r/InfiniteWinter • • Feb 17 '16

Is IJ among the whitest novels ever?

0 Upvotes

I’ve read to P220 or so – no spoilers here. In IJ it seems as if everyone can be assumed to be white, unless adjectified otherwise. Lots of references to black men and/or ‘street’ speech as identifier. I can conceive of ways in which this might be thought of as a strategy that makes this book, at least in part, the wakeup call it is.


r/InfiniteWinter • • Mar 14 '16

Eschaton Inspired Entertainment

Thumbnail
youtube.com
4 Upvotes

r/InfiniteWinter • • Feb 20 '16

Consider the Pothead

Thumbnail
broadly.vice.com
0 Upvotes

r/InfiniteWinter • • Jan 31 '16

I have so much book lust

1 Upvotes

Super pumped to re-read IJ!


r/InfiniteWinter • • Jan 29 '16

Infinite Winter group on Goodreads

Thumbnail
goodreads.com
2 Upvotes

r/InfiniteWinter • • Feb 10 '16

Just finished the book for the first time. Here are my thoughts

2 Upvotes

I just finished this novel after about five months of reading. I have to say, my reaction is pretty lukewarm - and while I'm proud to have read the book and felt like I mostly understood it, I can't say I'd recommend it.

Infinite Jest contains some truly stunning imagery and beautiful sentences. Additionally, I appreciated the creativity involved - a pseudo science fiction world not too exaggerated from reality, in which North America is governed by commercialization, superficiality, and mass media. Memorable scenes abound: Eschaton, the marijuana addict waiting for his delivery, the Quebec terrorists, and the final 50 or so pages.

But the book isn't just "difficult". It is, undoubtedly, one of the most self-indulgent texts I've ever read. While some of the footnotes provide clarity and insight, they're often intrusive and irrelevant (how many simply read "sic" or excessively detail a drug?). Plus, all those obscure words? It really comes across as Wallace jerking himself off.

The satire can be sharp and amusing, but nothing is laugh-out-loud hilarious - only the absurdity of the work's length comes close. (Not to mention the book often felt like the worst kind of joke - on the reader's behalf.) Lead character Hal is whiny, pretentious, and largely unlikable. With so many characters throughout the sprawling text, only Don Gately inspires sympathy and thought.

One reason I had such a big problem with the book was the insane number of run-on sentences. I understand that Wallace was trying to replicate how the mind goes through so many thoughts so quickly. But there's a reason why most sentences are fairly short, and that's because when you insert a ridiculous amount of information into a single line, the author's point becomes opaque and incomprehensible. This book was far, far too long in so many ways, and in desperate need of an editor.

I honestly found The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy funnier, more insightful into the human condition, and simply more enjoyable.

That said, I really wanted to love this book. I spent a lot of time trying to "get" it and stuck with it until the end. But I don't see the appeal, and would appreciate other people's thoughts. It just seems to me for someone who was such a "humanist", Wallace wrote an exceptionally elitist and unnecessarily difficult book.


r/InfiniteWinter • • Mar 10 '16

Question: I'm about to abandon IJ after about 130 pages for specific reasons (below). Am I making a mistake, based on my differences with the book?

6 Upvotes

I'm a pretty comfortable reader of long-and-wordy books-- I've read all of the Pynchon canon (except Against the day, which I abandoned for roughly the same reasons as I'm about to abandon IJ) along with Beckett etc.

But here's my problem with IJ: I find a lot of the dialogue to be just brutal. The characters often don't speak as individuals. When the Quebec characters do--coming from a half-French quebecker--the accent is EGREGIOUSLY wrong. They Quebec characters sound to me like someone from Latvia would imagine a Francophone Quebecker speaking English. They make constant linguistic errors that don't correlate with French and therefore don't sound like Francophones speaking English. That's one problem for me.

