r/IndianCountry • • Mar 09 '23

LOCKED We don't say "Indian".

0 Upvotes

Is what my professor told me in my zoom class of Intro to Women's Studies

"No, you don't say 'Indian'" is how I would have replied if I was a different person. Instead, I just replied that I say Indian because that's what I hear Indians call themselves. I also said that a lot of Natives find the term 'Native American' to be stiff and awkward.

She then told me that I wasn't allowed saying it because I'm not Native. (For the record, she isn't either. She's Brazilian.) And she said that only Indians can call themselves Indians.

She at least redirected me to the term "indigenous" which I do use interchangeably with "Native" and "Indian". But I decided to take this discussion to actual Natives and get it from the horse's mouth, are non-Natives allowed to say "Indian"?

I mean, there is literally the American *Indian * Movement and the Pan- Indian Movement but the last thing I want to do is offend someone, so put this to rest for me, please.


r/IndianCountry • • May 02 '24

Discussion/Question Question about how reservations work?

0 Upvotes

I was just looking on google maps through some states like OK,WY,ND, and SD, and i saw a sizable amount of reservation and nation land. I am not well versed, how does this exactly work? How much authority does the US government have? Who makes up laws, taxes, police force?

I also saw a lot of chain franchises like Hilton’s and Starbucks, i did not know those would be in there. I am not from the US so apologies if its a bad question.


r/IndianCountry • • Oct 05 '23

Discussion/Question Would growing my own sage as a white person for personal use be considered appropriation?

23 Upvotes

I wasn't sure which tag to use so forgive me.

My fiance is native, though she is not part of any tribe since her family didn't have a way to trace their heritage. She is adamant about neither of us using white sage since I'm white/Latino and she's "not native enough" which is a touchy subject in itself. I was raised by someone who didn't really consider closed practices of other people and just did whatever she wanted. So sage was burnt in my house pretty regularly without considering how it was grown and who she was impacting by buying from non native individuals.

I want to use it again for my own spiritual practice and also as I really like the smell, but I don't want to appropriate Native American culture for something as vane as liking the smell of burning sage. I havent bought from any stores or especially Amazon, but last night I had the idea of growing it myself. I love plants and I figured that if I wasn't selling it and therefore not competing with any native person that might be selling it that it wouldn't be a problem. I also wouldn't call it smudging because i know thats a closed practice and I've never been taught. But my fiance still thinks that might be appropriating native culture. We can't ask her grandma because she has been whitewashed and has the some very white woman opinions and has said some racist things about native and Latino people so I try not to bring cultural dilemmas up to her. How should I go about it?

Would buying a seedling or seeds be wrong? I have a green thumb and have been looking for a new plant anyway but I don't want to be a part of the problem that white people created by using white sage and buying too much of it.


r/IndianCountry • • Oct 05 '22

Discussion/Question I have a question about the landback movement.

1 Upvotes

So we talked a lot about this movement in one of my classes yesterday (I’m a college student). I promise I’m coming here in good faith with an open mind and I’m not a troll. It seems like to me, that Native Americans want ownership of certain territories and to be able to have their own governments without interference from the federal government, which I support as long as no one gets hurt (I know very little about Native American governments).

But like a year ago, I think, there was this YouTuber (not a Native American) who was saying that if Native Americans want to deport everyone who’s not Indigenous, they should be able to do so. I’m against that. But I assume this isn’t what the movement stands for, right? No one in my class proclaimed support of this and I haven’t seen anybody else supporting that, including Native Americans.


r/IndianCountry • • Feb 15 '24

Discussion/Question Colonizing the Colonizers

0 Upvotes

I don't mean any disrespect by this, it was just a random thought I had one day and was curious. Natives have been scattered to the four winds in this country so it's hard to get a majority anywhere to push for policies to help natives. I'm assuming there really isn't any representation in the US government for native issues. So I was wondering has anyone thought of convincing some natives to move to a low population state, like say Wyoming which only has about 500k people in it, until natives outnumber whites and can at that point get elected to all state positions and effectively take over a state. It would still be a US state but natives would be the majority and could pass whatever policies they wanted to further help natives. I know it wouldn't help with past injustices however it would give natives more of a say in our dysfunctional government with representatives in the house and the senate.


r/IndianCountry • • Mar 23 '26

Media Thoughts on Sandman/Soundman from jojo's part 7?

