In the last couple of years I think we all could observe a certain, significant amount of hate, specifically targeted towards the story of Mushoku Tensei. You keep hearing the same complaints over and over again, most of which in a very coarse and emotionally-charged manner. The core of all this outrage is this one singluar claim: „The protagonist of MT is a p3do!“ So, after witnessing and watching this hatred grow and fester, and not diminish despite the story itself moving on from the childhood arcs of Rudeus, I have decided, that it is time to say something. This has gone on for way too long, and it doesn’t really go anywhere, because all the arguments that are being made by the haters really don’t evolve or change, they are just the same basic claims repeated for the billionth time!
Firstly, let me start off with my own background here, so you can understand, why I am the least likely person to actually defend Mushoku Tensei, ever. I never liked isekai. I always took this genre for a superficial power fantasy with loads of fanservice but devoid of any depth or complexity. In other words, I saw it as a cheap way for anime studios to make money from gullible, horny teenagers who will watch anything as long as it has pretty colours and booba on screen (Please, excuse my language!). Even when I watched the first two seasons (!) of Re:Zero that impression oft he genre didn’t change in any way, shape or form. And just to make it clear, IT STILL HASN’T! The isekai genre generally is what I always thought it was.
However, that doesn’t mean that there can’t be exceptions, that there can’t be at least a single gold nugget hidden in that huge pile of crap that is this genre. At least in theory. So, when I watched Mushoku Tensei, I approached it with an open mind, meaning without any expectations or prejudices. So, I went in. After the first 3 episodes I already had the impression of it being very similar to most other isekai: a perverted but gifted MC in a generic fantasy setting. But even at this point it was already very clear that MT was at least giving some thought to what it was doing. The MC had a backstory that explained his contemptible behavious – something that almost never happens in the usual isekai! – and it also strongly humanised him, i.e. made us understand the character, even if we had strong issues with some of his thoughts. He was always shown trying to be kind to/thoughtful of others, and whenever he made a mistake, he tried to apologize for and learn from it. That was a VERY important part, that grounded the character, as someone who at his core still is a good person, depite his MANY problems, that stem from his past traumas.
After the first 5 episodes I went on to read the source material. Why? Well, this is a really important question, btw! Up to that point I had read quite a number of books, but never had I ever read a light novel. Why did I suddenly get interesting in read a story from THAT genre in particular? Sounds pretty insane, doesn’t it? Yes, indeed! After the first couple of episodes of the anime, I scoured the internet for more information on this story, because it was the first isekai that at least seemed to know what it was doing, instead of the usual random collection of tropes. So, when I found some insular information about what happens later in the story, I got curious, and then actually started reading the webnovel. (….) I finished the entire thing. It turned out to be a well-thought out narrative with a lot of challenging and mature themes and characters, which is very different from the 99% of other isekai which usually are just power fantasies and fanservce slop for the braindead masses!
I do not consider this story to be literary masterpiece. In my opinion, it could have done some things better or differently, but I also have to point out the BRILLIANT plot twist that is Turning Point 4, which left me stunned! If you ask me, MT is a great story, and it certainly is the best isekai ever written. But considering that 99% isekai is essentially pure garbage, this doesn’t say as much as a lot of people would assume it does. MT just so happens to be the only work that actually does isekai right.
So now let’s shift focus to the actual topic of this essay: What is going on with the online conversation about this story?
Honestly, I don’t know. Tons of people get disgusted by the MC in the very first couple of episodes an leave in a huff; that was to be expected, and I would say it’s a great filter for those with little media literacy and those who cannot cope with controversial, challenging themes. As a consequence, I understood the initial hate, but also the praise that the anime got in season 1. But I also assumed that this outcry that mostly originates from people who couldn’t get past the first couple of episodes and who are guaranteed to hate ALL other isekai and most other anime as well (because they have issues the sexualized depiction of characters – which is a perfectly fine opinion to have, btw!) would die down with season 2. In this season Rudy is already significantly older, and he suffers from ED and a lot of other terrible stuff that cannot be considered wishfulfillment or a power fantasy, not by any stretch oft he imagination.
