r/IndiaRWResources • • Apr 19 '21

HINDUISM Islamic Destruction of Hindu Temples

163 Upvotes

For those who don’t believe or do not know of the amount of destruction that took place in India at the hands of the Muslim invaders and Islamic rulers who established themselves in parts of India, we can review the Islamic chronicles of the deeds of these rulers of the day, as written by the Muslim contemporary writers or historians. So what follows is a review of some of the books and their authors who recorded the histories of the Islamic rulers, and quotes from some of the descriptions within them about the cities they attacked and the temples they destroyed. It really shows how demoniac and cruel these rulers were.

      The evidence of destruction of thousands of Hindu temples can be primarily found from two different sources:
        1. Literary Evidence from the work of renowned Islamic historians
        2. Epigraphic Evidence from the inscriptions on numerous Mosques all over India.
        This article deals with only the literary evidence.

        Hundreds of Muslim historians have glorified the deeds of their Muslim heroes all over India.  This by no means is an exhaustive list! To learn more about this, please read both volumes of, Hindu Temples: What Happened To Them? by Sita Ram Goel.
        There is elaborate literary evidence from the Islamic sources which glorify the crimes committed by the Muslims in India. Crimes such as the desecration of the Hindu idols, looting of the temples, killing devotees and raping have been well documented by the Muslim historians themselves. They have done so because according to them these Muslim rulers by doing such deeds were following the tenets of Islam and Sunnah of the prophet Mohammed. The literary evidence stated below is in chronological order with reference to the time at which a particular work was written.

      1. Name Of The Book: Hindustan Islami Ahad Mein (India under Islamic Rule)
      Name Of The Historian: Maulana Abdul Hai.
      About The Author: He is a highly respected scholar and taken as an authority on Islamic history. Because of his scholarship and his services to Islam, Maulana Abdul Hai was appointed as the Rector of the Darul Nadwa Ullum Nadwatal-Ulama. He continued in that post till his death in February 1923.

      The following section is taken from the chapter Hindustan ki Masjidein (The mosques of India) of the above mentioned book. Here we can see a brief description of few important mosques in India and how each one of them was built upon plundered Hindu temples.
          a. Qawwat al-Islam Mosque at Delhi: "According to my findings the first mosque of Delhi is Qubbat al-Islam or Quwwat al-Islam which, Qutubud-Din Aibak constructed in H. 587 after demolishing the Hindu temple built by Prithvi Raj and leaving certain parts of the temple outside the mosque proper; and when he returned from Ghazni in H. 592 he started building, under orders from Shihabud-Din Ghori, a huge mosque of inimitable red stones, and certain parts of the temple were included in the mosque..."
          b. The Mosque at Jaunpur: "This was built by Sultan Ibrahim Sharqi with chiseled stones. Originally it was a Hindu temple after demolishing which he constructed the mosque. It is known as the Atala Masjid."
          c. The Mosque at Qanauj: "It is well known that this mosque was built on the foundations of some Hindu temple that stood here. The mosque was built by Ibrahim Sharqi in H. 809 as is recorded in Gharbat Nigar."
          d. Jami Masjid at Etwah: "This mosque stands on the bank of the Jamuna at Etawah. There was a Hindu temple at this place, on the site of which this mosque was constructed. ."
          e. Babri Masjid at Ayodhya: "This mosque was constructed by Babar at Ayodhya which Hindus call the birth place of Ramchandraji... Sita had a temple here in which she lived and cooked for her husband. On that very site Babar constructed this mosque in H.963 "
          f. Mosque at Benaras: "Mosque of Benares was built by Alamgir Aurangzeb on the site of Bisheshwar Temple. That temple was very tall and held as holy among Hindus. On this very site and with those very stones he constructed a lofty mosque, and its ancient stones were rearranged after being embedded in the walls of the mosque. It is one of the renowned mosques of Hindustan."
          g. Mosque at Mathura: "Alamgir Aurangzeb built a mosque at Mathura. This mosque was built on site of the Govind Dev Temple which was very strong and beautiful as well as exquisite."

        2. Name Of The Book: Futuhu'l-Buldan
        Name Of The Historian: Ahmed bin Yahya bin Jabir
        About The Author: This author is also known as al-Biladhuri. He lived at the court of Khalifa Al-Mutawakkal (AD 847-861) and died in AD 893. His history is one of the major Arab chronicles.
        The Muslim Rulers He Wrote About:
          a. Ibn Samurah (AD 653)
          Siestan (Iran)
          "On reaching Dawar, he surrounded the enemy in the mountain of Zur, where there was a famous Hindu temple." "...Their idol of Zur was of gold, and its eyes were two rubies. The zealous Musalmans cut off its hands and plucked out its eyes, and then remarked to the Marzaban how powerless was his idol..."

          b. Qutaibah bin Muslim al-Bahili (AD 705-715)
          Samarkand (Farghana)
          "Other authorities say that Kutaibah granted peace for 700,000 dirhams and entertainment for the Moslems for three days. The terms of surrender included also the houses of the idols and the fire temples. The idols were thrown out, plundered of their ornaments and burned..."

          c. Mohammed bin Qasim (AD 712-715)
          Debal (Sindh)
          "...The town was thus taken by assault, and the carnage endured for three days. The governor of the town, appointed by Dahir, fled and the priests of the temple were massacred. Muhammad marked a place for the Musalmans to dwell in, built a mosque, and left 4,000 Musalmans to garrison the place..."
          "...Ambissa son of Ishak Az Zabbi, the governor of Sindh, in the Khilafat of Mu'tasim billah knocked down the upper part of the minaret of the temple and converted it into a prison..."

          Multan (Punjab)
          "...He then crossed the Biyas, and went towards Multan...Muhammad destroyed the water-course; upon which the inhabitants, oppressed with thirst, surrendered at discretion. He massacred the men capable of bearing arms, but the children were taken captive, as well as ministers of the temple, to the number of 6,000. The Musalmans found there much gold in a chamber ten cubits long by eight broad..."

          d. Hasham bin 'Amru al-Taghlabi
          Khandahar (Maharashtra)
          "He then went to Khandahar in boats and conquered it. He destroyed the Budd (idol) there, and built in its place a mosque."

        3. Name Of The Book: Tarikh-i-Tabari
        Name Of The Historian: Abu Ja'far Muhammad bin Jarir at-Tabari
        About The Author: This author is considered to be the foremost historian of Islam. The above mentioned book written by him is regarded as the mother of histories.
        The Muslim Rulers He Wrote About:

          a. Qutaibah bin Muslim al-Bahili (AD 705-715)
          Beykund (Khurasan)
          "The ultimate capture of Beykund (in AD 706) rewarded him with an incalculable booty; even more than had hitherto fallen into the hands of the Mohammedans by the conquest of the entire province of Khorassaun; and the unfortunate merchants of the town, having been absent on a trading excursion while their country was assailed by the enemy, and finding their habitations desolate on their return contributed further to enrich the invaders, by the ransom which they paid for the recovery of their wives and children. The ornaments alone, of which these women had been plundered, being melted down, produce, in gold, 150,000 meskals; of a dram and a half each. Among the articles of the booty, is also described an image of gold, of 50,000 meskals, of which the eyes were two pearls, the exquisite beauty and magnitude of which excited the surprise and admiration of Kateibah. They were transmitted by him, with a fifth of the spoil to Hejauje, together with a request that he might be permitted to distribute, to the troops, the arms which had been found in the palace in great profusion."

          Samarkand (Farghana)
          "A breach was, however, at last effected in the walls of the city in AD 712 by the warlike machines of Kateibah; and some of the most daring of its defenders having fallen by the skill of his archers, the besieged demanded a cessation of arms to the following day, when they promised to capitulate. The request was acceded to the Kateibah; and a treaty was the next day accordingly concluded between him and the prince of Samarkand, by which the latter engaged for the annual payment of ten million of dhirems, and a supply of three thousand slaves; of whom it was particularly stipulated, that none should either be in a state of infancy, or ineffective from old age and debility. He further contracted that the ministers of his religion should be expelled from their temples and their idols destroyed and burnt; that Kateibah should be allowed to establish a mosque in the place of the principal temple...."
          "...Kateibah accordingly set set fire to the whole collection with his own hands; it was soon consumed to ashes, and 50,000 meskals of gold and silver, collected from the nails which had been used in the workmanship of the images."

          b.. Yaqub bin Laith (AD 870-871)
          Balkh and Kabul (Afghanistan)
          "He took Bamian, which he probably reached by way of Herat, and then marched on Balkh where he ruined (the temple) Naushad. On his way back from Balkh he attacked Kabul..."
          "Starting from Panjhir, the place he is known to have visited, he must have passed through the capital city of the Hindu Sahis to rob the sacred temple -- the reputed place of coronation of the Sahi rulers -- of its sculptural wealth..."
          "The exact details of the spoil collected from Kabul valley are lacking. The Tarikh [-i-Sistan] records 50 idols of gold and silver and Mas'udi mentions elephants. The wonder excited in Baghdad by baghdad by elephants and pagan idols forwarded to the Caliph by Ya'qub also speaks for their high value."

        4. Name Of The Book: Tarikhu'l-Hind
        Name Of The Historian: Abu Rihan Muhammad bin Ahmad al-Biruni al-Khwarizmi.
        About The Author: This author spent 40 years in India during the reign of Sultan Mahmud of Ghazni (AD 997 - 1030). His history treats of the literature and learning of the Hindus at the commencement of the 11th century.
        The Muslim Rulers He Wrote About:

          a. Jalam ibn Shaiban (9th century AD)
          Multan (Punjab)
          "A famous idol of theirs was that of Multan, dedicated to the sun, and therefore called Aditya. It was of wood and covered with red Cordovan leather; in its two eyes were two red rubies. It is said to have been made in the last Kritayuga .....When Muhammad Ibn Alkasim Ibn Almunaibh conquered Multan, he inquired how the town had become so very flourishing and so many treasures had there been accumulated, and then he found out that this idol was the cause, for there came pilgrims from all sides to visit it. Therefore he thought it best to have the idol where it was, but he hung a piece of cow's flesh on its neck by way of mockery. On the same place a mosque was built. When the Karmatians occupied Multan, Jalam Ibn Shaiban, the usurper, broke the idol into pieces and killed its priests..."

          b. Sultan Mahmud of Gazni (AD 997-1030)
          Thanesar (Haryana)
          "The city of Taneshar is highly venerated by Hindus. The idol of that place is called Cakrasvamin, i.e. the owner of the chakra, a weapon which we have already described. It is of bronze, and is nearly the size of a man. It is now lying in the hippodrome in Ghazna, together with the Lord of Somnath, which is a representation of the penis of the Mahadeva, called Linga."

          Somnath (Gujrat)
          "The linga he raised was the stone of Somnath, for soma means the moon and natan means master, so that the whole word means master of the moon. The image was destroyed by the Prince Mahmud, may God be merciful to him! --AH 416. He ordered the upper part to be broken and the remainder to be transported to his residence, Ghaznin, with all its coverings and trappings of gold, jewels, and embroidered garments. Part of it has been thrown into the hippodrome of the town, together with Cakrasvamin, an idol of bronze, that had been brought from Taneshar. Another part of the idol from Somnath lies before the door of the mosque of Ghaznin, on which people rub their feet to clean them from dirt and wet."

        5. Name Of The Book: Kitabu'l-Yamini
        Name Of The Historian: Abu Nasr Muhammad ibn Muhammad al Jabbaru'l-Utbi.
        About The Author: This author's work comprises the whole of the reign of Subuktigin and that of Sultan Mahmud down to the year AD 1020.
        The Muslim Rulers He Wrote About:

          a. Amir Sbuktigin Of Ghazni
          Lamghan (Afghanistan)
          "The Amir marched out towards Lamghan, which is a city celebrated for its great strength and abounding wealth. He conquered it and set fire to the places in its vicinity which were inhabited by infidels, and demolishing idol temples, he established Islam in them. He marched and captured other cities and killed the polluted wretches, destroying the idolaters and gratifying the Musulmans."

          b. Sultan Mahmud of Ghazni (AD 997-1030)
          Narain (Rajasthan)
         "The Sultan again resolved on an expedition to Hind, and marched towards Narain, urging his horses and moving over ground, hard and soft, until he came to the middle of Hind, where he reduced chiefs, who, up to that time obeyed no master, overturned their idols, put to the sword the vagabonds of that country, and with delay and circumspection proceeded to accomplish his design..."

          Nardin (Punjab)
          "After the Sultan had purified Hind from idolatry, and raised mosques therein, he determined to invade the capital of Hind to punish those who kept idols and would not acknowledge the unity of God...He marched with a large army in the year AH 404 (AD 1013) during a dark night..."
          "A stone was found there in the temple of the great Budda on which an inscription was written purporting that the temple had been founded 50,000 years ago. The Sultan was surprised at the ignorance of these people, because those who believe in the true faith represent that only seven hundred years have elapsed since the creation of the world, and the signs of resurrection are even now approaching. The Sultan asked his wise men the meaning of this inscription and they all concurred in saying that it was false, and no faith was to be put in the evidence of a stone."

          Thanesar (Haryana)
          "The chief of Tanesar was...obstinate in his infidelity and denial of God. So the Sultan marched against him with his valiant warriors, for the purpose of planting the standards of Islam and extirpating idolatry.."
          "The blood of the infidels flowed so copiously, that the stream was discoloured, not withstanding its purity, and people were unable to drink it...The victory gained by God's grace, who has established Islam for ever as the best religions, notwithstanding that idolaters revolt against it...Praise be to God, the protector of the world, for the honour he bestows upon Islam and Musulmans."

          Mathura (Uttar Pradesh)
          "The Sultan then departed from the environs of the city, in which was a temple of the Hindus. The name of this place was Mahartul Hind... On both sides of the city there were a thousand houses, to which idol temples were attached, all strengthened from top to bottom by rivets of iron, and all made of masonry work..."
          "In the middle of the city there was a temple larger and firmer than the rest, which can neither be described nor painted. The Sultan thus wrote respecting it: --'If any should wish to construct a building equal to this, he would not be able to do it without expending an 100,000,000 red dinars, and it would occupy 200 years even though the most experience and able workmen were employed'... The Sultan gave orders that all temples should be burnt with naptha and fire, and levelled with the ground."

          Kanauj (Uttar Pradesh)
          "In Kanauj there were nearly 10,000 temples, which the idolaters falsely and absurdly represented to have been founded by their ancestors two or three hundred thousand years ago...Many of the inhabitants of the place fled and were scattered abroad like so many wretched widows and orphans, from the fear which oppressed them, in consequence of witnessing the fate of their deaf and dumb idols. Many of them thus effected their escape, and those who did not fly were put to death."

      6. Name Of The Book: Diwan-i-Salman
      Name Of The Historian: Khawajah Masud bin Sa'd bin Salman
      About The Author: Khawajah Masud bin Sa'd bin Salman was a poet. He wrote poems in praise of the Ghaznavid Sultans-Masu'd, Ibrahim and Bahram Shah. He died sometime between AD 1126 and 1131.
      The Muslim Rulers He Wrote About:

            a. Sultan Abu'l Muzaffar Ibrahim (AD 1059-1099)
            "As power and the strength of a lion was bestowed upon Ibrahim by the Almighty, he made over to him the well-populated country of Hindustan and gave him 40,000 valiant horsemen to take the country, in which there were more than 1000 rais...The army of the king destroyed at one time a thousand temples of idols, which had each been built for more than a thousand years. How can I describe the victories of the King..."

            Jalandhar (Punjab)
            "The narrative of any battles eclipses the stories of Rustam and Isfandiyar... By morning meal, not one soldier, not one Brahmin remained unkilled or uncaptured. Their heads were levelled with the ground with flaming fire… Thou has secured the victory to the country and to religion, for amongst the Hindus this achievement will be remembered till the day of resurrection. "

            Malwa (Madhya Pradesh)
            "…On this journey, the army destroyed a thousand idol-temples and thy elephants trampled over more than a hundred strongholds. Thou didst march thy army to Ujjain… The lip of infidelity became dry through fear of thee, the eye of plural-worship became blind..."

          7. Name Of The Book: Chach-Namah
          Name Of The Historian: Mohammed Al bin Hamid bin Abu Bakr Kufi
          About The Author: The Persian history was translated from Arabic by the above mentioned author in the time of Nasiruddin Qabacha, a slave of Mohammed Ghori.
          The Muslim Rulers He Wrote About:

            a. Mohammed bin Qasim (AD 712-715)
            Siwistan and Sisam (Sindh)
            Mohammed bin Qasem wrote to al-Hajjaj, the governor of Iraq:
            "The forts of Siwistan and Sism have been already taken. The nephew of Dahir, his warriors and principal officers have been dispatched, and infidels converted to Islam or destroyed. Instead of idol temples, mosques and other places of worship have been built, pulpits have been erected, the Khutba is read, the call to prayers is raised so that devotions are performed at sacred hours."

            Multan (Punjab)
            "Mohammed Qasem arose and with his counselors, guards and attendants, went to the temple. He saw there an idol made of gold, and its two eye were bright red rubies... Muhammed Qasem ordered the idol to be taken up. Two hundred and thirty ‘mans’ of gold were brought to the treasury together with the gems and pearls and treasures which were obtained from the plunder of Multan."

          8. Name Of The Book: Jamiu'l-Hikayat
          Name Of The Historian: Maulana Nuruddin Muhammed `Ufi
          About The Author: The author was born in or near the city of Bukhara in Transoxiana. He came to India and lived in Delhi for some time in the reign of Shamsu'd-Din Iltutmish (AD 1210-1236)
          The Muslim Rulers He Wrote About:

            a. Amru bin Laith (AD 879-900)
            Sakawand (Afghanistan)
            "It is related that Amru Lais conferred the governorship of Zabulistan on Fardaghan and sent him there at the head of four thousand horses. There was a large Hindu place of worship in that country, which was called Sakawand and people used to come on pilgrimage from the most remote parts of Hindustan to the idols of that place. When Fardaghan arrived in Zabulistan he led his army against it, took the temple, broke the idols in pieces and overthrew the idolaters... "

          9. Name Of The Book: Taju'l-Ma'sir
          Name Of The Historian: Sadru'd-Din Muhammed Hasan Nizamii
          About The Author: The author was born at Nishapur in Khurusan. He had to leave his ancestral place because of the Mongol invasion. He came to India and started writing his history in AD 1205.
          The Muslim Rulers He Wrote About:

            a. Sultan Muhammed Ghuri (AD 1175-1206)
            Ajmer (Rajasthan)
            "He destroyed the pillars and foundations of the idol temples and built in their stead mosques and colleges, and the precepts of Islam, and the customs of the law were divulged and established. .."

