Greetings r/InfiniteStratos community. This is /u/Igorthemii speaking. I've came to talk about the treatment of Ichika Orimura from his supposedly "abusive" harem. The reason why i put abusive in quote marks? It's because the Harem is not abusive towards Ichika Orimura.
Why? I'll explain it how.
How does Ichika handle the so-called "abuse"?
Ichika is often subjected to attacks from his I.S. Harem, including those that would be incredibly lethal to him. How does he survive all of those? It's easy, it's slapstick. The following quotes will explain what is Slapstick.
"Slapstick is a kind of comedy based on practical jokes, collisions, clumsiness and embarrassing events. An example of slapstick is comedy performed by the television characters called the Three Stooges where people get poked in the eye or pies in the face." -YourDictionary
"Slapstick is a style of humor involving exaggerated physical activity that exceeds the boundaries of normal physical comedy. Slapstick may involve both intentional violence and violence by mishap, often resulting from inept use of props such as saws and ladders." -Wikipedia
"These anime feature humor based on physical comedy. Characters might be comedically clumsy, or hit each other in comical, over the top ways." -Anime-planet
"Okay, but that doesn't explain how the harem is not abusive towards Ichika!"
As mentioned previously, due to the attacks being played for comedy and slapstick, Ichika is left uninjuried or his injuries are rendered non-existent.
The one bombshell that was Season 1's Episode 11 "Get Ready" However, has Ichika be critically injuried by the unmanned I.S. Silver Gospel to protect Houki. As opposed of Ichika being left unscatched like prior incidents, he is actually injuried in a manner that can leave him to die. This is because the situation was being played out seriously and not for comedy. If Ichika thought Houki was really abusive, he would have left her open to be attacked by Silver Gospel, but he still protects her and selflessly gets hurt to protect Houki. This would result into the I.S. Harem into becoming demoralized and horrorified when they see that Ichika was left in a critical state, with Houki suffering it the worst, blaming herself for it and even wanting to give up piloting an I.S.
Also, if the harem was really abusive, Ichika would have started to avoid them VERY early on, possibly as early as episode 3. Not to mention the other girls in the academy would attempt to protect Ichika from his supposedly "abusive" harem.
Ichika's treatement is nothing special compared to other harem protagonists.
Let's take TO LOVE-RU's Rito Yuuki as an example. The due is subject to being hurt or screwed over due to TO LOVE-RU's slapstick comedy. In fact, he arguably gets it even worse than Ichika does. Dude gets dragged around, slapped, knocked around, and hit by a bunch of stuff (Usually Lala's malfunctioning machines), yet the TO LOVE-RU Fandom doesn't act like Rito is a holy saint while demonizing Lala Satalin Deviluke and the other girls, unlike the Infinite Stratos fandom.
Horrorifying Fantasies from the Infinite Stratos Fandom
Good fucking lord, the I.S. Fandom sure loves making the girls suffer so much because of their so-called "abuse" towards Ichika. Be it using characters of other media to attack the I.S. Harem (Fun fact - Steven Universe (one of the characters used in that fic) has tried to see good and forgived(?) the diamonds from his show, so it feels kinda out of character to him to try to attack the I.S. Harem for supposedly being "abusive" when it's not even the case) or commisioning entire sets [of] (https://www.deviantart.com/hikariangelove/art/commission-out-of-deviantart-853657518) pictures of the harem being spanked due to their supposed "abuse" of Ichika Orimura. Even this subreddit is spreading the "revenge fantasies" aganist the harem as well.
This is an overreaction and this needs to stop.
Ichika is not the saint the fandom makes him to be.
Ichika, according to the light novels, is explicitly faking his denseness to "protect himself" around the harem, but then attempts to kiss Houki in the ending of Season 1's Episode 12 "Your name is....", but then pretends it never happened in the rest of the series. This is incredibly manipluative of Ichika to do so, yet he is never held accountable by the fandom. Only the harem is.
In Conclusion
Ichika Orimura is not a saint, he has his share of wrongdoings, and his I.S. Harem is not abusive at all. If you're going to hold his harem accountable for slapstick, then do me a favor and do the same thing to other harems from other media. If not, stop acting like the I.S. Harem is abusive.