r/Ironsworn • • Aug 15 '24

Play Report Chat GPT for solo play

0 Upvotes

Chat GPT has been amazing for solo play! I just asked “Will you play ironsworn with me” and off we went. It reminds me of a text based game where it says “x, y and z happen, what do you do?” And then gives you a list of options. But the real fun is how interactive chat GPT is with your responses. Don’t like any of the provided options? Tell it something else.

Also, don’t limit yourself to just responding, chat GPT also works well when you introduce new events into your scenes. You can easily interrupt decision points with new events and they get incorporated into the story quite well.

Obviously there are limits to chat GPT, but I have been pleasantly surprised so far. The main downside is the limited chats per day. I still suggest anyone struggling to give it a try!


r/Ironsworn • • Nov 16 '23

Tools Ironsworn Pathfinder: a custom GPT that's an Ironsworn rules expert for ChatGPT plus members

4 Upvotes

For those who aren't familiar with what a GPT is: it's basically a custom version of ChatGPT that you can give extra context and instructions so it specializes in one specific task. These are available if you're a ChatGPT Plus member.

I just created a GPT that has access to the Ironsworn rulebook and is ready to answer questions, clarify rules and even offer some roleplaying opportunities.

I know this can be a rather polarizing topic but so far this has been an amazing tool for me to use, as it can condense and quickly explain rules and also suggest plot twists, hooks and even interpret oracle rolls. Sometimes I like them, sometimes I don't and I just end up using my own interpretation. This is just a tool. For example, yesterday I wanted a quick session with a new character so I just asked IP to create a character for me:

This is just enough to start playing but you can actually dig deeper and add more substance.

If you're interested ,and are a ChatGPT+ member, you can access it here: https://chat.openai.com/g/g-izW8e8cgt-ironsworn-pathfinder


r/Ironsworn • • Jun 15 '23

Play Report My AI Ironsworn Adventure

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Well my side quest to gain the aid of the gaints to retrieve the moonheart stone has been longer than I expected but fun and added a lot of depth to my ironlands. Turns out there are hill giants in the hinterlands (some of whom I previously met) and the their are the Frost Giants who live on the edge of the Shattered wastes. This is where I ended up for this adventure. Here is the re-cap the AI wrote about this chapter of my story

"Upon arriving in Jotunheim, you were greeted by Njordr, the leader of the giants, who extended his hospitality and offered assistance, in the form of a small warband, in your quest to retrieve the Moonheart stone. However they are having their own problems with Ice wraiths that they will need you to help deal with first.

Determined to aid the giants, you joined them in their raids against the wraiths, witnessing firsthand their destructive power. In one of these early encounters, Faelin, your human companion, sustained a life-threatening injury. The close call served as a stark reminder of the urgency of your mission and the need for a decisive victory against the wraiths.

A scouting mission found that the wraiths power was coming from a number of large, enchanted ice pillars and destroying these would be key to destroying the wraiths for good. Recognizing the need for additional assistance, you embarked on a perilous journey to Eldrhjarta, the mountain of fire, to recruit Sigrun, known as the Eternal Flame. With Sigrun's fiery magic now at your disposal, your warband grew stronger and more determined.

The time came for the final showdown. You strategise to have Njordr lead the main force head on at the wraiths in a shield wall. While Hjalmar, another skilled giant warrior, leads a small band on the eastern flank and you, with Sigrun and your warband, come in from the west to hit the pillars. As the battle unfolded, you witnessed the unyielding strength of the giants and the formidable power of Sigrun's fire magic. The fight against the wraiths was fierce and unforgiving, but your warband held their ground, protecting Sigrun as she focused her magic on destroying the pillars that empowered the wraiths.

Throughout the battle, the giants demonstrated their unwavering loyalty and determination, pushing back against the relentless onslaught. The sacrifices made by fallen giants were not in vain, as their memory fueled the resolve of those still standing.

Despite facing unexpected challenges, including a formidable wraith king and sustaining injuries, your warband fought valiantly. With Ragnhild's guidance and the combined efforts of the giants, you succeeded in destroying the pillars one by one, causing the wraiths' power to wane with each victory.

Amidst the chaos of battle, Faelin, the skilled archer, demonstrated unwavering courage and resilience, refusing to succumb to her injuries and fighting on alongside you. Her determination became a symbol of the indomitable spirit of your warband.

