r/Italianhistory • • Apr 26 '25

Why has Hollywood consistently portrayed Italians (especially Italian Americans) as fair skinned? Despite racism at the time esp pre-WW2?

0 Upvotes

Considering the common stereotype that Italians are olive skinned and among the darkest of the white people? I can understand modern cinema showing them as fair and even pale since much of the Italian Americans nowadays either have Germanic or Celtic blood or are immigrants from the wealthier Italian regions (or of middle class origin).

However even old movies from the 30s-50s, when racism against specific nationalities of white immigrants was still a thing, show them as fair skin. Even the stereotype of Italians being (by white standards) dark skin still lasted into the 70s. Yet much of the most popular flicks revolving around Italians or Italian Americans such as Rocky show them as milky white as your average American (especially Sylvester Stallone who is really of Italian descent). Even films that show Italian stereotypes such as The Godfather tended to portray them considerably lighter skinned than stereotypes at the time.

Why did this phenomenon occur in cinema despite Italians being portrayed as dark and borderline nonwhite in American bias at the time (and heck even Western Europeans saw them as lowly whites especially Anglo Saxon and Germanic nations)? I mean Hollywood stereotyped much of the Spaniards, Portuguese, and such as olive skin (with much of the same stereotypes as Italians in the early 20th century).

Why did this phenomenon occur in cinema despite Italians being portrayed as dark and borderline nonwhite in American bias at the time (and heck even Western Europeans saw them as lowly whites especially Anglo Saxon and Germanic nations)? I mean Hollywood stereotyped much of the Spaniards, Portuguese, and such as olive skin (with much of the same stereotypes as Italians in the early 20th century).

Hollywood usually portray the Arabs as brown skin as Mexicans or at best olive skinned if they are shown as white. Enough that when they use big stars like Guinness they darkened them intentionally with makeup and such (as seen in Khartoum and Lawrence of Arabia) to at least look olive skin dark shade. With the Balkans swarthy whites is the typical portrayal in cinema and recently video games as seen in Grand Theft Auto 4's protagonist Niko Bellic.

However Italians are shown as much lighter even when they hire olive actors (even using make up as seen in some of Rudolph Valentino's behind the scene stuff).

Stallone may have facial features associated with Italians, but his skin can pass off as WASP esp in his younger years and in certain shades of light.

The point I'm making is that from the 19th century up until the 50s Italians had a lot of prejudice similar to what Mexicans and other Latinos currently face. Dark skinned, uneducated, and lazy criminals or manual laborers.

They practically repeat these stereotypes with Hispanics and same with whatever national negative stereotypes with other groups (such as Russian immigrants being commies, French being perverts and white skinned, etc).

With the Italians, they refused to revert to stereotypes and portray them positively, even going as far as using make up to lighten up darker skinned Italians to make them appear more WASP in skin tone. VERY STRANGE which is why I asked this question. Why portray Italians in a positive manner and refuse to use the old negative racist stereotypes actual Italians were facing at the time?

Why couldn't say the French (portrayed as all pale skinned whites and aggressive imperialists abusing natives or perverts who chase skirts) be shown with an olive skinned citizen who has the sex drive of a monk? Or Chinese guys being romantic and rebelling against parents? Or better yet use a Mestizo Mexican who's light skinned with a role of a scientist (I know Salma Hayek is already one example but most roles don't try to avert stereotypes)?

What made Hollywood interested in averting negative prejudices about Italians? I mean Rudolph Valentino was Hollywood's first sex symbol and he was a recent immigrant when he became a star!

So why did Italians break away from this stigma in popular movies?

So why did Italians break away from this stigma in popular movies?


r/Italianhistory • • Apr 12 '25

Is it true that the mechanized Italian Army was literally losing to an army of spearmen in Ethiopia in the 1930s?

0 Upvotes

In the 20th Century the Italians have a mockible reputation comparable to that of the French post World War 1. Italians are believed to have lost every battles they fought against the Allies and the Italian Army was considered so poor in quality that most of the troops that fought during the Italian campaigns were stated to be professional German soldiers, not Italains.

But the greatest shame to Italy (well at least according to popular History) is their war in Ethiopia back in the 1930s. The popular consensus is that the Italian Army was a mechanized force with the latest modern weaponry from tanks to machine guns to gas bombs and even Fighter planes.

That they should have wiped out the Ethopians who were mostly using spears as their prime weapons with only a few using outdated rifles.

However the popular view of the Italian invasion of Ethiopia is that the Italians despite being a modern force were literally losing the war and it took nearly 10 years to even stabilize the region. That the Ethiopians were seen as an inspiring force of a backwards army defeating a modern mechanized force.

