r/IndianLeft • • May 10 '25

Indian leftists have condemned military action against Pakistan. Is it because you believe Pahalgam was a false flag operation by the warmongering Indian army, or is it because you believe one must not kill anyone even if the enemy sponsors terror attacks?

0 Upvotes

Do you believe a war is only justified in India if it's between oppressed Muslims, SC/ST people, and the poor, against oppressor UC Hindus and the bourgeoisie?


r/IndianLeft • • 8d ago

🎭 Meme/Comic The clown

Post image
10 Upvotes

Interested in seeing if one of them come here and comments like BJP IT cell mosquitos


r/IndianLeft • • Jul 24 '26

Caste What are yalls stance on reservation as a solution for equality/caste discrimination

0 Upvotes

As the title states, I have been talking with a friend and thinking about this. We have been going back and forth and he says reservation are needed for caste abolishment but i cant understand his view.

I think reservation can bring pseudo equality in social class between the castes but it isnt a solution for caste abolishment. Am I in the wrong here? And what are yalls view on this


r/IndianLeft • • Jan 18 '23

Discussion/Opinion its crazy how the new report of 1% rich people of india having 40% of wealth don't mention about upper caste hindus.

0 Upvotes

Way too obvious it's them, yet no mentioning of this. Such an apolitical report.


r/IndianLeft • • 27d ago

I mean....

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft • • Dec 29 '25

🎭 Meme/Comic How are we feeling about this tier list?

Post image
9 Upvotes

Personally, I believe Malcolm X, Angela Davis and George Habash should be a bit higher. Also, how is Gorbachev flawed but based? Didn't he bring neoliberalisation into the government?

Also, no Indian/ South Asian communist figures like Bhagat Singh makes me sad :(


r/IndianLeft • • Feb 23 '26

💬 Discussion Critique of feminism

0 Upvotes

Scientific socialism is not merely a set of opinions about what is fair or just. It is a totalizing analysis of society and it tries to explain how the whole system works, not just one part of it.Historical Materialism is it's Foundational Ontology.It possesses a theoretical core (historical materialism) that provides the conceptual apparatus to analyze all social formations, including gender, race, and empire, as moments within a totalizing system.

Because this theoretical core exists all variants of left are disciplined by it. They must define themselves in relation to this core. They argue about methods and strategies But they cant ignore the central questions of What is class? How does the capital function? Now compare this to feminism. When you ask What is feminism? you dont get one answer. You get a list like liberal feminism, radical feminism, Marxist feminism etc.This is because feminism is grounded in identity and structure of oppression.Which is gud for diagnosing a problem but the moment you move from discription to explantion and solution of the problem you will encounter difficulties.It has no foundational core of its own about the nature of social reality.As a result it has to borrow from other philosophies and it becomes a site of theoritical borrowing.For example Liberal feminism borrows from liberalism.Radivcal feminism makes patriarchy as the ultimate oppression but they essentially make bio essentialist claims.Because feminism has no theoretical core of its own, it cannot discipline these different currents.This dependency produces proliferation without paradigm.There are many feminisms but no single unifying framework.A liberal feminist Marxist feminist and a radical feminist will have different goals different solutions.

Because feminism lacks a foundational ontology, it becomes structurally vulnerable to capture by hegemonic forces

Today, states like Israel and the United States actively promote their records on lgbt and women's rights to manufacture consent for their wars, occupations, and settler-colonial projects. This is pinkwashing—the direct descendant of the old colonial "civilizing mission" of the Europeans. In its most politically coherent and institutionally powerful form the form backed by state power, corporate media, and global capital feminism has been captured by imperialism. It provides the moral language for Western hegemony while remaining structurally silent about the capitalist logic that drives it.


r/IndianLeft • • Aug 07 '25

💬 Discussion Why are Indians online so insecure?

3 Upvotes

Why are Indians so damn insecure?

This isn't me under pretext of a sepoy as you keyboard warriors like to say.

I've noticed especially online over many years how overly victimizing and insecure Indians tend to act. Every second day you've got keyboard warriors pledging about how the rest of the world "hates" us and whatnot.

