r/JRPG • • Jan 27 '26

Discussion I feel like FF6 does not hold up nearly as well as I hoped it would. Spoiler

5 Upvotes

Playing FF6 for the first time after hearing my entire life that it is one of the best stories of all time and I'm... kinda underwhelmed, which is really bumming me out.

DISCLAIMER - Have not actually beat the game yet. I'm maybe halfway through the World of Ruin. I'm no stranger to JRPGs, but I haven't played a lot of the classics (especially FF games), so I'm trying to cross some of them of the list. I played Chrono Trigger right before this, and I absolutely loved it, both story and gameplay, and I felt like it lived up to all my expectations.

FF6, though, constantly has me thinking "that's fun, I'm sure it was amazing at the time". Like enjoying myself but always hoping that things were expanded on and that the story bit off more than it can chew. For example, when I've gotten the party members back in the WoR, I'm really excited by the concepts presented but then the party members seem to have their arcs resolved in like 5 lines. I think the large cast is really cool in concept, but it dilutes their overall strength. I like Terra, Locke, Celes, and Setzer, though. The brothers are cool too.

Another character that has always been hyped up is Kefka. Again, I haven't actually beaten the game yet so he could still surprise me, but I really haven't found him that engaging. I think he was extra hurt by the fact that I knew he was the main villain and that he wins going in, that would have probably been a fun twist thinking that Gestahl is the big bad.

Gameplay is another part where I felt a bit let down. It's fun, yes, but again nothing spectacular. I like having all these different techniques, but magic is so strong and enemies tend to be weak enough where I can just mash the strongest attacks and get through every fight. I don't need it to be like SMT difficulty but it doesn't feel like there's a ton of strategy required in general.

Don't get me wrong, it's been fun overall and the opera scene and the music is amazing. I'm sure there are also character analyses that would also make me think differently about the story. But like I said before, I can really only imagine this game being so amazing when I think about it in the context in which it first came out. (Which is funny, because I actually felt like Chrono Trigger could come out today and I would still love it.) I think the standards for character-driven stories have raised well beyond what FF6 offered, and while that is largely in thanks to FF6's success, I feel like I am running into a lot of disappointment with the game as a result.

I haven't looked too much into negative criticism about the game to avoid it affecting my opinion, so I'm not sure if this is a hot take or not lol. Curious what others think.


r/JRPG • • Dec 24 '23 Galaxy Brain

Review Persona 5 Review - I hated it (Spoiler Free Critical Review)

0 Upvotes

After falling victim to this 'game', I thought it might be therapeutic to share my thoughts. This is a long, critical spoiler-free review of Persona 5 Royal. If you decide to read this, feel free to share your thoughts.

I was lured into this interactive novel by IGN's deceptive review and 10/10 rating, although I should have known better. With genuine enthusiasm I began, selecting the most challenging difficulty in hopes of experiencing this 'game' at its fullest. The on-rails visual novel you are treated to in the first 10 minutes is exactly what you will endure over the next 70 hours. In truth, the game's most challenging and rewarding element is knowing when to toggle the fast-forward feature, so as to skip the meaningless ramblings which constitute most of the dialogue, while reading just enough to know where the boring plot will carry you next.

As the devil should always be given his due, I will say there is a charming art style to the UI, which polishes this turd of a game to a nice sheen. The 3D visuals however, are abysmal, with graphics being surpassed by my GameCube 20 years ago. The music seemed to have potential, but at some point it became repetitive, I had enough, and muted it altogether.

The gameplay boasts the most infantile loop I have ever suffered through: You choose two stats you want to raise each day, once in the afternoon and once in the evening. Accordingly, you pick two uninteresting NPCs you want to engage in a meaningless dialogue with, you fast-forward until you are prompted to respond to them and you choose the only response that is not an insult. This makes them like you, raising your stat. You perform this on repeat 30 times until you are permitted to race through a short, straightforward dungeon. Within these dungeons you will find easy respawning mobs and puzzles an ape could complete. You win before you know it, and are then pushed right back through the boring dialogue meatgrinder. At some point you will encounter the end credits in disbelief.

At a point about 20 hours in, between boring dialogue prompts, you are given 'freedom' to move about tiny room-sized pieces of Tokyo. You learn quickly there is no reason to move about them, because they are empty. Talking to the NPCs within them never once does anything, so you don't. Nearly all activities are text based, and some rare moments of excitement involve button-mashing. In what may be an accessibility feature for the disabled that cannot be turned off, the 'game' without fail tells you exactly what to do next and where to do it. This isn't hand holding mind you, you are effectively handcuffed and dragged from waypoint to waypoint. It even opens the fast travel prompt for you at times, which is ironic because wasting your time is what this 'game' excels most at.

The characters are one dimensional, each having their single respective dimension. Frankly, I found none interesting. I suspect only sociopaths can develop a sense of companionship with the unrealistic cookie-cutter NPCs of this game. Fortunately, the blessed fast-forward feature grants you the ability to avoid interacting with them altogether. There are no branching-narratives, so the chat responses you select are entirely meaningless, which as far as I'm concerned is an affront to the player. This JRPG is 85% 'J' and 15% 'RPG'. While I'm sure we all love Japan, better ways of experiencing the country exist.