Post image
0 Upvotes

he isnt a very complex character, his goal is noble but he does fit a bit too much into the "magic native american" trope. Then again, the reason for this is because he can keep up during a horse race on foot.


r/IndianCountry • • Sep 09 '26

Literature Book recommendations on Native American history before and during colonization

0 Upvotes

Hi all - I've been interested in this topic for some time and would love some book recommendations.

Ideally, it would cover the lifestyles of various tribes (customs, alliances, wars, etc), as well as their interactions, both good and bad, with incoming settlers, like treaties, wars and disagreements, all the way up to at least I'd say the end of the 19th century give or take, but I'm flexible.

I'm currently reading Pekka Hamalainen's Indigenous Continent - it's been interesting so far and I'm about 30% through it. I generally like it, but it feels a little academic and is starting to feel repetitive. It kinda just lists events but doesn't feel like it has much of a human element in it. It feels more informative than narrative, and a bit dry. I'll continue for now, but wondering if there are better recommendations.

I know a few of the more well known titles, but each seem to have their drawbacks.

  • Empire of the Summer Moon - gets rave reviews from some, but several times I've seen it called out for leaning into cheap tropes about the indigenous "savages." I'd like to avoid tropes from both sides--both those of the natives being thoughtless savages, as well as of them being perfectly noble, naive creatures that were preyed upon be evil settlers. I'd much prefer a less biased view.

  • Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee - seems to get good reviews critically, but in forums and user reviews it is often called repetitive, dry, and a bit boring.

  • An Indigenous Peoples' History of the US - also a book that gets mixed reviews. Some like it, many say it's again academic and rather repetitive. I thumbed through some of it and it read a bit like a college thesis to me, but it was only a few pages.

I'm wondering if these books all get pegged as repetitive simply because so many similar wars, treaties, entanglements, etc happened over those few centuries. Maybe it would be better to find a book with a smaller focus that could focus more on the human side of things rather than event after event from a distant view.

Anyway, would love some recs on your favorite books that give a picture of life around that era and hopefully aren't too biased in either direction.

Thanks all!


r/IndianCountry • • Oct 17 '25

Culture This is why I use the term indian.

Post image
0 Upvotes

Indigenous is too vague, the federal government will look for any reason to remove tribal sovereignty. Heck even right now tribes risk losing sovereignty over purchasing land off of their reservation.


r/IndianCountry • • Jun 18 '24

Discussion/Question Is true native americans didn't like white pagans?

9 Upvotes

I had a canadian friend that is member of the asatru (norse germanic religion) he say me native americans didn't like white pagans and despite them, btw my friend is very sensitive for his clinic depression so i think he could be over-acting, if is true that why?, is because some wiccans/neopagans use closed native practices with not permission no?


r/IndianCountry • • Apr 24 '24

X-Post When dictatorship of the proletariat starts looking like the doctrine of discovery

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/IndianCountry • • Jun 03 '26

Other Name Question

3 Upvotes

Hello! I am a white transgender woman who likes to experiment with names. I've been going by "Winona" to a few people for a couple months now and I really like it. But as do many who find themselves bored late into the night, I googled the origin of the name only to discover that it is derivative of the Dakota word for "first born daughter." I'm concerned about appropriation, and I'm hoping to get some indigenous feedback on the matter. Thank you!


r/IndianCountry • • Dec 03 '24

Discussion/Question What is the systematic situation for Native Americans in USA and Canada today?

0 Upvotes

First and foremost, I’d like to stress I’m not an American (Native or otherwise) but a Serb from the Balkans - my question is not provocation if it may seem like it, but genuine curiosity.