Victorious, the giants celebrated their newfound safety and the defeat of the wraiths. The melting ice and snow revealed a vibrant green plain beneath, symbolizing a return to prosperity for the giants. The sacrifices made by the fallen giants were honored, and plans were made to ensure their memory lived on."

I now have a small warband (commander assest) of female giants traveling with me as I head back south to try again at delving into the Shadowmire.


r/Ironsworn • • Nov 11 '24

Hacking Anyone ever tried a NSFW campaign? NSFW

12 Upvotes

Are there any oracles or supplements out there that would be good for hacking a horny campaign? What supplemental rules do you think it would need?


r/Ironsworn • • May 30 '23

I asked chatgpt to write a ballad about my characters final scene

0 Upvotes

In the Ironlands, where shadows loom,

A tale of sacrifice and doom,

A hunter ventured, brave and strong,

To shield a child from nature's wrong.

A little girl, with eyes so wide,

Lost in the woods, where fears reside,

A bear emerged, with hunger's growl,

Threatening to consume her soul.

With weapon drawn, the hunter fought,

Against the bear, with all he brought,

His body battered, spirit frayed,

He stood between her and the beast's blade.

Through piercing roars and desperate cries,

He battled on, no fear in his eyes,

Each strike a plea, a valiant plea,

To grant the girl a chance to flee.

In Ironlands, where sorrows seep,

A hero's sacrifice, so deep,

He fell, his life for hers exchanged,

A debt repaid, forever unchanged.

The little girl, now safe and sound,

Her tears fall on hallowed ground,

For in her heart, she'll always know,

The hunter's love, that helped her grow.

In Ironlands, his story's told,

A legend etched in tales of old,

A hunter's heart, forever mourned,

A life well spent, forever adorned.

So let the tears flow freely now,

For the hunter's vow, we shall avow,

In the Ironlands, his memory will stay,

A bittersweet ache, that won't decay.


r/Ironsworn • • Sep 10 '26

Hacking How to choose the monster's rank when converting from D&D to Ironsworn?

1 Upvotes

There is a TL;DR at the end of this opening post.

What criteria should I use? I suppose I should take HD (Hit Dice) an AC (Armor Class) in consideration. I developed some criteria for determining the Ironsworn ranks of D&D monsters, and I want to know what you think.

I know that the ranks have some subjectivity, but I want a quick way to determine the "default rank" of a D&D monster.


But, before anything, here are the ranks of some foes from the Ironsworn books (core book and Sundered Isles) and their counterparts in the D&D or equivalent systems:

DATA

  • Bear (Formidable)

    • Black Bear (B/X) – HD: 4; AC: 13 / Black Bear (5e) – HD: (3d8+6); AC: 11; CR: 1/2

    • Grizzly Bear (B/X) – HD: 5; AC: 13 / Brown Bear (5e) – HD: (4d10+12); AC: 11; CR: 1

    • Polar Bear (B/X) – HD: 6; AC: 13 / Polar Bear (5e) – HD: (5d10+15); AC: 12; CR: 2

  • Boar (Dangerous)

    • Boar (B/X) – HD: 3; AC: 12 / Boar (5e) – HD: (2d8+2); AC: 11; CR: 1/4

  • Mammoth (Extreme)

    • Mastodon (B/X) – HD:15 ; AC: 16 / Mammoth (5e) – HD: (11d12+55); AC: 13; CR: 6

  • Wolf (Dangerous)

    • Wolf (B/X) – HD: 2 +2 ; AC: 12 / Wolf (5e) – HD: (2d8+2); AC: 13; CR: 1/4


  • Common Folk (Troublesome)

    • Normal Human (B/X) – HD: ½ ; AC: 10 / Commoner (5e) – HD: (1d8+10); AC: 10; CR: 0

  • Elf (Dangerous)

    • Elf (B/X) – HD: 1 +1 ; AC: 14 / Drow (5e) – HD: (3d8); AC: 15; CR: 1/4

  • Raider (Dangerous)

    • Bandit (B/X) – HD: 1 ; AC: 13 / Bandit (5e) – HD: (2d8+2); AC: 12; CR: 1/8


  • Basilisk (Extreme)

    • Basilisk (B/X) – HD:6 +1 ; AC: 15 / Basilisk (5e) – HD: (8d8+16); AC: 15; CR: 3

  • Chimera (Extreme)