The story of Persona 5 is only sometimes comprehensible, and even still is never subtle or clever. It becomes more convoluted as the 'game' progresses, and from a certain point onwards the story is delivered to you through a gavage of endless chatter. If this were to be made into a full-fledged anime, it would be a bad one. As an insult upon completion, you are taunted with the option of 'replaying' the 'game' in NG+ mode. Needless to say I declined, so I cannot elaborate. The 'Royal' edition purports to have an additional postgame. However, unbeknownst to me and likely many others, this is only unlocked if you consistently talk to one of the lamest NPCs in the game (and there are many lame ones). Being lame, I avoided him and missed out. Oh well.

Onto the minor RPG aspect of the game:

Inventory management does not exist, as you always have what you need. There is a currency, which you can spend freely and you will never have less than you need to keep spending freely. The equipment management is buying the best weapon/armor/gun with your endless money and then selling the old one.

The logical place to search for factors that might redeem this bad game is in the combat. Combat involves contending with 'Personas', ugly creatures rendered in inconsistent art styles that you fight in a cliche turn-based system. It's not fun. The fight is oversaturated with complex, unbalanced mechanics that need not be used in order to win consistently. I suppose if I were to use them my reward would be making this joke of a game even easier. You can choose to either win manually by spamming attacks, or win by putting your team on automatic to spare yourself the effort. Losing is difficult. At times, you are prompted to 'negotiate' with the enemy 'Personas', where you employ the negotiation tactic of boring dialogue. Here the game actually tells you which responses to choose in order to complete the negotiation. It's mindless, but it saves time, so it's not clear whether this is a fault or feature. There is a designated button that tells you which move is best to use, as though it's not obvious. Moreover, the stats you waste time building in the overworld seem to have no effect on the combat. In fact, having completed the game I still don't know what they do.

The 'game' constantly attempts and fails to stoke your interest in these 'Personas'. There exist all sorts of complicated ways to fuse, upgrade, teach and train these monsters. I put off studying these systems until the combat required me to learn them. Thank God that moment never came.

Conclusions:

It troubles me to know that some people have logged hundreds of hours on this game, mainly because I'm not sure how that is technically possible. Perhaps they just fell asleep on their keyboards. Yet for reasons that confound me, this 'game' rests atop a podium, instead of lying in the trash bin of history where it belongs.

I still question how and why I saw this through to the end. While perhaps not justified, I feel the reasons are that I like to finish what I start, and I naively held onto the hope that there is some greater challenge or interesting plot twist just around the corner. I promised no spoilers, but you get it. If like me some force compels you to experience this on-rails interactive novel, I suggest you approach it as a speedrun. Try to get it over with as quickly as possible. While the 'Phantom Thieves' stole 70 hours of my life and didn't change my heart, I think it can be done in less.

Persona 5 is best described as a long narrow road, leading nowhere and padded on both sides to ensure you don't stray from where the game wants to take you - nowhere.

I chose to finish it and I have no regrets, but I'm glad it's over. I didn't like it, no problem if you did.


r/JRPG • • Jan 01 '26

Discussion As an RPG fan, FFVII Remake/Rebirth’s combat just didn’t work for me

5 Upvotes

Whenever I ask friends, they say they loved Final Fantasy VII Remake/Rebirth, but I can’t bring myself to like these titles when they’re called RPGs, because they don’t feel like RPGs to me. The button mashing in these games doesn’t really resonate with me. I tried playing Rebirth in “classic” mode, but that didn’t change my impression either. Dodging attacks is something I don’t enjoy at all in games that I thought were supposed to be “RPGs.”

In my view, these games are much closer to a hack and slash than to a traditional RPG. I really like the “pause time” system when you open the action menu, like in Final Fantasy XII (my favorite). But beyond the button mashing I experienced, what bothers me the most is that practically all enemies require you to build the Stagger bar in order to defeat them. If the bar isn’t full, it feels like they take almost no damage, which means they only really receive meaningful damage during small time windows.

I couldn’t finish either Final Fantasy VII Remake or Rebirth because of this new gameplay style, which simply wasn’t fun for me, so I ended up dropping both games after about 10 hours each. I’d like to know whether most RPG fans actually enjoyed this new gameplay approach and, since I didn’t play these two games for very long, whether later on the games stop treating the Stagger bar as a near “requirement” to defeat enemies.


r/JRPG • • Aug 01 '26

Review Sea of Stars is INCREDIBLE, I don’t understand the hate it gets here

Post image
0 Upvotes

Let me preface this by saying I’m playing it on the hardest difficulty, and I recommend that to everyone because the challenge makes it a lot more fun.

One of the biggest things people complain about is the story, and while I agree the story isn’t one of those “edge of your seat, can’t wait to see what happens next” narratives, it’s a totally fun adventure vibe. Honestly feels a lot like Lunar to me. Garl is literally the spiritual successor of Ramus.

But outside of the story everything else is fire. The graphics are gorgeous, I love Sabotage Studios and the Messenger is one of my all time faves, their pixel art is top shelf. The music is awesome, and I loved the Glacial Peak music felt like it was ripped right from the Messenger. And the level up music has me vibing every single time.

As mentioned, the challenge of hard is so much fun having to strategize boss fights and enemy encounters, and I’ve found myself getting my butt smacked more than a couple times. And the puzzles are probably my favorite part, as it feels like a mix of Lufia 2 and Zelda, it makes things soo much more fun than your typical JRPG fare.

I actually never like minigames in JRPGs, but I’m even finding myself enjoying Wheels, it’s actually a really addictive game.

I’m almost 20 hours in and I’m completely in love with this game. I can’t believe I put it off for so long because of all the negativity I’ve seen on it around this sub.


r/JRPG • • Sep 01 '24

Discussion I'm enjoying Visions of Mana more than FF16.

