Ipsy often has brands Iāve never even heard of, so when I got the NEOGEN DERMALOGY Hyal Glow Rose Essence, I wasnāt sure what Iād think of it. When I opened the box, it reminded me of my former obsession: the Pat McGrath Rose 001 Essence. I used to loooove this product like 5 years ago and was my first milky toner before milky toners were EVERYWHERE. I started using the Neogen Essence about two weeks ago and I looooove it. I had to go run a quick ingredients comparison between that and the PMG and itās laughable how much better this Neogen Essence is. Especially when itās currently $5 for the mega drop and the PMG is $80+ if I remember correctly. I did find the Neogen on Amazon for $18 each. Iāll be stocking up on this during the mega drop. If anyone else has tried this, what did you think???
The comparison is below if youāre interested!
While both formulas focus on rose-infused hydration and barrier support, NEOGEN DERMALOGY Hyal Glow Rose Essence uses a 74% Damask rose water base packed with multi-weight hyaluronic acids and niacinamide, whereas Pat McGrath Labs Divine Skin: Rose 001 The Essence relies on a water-and-oil biphase formula rich in sweet almond oil, macadamia seed oil, and ceramides.
Side-by-Side Ingredient Comparison
Feature
NEOGEN Hyal Glow Rose Essence
Pat McGrath Divine Skin: Rose 001 The Essence
Primary Base
74% Rosa Damascena Flower Water, Glycerin, Cetyl Ethylhexanoate
Water (Aqua), Prunus Amygdalus Dulcis (Sweet Almond) Oil, Glycerin
Formula Type
Single-phase milky essence
Shake-to-mix biphase emulsion
Rose Actives
Damask Rose Water (74%), Damask Rose Extract, Damask Rose Flower Oil
Damask Rose Flower Water, Rosa Centifolia Flower Extract
Key Hydrators
8 types of Hyaluronic Acid, Glycerin, Squalane, Panthenol
Glycerin, Squalane, Panthenol, Trehalose
Barrier & Oils
Ceramide NP, Cholesterol, Jojoba, Sunflower, Sea Buckthorn Oils
Sweet Almond Oil, Macadamia Seed Oil, Sea Buckthorn Oil, Ceramide NP, Phytosphingosine
Brightening & Anti-Aging
Niacinamide, Adenosine, Retinyl Palmitate, Rice Ferment Filtrate
Tocopherol (Vitamin E)
Fragrance & Colorants
Added Fragrance, Citronellol, Alpha-Isomethyl Ionone, Rose Flower Oil (naturally pink)
Added Fragrance (Parfum), Hexyl Cinnamal, Red 33 (CI 17200)
Ingredient Count
Extensive (over 70 ingredients including dozens of botanical extracts)
Minimalist (27 ingredients total)
Shared Key Ingredients
Both products share a solid core of barrier-strengthening and soothing ingredients. [1, 2]
Hydrators and Soothers. Both formulas include Glycerin, Panthenol (Vitamin B5), and Allantoin to attract water and calm irritation.
Barrier Lipids. Both contain Ceramide NP, Squalane, and Hydrogenated Lecithin to reinforce the skin barrier and prevent moisture loss.
Antioxidants. Both feature Sea Buckthorn Oil (Hippophae Rhamnoides Oil) and Tocopherol (Vitamin E) to protect skin against environmental stressors. [1, 2, 3, 4]
Major Differences
Botanical Complexity vs. Streamlined Oils. The NEOGEN Hyal Glow Rose Essence features an intricate K-beauty formula loaded with over 40 plant, fruit, and ferment extracts like Centella Asiatica, Sake, Ginger, and Propolis. The Pat McGrath Rose 001 Essence keeps its ingredient list under 30 items, focusing heavily on emollient plant oils like sweet almond and macadamia seed oil to create a plush lipid layer. [1, 2]
Active Skin-Tone Ingredients. NEOGEN includes Niacinamide high up on its list for brightening and pore care, alongside Adenosine and Retinyl Palmitate for anti-aging. Pat McGrath omits niacinamide and retinoids entirely, focusing purely on moisture, glow, and lipid replenishment. [1, 2, 3, 4]
Hyaluronic Acid Focus. NEOGEN utilizes a complex of 8 different molecular weights of hyaluronic acid to draw water into multiple layers of the skin. Pat McGrath contains zero hyaluronic acid, relying instead on glycerin, trehalose, and plant oils for hydration. [1, 2, 3]
Sensitivity Considerations. Both essences contain added fragrance and natural fragrance allergens (Citronellol in NEOGEN; Hexyl Cinnamal in Pat McGrath). However, NEOGEN's long list of botanical extracts and essential oils increases the number of potential triggers for highly reactive skin, whereas Pat McGrath uses synthetic Red 33 dye to achieve its pink hue. [1, 2]