I was always under the impression that the Natives are completely equal under the law to European Americans, and that all tribes are legally protected and given a degree of autonomy. I assumed the oppression would come from powerful people personally mistreating the Natives, rather than any systematic or legal oppression. But the more I read and learn about it, it seems there are some very legal problems.

What are some of these problems? I apologize, again, if this question is too broad, but I would like to know what is it the Natives go through today that has itself adopted and canonised as law.


r/IndianCountry • • Apr 12 '22

Discussion/Question What do you think Natives are?

0 Upvotes

Being native myself I've struggled with this question. Are we our own race? Are we mixed with Asian or middle eastern? Some say we might be the lost tribes of Israel. Cause you gotta remember all the continents use to he connected, did we walk over from somewhere? what do you think?


r/IndianCountry • • Oct 27 '23

Discussion/Question How does a potlach work and why does social prestige play a role?

4 Upvotes

Hi!

I recently posted this in r/AskAnthropology: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskAnthropology/s/YrAcogYIww

The basic question I was asking is: how large can a gift economy get in practice? My thinking was that gift economies rely on interpersonal relationships and trust. So like, I help you get new shoes, you help me build me house later on that sorta thing.

But humans have a limit to how many people they know and how many debts and relationships they can remember. So my hypothesis was that there was a "maximum" size for a gift economy beyond which more complicated instruments of credit/debt are needed.

One of the comments on that thread pointed out that potlachs of the indigenous peoples of the pacific northwest are pretty big. That interested me so I looked it up and I was surprised.

My understanding is that it's basically competitive gift giving to enhance social prestige. So like, if I catch a lot of fish, I can keep some for me and give the rest away to show how cool I am cause I caught a lot of fish. That spreads wealth around between villages and communities while making the fisherman real famous and sought after.

So my question is: why? I get the desire to enhance social prestige within your group. So like, if the family I have and the frends i have in my town think I'm cool that's great and all. Why do I care about my social prestige in other villages?

To what extent does credit/debt play a role? I get that the goal is to give away stuff but I suppose participation can function as insurance? I.e. if my town has a particularly bad year I know I'll be covered cause the next town over wants to show off how cool they are. But now that I have taken fish or whatever from them I need to reassert my social status and out give them at the next potlach. That's sort of a credit debt insurance system right? I'm not sure, but would love to learn more!

So in summary my questions are: Why do I care about my social prestige in another Village?

To what extent is the potlach system able to be categorized as a credit/debt system using the informal unit of social prestige?

Can a potlach be accurately characterized as an insurance mechanism for all participating communities?

Have there ever been instances were one community fell they were giving too much or not getting enough out of the system? How were these situations handled?

To what extent is the potlach system scalable?

Thanks!

Would love to hear thoughts!


r/IndianCountry • • Aug 22 '25

Discussion/Question Should Non-Native People Avoid Visiting or Entering Reservation Territories?

3 Upvotes

I hope this question is okay here! And if not, or if it's been asked before and I missed it when I checked, I'm happy to take this down. Understanding & being respectful is my entire goal here.

And to be clear, I don't mean like. Vacationing TO a reservation to be a culture vulture or anything 😅 I'm not looking to come stay in a reservation town, gawk at the native residents, and try to appropriate their cultures or anything. I'm just talking about simply passing through on my to somewhere else.

I ask because I'm planning a Cali road trip, and the ideal route between two of my destinations would involve driving through Indian Country for about 20mi/26min (if anyone's curious, I'm talking about the stretch of hwy 96 in Six Rivers. The highway there technically crosses through 2 reservations - about 2.5mi through the Yurok Reservation, then the rest through Hoopa Valley Reservation, pretty much straight through the middle - all of this is assuming Google Maps is accurate ofc). If I were to stop here at all, it would be briefly, to look at the scenery and nature, away from any towns. I don't want to be disrespectful or invasive or anything. There isn't another comparable route, or anything that goes through the same regions I'm wanting to see without going through Indian Country. (Technically, my second favorite option still goes through Yurok Territory for roughly 2.5mi on the coast near Klamath on hwy 101, since Yurok Territory follows Klamath river clear down to the coastline, so I have similar concerns about being invasive/overstepping/etc taking this route.)