0 Upvotes

It's just got that perfect experience that I had when I was playing RPGs back in the SNES era, but skinned in a modern day experience. It's exactly what I needed, but didn't know I needed it! To me it's the closest to Secret of Mana/Trials of Mana we've gotten EVER.

I read this review on Steam after having played the game (not the demo) for a bit, and could not agree more with it:

"This feels like sitting in front of the SNES playing Mana in the 90s. The music. The colorful intro. The characters. Everything about it, is pure Mana. Child-like wonder and the power of friendship. I hope they port the other Mana games over to Steam. These games are instant buys. There was one summer where every day, I'd ride my bike down to a friends house to play Secret of Mana with him. Furiously pedaling, hoping against hope that he didn't progress the story any since the previous night. This game takes me back to that time. Where are you now friend? We have a new Mana Tree to save."

It's an absolutely beautiful experience so far!


r/JRPG • • Nov 07 '24

Discussion Unpopular Opinion : I think first Xenoblade game is just okay. Spoiler

38 Upvotes

OKAY before you attack me, I don’t do this from a place of hate, I quite like the game and what it represents. I would still give this game a solid 8/10. I just feel like the gaming community has gaslighted me into thinking this is the second coming of christ, but in all honesty I don’t think even the story does much to innovate on the very common jrpg structure. The exploration and map design are my favorite part of the game. The landscapes inspire a sense of awe that is very rare in gaming. I do love the artstyle and the overall concept of the world, the mechons and all the little twists in between.

But OH MY GOD the combat is straight up un-intuitive, even for mmo-like standards. The side quest are absolutely atrocious and maybe 10 out of the 300 are interesting (and I did every single one because I ALWAYS felt underleveled on any given boss fight, might be skill issue tho). The xp system is stupid, party members are kinda dumb, fetch quests are sloww and boring.

What I think will be my most controversial take of all, is that the story ain’t really all that. SPOILERS: Although I was extremely invested on the story for about the first half of the game, the moment they reveal that fiora girl was a mechon, the story dropped HARD.

Im sorry but it was so extremely disappointing to me having this awesome set up of visions of the future and this awesome cool enemy that is unknown and unbeatable… only to end with the same old cliche jrpg trope were you battle with the all mighty creator god or some bullshit. The whole sequence leading up to that climax is fucking atrocious as well, going inside the giant robot and doing a dumb elevator puzzle maze was absolutely terrible. Also the final boss fight is probably one of the most boring in game, structure wise. The conclusion is just okay. Like they saved the world and that’s it.

I know it sounds like I hate it but I swear I really really don’t. In fact, I was enjoying the first half of the game SO MUCH, the momentum was building up beautifully, I was willing to forget my gripes with combat just purely based on the fact that the story felt so refreshing. So when I finally got to the end and the final act became the most generic thing a jrpg could be, I just felt severly disappointed.

And I also consider the context and era in which this game released, but cmon we’ve been doing the whole “battle against god” trope since fucking chrono trigger , like can we get over that, eventually, please..

Sorry for this post , i’m sure I’ll get some hate but I really wanted to express my thoughts, and I got no one Irl to talk this with irl. Also there is no way I would post this on Xenoblade subreddit, for obvious reasons..

Still think it’s a good game, will try 2 and 3 later. Its just not the life changing masterpiece y’all were hyping it up to be, personally speaking .


r/JRPG • • Dec 05 '23

Discussion Is it me or is this sub super toxic?

89 Upvotes

So many post sit at < 0 karma. And I don't know why. Some are people asking questions and boom, downvote.

Yet we see the same thread about favourite tropes, unpopular JRPG opinion, here are the JRPGs coming out soon (yay!), Best RPG of this year/past x years/past decade, etc.

Is it just reddit in general? or something specific to this sub?

And yes, I'm fully aware the irony that this thread is going to be downvoted and/or get removed by the mods.

Edit: Sorry, should not have included the last sentence. Shout out to u/andrazorwiren for pointing out my confirmation bias which could be toxic in of itself.

Edit 2: It looks like the general consensus is what I'm describing isn't 'toxic', so that's my bad for using that term loosely.


r/JRPG • • Jun 14 '23

Discussion Final Fantasy 16: A pretty disappointment

30 Upvotes

Firstly, i'll say what I liked, this is only off the demo.

The game looks amazing, the action sequences look fluid and even the goblins looked cool. The marlboro looked incredible.

I like the idea of the active time lore.

Music is top notch.

Clive, Jill and Joshua are likable characters!

What I don't like:

The setting/story, so far in the demo it is hard not to see Clive as a Jon Snow rip off. The whole world seems like Game of Thrones lite. He is literally the gifted swordsman son of the king of the north, with the mystic little brother who ultimately is the chosen one. The world hasn't stood itself out from any other fantasy based setting (so far)

The combat: Style over substance, the battles look good but more often you are just mashing square and tapping R1 every now and then. A very shallow battle system (so far), it felt repetitive in a short demo so that does not bode well for the game. I HATED the cinematic strike. I can't help but think if you had multple party members that you could swap between how much more engaging it would be.

