After falling victim to this 'game', I thought it might be therapeutic to share my thoughts. This is a long, critical spoiler-free review of Persona 5 Royal. If you decide to read this, feel free to share your thoughts.
I was lured into this interactive novel by IGN's deceptive review and 10/10 rating, although I should have known better. With genuine enthusiasm I began, selecting the most challenging difficulty in hopes of experiencing this 'game' at its fullest. The on-rails visual novel you are treated to in the first 10 minutes is exactly what you will endure over the next 70 hours. In truth, the game's most challenging and rewarding element is knowing when to toggle the fast-forward feature, so as to skip the meaningless ramblings which constitute most of the dialogue, while reading just enough to know where the boring plot will carry you next.
As the devil should always be given his due, I will say there is a charming art style to the UI, which polishes this turd of a game to a nice sheen. The 3D visuals however, are abysmal, with graphics being surpassed by my GameCube 20 years ago. The music seemed to have potential, but at some point it became repetitive, I had enough, and muted it altogether.
The gameplay boasts the most infantile loop I have ever suffered through: You choose two stats you want to raise each day, once in the afternoon and once in the evening. Accordingly, you pick two uninteresting NPCs you want to engage in a meaningless dialogue with, you fast-forward until you are prompted to respond to them and you choose the only response that is not an insult. This makes them like you, raising your stat. You perform this on repeat 30 times until you are permitted to race through a short, straightforward dungeon. Within these dungeons you will find easy respawning mobs and puzzles an ape could complete. You win before you know it, and are then pushed right back through the boring dialogue meatgrinder. At some point you will encounter the end credits in disbelief.
At a point about 20 hours in, between boring dialogue prompts, you are given 'freedom' to move about tiny room-sized pieces of Tokyo. You learn quickly there is no reason to move about them, because they are empty. Talking to the NPCs within them never once does anything, so you don't. Nearly all activities are text based, and some rare moments of excitement involve button-mashing. In what may be an accessibility feature for the disabled that cannot be turned off, the 'game' without fail tells you exactly what to do next and where to do it. This isn't hand holding mind you, you are effectively handcuffed and dragged from waypoint to waypoint. It even opens the fast travel prompt for you at times, which is ironic because wasting your time is what this 'game' excels most at.
The characters are one dimensional, each having their single respective dimension. Frankly, I found none interesting. I suspect only sociopaths can develop a sense of companionship with the unrealistic cookie-cutter NPCs of this game. Fortunately, the blessed fast-forward feature grants you the ability to avoid interacting with them altogether. There are no branching-narratives, so the chat responses you select are entirely meaningless, which as far as I'm concerned is an affront to the player. This JRPG is 85% 'J' and 15% 'RPG'. While I'm sure we all love Japan, better ways of experiencing the country exist.
The story of Persona 5 is only sometimes comprehensible, and even still is never subtle or clever. It becomes more convoluted as the 'game' progresses, and from a certain point onwards the story is delivered to you through a gavage of endless chatter. If this were to be made into a full-fledged anime, it would be a bad one. As an insult upon completion, you are taunted with the option of 'replaying' the 'game' in NG+ mode. Needless to say I declined, so I cannot elaborate. The 'Royal' edition purports to have an additional postgame. However, unbeknownst to me and likely many others, this is only unlocked if you consistently talk to one of the lamest NPCs in the game (and there are many lame ones). Being lame, I avoided him and missed out. Oh well.
Onto the minor RPG aspect of the game:
Inventory management does not exist, as you always have what you need. There is a currency, which you can spend freely and you will never have less than you need to keep spending freely. The equipment management is buying the best weapon/armor/gun with your endless money and then selling the old one.
The logical place to search for factors that might redeem this bad game is in the combat. Combat involves contending with 'Personas', ugly creatures rendered in inconsistent art styles that you fight in a cliche turn-based system. It's not fun. The fight is oversaturated with complex, unbalanced mechanics that need not be used in order to win consistently. I suppose if I were to use them my reward would be making this joke of a game even easier. You can choose to either win manually by spamming attacks, or win by putting your team on automatic to spare yourself the effort. Losing is difficult. At times, you are prompted to 'negotiate' with the enemy 'Personas', where you employ the negotiation tactic of boring dialogue. Here the game actually tells you which responses to choose in order to complete the negotiation. It's mindless, but it saves time, so it's not clear whether this is a fault or feature. There is a designated button that tells you which move is best to use, as though it's not obvious. Moreover, the stats you waste time building in the overworld seem to have no effect on the combat. In fact, having completed the game I still don't know what they do.
The 'game' constantly attempts and fails to stoke your interest in these 'Personas'. There exist all sorts of complicated ways to fuse, upgrade, teach and train these monsters. I put off studying these systems until the combat required me to learn them. Thank God that moment never came.
Conclusions:
It troubles me to know that some people have logged hundreds of hours on this game, mainly because I'm not sure how that is technically possible. Perhaps they just fell asleep on their keyboards. Yet for reasons that confound me, this 'game' rests atop a podium, instead of lying in the trash bin of history where it belongs.
I still question how and why I saw this through to the end. While perhaps not justified, I feel the reasons are that I like to finish what I start, and I naively held onto the hope that there is some greater challenge or interesting plot twist just around the corner. I promised no spoilers, but you get it. If like me some force compels you to experience this on-rails interactive novel, I suggest you approach it as a speedrun. Try to get it over with as quickly as possible. While the 'Phantom Thieves' stole 70 hours of my life and didn't change my heart, I think it can be done in less.
Persona 5 is best described as a long narrow road, leading nowhere and padded on both sides to ensure you don't stray from where the game wants to take you - nowhere.
I chose to finish it and I have no regrets, but I'm glad it's over. I didn't like it, no problem if you did.