    • Chimera (B/X) – HD:9 ; AC: 15 / Chimera (5e) – HD: (12d10+48); AC: 14; CR: 6

  • The Kraken (Epic)

    • Kraken (Basic Fantasy) – HD: 36 +16 ; AC: 19 / Kraken (5e) – HD: (27d20 + 189); AC: 18; CR: 23

  • Leviathan (Epic)

    • Mosasaurus (Basic Fantasy) – HD: 12 +10 ; AC: 12 / Mosasaur (5e) – HD: (14d12 + 56); AC: 13; CR: 7

    • Sperm Whale (OSE) – HD:36 ; AC: 13 / Sperm Whale (5e) – HD: (14d20 + 42); AC: 13; CR: 8

  • Sea Serpent (Epic)

    • Greater Sea Serpent (OSE) – HD: 14 ; AC: 16 / Sea Serpent (5e) – HD: (15d20 + 60); AC: 16; CR: 12

  • Troll (Formidable)

    • Troll (B/X) – HD: 6 +3 ; AC: 15 / Troll (5e) – HD: (8d10+40); AC: 15; CR: 5

  • Wyvern (Extreme)

    • Wyvern (B/X) – HD:7 ; AC: 16 / Wyvern (5e) – HD: (13d10+39); AC: 13; CR: 6


By the way, since the original B/X system uses Descending AC, I converted the AC numbers to Ascending AC. And I had to use some Basic Fantasy monsters when I could not find the equivalent monster in the B/X books or in the ones from OSE (Old-School Essentials), in this case I subtracted 1 point from the AC.


My method of conversion is based on both HD and AC, and I prefer to use B/X monsters because of the simplicity of their stats; if the monster is not available in the B/X books, I used the ones from Basic Fantasy or Old-School Essentials. You take in consideration either HD or AC, and you choose the stat that favors the highest rank; for example, if the HD of a monster would give it a Dangerous rank, but its AC is within the Formidable rank, you take only the AC in consideration.

Troublesome: Common enemies

It's seems to me that the enemy must be too basic to remain in the Troublesome rank, even a Hunter has a higher rank.

HD: ½ ; AC: 10

Dangerous: Capable fighters and deadly creatures

Taking in consideration on what we see on the data, it's too easy for a "weak" monster to fall in this rank, the Raider/Bandit foe has shown that to us

HD: 1—3 ; AC: 11—12

Formidable: Exceptional fighters and mighty creatures

HD: 4—5 ; AC: 13—15

Extreme: Foes of overwhelming skill or power

Epic: Legendary foes of mythic power

It's here that things got complicated; in the B/X system, the Mastodon is more deadly than the Mosasaurus (well, taking in consideration the image of a mosasaurus that appears in the "Representing Difficulty" subchapter, I assume it's the representation of the Leviathan although The Sundered Isles describe it as a whale...), that's why I will consider the Leviathan as an equivalent of the Sperm Whale.

From the gathered monsters, the lowest HD was 14, but I decided to determine that an HD of 10 is enough to be considered Epic

Extreme: HD: 6—9 ; AC: 16—

Epic: HD: 10— ; AC: 15—


TL;DR:

This is a method of defining the Ironsworn rank of B/X monsters; you take in consideration either HD or AC, and you choose the stat that favors the highest rank.

Troublesome: HD: ½ ; AC: 10

Dangerous: HD: 1—3 ; AC: 11—12

Formidable: HD: 4—5 ; AC: 13—15

Extreme: HD: 6—9 ; AC: 16—

Epic: HD: 10— ; AC: 15—

What do you think?


Edit 1: Thanks to the suggestions, I've added the CR (Challenge Rate) to the 5e monsters. Here is the conversion method based on CR:

Troublesome: CR: 0

Dangerous: CR: 1/8—1/4

Formidable: CR: 1/2—2

Extreme: CR: 3—6

Epic: CR: 7—


r/Ironsworn • • 4d ago

Starforged How critical are accurate maps in Starforged?