Exploration: The few areas we got to see are corridor navigator, with little buffer areas to allow the enemies to spawn for the next area. Light jog to the next set of enemies

RPG elements: There doesn't really seem to be much? You level naturally by winning battles, and the gear seems to be irrelevant (so far) Your customizable attacks only change the visual look of the attack, the damage and effects are the same. Let's move past the stagger effect at this stage

The Eikon battle is literally just a cutscene

All in all: I think the full game could be great in the long run, but the combat is so repetitive it may be a slog to continue all the way!


r/JRPG • • Jul 05 '25

Discussion FF VII Rebirth somehow feels tiring and can't capture my attention

3 Upvotes

I see that my play time are only 4 hours in and I don't really get excited with the game. Unlike Remake, they gave you a whole party (after prologue) with the addition of many new and changing system that seems overwhelming to me.

I remember my last 3 JRPG are E33, Metaphor, and Triangle Strategy. All of those has the similarity that I can't put the game down, I play until 1-2 am and be sleepy for work tomorrow and all I can think of is to continue the journey.

Not for this game, like every minutes I feel like forcing myself to continue. Like I'm very excited only on prologue and Chapter 1, come open world I just feel drained. Will there be some exciting things or after this is all the same? And does the open world rewarding like full of content or no?


r/JRPG • • Jul 31 '23

Discussion Is it really unfair to criticize Final Fantasy 16 for its complete culling of gameplay?

26 Upvotes

Let me start this by stating I don't think this game is a bad game, if you love it, good for you and I'm not trying to convince you it's a bad game.

However.

Is it really a game for lovers of this franchise that spans more than 3 decades now? If you started loving Final Fantasy from PS2 era or back, this game has nothing of the gameplay elements that made you fall in love with Final Fantasy.

The missing stuff.

Turn-based combat

Party members that you control and pick who to go with (only one closest to a Final Fantasy party member is Torgal but his role in combat is pathetically small when compared to an ACTUAL PARTY, oh and your party members can't die and are fully controlled by AI too)

Equipment system which is not laughably shallow

Resource management (mana, MP, whatever)

It goes on.

How many people do that?

Think of wildly different franchises that span from the 90's: Atelier, Shin Megami Tensei, Mortal Kombat, Street Fighter, Xcom (a series which was on its death knell when it tried to become something completely different), GTA, Civilization...

Which of these franchises has shed as many gameplay elements in favour of simplification/streamlining for its mainline entries as Final Fantasy has over the course of their histories?

The result

FF16 is streamlined to the extreme and leaves so many franchise key elements behind to the point of becoming something else entirely in terms of gameplay. And that matters a lot because I'm playing a video GAME, not a video story otherwise known as a movie. So no matter how amazing the visuals are or how good the story is, that does not compensate for this culling of gameplay. Final Fantasy has been brought to the pedestal it stands on by fans that spent decades with it and they bought their games because they LIKED the gameplay.

Why is it like that?

I feel like all of this started with 13 and how bashed it was, but 13 was not bashed for having party members, or turn-based combat, or anything that Square Enix has decided is not worth their time, it was bashed primarily, mostly and chiefly because of its linearity and that was also amplified by the "open-world is the best" mindset of that era. So now 15 is open-world, but they don't nail the open-world and the game is not without its problems either. So now let's make a game which is REALLY simple to play but which is visually stunning, much harder to miss the mark with that in terms of gameplay at least.

Conclusion

So no, it is not a bad game, but it is a game that leaves old fans in the dust. All I'm saying is, if I'm a huge fan of Jojo's Bizarre Adventure and a new season gets announced, I'm going to feel immensely let down when I start watching One Piece instead (no hate to either, I like them both but prefer Jojo in terms of anime, prefer One Piece in manga format though).

Square Enix is a leader in the market and I certainly hope their decisions do not influence other greats that have been carrying this banner that we call "JRPG" (I never thought of it as a bad term, even if it's an entirely imprecise and nebulous one) like the ones making Trails, SMT, Tales, Persona, Fire Emblem, etc...

It's great to add innovations, but don't just drop your main guns on the ground as you prepare for combat.

Otherwise, you get this, God of War starring pretty boy, and God of War is really good, but it is not Final Fantasy.

EDIT:

I didn't say that turn-based or anything else was a key element that makes Final Fantasy games rpgs or jrpgs. I said in my post that too many series' traditions have been left behind at this point that it doesn't feel like Final Fantasy anymore (and if you wanna criticize that point of view, that's fair). Whether it's an RPG or not is beside the point and is a discussion we'll never a satisfactory answer to.

Is Zelda an rpg? Is Fallout? Is Sonic Frontiers? Idk man, the term is too vague at this point and I only know that D&D by Arneson and Gygax is the only one I feel safe calling it at this point because they started the whole thing.

So, please no discussing whether it's an rpg/jrpg or not.