            Kuhram and Samana (Punjab)
            "The Government of the fort of Kohram and Samana were made over by the Sultan to Kutuu-din. He purged by his sword the land of Hind from the filth of infidelity and vice, and freed it from the thorn of God-plurality, and the impurity of idol-worship and by his royal vigor and intrepidity, left not one temple standing..."

            Meerut (Uttar Pradesh)
            "Kutub-d din marched from Kohran and when he arrived at Meerut which is one of the celebrated forts of the country of Hind, for the strength of its foundations and superstructure, and its ditch, which was as broad as the ocean and fathomless- an army joined him, sent by the dependent chiefs of the country. The fort was captured, and a Kotwal was appointed to take up his station in the fort, and all the idol temples were converted into mosques."

            Delhi
            "He then marched and encamped under the fort of Delhi...The city and its vicinity were freed from idols and idol-worship, and in the sanctuaries of the images of the Gods, nosques were raised by the worshippers of one God. Kutub-d din built the Jami Masjid at Delhi and adorned it with stones and gold obtained from the temples which had been demolished by the elephants, and covered it with inscriptions in Toghra, containing the divine commands."

            Varanasi (Uttar Pradesh)
            "From that place (Asni) the royal armi proceeded towards Benares which is the center of the country of Hind and here they destroyed nearly 1000 temples, and raised mosques on their foundations and the knowledge of the law became promulgated, and the foundations of religion were established. ."

            Aligarh (Uttar Pradesh)
            "There was a certain tribe in the neighbourhood of Kol which had occasioned much trouble. Three bastions were raised as high as heaven with their heads, and their carcasses became the food of beasts of prey. That tract was freed from idols and idol-worship and the foundation of infidelity were destroyed."

            Bayana (Rajasthan)
            "When Kutub-d din heard of Sultan's march from Ghazna, he was much rejoiced and advanced as far as Hansi to meet him. In the year AH 592 (AD 1196), they marched towards Thangar, and the center of idolatry and perdition became the abode of glory and splendour.."

            Kalinjar (Uttar Pradesh)
            "In the year AH 599 (Ad 1202), Kutub-d din proceeded to the investment Kalinjar, on which expedition he was accompanied by the Sahib-Kiran, Shamsu-d din Altmash... The temples were converted into mosques and abodes of goodness, and the ejaculations of bead counters and voices of summoners to prayer ascended to high heaven, and the very name of idolatry was annihilated. ."

            b. Sultan Shamsu'd-Din Iltutmish (AD 1210-1236)
            Delhi
            "The Sultan then returned from Jalor to Delhi..and after his arrival 'not a vestige or name remained of idol temples which had raised their heads on high; and the light of faith shone out from the darkness of infidelity.. and the moon of religion and the state became resplendent from the heaven of prosperity and glory."

          10. Name Of The Book: Kamilu't-Tawarikh
          Name Of The Historian: Ibn Asir
          About The Author: The author was born in AD 1160 in the Jazirat ibn Umar, an island on the Tigris above Mosul.
          The Muslim Rulers he Wrote About:

            a. Khalifa Al-Mahdi (AD 775-785)
            Barada (Gujrat)
            "In the year 159 (AD 776) Al Mahdi sent an army by sea under Abdul Malik bin Shahabu'l Musamma'i to India. They proceeded on their way and at length disembarked at Barada. When they reached the place they laid siege on it. The town was reduced to extremities and God prevailed over it in the same year. The people were forbidden to worship the Budd, which the Muhammadans burned."

          11. Name Of The Book: Tarikh-i-Jahan-Kusha
          Name Of The Historian: Alaud-Din Malik ibn Bahaud-Din Muhammed Juwaini
          About The Author: The author was born a native of Juwain in Khurasan near Nishapur. He was the Halaku during the Mongol campaign against the Ismai'lians and was later appointed the governor of Baghdad. He fell from grace and was imprisoned at Hamadan.
          The Muslim Rulers he Wrote About:

            a. Sultan Jalalud-Din Mankbarni (AD 1222-1231)
            Debal (Sindh)
            "The Sultan then went towards Dewal and Darbela and Jaisi... The Sultan raised Masjid at Dewal, on the spot where an idol temple stood."

          12. Name Of The Book: Mifathu'l-Futuh
          Name Of The Historian: Amir Khusru
          About The Author: The author, Amir Khusru was born at Delhi in 1253. His father occupied high positions in the reigns of Sultan Shamsu'd Din Iltutmish (AD 1210-1236) and his successors. Reputed to be the dearest disciple of Shykh Nizamuddin Auliya, he became the lick-spittle of whoever came out victorious in the contest for the throne at Delhi. He became the court poet of Balban's successor, Sultan Kaiqbad.
          The Muslim Rulers he wrote About:

            a. Sultan Jajalu'd-Din Khalji (AD 1290-1296)
            Jhain (Rajasthan)
            "The Sultan reached Jhain in the afternoon of the third day and stayed in the palace of the Raya he greatly enjoyed his stay for some time. Coming out, he took a round of gardens and temples. The idols he saw amazed him. Next day he got those idols of gold smashed with stones. The pillars of wood were burnt down by his order. A cry rose from the temples as if a second Mahmud has taken birth. Two idols were made of brass, one of which weighed nearly thousand ‘mans’. He got both of them broken, and the pieces were distributed among his people so that they may throw them at the door of Masjid on their return to Delhi."

            b. Sultan Alaud-Din Khilji (AD 1296-1316)
            Vidisha (Madhya Pradesh)
            "When he advanced from the capital of Karra, the Hindus, in alarm, descended into the earth like ants. He departed towards the garden of Behar to dye that soil with blood as red as tulip. He cleared the road to Ujjain of vile wretches, and created consternation in Bhilsan. When he affected his conquests in that country, he drew out of the river the idols which had been concealed in it.

            Devagiri (Maharshtra)
            "But see the mercy with which he regarded the broken-hearted, for, after seizing the rai, he set him free again. He destroyed the temples of the idolaters, and erected pulpits and arches for mosques

      13. Name Of The Book: Nuh Siphir
      Name of the Historian: Amir Khusru
      About the Author: The above mentioned book is the fourth historical mathnavi which Amir Khusru wrote when he was 67 years old. It celebrates the reign of Sultan Mubarak Shah Khalji.
      The Muslim Rulers he wrote About:

        a.. Sultan Mubarak Shah Khalji (AD 1315-1320)
        Warrangal (Andhra Pradesh)
        "They pursued the enemy to the gates and set everything on fire. They burnt down all those gardens and groves. That paradise of idol-worshippers became like hell. The fire-worshippers of ‘Bud’ were in alarm and flocked round their idols…"

      14. Name of the Book: Siyaru'l-Auliya
      Name of the Historian: Sayyed Muhammed bin Mubarak bin Muhammed
      About the Author: He was the grandson of an Iranian merchant who traded between Kirman in Iran and Lahore. The family traveled to Delhi after Shykh Farid's death and became devoted to Shykh Nizamu'd-din Auliya.
      The Muslim Rulers he wrote About:

        a.. Shykh Mu'in al-Din Chisti Ajmer (AD 1236)
        Ajmer (Rajasthan)
        "..Because of his Sword, instead of idols and temples in the land of unbelief now there are mosques, mihrab and mimbar. In the land where there were the sayings of the idol-worshippers, there is the sound of 'Allahu Akbar'...The descendants of those who were converted to Islam in this land will live until Day of Judgement; so too will those who bring others into the fold of Islam by the sword of Islam. Until the Day of Judgment these converts will be in debt of Shaykh al-Islam Mu'in al-din Hasam Sijzi..."

      15. Name of the Book: Masalik'ul Absar fi Mamalik'ul Amsar
      Name of the Historian: Shihabu'd-Din 'Abu'l Abbas Ahmed bin Yahya.
      About the Author: He was born in AD 1301. He was educated in Damascus and Cairo. He is considered to be a great man and scholar of his time and author of many books. He occupied high positions in Syria and Egypt.
      The Muslim Rulers he wrote About:

        a. Sultan Muhammed bin Tughlaq (AD 1325-1351)
        "The Sultan is not slack in Jihad. He never lets go of his spear or bridle in pursuing jihad by land and sea routes. This is his main occupation which engages his eyes and ears. Five temples have been destroyed and the images and idols of ‘Budd’ have been broken, and the lands have been freed from those who were not included in the daru'l Islam that is, those who had refused to become zimmis. Thereafter he got mosques and places of worship erected, and music replaced by call to prayers to Allah... The Sultan who is ruling at present has achieved that which had not been achieved so far by any king. He has achieved victory, supremacy, conquest of countries, destruction of the infidels, and exposure of magicians. He has destroyed idols by which the people of Hindustan were deceived in vain..."

      16. Name of the Book: Rehala of Ibn Battuta
      Name of the Historian: Shykh Abu Abdullah Muhammad ibn Ibrahim al-Lawatt at-Tanji al-Maruf be Ibn Battuta.
      About the Author: He belonged to an Arab family which was settled in Spain since AD 1312. His grandfather and father enjoyed the reputation of scholars and theologians. He himself was a great scholar who traveled extensively and over many lands. He came to India in 1325 and visited many places. He was very fond of sampling Hindu girls from different parts of India. They were presented to him by the Sultan Mohammed bin-Tughlaq with whom Ibn Battuta came in close contact. He also married Muslim women wherever he stayed and divorced them before his departure.

        a. His Travel description:
        (Delhi)
        "Near the eastern gate of the mosque, lie two very big idols of copper connected together by stones. Every one who comes in and goes out of the mosque treads over them. On the site of this mosque was a bud Khana that is an idol-house. After the conquest of Delhi, it was turned into a mosque..."

      17. Name of the Book: Tarikh-i-Firuz
      Name of the Historian: Shams Siraj Alif
      About the Author: The author became a courtier of Sultan Firuz Shah Tughlaq and undertook to complete the aforementioned history of Barani who had stopped at the sixth year of Firuz Shah's reign.
      The Muslim Rulers he wrote About:

        a. Sultan Firuz Shah Tughlaq (AD 1351-1388)
        Puri (Orissa)
        "The Sultan left Banarasi with the intention of pursuing the Rani of Jajnagar, who had fled to an island in the river...News was then brought that in the jangal were seven elephants, and one old shoe-elephant, which was very fierce. The Sultan resolved upon endeavoring to capture these elephants before continuing the pursuit of the Rai... After the hunt was over, the Sultan directed his attention to the Rai of Jajnagar, and entering the palace where he dwelt he found many fine buildings. It is reported that inside the Rai's fort, there was a stone idol which the infidels called Jagannath, and to which they paid their devotions. Sultan Firoz, in emulation of Mahmud Subuktign, having rooted up the idol, carried it away to Delhi where he placed it in an ignominious position."

        b. Nagarkot Kangra(Himachal Pradesh)
        "..Sultan Muhammed Shah bin Tughlaq and Sultan Firuz Shah Tughlaq were sovereigns especially chosen by Almighty from among the faithful, and in their whole course of their reigns, wherever they took an idol temple they broke and destroyed it."

        Delhi
        "A report was brought to the Sultan that there was in Delhi an old Brahmin who persisted in publicly performing the worship of idols in his house; and that people of the city, both Musalmans and Hindus, used to resort to his house to worship the idol. The Brahmin had constructed a wooden tablet which was covered within and without with paintings of demons and other objects. An order was accordingly given that the Brahmin, with his tablet, should be brought into the presence of the Sultan at Firozabad. The judges and doctors and elders and lawyers were summoned, and the case of the Brahmin was submitted for their opinion. Their reply was that the provisions of the Law were clear: the Brahmin must either become a Musalman or be burned. The true faith was declared to the Brahmin, and the right course pointed out, but he refused to accept it. Orders were given for raising a pile of faggots before the door of the darbar (court). The Brahmin was tied hand and foot and cast into it; the tablet was thrown on top and the pile was lighted. The writer of this book was present at the darbar and witnessed the execution. The tablet of the Brahmin was lighted in two places, at his head and at his feet; the wood was dry and the fire first reached his feet, and drew him a cry, but the flames quickly enveloped his head and consumed him. Behold the Sultan's strict adherence to law and rectitude, how he would not deviate in the least from its decrees!"
      Here Sultan Firuz Shah Tughlaq glorifies his own criminal acts in Bharat as sanctioned by the "holy" Koran.

      18. Name of the Book: Futuhat-i-Firuz Shahi
      Name of the Historian: Sultan Firuz Shah Tughlaq
      About the Author: Sultan had got the eight chapters of his work inscribed on eight slabs of stone which were fixed on eight sides of the octagonal dome of a building near the Jami Masjid at Firuzabad.

        a. Prayers of Temple-destroyers in this Book
        "The next matter which by God's help I accomplished, was the repetition of names and titles of former sovereigns which had been omitted from the prayers of Sabbaths and Feasts. The names of those sovereigns of Islam, under whose happy fortune and favour infidel countries had been conquered, whose banners had waved over many a land, under whom idol-temples had been demolished, and mosques and pulpits built and exalted..."

        Delhi and Evirons
        "The Hindus and idol-worshippers had agreed to pay the money for toleration (zar-i zimmiya) and had consented to the poll-tax(jiziya) in return for which they and their families enjoyed security. These people now erected new idol-temples in the city and the enviorns in opposition to the law of the Prophet which declares that such temples are not to be tolerated. Under divine guidance I destroyed these edifices and I killed those leaders of infidelity who seduced others into error, and the lower orders I subjected to stripes and chastisement, until this abuse was entirely abolished. The following is an instance: In the vilalge of Maluh, there is a tank which they call kund (tank). Here they had built idol-temples and on certain days the Hindus were accustomed to proceed thither on horseback, and wearing arms. Their women and children also went out in palankins and carts. Then they assembled in thousands and performed idol-worship. ...when intelligence of this came to my ears my religious feelings prompted me at once to put a stop to this scandal and offence to the religion of Islam. On the day of the assembly I went there in person and I ordered that the leaders of these people and the promoters of this abominations should be put to death. I destroyed their idol-temples and instead thereof raised mosques."

        Gohana (Haryana)
        "Some Hindus had erected a new idol-temple in the village of Kohana and the idolators used to assemble there and perform their idolatrous rites. These people were seized and brought before me. I ordered that the perverse conduct of the leaders of this wickedness should be publicly proclaimed, and that they should be put to death before the gate of the palace. I also ordered that the infidel books, the idols and the vessels used in their worship, which had been taken with idols, should all be publicly burnt. The others were restrained by threats and punishments, as a warning to all men, that no zimmi could follow such wicked practices in a Muslaman country."

source


r/IndiaRWResources • • Apr 05 '21

HISTORY In pre-British India,widows were supported through revenue-free land grants by local rulers,Hindu/Muslim.When the Company took over,it started canceling all allotments of this kind to maximize profits.To protest this, widows started committing Sati which EIC subsequently banned to quell protests.

152 Upvotes

When Governor-General Bentinck abolished Sati (Suttee, as Britishers called it), he had a larger-than-life statue commissioned showing him dramatically rescuing and Indian women from the funeral pyre. (It can still be seen in the compounds of Victoria museum).

Thomas Metcalf writes how despite infrequent occurrences of it, the British were quite fascinated with the act of Sati. With its immolation of a living woman in a raging fire, Sati, even more than the public execution, catered to the English obsession with death as spectacle.

The scene on this statue evokes a salacious mixture of sex and violence. It represents the Indian woman as a helpless victim of a blood-thirsty and superstitious faith, placed on the curved pedestal at the center of the composition, while Bentinck presides majestically above.

While this statue tried to depict Sati as emblematic of much that was wrong with Indian society, such an understanding has been now problematized in the recent work of Indrani Chatterjee. ['Monastic Governmentality, Colonial Misogyny, and Post-colonial Amnesia in South Asia’]

She has documented the fact that, in pre-British India,the widows were supported through revenue-free land grants by the local rulers,Hindu/Muslim. When the Company took over the function of collecting revenue,it started canceling all allotments of this kind to maximize profits.

To protest this, widows started committing Sati as a form of cultural protest. Many of these widows were in their middle age. (this has been documented well in an article titled ‘Whose Sati? Widow burning in the early 19th century’, in a book edited by Sumit & Tanika Sarkar).

It was in response to these protests, the British decided to ban it. If these facts are kept in mind, then the abolition of Sati, far from being a humanitarian act, begins to look more and more like a cover-up of commercial rapacity.

~ From ‘The Ruler’s Gaze’ by Arvind Sharma

https://twitter.com/Anuraag_Shukla/status/1355172832695603203

pdf copy available here

https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5406/historypresent.3.1.0057#metadata_info_tab_contents

Some points from pdf

By 1781, confrontations with these women-sponsored monastic militias translated into official policy. Unable to physically coerce heavily guarded, “secluded” (pardanashin) authority figures to give up cash and valuables, local British officers serving the company as tax collectors devised rules in 1784 that tilted decisively against such women’s authority.These regula­tions established that all land taxes in all parts of company-taxed Bengal would be paid by male and adult zamindars. If zamindars were either minors, females of “acknowledged incapacity” (in later regulations called “lunatics and idiots”), or involved in debts which gave creditors charge of the lands, the actual payee would be a male figure, preferably the most responsible and creditable of the zamindar’s relations. Such a figure would be given the sole charge and authority of management of the lands and of dealing with the European collectorate. Being a female in India became a legal disability in company-written revenue policy thereafter.

The company government’s program of taxation and record keeping be­tween 1784-1800 did not merely drive already poor women to the edge of subsistence; the shrillness of evangelical pamphleteering on widow-im­molations also ensured that these women’s relational identities as sisters, daughters, and patrons would be lost forever from the records. Brahman women had not been widows alone. Their relationships to brothers and fathers had remained strong, as a rapid survey of the gift-giving records reveals. For instance, brahman grandsons inherited shares in their maternal grandfather’s tax-exempt lands because of their mother’s continued claims on their own athers’ estates. The grandson was a dauhitra (or daughter’s son) to his grandfather. Similarly, among those who inherited a portion of tax-exempt lands of a brahman learned in Nyaya (law) was the sister’s son (bhagneya) of the original holder. These records confirm the claims that married sisters and daughters had on their brothers and fathers among the most respected of groups in Indian society until at least the middle of the eighteenth century. This was equally obvious among daughters of Sufi Muslim men who had received gifts of tax-exempt lands in the eighteenth century. These relationships were just as severely impacted by the struc­tural changes under way in colonial governmentality as were the many re­lationships between gurus and disciples directly.

Source:

https://www.reddit.com/r/indianews/comments/mjps0w/can_someone_help_me_in_getting_the_name_of_this/?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share


r/IndiaRWResources • • Oct 01 '20

Pro-Indian users are banned from r/India and r/worldnews for the same reason Randians are brigading the /new/ and /rising/ sections of r/IndiaSpeaks and r/IndiaDiscussion.

146 Upvotes

On reddit even a big subreddit can be influenced by a small group of people patrolling its /new/ and /rising/ sections. The reddit algorithm is heavily biased by the first few votes:

The first 10 upvotes count as high as the next 100. The next 100 upvotes count as high as the next 1000 etc.