The other problem has really become an issue with CTA. There are long sections in which scenes are populated by dozens of characters who all speak in nearly identical voices and registers, usually on the subject of tennis in a way to show off to readers precisely how much we do not have a grasp of what it's like to be intimately connected to that sport. There is very, very little to distinguish these characters from one another for me and I can't understand why there are so many of them in these conversations if they're all going to sound the same. Yes, some of them don't like certain of the others, but I find it nearly impossible to care when the narrator tells us this rather than making some distinctly unlikeable or likeable--or just distinct at all.

I gave DFW 130 pages because I love his non-fiction, and I find his writing generally to be kind and humane and tender, never callous or contemptuous. But what I didn't expect is how tedious this all has begun to seem. I cared about Hal but I'm caring less and less as I slog through these robotic conversations. It's hard for me to connect to the Quebec characters because it's like listening to an unconvincing Englishman try to sound like he's from way down south in Georgia, y'all--though that's the SAME language. Imagine an Englishman trying to MAKE UP southern slang with a twang.

It's possible that DFW did this on purpose, to bore the reader or create unbelievable francophones, but I'm just not that interested in being that bored or being constantly reminded that yes, this is a novel, yes, somebody wrote it, and they didn't do a good enough job making these characters seem human, either on purpose or accidentally.

I find the bits about addiction and mental illness very engaging, warm, and resonant, and bits about the Indandenza family life are generally about the same. But I'm about to drop it because it seems the signal to noise ratio is all off.

Is this a flaw of the early part of the book? Does it get better? Do you remember having this problem but reading on and finding it went away? Or would you say if I don't like it for these reasons by this point, I probably won't like the rest?

TL;DR: There is no TL;DR because I'm talking about Infinite Jest.


r/InfiniteWinter • • Jan 31 '16

A Broad in Denver: On Reading Infinite Jest with a Group

Thumbnail
abroadindenver.blogspot.com
1 Upvotes

r/InfiniteWinter • • Feb 07 '16

Copy-editing error or on-purpose mistake?

1 Upvotes

So if someone who had the 20th anniversary edition, or even any edition besides Nook could check this: In the last paragraph before the part with Orin at the football game (or if it's more helpful, the section is the one including fn24, the filmography) the word "elegaic" is used. This is of course not the correct spelling and I was wondering if it's just a typo, or if it's showing the narrator's lack of knowledge.

Thanks!


r/InfiniteWinter • • Feb 19 '16

Anyone buying the Anniversary Edition?

1 Upvotes

For any 2+ time readers of IJ, is anyone buying the anniversary edition? When I bought my paperback copy a couple years ago, I had no idea how much wear and tear I was going to put it through. Both covers have fallen off and the pages look like they're about to head the same way. At the same time, all my notes/scribbles/highlights make my copy of IJ really special to me.

Anyone in the same boat?


r/InfiniteWinter • • Feb 15 '16

Reading Strategies???

2 Upvotes

So right now my course load in school is pretty rough. Many times i'll read before a long study session, but recently I'm getting so wrapped up in school that my mind is too exhausted for reading before or after. Consequently, I'm finding myself a little behind in the readings. Does anybody have advice on times or strategies that work for them best, during a busy schedule?? P.s.- I'm not having trouble understanding the story, just in finding productive times to read (without falling behind on my studies).


r/InfiniteWinter • • Feb 01 '16

Could this be a long-lost chapter from IJ?

Thumbnail
washingtonpost.com
2 Upvotes

r/InfiniteWinter • • Mar 14 '16

Will there be a second video roundtable at the 50 percent mark (Friday)?

2 Upvotes

See topic title.

The previous iteration of the video roundtable was to discuss the first quarter of the book, so I'm curious as to if this will be carried out as further quarter-markers or was it just a coincidental tie-in for the first video?

Either way, I thought that video chat was very positive and beneficial to this reading of IJ. Helping put faces and voices to all the guides also influenced my reading of their posts on the InfWin website.


r/InfiniteWinter • • Mar 25 '16

more skullduggery, i.e., Shakespeare this time

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
2 Upvotes

r/InfiniteWinter • • Mar 03 '16

IJ as Sierpinski Gasket

2 Upvotes

More than a few times i've read that Wallace modeled the structure of IJ after a Sierpinski Gasket.