r/JRPG • • Jun 24 '23

Discussion The problem with the discourse around Final Fantasy XVI

49 Upvotes

Final Fantasy XVI has released to critical and commercial success and is the highest rated mainline final fantasy title in over a decade. Despite this, however, the RPG and JRPG crowd still seem upset that this game is a character action game with light rpg mechanics. Which is understandable of course. Those who have a preset idea of what final fantasy should be are upset that this game isn’t what they wanted out of the series. What I find interesting though is I assumed that once the game released and was proven to be good, then people would just move on. That doesn’t really seem to be the case. In fact, it feels like the negative reception on this game from rpg fans has grown in size considerably. Of course the game has flaws as every game does so criticism is to be expected. What I see though is a number of fans outright offended at what this game has ended up being. Which I can’t lie, rubs me the wrong way. The reason it rubs me the wrong way is because people seem to think that “this is what final fantasy is now” just a character action game, which isnt true? Yoshi P has gone on time and time again saying that THIS game is a character action game and is not representative of the direction the series is going in from now on. He literally said “the next final fantasy game could be a turn based pixel art rpg”. Which is why all this discourse is puzzling to me. Sure this particular Final Fantasy isn’t your thing but that doesn’t mean the next one won’t be. Every series has a certain game in the series thats an outlier, so why is Final Fantasy getting all this controversy. The only real conclusion I can come to is development time really. Between this game and Final Fantasy 15 there was a 7 year gap. Maybe people just don’t want to wait so long for “their” final fantasy. Just my 2 sense. Tryina make sense of all this madness. EDIT: Surprised this is getting downvoted to hell. It seems people really ARE offended by how this game is. I tried looking at it from both sides but it’s alright I guess.


r/JRPG • • Sep 09 '26

Review Final Fantasy Resonance Sucks

0 Upvotes

I'm about halfway through the Final Fantasy Resonance demo, and honestly, I think it sucks. As a 43 year old gamer whos played countless RPGs and loved all three Octopath Traveler games, I was really looking forward to this. So far, though, it just isn't clicking with me. I am not a AI Troll Bot fyi.

The combat feels incredibly shallow. I can simply mash X through every random encounter without any real challenge. The stagger system isn't doing much for me either. Maybe I'm missing something, but I usually only get access to the Resonance Attack after an enemy is already dead, which makes it pointless. The only ability I've found consistently useful is Leahs Healing Wind, since it heals the entire party. But, that just reinforces the strategy of repeatedly pressing X and brute forcing every fight.

I was initially excited about the Vision system, but the more I played, the more it felt like something lifted from a mobile game rather than a fresh RPG mechanic. It would have been far more interesting if the Visions were unique to this game's world and story. That would require deeper world building and more thoughtful storytelling, though. Instead, it feels like recycled ideas supported by uninspired writing and direction.

I understand that side quests are a major part of modern RPGs, but these feel especially lazy. Ironically, my biggest complaint about Octopath Traveler was the same thing: repetitive quest design.

Talk to a random NPC. Go to a nearby cave, town, or monster. Complete the task. Return to the NPC. Repeat.

The game even places quest icons over NPCs and marks objectives directly on the map, eliminating any sense of discovery or exploration. It's as if the developers were worried players might get lost in an already very easy game.

The music has been a disappointment as well. Nothing has stood out so far, and the lack of a memorable battle theme makes combat feel even less exciting. I thik the main song is annoying.

The world map feels small and overly cartoony.

You get a Chocobo almost immediately with no sense of anticipation or accomplishment.

I collected four Visions within the first two hours, which removed any excitement or buildup that should come from unlocking powerful new abilities.

It also looks like there won't be any original side activities or mini-games. At least Octopath Traveler had its monster capture system, which was both useful and genuinely fun to engage with.

Gil is plentiful so equipment upgrades are easy to get, and the best weapons seem readily available. As a result, the game's systems never push you to experiment or think strategically. Once again, the optimal approach seems to be mashing the attack button through every thing.

Overall, the game feels like a low-budget mobile port rather than a premium RPG. It comes across as easy, predictable, and lacking the charm that made classic RPGs memorable. Perhaps my expectations were too high, but I was hoping for something special.

I still hope Square Enix eventually dedicates the time and resources to create a true standalone HD 2D Final Fantasy that captures the originalitty, depth, and magic that made their older games so beloved. It is free, so theres that, but not sure I will buy this when it comes out, at least at full price.


r/JRPG • • Mar 12 '24

Discussion FF Rebirth likes to waste your time.

26 Upvotes

I feel like everything in this game is designed In a way to make it take as much time as possible so that can say it's a "100h" Game. Every zone has the same Ubisoft crap style of content, stupid annoying minigames, places where you have to search for few chests that have dumb rewards that change nothing. My drop point was where Johnny is Costa del sol wanted me to collect his shit "near zip lines" So I did for like 30 minutes till I checked google for a solution then I realized he meant ziplines all over the zone. Ehhh I was so hyped for this game and it's just another medicore overpriced triple A game that should be 30h max stretched for the sake of being big for no reason. What a waste

Im glad that we still have indie games.


r/JRPG • • Apr 30 '25

Question Are the microaggressions towards JRPGs from Western devs more obvious now?

Thumbnail
bsky.app
1 Upvotes

You'd think Persona 5, Dragon Quest, Like a Dragon, NieR, SMT have not been a thing these past few years. I can't help but feel weird about how after decades of incredible JRPGs, there's one incredible western game based on JRPGs and now it's getting toted as the savior of JRPGs.

This is a former Dragon Age writer btw.


r/JRPG • • May 08 '25

Discussion Does it ever feel like the “see turn based isn’t dead” crowd are mostly a bunch of Final Fantasy fans still stuck in 2001

4 Upvotes

I absolutely adore turn based games, I’ve sunk 1,000’s of hours in this genre over the years but it feels like recently that anytime a popular turn based game makes movement, the conversation always comes back to final fantasy for some reason.

It’s genuinely baffling because the last truly turn based final fantasy game was FFX, which released in 2001. How is it that after 24 years people are still weaponizing other amazing turn based games as fuel for their beef with how the FF series currently is.

