​
I've been thinking about this for a while and I genuinely want to know what other people think
Every year during Chhath Puja we see women waking up at 3–4 in the morning going to rivers or ponds in freezing temperatures standing in cold water and observing extremely strict fasts sometimes without even drinking water
And most of the time they're doing all this while praying for their children's health their family's prosperity and everyone's well being
I understand that it's a religious and cultural tradition I respect people's faith and I'm not saying women shouldn't be allowed to practise it That's not my point
But why is it predominantly women who are expected to go through all this
Why is a woman's devotion so often measured by how much she can sacrifice for her family Why is it so normalised that mothers have to fast and put their bodies through physical discomfort for their children's well being
Men can observe Chhath too so it's not like the rituals are exclusively for women But look at how society has traditionally distributed these responsibilities
And I find that worth questioning
There's a difference between choosing to do something out of faith and feeling obligated to do it because society expects you to A woman choosing to fast is her decision but a woman being judged for not fasting is an entirely different thing
Also why isn't the responsibility equally shared If a mother's fasting is considered important for her children's well being why isn't the father expected to do the same
I don't think worshipping the Sun or celebrating an ancient tradition is inherently patriarchal But I do think the way we assign these responsibilities to women reflects some deeply rooted patriarchal expectations
And honestly I think we need to stop romanticising women's suffering and calling every sacrifice beautiful just because it's done in the name of devotion
Maybe I'm missing some cultural or historical context here and I'm open to hearing different perspectives
But I genuinely want to understand why we've normalised this and whether anyone else questions it too