Thumbnail
claude.ai
0 Upvotes

I am new to rpgs (but older in life with lotsa obligations) and so built this whole GitHub management scheme to play different systems solo. Dump a pdf, makes a knowledge base, Llm is my guide, have physical dice or use dice app (playing on the go on my phone might be a bit time sink I’m realizing). In DnD campaigns I need a map so my guide knows distances and travel times. (I use Claude as my dm but it sucks at art so I use assets or have something like openAI make art, like on that link)

But now I am running Starforged (awesome Black Friday sale on drive thru rpg) and super stoked. But the general galaxy map versus sectors versus sector maps, it’s all procedural which is cool and there’s planets and info in the guide if I want. But since ships can just jump (in my universe), how critical is the sector map? Part of me wants to spend time on this at the start but also that it kinda doesn’t matter. My current map is lame and I definitely need better there.

What do people do or think about the importance of a map and which map level?


r/Ironsworn • • Apr 14 '20

I downloaded the PDF but the game seems complicated.

2 Upvotes

This is coming from someone who moved from 3.5 to 5e, and anyone who’s played 5e knows they streamlined everything.

Anyway I feel like a Move is just another word for an Action you take. I skimmed the book and a few questions:

  1. I’m surprised Ironsworn doesn’t have caves/dungeons as part of the vanilla game. Really?

  2. Did I misinterpret something during my skim or do companion NPCs not really have stats?

  3. The rules seem fairly complex. Is there a basic rules edition or just the 200p PDF?


r/Ironsworn • • Oct 02 '24

ChatGPT can run an Ironsworn game with you.

0 Upvotes

It knows the rules, it knows all the moves and assets, it's great as a rules reference, can be used to recommend the right move for the right situation, can describe all the mechanics related to any move, it's also amazing as an oracle. It can walk you through character creation and world building, it's great at helping you brainstorm story and character concepts, makes your encounters more epic by adding environmental conditions, roleplaying enemies, etc. I played an hour long game with the advanced voice feature last night and I only had to correct it twice on rule mistakes. Each time I just asked it if it was sure it was getting the rule right and it automatically corrected itself. I recommend asking it to talk using a dramatic voice.


r/Ironsworn • • Feb 05 '24

Play Report The game is too hard, it's almost impossible to get a strong hit.

0 Upvotes

Sure, I can help you with grammar and spelling. Here is the corrected sentence:

I get in a lot of trouble because of too many pay the price results. I lost a lot of momentum, health, spirit and supply. I can't get out of combat because I don't get a strong hit even when I have the 10 progress marks full. When I finally get a strong hit to end the fight, I get a 10 (in the challenge dice) and it's a weak hit. I'm afraid of gathering resources, asking for help or even healing myself at this point because the "pay the price" is around the corner.


r/Ironsworn • • Apr 23 '23

Rules Question

1 Upvotes

When it says "take a +1 momentum on a hit" does that mean I'm supposed to add or subtract 1 momentum?


r/Ironsworn • • Feb 26 '26

Rolling for pronouns

12 Upvotes

At some point during my Starforged campaign I realised, that more or less by default characters, I encountered, were quite often male. Having grown up in the world as it is, I am not really puzzled about this, but wanted to change it. So, inspired by Matt Risby's podcast "The Bad Spot" (definitive recommendation!) I built my own little pronoun oracle. Now I have a healthy spread of pronouns. I am curious, how do you all tackle this issue? Is it even a problem you have?


r/Ironsworn • • Mar 29 '23

Inspiration 5 Tips For Playing Better Noble Characters

Thumbnail
pinterest.com
0 Upvotes

r/Ironsworn • • Oct 12 '26

Inspiration Bad Oracle Rolls Are Just Good Oracle Rolls But Ur A Little B*

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/Ironsworn • • Feb 18 '25

Sundered Isles Help me love the game i wanna love, even though i. frikkin. hate. it.

0 Upvotes

Sundered Isles looks like a dream game for me. A solo RPG that lets me mash pirates of the Caribbean with treasure planet? Focused on journeys, discoveries and meaningful quests? Let’s fucking go! But while I love the concept of this game so much, and it seems all so intuitive when I watch other people play it online, every time I try to play it myself, I hate it so, so, so much. If you read this post, you’ll probably think to yourself: this guy doesn't want advice. He just wants to rant and shit all over the game I like. And you would be 98% right. That’s exactly what I want. However, what I want even more than that is love this game.