The Randian and r/librandu brigade are doing this right now on r/IndiaSpeaks and r/IndiaDiscussion. Tons of good posts on both subreddits are downvoted into oblivion before they get traction. This is how a dozen Randian and r/librandu brigaders can subvert r/IndiaSpeaks. We saw that yesterday where they used the Hathras incident to push their agenda.

What has that to do with the Randian mods of r/India and r/worldnews banning thousands of pro-India users? They are banning pro-Indian users because upvotes/downvotes by banned users are ignored. They don't want pro-Indian users to vote on new posts in the /new/ and /rising/ sections of r/India and r/worldnews.

What can be done about this? The r/IndiaSpeaks and r/IndiaDiscussion mods need to ban the Randian concern trolls just like the r/Chodi mods have done. How to identify Randian concern trolls? Just look at their post history. You will know.

Something we all can do organically is to be more active in the /new/ and /rising/ sections of the subreddits we care about.


r/IndiaRWResources • • May 28 '21

CONGRESS I've collected all available records of UPA censoring free speech. Congress made 18 requests/day to Facebook and 15 requests/day to Google. That is when 70% of the country didn't even have access to the internet.

140 Upvotes

r/IndiaRWResources • • Jul 28 '21

What all has the modi/BJP government done? Here is the answer-

136 Upvotes

What has Modi done?

Internet in India -> then and now-/preview/pre/34o54ckju9b41.jpg?width=1024&auto=webp&s=0922dae9bbdcd45a01f27a6035b84bb0fb8c79f6

source TRAI

38% (14000km) of Indian Railway's entire electrified network was built after 2014.

Modi government Build 110 million toilets in just 5 years

https://www.cnn.com/2019/10/05/asia/india-modi-open-defecation-free-intl-hnk-scli/index.html

India also became the fastest growing economy under modi government before trade war

India become almost 3 trillion $ economy from 1.8 trillion $ economy in just 4 years

India gdp in 2013 ==> https://countryeconomy.com/gdp/india?year=2013

India Gdp in 2018 ==> https://countryeconomy.com/gdp/india?year=2018

They are building worlds biggest green field smart City bigger then Singapore

https://www.financialexpress.com/infrastructure/indias-own-singapore-dholera-an-upcoming-greenfield-city-in-gujarat-will-blow-your-mind-check-facts/1513132/

15 million houses were build in just 4 years

https://www.moneycontrol.com/news/business/real-estate/close-to-1-5-crore-houses-built-for-poor-under-pmay-pm-narendra-modi-3532891.html

There are building 83,000 Km Of Roads

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bharatmala

Modi in 5 years

7 IITs: Palakkad, Tirupati, Dhanbad, Bhilai, Goa, Jammu, Dharwad

15 IIITs (Indian Institute of Information Technology): Una, Sonepat, Kalyani, Lucknow, Dharwad, Kurnool, Kottayam, Manipur, Nagpur, Pune, Ranchi, Surat, Bhopal, Bhagalpur, Agartala

7 IIMs: Nagpur, Vishakhapatnam, BodhGaya, Amritsar, Sirmaur, Sambhalpur, Jammu

15 AIIMS: Mangalagiri, Nagpur, Gorakhpur, Kalyani, Bhatinda, Bilaspur, Darbhanga, Kamrup, Jammu, Kashmir, Madurai, Deoghar, Rajkot, Bibinagar, Raebareli

The overall allocation for the [education] sector went up by over Rs 5,000 crore — it will be Rs 99,300 crore in 2020-21, up from Rs 94.853.64 crore in 2019-20.

Sex education, breaking gender stereotypes in Modi govt’s new school curriculum

Summary of the relief package announced by Govt for COVID-19

The total worth of the package is ₹1.7 lakh crore, released for the immediate help of migrant workers and urban and rural poor.

There will be Rs 50 lakh insurance per health care worker as a medical insurance cover for them for three months.

Pradhan Mantri Gareeb Kalyan Ann Yojna(for next 3 months):80 cr poor ppl covered(2/3rd of India’s population), in addition to already allotted 5Kg of rice/wheat per person, an additional 5kg will be free. Additional 1kg pulse (acc to regional preference) will be given.

8.69 crore farmers to be immediately benefited through Direct cash transfers. Installment of Rs 2000 in the first week of April will be transferred.

Wage increase in MGNREGA- 5 crore families benefited, an increase of Rs 2000 per worker on average as additional income.

Old age, Divyang, pensioners: 3 crore people covered, one-time amount of additional Rs 1000 in two installments through DBT (hence no middlemen) over 3 months to be given.

20 crore Jan Dhan Women account holders covered- Ex gratia amount of Rs 500 per month for the next three months.

Ujjawala scheme near 8.3 crores BPL families covered in this, so that no running short of cooking medium, for 3 months free cylinders.

Self Help women groups (7 crore houses holds covered), collateral-free loans doubled to 20 Lakh, to increase money in hand.

Govt of India will pay the Employees’ Provident Fund(EPF) contribution, both employer and employee, put together it will be 24%, this will be for the next 3 months. This is for those establishments which have up to 100 employees and 90% of them earn less than 15,000.

Govt ready to amend the regulation of EPF due to this pandemic so that workers can draw up to 75% non-refundable advance from credit in PF account or 3 months salary, whichever is lower.

Welfare for building and construction workers registered 3.5 crore workers to be benefited, Central Govt has given orders to State Govts to use funds (Rs31,000 crore) to provide relief. Central Govt to request State Govts to use this fund to augment medical testing and screening and providing health attention

RSS COVID-19 Seva till 20 May 2020

Places Served: 85,701

Dedicated Volunteers: 4,79,949

Ration kit donated to Families : 1,10,55,450

Meal packets distribution : 7,11,46,500

Migrant workers helped in different ways : 27,98,091

Blood Donation : 39,851

Mask Distribution : 62,81,117

https://mobile.twitter.com/RSSorg/status/1264083060447993856

Under Modi: 500 million covered under Ayushman Bharat, 350 million have access to bank accounts for the first time, toilet coverage has increased from 40 to 99%, rural electrification has been completed, absolute poverty has gone from 20% in 2014 to 3% today (according to World Poverty Clock/IMF data), DBT (transfers subsidies directly into bank account of farmers - saving an estimated 200 crore in leaks), demonetisation helped file an extra 70 million tax returns. Vs Manmohan Singh govt: x4 times the road development, x100 times the LPG grid connections and x100k times the Broadband connectivity set up, Ease of Business rankings at a record high, FDI at record high.


r/IndiaRWResources • • Apr 03 '21

ISLAM Remove 26 verses from Quran, says PIL filed by Wasim Rizvi. Here are the verse:

132 Upvotes

9:5 And when the sacred months have passed, then kill the polytheists wherever you find them and capture them and besiege them and sit in wait for them at every place of ambush. But if they should repent, establish prayer, and give zakah, let them [go] on their way. Indeed, Allah is Forgiving and Merciful.

9:28 O you who have believed, indeed the polytheists are unclean, so let them not approach al-Masjid al-haram after this, their [final] year. And if you fear privation, Allah will enrich you from His bounty if He wills. Indeed, Allah is Knowing and Wise.

4:11 And when you travel throughout the land, there is no blame upon you for shortening the prayer, [especially] if you fear that those who disbelieve may disrupt [or attack] you. Indeed, the disbelievers are ever to you a clear enemy.

9:123 O you who have believed, fight those adjacent to you of the disbelievers and let them find in you harshness. And know that Allah is with the righteous.

4:56 Indeed, those who disbelieve in Our verses - We will drive them into a Fire. Every time their skins are roasted through We will replace them with other skins so they may taste the punishment. Indeed, Allah is ever Exalted in Might and Wise.

9:23 O you who have believed, do not take your fathers or your brothers as allies if they have preferred disbelief over belief. And whoever does so among you - then it is those who are the wrongdoers.

9:37 Indeed, the postponing [of restriction within sacred months] is an increase in disbelief by which those who have disbelieved are led [further] astray. They make it lawful one year and unlawful another year to correspond to the number made unlawful by Allah and [thus] make lawful what Allah has made unlawful. Made pleasing to them is the evil of their deeds; and Allah does not guide the disbelieving people.

5:57 O you who have believed, take not those who have taken your religion in ridicule and amusement among the ones who were given the Scripture before you nor the disbelievers as allies. And fear Allah, if you should [truly] be believers.

33:61 Accursed wherever they are found, [being] seized and massacred completely.

21:98 Indeed, you [disbelievers] and what you worship other than Allah are the firewood of Hell. You will be coming to [enter] it.

32:22 And who is more unjust than one who is reminded of the verses of his Lord; then he turns away from them? Indeed We, from the criminals, will take retribution.

48:20 Allah has promised you much booty that you will take [in the future] and has hastened for you this [victory] and withheld the hands of people from you - that it may be a sign for the believers and [that] He may guide you to a straight path.

8:69 So consume what you have taken of war booty [as being] lawful and good, and fear Allah. Indeed, Allah is Forgiving and Merciful.

66:9 O Prophet, strive against the disbelievers and the hypocrites and be harsh upon them. And their refuge is Hell, and wretched is the destination.

41:27 We shall certainly make these unbelievers taste a terrible chastisement and shall fully requite them according to the worst deeds that they committed.

41:28 That is the recompense of the enemies of Allah the Fire, their abiding home. That will be the re-compense for their denying Our Signs.

9:11 But if they repent and establish Prayer and give Zakah they are your brothers in faith. Thus do We expound Our revelations to those who know.

9:58 And among them are some who criticize you concerning the [distribution of] charities. If they are given from them, they approve; but if they are not given from them, at once they become angry.

8:65 O Prophet, urge the believers to battle. If there are among you twenty [who are] steadfast, they will overcome two hundred. And if there are among you one hundred [who are] steadfast, they will overcome a thousand of those who have disbelieved because they are a people who do not understand.

5:51 Believers! Do not take the Jews and the Christians for your allies. They are the allies of each other. And among you he who takes them for allies, shall be regarded as one of them. Allah does not guide the wrong-doers.

5:14 And from those who say, "We are Christians" We took their covenant; but they forgot a portion of that of which they were reminded. So We caused among them animosity and hatred until the Day of Resurrection. And Allah is going to inform them about what they used to do.

9:29 Fight those who do not believe in Allah or in the Last Day and who do not consider unlawful what Allah and His Messenger have made unlawful and who do not adopt the religion of truth from those who were given the Scripture - [fight] until they give the jizyah willingly while they are humbled.

4:89 They wish that you reject faith, as they have rejected, and thus that you all become equal (like one another). So take not Awliya' from them, till they emigrate in the way of Allah. But if they turn back, take (hold of) them and kill them wherever you find them, and take neither Awliya' nor helpers from them.

9:14 Fight them; Allah will punish them by your hands and will disgrace them and give you victory over them and satisfy the breasts of a believing people

3:151 We will cast terror into the hearts of those who disbelieve for what they have associated with Allah of which He had not sent down [any] authority.1 And their refuge will be the Fire, and wretched is the residence of the wrongdoers.

2:191 And kill them wherever you overtake them and expel them from wherever they have expelled you, and fitnah is worse than killing. And do not fight them at al-Masjid al- îaram until they fight you there. But if they fight you, then kill them. Such is the recompense of the disbelievers.


r/IndiaRWResources • • Mar 23 '21

HINDUISM Terrorists dont have religion but Nationalist and Supremacists do??🥺🧡 Hidus have been constantly attracted and labeled by thses let is give it another religious spin ☺️🔥 cuz why not?

131 Upvotes

Let's start calling them

🔸️Islamic supremacists

🔹️Islamic State Nationalists

🔸️Jihad Supremacists

🔹️Jihadi state Nationalists

🔺️Inquisitions fanatics/ colonial sadists

🔻Pagen killers (🍀so it will alarm more pagen communists that are passive hopefully bit idk lol because pagans were seen as witches and demonic worshippers)

Any catchier versions are welcome💖👍

And more.....

Words and labels have a lot of impact in global narratives, I'm pretty sure u are aware of that now🙄

Instead of terrorists until it becomes mainstream until they are forced to say supremacy and nationalism does not have religion 😭.

Do u have a better solution? do tell if so down below 👇

Copy paste and forward to ur viraat groups if u find this useful 🙏🏼😊🚩


r/IndiaRWResources • • Feb 11 '21

DEFENSE You might be sick hearing of Soros,frankly so am I.But it can't be helped.After employing Manmohan's daughter,Maino's close adviser Harsh Mander,funding Rajiv Gandhi foundation,Soros org worker campaigning against Adani/Ambani(2 corps specified in Greta-kit),now Tikait's global org funded by Soros

125 Upvotes

Manmohan Singh's daughter works as a lawyer for Soros NGO.

https://np.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/hips5d/manmohans_daughter_amrita_singh_is_a_human_rights/

https://www.opindia.com/2020/07/amrit-singh-manmohan-singh-george-soros-open-society-justice-initiative/

Harsh Mander, Chairman of George Soros’s Open Society Foundation’s Human Rights Initiative Advisory Board, was member of Sonia Gandhi’s National Advisory Council which drafted the nauseatingly anti-Hindu Communal Violence Bill under which no Hindu could ever claim to be victim of communal violence and no minority could ever be convicted of communal violence. Also was at the centre of Delhi riots, and currently orphanages run by him are accused of sexual abuse of children.

https://www.opindia.com/2020/03/harsh-mander-ara-pacis-initiative-italian-govt-secret-service-foriegn-policy-india/

https://www.opindia.com/2020/02/george-soros-harsh-mander-open-society-petition-arrest-bjp-leaders-delhi-riots/

Soros org propped up anti-India Kashmiri journalist Basharat Peer who went on to write Haider movie.

https://np.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/jmfgax/til_the_movie_haider_romanticizing_kashmiri/

If you thought that's a mere coincidence and of course Bashrat Peer was selected as a fellow by Soros org for his mere skills, George Soros backed lobbying firm Soros foundation Moldova and his NGO OFS lobbied with the EU Parliament for adopting a resolution on Kashmir which is why six different EU parliamentary groups/alliances al submitted draft resolution on CAA on the same day.

https://np.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/eusz6v/the_real_story_george_soros_backed_lobbying_firm/

And here's Soros bringing up freedom of "Muslim majority semi-autonomous Kashmir" being oppressed by a "Hindu nationalist state."

https://twitter.com/NavroopSingh_/status/1220526717816594432?s=20

Rajiv Gandhi Foundation and its links to shady Soros funded orgs in India and Soros-linked organisations abroad

https://www.opindia.com/2020/06/rajiv-gandhi-foundation-george-soros-open-society-institute-hrln-harsh-mander/

NGO that filed complaint against Rafale Deal is partners with George Soros’ Open Society, Misereor and Oxfam among others

https://www.opindia.com/2018/11/ngo-that-filed-complaint-against-rafale-deal-is-partners-with-george-soros-open-society-misereor-and-oxfam-among-others/

Funds Colin Gonsalves, the Supreme Court lawyer involved in bailing out Naxals arrested in Bhima Koregaon case, arrested in Bastar, bailing out Soros org activist Harsh Mander, fights for anti-CAA rioters, for settlement of Rohingyas to in Jammu, against Tata in Singur case, etc

https://np.reddit.com/r/indianews/comments/gtr3ib/colin_gonsalves_close_close_friend_of_harsh/

https://np.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/iza4tr/not_just_european_churches_even_european/

Coming to current affairs, Soros org worker was discovered by Strings yesterday to be campaigning against Adani & Ambani (the 2 corporates attacked in Greta's toolkit as well) while tagging Saket Gokhale, a known Congress stooge.

https://np.reddit.com/r/Chodi/comments/lgtq15/this_guy_fked_up_the_entire_leftists_media_and/

Human Rights Watch" funded 100 million by Soros campaigns against Indian govt in concert with Rihanna.

But more pertinently, it had received a record donation of $100 million from Hungarian tycoon-cum-global political meddler George Soros in 2010. The same Soros in 2020 pledged a $1 billion fund to fight “would-be dictators”, which includes Narendra Modi, a man who has been overwhelmingly voted to power by the people of India for the second time in the most transparent of elections.

https://www.firstpost.com/india/in-rihanna-greta-malalas-anti-india-symphony-who-is-the-invisible-conductor-9266191.html

More importantly, Rakesh Tikait confirmed in AajTak that global org he is part of has branches across 73 nations and is campaigning against corporates even in Brazil.

https://np.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/lhlr7l/aajtak_rakesh_tikait_confirms_the_global/

Which global org? That was also dug up by somebody on twitter.

https://archive.is/KXwOM

La via Campesina, based in Brussels, Belgium, comprises 164 local & national farmer Organizations in 73 countries.

WTO, Buenos Aires, December 2017.

"The farmers have been accredited to attend the WTO Ministerial Conference as Civil Society representatives of the international peasants’ movement, La Via Campesina"

https://viacampesina.org/en/indian-farmers-attending-world-trade-organization-ministerial-buenos-aires-ask-government-take-agriculture-wto/

https://archive.is/Svix9

Above links have LVC protesters campaigning against WTO, you would find Tikait in the pics posted as well as his name listed as represented Indian farmers.

LVC mentioned in Greta's toolkit in both first & second pages.

https://twitter.com/sidhant/status/1356991778717503490/photo/1

https://twitter.com/by2kaafi/status/1359748001560895488

Now we go back to who funds LVC, again dug up by the same guy. One of its main donors is AgroEcologyFund - an NGO created to supposedly decorporatise agriculture.

https://www.agroecologyfund.org/grantmaking

Who funds AgroEcologyFund? Around 20 other NGOs including evangelist NGOs like Francisian sisters, IKEA and also Soros' Open Society Foundation.

https://www.agroecologyfund.org/leadership-and-allies

Though this one is not limited to India,18 out of 20 members of Facebook’s new ‘oversight board’ meant to ‘regulate content’ linked to George Soros. (This man who went so far as to target everything from Rafael to Kashmir and keeps Congress as his lapdog won't hesitate to use this "oversight board" to control future elections in India to install his favorite puppies?)

https://np.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/imx66h/18_out_of_20_members_of_facebooks_new_oversight/

This I personally can't verify, but this twitter thread talks of NGOs funded by Soros manufacturing "agri crisis" in MP 3 years back at the time of its state elections.

https://np.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/etqpri/what_our_teams_were_surprised_to_discover_there/

Other miscellaneous info about Soros. Soros' only interview in Indian electronic media is in Print and only written interview is also in Print. Soros also funds in India radical orgs like Lawyers Collective, Center for Policy Research whose head called for street mobilisation against court rulings (Harsh Mander), Evangelical Trust Association of North India, Media Development Investment Fund (which invested in hard-left anti-India houses like Scroll & Gramvaani

https://np.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/ldwjrz/shefali_vaidya_why_arent_we_talking_this_soros/

Soros' Open Society Foundation also funds organisations linked to Palestenian terror groups responsible for hijacking & destruction of airplanes.

https://osmomag.com/politics/amnesty-international-george-soros-and-terror-groups-a-vicious-nexus/

Soros' Human Rights Watch also partners with Unitarian Universalist Holdeen India Program, an out and out Christian organisation and like other Christian denominations, it too, has a dedicated plan to harvest Hindu souls in India. In India, it masks its proselytising activities under the garbs of social justice, women empowerment, and grassroots work.

https://www.dharmadispatch.in/commentary/untangling-the-oxfam-labyrinth-what-unites-george-soros-harsh-mander-and-ashoka-university

Soros's other org the Human Rights Law Network (HRLN) has been involved in the campaign against ISKCON’s Akshaya Patra, a campaign against Indian sedition laws, and it has been providing free legal aid to Rohingya Muslims in India. It has also been engaging in activism for the implementation of the RTE Act that works against Hindu-run institutions. Furthermore, it is also linked to a plethora of organizations across the country that seeks to undermine India’s territorial integrity.

