r/JackReacher • • Aug 08 '24

Things a British Author Gets Wrong

0 Upvotes

I’m rereading the Reacher series and I’m frequently reminded of the little things that Child gets wrong. I’m sure there are more, but as an American, the things I notice are about guns and cars. Sort of the way Deighton has Americans say “physiotherapy” rather than “physical therapy.”

I’m reading “The Midnight Line” now and he describes the rifle as an “M14 Garand.” There never was such a thing and no former Army officer who won a long range shooting competition would call it that. In “Killing Floor,” he talks about how a 90 grain 9mm is low velocity subsonic. A 90 grain 9mm would be either very high velocity or not cycle the action. A 90 grain would be subsonic in a .380 (9mm kurtz). There’s the one where loading M9s multiple times would cause a failure to fire, when the issue would be failure to feed.

There’s lots of car errors, but the one that comes to mind is when he gets an 80s Corvette and says it has a bigger engine than the sedans of the era. Nope. Same engine, same size.

Anyway, I really like the books and am rereading them, but it’s half frustrating that a character that professes attention to detail has these issues and half enjoyment of my own interaction with the stories.

Are there other things that a British author gets wrong about Americana?


r/JackReacher • • Aug 14 '25

‘Reacher’ Spin-Off ‘Neagley’ Faces Trouble as Paramount Merger Splits Studios

Thumbnail
watchinamerica.com
0 Upvotes

r/JackReacher • • Dec 30 '23

Loved S1 of Reacher, not so much S2...

1 Upvotes

But have also been watching Bosch : Legacy (Freevee in the UK) which is soo much better than Reacher in terms of acting, pacing, realism and production values.

It maybe because the book writer (Michael Connelly) has control over the screen production ?

Give Bosch a try, I Can highly recommend 👌🏻


r/JackReacher • • Jul 20 '22

who would win jack reacher tv version vs John wick vs nobody vs Tyler rake

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/JackReacher • • Aug 31 '26

They should do a multiverse Jack Reacher where Tom Cruise and Alan Ritchson run an Econo Lodge.

7 Upvotes

r/JackReacher • • Jan 11 '24

Not liking TVseason 2

0 Upvotes

I've read all the reacher books. So, I'm somewhat a fan.

I quite liked TV season 1 and was very happy that Reacher was physically what I expected (not as in the movies with handsome Tom Cruise).

But I honestly can't get into season 2. I hate Reacher being part and working in a team. It's probably better for the screenplay, I get that. But that's just not what the books are all about. That's just not what I like about Reacher. Reacher is a loner.

What are your opinions? Do you like the Team in season 2?


r/JackReacher • • Jan 28 '24

Everything that's sadly wrong with S2..

1 Upvotes

Is presented during the poorly contrived Helicopter sequence in Ep8 imo.

From Reacher managing to leap like a salmon onto the departing helicopter - despite running slower than a drunken duck.. With a broken leg.

To the ridiculous gurney scene.

The whole thing is sadly too contrived and Hammy.


r/JackReacher • • Jun 11 '22

Working my way through Season 1…

0 Upvotes

and I feel like I’m in the minority who just can’t get past Alan Ritchson’s Reacher. First, his acting shows no depth. When he does try to show emotion and get introspective, it just feels forced and mechanical. Reacher’s quiet confidence that comes from someone who’s been through hell and survived, which Tom Cruise tapped into so well, just comes off as a privileged jock through Ritchson. And, Ritchson is almost too perfect in appearance and too sculpted: this isn’t someone who’s been through wars, this is someone who’s been through Mr Universe competitions. He gets the humor right, but because there’s so little depth too his performance his whole persona seems too comical.

Ultimately, I really can’t take Alan Ritchson’s Reacher seriously, and that just doesn’t work for the story. As a result, the series comes off less as a drama and more as a sitcom. I can’t help but feel let down.

And, please, add in some inner dialogue from Reacher. The calculus that goes on in his head in these split second moments of duress are really what brings a sense of awe to the character behind his mere physical prowess.


r/JackReacher • • Feb 01 '24

Is Jack in the TV show an unhinged psychopath? Or am I out of touch?

0 Upvotes

FYI I really enjoyed season 1 but I have a question for you.