Curry smell jokes, Indians cry, scammer jokes, Indians cry, drinking cowpiss jokes? Indians bawl. I mean sure, not like the US has been the laughing stock for the rest of the world with constant jabs at capitalism, their love for guns, their deplorable tax and education policy and then finally the "Americans are morons" meme. The British get constantly berated for a colonial history and having bad dental hygiene. The french smell bad. The Germans did bad things 80 years ago. Japanese did even worse things and they are obsessed with child pornography. Literally any semi great power is criticised by the rest of the world, India is no different but unlike the rest, India gets very upset when someone says legalizing marital rape is bad.

Subs like city porn are basically full of Indian propaganda showing how glorious Mumbai looks at night but God forbid someone says that behind the Twin Towers is the largest slum in the world, the entire Desi army shows up to mald.

Are there people racist towards India? Fucking yes there are, are there people racist towards any nationality in the world? Also yes. Just go ask a German kid what it felt growing up in the US? It won't be pretty I can tell you. I mean there's a reason why half the IT companies there are run by Indians, there's a reason why the former British Prime Minister was of Indian origin, there's a reason why the "Indian guy on yt meme exists".

No one fucking hates India, people hate self victimizing insecure losers because that's what half the Indians I see online act as. I saw one thread where Indians were celebrating a fire in LA because some Californian was saying he'd have illegal immigrants from Mexico than legal immigrants from India. The response? "Hahaha hahaha you all are burning alive thats great!!"

Revolting. Is it because do Indians genuinely believe that India is perfect and has no flaws or is it just anger?


r/IndianLeft • • Aug 30 '19

I hate 99% things of BJP still will keep voting for him

0 Upvotes

Hi. I am hardcore libertarian. I believe for free speech. I believe free speech trumps hate speech. I believe in freedom of expression. I am not offended if someone burns Indian flag and same time am patriotic. I am Hindu but I don’t get triggered if someone calls ramayan fiction. I don’t care about ram temple. I am agaisnt socialism. I believe in free market anarchism. am anarcho-capitalist. I am bitcoin maximalist.
I have problem with communist ideology. being leftist and being communist is different. It is sad that in India both are seen as synonyms. I hate modi’s/bjp economics policies. I myself got BA with economics. I wished they bring back raghuraman rajan and don’t interfere in his Job. modi will win 2024 with bigger mandate because of socialism. he is giving free stuff like farmers pension, giving money for building homes. now he promised water connection so I believe he will win great in 2024. his policies are time bomb. it may burst post 2024 or may be not.

I am only supporting modi because I have problem with ISLAM. Radical Islam. not muslims. but wahabis ideology. Islam is against Feminism. their are lot of bad ideas in Hadis. congress or Left doesn’t acknowledge terrorists as a terrorist. it labels everyone islamophobes who talks about genuine problem related to radical islam. left and congress are crying unemployment but that nothing to do with modi or bjp. and being impartial I see data not accurate. jobs like amazon, swiggy, zomato, etc not counted. and unemployment is bound to rise because of technology and AI. Opposition or LEFT don’t talk about population control. most of time congress ruled India with protectionist ideology which I don’t agree. I don’t see any left or opposition respecting liberal values. I see them as hypocrites. Bjp, rss, vhp might be biased towards minority or muslims because of hatred and that is a bad thing but what Left is offering??? communist ideology? I am better of with right wing. my blood boils when I see people like sadhvi, yogi, etc but on the other hand have more dislike for people like mamta, lalu, mayavati. if left is equal to communist than I better have hindu nationalist change my mind.


r/IndianLeft • • Apr 27 '25

Why Kashmir is not Gaza

36 Upvotes

I think it is an imperative for me to write my opinion as a someone who has only recently started questioning indian media narrative on Kashmir. And I also think that each violence leave humanity at a peril, be it Hamas blowing Israel homes or Israel ethnically cleansing Gaza. It is not only to say that scale of brutalization has no place. It is important. History is also important. Regarding Gaza, western response is frustrating. They have diluted their image as a beacon of peace and balance. Irreversibly, I guess.
But each history has a context and I think it is important to see them to explain and respond to events around us.

Why Kashmir is not Gaza

I think it is pretty simple. If you see Israel and Gaza map from 1949 and of today, you will clearly see a shrinking Gazan map and Israel perpetual expansion of its border. That's horrific. That's how an expansionist state look like. Regarding claim that tourism serves a tool to Indian Gov to claim Kashmir parts ( let's assume it is so) but Israel has made permanent settlements on areas occupied. At least till now Indian gov has not done such a thing. You don't see Indians from other states occupying Kashmir local places. If it was done persistently, past 75 years would show it. In 71 war India Indian forces captured about 15,101 square kilometers of Pakistani territory on the western front (in regions like Sindh, Punjab, and Kashmir areas, while Pakistan captured 500 square km to be correct) and have given up for whatever reason it is not something an expansionist state can do.

