r/InsuranceAgent • • Aug 03 '26

P&C Insurance When They Call Right At 8:30

I dislike it immensely.

Have I been at my desk for more than ten minutes already? Yes.

Have I already deleted all the junk and non-important emails? Yes.

But still don’t call literally right when we open. My body might be ready to do business but my soul is not.

95 Upvotes

68 comments sorted by

77

u/Objective_Earth_2610 Aug 03 '26

This, and all the calls that come in past 4 pm on Friday.

2

u/Affectionate_Emu335 Aug 03 '26

Yes!!!! 🙌🏻

31

u/SluttyKitchen Aug 03 '26

Our office closes at 3pm on Fridays. We (husband and I are independent agency owners) think that anyone who wants to talk insurance after 3pm on a Friday has something wrong with them and we don't want them as clients. Not one complaint after doing this for five years!

33

u/howtoreadspaghetti Aug 03 '26

Clients that call in after 430 PM either have some USDA certified bullshit or they're big new business (just my experience)

10

u/Modest-Meece Aug 03 '26

I once had office hours 8-4pm. Client called at 4:45 and left a message. Called again 5 minutes later and left a message. Then sent an email after 5pm stating “I need an agent who’s actually there and answers”.

Next email was a notice they BORd their policies….

Mind you my email signature and voicemail greeting stated my office hours.

8

u/KiniShakenBake Aug 03 '26

Well, I do love it when the trash takes itself out.

If my clients are that dismissive of the fact that I have office hours and availability that allow me to be 100% present for most of the other hours that they are likely to need me, and I also have staff that answer the phone to take care of things the rest of the time, then I don't need or want them in my book.

Period.

My time away makes my time present possible and effective. Without one, you cannot have the other.

I also send email at 11pm, but don't get to the office until 10am. I find that about an hour of good, concentrated responding at some point before I go to bed but after most folks have, so the 6am folks who went to bed shortly after I got off work can have the information they needed when their day starts is a tremendously effective way to both use my best hours of the day and also get a lot knocked out in what is asynchronous communication but gets mistaken for synchronous during work hours.

When it stays asynchronous, I can get a lot more off my plate at once that doesn't need to eat the whole day on back and forth and unscheduled phone calls.

6

u/Modest-Meece Aug 03 '26

I mean I keep my hours strict. I am not available outside of office hours. Almost nothing is that pressing. Payments don’t need me and I encourage clients to pay carriers directly.

I’m independent so the contract and payments between clients and carriers not me.

Further I’m not claims. I can advise and help file but that’s not necessary. So even then if they have to file a major claim, they need to contact the carrier anyways. I’m an extra step in that process that doesn’t need to be there.

2

u/KiniShakenBake Aug 04 '26

Then it sounds like the trash took itself out.

I am also Indy now. I was captive for a long time and my hours were still mine to set, but things were ... Different.

This is the epitome of independent and everything I do is 100% mine.

1

u/beccam12399 Aug 04 '26

we close at 4 on fridays love my office for this. We still do have those ppl that call at 3:45 friday “hey im closing on a house tmr need POI for mortgage 🙃” lol

1

u/ShortSponge225 Agent/Broker Aug 04 '26

my favorites are the ones who just closed on a cash deal home, desperate for insurance before the weekend. And then they cancel 2 months later when they 'found a better deal". ughh

22

u/[deleted] Aug 03 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

33

u/T-Revolution Aug 03 '26

Length? "uh....I dunno, maybe 31? Hey MARY, what's the length of the RV? Sorry, maybe it's 28. Oh and I want this cheap as possible."

1

u/ShortSponge225 Agent/Broker Aug 04 '26

How is it that no one knows the details of boats and trailers?

I've had people say "uhhh, the registration says it's a BT model." "Sir, that means the state recognizes that it is in fact, a BOAT. I need to know, what KIND OF BOAT YOU JUST DROPPED $30K ON!!!"

11

u/Rider-on Aug 03 '26

"Yep!! Going up the lake for the long 3 day weekend. I knew I had to call before you left for the weekend to get it covered. What are you doing for the holiday?"

So many times this has happened...

2

u/Megad13 Aug 04 '26

I literally thought this was just an Australian thing but seems to be a western world behaviour

22

u/Realistic_Brush_6047 Aug 03 '26

clock strikes 8:30AM

“WHy iS mY pREMiuM HiGheR?!” 🤡

20

u/Affectionate_Emu335 Aug 03 '26

I’m 83 years old and never had an accident!!

17

u/MiscBlackKnight Aug 03 '26

9 am open crew 💪

6

u/Affectionate_Emu335 Aug 03 '26

I pray the winds of fate do not blow any phone calls your way within the first minute of your Monday! 🤞🏻

18

u/WMINWMO Aug 03 '26

Eh. I tell all my clients that I am available M-F from 9AM to 5PM. If they call at 8:59 and it stops ringing before 9, they can call later. If they call at 5:00:01 they can call back tomorrow. I also have an hour lunch at noon, but I'm a bit more flexible with that depending on the situation.