If sundered isles were a woman, it would be one of the most funny, smart and attractive women I have ever met. And while in public she's super friendly and kind. But when I’m alone with her she is cold as ice and cannot stop making really mean jokes about me, and then laugh at me when I complain about it. So, I leave frustrated, but the next day she acts like nothing happened and asks if I want to hang out with her. Then look on her social media and talk with her exes (i.e. read forums and reviews) but everyone just talks about how awesome she is and its driving me nuts. I read threads upon threads about this game, hoping someone, anyone, could help me make it make sense for me. But so far, without any success. So, I wrote this wall of text more as a form of therapy than anything else.

Because we got to start somewhere, let’s first look at combat moves. And let us assume that we always have a stat of +3 (forcing us to use our best stat all the time, already making the narrative more boring) so we have a roughly 33% chance of a strong hit, 44% of a weak hit and 23% chance of a miss. Enter the fray is fine. But then, the problems begin. Secure and advantage is seldom useful, because it risks getting us in a bad spot 25% of the time, which is extremely punishing. And because the game hates us, if that happens, we also have to pay the price (we will get to that move) on top of that. I’m already struggling to see why the move needs to be as punishing as it is. Why does failing to push your advantage, automatically means being at a disadvantage now? And this is one of the least punishing moves. Also getting in a bad spot is so easy, yet getting in control is really hard. Then come Strike and Clash, which both have a chance of 67% of putting me in a bad spot. Why not let me choose between letting me make progress or staying in/gaining control? Why does a miss need to have 2 bad outcomes? Getting in control is so difficult, why is getting in a bad spot so easy?

And then there is the worst offender: react under fire. On a weak hit not only do you stay in a bad spot, but you also have to do a suffer move. So, a weak hit means... two exclusively bad things happen? In other places in the rules this move is referred to as trying to parry in close quarters combat. So, by getting a weak hit on a parry attempt while in a bad spot, I still suffer harm, while also staying in a bad spot? WTF? How is this a hit in any way? Why would I ever use this move, when I can probably always justify using clash (with pistols to use edge) instead from a narrative point of view? Even if you have +3 wit and +1 iron, clashing is probably still preferable because the risk of reacting under fire is so big compared to the possible gains.

Which is brings us right to our next problem: the standard reply to complaints about the cataclysmic catastrophe this game turns into, whenever my character just tries to tie his shoes, is usually: try to make the pay the price move less punishing. However. If I use the pay the price move to "envision a complication in the narrative, that does not have to enforce a negative mechanical consequence", this makes the miss for react under fire a straight up better mechanical outcome than the weak hit. Which seems like a problem. This approach also creates issues with other moves. Take face danger. Weak hit: success, but mechanical punishment. Miss: no success but also no mechanical punishment. So, the narrative of somewhat successfully facing danger incurs mechanical harm, but the narrative of completely failing to face danger does not? That doesn’t seem right, does it? Or what about undertake an expedition. The weak hit marks progress, but also incurs a suffer (-2)!!!! move or another peril (which should at least have the potential of an equally bad -or better: worse- mechanical outcome, because otherwise, why ever bother with the suffer (-2) move ever?). Meanwhile the miss marks no progress, but also may not cause any mechanical disadvantage? Wouldn't that make the miss preferable to a weak hit in most cases?

Another possibility would be, to make the pay the price move enforce consequences that have to be dealt with. But how do I deal with those consequences? By making more moves. Which more often than not result in additional weak hits or misses, thereby incurring additional suffer or pay the price moves, bloating the narrative to a ridiculous degree. Just use the table for pay the price for inspiration? This table is pretty horrible. What is worse: enduring 1 harm or having a trusted individual turn against you? I would argue the latter. A lot of those things are worse than enduring harm or stress. Betrayal? A new looming threat, enemy or hazard? A community I care about gets threatened? All these things imply multiple new moves or entire combats or scenes or vows that all are going to likely result in harm and additional pay the price moves, because these are just the most common outcomes. If I then use the narrative table for the pay the price move as inspiration I’m going to be buried under iron vows, avalanches, new enemies and rivals, storms and floods in no time. Not even speaking from the incoherent narrative this would bring. Like, I just want to heal up in this peaceful village. But because I get a miss I not only don't get to heal, but have to now make up a whole other problem for my wounded, shaken unprepared character to deal with, despite being in a very safe environment? The epitome of fun!