All that said - being respectful and not forcing my way into places where those who rightfully own the land don't want me is my priority. If it's disrespectful/harmful/etc for me to go take those routes, I'll take another. Being respectful and mindful is far more important to me than convenience or my vacation. I recognize my privilege in this and I do NOT want to overstep or cause harm.

And if your opinion is that it's okay for non natives to pass through like that - is there anything I should keep in mind, beyond the obvious that any towns there are someone's hometown and not some tourist destination for me to gawk? Is it best if I just drive straight through and avoid stopping? Is it disrespectful to take photos of the landscape (without any people in it obviously - just pictures of mountains or trees or something)?

I appreciate any insight or input anyone has on this! :)


r/IndianCountry • • Dec 14 '22

Discussion/Question Do native people struggle more with impulse control or is that a colonist’s lie?

0 Upvotes

TL;DR Are native people more likely to have ADHD, or is that a eugenics myth?

Hi. My name is Kai, and I was wondering if anyone has experience with what I’ve noticed with myself and my family. First, some backstory. My grandfather and my great uncle were adopted in the 1950s. I don’t know much about my dad’s side of the family genetically, but my grandfather has mentioned things in passing about being Native American. I.e. when my dad was younger going through puberty, and he doesn’t grow much leg hair, my grandfather told him “You don’t have leg hair because we’re Native American, and we’re more evolved than the white men who walk around like monkeys.” My great uncle had at some point reached out to our family members whom him and my grandfather were adopted from, but my grandfather decidedly didn’t want anything to do with it, and my great uncle has since passed away. With that bit of backstory, I was curious about something my grandfather had said more recently to me about mental health. “Some of that stuff definitely comes from our side of the family, we’re all a little crazy.” After I had talked to him about being diagnosed with ADHD, anxiety, and depression. My dad still doesn’t really acknowledge or care to be medicated for his ADHD, some part of that due to my grandfather being a drug addict when my dad was a child. We’ve also lost some family members to suicide. My sister also shows symptoms of ADHD, and I have ADHD and autism. There are some theories in psychology that people who have attention disorders, anxiety, etc. would have been the more inherent hunters in their societies. Does anyone have any anecdotes, stories, or mental health studies connecting the 2? To me it just seems like eugenics propaganda.


r/IndianCountry • • Apr 14 '22

Discussion/Question Gatekeeping

0 Upvotes

Since when did we start Gatekeeping who is native depending on what tribe you’re in?

I missed the memo where all cherokee are pretendians.


r/IndianCountry • • Oct 11 '26

Discussion/Question Am I the only one that doesn’t like being called indigenous?

74 Upvotes

I feel like the term is supposed to seperate us and make it sound like some foreign bullshit.

I’m a Native American. We are of the First Nation.
This land is ours and I hate we’ve fallen into some divide and conquer bullshit.
We’re warriors.


r/IndianCountry • • Aug 16 '24

Discussion/Question Hello, I am white but I do support Indigenous movements like land back, and I was hoping to find some good resources like books and documentaries about Indigenous Issues and history.

8 Upvotes

I especially want to learn about the Oaka crisis, and pine ridge.
thank you in advance for any help!


r/IndianCountry • • Feb 26 '25

Discussion/Question I'm not Indigenous, so can someone please explain to me why some Indigenous people still try to defend blood quantum despite its harms?

14 Upvotes

Hi, everyone! I'm a nonnative who studies the sociology of race and ethnicity. You might remember me from my Indigenous Pop-Tart post from last year. When researching Indigenous people and their struggles, I learned about the issue of blood quantum and its harms on Indigenous families.