4

u/Affectionate_Emu335 Aug 03 '26

I only get a half hour lunch now and I really miss having an hour! I bumped my lunch back to 2:00 and now the days seem to go by much faster for me

1

u/rachalh86 Aug 03 '26

I have been on a 30 min lunch for about a year and its rough

2

u/Affectionate_Emu335 Aug 03 '26

Agreed! I just went to half hour from an hour at the beginning of the year and changed the time a couple months after that. It was so annoying having to stop what I was in the middle of to only be gone for 30 minutes. Having it later makes me feel like I get more work done and then there’s only two hours left when I get back, so it feels like the day goes by quicker. They don’t seem to care when I take lunch as long as I take one - no skipping lunch to make up time here!

9

u/howtoreadspaghetti Aug 03 '26

We open at 8 AM and there are people that want 8:15 AM calls.

5

u/Affectionate_Emu335 Aug 03 '26

That is terrible 😭😭😭

5

u/howtoreadspaghetti Aug 03 '26

It's always to remarket accounts too. Never new business that actually pays me.

6

u/Affectionate_Emu335 Aug 03 '26

Remarkets are crazy right now, right? Hardly any time for marketing when you’re just trying to make sure you’re not bleeding out what you already have. The market seems to finally have softened some, but it’s still crazy out here with roof guidelines and mandatory wind deductibles. I’m in PA and they’re relatively new here. I have two carriers right now with mandatory minimum wind deductibles. One is a nonstandard and one is a regional, so hopefully it takes a bit to hit the national, standard markets

6

u/howtoreadspaghetti Aug 03 '26

I'm of the belief that retention is as important as sales, if not more so at times. It's about what you keep. If your sales team is constantly stressed about having to produce against worsening retention numbers then they won't do their best work. Stress eats away focus and productivity. And I can't blame anybody for wanting the best prices possible. But some of these remarket requests are ridiculous.

7

u/[deleted] Aug 03 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/howtoreadspaghetti Aug 03 '26

I'll get people wanting the $1100 rate to go lower. I quickly tell people I have zero control over rates. People don't know how actuarial the data is. But they don't care and don't listen. They're not bad people. They're tired of spending money on something that they will not see as valuable. 

2

u/[deleted] Aug 03 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Affectionate_Emu335 Aug 03 '26

I saved someone money by moving their auto and home from one of our companies to another. Sent out the apps, crickets.

A week later they called and said their son told them to call State Farm, who had a much lower premium than the premium I had just gotten them.

Did I tell her I’ve had three different State Farm customers contact me for quotes? Nope. Just sent the LPRs and silently seethed for a while. People freaking suck

1

u/Smedum Aug 04 '26

I’ve lost a few accounts to State Farm this year from them doing some shady things.

Lost a home/auto because State Farm rated it with no pool and they do have a pool.

Lost another home to State Farm because their replacement cost estimator came in at half of mine and so their price was much better because it was half the coverage; client didn’t care, they just wanted the lowest price.

Lost a lessors risk because State Farm rated with no claims when in fact the insured had a $50k claim last year.

2

u/Affectionate_Emu335 Aug 04 '26

Snake Farm at its best! I hear this so many time about them. That and they don’t add youthfuls until after they get into an accident because “permissive use”. 🤦🏻‍♀️ I’ve always wondered if they charged back premium for that, but no Snake Farm agent wants to be the one to admit they did it so it will just go down as one of the great mysteries of my time

1

u/howtoreadspaghetti Aug 04 '26

The agent doesn't get away with it. UW catches this stuff and the policy issues differently than quoted. It's best to just do the honest work and if the rate is lower with everything accounted for then I can respect the client leaving. Nobody has a bottomless insurance budget. 

1

u/Smedum Aug 04 '26

Even if they don’t get away with it, you still lose the client and then the client is pissed because their policy issued different than quoted and it gives everyone in the industry a bad name.

I agree, if they have a better rate with all rating factors accounted for then yes, I understand the client switching.

7

u/HamiltonSt25 Agent/Broker Aug 03 '26

We open at 8:30 but I won’t answer until close to 9 so I can get caught up from the weekend or previous day. If it’s something urgent I’m aware of, then I’ll answer at 8:30

6

u/Affectionate_Emu335 Aug 03 '26

I find that the customers who call right when we open are also the customers who will call over and over and over again. Like, obviously they’re my only customer so I should be available immediately at all times 🙄

5

u/HamiltonSt25 Agent/Broker Aug 03 '26

Well yeah? Just get them what they need jeez. Don’t you know how much they pay? I bet they’re your largest client. /s

I love those. “Sir, you’re not even close to the top 20 of largest. Chill out. “

4

u/Decent-Marsupial-986 Aug 03 '26

I received a request for something at 4:40 on Friday and by 8:10 I received a follow up. It’s been 20 business minutes. 