Italian soldiers are thought in this campaign as ill-disciplined, poorly motivated, cowardly, and just plain unprofessional. In fact I remember reading in my World History textbook saying that the Italians committed atrocious war crimes such as bombing innocent towns, rounding up women and children and shooting them, plundering whole communities and enslaving the local inhabitants and raping the young girls and women, and even gassing up groups of Ethiopian civilians out of nowhere that were not involved in the rebellion.

In addition Ethiopians are seen in this war as cut out from any form of foreign support. No country not even the US had supply Ethiopia supplies and weapons or any other means of defending herself.

My World History textbook put a specific section show casing how the Italians violated the rules of war in this campagin.

Its not just this war that mentions such stuff-the Italian war in Libya according to popular History seems to repeat the same thing and indeed its shown perfectly in the classic film "The Lion of the Desert" starring Alec Guinness as the rebel of that insurgency, Omar Mukhtar.

I'm curious what was the truth? I find it impossible to believe an army of spearmen can destroy a modern mechanized army. Even if the Italians were cowardly and undisciplined, their modern arms is still more than enough to compensate for their lack of professionalism.

In addition, are the warcrimes as mentioned in my World History book and popular history portrays in the war-are they over-exaggerated and taken out of proportion?I seen claims of genocide in Ethiopia by the Italians!


r/Italianhistory • • May 17 '26

Gal. Liu Xiang could have given so much more to his country against the invader. Italy has an unjust reputation about WW2: what of its commanders was the finest demonstration of their military traditions ?

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Italianhistory • • Mar 03 '26

GIUSEPPE MAZINNI

0 Upvotes

When did GIUSEPPE MAZINNI attempted revolution in liguria and was sent into exileeeeee?????


r/Italianhistory • • Jun 26 '25

If Italy had the mindset of the early Romans, how different would the World Wars have been?

0 Upvotes

Inspired by a post I saw on Historum.

https://historum.com/t/why-is-italy-so-weak-compared-to-her-predecessors-the-roman-empire.124788/

So I am curious if Italy had the qualities we associate with the Romans of the Early Republic in particular nationalism and militarism, how different would the World Wars have played out? Italy is always bashed as a pathetic military force in its history with its debacles in Africa (esp. Ethiopia) and incredible crappy performance in the World Wars. Hell a common comment is that Italy should not have fallen so fast in the war with its mountainous terrain and decently trained and equipped army (even if its poor compared to other superpowers in the war in particular the Americans and Germans).

At the very least Italy should have been able to defeat the other European countries they attempted to invade with moderate difficult at worst (excepting France and Russia). Or so I see frequently claimed in internet discussions and debates at recreational places such as restaurants. In particular its always pointed out how Italians get so kicked down hard in Albania and Greece and had to call German reinforcement.

That in these online discussions, netizens make it out as that if Italian soldiers had the disciplined, bloodthirst, organization (esp in logistics) , and above all patriotism that defined their forefathers in the Roman legions, they should have handled Greece and Albania with no problem thus in turn conquer Yugoslaia on their own and thus not force the Germans to have to send reinforcements that could have been used for Operation Barbarossa.

I even seen claims that had the Italian people had Roman qualities, they could have defended Italy with its mountainous terrain and German aid with such tenacity that D-Day would be delayed and the war extended several years by the bare minimal. At least a few posts on other sites even state with the Roman personality, the Italians-provided they are aided by German supplies- would have not only handled the British on their own but even defeat them after a protracted conflict in North Africa (as eventually German reinforcement will give new life after both sides battered each other's nose bloody).

How legit are these claims? Is it an incredible simplification as my friend's claim on the other link about Italy being so weak in the modern era due to being hedonistic and self-centered lazy cowards?

I seen some people even extend Italy would not have been on the defensive in World War 1 and would actually even take the initiative and attempt to invade the Austrian-Hungary Empire thus changing the entire WWI as we know it!


r/Italianhistory • • Jun 04 '22

US Fifth Army captures Rome in 1944

Thumbnail
self.historyunderyourfeet
2 Upvotes

r/Italianhistory • • Oct 29 '18

Christopher Columbus -- the hidden Jew?

Thumbnail
timesofisrael.com
1 Upvotes

r/Italianhistory • • Mar 23 '26

Best mail order bride site in 2026 – my honest experience

15 Upvotes

I tried a few dating platforms over the last year because I wanted a serious relationship, not just chatting or games. Many sites looked nice at first, but after some time I saw fake profiles, expensive messages, or people who were not really interested.

