r/IndoEuropean • • Feb 08 '24

How did the Sintashta cross the Jagged rough glaciated Hindu Kush mountains on Horse into india?

0 Upvotes

Aryan migration theories show them crossing the Hindu Kush Mountains. This seems a little unrealistic. Other theory I think the Sintashta would have migrated around Afghan plateou then into Kandahar and followed river into Jalalabad and then to Punjab lowland, just like the Turkic invaders. Problem is there is no archeological evidance found in this region aside from India and Central Asia. Anti Aryan migration and out of india theorists highlight these loopholes and such as other lack of evidance related to potteries. so What do you think happened actually back then?


r/IndoEuropean • • Nov 12 '21

Tocharian kid, Xinjiang China

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/IndoEuropean • • Dec 25 '21

Discussion If PIEs are resurrected now, which modern culture would they find more similar to theirs?

1 Upvotes

Explain your reasoning in comments. By culture I mean language, extant traditions and national festivals.

(PIE = Proto Indo-European)

298 votes, Jan 01 '22
33 Slavics/Russians/Ukranians
66 Iranians/Afghanis/Tajiks/Ossetians/Pamirs
35 Indians/Pakistanis
42 Turkish/CA Turkics/Mongolians/Yakuts
22 Germanics/Italics/Hellenics/Celts
100 See Result

r/IndoEuropean • • Feb 17 '22

Yamnaya cannot be Proto-Indo-European origin

1 Upvotes

Why everyone say Yamnaya is origin of PIE when most linguist think Anatolian separated centuries before Yamnaya, before wagon even exist on steppe? David Anthony say this in his book yet nobody pay attention to this? Geneticists look for Yamnaya dna in Turkey to find hittites and find nothing, why is this seen as surprise?

Proto-Indo-European homeland is Sredny Stog during late neolithic. No evidence is there that Corded Ware is child of Yamnaya rather than brother.


r/IndoEuropean • • Jun 26 '25

Discussion After researching on Indian R1a, Steppe hypothesis doesn't add up. Feel free to change my mind : )

0 Upvotes

If R1a-Y3 came into Indian subcontinent via a mass male migration/invasion from the Steppe (as the Steppe hypothesis claims) then why doesn’t the genetic data show it?

A real influx of Y3-bearing males would’ve resulted in a star-like branching pattern directly under R1a-Y3 in India, as multiple unrelated lineages begin mutating independently.

But that’s not what we see. The actual star-like expansion happens much further downstream, under R1a-L657, specifically below M605 → Y28 and Y9. That kind of structure points to a small number of founders already in Indian subcontinent, not a wide-scale migration from outside.

And then there’s the complete lack of R-L657 in the steppe. Out of all the steppe samples so far, L657 isn't found even though the TMRCA of R-L657 predates Sintashta and other steppe cultures.

The lone R1a-Y3 sample from the Steppe is from a culture (Nepluyevsky) where the dominant male line at that site isn’t R1a at all. The patriarchs were of haplogroup Q, which is tied to local, pre-Steppe populations (Kumsay EBA). The people of this site were patrilocal and patrilineal suggesting the Y3 and Q individuals were related through their paternal lineage. The people in this site were Uralic speaking.

TL;DR: So the question is simple: If Y3 shows no sign of expanding in the Steppe, if its only known Steppe context was non-Indo-European, and if the real expansion happens within Indian subcontinent—what’s actually left of the Steppe argument here? What solid basis remains for claiming R1a-L657 lineages in India came from a Steppe migration?


r/IndoEuropean • • May 23 '24

Origin of Indo-European not as clear as thought before.

0 Upvotes

r/IndoEuropean • • May 21 '26

History IE Language group origins from Southern Caucuses/Armenian Highlands/Northern Iran

Post image
14 Upvotes

We know now the Yamnaya culture was not the originator of the language but inherited and eventually spread the language and with far reaching distance due to their use of wheeled technology. Yamnaya culture contained a large admixture from the Caucasian HG DNA combined with Eastern HG DNA which makes sense given the origins of the IE languages started from Southern Caucuses and they would have inherited the language through their Southern Caucasian ancestors.

Early on in the development of the language it spread west in Anatolia and would eventually form the earliest attested IE language, Hittite. And we know from genetic research Hittites did not have Yamnaya DNA. Another migration reached the Pontic-Caspian and Forest Steppe around 7000 years ago, and from there subsequent migrations spread into parts of Europe around 5000 years ago.

