The Makers Deserve Zero Special Treatment. Instead, Ramayana Should Be the Most Harshly Critiqued Movie of Our Lives.
I urge people to do this in order to save the film and cinephile community.
If the makers of Ramayana chose to go entirely CGI instead of shooting on real locations, then they made a conscious decision to let CGI carry the entire visual experience. They could have saved a lot of money had they chosen to shoot some scenes in real locations. But with a reported budget exceeding ₹1,000 crore, they have set the bar themselves. Nobody forced them to take this route. Nobody asked them to spend this kind of money on CGI.
So judge the visuals accordingly. They should look spectacular. They should look better than real locations, not like cheap plastic looking environments without real shadows, reflections or particle physics dressed up as cinema. The benchmark should be world-class visual effects, on par with or better than what we’ve seen in Game of Thrones S6, The Odessey and the best of Indian cinematic environments, like Kantara. If the makers set that standard for themselves and fail to meet it, they deserve to be criticised. Openly, directly, and without excuses.
This is exactly how we ended up with Adipurush. Now we have Ramayana. Tomorrow, it’ll be another big-budget film where the makers expect the audience to lower its standards, ignore glaring flaws, and applaud the ambition instead of judging the actual product.
Ambition is not an achievement. A massive budget is not an excuse for mediocre execution. Mythology and religion is not a shield against criticism.
The audience does not owe filmmakers blind faith, free goodwill, or unconditional support. If you charge premium ticket prices, reportedly going upwards of ₹1,000, you better deliver a premium cinematic experience. We never demanded that filmmakers blow thousands of crores on CGI. They chose to do it. They should be held accountable for the results.
Stop asking audiences to adjust their expectations after setting sky-high expectations yourselves. Stop using the scale of the project as an excuse for its shortcomings. Stop confusing spectacle promised with spectacle delivered.
If the visuals look worse than the standards the makers themselves are trying to compete with, call it out. Don't defend mediocrity just because the film is based on the Ramayana has a massive budget, or comes with patriotic and cultural baggage.
The industry needs to learn one lesson: the Indian audiences are not fools and the directors and producers need to be scared of us.** If filmmakers keep delivering underwhelming products while demanding premium prices and unconditional praise, they deserve to see the consequences at the box office.
Hold them to their own standards. No excuses. No special treatment. No blind worship or fandom.