And I just don’t want to constantly have to envision new bad stuff. After having to think of a like a 7th possible peril in this dungeon, after I got 3 misses in a row (which is not that unlikely with even your BEST STAT) I usually just quit. Before this rant I just wanted to explore a dangerous ruin. Not formidable. Not extreme. Not epic. Just dangerous. So far, I’ve stumbled over traps, lost my torches, fought some cultist squatters, got my powder wet, got scared by disturbing wall paintings and on and on and on. It is just so exhausting. I just want to get on with this story. Instead I have to constantly think about shit that can go sideways. Yes, having bad things happen and obstacles to overcome is exiting. The first time, also the second and third, but then it starts to feel grindy. Sooner or later I just default to suffer moves, because I stop caring. This game is often described as falling forward, but to me it often doesn’t feel that way. Even a strong hit usually doesn’t feel that good, because a weak hit usually either directly negates everything I gained extra from the strong hit, or will require additional moves, that will cost more than the few strong hits ever gave.

And all of that, all that failure, all that failure, all that struggle, ALL OF THAT IF I USE MY BEST STAT EXCLUSIVELY! I, of course, use my best stat to explore the dungeon. Don’t ask me how my dude explores a ruin by just being really fast. I would like to use wits or shadow because its more thematic, but can you imagine the comical amount of unexpected obstacles, failure and bad fortune that would entail? Heavily incentivising me to use the same approach over and over again, doesn't seem that good of a design to me. Want to gain advantage in combat? I’m going to use my agility to manoeuvre myself into a better position! Oh no, how do I get out of this dangerous situation? I’m just going to use my agility to run really fast! Want to explore these uncharted waters? I’m just going to use my agility to explore really fast (?)!

Someone compared playing Ironsworn to reading a Joe Abercrombie novel, but I have to disagree. In the first or second book, there is a fight where a character dispatches two bandits with ease, but then gets clocked from behind in the head, because he got overconfident. That is not what would happen in Ironsworn. If this would be a formidable Ironsworn fight, this is what would happen:

"Jezal dan Luthar dispatches the first bandit with ease, but then three more of them arrive at the scene. He stabs one of them, but the blade gets stuck in his enemy, so he loses it. Then he loses footing and stumbles to the ground. Suddenly, two more foes enter the fight. He draws his dagger, stabbing one of his enemies in the foot, wrestling his axe from him and managing to get upright again. But two more ruffians come to the aide of their comrades. But than a bird shits in Jezal’s eye, and he loses orientation, getting nicked by the scimitar of one of his opponents while being blinded. Also, two more bandits join the fight. He manages to retaliate with a deadly strike, but then an angry squirrel comes out of nowhere, biting his nuts. He screams in pain, but through his tears manages to dispatch one of his foes and the squirrel. But then, just as, like, five more bandits arrive, the ground beneath his feet starts to shake! An Earthquake! But he keeps his balance, thanks to his impeccable footwork, honed by years of intensive fencing training. And then, oh foul betrayal, he gets stabbed in the bag by Bayaz the mage, not because it makes sense from a story point of view, but because I’ve run out of possible negative outcomes and feel like I have overplayed the 'a new enemy arrives' outcome already!"

It gets exhausting pretty fast. Even in the original book, the fight was a transforming moment for the character. And RPG characters tend to get in a lot more fights then book characters. If Logan Ninefinger had been an Ironsworn character, he would have been called Logan Nofinger at the end of Before they are hanged. And he has probably a +5 in iron. Yes, characters in novels are most interesting when they fail, but only if they manage to also get shit done from time to time, without losing all their blood, money and hope in the process.

Now there are other suggested solutions. Like Changing the character stat array, or using other dice combinations. But here comes the part where I can’t get over myself: yeah, that feels like cheating. If all my characters fail horribly all the time, am I to stupid? Do I play this game correctly? Do I play it, as it is intended? Am I missing something? The rules as written just make me feel like something is wrong with me, and that drives me nuts. Please justify my anger and comfort my fragile ego.