Can anybody shed light on how the two relate?


r/InfiniteWinter • • Sep 17 '19

I thought this was obviously the point of Infinite Jest but maybe i'm an idiot?

2 Upvotes

Hi. I've barely ever visited reddit before and certainly never posted.

So my apologies if this is totally obvious to everyone already; my quick (I forced myself to spend 20 seconds before coming to you with this) internet search did not return the answer I thought obvious.

When I got to the end of Infinite Jest (I read it about 10 years ago and I'm not one of those people with great memories; I remember it but couldn't tell you Hal's dad's dog's name), it was obvious to me that the whole point of the book from DFW's perspective, was to create The Entertainment in real life, or, something close to it. I mean, the surface-level read of the book is that its a book without a point (not here to debate that), but that it's entertaining in a way that you can't put it down. HE MADE THE ENTERTAINMENT! HE GOT ME! (i said to myself).

Is this obvious to everyone? Do people talk about this? If so, can you send me to the link where it's discussed, because I can't find it.

I mean, just think about it. The very existence of this page means that the jest went beyond the 981 pages originally published. I would argue that the jest was infinite.

Thanks!


r/InfiniteWinter • • Jan 26 '16

**BUYS INFINITE JEST USEES BOOK TO PROP UP IPAD FOR INFINITE NETFLIXING**

Thumbnail
taylor-solomon.squarespace.com
10 Upvotes

r/InfiniteWinter • • Apr 18 '16

WEEK TWELVE Discussion Thread: Pages 833-907 [Spoiler-Free]

3 Upvotes

Welcome to the week twelve Infinite Jest discussion thread. We invite you to share your questions and reflections on pages 833-907 -- or if you're reading the digital version, up to location 20767 -- below.

Reminder: This is a spoiler-free thread. Please avoid referencing characters and plot points that happen after page 907 / location 20767 in the book. We have a separate thread for those who want to talk spoilers.

Looking for last week's spoiler-free thread? Go here.


r/InfiniteWinter • • Feb 11 '16

[SPOILERS] Hal eating mould in the opening

3 Upvotes

I'll keep it short, but does this actually happen? I don't have the text handy to help me reference, but it starts off with 'It's funny the things you don't remember', and says how Orin tells Hal that he ate the mould, and the story is all from Orin's perspective. Not only this, but DFW makes it clear that Orin has retold this story with different facts on several occasions (like what The Moms says when she discover's Hal's eaten the mould). This is all on top of the fact that Orin is very strongly painted as pathological liar throughout the book.

Is there anything else in the novel that reliably confirms Hal ate the mold/DMZ?

This, obviously, has huge implications for answering the 'What happens to Hal?' (Withdrawal vs Mold vs DMZ vs DMZ-as-mold vs Trauma etc. etc.) theories


r/InfiniteWinter • • Feb 18 '16

Anecdote

4 Upvotes

Today. Hospital. High dependency ward.

Nurse somewhere behind me: "Hey! You're not allowed dispose of that medication through the standard drain anymore. There was a memo about rats eating it where it comes out and growing huge and aggressive. I'm not joking. Don't do that anymore. We aren't equipped to fight super rats."


r/InfiniteWinter • • Feb 12 '16

A Few Thoughts on Switching to Kindle for Infinite Jest

Thumbnail
abroadindenver.blogspot.com
4 Upvotes

r/InfiniteWinter • • Apr 12 '16

WEEK ELEVEN Discussion Thread: Pages 759-833 [SPOILERS]

5 Upvotes

Welcome to the week eleven Infinite Jest discussion thread. We invite you to share your questions and reflections on pages 759-833 -- or if you're reading the digital version, up to location 19021 -- below.

Reminder: This is the spoilers thread. Discussions may reference other characters and plot points from the novel. If you prefer a spoiler-free discussion, check out the other stickied discussion thread.

Looking for last week's spoiler thread? Go here.


r/InfiniteWinter • • May 01 '16

Is there a radio show in real life that is like the one by Madame Psychosis?