Members of the Right to Food Campaign (RFC), an organization HRLN is linked to, were also involved in the protest against then CJI Ranjan Gogoi that sought to undermine the legitimacy of the Indian Judiciary.

https://www.opindia.com/2021/02/rona-wilson-forensic-report-propaganda-george-soros-canada-govt/

After the government imposed restrictions on Soros funding NGOs in India in 2016, Soros has been channelling money into India via UK based orgs.

Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative is registered under FCRA in New Delhi with a registration number, DL/231650671. It appears to work on the so-called ‘Right to Information (RTI), Police Reforms, Prison Reforms, and International Advocacy and Programming (IAP). CHRI’s current Director is Shri. Sanjoy Hazarika, Honorary Research Professor at Centre for Policy Research, Delhi, Senior Journalist and who is also on the Executive Committee of the Indian Police Foundation.

Out of the Rs. 50 and odd Crore that it has received in the period 2006-2018, nearly a quarter has come from Open Society Foundation (donations from its sister organization Open Society Institute is also included in this entry). OSF/OSI are in Zug, Switzerland, Budapest, Hungary and in New York, USA.

Donations from George Soros’ OSF/OSI stopped after 2016 since the Government of India’s Ministry of Home Affairs (FCRA Wing in particular) had placed the OSF/OSI into something called Prior Permission category, i.e., FCRA-NGOs can no longer received ‘donations’ from OSF/OSI directly, but need to seek a permission from MHA for every ‘donation’.

Not just CHRI, but no NGO received foreign ‘donations’ from OSF/OSI. So, it is clear that MHA did not let in any ‘donation’ from OSF/OSI, directly.

Interestingly, a new ‘donor’ to CHRI emerged in the year 2018, i.e., CHRI-UK. It donates a whopping Rs. 2.1 Crore that year.

CHRI-UK is registered as a Charity (Charity No. 803235 and Company No. 02488240) in the United Kingdom.

An examination of CHRI-UK’s financial records at UK’s Companies House (unlike India’s MCA, UK’s Companies House gives out for free, all company related Documents to all, online) reveals that it had an income of about GBP 50,000 in the year 1998, with grants from the Foreign Office of UK Government and the European Commission.

It is thus established that CHRI-UK has had not much of ‘Income’ until 2017. However, in its Full Accounts submission for the year 2017-18, it reports the receipt of huge grants from Foundation to Promote Open Society (GBP 1,33,732) and Foundation Open Society Institute (GBP 18,971). It receives, pretty much, no other income that year.

https://indiahap.wordpress.com/2020/10/08/foreign-donations-are-my-birthright-and-i-will-certainly-attain-it/

Before I end this post, a final disclaimer. Please don't construe this post to mean that Soros is the only US establishment billionaire working to recolonise India. There are many like him from Omidyar to Google to Dorsey (enumerating their achievements is outside scope of this post, but hopefully I manage to someday). He is just the most public.


r/IndiaRWResources • • Jan 31 '21

HINDUISM 9 lakh Hindus disappeared in Bangladesh in 10 years.

125 Upvotes

9 lakh Hindus have decreased in 10 years

Putting together the district-wise data of the 2001 and 2011 censuses, it can be seen that the Hindu population has declined in 15 districts. BBS officials said that the Hindus of these districts have migrated to other districts of the country, the statistics do not say that. In other words, the Hindu population has not increased in other districts as well. Officials call them 'missing population'.

The number of Hindus has not increased in any district of Barisal division. Barisal, Bhola, Jhalokati, Pirojpur, Patuakhali, Barguna — these six districts had a Hindu population of eight lakh 18 thousand 51 people in the 2001 census. In the 2011 census, the number has come down to seven lakh 72 thousand 479 people. Bagerhat, Khulna and Satkhira of Khulna division — besides, the number of Hindus in these three districts has decreased than before. The trend is similar in Narail and Kushtia districts of the division. The list includes Gopalganj, Madaripur and Kishoreganj districts in the Dhaka division. On the other hand, even in Pabna district of Rajshahi division, the number of Hindus has not increased keeping pace with the population growth.

Analyzing the data of the two censuses before and after the independence, it is seen that the number and rate of Hindus has decreased as compared to the total population. The number and rate of Muslims has always increased. The rate of Buddhism, Christianity and other religions was or is almost the same.

Pankaj Bhattacharya, a veteran politician and convener of the People's Unity Committee, told Prothom Alo that this was happening because of creating communal atmosphere and destroying harmony. Forces like Jamaat are planning and happening regularly. Recently, attempts have been made to create division among the people by raising religious jigs at Hathazari in Chittagong, Kaliganj in Satkhira and Chirirbandar in Kurigram. He said no one was standing by the side of the minorities, not reassuring them. That is why they are leaving the country in silence.

Why it is declining: Multiple census reports have claimed that the total fertility rate (TFR) is relatively low among the Hindu population. But no data was obtained from the Bureau of Statistics.

However, speaking in different villages of Gopalganj, Barisal, Bhola, it is known that the main reason for the decrease in the number of Hindus is emigration. People in some districts say that it has been a natural tendency of the Hindu community to leave the area since the partition of the subcontinent in 1947. Someone said, the main reason is the enemy property law. He said that Hindus have to face various kinds of pressure and torture centering on the election. On the other hand, if there is communal tension in India, it also ignites the Hindus of this country.

"The culture of standing on one's chest has decreased," said Dr. Anisuzzaman. The Emeritus Professor of Dhaka University said that the lack of security for minorities is real and predictable. Some people are causing various incidents for the purpose of seizing property. He said some leaders or political parties centrally make promises about minorities. But at the local level that promise is not kept, staff is not available.

There is panic in Chandshi-Illa-Dhandoba: Several Hindu families from Gournadi and Agailjhara upazilas of Barisal district have left the area since 2001. It is learned that Manoj Vaidya left home with his wife two days after the 2001 elections in Dhandoba village. He did not return. Manoj's neighbor Saiful Islam told Prothom Alo that the day after the election, BNP activists attacked and looted Hindu and Christian houses in the village. They took cows and paddy from Manoj's house. Destroys drinking waste.

The families of Kalipada Dafadar, Subal Dafadar, Montu Dafadar and Joydev Nandi of Illa village also left the country due to the post-election terror of 2001. Aditya Nag and Subal Dey from Sutarbari village have left the country for the same reason.

Krishnakant Dey, chairman of Chandshi Union Parishad No. 3, told Prothom Alo that many families including his own family, relatives and neighbors were attacked, looted and tortured. No family from the union left the area. However, many families do not live in the country. He said, "Suppose a family has five brothers, their two brothers do not live in the country."

Kajal Debnath, a member of the presidium of the Bangladesh Hindu Buddhist Christian Unity Parishad, said many parents are marrying off their daughters at an early age, or leaving them in India to go to school or college. However, he claimed that the tendency to emigrate has decreased. Although the government's initiative on enemy property (vested property) has not been entirely successful, minorities are hoping that the property will no longer be lost or the lost property will be returned. Now Hindus are building houses and buying flats in big cities.

Situation in Bhola: According to BBS statistics, there were 82,265 Hindus in Bhola district in 2001. According to the latest census, the population has come down to 61,162.

There were six families in the house of Sadhu Singh of Nalgora village in Charpata union of Daulatkhan upazila of Bhola district. The head of the family was Lakshmi Narayan Singh. Lakshmi Narayan sold the land after 1992 and left. The people of the village told Prothom Alo that Hindu families started leaving after 1992. The people of this village were the victims of communal terror in the communal riots that took place in India over the demolition of the Barri Mosque at that time.

Many families have left even after the 2001 parliamentary elections. Talking to people around the village, it is known that since 1992, there are four in Sutarbari, 10 in Daktarbari, six in the middle Singbari, seven in Ras Kamal Hawladar's house, three in Laxmikant Hawladar's house, seven in Tirthabas Hawladar's house, seven in Paresh Hawladar's house, three in Telibari and three in Radheshyam Sutarbari's. , More than two hundred families from 65 houses in the village, including one from Montu Hawladar's house and all the families from Rari's house.

Nalgora, Lejpata and Chargumani of the upazila these three villages were Hindu-inhabited. At the time of independence this village had more than four hundred houses. Hundreds of families have left 162 houses in these villages.

Till 1991, there were more than one thousand Hindu families in Mulaipattan village of Tobgi union of Borhanuddin upazila. At present there are 44 families. Four villages in Lordhardinge's union of Lalmohan upazila were Hindu-inhabited. Till 1991, there were 4,600 Hindu votes in this union. Jatramani Lashkar of Annadaprasad village in the union said most of the Hindu families in the villages fled the area after the Babri Masjid incident in 1992 and the 2001 election. According to the data provided by the local Union Health Center, there are currently 600 Hindu voters in the union.

Gopalganj: Awami League is the sole dominant party in Gopalganj district. It is generally believed that minorities have good relations with the party. Not to mention the incidents of communal clashes in the district after independence. Even after that Hindus are leaving this district regularly. In 2001, there were three lakh 61 thousand 729 Hindus in this district. In 10 years it has come down to three lakh 53 thousand 894 people.

A senior journalist, who did not want to be named, told Prothom Alo that torture of 'enemy property' has been suppressed for almost 50 years. Then came the big blow by making Islam the state religion. The Awami League has not kept its promise in these matters. The chairman of a union council has said that religious minorities do not get the post of president or general secretary in the district Awami League even if it is suitable. The highest post of Hindu students in the Parliament of Government Bangabandhu College is Assistant General Secretary (AGS). In the small town of Gopalganj, the leaders of the big parties are occupying the houses and properties of the minorities. Hindus do not feel safe seeing these scenes.

Kajal Debnath's comment about the situation in Gopalganj, 'Darkness under the lamp.'

No initiative: No initiative to stop emigration was seen in these areas. A chairman of Gopalganj district, who did not want to be named, said, 'I am trying to help him sell his land and house safely. I can't tell you to stay. '

Hindu Buddhist Christian Unity Parishad, Puja Udyapan Parishad occasionally hold meetings and seminars at district and upazila level. In these meetings and seminars, it was said not to leave the country, to protest against torture. Kajal Debnath claims that work is being done on this.

Translation of 2012 report from Bangladeshi newspaper Prothom Alo: https://archive.is/dPcyd

By u/mittro70_


r/IndiaRWResources • • Mar 20 '21

HISTORY Myth of ancient Indian "disunity" and "weakness" to invasions

124 Upvotes

"You are very wrong. If anything India is THE only exception when it came to Islamic conquests.

isn't it Hindus fault that we kept fighting amongst ourselves that we allowed Muslims to invade us?

You couldn't be more wrong. The armies of Mohd first left Arabia ~ 620 AD. They reached Sassanid Persia by 633AD. By 650 AD, Persia was conquered. By 800 AD Zoarastrianism was extinct.

Starting 620 AD (same time they reached Sassanid Persia) the Arabs took over huge parts of Egypt, Iraq, Syria and Palestine from the Byzantine empire. This was completed by ~ 650 AD. The Arabs reached into parts of Anatolia, but were repulsed by the Byzantines. However, by 1075 AD, almost all of Asia Minor was Islamic.

After this from 650 AD to 700 AD, the Arab armies conquered all of North Africa and converted huge swathes of people into Islam.

In 710 AD, the first Arab expeditionary force reached the Iberian Peninsula. By 725 AD all of Iberia was under Arab control, huge conversions began here also, but the Cordoban caliphate decided to disallow forcible conversions and the process became more organic and slowed to a crawl.

As you can see, Arab and Islamic armies were UNSTOPPABLE.

Now let us look at the East of Saudi Arabia.

By 720 AD all lands from Saudi Arabia right to the Sindh were captured by the Umayads. Afghanistan though remained under Hindu kings (these wouldn't be subjugated till around 1,000 AD). From 720 AD to about 1,000 AD with the Ghaznavid invasions, India resisted any and all Islamic incursions. THE ONLY culture to do so while every other nation / culture fell like ninepins.

About 'disunity amongst Hindus', are you even aware of the Battle of Rajasthan? Two warring empires, The Chalukya's and Gurjara Pratihara's set aside their own century of warfare and formed an alliance that then not only decimated Umayad forces, it reoccupied all of Rajasthan and Gujarat captured by the Arabs and sent them back across the Sindh. From then till 1000 AD, the Arab armies tried many times to retake lost territory, but failed.

What changed in 1000 AD?

  1. Military power and tactics. My 1000 AD, Islamic conquests of India were now led by Turkic Islamic tribes or Central Asian (Mongolian) tribes. These tribes used entirely different tactics, they were the prototype of the Mongols (similar tactics really). Highly mobile Cavalry archer units, and the Turks had superior (borrowed from the Byzantines and Western Europe) artillery also. This combination is unbeatable, as we were to see when all of Europe+China+Arab states failed to check the Mongols.

  2. Power Vacuum - After the Gupta's fell, their place was occupied by the Chalukya's, Pratihara's and Pala's. After about 400 years, the Pratihara's fell, the Chalukyas weakened by the Rashtrakuta's and Chola's and were on their death bed. It was at this precise point in time Ghazni invaded us.

These wars between empires is not a "Hindu" thing but a human thing and 'modern, humanist Europe' is THE worst at this.

Please learn history first before you make sweeping claims."

Author: u\RajaRajaC

Year: 2015

Source


r/IndiaRWResources • • Apr 20 '21

POLITICS The first education minister of independent India, Maulana Abul Kalam Azad was an incapacitated alcoholic and a pan- Islamic Jihadist.

114 Upvotes

"This biradri (community of Muslims) has been established by God...All relationships in the world can break down but this relationship can never be severed. It is possible a father turns against his son, not impossible that a mother separates her child from her lap, it is possible that one brother becomes the enemy of other brother...But the relationship that a Chinese Muslim has with an African Muslim, an Arab bedouin has with the Tatar shepherd, and which binds in one soul a neo-Muslim of India with the right-descendant Qureshi of Mecca, there is no power on earth to break it, to cut off this chain…"

"Then, if it is true that a sword is being sharpened to strike in the heart of Islam, then what hesitation that we be engaged in developing a shield. If the worship of Jesus has ancient enmity against the worship of God, and this is not a new Christian conspiracy, then the unity of brotherhood is not a new tactic of the followers of Tawheed (Islamic monotheism) to defend against the attack of polytheists."

"That by the Lucknow Pact they had sold away their interests. The Delhi proposals of March last opened the door for the first time to the recognition of the real rights of Musalmans in India. The separate electorates granted by the Pact of 1916 only ensured Muslim representation, but what was vital for the existence of the community was the recognition of its numerical strength. Delhi opened the way to the creation of such a state of affairs as would guarantee to them in the future of India a proper share. Their existing small majority in Bengal and the Punjab was only a census figure, but the Delhi proposals gave them for the first time five provinces of which no less than three (Sind,the Frontier Province and Baluchistan) contained a real overwhelming Muslim majority. If the Muslims did not recognise this great step they were not fit to live. There would now be nine Hindu provinces against five Muslim provinces, and whatever treatment Hindus accorded in the nine provinces, Muslims would accord the same treatment to Hindus in the five Provinces. Was not this a great gain? Was not a new weapon gained for the assertion of Muslim rights?"

He asked Muslims to bear in mind that at the time there was “only one sword in the defence of the religion of Allah” and that was in the hands of the falling Ottoman Caliph. He also criticised liberal Muslims who did not side with him in support of the Caliphate, saying that time has come to “discriminate between faith and kufr (non-belief)” and cited the Quranic verse 2:14: “These munafiqeen (hypocrites among Muslims), when they meet Muslims they say, we are Muslims. But when they visit alone their Satans (non-Muslims), then they say, we are with you by heart…”

Ambedkar: The Communal Question in its "lesser intent"

Maulana Azad's tragic contradictions

Global Islamism, jihadism and Maulana Abul Kalam Azad, my defence lawyer

"One day the Maulana’s favourite Private Secretary came to see me privately. He told me that he was worried about the Maulana because he was imbibing half a bottle of whisky every evening. Falls were not infrequent In fact he had broken his back in a fall and had to wear a metal plate to support his back. Since then an able-bodied man was always available to support the Maulana whenever he got up during and after his drinks." "As a departmental minister, the Maulana was a disaster, as Gandhiji had feared. He made no contribution to education. He left everything to the trio — Humayun Kabir, K.G. Saidayin and Ashfaque Hussain."

-Reminiscences of the Nehru Age by M. O. Mathai (Private Secretary to India's first Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru) (Entire chapter on Maulana starts from Page 147)

Time to lift the ban on what Nehru’s aide wrote about him and his contemporaries?

On Gandhiji’s usual silence day on a Monday he wrote a personal letter to Nehru on the inside of a used envelope advising him not to make Maulana Azad the Education Minister as he was convinced that the Maulana would ruin education.

In Delhi, the Maulana never attended a dinner party. He came to the PM’s house only for lunches in honour of important foreign dignitaries. At Cabinet meetings, which were normally fixed for 5 p.m. or soon after, the Maulana would get up at the stroke of six, regardless of the importance of the subject under discussion, and leave. Soon he would be before his whisky, soda and ice anda plate of samosas…Nehru avoided seeing him in the evenings…One day the Maulana’s favourite Private Secretary came to see me privately. He told me that he was worried about the Maulana because he was imbibing half a bottle of whisky every evening. Falls were not infrequent. In fact he had broken his back in a fall and had to wear a metal plate to support his back. Since then an able-bodied man was always available to support the Maulana whenever he got up during and after his drinks.

-Genesis and Growth of Nehruism: commitment to Communism Book by Sita Ram Goel

Atal Bihari Vajpayee: A Hero of India’s Second Freedom Movement


r/IndiaRWResources • • Apr 24 '21

POLITICS Those who rant in the media about lynchings and cow vigilantes are the same ones who, when one night in my posh gated colony in Delhi, the chowkidar caught a thief in the act of stealing a stereo from a Hyundai Verna, gathered hockey sticks to beat him up until the police came.