1

u/Affectionate_Emu335 Aug 03 '26

It was probably something complicated too, wasn’t it? 😒

2

u/Decent-Marsupial-986 Aug 03 '26

A revised COI asking to be named an Additional Insured. It was on the Liability Cert but not the property cert. 

3

u/Blue-Sky-Ahead Aug 03 '26

One man agency owner here. I have the world's greatest intentions, but rarely make it in before 9:30. I start answering the phone at 9:00. Maybe it's the insurance gods, but there's rarely anything that can't wait until 9:30. I'll have them text or email me the important details if needed, and am extremely responsive once I'm in office. My clients are pretty much coached to text and email, so maybe 10% of my book is over the phone, and that's typically elderly clients.

I'll add that I'm still only 18 months old, so the book isn't that difficult to keep up with yet.

3

u/Affectionate_Emu335 Aug 03 '26

I’ve had customers tell me I’m still saved as the old agents name in their phone. With the phone number that hasn’t been printed on any documents or on the website in almost ten years! Why do they still have that number? 😭 I’m slowly getting more and more people trained to email me, but never again am I giving my personal cell number to a customer so they can call - TWICE! - back to back at 2am and wake me up. Nope nope nope.

3

u/Blue-Sky-Ahead Aug 03 '26

Same. I've had a business cell for several years now.

4

u/hooops55 Aug 03 '26

Just don’t answer 😂

9

u/Affectionate_Emu335 Aug 03 '26

I find the customers who call right at open are also the customers who call over and over and over again. The older they are, the more true this is. The dread I feel sometimes when I see the caller ID….

4

u/howtoreadspaghetti Aug 04 '26

We have clients who will email and then 5 minutes later will call us as if we have zero else to do. It's ridiculous. 

6

u/Insurancenerd85 Aug 03 '26

I received a claim call at 10:30 at night this weekend. I ignored it…

4

u/Odd-Restaurant870 Aug 03 '26

7am start time (because employer is dumb) and I wholeheartedly agree.

2

u/Geaux Aug 03 '26

So, then don't answer when they call, and call them back later.

0

u/txmarineveteran Aug 03 '26

As a long time agent, I get it. Especially the character who calls with the add-on 15 mins to close. However, this is what you signed up for. You are in the customer service business. You have a good problem to betch about. Just think if you were unemployed. You'd wish for this "problem."

If you had a restaurant or business, open hours are open hours. The guy/gal/whatever that walks in at 08:01 should be treated the very same as the person that walks in before close. Those folks are the reason you are in business. Be grateful and find other things to betch about.

3

u/Affectionate_Emu335 Aug 03 '26

20 year agent here. I can still complain. You can still scroll on.

-1

u/txmarineveteran Aug 04 '26

😂😂😂 Sound like the type of insurance agent we all don't need

1

u/Affectionate_Emu335 Aug 04 '26

Still can’t scroll on 😂😂😂 No venting allowed around you, got it!

1

u/FrontPorchIns Aug 04 '26

I'm a life agent evening's, weekends are bread and butter

1

u/Numerous-Shirt-9307 Aug 15 '26

the "body might be ready but my soul is not" part is painfully accurate. i've seen people use things like Nextphone to take the first wave of calls, and honestly i can understand the appeal. not because answering the phone is hard, just because sometimes you need five minutes to become a person before talking to customers.

1

u/Ok-Pay-6927 Aug 03 '26

I like money and commissions. Call me whenever.

0

u/Colonel460 Aug 04 '26

Amazing ! No wonder I was able to take business from you . I gave people service they wanted and you don’t want to talk to them on the phone , don’t want to help with a claim , don’t want them to pay you directly, don’t want to help even during all the stated office hours . Renewals & referrals verses you lose business because you don’t want to service it .Hooefully your doctor , CPA, financial advisor take more interest in you than it appears you have in your clients .

1

u/Affectionate_Emu335 Aug 04 '26

You’re welcome!! ☺️

-5

u/Moneymatriarch Aug 03 '26

Well i was in an accident yesterday. So yea. Im calling as soon as you open. Get up earlier so you’re ready to work at work time..?

3

u/Affectionate_Emu335 Aug 03 '26

Did you not read the part where I’d already been at my desk for more than ten minutes?

Claim? No problem! You may hear a click and some silence, but that’s just me getting you through the phone tree to a real live person in the claims department at your insurance company to take that claim info from you.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 03 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Affectionate_Emu335 Aug 03 '26

Smiling on the outside but crying on the inside is what I would be 😭

0

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '26

[deleted]

1

u/InsuranceAgent-ModTeam Sep 03 '26

Be a good reflection of the industry and remain professional.