Caucasian Hunter Gatherer DNA is also directly related to Iranian Zagrosian Hunterer Gatherer DNA so indirectly Europeans through Yamnaya do have ancestry related to Iran through CHG DNA.

Through the Yamnaya migrations eastward the development of a new culture called the Sintashta culture (Proto-Proto-Iranic ancestors) would come to fruition and eventually through migrations south into Central Asia come FULL CIRCLE back into Iran as a more modern variety of the ancient language that was originally spoken in its northern lands.


r/IndoEuropean • • Apr 07 '23

The Impact of Vedic Upanishads on Human Society: Insights into Spirituality, Philosophy, and Morality

Thumbnail self.hindubooks
0 Upvotes

r/IndoEuropean • • Apr 28 '22

Archaeogenetics Sintashta were over 50% blond haired and blue eyed. Frequency so high that only Scandinavians have higher numbers

Thumbnail
eurogenes.blogspot.com
0 Upvotes

r/IndoEuropean • • Apr 21 '21

Today's Rama Navami birthday of Lord Rama

0 Upvotes

Warm greetings to my Aryan Brethrens on the auspicious occasion of the birth of Lord Rama. Happy Ram Navami!


r/IndoEuropean • • Jul 31 '22

Why weren’t the AASI and Iran_N able to colonize the Himalayas?

0 Upvotes

r/IndoEuropean • • Nov 20 '24

Could the prevalence of the Vedic Culture be attributed to female steppe migrations?

0 Upvotes

Hey guys, I'm just a casual enthusiast in IE ancestry so don't take my word for anything.

Could it be possible Steppe women (MLBA) somehow interacted with the AASI rich men (possibly IVC) that gave birth to the Vedic culture we know today? I know steppe mediated migration of women are not dominant, but maybe ignited the spark of its existence?

From what I know, ancient women spent more time nurturing children and managing households, which means they are more likely to imbibe their cultures and habits down to their children. Then, the men started appearing too, through word of mouth and eventually gave birth to the the Early Vedic civilization (Early Steppe Migrations were female mediated).

I remember how Basque survived despite most of the speakers being of IE lineage, and there's a popular opinion that women passed down the culture and traits to their children. That's where I got the inspiration from.

What do you guys think? Do you think Sintashta women were the early pall bearers of Vedic Civilisation?


r/IndoEuropean • • May 04 '25

Linguistics Germanic Picts In Pre-Norse Scotland?

Thumbnail
hamburgercountryblues.substack.com
0 Upvotes

Excerpt

In Roman Times, the word “Pictish” meant anyone that lived beyond the Roman frontier, especially anywhere north of Roman controlled Britain. By the early middle ages, the word “Pict” transformed from meaning any Briton who wasn’t Romanized to a discrete ethnic identity. The framed Anglo Saxon Bede described the Picts as coming from a region known as Scythia, modern Eastern Europe or the Baltic.

The Welsh born Celtic scholar John Rhy concluded that Pictish was a “pre-Aryan” language, a speculation that might have influenced the fictional “Picts” of the Texian Robert E Howard.

Many have tried to interpret the ogham inscriptions left by these mysterious people through Celtic Language lines, though each translator seems to have his or hers own “translation”. What is lacking in these attempted translations is a European language other than Celtic. Remember, the Picts lived on the Western edges of Scotland, short sea travels away from Scandinavia and Germania. i have study a significant amount of Old Germanic languages, such as Old Saxon, Old High German, and Old Norse.


r/IndoEuropean • • Jun 01 '22

Stop saying blonde hair comes from ANE, it doesn't!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/IndoEuropean • • Sep 17 '22

Indo-European migrations Who are Indians? | Aryan Invasion Theory Explained

Thumbnail
m.youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/IndoEuropean • • Jul 01 '25

Are people in Americas and some parts of Africa where theşr mother tongue is an Indo European language considered IndoEuropean?

1 Upvotes

Thank you


r/IndoEuropean • • May 28 '22

History Would human civilization be less developed without Indo-European migrations? How different would be the history of Europe without them?

6 Upvotes

Personally, i feel like, Proto-Indo-Europeans were an unique culture, because there was no chariot technology at that time, which was so developed. We would have waited much more time for such culture to appear and conquer agricultural societies. Without them, technological development would have been slower and civilizations would have been less connected.

Without IEs, Middle Eastern history would probably remain the same, but European history would drastically change, since the Romans and Greeks wouldn’t exist in the way we know them in Antique period. We would probably see more Oriental version of European history.