Also, I don’t think they address the key problem: the move design. Undertake an expedition for example, is a core move for a core concept of this game. But the most likely outcome of that move is to envision a new peril I encounter (isn't that kind of the same as what people want to me to use the pay the price move as?) or suffer a (-2) move. Why is this more punishing than the core moves of combat (ignoring react under fire, because that’s what you should do), even though combat and expeditions are mechanically kind of the same? Also, a lot of times something bad happens on a miss for seemingly no reason. Want to repair your ship but miss (again: one in four misses even on a +3, one in three on a 2+). So, you don't get to repair, but inexplicably things also get worse? That seems just so... antagonistic. Why not just say, that repairs are not possible until you reach port or that you need to invest additional resources for a worse outcome (and no, that’s not "things getting worse"; that’s worse than a weak hit, but not worse than the status quo)? But no, things have to get worse. That’s also the case for the other recover moves: not only don't you get to recover (which already seems harsh, considering the odds for that happening), but the rules state explicitly that your situation gets even worse. Ironsworn treats misses like most DnD groups treat natural 1s, even though misses in Ironsworn are wayyyy more common. Now again, we can discuss what pay the price means all day long, but the rules say: the situation gets worse. I guess, these rulings are the way they are to prevent abuse. To prevent players from taking these recover moves over and over again, when there are no negative outcomes. But it seems like this is a weird way to go about it, by punishing you for trying to recover when you need it the most. Aren't there better ways to limit the availability of such moves? Does the game don't trust me with using moves responsibly?

There's also sometimes this antagonistic bent to it, especially in the recovery rules. The heal move acknowledges, that when you mend your own wounds, using iron and wits both make sense, but it forces you to take the lower of both. However I can ise wits if I dont treat myself and if i want to use iron to heal my wounds i have to receive treatment from someone else. But also, that someone else cannot be an ally?! It doesn't make sense narratively. It just seems in place to make things mechanically harder for you. If I’m out of danger, in a safe environment, why not just let me heal up and resupply somewhat reliably? If out of 4 recovery moves 2 come with a catch and one fails completely and makes the situation worse, that’s not keeping it interesting, that’s just keeping it frustrating. I've just got this awesome idea for an expedition; all i need is a quick resupply aaaaaaaand I’ve got to envision a new complication (of course I could ignore it, but why did I then role in the first place?). Why won’t you just let me have fun?

I remember once when I returned to my ship from an expedition (searching a ruin which was a waypoint for another expedition) with 1 health and 1 spirit. Having a +2 heart I missed both my recovery moves. Because I had enough already, I simply ignored the "situation gets worse". But I still don't know where to go from here? Start on new expedition or iron vow? I'm like two weak hits away from suffering three impacts. I thought about narrative implications. What if some of the traps I’ve tried to dodge in the ruin were poisoned and that’s why I couldn't heal either body or soul? Now I’ve got to find a witchdoctor, who could use his mythical healing powers to restore my vitality. Sounds kind of cool. But my chance to miss a healing roll is 33%. I cannot completely force my narrative to be jerked violently in a new direction, every time I fail two 67% roles. Even if I just envision immediately finding a witchdoctor and take two automatic strong hits on my recovery moves (which really doesn't feel like playing the game as intended), these interruptions are just so numerous. Because failing completely and almost failing is so ubiquitous.

It seems this game doesn't need another stat array to be appealing to me, but a whole other core philosophy.

Also English not my first language yada yada yada and thanks for listening to my TED-talk.

PS: Also, what’s with this dice system? Even if I roll the best possible number on my action die and can add +4 because of assets or even if I burn 10 momentum or even if I push through until 10 progress, I still have a nearly 20% of just getting a your-princess-is-in-another-castle-bullshit weak hit? So, can I get 11 momentum? VERBOTEN! And can I get 11 progress? ALSO, VERBOTEN! Like, I can burn 10 momentum and can still stay in a bad spot in combat? Or even better: get a free suffer (-1) move when using react under fire! It’s on the house! Why would you not want to have a one in five chance of an outcome that is exclusively bad in, enticingly, several ways, when burning all your gruellingly hard earned meta currency? Like, how is everyone ok with this? Could I homebrew it? Of course! But WHY IS EVERONE ELSE OK WITH THIS? IM NOT THE WEIRD ONE! YOU ARE THE WEIRD ONE! You could have just made it so that we only have to match the challenge dice like ANY OTHER RPG does with challenge numbers and just subtract one from all attributes! But then we would be having fun not playing Charlie Chaplin slapstick characters brutally getting murdered and we can’t have that now, can we?


r/Ironsworn • • 26d ago

Play Report Actual play de Ironsworn con reglas y assets de starforged.

4 Upvotes

Hola a todos. Estoy jugando una partida de Ironsworn starforged, ambientado en Japón fantástico, similar a Rokugan. Lo he redactado las tiradas y la historia y me gusta mucho como ha quedado.