After testing different options, I can say that Cupidlee was the best experience for me so far. The site feels simple and easy to use, which I liked a lot. I didn’t feel lost like on some other platforms. Profiles looked more real, and I had normal conversations, not strange or scripted messages.

One thing I noticed is that people there actually reply and want to talk. I had a few good chats, and one even moved to video calls after some time. That gave me more trust, because many sites don’t offer that kind of real connection.


r/Italianhistory • • Apr 07 '20

From Italia with love

0 Upvotes

Can someone tell me their favorite italian song that sets you in one caffe bar somewhere in italy drinking vino and just sitting and enjoying the view alone without mobile phones and camera and just living the moment. Mine is l’appunatemento by Ornella Vanoni


r/Italianhistory • • Feb 13 '21

Will your kid become the next Leonardo da Vinci? The 2021 Kid Inventors Challenge has been announced!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/Italianhistory • • May 10 '25

Italian colonial troops in Abyssinia, 1935

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/Italianhistory • • Aug 16 '25

I need help with an old birth certificate

Post image
3 Upvotes

Hello everyone! Me and my wife were having some fun creating her family tree. We were searching documents, going back to 1850s, and we found this birth certificate in the Archivio di Stato di Milano.

I can't understand what is written here. I don't speak italian, and the caligraphy doesnt help. Can anyone help me understand what is written in this document?


r/Italianhistory • • Feb 23 '26

MyTransgenderDate review

57 Upvotes

I decided to try MyTransgenderDate because I wanted to meet someone serious and open-minded. The sign-up was simple and the profiles looked real. I liked that many people wrote detailed bios. I had a few good conversations and one real date. She was kind and honest, and we talked for a few weeks after.

But I also had some problems. Some profiles stopped replying after a few messages. A few accounts looked inactive. The site is not bad, but it felt a little slow for me. I think it depends on your location too.

Later I also tried Quickmedates.com. For me it felt more active and faster. I had more replies and easier chats. Just sharing my experience in case it helps someone.


r/Italianhistory • • May 12 '26

Postcard of Italian soldiers happily entertaining themselves with the grisly trophies hacked off their Ethiopian captives. (Second Italo-Ethiopian War, 1935-1937) NSFW

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/Italianhistory • • Oct 17 '24

Italian brides: are italian mail order brides a real thing or just a myth?

37 Upvotes

I know this might not be the best place for this question, but I figured people here who are interested in Italy's history and culture might have some good insights. Lately, I've been seeing a lot of stuff online about Italian mail order brides, and I’m curious if this is actually legit or just a myth? Some websites claim you can meet Italian women for marriage, but it feels a bit sketchy. Has anyone here heard of this, or know if it's safe? Is this even legal or just a scam? I’d really appreciate any recommendations or feedback from those who know more about Italian culture!


r/Italianhistory • • Oct 11 '25

Watch this video to learn about Benito Mussolini's rise to power

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/Italianhistory • • May 11 '25

The reconquest of Tripolitania, part.2 (in the photo General Rodolfo GRAZIANI)

Post image
0 Upvotes

At the end of January 1923, three columns converged on Tarhuna, an important caravan center south-east of Tripoli:

-the column of the Msellata (Colonel Pizzari: 3,100 rifles, 300 cavalry, 4 pieces) left on 29 January from Tagiura and, proceeding along the coast to Gasr Garabulli, on the 29th repelled a violent attack by the rebels and supported another victorious fight on 1 February at Fondug el Naggaza. On the 2nd he joined the mobile forces leaving Homs, on the 4th he reached el Gusbat, where he captured weapons and livestock;

-the Gefara column (lieutenant colonel Belly: 1,400 rifles, 220 cavalry, 4 pieces) moved from Azizia to the Wadi Milga and on 2 February took possession of Sidi el Uled, somewhat west of Tarhuna;

-the Gebel column (Colonel Graziani: 3,700 rifles. 350 cavalry, 4 pieces) moved from the Garian on the 31st towards the south-east up to the wells of Magleb el Me and dispersed groups of armed enemies there. On the 4th it attacked the strong positions of Gasr el Hagera which blocked the access road to Tarhuna and took it over on the same day, launching the cavalry in pursuit. He continued on the 5th, advancing to within a few kilometers of Tarhuna.

On the morning of 6 February the Graziani column quickly headed for Tarhuna and, breaking down the last resistance of the adversary, entered there at 6pm, immediately hoisting the tricolor on top of the castle. The rebels fled in maximum disorder, abandoning weapons and ammunition and partially surrendered. During the operations they had lost as many as 1,500 men. Shortly thereafter, the new, very important area was settled, proceeding with the disarmament of the populations who showed up en masse to take action of submission.


r/Italianhistory • • Nov 10 '23

Cronologia delle sigle informative/News Intro Evolution: Telegiornale Uno (do/since 1952) [coffemansky , 2023]

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/Italianhistory • • Feb 22 '25

What if Italy Became Communist in 1936?

