I think it is an imperative for me to write my opinion as a someone who has only recently started questioning indian media narrative on Kashmir. And I also think that each violence leave humanity at a peril, be it Hamas blowing Israel homes or Israel ethnically cleansing Gaza. It is not only to say that scale of brutalization has no place. It is important. History is also important. Regarding Gaza, western response is frustrating. They have diluted their image as a beacon of peace and balance. Irreversibly, I guess.
But each history has a context and I think it is important to see them to explain and respond to events around us.
Why Kashmir is not Gaza
I think it is pretty simple. If you see Israel and Gaza map from 1949 and of today, you will clearly see a shrinking Gazan map and Israel perpetual expansion of its border. That's horrific. That's how an expansionist state look like. Regarding claim that tourism serves a tool to Indian Gov to claim Kashmir parts ( let's assume it is so) but Israel has made permanent settlements on areas occupied. At least till now Indian gov has not done such a thing. You don't see Indians from other states occupying Kashmir local places. If it was done persistently, past 75 years would show it. In 71 war India Indian forces captured about 15,101 square kilometers of Pakistani territory on the western front (in regions like Sindh, Punjab, and Kashmir areas, while Pakistan captured 500 square km to be correct) and have given up for whatever reason it is not something an expansionist state can do.
So this leave out that India as an expansionist power in this perspective. Has India colonized Kashmir? It's another question altogether. Not less important.
Now role of Pakistan in Kashmir problem has been magnificent. The pakistani tears about 'kashmiris' has a crocodile tone in it.
A state which has been unstable, has done horrific war crimes in Bangladesh, ruled by a brutal military and an elite which devour its own people, has been put in prohibited lists by international community and has equally terrorized Afghanistan.
I think such a country( not its people) can have no moral and human sentiment about other state affairs. And Kashmir is a tool by its military rulers to distract common pakistani. Its role in polarizing kashmiris can't be forgotten, neither can be diminished by whatever indian gov has done later. Neither it can denied that ( relatively peaceful periods prior to 1989) that kashmir problem is an extension of what is a Pakistan problem.
Gazan is fighting an expansionist power. Not Kashmiris. Kashmir needs peace, support but it doesn't need to become- as it would be clear to any kashmiri- a tool for any state.
And while whatever India gov has done in Kashmir since 90s is horrific, I would think twice before accepting any narrative from a state which has continuously waged war against its own people, recent example would be overthrowing Imran Khan and jailing and killing unknown but large number of people. PS - if questioning Pakistan's role in Kashmir is called non leftist I guess I don't want to be called leftist. Better a person who understands everything. It is coming from someone who has read the capital, numerous other Marxist like Marcuse, Lenin, and Chomsky. Again resistance doesn't mean describing what one state says and accepts another even if two states are the same on everything. But questioning both states! Is Pakistan beyond questioning? A country with horrific history? Laugh for the city - Being leftist mean avoiding the very racist, fundamentalist two nation theory! According to some commentors here. If it is not what is racism then ? And now more - A hindu king didnt take interest of its own people before joining india! Really ? So a hindu king could not give assent to join India if majority was muslims ? Is it not support of two nation theory ? That muslims population should go with pakistan! Was nizam of Hyderbad not cynical to join India even if their majority population was Hindu ?