So, imagine my shock, when I found that the hate just kept going unabated. It was completely detached from what was actually going on in the story, but it just kept going and going. And most interestingly, the vast majority of the hate kept revolving around season 1 Rudy, so a significantly different person from who he is in season 2 already. The same claims kept and still keep being regurgitated by the haters. And this is why I now HAVE TO say something. Please, give it a rest, guys! You’re not even making sense anymore!
I watched quite a number of videos and read more than a handful of negative reviews of this story, and it really just feels like I’m tapping into a hivemind there. It’s bascially the same stuff you heard in season 1, just a bunch of prematurely drawn conclusions and the complete inability to even understand the basic premise of the story! Is this all ragebait? It’s way too widespread to mostly be ragebait, so I don’t think so!
Let me lay it out for you:
Rudy is often interpreted by these people as a grown man living out p3dophilic fanasies in this new world. When I first watched the story, that thought didn’t even cross my mind. And do you know why? Well, the entire premise of the story hinges on the idea of „getting a second chance at life“. Him getting reincarnated is essenitally him getting a fresh start. And sure, the main argument against my claim of course is: „His past still haunts him, so it’s actually not a fresh start from zero!“ That claim is also true. Rudy still carries over his past traumas into this new life and he still remembers his previous life and experiences. But the narrative purpose of this is, for him to OVERCOME his past shortcomings, to become a better person than he used to be. He CANNOT possibly learn the lesson from his despicable past, if that isn’t the case! So, if this didn't happen in the story, if he actually was just a blank slate at the beginning, the entire premise of "getting a second chance“ is pointless and IMPOSSIBLE to implement. Heck, there wouldn't even be a reason for it to be an isekai in that case!
Thus, Rudy has to retain the memories (and traumas!) from his past life in order for the main idea of this story to work in the first place. Rudy never was meant to be a pedophile. He was, however, meant to have strong sexual urges and deviancies. Why? Well, the sexual trauma he suffered in his previous life resulted in his hypersexual tendencies. (This isn’t bs. It‘s a real psychological thing, look it up!) It does indeed make logical sense why Rudy is so degenerate. But that’s not meant to be a "nice“ thing. The audience is not meant to look at his degenerate behaviour and find it „arousing“ or see it as "wishfulfillment“. The fact TONS of people interpret Rudy’s terrible behaviour in season 1 of MT as fanservice is owed to them having grown accustomed to fanservice in modern anime to such a degree, that they immediatly conclude that "anything sexual in a story is automatically fanservice“. That, however, is a misinterpretation of what MT’s intentions are here.
Rudy’s sexual deviancy is a MASSIVE issue - i.e. an actual plot point - one that he has to overcome, depite the fact that he himself isn’t even aware of this (very often people are not aware of their own mental illnesses and complexes and/or the fact that they need to conquer them!). He does become a better person but only very slowly and gradually. But the fact that sexuality is one of the main themes of the story, right away leads most people to the wrong assumption that Rudy’s actions are intended to be fanservice and that, because he’s a kid who still has all the memories of his previous life of 30+ years, this is meant to be a pedophile wishfulfillment story.
It is not.
As proof of this I could point out that Rudy never lusts after anyone who is physically younger than himself throughout the whole story. This argument will not matter to anyone who just has issues with the sexualized depictions of minor characters in season 1, I know. However, it HAS TO be pointed out that these kinds of depictions are RAMPANT in all of modern anime!!! (It was a huge surprise even to me that the haters usually like other anime, though.) So, using this as proof that Rudy is a pedophile is like pointing at a single corncob, while you’re standing in a cornfield, and proclaiming it to be "THE ONLY corncob“. It makes very little sense. Those kinds of depicitions are too widespread in anime to use them as evidence for anything (unless you want to argue that all of anime is pedophilic). Only pointing at that and saying „that’s why MT is pedophile“, while pretending that all other anime are not, is hypocritical in the best of cases.