So this leave out that India as an expansionist power in this perspective. Has India colonized Kashmir? It's another question altogether. Not less important.
Now role of Pakistan in Kashmir problem has been magnificent. The pakistani tears about 'kashmiris' has a crocodile tone in it.

A state which has been unstable, has done horrific war crimes in Bangladesh, ruled by a brutal military and an elite which devour its own people, has been put in prohibited lists by international community and has equally terrorized Afghanistan.

I think such a country( not its people) can have no moral and human sentiment about other state affairs. And Kashmir is a tool by its military rulers to distract common pakistani. Its role in polarizing kashmiris can't be forgotten, neither can be diminished by whatever indian gov has done later. Neither it can denied that ( relatively peaceful periods prior to 1989) that kashmir problem is an extension of what is a Pakistan problem.

Gazan is fighting an expansionist power. Not Kashmiris. Kashmir needs peace, support but it doesn't need to become- as it would be clear to any kashmiri- a tool for any state.

And while whatever India gov has done in Kashmir since 90s is horrific, I would think twice before accepting any narrative from a state which has continuously waged war against its own people, recent example would be overthrowing Imran Khan and jailing and killing unknown but large number of people. PS - if questioning Pakistan's role in Kashmir is called non leftist I guess I don't want to be called leftist. Better a person who understands everything. It is coming from someone who has read the capital, numerous other Marxist like Marcuse, Lenin, and Chomsky. Again resistance doesn't mean describing what one state says and accepts another even if two states are the same on everything. But questioning both states! Is Pakistan beyond questioning? A country with horrific history? Laugh for the city - Being leftist mean avoiding the very racist, fundamentalist two nation theory! According to some commentors here. If it is not what is racism then ? And now more - A hindu king didnt take interest of its own people before joining india! Really ? So a hindu king could not give assent to join India if majority was muslims ? Is it not support of two nation theory ? That muslims population should go with pakistan! Was nizam of Hyderbad not cynical to join India even if their majority population was Hindu ?


r/IndianLeft • • Apr 04 '26

If not BJP then who ?

0 Upvotes

So i am a confused person, i don't know much about politics, my family supports BJP so that's why i been doing the same, but i know BJP is not the good government, and i started to explore a bit and it only took a bit to hate modi. But the argument i hear the most is if not BJP then who? there is no better opposition. So what should i say when i'm questioned about my stand on this topic, Like if you had the option, to choose a party which party would you choose and why, i want strong arguments to back it up.

Also please be nice, i am very new to all of this.


r/IndianLeft • • Feb 28 '22

What Russia Wants From Its Invasion of Ukraine—and Why Zelensky Is Evil

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft • • Feb 15 '26

What's your thoughts on this.

Post image
0 Upvotes

Ruchi Tiwari, journalist from ANI has been assaulted by Pro UGC protesters. She claimed that they said they will make her walk naked parade. Many right wingers who were silent when thousands of Dalits assaulted are now posting against pro UGC protesters and left wingers. But as a human we have to stand with justice. If what Ruchika said about they said they will make her walk naked parade is true we have to support her.


r/IndianLeft • • Dec 13 '25

❓Questions What the heck is happening in UK? I see all these anti-Starmer things everywhere.

0 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft • • Jun 11 '21

Discussion Why do Indian leftists hate Hindus and embrace Islam?

0 Upvotes

People often accuse leftists of being Hinduphobic and pro-Islamist.


r/IndianLeft • • Jun 11 '26

Does anyone else find caste reductionism far too common?

3 Upvotes

Caste reductionism is the idea being that every single social and economic problem in India is solely or mostly attributable to caste. It ignores and downplays neoliberal capitalism and class relations (productive relations).

It is an incorrect, idealist and incredibly misleading tendency.

For instance, the exploitation of domestic labourers (maids, household help, etc) is an issue of particular importance, and in a lot of online discourse about the situation of domestic labour, people reduce the entire issue to caste.