113 Upvotes

Indian marxists keep writing PhDs about subalterns but in real life they have contempt for subalterns, which is why in 2014 they derogatorily called Modi a chaiwallah and now chowkidaar. The reality is that the BJP has refashioned itself as the party of aspirational subalterns.

The vast majority of our Anglophone elite is so deracinated and disconnected from Indians outside their South Delhi, South Bombay, and Civil Lines gated communities, that they Orientalise and Other the rest of India, the way they've seen Western scholars and journalists do.

Most of these intellectuals, despite their token Marxism, have abandoned any form of resistance to neo-colonialism or neo-imperialism, to act as a new "comprador bourgeoisie", repeating and amplifying Occidental and Eurocentric biases and agenda with their views and writings.

They don't find the heinous poverty or inequality or injustice around them as offensive as they do that their monopoly during the License Raj, over cars, bungalows, private Anglophone education, and political proximity are being challenged by vernacular subalterns.

The fact that the Indian middle class and working class have Asian values rather than Western bourgeois liberal values, means that they are automatically seen as lacking the social capital our Anglophone class monopolised for decades.

So now that their social capital no longer buys them entrance to the corridors of power at home, they slavishly prostrate themselves to prove to Western centrist elites that they are worthy of joining their club, with the right accents and the right views.

So instead of working to dismantle the structures designed to maintain the status quo where post-colonial countries are poor, unequal, and chaotic, they betray both their beloved Marxism and other Indians in order to ally with those who designed and benefit from these structures.

Steinbeck said that the American poor "see themselves not as an exploited proletariat, but as temporarily embarrassed millionaires." I say the Indian rich see themselves not as a comprador bourgeoisie, but as future US/UK citizens, temporarily inconvenienced by Indian passports.

I should know, having been socialised in exactly this environment in school and university, having studied Marxist theory and historiography myself, and this having had the chance to observe up close the hypocrisy around me.

This hypocrisy, be it from the Arundhatis who believe that the nation-state model of intrabellum Europe, which created chauvinistic ethno-linguistic fascist states that led us into war, is a better model for Kashmir than being part of a "fascist" multicultural, democratic India,

Or the Pankaj who achieved the Indian leftist dream of marrying into Conservative British aristocracy while repeating neo-colonial tropes in the anti-leftist, Viner-era neoliberal Guardian, or even those among my peers who entered JNU as Marxists but came out as Western liberals with an Indian veneer, who can't see that any Indian leader, even Modi, is more leftist than a Hillary, Trudeau, Macron or Merkel, lies at the heart of the Indian Left's moral bankruptcy.

Those who rant in the media about lynchings and cow vigilantes are the same ones who, when one night in my posh gated colony in Delhi, the chowkidar caught a thief in the act of stealing a stereo from a Hyundai Verna, gathered hockey sticks to beat him up until the police came.

PSA: Postcolonial societies are not a canvas for Western liberals to project what they are uncomfortable about in their own societies but unable or unwilling to change. Our civilisation, culture, and polity do not exist for your benefit, to give you a sense of validation.

The Dalit experience is not analogous to that of African Americans, Indian Muslims are not analogous to the Roma, Brahmins are not analogous to WASPs, the BJP is not analogous to the Republicans, nor the Congress to the Democrats, nor Modi to Netanyahu, nor Rahul to Trudeau.

We have our own historical contexts, and are bound together by a shared colonial trauma. The Western paradigm of liberal-conservative or left-right is not something to superficially apply on postcolonial societies like India just because a journalist or scholar wants to inform their audience who the "good guys" and the "bad guys" are, because that's all they need to make sense of the world. Nuance be damned. Just so you know, all Indian parties are to some extent economically left-wing, all of them are to some extent socially conservative.

Our parties differentiate themselves through their strategies to address colonial trauma - some are focused on cultural revivalism, some on self-respect for indigenous philosophies, some promote parochial, regional, or subaltern interests, and some on enriching their founders.

This impression that the "liberal-conservative" divide in postcolonial societies is somehow analogous to Western politics is either projection by Western media and academics or a reflection of the deracination and mental colonisation of the Anglicised postcolonial elite, who act as the West's interlocutors to a set of indigenous cultures and languages they perceive as inferior.

It's not taxi drivers whose jobs are at risk from self-driving cars in India, it's English-media journalists who will be rendered unemployed, as their only window into the political or cultural views of India is conversations with the driver who picked them up from the airport.

If it were the case that these people genuinely cared about the left or liberal cause, and genuinely felt that they can't relate to Indian culture enough to be a part of politics in India, fair enough. Go to the UK, join a party, fight an election. Move to NY, write for the NYT.

If they did that, we would have respect for them, as we do for Dadabhai Naoroji. But the reality is, they won't do that. They can't do that. They are only useful to Western liberals as compradors and fixers who help them navigate Indian politics, history, or culture.

They can only get a column in the Graun, BBC, or WaPo if it's to shame other Indians and rob them of agency. Their awards for their journalism in India are merely pats on the head for being pliant. If they were actually respected, they would be entrusted with UK/US politics.

As soon as they stop toing the line or try to engage with politics in the West the way they report on India, they are brutally cut down to size. They don't get to host debates on CNN or the BBC. Because just like in their South Delhi homes, servants don't get to eat at the table.

Nobody takes them seriously outside of their established Uncle Tom role, simply because they have no self-respect. That is why all they can do is pontificate from a studio or newspaper column, write clickbait for the elite, or get into fistfights with subaltern Indians abroad.

-Ruchir Sharma

The Hypocrisy Of The Indian Elite And The Reactionary Brutality Behind Their Liberal Veneer

What The Media Gets Wrong About India: A Guide To The 2019 Elections

India Doesn’t Have A Cow Vigilante-Muslim Lynching Problem But A Mob Justice-Meat Mafia Problem That Can Be Solved


r/IndiaRWResources • • Dec 23 '20

HISTORY The mighty myth of Sikhs saving Hinduism The narrative of Sikhs coming to the aid of Hindus needs to be re-examined.

113 Upvotes

“Tumhari quam ke liye khade na hote, tumhari ma behan biwi ke liye lade na hote, to tumhare waris kabhi bade na hote” (If we have not stood for your religion, if we have not stood for your mothers, sisters and wives, your children would’ve never grown) said a fluffy face Sikh girl rhapsodically with laborious effort in an effort to sound savage – in a short video message; which was later shared by the best selling author from the Sikh community, Harinder S Sikka on his Twitter account. The sonorously angry girl with a discernible supremacist tone and dramatically plain expression continued to add a very casual threat – “Agar pata hota nazre humhi par hai to jis zameen ke taraf bad rahe ho, usi me gade na hote” (If it was known that your eyes are on us, then you would’ve been buried in the same land towards which you’re heading to).

Another one of the influential Sikhs – Yograj Singh, father of cricketer Yuvraj Singh – proudly regurgitated it with same rue – “we saved their women”. Recurrences of this theme – of Sikhs saving Hindus – has seen particular accretion in the past few years. The narrative – which has now turned into mammoth propaganda – is clearly short of any legitimacy at historic evaluations.

Since the start, till up to the 5th Guru, Sikhism had hardly established itself as a separate religion. It was seen more as a long extending branch of the great tree of Hinduism. And this branch, under the ruling, or rather guidance, of the earlier 5 gurus, was largely a peaceful one – not habitual to carrying arms & far away from proper militarisation. It was under the celebrated clans of Rajputs, particularly Rathores, that the militarisation of Sikhs was initiated. According to Sikhan di Bhagat Ratan Mala (written in the 17th century), Guru Hargobind was taught Shastarvidya by two Rajputs, namely Rao Sigara and Rao Jaita. His great-grandson Guru Govind Singh, the tenth Guru of Sikhs, was taught Shastra-Vidya by Rao Bajjar Singh Rathore, great-grandson of Rao Mandan Ji Rathore. And later Guru Govind’s kids were taught by Rai Alam Singh Chauhan, who, till today is considered as one of the finest generals to have ever lead Sikhs.

The most prominent of names, under the Sikhs saving Hinduism claim, is of the tenth Guru, Govind Singh. However, history around him is not as simple as has been painted over the years with a thick bold brush. When his father Guru Teg Bahadur, who later became the ninth Guru, was facing heavy opposition from other Sikh groups against heading the Sikh community; it was Sawai Jai Singh who supported and played a crucial role in ensuring his elevation to the top. The same Sawai Jai Singh also, along with Rana Raj Singh, saved Guru Teg Bahadur from the evil clutches of Aurangzeb and gifted Gurudwara Bangla Saheb to the Sikhs.

As per Guru Govind Singh’s own confession in the Zafarnama – a letter, of him to the tyrant Mughal ruler Aurangzeb, with a complex set of challenging and pleasing words of pure puffery – Guru Govind was an ‘idol-breaker’.

“I vanquished the vicious hill chiefs, they were idol-worshippers and I am idol-breaker,” he said as per the verse 95.

Aurangzeb was sufficiently pleased with the letter for he ordered his governor Wazir Khan – who was in conflict with Guru Govind prior to the letter exchange – not to trouble the Guru anymore. One of the instances of Wazir Khan troubling Guru Govind comes at the famous battle site of the Chamkaur-sahib, in 1704, when Guru Govind, after being chased by Wazir Khan and 700 horsemen and losing his 40+ men and 2 young sons, was in a hapless and life-threatening situation. If it wasn’t for Roop Chand & Jagat Singh – the two Hindu Rajputs of Kachhawaha clan – who provided protection & refuge to the Guru, darkness would have swooped the time frame.

Guru’s conflict with the hill Rajas was not confined only to words. His men had plundered the domains of the semi-autonomous Hindu Rajas in the Punjab hills, some of them being the same who gave Guru Govind asylum post his father’s execution.

Similar contrasting records to the recent narrative can also be seen in events relating to another Sikh Guru, Hargobind Singh, the 5th Guru. When Guru Hargobind was released from Gwalior jail in February 1620, he had with him the company of 52 Rajput princes of the Rathore clan. These Rajputs then went on to raise an army of 700 horsemen for the protection of the ruling house of Sikhs. The local Jagirdars of Punjab – who, being unhappy after Guru Hargobind’s release from Gwalior, had struck an alliance with Mughal governor Abdul Khan – attacked Guru at Rohilla, in, what later came to be known as the first battle of the Sikhs. Luckily for the Sikhs and the Guru, Rajputs under Rao Mandan Ji Rathore were standing as the bulwark in between. The Mughal governor was badly defeated and Jagirdars, the enemies, were made to flee. Subsequently, the Sikh Guru was saved & protected by the mighty and glorious among the already battle-hardened Rajputs.

Another of such instances of effort and sacrifice by Hindus for the Sikh Guru can be seen when in 1628 CE Guru Hargobind visited Raja of Bilaspur Kalyan Chand at his capital Kot-Kehloor. Raja gave him patronage along with the village of Kiratpur and Kalyanpur as Jagir. The Mughal Emperor Jahangir, taking serious objection to it, asked the Raja to remove the Guru from the hill state of Kehloor, to which the Raja refused. Later Raja Kalyan Chand shifted his capital from Kot-Kehloor to Sunhani (Bilaspur), but didn’t renege from his stance[1].

In modern propaganda, both the contributions of Hindus in saving Sikhs is often sidelined and slipped under the carpet.

And the other who can’t be ignored gets appropriated. As with Banda Bahadur, the man who slaughtered Afghans and Mughals greatly and protected the Sikh Guru, is now being claimed by some as Sikh. While he was a Hindu Rajput (of the Manhas Clan) and was born as Lakshman Dev. The first Sikh state was created by him. As part of a Bairag Vaishnav sect, he had an ashram of his own, where Sikhs used to throw meat and slaughter goats. Infuriated with which his contempt against those Sikhs increased and is apparently seen in verses (18, 19, 20, 21) of Sri Gur Panth Prakash. Verses tell that Banda Singh had written that he was no longer a follower of the Guru but now of Bairagi Vaishno seat. Adding that he harassed and tortured those Sikhs as brutally as they had slaughtered goats in his monastery.

No single caste or community holds the exclusive prerogative to wear the badge of saviours of Hinduism. The safety, security and prosperity of Hinduism has been and is a collective effort. There is no “Assi Hindua Nu Bachaya Si”.

https://pragyata.com/the-mighty-myth-of-sikhs-saving-hinduism/


r/IndiaRWResources • • Apr 22 '21

Chattisgarh had all early signs of the covid surge and ignored CM Bhupesh Baghel still blames Modi for not warning on the second wave ahead of time

112 Upvotes

Sept 13, 2020: Central Govt asks 7 big states to ensure adequate oxygen supply - Maharashtra, Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, Telangana, Gujarat, Rajasthan and Madhya Pradesh.

Tweet from The Print | Article from The Print

Jan 7, 2021: Central Govt asks Bengal, Chattisgarh, Maharashtra and Kerala to remain vigil on new spike and rising covid cases.

Tweet from The Print | Article from The Print

Jan 11, 2021: Chattisgarh Health Minister says his govt won't allow use of Covaxin unless trials are over

Article from Times of India

16 Mar 2021: Chattisgarh starts using Covaxin, a month after debating on efficacy

Article from Hindustan Times

18 Mar 2021: The Wire points out Chattisgarh administration is relaxed on covid and the CM is busy campaigning in Assam.

https://thewire.in/government/chhattisgarh-covid-19-bhupesh-baghel

21 April 2021: Modi govt didn't alert states on 2nd covid wave, else we could have prepared: Chattisgarh CM Bhupesh Baghel

Tweet from Shekhar Gupta lauding his young journalists| Article from The Print

Shamika Ravi pointing out facts - https://twitter.com/ShamikaRavi/status/1385134427978702853

PS> didn't like quoting from The Wire or The Print, but wanted to give them the taste of their own medicine.


r/IndiaRWResources • • Aug 28 '21

HINDUISM What is Wrong in India becoming a Hindu Rashtra?

111 Upvotes

In this brilliant short article, Khalid Umar writes on the possibility of the creation of Hindu Rashtra. Liberals often tell scary stories about holocausts and genocides of minorities in India if the Hindu Rashtra is ever created. Khalid Umar, instead claims that it is the creation of Hindu Rashtra that will ensure peace and progress of every community owing to the Hindu ethos of the country.

It is alleged that Narendra Modi and the BJP want to make India a Hindu State. If that is so, I question, what is wrong about India being a Hindu Rashtra?

Bharatvarsh, a civilization as old as 5000 years, needs no introduction of it being the original homeland sheltering 95% of all the Hindus in the world and birth place of Sanatan Hinduism. India should not be shy of recognizing her identity as a Hindu Nation. Hinduism is the 3rd largest religion in the world after Christianity and Islam. But it is not demographically as widely spread on the world’s map as the first two. 97% percent of all Hindus live in the world’s three Hindu-majority countries (India, Mauritius and Nepal). It is the most geographically concentrated of all the major religious. 95% of the Hindu population lives in India whereas only 1.6% of Muslims live in Arabia, the birthplace of Islam.

The left-liberals have no problems with the 53 Muslim dominated countries (Islam is the official religion in 27) in the world; 100+ Christian dominated countries. In 15 nations, Christianity is the official religion. These Christian nations include England, Greece, and Iceland, Norway, Hungary, Denmark. and 6 Buddhist countries. Israel is a Jewish state. But, when it comes to India, their rationale fails to make me understand as to why Hinduism can’t be state religion of India?

There is no evidence that threatens the secular ethos of the country, if India is declared a Hindu State. All faiths have flourished in India, including Parsis, Jains, Sikhs, Muslims, Zoroastrians because Hindus are not intolerant towards other religion.

One can go to a religious place associated to any religion and find Hindus there. There is no concept of conversion in Hinduism. There are Christian and Muslim nations in the world who raise voice on the Human Rights abuses and religious persecution of Muslims and Christians the world over. The world remembers Myanmar, Palestine, Yemen etc. but not the Hindus & Sikhs of Pakistan or Afghanistan or that of other Islamic nations! Does anyone remember what happened with the Hindus in Bangladesh during the 1971 genocide by Pakistan Army or the Pundits in Kashmir or the 1998 Wandhama massacre of J&K, systemic elimination of Hindus in Pakistan, the elimination of historic temples and Hinduism in the Arab world, e.g. in Muscat?

The policies of the Indian state have been anti-secular. There has been blatant religious reverse-discrimination against Hindus, its majority community. There are many examples. Have you heard about the Hajj Subsidy? Since 2000, over 1.5 million Muslims used the subsidy. It was only that the Supreme Court passed an order that directed the government to phase out this subsidy within 10 years. Which secular country will subsidize religious tourism for one faith group? The average airfare subsidy was (US$1,000) per Muslim pilgrim in 2008.

While the Indian Government was supporting their citizens’ religious tourism, Saudi Arabia, a country where Hindu icons are condemned as idol worship, was spreading Wahabi extremism worldwide. Hindus are not permitted to build temples and Indian tax payer money was being used to facilitate the Saudi economy by pilgrimage subsidies.

In a truly secular country, all citizens irrespective of religion would be covered by a single set of laws. In India, however, people of different religion beliefs are covered by different personal laws. Government control temples but mosques and churches are autonomous. There were subsidies for Hajj but not for Amarnath Yatra or Kumbh Mela. A truly secular country would not subsidize any pilgrimage at all!

Hindus have always welcomed and protected minorities. Let’s have a look at its history of tolerance. The Hindu Community of India welcomed Parsis when they were persecuted the world over. They have flourished here for over a thousand years. The Jewish tribes found refuge in Bharat nearly 2000 years ago and same goes for Syrian Christians 1800 years ago. The Jains, Buddhists being religions derivatives of the Hinduism have co-existed for 2500 years and Sikhs for 400 years.

It’s time to look back at the facts to feel proud to be a Hindu, not shy anymore!

Even today, India is secular, not due to a Constitutional amendment of 1976 and lawyers and law makers, but because the majority of the people of India are Hindus. It is the very nature of this religion that ensures secularism, not a piece of paper that came into account after thousands of years of tolerant practice. India should openly declare itself as a “Hindu” (Hindu/Sikh/Jain) nation. India should interfere to protect the interests of all of the aforementioned people because no other country is doing it.

Declaring Hindu nation will open new door of safeguarding the majority against forced conversion and minority appeasement. India will remain a progressive country only till it remains a secular country. And it will remain a secular country only if Hindu domination persists in its demographics. Secularism and Hinduism are two sides of one coin. You toss it, in either ways you win!