Is Jack genuinely a psychopath? This guy regularly fights off armed bad guys in season 2 with his bare hands, beats them to death and then goes "damn, we should of kept one alive for questioning". Season 1 I pass this behaviour off as him being in practical situations (e.g breaking legs on a corpse to fit it in a car) that would otherwise be very stressful

I just got to the episode 7 so spoiler ahead:

He interrogates an assassin in critical condition, gets the information and then murders him. Knowing that his victim might of been killed later that day by his former employer. Its so pointlessly vindictive. At no point does he wonder why this man might of turned to a life of crime? Or if his murder was justified?

I haven't read the books, so I wanted to know if this behaviour is just a TV invention. Or a genuine plot point they will bring up later.


r/JackReacher • • Jan 06 '24

why are the sex scenes so boring

0 Upvotes

we have Reacher pumped on steroids and Karla has implants, so why am i fast forwarding the sex scenese?

Season 2 blows💨


r/JackReacher • • Oct 15 '26

reacher season 4 so disappoint ...

22 Upvotes

i just finish watching season 4 and i gotta say it pissed me off so much, season 1 was great but it was all down hill from there, season 2 was ok but still watchable , i couldn't even finish season 3, then i watched season 4 last night, first 3 episode was really good, the story and plot twist all hooked me, then its just shit after shit after that, the jake character is the worst thing in season 4, from start to finish, he's just useless and do stupid decision over and over, i kept thinking "oh usually this kinda character would turn around in the end" but no......... he's that bad, i've never read the book but its really hard to imagine such character really exist in the book "or he's in the show only", another thing is reacher has a quote " coincidence rarely happen" but it happened time after time in S4, and not in a good way, ridiculous even. it happened so much when reacher is on the run from the police and fighting the bad guys, they had so much "lucky break", i felt like i was watching sci-fi comedy.

season 4 really left a bad taste in my mouth, i turned fan after season 1 but now i dont even wanna see next season


r/JackReacher • • Dec 26 '23

TV show has wildly inconsistent writing in its tone.

0 Upvotes

I don't mean to sound like a hater but WTF is going on.

It seems like the characters are super-geniuses one moment and then complete morons the next.

In episode 01 alone, a "Stressful moment" is Reacher trying a mailbox. Then Neagley calls a "Flash Drive" a hard-drive. Says "my laptop has a different port" as if 90% of laptops don't have USB-A ports still. She'd have to have a very rare, thin, laptop that is only USB-C which is unlikely.

The bar fight scene felt so hokey and forced. Like some high school movie where the bully approaches the quiet kid and gets beat up after a dramatic stand-off.

Is this show meant for kids? Is there a show that's a bit more "serious" with how it approaches Special Ops and stuff like that?


r/JackReacher • • Jan 06 '24

It's official. I'm massively disappointed in season 2.

0 Upvotes

RANT. I loved season 1 especially after the 2 movie fiascos... It was funny, smart, well-written and Reacher. Great characters, plot and dialogue. I still love Roscoe telling Reacher and Finely that if they didn't play nice, she was going to do what meemaw used to and make them sit on the ground and hold hands.

This season, it's lazy. Lazy writing, cheap plot devices, predictable ploys and ridiculous holes. They have dumb bad guys with bad dialogue and worst aims. Even with scopes and their targets basically running directly at them. Like come on. Not going to spoil anything so I'll keep it vague. Just saying bullets go through cars. I saw that bomb a mile away. Professional assassins with overgrown frat boy vernacular and demeanor? All that military and cop training and NO ONE knows how to put pressure on a wound? Cops don't call other cops for back up? Just randomly drive toward Queens in hopes of meeting up with new people he met just a few days ago. Do you know how big Queens is? I do. I grew up there.

So far, every single episode, I've found multiple instances that are so dumb and unrealistic that my suspension of disbelief just fails. I get it. It's TV. BUT if you're going to emulate certain professions, situations, and just plain law of physics of daily life, there is a minimum level of realism you have to meet for me to stay in and enjoy the story. If you show a car shot to pieces and the occupants miraculously don't get shot, and appears outside of the car without opening any doors... I'm no longer in the story but instead, yelling at the TV. Lazy. And dumb.

Even Reacher is disappointing. He's doing and saying dumb things that Reacher would never do. Yes, Reacher can be a Neanderthal, but he was Neanderthal with singularly brilliant brain. Something is missing this season.

The most (and only, really) fun I had this season was the Sarah Connor mention in the first episode. Oh, the fake silencer was funny.

At this point, I'm only staying to see the revenge. Pretty sure they're going to follow the book and go on a plane ride. They have not been that creative.