So, let’s return to the more important aspect of this: the story’s premise. MT’s main idea is about a new chance at life for a character who is hypersexual, due to his past sexual trauma. Expecting such a character to wait until he is of age to do have sex is unrealistic (even though he did try, but whatever, the haters don’t care about context anyway…). Of course, it would have been the right thing for him to wait until he’s of age, but given the context of his backstory, it is fair to say, that this was NEVER what was going to happen. (short tangent: If you look at statistics from our real world as to when people – in whatever country doesn’t matter– have their first time, it is apparently also too much to ask of A MASSIVE percentage of the people in the world, to wait until they are old enough to do the deed legally. So, this story isn’t exactly unrealistic. It just depicts stuff some people don’t want to see.)
Rudy never was going to start off as a "good guy“. The intention always was for him to start off as a terrible person, who then slowly, gradually, with some relapses in between, becomes a better human being. He was reincarnated, born anew. So, if some people think that two underaged characters having s3x makes them pedophiles, I would love to see how they react, when they learn just how many people actually do the deed before they are of age…………….or how they react to the legal definiton of pedohilia….. which doesn’t apply in this case, just saying….
Once more: I am not promoting such acts, I am merely pointing out that this isn’t as uncommon as some people seem to believe. There are many, MANY degenerate people out there. (And anime is a medium that has been amplifying these things to a huge degree.) But simply depicting this in a story does not mean that the author is “glorifying“ it, especially when the story is supposed to show a TERRIBLE character who slowly becomes a better person.
Next up: selectively reading the source material.
There a these special kinds of haters who read the source material, only to nit-pick specific parts of it in order to justify their delusional interpretations of this story, while simultaneously ignoring the majority of the context and the events in the story. This is insanity in its purest form. You probably will not come across many of these people, because they are very few in number – as are INTELLIGENT defenders of MT. On the internet you will mostly just encounter those haters who wrongly interpret the bathing scene with Sylphie from ep. 2 for example, so people whose surface-level misinterpretation of the scene is already laughable if you have more than 2 braincells. But there is a whole spectrum of way more sophisticated haters, those who have made it their goal to deliberately seek quotes from the source material, in order to misconstrue the entire premise and theme of the story. These are the kinds of folks who quote passages of Rudy j3rking off to very specific kinds of p0rn in his previous life with the aim of arguing against the MT-fans that he is a p3do.
This ist he kind of sh%t we have to deal with! The haters ignore all the context, the fact that Rudy grows up, changes into a loving father and husband who acts like a respectable member of society. They pretend that he hasn’t changed – which is insane! – and that he just gets what he wants and doesn’t redeem himself. I can’t go into ALL the stuff they say, because it would make my essay a thousand times longer than it already is (no, really!), so I’ll refrain from that. Instead, let’s adress the prior claims:
Rudy gets a lot of punishement over the course of the story, among which his ED that lasted for 2 whole years! How is this not punishment? Or do the haters only see something as punishment, when THEY get to choose it? (I think that’s the answer!) So, do the haters even ALLOW him to become a better person, to slowly improve? NO, they basically reject the very concept of redemption, so it’s impossible for this story to EVER redeem Rudy in their eyes anyway! They’re just not honest enough to admit this!
Rudy becoming a better person with the help of other people (mostly his wives) is the core of this story’s theme! The importance of family is what he needed to learn, so, despite some relapses, he did end up becoming a better man BECAUSE of his loving family! Pretending that Rudy gets what he wants, when the core idea of the story is that you NEED other people in your life to give you stability and a purpose, is an ABHORRENT and deliberate misinterpretation of THE ONLY GOOD ISEKAI EVER WRITTEN! Shame on anyone who does this!