When tribes continue to maintain this problematic concept, enrolled tribal members with less Indigenous ancestry from a single tribe often have two undesirable options:

  1. Marry (or engage in other forms of love with) a person who is not part of their tribe whilst knowing that their children will lose all or most forms of federal and state protection

  2. Restrict their patterns of marriage (or other non-Eurocolonial forms of childrearing) within their tribe

Blood quantum also creates a form of inequality within tribes; people of full Indigenous ancestry can engage in relationships with people of any ethnic group without their children losing status, while people with less Indigenous ancestry will face this aforementioned dilemma. While I personally do not have any experience with this concept as a complete outsider to the culture, I definitely feel that it contributes to the false belief that people should distinguish among and differentiate others by their exact ancestry.

Despite the misconception that opposition to blood quantum has only occurred recently, my in-depth research indicates that Indigenous people have questioned the concept of blood quantum for decades. This article, a 1944 issue of a publication titled Indian Education, aptly describes the problem with blood quantum in a way that strongly resembles the concept's modern critiques.

However, I have seen some modern-day Indigenous people start petitions encouraging the continuation of blood quantum, which baffles me when considering the concept's problematic implications. I will not link to any of these petitions to avoid promoting them, but it is not too difficult to find them by yourself.

Could you please explain to me the underlying motivations behind these petitions? Are they merely motivated by greed and prejudice against those with less Indigenous ancestry, or is there any other factor which may lead Indigenous people to defend a problematic social institution?


r/IndianCountry • • Jan 10 '24

Discussion/Question Where to find vegan moccasins?

47 Upvotes

Hey y'all/Wingapo!

I've found a couple companies online that sell vegan leather moccasins, but I'd prefer to give my money to a Native company. Does anyone know of any Native companies/Etsy stores/etc? Please and thank you!

Edit: Thanks everyone who has left feedback/insight! I appreciate getting another perspective on using leather and might have figured out a way to do so that is compatible with my beliefs. Whether I source pre-owned leather or some kind of biodegradable alternative, I will only give my money to Native artists (either through a commission to make the moccasins or in a class to learn how to do it myself). :)


r/IndianCountry • • 26d ago

Discussion/Question Enrolling out of State

0 Upvotes

Is there reason to enroll even if you live out of State and far from where your family/tribe is located?


r/IndianCountry • • Jun 29 '21

Discussion/Question How common was it for Natives west of the Rockies during Native Genocides to pass as Asians or Latin Americans in order to stay alive?

0 Upvotes

r/IndianCountry • • Aug 19 '22

Discussion/Question Bought a crystal and it was cleansed and shipped with white sage, what do I do?

0 Upvotes

When I opened my package I noticed there was something else in there but didn’t pay any attention to it but after awhile I kinda got a bad feeling so I looked at it and I saw a few things that looked like leaves. I don’t know anything about white sage other than it’s a closed practice so I looked it up and the pictures looked like what came into my package.

I went back to the description of the product to see if it would mention it coming with white sage leaves, it didn’t but at the bottom it said that it would be cleansed with white sage before shipping. Most places I buy crystals from don’t mention cleansing them before sending so it didn’t even cross my mind to look for that, it is my fault for not thoroughly reading the description and now know I should look be on the look out for that.

I had cleansed it with a frankincense and myrrh incense before wearing it (before I was aware it was cleansed with white sage), should I get rid of the crystal or is it ok to keep if I’ve cleansed it? And what do I do with the white sage leaves it came with?

Thank you in advance.


r/IndianCountry • • Jan 07 '22

Discussion/Question Is there one symbol that is universal amongst the majority of tribes?

1 Upvotes

I'm doing some research on symbols of first people cultures across the world in order to understand if there is a symbol or commonality. For example in India, the sun symbol occurs consistently across all tribes from the North to the South.

Edit.: Thank you to everyone for the very detailed and informative replies. I realise from the strong downvotes in getting that I am not communicating my intentions very clearly and I apologize sincerely if I have hurt you. My intention is not to homogenize at all and I see that my query is coming across as such.

Please accept my apology and thank you for all the beautiful answers. Stay healthy and stay fierce!