Okay. End of rant. Who else is as disappointed. I feel like a bait and switch was done with season 1.

Edit: Couple of commenters pointed out something I didn't think about at all. The strikes. The loss in quality makes total sense now and is somewhat more acceptable, given the circumstances. I was missing the fight choreography of the first session. Thanks.

Question: did they go from R to PG-13 or something? Less to no cursing, less graphic violence and gore, and of course, nudity. I didn't think these were any f bombs, or if there were, I missed them. There's probably more shooting and blood packs, but nothing that made me wince. Everything feels tamer? Which is probably one of the reasons I was so annoyed. Reacher is anything but tame.


r/JackReacher • • Dec 31 '23

Apart from the physical size, the Cruise movies just did everything better

35 Upvotes

Don't get me wrong, I like this show a lot, but its just missing so much of the character. I know Lee Child said he wasn't happy with Cruise's size, which everyone seems to repeat, they forget he said Cruise captured everything else about Reacher and made him better.

Reacher is a pulp fiction superhero. Obviously his size and appearance is the first thing you see, literally, but thats not what makes him special. Its all the other things - his intelligence, presence, quick wits, resolve, moral code, and just plain being lethal.

Cruise had all that in spades. He had the presence and aura, you could believe this was not a man to be messed with, and everyone he came into contact with realized how smart and resourceful he was, just like in the books.

Alan Ritchson is never going to be 1/100th as good an actor as Cruise, but its also the appearance and the writing. This season they've chosen to make him buffier and dumber than ever. He comes across as a dumb jock or NFL linebacker vs someone smart and deadly. When he says 'I want to throw you out of a helicopter' it doesn't sound scary at all.

And then there's the physicality. Reacher is an expert in all forms of combat, like it says in the books, he's hunting trained killers and has to be better than them. This includes special forces. In the Cruise movies, he has no problem taking down 4-5 guys with ease. His fighting looks a lot superior, as it should.

In this show, he fights like a bar brawler. He gets cut in a fight 1v1 vs a street thug, in s1 he almost drowned. He should be so much better. The fight choreography is to blame, and the stupid editing, or maybe he didn't train to learn the moves?

None of it is memorable in any way. Think Jason Bourne fighting, people still remember that.

Or how about the shooting. Reacher is one of the best in the world. He won the Wimbledon cup, he's so legendary instructors remember him decades later. So of course when its time to shoot, the show writers think instead of shooting he should run and present a 8x6ft target a blind man could hit, never mind 2 snipers at close range, but of course the stupid writing means he's invincible. Now compare that to the sniper scenes in the movies, or Cruise handling guns in general.

All they had to do was film the book. Instead they've added stupid scenes like the 'girl power' scene with Dixon and Neagley disappearing into thin air and then armed men with machine guns running scared from pistols. Or the loud shouty bald fat cop whos the same in every scene.

S1 was so much better because it followed the book closely. Ironically the best part of S2 has been the surprise appearance of Finlay.

I hope they pick better writers for S3.

edit - people seem to think I'm against this show. here's a post I made when s1 came out -

'Reacher' on Amazon Prime is fantastic! And it shows you shouldn't mess with great source material

and I stand by it. S1 was much better


r/JackReacher • • Feb 05 '22

Worst casting in history?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/JackReacher • • Jul 19 '25

Thumbtack heads at 25 yards—nobody could see them, much less intentionally hit them

Post image
8 Upvotes

Go to a gun range and put thumbtack size marks on a target then run it out to 25 yards. Now try to see those marks. And even if you could, no handgun is that accurate. Hitting a thumbtack at 25 yards would be blind luck and have little to nothing to do with the gun.

Pictured excerpt from Die Trying.


r/JackReacher • • Dec 14 '25

Reacher just not doing it for me :-(

0 Upvotes

Is it worth it getting the latest Reacher book or should I not waste my $$$?


r/JackReacher • • Aug 19 '26

Reacher Season 4 poster inspired by Motor City, fan art by me.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/JackReacher • • May 10 '25

I asked AI to create a pic of Reach and it’s EXACTLY how I thought

Post image
90 Upvotes

uff


r/JackReacher • • Jul 17 '25

Are you enjoying your butter noodles?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/JackReacher • • Mar 11 '25

S03E04 Dominique

2 Upvotes

Who writes this stuff.