Whether it’s persona, bg3, metaphor, and currently now expedition 33, these games always get used to slander Square Enix for the direction they took the franchise.


r/JRPG • • Mar 31 '25

Review [Spoiler] Final Fantasy 16 – Amazing Interactive Movie, Terrible Video Game [A Very Long Rant] Spoiler

0 Upvotes

2 years since FF16 release date.

And around a month since a certain event opened a floodgate to many new (and poor) PC players.

I think it’s the right time to have a discussion about FF16. I hope we can have a nice discussion about it since I have A LOT to say regarding this game, especially about its shortcomings.

Before I start, I’d like to inform that I JUST dropped the game after Main Quest 36 out of 49; just after Titan battle and a series of Mid’s fetch quests. My reason? Because FF16 is a huge chore to PLAY. As I’m about 75% done with the game, I think I’m more than qualified enough to talk about it. Let’s start with what I think is the most integral part about a video game, the Combat.

-------

Ditching the traditional (Action) Turn Based combat, SE decided to make FF16 a pure Action Hack & Slash game instead. Is this a problem? Not at all, since I’ve played Stranger of Paradise and enjoyed it a lot. However I can’t say the same about FF16 for a few reason:

  • Overly simplistic everything. All you do in a fight is spam attack button while waiting for skill cooldown to spam without even moving an inch since the lock on is like a magnet, so you’ll always advance towards the enemy just by pressing the attack button.

  • You don’t even need to Dodge much since most of the time, enemies are standing still or being staggered by Clive combos. And while writing this, I suddenly remembered that FF16 had a Guard button

  • No magic, buff, debuff or stats ailment and of course no HP bars to worry about other than Clive’s, since they made Jill and Torgal immortal supporters. I call them my supporters, but I never really recognize them in battle. Do they even deal real damage to enemies? I’m not sure. They’re both invisible to me.

In short, the combat FEELS LIKE AUTO COMBAT where you aren’t required to think or be worried about anything

-------

Next is about Leveling, Gearing & Enemy Strength Scaling, which made the combat even worse than I explained above. How so? Well...

  • Gearing: The only meaningful metrics in gearing system are stats increase (Atk/Def) and nothing else. Accessories are borderline useless since most of them are buffing a specific skill, and even then, the buff isn’t really noticable.

  • Leveling; ABSOLUTELY WORTHLESS. Leveling up only increases your ATK/DEF by like 2-3 points (a weapon upgrade is like +20). So yeah, not only leveling up is EXTREMELY SLOW in this game, there’s CLOSE TO NO BENEFIT from leveling up. Do I even get stronger???? Well, I get a little bit... just a little bit tankier from the +HP bonus, I guess?

  • Enemy Strength: From Main Quest 1 to 36, mobs or bosses, I feel like enemies never got any stronger or weaker. They receive the same damage, deal the same damage with the same attack pattern.

My point is... FF16 IS DESIGNED TO MAKE SURE I CAN NEVER, EVER GET STRONGER. In old FF, you can get stronger by learninga all kind of new Spells, passives, synergies with party members, fitting your characters into specific niches (tank, crit, agility, buffer). You can’t do any of that here. All you can do is raise your primary (atk/def) stats either by leveling up (miniscule amount) or gear upgrade (story locked), and even then... you don’t actually get noticeably stronger. THERE’S NO SENSE OF PROGRESSION IN THIS GAME.

Now, combine my rant about progression with my rant about the combat system. WA-LA, now you get the most pain in the ass combat in any video game ever. Once you’ve realized that you can’t REALLY  get stronger, you’d constantly ask this question in battle: “why the fuck am I fighting these goons?”. Not for the item drops for sure, since they all drop junk upgrade materials and little worthless gils.

----------

Next, the non-combat/gearing gameplay aspect of the game: Questing. TOO. MUCH. FETCH. QUESTS. Even in the MAIN QUESTS. I don’t think I need to explain much. It’s simply too much. Waaaaay too much. I can’t stand it anymore. Am I playing a MMORPG??? No I don’t wanna talk to NPC A>B>C.D then help NPC D kill some monsters or gather some plants DURING THE MAIN QUEST. I’m so tired of walking around the area just to talk to some random ass NPCs. No more.

 -----------

I think that was the last negative aspect I want to talk about this game. Let’s be positive from now on. The strongest point of FF16 is, without a doubt, the quality of the cinematic scenes. It’s the reason why boss battles are so fun. Not because of the combat itself, but for the epic cinematics during and after the combat. It’s simply impressive. The cinematics aspect alone would make FF16 a great movie. Just imagine FF16 as a 3 parter movie with all the MMORPG fetch quest padding removed.

Another thing I really like about FF16 is Clive. He’s got the coolest and definitely the manliest design out of all Final Fantasy protagonists (except Jack the CHAOS Slayer). I mean, just think about other FF protags, they’re either teens or flamboyant twinks lol. Anyway, I like the design for all major characters in this game.

-------------

The story is... I don’t want to talk about it since I want to focus this thread on  the gameplay. Let’s just say I have some problems with the concept of Dominant, Mother Crystal as primary natural resources and Clive/Resistance’s eco-terrorism act. But whatever. As long as the cinematics are cool...

-------------

To sum it up, I DISLIKE FF16 AS A VIDEO GAME, BUT LIKE IT AS A MOVIE.

I think FF16 would’ve been a far better game, only if they had simply taken Stranger of Paradise (Pure Action) or FF7 Remake/Rebirth (ATB) gameplay or.... hear me out... 2D-HD Demake with Octopath Traveler’s gameplay. Haha.

I think that’s all from me.