4 Upvotes

💥 The 1936 Italian Civil War and the Rise of the Socialist Republic of Italy 💥

What if, instead of consolidating his power, Mussolini was overthrown by a socialist uprising in the mid-1930s? In my alternate history project, Italy goes through a brutal civil war, leading to the establishment of the Socialist Republic of Italy under the leadership of Sandro Pertini, while Mussolini desperately flees to Naples, only to be captured later.

🔴 Key Events in My Alternate Timeline:

  • 1936: The Italian Civil War erupts between Fascists and Socialists, with decisive battles in Turin and along the Po River.

  • 1937: Mussolini is defeated, and the Socialist Republic of Italy is born. Italy allies with the USSR and intervenes in the Spanish Civil War, helping the anarchists defeat Franco.

  • 1938-1939: Italy declares war on Nazi Germany, advancing through Munich, Vienna, and Berlin. Hitler commits suicide in his bunker as Italian socialist forces march into the German capital.

  • 1940: After the fall of the Reich, Italy promotes socialism across Europe and declares war on colonial empires to liberate Africa.

🧐 Questions for the Community:

  • How would global power dynamics shift if Italy turned socialist in 1936?

  • Would the USA and the UK have launched an early Cold War against Italy and the USSR?

  • What role would this alternate Italy play in World War II?

🔗 Want to read the full story?
I published it on Wattpad! Link here 👉 [https://www.wattpad.com/1513639637-stivale-rosso-e-se-l%27italia-fosse-stata-comunista]

Let me know what you think and if you have any suggestions to improve historical accuracy!


r/Italianhistory • • May 05 '20

It’s division time

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/Italianhistory • • Sep 09 '26

Fluent Italian speakers needed for a study (USD 100 incentive)

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I'm looking for a few fluent Italian speakers for a paid study.

You'd be transcribing a 30-minute recorded conversation of 2-4 people about everyday life, Italian audio into Italian text. Pays USD 100.

If that sounds like something you'd want to do, just comment below or send me a DM and I'll fill you in on the details. Thanks!


r/Italianhistory • • Aug 01 '26

Question historique : comment les habitants autochtones du Val de Suse se sont-ils historiquement identifiés ?

0 Upvotes

Bonjour à tous,

Je m'intéresse à l'histoire du Val de Suse et je me pose une question sur l'identité historique de ses habitants.

La vallée a connu plusieurs influences au fil des siècles : peuples alpins celto-ligures avant Rome, intégration à l'espace romain, liens médiévaux avec les territoires alpins voisins, puis appartenance aux États de Savoie avant de devenir italienne avec l'unification de l'Italie.

D'un point de vue culturel et linguistique, certaines zones de la vallée étaient liées aux parlers alpins occidentaux (francoprovençal/arpitan, et influences occitanes dans les vallées voisines), avec des échanges importants avec la Savoie et le Dauphiné.

Selon vous, les populations autochtones du Val de Suse se sont-elles historiquement plutôt perçues comme :

italiennes ?

savoyardes/alpines ?

françaises (par proximité culturelle avec le Dauphiné et les langues d'oïl/d'oc voisines) ?

ou comme une identité alpine particulière qui ne rentre pas vraiment dans ces catégories ?

Je serais curieux d'avoir l'avis de personnes connaissant l'histoire locale, la langue, les traditions ou ayant des origines dans cette vallée.


r/Italianhistory • • May 07 '20

Monotheism bad

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/Italianhistory • • Jun 22 '20

Italian-American history question?

5 Upvotes

Hey there, I was hoping to ask a question here to help me better understand my roommate, so if this sub is really meant more for Italy purely, I apologize. The guy is passionately and proudly Italian, something I really respect about him, but he just wasn't getting a point across clearñy about Columbus statues being torn down here in the U.S.

He texts me at 2 A.M. last night absolutely furious that people are tearing down statues of Columbus, showing that "they don't know anything about this country's history", mainly referencing that he felt it was disrespectful to him and other Italian-Americans to do so.

Now I didn't quite understand this line of thought, and when I asked him a couple times to elaborate a bit he just kept getting more and more pissed. I was hoping someone here could help better explain this to me.

Is the tearing down of Columbus day statues something that's affecting Italian-Americans? Would there be something better that could be done to honor Italian-American heritage?