If India becomes a Hindu Rashtra, that would be the best thing to happen. There would become a Uniform Civil Code with no allowances for anyone (including Hindus). Rule of Law has always been one of the main reasons for Growth in any country- Germany, Japan, USA are all based on rule of law. Conversions (to and against) will be banned, proselytizing which is the root cause of religious friction will stop; no Tablighis anymore. Once conversions are stopped, each person can follow whatever religion he chooses or choose to be atheist (there is a sect called- Nir Ishwara Vad in Hinduism itself). Show me another religion that recognizes non-practitioners of the faith with such regards!

Secularism and religious tolerance is the ethos of the inhabitants of this region much before the Muslim invaders ransacked this land. Muslim invasions into the Indian subcontinent started around 1000 AD and they lasted for several centuries till 1739. Destruction of about 100 million Hindus is perhaps the biggest holocaust in the whole world history. Hindus did not take any revenge of from the off springs of these invaders. It is not Hinduism but the implementation of pseudo-Secularism which is causing interfaith friction between the Hindu majority and the Muslims. In a Hindu Rashtra, the religious freedom of the Non-Hindus will not be clipped.

Hindus must take pride in the history of the land they belong to. They must resort to facts to sort out frictions. They shying away from reality will result into disaster of a land that has its sheer ethos and rich culture of tolerance deeply etched in its soil. India has been foolish enough to give away precious slices to fulfill the demands of Muslim Nations. India has been tolerant enough to practice appeasement in the name of secularism. It time now Hindus must UNITE proclaiming the peace they inherit in them. A Hindu Rashtra, that values secularism through its very nature of practice, devoid of any preamble, will be a citing example for the world.

The time is NOW.

----------------------------------

Source: https://cisindus.org/2020/04/15/what-is-wrong-in-india-becoming-a-hindu-rashtra/


r/IndiaRWResources • • Feb 16 '21

DEFENSE Nikita Jacob states she worked on GretaKit as part of anarchist ExtinctionRebellion with stated aim "To build structure, community, and test prototypes in preparation for structural collapse of western “democracies”" Who funds XR?Greenpeace, OilHeiress Getty,Soros (tabulated by XRFinland's bulletin)

110 Upvotes

r/IndiaRWResources • • Mar 24 '21

HISTORY Wrongfully Accused: The Swastika Is Not Hitler's Hakenkreuz

108 Upvotes

BUT, WAS IT THE SWASTIKA? Yet, while the symbol appeared similar, it was not the Swastika. My research on this topic led me to the works of many scholars, including Rev. T.K. Nakagaki, former President of the Buddhist Council of New York. Nakagaki’s book The Buddhist Swastika and Hitler’s Cross: Rescuing a Symbol of Peace from the Forces of Hate, provides exhaustive details about the Swastika as well as its wrongful association with the Hakenkreuz, the symbol used by Hitler and the Nazis. According to Nakagaki,

“Many in the West believe that Hitler invented the swastika symbol. He didn’t. Many also believe he invented the word ‘swastika’ to describe it. He didn’t do that either. But, he did consciously use a different German word, ‘Hakenkreuz,’ and that is more significant because in the use of that word we can see how Hitler saw the symbol…”

Hakenkreuz at the Benedictine Monastery, Lambach, Austria

Similarly, Dr. Daniel Rancour-Laferriere, an expert on Christianity and Professor Emeritus at University of California Davis, provides plethora of evidence regarding Hitler’s Christian upbringing and the influence of Christian symbolism on him. In his book The Sign of the Cross: From Golgotha to Genocide Rancour-Laferriere shows that Hitler’s decision to use the Hakenkreuz as a symbol of the Nazi party may have been due to his childhood upbringing at the Benedictine Monastery in Austria, where he repeatedly saw the “hooked cross” in multiple places, and used to see a statue of Abbot Theoderich von Hagen, who had a stylized Hakenkreuz in the coat of arms.

Furthermore, Rancour-Laferriere points out the mistranslation of Hakenkreuz into Swastika, even though a native German speaker can easily understand that the infamous term is translated as “hook” (Haken) “cross” (Kreuz). Rancour-Laferriere observes: “It cannot be disputed that, as a boy, Adolf Hitler repeatedly saw the hooked cross in the Christian context of the Benedictine Catholic Monastery where he had his choir lessons and other classes…”

Rancour-Laferriere’s book discusses the work of Werner Maser, a famous German historian and a leading expert on Hitler who observed that in an early notebook of Hitler, we find a sketch of a projected book cover featuring the hooked cross which looked similar to what would become the Nazi flag of the future. Maser believed that the hooked cross and the banner reflected the influence of the Hakenkreuz that Hitler saw at Lambach Abbey and on the coat of arms of Abbot Hagen.

To illustrates this further, German historian John Vincent Palatine discusses Hitler’s affinity for the monastery, his admiration for the Abbot and his constant encounters with the Hakenkreuz at the monastery. In his article, The Oedipus Factor — Alois Hitler and his son Adolf, Palatine outlines Hitler’s childhood experiences as follows:

“Lambach had a quite modern primary school in which Adolf did well…He also participated in the monastery’s boys’ choir, where he, probably for the first time in his life, saw the [hooked cross]. The depiction was part of a previous abbot’s coat of arms, a huge specimen of which was fastened to the stone arch over the abbey’s entrance, which the boys had to pass under on the way to choir practice…”

Using Hitler’s own words from Mein Kampf, Palatine illustrates the young dictator’s admiration for the church and the Abbot:

“Again and again I enjoyed the best possibility of intoxicating myself with the solemn splendour (sic) of the dazzling festivals of the church. It seemed to me perfectly natural to regard the abbot as the highest and more desirable ideal, just as my father regarded the village priest as his ideal.”

Palatine goes on to state the impression that the Hakenkreuz had left on Hitler’s mind:

“One thing [Hitler] clearly kept in mind was the [hooked cross] he had discovered on the abbot’s coat of arms. The original bearer of the coat, Abbot Theoderich von Hagen, had been the prior of the monastery in the middle of the preceding century, and the [symbol] was not only featured on his coat but was found at many places in the structure as an element of decoration.”

Similarly, Rancour-Laferriere points us to the writings of Robert Payne, the famous biographer of Hitler’s life, who also surmised that the Hakenkreuz at the monastery was the source of Hitler’s Nazi emblem.

In order to understand why Hitler chose the Hakenkreuz and not any other symbol, one must study the importance and usage of this symbol in Christianity and in German literature, as well as the dynamics surrounding racial and theological narratives in nineteenth century Europe and Germany.

Hooked Cross in Christianity

The hooked cross holds deep significance in Christianity, and can be found across Europe and other places where Christianity is practiced, from the tombs of the Knights Templar to mosaic on the floor of the Byzantine Church in Shavei-Zion, on the walls of the Lalibela Church in Ethiopia, in churches in Mexico and in Macedonia, etc. The hooked cross was seen as the symbol of Jesus’ victory over death and persecution.

Thus, for Hitler, who was exposed to such teachings at the Lambach Abbey, it was quite natural to see this connection and twist it into a powerful yet evil symbol known to the masses and one that could be easily repurposed to arouse anti-Jewish emotions among the Volk.

Please read the full essay here:

https://cohna.org/swastika-is-not-hakenkreuz/


r/IndiaRWResources • • Mar 13 '21

MEDIA Bollywood’s passive-aggressive attitude towards Hinduism. Excellent writeup by Amrit Hallan.

106 Upvotes

My daughter was insisting that we watch “funny videos” on YouTube (casting on TV) while she had her scrambled egg breakfast and waited for her math teacher to show up. When I started the YouTube app, I came across the trailer of the upcoming Amitabh Bachchan-Rishi Kapoor flick, 102 Not Out. I like both the actors, so I insisted that before we proceeded to funny videos, we should watch the trailer.

They show lots of stuff in the trailer and eventually, they show that Rishi Kapoor’s character is going through some existential dilemma and he ends up sitting in a church. Something in the scene put me off and without making it apparent to my daughter, I changed the video quickly and loaded one of the funny videos she was insisting on watching.

After reading what I’m writing, you may think that I am raking up some conspiracy theory or, I’m one of those “Right Wing” Sanghis constantly demonizing minorities and claiming that Hinduism is being targeted.

My grandmother often used to say that before my birth, she had never seen a disabled person. After my birth, she could spot people with disabilities everywhere (because I was born with a disability). My disability sensitized her towards a part of worldly reality she was totally oblivious to simply because she hadn’t experienced it herself.

Something of the same sort happens when you have been sensitized towards a particular issue: you begin to recognize patterns that others can’t. Of course, sometimes you begin to see patterns where none exist because you are too eager to find those patterns. But sometimes these patterns are too obvious.

In the above-mentioned movie, why did Rishi Kapoor’s character sit inside a church? Why not in a temple? Is he a Christian? If yes, why does the theme have to be about Christian characters? Would the characters look uncool had they been temple-going Hindus? Do the makers of the movie think the urban audience won’t be able to relate to temple-going characters?

Being one of the major religions in India, why should there be a problem if a character in an Indian movie sits in a church, whether he or she is a Christian or not? Of course, in an ideal world, in a world where all communities are treated equally, all religions are respected, and thousands of organizations are not converting the crap out of unsuspecting people, there shouldn’t be a problem. The character can be from a tiny tribal religion from Andaman Nicobar Islands whose followers shoot arrows at helicopters thinking that they are giant birds, for all I care.

>I’m talking about the pattern. I’m talking about the passive-aggressive attitude that manifests in Bollywood films, advertisements, and even popular literature. But, here I’m just focusing on Bollywood.

Take for example the above-mentioned movie 102 Not Out. Yoga is made fun of. The grumpy, grouchy, lazy and timid character played by Rishi Kapoor who has no zest for life does anulom-vilom. Amitabh Bachchan’s character mocks the swaas-kriya. Subtle, but such things make strong imprints.

My wife and daughter went to see Hichki recently, a story about a woman with Tourrette Syndrome who wants to become a teacher in a school. Wherever she goes she faces rejection. Guess who gives her a chance; a Muslim principal of a Christian school. Yup.

PK. Yes, I know plenty has been written on the film but no harm in repeating it. When many Hindus started protesting that in the film Hindu gods, especially Shiva, are ridiculed, the makers of the film insisted that all religions are questioned in the film and to an extent, they are right.

The small difference is, whereas all the religions are questioned, Hinduism is ridiculed, and the ridicule is highlighted in a long sequence when one of the greatest Hindu gods, Shiva (a person acting as Shiva in a nautanki, not actual Shiva) is shown crawling under the seats or hiding in a toilet.

Remember that a movie is a visual medium. Visuals make a great impact.

Talking about visuals, I remember the first visual of a Brahmin scolding a lower caste and making all sorts of violent gestures just because the person of the lower caste accidentally bumps into him in a black-and-white movie. That made an imprint for a long time and whenever I saw a Brahmin or whenever I read about a Brahmin, that image popped inside my head. Of course, all the atrocity literature that you constantly come across played an important role too. Until I started reading alternative literature I always had this underlying negative attitude towards Brahmins.

Visuals are very important. If you can see the pattern, you will notice how Bajirao Peshwa has been depicted in Bajirao-Mastani, how Maharawal is shown in Padmavati, and then contrast, how Akbar is shown in Jodha-Akbar. These visuals are meant for your subconscious.

Coming back to PK, whereas, when the central character of the film PK questions other religions, he is not questioning their gods or making fun of their gods, he is simply questioning the way people try to placate the gods or try to make profit out of people’s blind belief.

But when it comes to a Hindu god, the very existence of the gods is questioned, and not just questioned, ridiculed, lampooned. Even the main godman in the end who questions and torments the female character is a Hindu, and not a Muslim or a Christian. If you say this is because maybe the female character was a Hindu, then in this case, why not have a Muslim female character or a Christian female character? There was no particular reason for the female character to be a Hindu, just like there is no particular reason for Rishi Kapoor’s character in 102 Not Out to seek solace in a temple rather than a church.

The Bollywood template for creating anti-Hindu movies and TV series

— Name the characters Ram, Krishna, Shiva or any other Hindu God and then make other characters call them names, or make the characters named after Hindu gods do nasty things.

— Show the hero entering the temple or interacting with the deity as if he is doing a favor by coming to the temple. The body language, the smug look on the face, nothing tells that the person has a trace of devotion.

— A nice person who comes to help the hero or his family is always a Muslim or a Christian — this is highlighted by the way the person plays or through the surroundings.

— When a destitute child in a movie is adopted, he/she is always adopted or sheltered by a pious Christian or Muslim, never buy a pious Hindu.

— If a kid studies in a good school, it is always a Christian missionary school with fathers and sisters moving around wearing cloaks.

— A person who speaks fluent English is educated and smart. A person who speaks fluent Urdu is cultured, refined and literary. A person who speaks fluent Hindi is either a comedian or a conniving, vile person.

— Make subtle, disparaging remarks such as what stupid rituals you have or what silly gods you have.

— Question religious practices and rites when they are taking place, create doubt and in general, create an atmosphere of cynicism around those practices and rites.

— Show a person misbehaving or doing a very filthy act immediately after praying in front of a Hindu deity or coming out of the temple.

— Never show religiously Hindu person doing good deeds.

— Create special circumstances where a person chanting a Hindu prayer is also doing something nasty such as stealing, beating up or misbehaving. On the other hand, a person chanting a Christian or a Muslim prayer is always dignified and up to some serious work, even if illegal.

— A good message or an inspiring manifestation comes to the protagonist only in the form of a Christian or a Muslim scripture, never from a Hindu scripture.

— Make fun of Hindu gods in the name of tolerance and sense of humor but never apply the same yardstick to other religions.

You may say that Hindus themselves lampoon their gods and goddesses especially during Ramlila and other religious festivals, and even in various film comedies, but this is primarily the impact of a lopsided and motivated popular culture. If you don’t take your gods seriously, you don’t take your religion seriously, and when you don’t take your religion seriously, it is easier to convert you.

Have you seen Judwa 2? In the movie there is a song Ganpati Bappa Moriya Pareshaan Karen Mujhe Chhoriya. Now, what sense does it make to make the central character of the movie sing such a song in a temple in front of the gigantic idol of Ganpati? The character repeatedly turns his back towards the idol and condescendingly folds his hands behind his head as if doing a favour to the idol by folding his hands. Visuals. Subconscious.

Can the same feat, especially in India, be carried out in a church or in a mosque? If yes, well, there is nothing to argue about.

Why don’t Muslims lampoon their god? In Western societies, whereas Christians do lampoon Jesus, in India the story is totally different. Why don’t Sikhs lampoon their 10 gurus? Have you ever seen Buddha or Mahavira being lampooned? No.

In the name of broad-mindedness Hindus have been made to believe that it is okay to make fun of their gods. But then, if it is okay to make fun of gods, I will ask you again, why isn’t it okay to make fun of a Muslim god or a Christian god (in India) or a Sikh guru? Can we ever have a movie showing Allah, Jesus and Guru Gobind Singh Ji goofing around? Theatres will be burned, and people will be killed.

On the occasion of Hanuman Jayanti the Indian wrestling champion Babita Phogat posted this tweet along with Lord Hanuman’s image:

In the tweet she says that her every act and success is due to the blessings of Bajrangbali, and people think that she is lucky. She never wrestles without seeking blessings of Bajrangbali.

Almost all Hindu wrestlers pray to Hanuman regularly, especially before a match. Even many non-Hindu wrestlers are Hanuman devotees. I remember when one of my cousins started wrestling, he became a Hanuman devotee (he’s a Sikh).

Almost every rural and urban wrestling akhara/gym has a Hanuman idol at some prominent location. He is the god of wrestlers in India.

Hanuman is my favourite Hindu god and just out of love and emotional connection, I wanted to see what sort of comments people had left. After scrolling a bit, I came across this comment from someone:

In case you’re not aware of the context, a movie was made on the story of the Phogat Sisters called Dangal (rural wrestling contest). So, the above twitter update mentions that if Lord Hanuman has such a prominent place in her life, why isn’t it even once mentioned in the movie? A movie about wrestling. No Hanuman. Not even once.

[Update — July 9, 2019 begins]

In a recent article on Dharma Dispatch Sandeep has explained how in Deewaar a Muslim symbol, the number 786 has been inserted for passive brainwashing. The number 786 has a strong religious significance among Muslims and in fact, in the movie, an aged Muslim character equates the number 786 with the Hindu chant “Om”. The number, the aged Muslim and in the movie explains, represents the word “Inshallah”.

Here is how a parallel is drawn between Hinduism and Islam and then it is proven that you are better off following Islam than Hinduism. In the movie, the mother (Nirupa Roy) of the protagonist (Amitabh Bachchan) all her life goes to a Shiva temple to pray and seek blessings. Amitabh Bachchan is an atheist or maybe he has a bitter feeling towards the god and never goes to the temple and makes a point to badmouth the god.

He works in a factory and wears a badge number 786. Despite him being an atheist and despite being told that the number has a religious significance, he never discards the badge and in fact, the badge saves him from bullets when the bad guys shoot at him. The power of you know who.

On the other hand, all the while visiting the temple, the mother goes through all sorts of hardships and eventually, almost dies. This is when Amitabh Bachchan goes to the temple and pleads to Shiva that He should not punish his mother for his sins. Hence, Shiva is punishing and harsh. The other god on the other hand is just fine with Amitabh Bachchan carrying around the badge with the right number.

Shiva also has an ego. Amitabh Bachchan says, “Khush to bohut hoge tum…” — You must be very happy that now you have forced me to visit you and plead to you.

You can read the whole analysis here.

Deewaar: Disarming Hindus via Billa No. 786 | The Dharma Dispatch

[Update — July 9, 2019 ends]

Remember Tamas? The TV series became a rage when it was broadcast in the 80s or early 90s. The book is written by Bhishm Sahni. Recently we found the TV series on YouTube and decided to watch it because we thought it is a gripping story based on the violence that happened during India-Pakistan partition. There is so much anti-Hindu propaganda in the movie that after a few minutes everything became so absurd that we decided not to watch it.

The story begins two weeks before the partition takes place. In the beginning, they show that the character played by Om Puri is trying to kill a pig. Although by profession he is someone who skins dead animals, he is ordered to slaughter a pig by some powerful person and he has no choice but to kill the animal. It is a very long, frustrating, 10 minute sequence.

Remember, visuals.

For 10 minutes and more, you see this person, in darkness, in all ugliness of poverty, with all sorts of awful facial expressions in close-up covering the entire TV screen, trying to kill a pig that doesn’t want to be killed, with a knife/ The dead pig is taken away by the man of the powerful person.

Then later on, it is discovered that someone has thrown a pig in front of a mosque and there is tension in their town. He can see that it is the same pig.

Then the news comes that someone has slaughtered a cow in front of a temple. How do they show the scene? Some person, you cannot even make out whether he is a Muslim or not, quickly runs across the frame of the screen with a cow. That’s it. It’s a hardy 2-second scene.