Me gustaría compartirlo, pero es bastante largo yo creo para publicarlo aquí y no sé muy bien cómo hacerlo, ni si le interesará a alguien.

Algún consejo?


r/Ironsworn • • Feb 24 '26

Ironsworn I Played Ironsworn Solo For 30 Days - Here Are My Thoughts

Thumbnail
youtube.com
44 Upvotes

r/Ironsworn • • Apr 12 '24

Rules How do you interpret rolls with 10?

0 Upvotes

If I designate 1d10 as the 10s place, and the other as the 1's, and I roll like so 4, 10 How do I interpret that? 410? 50? Or this one: 10, 5 Is that 105? 15?

Halp!


r/Ironsworn • • Nov 08 '22

Delve I know Starforged is all the rage now, but...

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

r/Ironsworn • • Apr 06 '23

ChatGTP Wrote My Character's Backstory Better Than I Did...

5 Upvotes

Brüz was born with an innate ability to endure more harm than the average human. As a baby, he would often crash to the floor while learning to walk, but he would simply pick himself back up and try again without showing any signs of discomfort.

As he grew older, it became clear that Brüz's exceptional pain tolerance wasn't his only gift. He had a preternatural ability to push his body past normal limits, allowing him to run faster, lift heavier objects, and endure longer periods of physical strain than anyone else in his village.

Brüz grew up feeling like an outsider among his peers. He would often tire of their human-made games and conversations, preferring to spend his time alone with the animals of the Ironlands. He found that he had a natural connection to the creatures around him, and that he was able to communicate with them in ways that other humans couldn't.

Once he reached adulthood, Brüz left his village and set out on his own, determined to use his unique abilities to protect the wilds and the animals he loved. He fashioned a gauntlet made from sharpened boar tusks, which he used to defend himself and his animal companions. And he donned a mask made from a deer skull, both to conceal his identity and to pay homage to the creatures he had come to hold so dear.

Despite his preference for animals, Brüz was not completely isolated from humans. When his path crossed theirs, he would use his gifts to help those in need, even if it meant enduring harm that would leave most others incapacitated. His reputation as an enigmatic protector of the wilds grew, and over time, many began to see him as a mystical figure, almost more animal than human. But Brüz knew that he was simply using the gifts he had been born with to keep the balance of the Ironlands intact. And he took comfort in the knowledge that, even if he couldn't fully understand human customs and conversations, he had found a place where he belonged - among the wild creatures of the Ironlands.


r/Ironsworn • • Nov 26 '24

Inspiration 100 Fantasy Professions (That Aren't "Adventurer") - Azukail Games | DriveThruRPG.com

Thumbnail
legacy.drivethrurpg.com
0 Upvotes

r/Ironsworn • • Jan 15 '21

Play Report Woden's Plays "Mega" thread

1 Upvotes

This is my post about me playing Ironsworn solo. I will be posting my play reports and my "going live" notifications here on this thread. If you're not familiar with World Anvil's Hero pages, they are simply put a social media for fictional characters. Kind of like those memes you see with the comic book characters sending messages. I personally like to think of it as something kin to cross dimensional thinking. Besides speaking to each other the Hero pages are used to explore the character's profile in general and for people to follow specific characters. Writers can even just make characters to interact on the Hero pages without needing a written fictional world. So please come follow Woden on his journeys.

Woden's Hero page

A public campaign page is for rpg campaigns that want some info to be public. Think of it as a reader's version of watching those video RPG videos. You can follow a campaign if you like or click on the various characters in a campaign to follow specific characters or even click on the world the campaign in set in to follow the world setting as it develops. Please join me as I play to see what happens to Woden the Traveler.

Woden's Travels public campaign page

If you want to watch me live, when I can be, Please feel free to follow my twitch channel.

My Twitch


r/Ironsworn • • Aug 23 '24

Inspiration A Baker's Dozen of Noble Families - Azukail Games | People | DriveThruRPG.com

Thumbnail
legacy.drivethrurpg.com
1 Upvotes

r/Ironsworn • • Oct 10 '25

¿Alguien conoce una versión en español del S.R.D. de Ironsworn?

1 Upvotes

Encontré una hace 1 año pero lo volví a buscar y no encontré nada, además era de una versión antigua sin el mapa de Ironsworn, por favor, quiero jugarlo con 2 amigos que no saben inglés