This morning the three major headlines of Italian newspaper are:
- airplane grounding in USA for IT failures
- Microsoft down
- Cybersecurity challenge after a fake as a 3.5$ coin email caused evacuation of thousand of schools on Wed and hundreds on Thu
Common denominator? People does not understand IT.
For the email threat, I understand that on Wed precautions might be king. But on Thu we should have reacted properly.
Basic understanding of email, a few checks and eventually some escalation to the proper people (we have Cybersecurity agency here! Don't mess with us bad guys!) could have driven the reasoning, at least the second time.
9yo children were already planning mail bombing the teacher to avoid school.. this is what I witnessed myself... Clever guys, much more clever than their school directors and police forces... :)
For the two other global events, there's an unavoidable series of questions:
Was it malicious? (hacking, insider action as retaliation, etc.)
Was it related to AI taking the wheel?
Was it handled correctly?
Was it avoidable?
I'm pretty sure 1 is no in both global cases. Too much clumsyness is probably more probable than malicious action.
About 2, I think it wasn't AI itself, but maybe blindly following AI suggestions without checking
3 is bright as the sun, NO. Was handled very badly from communication viewpoint and prepareness was almost zero if AI wasn't working at least for Microsoft case.
For the airport case, the timing was completely wrong for sure. There were already cases of redundancy failures, and it should have accounted for. The spreading is unavoidable as soon as you have updated blindly too much stuff, also bad practice.
I have no tech details, but I'm pretty sure such a vital system should have a digital twin at least, or if you're tight on budget, a simulated environment into a vendor's lab.
What I know for sure it's that the contractor will not be cheap for such a big infrastructure, and he can probably easily afford at least a simulated lab... if the contract forces it.. otherwise, more money for the stakeholder, easy peasy.
About 4.. Yes, all of this was probably avoidable. The school threat for the second occourence for sure.
The airport stuff was bad planning and careless execution at 99.99999% confidence.
Microsoft laid out tons of people with thousand of years of cumulated experience and relied on AI for ... whatever was missing after people was laid out. IT was outsourcing since its early days, from US to East Europe, then Asia, now AI.
The difference is that if technology break people might be impacted, but human mind stays. AI is just the opposite, you expect AI to fix things that hinder AI itself. The very old fashion of circular dependencies.
That's why I say we're killing IT. We expect a car to fly or a pan to cook by itself.
Overcomplicating things and models, just to laid off people and get a bonus on the CEO level.
Then things break and everybody blame everything but the very real cause, that is bad planning and careleness at all level, starting from the top of the pyramid.
I heard mom saying that cybersecurity should have stopped a fake email before a reasoning human took a bad decision.
I just told her that even we the most advanced protections, stupidity wins anyway.
I think we just had 3 proofs in a row (two globals and one Italy related).
My 2 cents.