the LA Quartet was published and really dug American Tabloid.

And then came The Cold Six Thousand and … it did nothing. I actively disliked much of it. I picked up Blood’s a Rover but only got a hundred of so pages in. There didn’t feel any character to invest in tbh.

So.. are the recent series books likely to change that or do they continue in the tone I disliked quite a bit?

UPDATE

In response to some chat in the responses I’ll lay out why I became dispirited by the Cold Six T. You can take it or leave it.

It coincided with when JE became a superstar.

I suspect it was the direction taken from the author’s preface to American Tabloid - the “here’s to the bad men” line.

It’s very different to the LA Quarter which had desperate ruined men fighting not to drown in a sewer of hatred, racism and violence.

So Underwold USA is about the bad guys. Cool. It’s the same world of brutal misogyny and race hate but not filtered. I can work with that.

It’s not the racism for eg. I don’t believe Ellroy is a racist. I really don’t. But I felt he was getting off on how transgressive he could be. Almost turned on by a licence to shock. Massive audience, critical acclaim to die for, the demon dog can blow out the lights!

I kept getting an ugly image of one hand on the typewriter keys and the other…elsewhere.

Look, I’m probably projecting here, but it read like fame had hit and it had an impact which for me, as a reader, didn’t do much.

Most of you probably see this is bullshit and I can’t /won’t argue. I simply miss the awe when I hit the final pages of The Big Nowhere. I’d love that buzz again.


r/JamesEllroy • • Sep 25 '26

My idea cast for American Tabloid

10 Upvotes

Title was supposed to read ideal sorry
Just off the top of my head:

Ben Affleck as Pete Bonduraunt
He’s got the size he stands at 6ft4 and his performance in the town helps me think he could pull it off. I know a lot of people like Michael Shannon but he’s so gaunt I can’t buy him breaking a pair of handcuffs. Aware this is a bit of a controversial choice.

Jeremy Strong as Ward Littell
Mainly because I was binge watching succession while reading the cold six thousand and started reading his part like him.

Ryan Gosling as Kemper Boyd
If he could pull off his charm blended with the performance he gives in blade runner 2049 I think he honestly do it. My other choice is Josh Hartnett

Other cast members I can think of

Giovanni Ribsi as J Edgar Hoover
Ben Mackenzie as JFK
Elizabeth Olsen as Barb Jahelka
Guy Pearce as Howard Hughes
David Krumholtz as Jack Ruby

Honestly just sitting here top of my head I know I’m leaving a lot out but it would have to be a massive cast.