Then they show something like the Hindu Mahasabha and the youth being radicalized. It is a complete half-an-hour sequence in which a timid youth is forced to decapitate a chicken because eventually, he will have to kill the “enemies”. He goes through a complete transformation and turns into a maniac. He takes references from Ramayana and Mahabharata and talks about using bows and arrows with the capacity of causing light and tender. He goes totally demented, constantly referencing to Hindu mythology and divine weapons.

Then the youth and his friends declare that a war has started between them and the “enemies”. They are even ready to kill their own. To show their seriousness, they must kill an enemy. It is a tense scene. They’re hiding in a room in an alley. Then an innocent Muslim perfume seller turns up and the group of youths decide to kill him. We couldn’t watch beyond that. It was insane.

To portray one side totally dark, they have gone to ridiculous lengths. They didn’t even care that at that point, the program seemed like it had been recorded by a bunch of kids, so silly were the dialogues and individual scenes. Throughout the series, the Muslim violence is shown from a distance or as reference, or as noises.

>Now that I think of it, it is so scary.

Have you seen Guide? Raju, the character played by Devanand, goes to a village and is confronted by two rotund and cunning-looking Hindu Brahmins. The pathetic looking Brahmins are constantly shown taking poor, illiterate villagers for a ride, fleecing money out of them and intimidating them with superstition. Then Raju has a debate, in English with the Brahmins. Of course, nobody understands English, not even the Brahmins, but everyone is so impressed by the fact that Raju can speak English, that the Brahmin duo flees in panic. They are literally chased by lathi-wielding villagers. What does this tell you as a young person?

While constantly trying to find some Bollywood movies that we can watch together as a family, we were watching Kalia, one of my favorite childhood movies.

As if every movie is a conversion opportunity, in the movie, the niece of Amitabh’s character studies in a Christian boarding school. The sister of Parvin Baby also studies the same boarding school but since suddenly, her situation has changed she can no longer pay the fee.

There is a prolonged sequence of the Principal (a nun) praising Christ and praying Him to send a “farishta” to help the poor girl. The “farishta”, in the form of Amitabh’s character, immediately comes and then she praises how Christ pays attention to every one’s plight.

In a jail scene, when the jailer boasts that even the most dreaded criminals bow their heads in front of him, Amitabh’s character proclaims that his head only bows in front of the Almighty. The way dialogues have been carefully crafted in such a manner that during the entire exchange, he talks as if he is a Christian or Muslim and not a Hindu.

In a Bollywood movie, when was the last time you saw a devout Hindu priest being kind to someone, or finding an orphan and raising him or her, or simply doing lots of good stuff? You won’t be able to recall. Can’t a Hindu priest or a Brahmin or a godman ever be noble, righteous and benevolent? How is it possible that amidst such a big community, Bollywood movie makers cannot conceive even a single such character?

On the other hand, you can immediately recall a Christian padre or a devout Muslim raising an orphan or giving an overwhelmingly nice advice to the hero or the heroine of the movie, or even dying for a cause or for the central character of the movie. There are plenty of such characters. In Dhool Ka Phool it is a Muslim who raises the orphan child. In Dost it is a Christian father who raises the character of Dharmendra.

In Yaadon Ki Baraat, when the young character of Dharmendra is hungry and desolate and there is no one to help him, suddenly a young boy sporting a white skullcap appears, steals food for him, and feeds him. Why couldn’t a Hindu boy wearing a Hindu topi appear out of nowhere? Again, the visual plays a very important part.

I’m not saying such instances are impossible to find in Bollywood movies, but you will really need to make an effort to find them, whereas, the examples mentioned above can be found aplenty.

When was the last time you saw a Hindu priest or a Hindu sadhu molesting a helpless woman or being nasty to people around him or indulging in all sorts of vile activities? Plenty of such instances.

In Roti Kapada Aur Makaan, what exactly was the need to show a person wearing bhagwa (safron clothing) when Moushmi Chatterjee’s character is tragically gang raped? Would the scene be less traumatic without such a person being one of the rapists?

When was the last time you saw a devout Christian or a devout Muslim (or even pretending to be one) molesting a woman or being nasty? You won’t be able to recall, because there is none. If there was any, there is a 100% chance that the movie was banned or something.

Amar Akbar Anthony. Three small kids get separated. One is adopted by a Christian Father, another is adopted by a Muslim person, and third, well, no idea, but since he is called Amar, let’s assume either he wasn’t adopted at all or some Hindu adopted him, but it is never shown.

Anthony is shown multiple times interacting with the Father in the church and even talking to Jesus. Akbar is shown in a Muslim atmosphere. He is also shown singing in a Dargah and flaunting religious garb and moving among Muslim men and women.

Amar simply exists. He has no other identity. He is never shown in the proximity of a Hindu god. He doesn’t have a Hindu guardian. There is nothing in the movie to show that in some way highlights the Hindu religion. Hindi language. If there are chaste Urdu dialogues and poetry in a movie, it signifies romance and high-class. In most of the mainstream movies, chaste Hindi and poetry either means a low-budget religious flick or cult movie, or a comedy.

Similarly, characters speaking fluent English or fluent Urdu are earnest, and are to be respected, but characters speaking fluent Hindi, for example Amitabh Bachchan’s character in Chupke Chupke, carries a funny tinge and hence, shouldn’t be taken seriously, and in fact, wherever possible, should be made fun of.

You can find plenty of mainstream songs using incomprehensible Urdu and even Arabic words and phrases and again, they are a mark of high-class and erudition. A purely Hindi song becomes a comedy song.

Rukh se, zara naqab uthado mere huzur, dripping with cultured Urdu vocabulary, is romantic and mellifluous and even high-grade poetry, Priye praneshwari, hrideshwari, in pure Hindi, is used as a comedy song.

Who the hell knows the meaning of Zihaale-e-masti Makun ba Ranjish? Still, this song is sung with great flair. Or for that matter, how many people are supposed to know the meaning of Nukta-chin hai gham-e dil?

The upcoming Meghna Gulzar movie, Raazi, is completely in Urdu. Yes, the theme of the movie is such that there is a Muslim girl who is sent to Pakistan as an Indian spy so, of course, the primary language would be Urdu. Maybe when Muslim characters are talking to each other or when the Muslim girl is in Pakistan. But why does everyone talk in pure Urdu? Even the characters who might not be Muslim? Have people stopped speaking Hindi at all? Or is it an Urdu movie (which should be fine if it is, but they should say it so).

In many mainstream movies you must have seen the hero adorning achkan-churidaar pajama. That was hot couture and stylish. You could see suave heroes like Rajesh Khanna, Raj Kapur, Rajender Kumar and Sunil Dutt courting damsels. Whether one lived in Mumbai, Delhi or Kolkata, it was kosher to wear such dresses. But come dhoti-kurta and it would be either a ganwaar hero who is a gaonwala, or a scheming mama who would torment the family of the hero or the heroine.

Again, I’m pretty sure, if you cannot detect the pattern, if you are not sensitive towards the existence of this pattern, maybe what I’m trying to say here will not make sense.

>There is an entire culture under siege, and people don’t even realize it.

https://amrithallan.medium.com/bollywoods-passive-aggressive-attitude-towards-hinduism-c6c883a0ed


r/IndiaRWResources • • Jun 23 '21

DEFENSE Unclassified CIA docs revealed 72 regime change ops by US during 1949-2000;most of these against other democratic states.Meddling in elections by funding/propaganda was the most successful strategy with win of US-backed party 75% of the time.Covert regime changes usually devastated target nations

105 Upvotes

As per the book "Meddling in the Ballot Box: The Causes and Effects of Partisan Electoral Intervention" by Doh H Levin,

The U.S. has intervened in the most elections between 1946 to 2000: 81 elections in total, followed by the Soviet Union/Russia with 36 examples of interference.

Electoral interventions have occurred in the elections of at least 60 different countries of all sizes and populations.

the U.S. has been a bit more likely to intervene in elections in Asia, while Russia (or the Soviet Union) has been more likely to meddle in European elections.

https://eu.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/elections/2020/09/04/u-s-interferes-more-elections-than-russia-meddling-author-says/5700657002/

Lindsey A. O’Rourke, assistant professor of international politics at Boston College, carried out similar studies of US unclassified documents and concluded that

The U.S. tried to change other countries’ governments 72 times during the Cold War and mostly targets other democracies for regime change.

She says:

Obviously, studying covert interventions is tough. By definition, the operations are designed so that the intervening state can plausibly deny it was involved, deflecting blame onto other actors. It’s impossible to get reliable cross-national data, given how widely countries vary in their rules about government transparency and freedom of the press. Add in flourishing conspiracy theories, and it can be hard to separate historical fact from fiction.

To tackle these problems, I have spent the past several years investigating allegations of U.S.-backed covert regime changes during the Cold War. I’ve done so by going through relevant documents from the National Archives, National Security Archive and presidential libraries. Fortunately, the combination of the U.S. government’s declassification rules, congressional inquiries and journalistic coverage has revealed a great deal about these operations.

Between 1947 and 1989, the United States tried to change other nations’ governments 72 times. That’s a remarkable number. It includes 66 covert operations and six overt ones.

Success depended in large part on the choice of covert tactics. Not a single U.S.-backed assassination plot during this time actually killed their intended target, although two foreign leaders — South Vietnam’s Ngo Dinh Diem and the Dominican Republic’s Rafael Trujillo — were killed by foreign intermediaries without Washington’s blessing during U.S.-backed coups.

Similarly, covert actions to support militant groups trying to topple a foreign regime nearly always failed. Of 36 attempts, only five overthrew their targets. Sponsoring coups was more successful: nine out of 14 attempted coups put the U.S.-backed leaders in power.

Meddling in foreign elections is the most successful covert tactic

I found 16 cases in which Washington sought to influence foreign elections by covertly funding, advising and spreading propaganda for its preferred candidates, often doing so beyond a single election cycle. Of these, the U.S.-backed parties won their elections 75 percent of the time.

Covert regime change can devastate the target countries

My research found that after a nation’s government was toppled, it was less democratic and more likely to suffer civil war, domestic instability and mass killing. At the very least, citizens lost faith in their governments.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/monkey-cage/wp/2016/12/23/the-cia-says-russia-hacked-the-u-s-election-here-are-6-things-to-learn-from-cold-war-attempts-to-change-regimes/

Mariya Y. Omelicheva-associate professor in department of political science at the University of Kansas, Christian Crandall-professor in the department of psychology at the University of Kansas, Ryan Beasley-senior lecturer in the school of international relations at St. Andrews University carried out similar research & arrived at the same numbers

They say:

We examined unclassified Central Intelligence Agency documents and historical academic research on U.S. interventions to identify 27 U.S. clandestine operations carried out between 1949 and 2000. Most U.S. “secret wars” were against other democratic states.

Unclassified documents published by the U.S. national security archive at George Washington University show that the British government helped the United States overthrow Mohammad Mosaddegh, a democratically elected prime minister of Iran, and tried to block the release of information about its involvement in the coup.

But that’s just one example. In 1954, an anti-Communist “army” trained and armed by the CIA deposed democratically elected president Jacobo Arbenz Guzman in Guatemala — leading to years of violent civil war and rightist rule. Fifty-seven years later, Guatemalan President Alvaro Colom, on behalf of the state, asked Guzman’s family for forgiveness.

And in 1981, President Ronald Reagan authorized the funding for the CIA-led “secret wars” against the democratically elected Sandinista government in Nicaragua. These are but a few examples of the U.S. covert operations abroad.

While working covertly to bring down democracies, the United States also worked to engineer public support for overt use of force, if necessary. For instance, in 1954, the Eisenhower administration spread fearmongering propaganda about the “communist leanings” of the Guatemalan president. The U.S. news media subsequently misrepresented the coup as a successful restoration of democracy in Guatemala, carried out by local freedom fighters.

The news media did not report what it did not know: that the CIA had masterminded and funded the revolt. Similarly, the British government used the BBC’s Persian service to spread anti-Mosaddegh attitudes before the 1954 Iranian coup.

When democratic governments can’t get their citizens to support coercive policies abroad, they — at times — can and do resort to covert force.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/monkey-cage/wp/2016/12/20/the-u-s-has-a-long-history-of-hacking-other-democracies/

Interestingly US defence publications have picked up steam and are now openly advocating for regime change in India.

https://np.reddit.com/r/RegimeChange101/comments/o5xgb9/us_defence_publication_openly_pushes_for_regime/https://old.reddit.com/r/RegimeChange101/comments/o5xgb9/us_defence_publication_openly_pushes_for_regime/


r/IndiaRWResources • • Dec 22 '21

India has world's top 3 reserves of thorium on eastern coast beaches-linked with illegal sand mining .Over 60 lakh cr worth thorium disappeared in UPA reign.Our work to develop thorium reactors stalled during UPA post US nuclear deal where we chose to depend on imported uranium & agreed on test ban.

103 Upvotes

TLDR:

  1. India has one of the world's largest reserves of Thorium along the sand beaches of east coast & minimal reserves of uranium.

  2. Therefore, India has been attempting to build Thorium fuelled reactors

  3. While Nehru had banned export of the mineral rich sands because of presence of rare earths, the bans were subsequently lifted in 2006, making it easier for sand mining companies to export the rare earths from sand except Thorium. Ban was lifted to coincide with Indo-US nuclear deal

  4. While technically there is ban on Thorium export by private companies, there is no accountability and as per Lok Sabha records between 2002 & 2012, 60 lakh crores worth Thorium has disappeared from the beaches.

  5. Indo-US nuclear deal meanwhile made us dependent on imported uranium to benefit US nuclear based corporates, while throttling Thorium fuelled development and at the same time, effectively bound us to non-proliferation treaty with the agreement that if we test any more nuclear weapons, we will lose all access to uranium. This at a time we are increasingly moving towards replacing coal based power with imported uranium based power.

  6. China built its first Thorium fuelled reactor in Sep 21.

A look into US universities focusing on India's vast resources of Thorium & attempt to use it for nuclear reactors & not depend on uranium:

Thorium does have several advantages over Uranium as a nuclear power source. Thorium is three times more abundant in the Earth's crust than Uranium, and many Thorium deposits contain other mineral resources of value (rare earths elements in particular). Significant Thorium deposits exist in the United States, Brazil, India, and Australia; these countries all have estimates of Thorium resources of greater than 600 kt. [1] Additionally, all the Thorium that is mined can be used in a reactor, in comparison to less than 1% of natural Uranium that may be used. [2] Finally, Th-232 possesses a 14 billion year half-life, rendering it safer than Uranium and Plutonium. [2]

http://large.stanford.edu/courses/2018/ph241/wolak1/

The tropical beaches of India probably bring to mind sun-dappled palms, fiery fish curries and dreadlocked backpackers, but they also hold a surprising secret. Their sands are rich in thorium – often hailed as a cleaner, safer alternative to conventional nuclear fuels.

India has the world’s largest reserves of Thorium Ore, or 60% of the world’s Thorium deposits — twice that of the US, Brazil and Australia put together. While these deposits in India are easily accessible in the form of sands (monazite) in our sea beaches, in most other countries, Thorium reserves are embedded in rocks which require elaborate processing to extract — both tedious and costly. 100 Tonnes of mineral rock yields just one kilogram of Thorium. A small place in Tamil Nadu (Manavalakurichi) supposedly has 12 % of World’s Thorium, although some reports suggest it could have as much as 30%.

Thorium Ore can be found all along our sea beaches from Odisha and Andhra Pradesh all the way up to Tamil Nadu and Kerala, easily accessible in the form of mineral sands. After extraction from ore, Thorium does not require energy-intensive enrichment as is the case with Uranium.

From Mineral rich sands (Monazite), it is possible to extract Thorium, Cerium, Cesium, Platinum and Lanthanum, and these minerals are referred as RARE EARTHS and are extremely expensive in global markets.

Thorium in its liquid form burns more efficiently than solid Uranium; liquid thorium reactors do not operate at dangerous high pressures. A Thorium-powered Nuclear Reactor is inherently safe. It doesn’t run the risk of “meltdown” or explosion nor can even a dirty bomb be created. Its nuclear reaction simply stops when its neutron exciter is turned off.

The country has long been eager to exploit its estimated 300,000 to 850,000 tonnes of thorium – quite probably the world’s largest reserves – but progress has been slow.

India’s strategy was governed by different calculus. The country’s meagre uranium deposits convinced the founding father of its nuclear programme, Homi Bhabha, that any long-term strategy must exploit thorium, its most abundant fuel, which inspired a three-stage programme that is still the central plank of India’s nuclear energy policy.

https://bagariaamit.com/2018/06/07/%e2%82%b9600000000000000/

https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20181016-why-india-wants-to-turn-its-beaches-into-nuclear-fuel

As India’s Department of Atomic Energy clearly recognizes, “We have rather meager reserves of uranium…We, however, have nearly a third of the entire world’s thorium…Our strategies for large scale deployment of nuclear energy must be, and are therefore, focused towards utilisation of thorium.”

"In 2002, construction on a prototype fast breeder reactor at Kalpakkam was approved by the regulatory authority, and this reactor is expected to progress to the second stage of the program by late 2014. Six additional fast reactors are slated for construction, with four of them planned for 2020.

https://k1project.columbia.edu/news/thorium-dream

https://bagariaamit.com/2018/06/07/%e2%82%b9600000000000000/

Most of us have been led to believe that the biggest scams of the UPA-era were the CWG scam, the 2G spectrum scam, the National Herald newspaper scam and the AgustaWestland VVIP chopper scam. This is far from the truth.

The Thorium scam, the Bank NPAs, and the gold / gems import scams were much bigger. Let us look at the ₹60,00,000 crores Thorium Scam.

A look into Jagran 2012 report on this:

"The Great Thorium Robbery: Mother Of All Scams…!!"

Thorium is believed as a key factor to India’s nuclear programme being freed from the dependence on uranium imports to power our nuclear plants and allowing us to develop limitless amounts of fuel since it could be extracted from sand on beaches.

But according to recent published report in ‘The Statesman’, the government has failed to control the export of monazite, the raw material from which thorium can be extracted, and has allowed extraction of2.1 million tonnes of monazite.

The report estimates that if the thorium extracted from the monazite is estimated at $5,000 per tonne (Ref : thorium.tv), then the loss to the exchequer is approximately Rs 48 lakh crore, in addition to the incalculable loss to the nuclear fuel programme.

Thorium Disappearing: UPA’s new Coalgate? The report comments on UPA’s policy on natural resources. It says, “Since the UPA government assumed office in 2004 with Manmohan Singh as Prime Minister, 2.1 million tones of monazite, equivalent to 195,300 tonnes of thorium at 9.3 per cent recovery, has disappeared from the shores of India.”

‘Thorium disappearing’ should be considered more serious as it is related with India’s Nuclear programme. Thorium is a clean nuclear fuel of strategic importance for both nuclear energy generation and nuclear-tipped missiles. The beaches of Orissa Sand Complex, Manavalakurichi in Kanyakumari district of Tamil Nadu and the Aluva-Chavara belt on the Kerala coast have been identified under the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957, as the main monazite bearing areas in the country.

