Don't get me wrong, I like this show a lot, but its just missing so much of the character. I know Lee Child said he wasn't happy with Cruise's size, which everyone seems to repeat, they forget he said Cruise captured everything else about Reacher and made him better.
Reacher is a pulp fiction superhero. Obviously his size and appearance is the first thing you see, literally, but thats not what makes him special. Its all the other things - his intelligence, presence, quick wits, resolve, moral code, and just plain being lethal.
Cruise had all that in spades. He had the presence and aura, you could believe this was not a man to be messed with, and everyone he came into contact with realized how smart and resourceful he was, just like in the books.
Alan Ritchson is never going to be 1/100th as good an actor as Cruise, but its also the appearance and the writing. This season they've chosen to make him buffier and dumber than ever. He comes across as a dumb jock or NFL linebacker vs someone smart and deadly. When he says 'I want to throw you out of a helicopter' it doesn't sound scary at all.
And then there's the physicality. Reacher is an expert in all forms of combat, like it says in the books, he's hunting trained killers and has to be better than them. This includes special forces. In the Cruise movies, he has no problem taking down 4-5 guys with ease. His fighting looks a lot superior, as it should.
In this show, he fights like a bar brawler. He gets cut in a fight 1v1 vs a street thug, in s1 he almost drowned. He should be so much better. The fight choreography is to blame, and the stupid editing, or maybe he didn't train to learn the moves?
None of it is memorable in any way. Think Jason Bourne fighting, people still remember that.
Or how about the shooting. Reacher is one of the best in the world. He won the Wimbledon cup, he's so legendary instructors remember him decades later. So of course when its time to shoot, the show writers think instead of shooting he should run and present a 8x6ft target a blind man could hit, never mind 2 snipers at close range, but of course the stupid writing means he's invincible. Now compare that to the sniper scenes in the movies, or Cruise handling guns in general.
All they had to do was film the book. Instead they've added stupid scenes like the 'girl power' scene with Dixon and Neagley disappearing into thin air and then armed men with machine guns running scared from pistols. Or the loud shouty bald fat cop whos the same in every scene.
S1 was so much better because it followed the book closely. Ironically the best part of S2 has been the surprise appearance of Finlay.
I hope they pick better writers for S3.
edit - people seem to think I'm against this show. here's a post I made when s1 came out -
'Reacher' on Amazon Prime is fantastic! And it shows you shouldn't mess with great source material
and I stand by it. S1 was much better