Thoughts?


r/JRPG • • 18h ago

Discussion I'm not feeling FFVII Rebirth Spoiler

Post image
122 Upvotes

I'm 30 hours in and i can't wait to finish it already.

The '' open world '' stuff is boring me to death. Like, it's cool during the first 2 hours i think but it quickly becomes a drag.

The exploration is pretty much on rails despite the huge size of the maps. During my 30 hours of playing it not even once i looked at something cool in the distance that piqued my interest and made want to go there, the maps feel big just for the sake of it.

Even FFXV with that empty open world still had interesting stuff to see, places you were not supposed to be, but you could get there anyway, if you were somewhere high you could just jump from there, get some fall damage or teleport yourself away from harm, it was actually kinda fun even if there wasn't anything to do.

But VII Rebirth had none of that.

You get somewhere high and Cloud can't just jump this 2ft gap, you need to look for the specific blue indicator with these yellow paint stuff that indicates a climbing Assassin's Creed like mechanic, or just do a long ass backtrack to get to lower ground. Chocobos can't do it most of the time either.

All you have to find are towers, battle intel, lifestream stuff for the 95th time in a row, chocobo spots and the game makes sure you won't miss any of them as there are literal moving guides to get you there.

The open world is bloated and empty at the same time, how is that possible ?

The sidequests are pretty boring as well. I could realize that from the get go and decided i would just finish the ones who come up naturally during my progression, but it's just not worth it.

The story is also being hit and miss for me. I honestly think they nailed the interactions of the main group, and non important characters like Jhonny, the Turks and so on are done amazingly well, but the serious moments that actually develops characters and progress the story are so undercooked and sometimes they even lost the original meaning behind them.

The Dyne cutscene was done way better in the OG imo, here you can't even let the scene hit you as right after, like, literally after you have to deal with Palmer shaking his fat ass in the most unecessary boss fight ever made. ( to be fair, this was in OG as well, but waaaaay later in the story ) . J

Jesus, just give Barret a moment to feel the loss of an old friend.

Feels like this game can't let a serious moment hit you in the face, it always have to be a high action sequence or goofy scene right after. I just finished the Seto storyline and Jesus Christ, did they fucked up that interpretation, the original was one of the best scenes in the game.

You just had Nanaki howling at his father's and Seto's tears falling down was absolute cinema.

But since Rebirth can't have moments like these, you have to fight a boss right after, how cool is that?

I'm really struggling to beat this game, there are some nice things about it like the Combat and Queens Blood, but honestly i decided to just focus on the main story and the only reason i'm willing to finish is because i already spent 30 hours in this thing.

I'm just glad i waited a good sale to get Rebirth cuz if i had gotten this day one at full price i would be pissed.


r/JRPG • • Dec 08 '23

Discussion Sea of Stars did not deserve Best Indie

0 Upvotes

The story and character was just so bad. The combat got so stale. The writing was riddled with grammar errors.

Most infuriating thing is that everyone online seems to love it. Are people really so swayed by a flashy aesthetic?

Edit: I think "infuriating" was the wrong word to use. I'm not taking the win personally and I am of course aware of the fact that the game did well in many circles. I was simply expressing my own opinion and I was wondering if my opinion was truly that unpopular.


r/JRPG • • Oct 19 '24 Polished Silver Turd

Discussion I HATE Metaphor Re:fantazio

0 Upvotes

I’ve been reading that everyone is loving the game and barely anyone has something negative to say about it, but I personally hate it. I really dislike it. So, I’ll just vent rn.

The combat is ABSOLUTELY AMAZING. It just hits everything I love about RPGs. I love how dynamic it is and that it actually presented me a challenge. I only died like one or two times in Persona 5, to make a comparison. The art is also gorgeous, not to mention the soundtrack. I absolutely believe Shoji Meguro is the best videogame music composer as of right now and he definitely did not disappoint.

My problem is the storytelling. I know nothing of the tribes other than they are racist to each other. No world building, no lore, no decent narrative. It can’t talk about anything else other than it’s pretentious social critique. Every two seconds I’m just bombarded with social class or racism stuff and zero fantasy fiction substance.

Also, it relies solely in shock value to captivate the player. Someone gets beaten to a pulp, hanged out of the blue, murdered our of the blue, etc… It’s just dumb and uncreative.

I really was enjoying the combat, but I just couldn’t continue playing it. The story just ruined it for me and that’s why I hate it. I put into it approximately 40 hours and I really wish I hadn’t given ATLUS my money on this one.

If I had to describe it in one word, it’d be: pretentious.


r/JRPG • • Oct 07 '24

Release Beloved Rapture (LGBTQ RPG) - Steam release today!

5 Upvotes

I was wandering if anyone was downloading and playing "Beloved Rapture?" It had a small kickstarter a few years ago. It just released today (as of twenty minutes ago my time zone)!!!

I caved and bought it (support indie queer developers) - wanted to see if other people were playing and their thoughts so far. I'm cautiously excited for the quality of the game and looking forward to playing later. I'm also keeping my eyes peeled for reviews - so far I haven't seen any.

https://store.steampowered.com/app/2017620/Beloved_Rapture/

And so you can see the graphics (which look pretty stellar):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S6chq5WCi4Q&ab_channel=GameTrailers

Looks like it is RPG Maker 2k3 but with custom assets - it looks quite beautiful!


r/JRPG • • Jul 30 '24

Discussion Unfortunately, the Visions of Mana demo is not good

51 Upvotes

Played the demo.