Not only is this problem not unique to India, it happens all over the Global South. Maids are common among the managerial class in the Philippines, Bangladesh, Pakistan, parts of Africa such as Kenya and Tanzania, and parts of South America, most notably Brazil, and in each of these countries, abuse and exploitation of domestic help is a serious problem, and none of these countries have caste.

On the broader issue of inequality, wealth inequality in India is certainly severe and worsening, but it is not uniquely severe among countries in the Global South. There are a number of countries, particularly in Southern Africa, Latin America and Southeast Asia with far higher levels of wealth inequality than India despite not having caste.

These contradictions and social evils do not require caste to be generated and reproduced, even if caste plays a role in reproducing them.


r/IndianLeft • • 24d ago

Theory I want to learn more about Anarcho-Communism. We don't discuss that often, right?

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Reference: Free Territory (Makhnovschina) in Ukraine (1918-1921).

⚠️ Warning: This ideology has direct clash with Soviet Communism. Since this entity was crushed and merged into the broader USSR. So while studying this is cool, it will have a leftist tension.

But I want to learn more about it, and discuss with you all. What do you think about it, and do you think it's viable for the betterment of the proletariat?

I don't see many book recommendations about it, so I wanna learn about it too.


r/IndianLeft • • Nov 08 '21

Ask What parties qualify as "Indian Left"?

0 Upvotes

Congress? TMC? CPI?


r/IndianLeft • • Sep 28 '14

Modi to meet Netanyahu| He has been in really good terms, almost like friends, with Shinzo Abe and Natanyahu; who I think are the morons of the highest order amongst world leaders

Thumbnail
thehindu.com
0 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft • • Nov 05 '25

Beginner questions What do y'all think of his remarks on the left ?

0 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft • • Oct 10 '24

Capitalism Ratan Tata

Thumbnail
reddit.com
11 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft • • Oct 07 '26

Falsifier Asking fascists to abandon and join their side is renegade behaviour, Neha Bora is anything but marxist.

38 Upvotes

Spirit of Salerno compromise, Straffreiheitsgesetz and Freikorps lives through words of Neha when she invites fascists that had their hands soaked in bloods of both working classes and minorities to the INDIA bloc popular front, by doing this she's doing commendable job to the bourgeoisie mechination who doesn't want structural changes but transfer of power to their own hands rendering everything as it is, including systematic oppression of minorities and proletariat oppression. Sure joining the liberal bloc will make them act like progresives for quite few moments but when another anti-incumbency wave arrives under the bourgeoisie electoral method due to contradictory nature of capitalist economy these hidden snakes will show it's true colour one day.

Imagine if tommorow Ajay Singh Bhisht joins INDIA bloc will this be historically progressive for working class movement? absolutely not, Will Bisht stop demolishing muslim ghettos overnight? Absolutely not. Bisht will continue to persecute minorities and working classes with blessings of both liberal front and as usual his corporate allies.

So far Neha Bora has been acting as pet of bourgeoisie pro-capitalist opposition front by advocating for the preservation of the electoralism that has been rigged and used for decades against working class mandate, until March 2023 when three panel committee for selection of process of Chief election commission was first introduced which included CJI, LOP and Prime Minister of India; which later got reformed by the ruling fascist replacing CJI with member of cabinet.

If we still partake in this system we are repeating same stalinist era blunder that stabbed steel in the back of revolutionary movements across the world including (Telangana movement) for becoming sheep infront of their supposed capitalist allies, and history has witnessed this did not end well for working class movement across the globe, betrayal after betrayal yet the left has not learnt anything from their mistakes.

At this point it's not even farce anymore but a clear coordinated move of pro-capitalist doppelgangers that has mastered gimmicks and tactics of revolutionary socialism program to lure enthusiasm of young radical minds to slowly indoctrinate them to become apologist for their exceptionalism that give breathing ground for reactionary elements.

Down with the falsifiers and counter-revolutionary doppelgangers dressed as communists !


r/IndianLeft • • Mar 29 '23

do dominant OBC castes prove that atheism/islam is the only solution

1 Upvotes

even after knowing about dravidian movement and self respect, many OBC castes of tamil nadu call themselves hindu kshatriyas and harass the dalits

is removal of surnames enough ? clearly that is not stopping these groups from forming caste alliances and gangs

clearly the high caste brahmins are giving them kshatriya status so as to give them false pride and fight the muslims


r/IndianLeft • • Aug 21 '26

Caste Mad respect for Delhi police

0 Upvotes