Hi!
I recently posted this in r/AskAnthropology: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskAnthropology/s/YrAcogYIww
The basic question I was asking is: how large can a gift economy get in practice? My thinking was that gift economies rely on interpersonal relationships and trust. So like, I help you get new shoes, you help me build me house later on that sorta thing.
But humans have a limit to how many people they know and how many debts and relationships they can remember. So my hypothesis was that there was a "maximum" size for a gift economy beyond which more complicated instruments of credit/debt are needed.
One of the comments on that thread pointed out that potlachs of the indigenous peoples of the pacific northwest are pretty big. That interested me so I looked it up and I was surprised.
My understanding is that it's basically competitive gift giving to enhance social prestige. So like, if I catch a lot of fish, I can keep some for me and give the rest away to show how cool I am cause I caught a lot of fish. That spreads wealth around between villages and communities while making the fisherman real famous and sought after.
So my question is: why? I get the desire to enhance social prestige within your group. So like, if the family I have and the frends i have in my town think I'm cool that's great and all. Why do I care about my social prestige in other villages?
To what extent does credit/debt play a role? I get that the goal is to give away stuff but I suppose participation can function as insurance? I.e. if my town has a particularly bad year I know I'll be covered cause the next town over wants to show off how cool they are. But now that I have taken fish or whatever from them I need to reassert my social status and out give them at the next potlach. That's sort of a credit debt insurance system right? I'm not sure, but would love to learn more!
So in summary my questions are: Why do I care about my social prestige in another Village?
To what extent is the potlach system able to be categorized as a credit/debt system using the informal unit of social prestige?
Can a potlach be accurately characterized as an insurance mechanism for all participating communities?
Have there ever been instances were one community fell they were giving too much or not getting enough out of the system? How were these situations handled?
To what extent is the potlach system scalable?
Thanks!
Would love to hear thoughts!