There's no way Reacher or any higher-up would have let Dominique Kohl arrest Quinn on her own after the confession about kidnapping a 4 year old, doing every single other part of the investigation together and the severity of his crimes. They definitely wouldn't have done it at his residence with only two people. Reacher shooting Quinn with a 22 from that distance is something he would have known as a problem beforehand. It was already personal, he would have shot him much closer just because of that like he did Duke. He would have had Quinn strip. And absolutely zero chance he'd survive that fall and not drowning or the hypothermia that would have set in.

Asides:I know Beck hates Quinn but you know that ogre Paulie would've mentioned Reachers name to Quinn at least once. The bodyguard that keeps trying to weasel out is a ridiculous add to this season. He'd be earmuffed and facing a wall once he stopped giving Intel. The stakeout of bizarre bazaars drop at the dock in a lone silver car in the woods and no one sees? I can spot my neighbor's car in the dense forest from over a mile away and even hear it on the gravel. Also there being zero security cameras or systems on any door window in a Beck's huge house with that level of paranoia is ludicrous.

This season's been a disappointment logic and writing wise. Suspension of disbelief doesn't exist with stupid writing and no common sense.


r/JackReacher • • Dec 27 '23

Found a T-shirt that matches Reacher's spirit

Post image
0 Upvotes

I think it's very close to how he does it.


r/JackReacher • • Mar 06 '25

Jack Reacher Plot Hole, I think

0 Upvotes

If Quinn or McCabe is as self-protective as he seems, why didn’t he check the profile of Zachary Beck’s right-hand man? If they had, they would have realized, “Wait, this is the guy who tried to kill me!” and taken action immediately. What do you think?


r/JackReacher • • Mar 23 '25

I Hate Dick

0 Upvotes

You read it right. I'm just not partial to Dick Hill.

I listened to his narration of A Wanted Man all the way through and it really took me out of the story. His reading of female characters dialogue is especially grating. Although to his credit he reads the voice of a man with a broken nose consistently for the entire book. I had a crush on the doomed Sorenson but he kinda killed it.

Just not my cup of tea. Not trying to sully his memory or anything. What do you think of him? Are there any other Reacher audiobook readers you would recommend?


r/JackReacher • • Feb 13 '22

I think for Reacher to be a truly great TV show and avoid feeling like one of these quickly canceled FOX shows, it needs to ditch some of the old school writing tropes and lean into the new ones. (SPOILERS) Spoiler

1 Upvotes

I'm not going to pretend like I'm the most die hard Reacher fan. I've read a few of the books, though its been years, and I don't quite remember everything about them.

But there are absolute moments of glory in this show that occasionally get tainted by corny moments that feel straight out of one of these terrible shows that airs on Fox for one season and gets cancelled.

A few examples that come to mind are the flashbacks to his childhood.

Honestly, we learn nothing from these moments that isn't explained in the present.

Through the flashbacks we learn

  1. Reacher and his brother were close. First off, 99% of siblings out there are close, and are going to be devastated at the loss of a brother. We don't need flashbacks establishing their relationship. Not only that, but Reacher tells stories about Joe detailing there care for each other. That was enough to establish his motivation for avenging his brother's death.

  2. It is used to establish Reacher's morals. But we've already seen throughout the present many of his acts of kindness and care for others. He helps random people and animals at most opportunities.

  3. We get a weird, corny moral lesson where sometimes bad things happen to good people. Wow. So deep. This is a concept that pretty much anyone in the intended demographic of this show should understand. If we could skip this, we would also be able to skip the terribly corny CGI tears and stuff.

This stuff bothers the dog shit out of me because this show is able to tell stories wonderfully at times, and treats its viewers as somewhat intelligent, but then hammers them over the head with obvious shit with those flashbacks. Its frustrating seeing someone so capable of good story telling just choose to suck at it.

And the action sequences.

We're in a new era of action and fight choreography where movies like John Wick and Nobody are all the rage.

This show captures those moments perfectly occasionally. The prison fight and the mansion fight were simply amazing. They're brutal and relatively realistic.

But then you get some dude who peaked in the 90's in the writers room who decided to have the villain give a terrible monologue at the climax of the finale, all while carrying around that rifle like a complete dumb ass. Or having Roscoe shoot a dude who explodes with the worst explosive graphics I've ever seen. That explosion absolutely wasn't necessary and only ruined things for me. Somewhere someone was sitting there saying, "We have to have explosions to be cool!" which is just entirely untrue.

Her just shooting it out with those guys was already intense enough.

Maybe I'm just a craby bastard, but I can't help but feel like these corny moments just taint the living shit out of the show.