What is your opinion about that?


r/IndoEuropean • • Jul 20 '23

Linguistics "I lie here on the ground twānk-ing"

2 Upvotes

Douglas Q. Adams gives several Tocharian B derivations that do not seem likely. For TB twānk- ‘I lie here on the ground twānk-ing the feathers of the kotstses, belonging to no one’, ‘twānk-ing ... he goes towards the tapovana-grove’, for TA ‘he was living in good fortune twānk-ing clothes of a penitent’, he can not decide among ‘wear / put on / take off’. Since there are very few IE words beginning with *twa- and exactly one that is *twak- (Skt. tvák- ‘(cow)hide’, G. sákos ‘[oxhide] shield’, phere-ssakḗs ‘shield-bearing’ ), it seems clear *twak-n- is a verb with nasal affix ‘wear/bear/carry’, with all connotations seen in other IE. There is no ev. that *twink-a:- or the like is the source; why go to such lengths to find a roundabout source when an exact match with the same meaning is available?

As to the identity of the kotstse bird, Adams offers ‘owl?’, for no reason I can see. Since *w-w seems to exist in cognates of Skt. kapóta-, MP kabōd ‘grey-blue / pigeon’, *kapavta- > *kavavta- > *kavamta-la- > *kawantara > Ps. kauntar ‘pigeon’, the same in *kewewte > *kewetye > *kewetsye > kotstse ‘dove’. For ‘wearing the feathers of doves’, maybe a phrase for ‘in love’, not literal. For Iranian *a > *e, see *aćva- ‘horse’ > TB etswe ‘mule’. For *w-w > *w-y, see many IE.

http://ieed.ullet.net/tochB.html

In https://www.reddit.com/r/IndoEuropean/comments/1528n9x/the_daily_compromise_1_turu%E1%B9%A3ka_kushans/ a new mod ordered me to change my style. “If you want to publish original research in this subreddit, make sure that the formatting is up to the standard we find in proper academic journals. Use the standard formatting for glosses, different writing systems and phonetic and phonological transcriptions, and make sure you have proper sources for everything you write.”, “Our subreddit is used by laypeople so make sure that your text is well-written and structured.” This is not a journal. This is actually MORE than some professionals do: in https://www.academia.edu/41561748 he does not use Greek (so laypeople can understand); in https://www.academia.edu she CHOOSES to use all caps for inscriptions in the Latin alphabet, italics for others. I will not be forced to do more than professionals put out online. If no one else has been told to change in this manner, I am being targeted for my ideas.


r/IndoEuropean • • Oct 24 '21

Misinformation

0 Upvotes

https://www.gnxp.com/WordPress/2021/05/18/all-the-yamnaya-horizon-zone-people-looked-the-same/

Something that needs to be nipped in the bud is how Razib Khan is manipulating nonstop, when you see 50 percent derived at herc2 do you assume that means the entire population is of intermediate eye color? So why does Khan get away with claiming the allele frequency of a set of 200 samples is the skin color per individual of a ancient population, bell beaker being 65-70 percent derived at slca5a2 means 65-70 percent have light skin not that they are darker than modern European, and the study itself even makes that point, number two we see here that sintashta is also listed and Razib Khan himself claimed sintashta is 93 derived at slca5a2 and 42 percent derived at herc2 out of 100 samples, HOW IS THAT SWARTHY like his first sintashta post claimed, modern France is only 89 percent derived at slca5a2 and Ukraine 92 just like sintashta, that the other sneaky trick Khan uses, he will take outliers like the Baltic and compare frequency, then say see darker than average European, well the Baltic is not a average European now is it, that like using one of the outliers of sintashta to claim what they look like and that they all Q not R1A


r/IndoEuropean • • Oct 14 '24

How long did it take for the proto Indo-Europeans (7,000 BCE) to evolve into the advanced megacities of Ancient Rome and Athens? (Circa 750 BCE).

0 Upvotes

And where is the evidence to show the progresión from horses, wheels and carts, to mega cities and advanced technologies of the ancient Roman’s?

Do we have chronological evidence for the technological advancement of these peoples going from horse drawn carts to then building advanced mega-cities?


r/IndoEuropean • • Jan 30 '21

Discussion Aryan Invasion/Migration Theory of India a Fact or Myth?

0 Upvotes

Hello, Indian here. I wanted to ask if the Aryan Invasion/Migration theory is a fact or myth?

Personally, I don't believe in an Invasion of some sort, it feels extremely Racist that there was some superior race and they gave us everything we know of.

Migration seems more sensible and possible in my opinion.