Oof.

Was not expecting it to be worse than Trials of Mana Remake, yet here we are.

Switching studios was obviously a bad decision. Instead of building upon the work that was done in Trials of Mana (which was a decent game), they started over with a new team that isn't competent.

I will say, I'm glad the Trials team is working on Romancing SaGa 2 Remake instead because I care about that far more. But for Mana fans, this is rough.

The movement is really clunky. It does not feel good to jump and run. Those are literally the basics and they couldn't get that right.

I tried the three characters, Warrior, Rogue, and Mage and none of them were fun to play. The combat is not good.

The UI is too busy.

The character design is atrocious, but that's more subjective. English voice acting was spotty at best.

This is Square Enix's weakest game since Forspoken.


r/JRPG • • Aug 15 '25

Discussion The "silent protagonist" is one of the worst cliches in a traditional JRPG.

0 Upvotes

You have a pre-defined character, with a pre-defined look, in a pre-defined story, with a pre-defined playstyle with pre-defined cutscenes but he's silent so you can "relate to them" or "decide for yourself what their voice is". This makes no sense.

It's just a compromise between an actual character and a character entirely made by the player. In the former you can have a character with a unique personality and interesting interactions or dynamics with other characters (ala Luke fon Fabre from ToA or Joel from TLOU) or you can have a character that is entirely made by the player (like in Fallout or other tabletop-inspired games where you make a character, decide what their stats and skills are, decide what they say in dialogue, and so on).

The "silent protagonist" doesn't take advantage of either. You don't have an interesting character who develops or interacts with other characters, and at the same time you don't have the freedom of choice of a character made by the player. In the latter it actually makes sense that the protagonist is silent because the game is literally designed around building dozens, if not hundreds of potential characters, all of whom have tons of potential personalities and who the player ultimately controls in both action and dialogue, one or even several "voices" would have no way of fitting all of them. The "silent protagonist" is neither.


r/JRPG • • Sep 25 '24

Discussion Underwhelmed by Metaphor: ReFantazio (Demo thoughts)

17 Upvotes

Let's start by saying I have been really excited for this game so I may have hyped it up too much since I've stayed away from trailers, gameplay videos, etc. but I was underwhelmed by the demo nonetheless.

I am playing the demo on PS5 on a 4K TV.

First of all, the resolution in this demo is bad at 4K. It looks like there is a lot of artifacts coming from an upscaler and everything has that sharpening look and pretty noticeable edges. It's worse in places where there is a lot of geometry like a city or on bushes, and there really aren't any resolution settings to target quality over FPS, which I would prefer if it had the option.

For more personal opinions, I think the demo opening hours were not very compelling and every scene relies very heavily on anime cutscenes. Persona 5 and 3 also did this, but it feels like every other cutscene is animated in 2D, where I would much prefer 3D for bosses at the very least (which is subjective, but I don't think the animation is all that good). Combat felt great and I thought the animations in and out of combat were very flashy. I also like many of the character designs and Gallica is a cute character, but I don't think I'm picking up what the story is laying down. When the prologue was over, I felt very indifferent about the world and the characters, which is a shame because I love Atlus, but this is an 80+ hour game that should hook me in 4.

I did laugh as soon as the main character ripped his heart out. It was this versions overcoming self thing and gave me a chuckle.

For anyone who has played the demo as well (which released today), what are your thoughts?


r/JRPG • • Sep 07 '25

Discussion It bothers me how unnecessarily long most of the JRPGs are

0 Upvotes

Now, I will say that I probably I have aged out of the main demographic for these games (teenagers with almost infinite free time),but man do I find the length of most JRPGs annoying.

Almost every new major title of the genre of the last decade (Trails, Persona 5, SMT, Metaphor,FF Rebirth....) are 50h+ titles, even if you only play the main story. And the thing is, if they needed that time to do something particularly interesting, I would not have any complains, but they mostly don't.

Is not like the plots of many of those games are complex and multi layered enough that need so many hours to explore all it's themes or threads. Or like the gameplay systems have so many mechanics that they need so much time to introduce everything (Xenoblade kinda does, but it is the main exception).

Most JRPGs use all that time for like.... Idk, making dialogue insanely long because everyone has to speak their mind even if they don't have anything interesting to say (Trail), making dungeons with an already limited selection of enemies and mechanics keep going and going and going beyond the point of exhaustion (Metaphor), or just recoloring enemies with higher stat numbers and throwing them to you again and again , or making you revisit earlier dungeons in "optional quests" that are de facto compulsory if you don't want to be under leveled for the main quest (too many games to count). It just feel like padding for the sake of padding.

I do get the logic of making games like this if your target demographic are younger people that have a lot of time and not that much money. You want to make them feel that they have "maximized" what they have spent in the game. I used to be there too, but these days between working et al what I have is more available money but less time. I don't mind spending more money in relatively shorter games (short for JRPG standards anyway, they are still longer than basically any other genre out there) if they are good .

And with this new constraints that I face, I find it difficult to enjoy games that feel like they don't respect my time. And most of the newer titles feel like they are falling into that category

I do think there is a market for smaller titles that are tighter, with a smaller scope, a clear idea of what they want to do and less padding. Hell, a lot of the classic JRPGs like Chrono Trigger, Vagrant Story or Suikoden 2 hit that sweet spot of 20 to 30 hours main story playtime, and I think they are better for it, while in most modern top JRPGs in 20 hours you don't even have your full party yet