5 Upvotes

like intellectual, queer, bizarre and eccentric ?


r/InfiniteWinter • • Mar 03 '16

Win a Copy of the 20th Anniversary Edition

5 Upvotes

Hi all --

Little, Brown was gracious enough to give us a few copies of the 20th anniversary edition of Infinite Jest. For your chance to win a copy, snap a picture of your current copy of Infinite Jest out in the world and either:

  • Tweet it on Twitter using the hashtag #InfWin

  • Post it on our Infinite Winter Facebook page.

The deadline to get your photo to us is Wednesday, March 9. The guides will pick their five favorite photos from the bunch as winners.


r/InfiniteWinter • • Mar 15 '16

Keep Coming (cross post from InfWin.org)

5 Upvotes

This is my second read and it was great for the first 300, but really grabbed me by the throat at about 400 and it won’t let me go.

I have been cogitating for weeks on aspects of the experience of time in the book (to many to count, but, e.g., Ken Erdedy waiting for the woman who said she’d come; the lengthy description of Poor Tony in withdrawal: “Time began to pass with sharp edges. Its passage in the dark or dim-lit stall was like time being carried by a procession of ants. . . .Time spread him and entered him roughly . . . “; the crawl of time in accumulating minutes of sobriety; the dead airtime stipulated my Madame P, the time the kids spend running ‘puker’ cardio exercises at ETA. It occurred to me that the fractured nature of the narrative and the intensely vivid descriptions of each scene, complete with smells and textures and a superabundance of words and endnotes that sometimes make the reading time seem to drag, all of these things tend to force the mind (at least my mind) to constantly “be in the moment” as I’m reading the text. Dialogs seems intentionally structured to require full concentration to follow who’s speaking. The subsidized time scale largely isolates the story from outside chronological references that might distract with orienting fixed points. There is simply no way to look forward and anticipate the story arc, and DFW rips you back and forth in time, between locations and people, and even in the physical book itself. I think this enforced focus on each present moment, the chapter right in front of ones eyes, might be at least part of his intent behind the fractured storytelling. The book is a 3-4 month exercise in enforced mindfulness. But why?

And but so an epiphany that hit me during this week’s reading relates to the AA meetings and specifically to the fact that it’s made so clear that you don’t need to believe in your higher power, and you don’t need to know how or why the steps work, you just have to stay focused on staying clean/sober for the present moment/hour/day, keep working the program, keep Coming Back to meetings, and the program will do its work for you.

This book made me view the world differently when I first read it in 2009. I have literally said to people that I don’t know why or how it had this effect, it just did, and the effect it had was in part to make me focus much more on the present moments and, per Marathe and Steeply’s convo, to pay attention to things I give myself away to. My shorthand for letting go and just going along for the ride as the book as it unfolds has been to “trust the author” and just keep reading. ‘Resonating’ doesn’t even begin to capture the effect the book has had on me.

So, as I mulled these things over the week’s reading, I realized that it’s just important to Keep Coming to the book and to work the chapters, and things will happen even if one doesn’t believe in the author and one doesn’t particularly like the story (although I love the story). The tales of the Quebecois and ETA and Ennet House may just be the hooks to to keep one Coming Back.

Then along comes the chapter (approx. 466) about Gately’s early days in AA and learning to work the program, and it’s recalled that Gately is advised by the Crocodiles to just stop worrying about HOW the program works, but to just “give himself a break and relax and for once shut up and just follow the instructions on the side of the f***ing box”, with further advice to put his shoes under his bed at night to help him remember to get on his knees before his higher power, whatever that is to him. So, even though he’s not a believer and he thinks it makes no sense, he puts his shoes under the bed and duly kneels AM and PM as a part of his commitment to working all the steps of the program.

So this is when I realized that for me, IJ is the program, not a Substance*, and the catchy fragments of story, such as they are, are really just shoes under the bed, helping me work the steps, keeping me Coming Back.

*Although, of course, anything can be a Spider.

*after I wrote this I saw that readers had raised this idea of IJ as the Program in the Week 6 discussion! I guess it just took me a while to 'get it'!