I am open to facts though, no matter how bitter.


r/IndoEuropean • • Aug 01 '23

A new study brings a fresh perspective on the Anatolian origin of the Indo-European languages

Thumbnail
anatolianarchaeology.net
0 Upvotes

r/IndoEuropean • • Jun 12 '26

Did the true Celts come from Lusitania?

1 Upvotes

Continuous human settlement in Lusitania dates back hundreds of thousands of years from the Pleistocene to the Neolithic Period of 12000 BC, to the Atlantic Bronze Age of 1300 BC and to modern times.

Herodotus, since antiquity described as the father of history, in his 430 BC book Histories, placed the Celts as living in the extreme west of Europe beyond the Straights of Gibraltar by the Atlantic Ocean in what is modern day Portugal – known in ancient times as Lusitania.

“The Celts live beyond the Pillars of Hercules, and border the Cynesians who dwell at the extreme west of Europe.” Herodotus, The Histories, book 2, chapter 33

In the 150 A.D Geographia, an ancient atlas written by Claudius Ptolemy, when describing several cities of the Celts in Lusitania, Claudius states:

“The Celts inhabit that region which from these cities lies toward the interior; their cities in Lusitania are Laccobriga, Caepiana, Braetoleum, Mirobriga, Arcobriga, Meribriga, Catraleucus and Arandis.”Claudius Ptolemy, Geographia, book 2, chapter 4

The first century geographer Pomponius Mela, describes the Lusitanian Atlantic coastline – modern day Portugal and Galicia, as the “Celtic coast”.Pomponius Mela, De situ orbis, book 3, chapter 47

The kingship of Celtic peoples from the southern Lusitania, modern day Portugal to the north in Galicia is evidenced by:

“Last of all come the Artabrians, who live in the neighbourhood of the cape called Nerium, which is the end of both the western and the northern side of Iberia. But the country round about the cape itself is inhabited by Celtic people, kinsmen of those on the Anas” Strabo, Geographia, book 3, chapter 3.5

Other Celt peoples of Lusitania were the Cantabarians, Carpetanians, Vettonians, Vaccaeans, Artabrians, Asturians, Cynesians, Cynetes, Conii, Turduli, Turdetanians, Tartessians and Galicians.

Strabo states:

“Lusitania is the greatest of the Iberian nations, and is the nation against which the Romans waged war for the longest times.”Strabo, Geographia, book 3, chapter 3.2

The Celtiberians were another Celt people bordering on the east of the Lusitanian people. Pliny the Elder believed the ancestral home of the Celtiberians was in the territory of the Celts in the south west of Lusitania and Strabo viewed the Celtiberians as a branch of the Celts from Lusitania.

“It is evident that the Celts have sprung from the Celtiberians, and have come from Lusitania, from their religious rites, their language, and the names of their towns”.Pliny the Elder, Natural History, Volume1, Book 3, chapter 3

“The Celts who have added to their name that of the Hiberi came also. To these men death in battle is glorious; and they consider it a crime to burn the body of such a warrior; for they believe that the soul goes up to the gods in heaven, if the body is devoured on the field by the hungry vulture. Rich Galicia sent her people, men who have knowledge concerning the entrails of beasts, the flight of birds, and the lightnings of heaven; they delight, at one time, to chant the rude songs of their native tongue, at another to stamp the ground in the dance and clash their noisy shields in time to the music…These men, and the Lusitanians drawn forth from their distant forests, were led by the young Viriathus.”Silius Italicus, Punica, Book 3, chapters 330-356

Are the Celts Lusitanians?


r/IndoEuropean • • Feb 10 '24

Saraswati and indo aryan migration

0 Upvotes

Saraswati is a highly eulogised river in rg veda, geologist HC VERMA has said that the river dried up around 2000 bce, he associated it with the now dried ghaggar-hakra Channel (now a seasonal river), as the rg veda in 10.75.5 says Saraswati flow in between yamuna and satluj, how can we say that the Aryans came to India around 1500


r/IndoEuropean • • Jul 23 '26

Archaeogenetics Were the people in the area where the Sintashta migrated to Caucasoid already, or were the Sintashta people there the first European-like people there? Do we know anything about the people before the Sintashta got there?

0 Upvotes

Were the people in the area where the Sintashta migrated to Caucasoid already, or were the Sintashta people there the first European-like people there? Do we know anything about the people before the Sintashta got there?

Also, I know that Uralic people were just to the north of them, and that around 2500 BC there was a draught that impacted adversely the PII there but not the Uralics.

So can we surmise that the pre-Sintashta people there were proto-Uralics with Eastern Asian phenotypes?