Developed Nations encouraging thorium-based reactors : The US and Japan are actively looking to increase their production of thorium and thorium-based reactors says report. That why, India needs to safeguard its mineral resources by banning the export of minerals from which thorium can be extracted, in order to safeguard its nuclear fuel programme for the future.

Thorium is crucial : On 2-December, 2009, Prithviraj Chouhan, then Minister for Science & Technology and Earth Science has stated in parliament, “Complete replacement of uranium by thorium in existing Indian Reactors is not feasible without a major change in design. However, thorium has been used in a few bundles of Pressurized Heavy Water Reactors earlier. Large scale use of thorium is planned in the 3rd stage of the Indian Nuclear Power Programme.”

Similarly, In July 2012, Atomic Energy Commission (AEC) chairman R K Sinha has stated that, the only problem with Thoriun  is that it can't be used directly as a fuel and it has got its own limitations too. This is the reason why the AEC is working hard to develop the next generation reactors that can use thorium as a fuel. This explains that Thorium is crucial for the Indian nuclear power programme and Indian government needs to guard its exports more carefully.

Destroying Ramsetu: Easy approach to Thorium rich beaches? It is considered that a large chunk of Thorium would be washed away if Ram Sethu is blasted. And almost all of it would be lost if another tsunami strikes the region. The Sethusamudram Canal, if built destroying RamSethu, will be beneficial to  private parties for easy snatching of beach sand for Thorium available on beaches of Tamil Nadu and Kerala.

The social organisations which protested against Sethusamudram Project said that since India had rich thorium resources and the technology to use it, the US was pressuring the Centre to speedily implement the Sethusamudram project (through India-US Nuclear Deal).

https://www.jagran.com/blogs/rakeshmishra/the-great-thorium-robbery-mother-of-all-scams/

https://ibtl.in/news/national/2015/thorium-disappearing-upas-new-coalgate

Jaideep Prabhu wrote for DNA in April 2014:

**“**A few years ago, a story appeared in the Indian press that a massive scam involving the illegal mining and covert export of thorium was taking place in Tamil Nadu. Then, two things happened: one, the story died out quickly without anyone investigating it further...

The beach sands of Tamil Nadu and Kerala are rich in several heavy minerals such as ilmenite, rutile, leucoxene, garnet, sillimanite, zircon and monazite. These minerals are used in several industries from steel and electronics to jewellery and ceramics. Monazite, however, contains thorium, a nuclear fuel of much interest.

The export of Monazite, used to procure nuclear cooperation from foreign states, was also banned by Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru in 1962. It was illegal to mine these rare earth heavy minerals until recently; the only entity allowed to do so was government-owned Indian Rare Earths Limited (“IRE”). In October 1998, government of India opened sand mining to private companies, on the basis of two licenses, one to mine the sand and another to handle nuclear materials. A further change in the law in January 2006 removed several of the minerals in the beach sands from the prescribed list and thus reduced the paperwork required to just one license to handle nuclear materials; private companies were now allowed to mine the sands for export of any mineral except monazite. The law retained thorium as a prescribed substance under the Atomic Energy Act and as a result, monazite remained off-limits to private entities.

However, the law also recognised that these minerals were mixed in the sand and therefore stipulated that companies handling the beach sand have to get a licence under the Atomic Energy (Radiation Protection) Rules from the Atomic Energy Regulatory Board (AERB). The company would have to either dispose of the monazite or store it on its premises as per regulations. Indian government denied private companies permission to process the monazite for thorium or to export the mineral: only IREL would be allowed to do that. The thorium scam allegations make four claims: 1) A private company is exporting thorium-rich sand illegally, 2) Between 2002 and 2012, some 2.1 million tonnes of monazite have gone missing, which amounts to approximately 235,000 tonnes of Thorium, 3) The Monazite has not been returned by the private company to the DAE after mining for other minerals, 4) Only a gentleman’s agreement requires the private company to inform the government about how much Monazite that they possess. 

The second accusation springs from a discrepancy between two reports by the Atomic Minerals Directorate for Exploration and Research (“AMDER”) of the Department of Atomic Energy (DAE). In a report read to the Lok Sabha in 2012, the AMDER stated that there were 10.7 tonnes of Monazite on India’s beaches; in a similar report prepared in 2002, AMDER had claimed 12.8 tonnes of the mineral to be present. This would indicate that 2.1 tonnes of Monazite, or approximately 235,000 tonnes of Thorium, had gone missing in the intervening period.

https://www.dnaindia.com/analysis/standpoint-what-happened-to-the-rs-60-lakh-crore-thorium-scam-1982959

Rest of the post iss reproduced from this blog:

https://bagariaamit.com/2018/06/07/%e2%82%b9600000000000000/

THORIUM & ILLEGAL MINING ON TAMIL NADU BEACHES

In August 2005, at an international conference on emerging nuclear energy systems in Brussels, Bhabha Atomic Research Centre scientists Usha Pal and V Jagannathan stated that BARC had designed the “World’s Safest Thorium based Nuclear Reactor,” after some seven years of effort.

Thorium is the preferred future fuel because of low radio-toxicity waste. It is rated as a clean fuel and is only slightly radioactive; it is clean with no burden of nuclear waste disposal. In one year, a 1GW Thorium Reactor produces less than 1% of hazardous waste.It is also potentially usable to breed reactor fuel and can theoretically generate 40 times more energy per unit compared to Uranium. Thorium based Fast Breeder Reactors (“FBR”) can breed more fuel than they consume.

A single Thorium FBR can produce all the Uranium fuel needed for all our 17 nuclear reactors. Usage of Thorium FBR’s would have freed India from importing expensive Uranium fuel from abroad.

India’s post-Pokharan isolation led scientists at BARC to develop a FBR using Thorium — the Indira Gandhi Centre for Atomic Research, Kalpakkam — which has been running for 27 years. India has indigenously built a 500 MW thorium fuelled FBR.

Late President APJ Abdul Kalam had told said that India must develop Thorium based nuclear reactors. Thorium contains 150 times more energy than Uranium and is the most efficient combustible.

The Plutonium, which is bred in FBRs and Thorium reactors, could be used for defence purposes which has the ability to bestow India with strategic advantage over the comity of nations.

India was the leading creator of Thorium-based FBR nuclear technology in the world, until Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh and then Defence Minister A.K Antony mothballed it for 10 years.

Once the Sonia Gandhi led UPA came to power, Dr. Manmohan Singh followed a policy of severely downsizing indigenous Thorium-based technology programme, thereby making India dependent on foreign countries for advanced nuclear technology. Indian nuclear scientists at Department of Atomic Energy (DAE) claim that by 2013, India would have mastered the technology to build Thorium based 1GW nuclear reactors.

A cartel headed by a Tirunelveli-based businessman, S.Vaikundarajan, main promoter of VV Minerals headquartered in Thisaiyanvilai, Tirunelveli, is depriving India of its precious mineral wealth. As I said earlier, Manavalakurichi in the Kanyakumari district in Tamil Nadu has the world’s largest deposit of monazite, ilmenite, garnet, zircon and rutile, all strategically and economically important minerals and metals. VV Minerals owns 96 out of the 111 garnet mining licences issued by the Indian Bureau of Mines**.** The Government of India has issued 44 licences for mining Ilmenite and they own all the licences.

The value the Thorium reserves at Manavalakurichi is 720 times more than the 2G spectrum scam, according to leading geologists. VV Minerals, which has monopolised sand mining along the seashore on the basis of its ability to bend and break laws of the land, is exporting the thorium-rich sand. Containers filled with sand from Manavalakurichi are exported through the Tuticorin Port. Instances of boats ferrying sand laden bags to ships anchored off the Tirunelveli and Kanyakumari coasts are regular sights, as per the locals in that area.

The mining baron Vaikundarajan has allegedly made lakhs of crores by exporting ilmenite, rutile, garnet and zircon**.** Though the Department of Atomic Energy (“DAE”) controls the sand along the coastline, because of the presence of elements like zircon, thorium and ilmenite, officials look the other way, when sand rich in thorium is exported from the region.

Officials of DAE have ignored the wanton looting taking place right in front of their eyes, as they are perhaps on the take. There are allegations that engineers in Indian Rare Earths Limited and DAE were helping Vaikundarajan export Monazite to other countries.

Dr. CSP Iyer, former director, Bhabha Atomic Research Centre, narrates an interesting incident when the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research wanted to find out the impact of mining along South India’s coastline and asked him to prepare a status report. “I was not allowed anywhere near the areas being mined by these private companies. They have something to hide,” he said.

THORIUM & INDO-US NUCLEAR DEAL

Immediately before the signing of the Indo-US civil nuclear deal in 2007, Government of India amended the Mines & Minerals Act by a Government order, probably under pressure from USA, to facilitate the export of the mineral-rich sand. Until then, private companies were not allowed mining of Monazite because of the presence of Thorium.

The illegal export of Thorium was first noted by scientists of DAE. Since their hands were tied because of bureaucratic procedures, they alerted concerned citizens in Chennai like former secretary to Tamil Nadu Government, V Sundaram and former executive at Asian Development Bank, S Kalyanaraman. Sundaram, an IAS officer belonging to the old school had been Tirunelveli District Collector and knew the district like the back of his hand. “What I found was flabbergasting. I hope Chief Minister Jayalalithaa would bring the culprits to book and save the south Indian coastline from further looting,” he said.

On the 30th of November 2011, V. Narayanasamy (then the Minister of State in the Prime Minister’s Office), told the Lok Sabha “However, under the guidelines framed by the Atomic Energy Regulatory Board (“AERB”), individual processors of beach sand have to separate and safely keep the Monazite content of such sand. No individual or entity is permitted to process Monazite in any manner without a licence from DAE. Further, no licences have been given to any private party to process Monazite and separate Thorium,” said the Minister.

However, Narayanaswamy did not say whether companies keep the sand containing Monazite with them after they have processed and extracted other minerals from the sand. Scientists and engineers said they were in the dark about the quantity of Monazite extracted by private companies and whether it has been exported or not.

Several scientists disagreed with Narayanaswamy. “Heavy mineral deposits often contain relatively high levels of radioactive elements (Thorium & Uranium). It is difficult to obtain clean separation of Ilmenite and Monazite and physical intergrowths of the two minerals are not uncommon. As a result, Ilmenite concentrates obtained from such deposits often contain high levels of Thorium and Uranium,” wrote J Nell, a noted mineral scientist, in a research paper.

The Atomic Minerals Directorate for Exploration and Research of the DAE, claims India’s coastline has a deposit of 10.7 million tonnes of Monazite from which it is possible to extract 8,46,477 tonnes of Thorium metal.

This was also announced by Narayanasamy in the Lok Sabha on the 14th of March, 2012. He said the Monazite is spread across States like Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, Kerala, Orissa, West Bengal and Bihar. Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh account for 2.16 million tonnes and 3.74 million tonnes Monazite, respectively.

At about ₹32.5 crores per tonne, the value of 8.46 Lakh tonnes of Thorium is approximately ₹275 Lakh Crores, or $4.25 Trillion. India’s GDP in the current fiscal is expected to be about $2.6 Trillion, so, if these estimates are to be believed, our Thorium reserves are worth 1.63 times the country’s annual GDP.

VV Mineral supposedly exported 15,87,806 tonnes of minerals during from 1999 to 2009 through just the Tuticorin Port. The company website itself claims that their annual export is 3,92,000 tonnes of mineral.

IRE officials are silent about the Monazite which the private enterprises were supposed to return to the Government. “It is a gentleman’s agreement and we have to believe what they tell us,” said Dr, CSP Iyer, former director, BARC. It is an open secret that some of the senior engineers of IRE and DAE work as consultants to private mining companies at exorbitant fees, which is 10 times more than what they get as monthly remuneration from the government.

How private companies flourished at the expense of India’s public sector undertakings is best described by the profit they generate by exporting precious minerals and other materials. IRE, with 2700 hectares of mineable land under its control, exported minerals worth ₹97.7 crore during from 2007 to 2010. But VV Minerals and its associates, which own just 187 hectares, earned ₹408 Crores (declared income) during the same period.

US NUCLEAR DEAL SUMMARY: MAKING INDIA ENERGY DEPENDENT ON IMPORTED URANIUM WHILE SIMULTANEOUSLY EFFECTIVELY MAKING INDIA SIGNATORY TO CBDT BY MAKING IT AGREE THAT ON ANY FURTHER THERMO-NUCLEAR TESTS, INDIA WILL LOOSE ALL ACCESS TO URANIUM

Indian media had numerous articles on how Dr. Manmohan Singh led UPA government was securing India’s future energy security by signing the Indo-US nuclear deal (the “123 Agreement”).

In this context, it is worth remembering the tragic accidental deaths of Homi Bhabha & Vikram Sarabhai, both involved in nuclear research. Two of our nuclear submarine scientists, Josh and Shivam, were found dead on railway tracks.

Mainstream media told us how this deal was going to push India into the big league of countries, by putting us on course to being the next super power. This hype was deliberately manufactured by Sonia Gandhi and her coterie.

The reasons why USA desperately wanted the nuclear deal were clear from the start. It wanted American companies like GE and Westinghouse to pursue nuclear trade with India worth billions of dollars and prevent India’s emergence as a real nuclear military power.

The nuclear deal, called the 123 Agreement, was subject to US laws such as the Hyde Act, and clearly stated that, if India tests a nuclear device, all further nuclear trade will end and nuclear material already sold to India should be returned. With no commitment to supply nuclear fuel, USA put a cap on India’s strategic programme, subjected us to the Non-Proliferation Treaty against our stated policy, and inspection of our nuclear installations through the International Atomic Energy Agency.

India’s indigenous nuclear programme, which was progressing quite well at that time, especially after encouragement during the 6-years of Vajpayee as Prime Minister, were put on the backburner.

As per the 123 deal, India agreed to separate our civilian and military nuclear activity and open up the civilian part to inspection by the International Atomic Energy Agency. In return, the US offered to resume full nuclear trade with India, ending our nuclear expulsion. We carved out two large chunks of real estate in Mithi Virdi (Gujarat) and Kovvada (Andhra Pradesh), and offered them to two multinationals to set up nuclear power plants.

While Toshiba-Westinghouse was given the Gujarat site for building six AP1000 reactors of 1100 MW each (total 6600 MW), and GE-Hitachi was to be given the Kovvada site to set up six units of 1594 MW each (total 9564 MW). Both projects involved untested technologies at that time. In both instances, public sector Nuclear Power Corporation of India was to be the operator.

The aim of the much hyped “Indo-US Nuclear Deal” was perhaps to make India one of the top three markets for American & European companies, rather than a competitor, in the $100 Billion nuclear power technology market. The deal would create a huge market for the Big3 conventional nuclear reactor manufacturers — Westinghouse, Areva and GE.

According to nuclear scientists at DAE, the attention given to the FBR and Thorium program were reduced still further by 2008, when discussions began with international companies about supply of conventional Uranium based nuclear reactors to India. If this had not been done, scientists say that by 2013 at the latest, India may have been able to develop the technology for 1GW reactors, thereby creating an export market with a potential for sales of $4 billion per year, initially. This advantage was handed over to China” Incidentally, China is now on the cusp of mastering the technology of 2GW reactors, while India was being forced in the UPA-era to rely on overseas suppliers for 1GW nuclear power plants.

Meanwhile this September, China successfully built thorium fuelled nuclear reactor:

https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-02459-w

https://www.livescience.com/china-creates-new-thorium-reactor.html

In 2016, Russian nuclear agency Rosatom commercially commissioned its BN800 FBR, which produces about 800 MW of electricity and supplies it to the Ural region including the city of Yekateringburg.

After coming to power in 2014, Narendra Modi has empowered Indian scientists and agencies to develop Thorium-based FBRs. The indigenously designed and locally constructed Prototype Fast Breeder Reactor (“PFBR”), an important link in India’s quest to gain complete control of the fuel cycle, is nearing completion. Once completed, it would allow the capability to grow “geometrically” and would make India the second country, after Russia, in the world to operate a FBR.

Six FBR units are planned to be set up, of which the first two will come up at Kalpakkam in Tamil Nadu. All six units are expected to become operational latest by 2039, though PM Modi is personally pushing for them to start much earlier. Construction of the two units at Kalpakkam is planned to start by 2021 and expected to begin commercial operations by 2029.

India has been following a closed fuel cycle and FBR is a critical link to it. The PFBR was scheduled to go critical in 2010 but it has missed several deadlines since then. It is an example of public-private partnership and many private industrial players like L&T and Walchandnagar Industries have contributed to the project. The public sector firm Bharat Heavy Electricals Limited is a major contributor in the project.

Founders of India’s nuclear energy programme harped on a closed fuel cycle, which means that India is reprocessing and remaking spent fuel from our nuclear power reactors. We have been following a three-stage nuclear electricity program: (1) pressurised heavy-water reactors (PHWRs) using natural uranium as fuel; (2) FBRs using plutonium and depleted uranium from the PHWRs; and (3) FBRs using abundant Thorium found in India.

Mainstreaming FBR technology and usage is the key to make nuclear energy sustainable in India. FBRs generate more fuel than they consume and are hence termed as breeders. Countries such as the US and France have also experimented with FBR technology programmes.

India’s installed nuclear power capacity is currently 6780 MW from our 22 operational plants, with another 6700 MW expected to be added by the year 2021. The Narendra Modi Government has set a target of achieving nuclear power capacity of 14000 MW by 2024.

PM Modi wants 25% of our electricity needs to be met by nuclear reactors by 2050. USA currently gets 20% of its power from nuclear energy, but this could fall to less than 10% by 2050, due to exceptionally slow construction rates, as getting regulatory approvals from the federal U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission to build a conventional reactor can take up to 25 years, while building a new plant by takes about 10 years.


r/IndiaRWResources • • Aug 30 '20

ISLAM Sexual slavery in Islam and it's impact on non-Islamic India.

103 Upvotes

Islam's views on sexual slavery

Sexual slavery in Islam results from the permission in Islamic law for men to have sexual intercourse with the female slaves they own. Legal and literary documents show that those slaves used for sexual service were differentiated at slave markets from those who were intended mainly for domestic services. These slave girls were called "slaves for pleasure" (muṭʿa, ladhdha) or “slave-girls for sexual intercourse” (jawārī al-waṭ). Many female slaves became concubines to their owners and bore their children. Others were just used for sex before being transferred. The allowance for men to use contraception with female slaves assisted in thwarting unwanted pregnancies.

Early sources indicate that sexual slavery of women was viewed as both a male privilege and a privilege for the victor over the defeated. Islamic legal texts state that sexual pleasure was a male privilege over women. Men were permitted to have as many concubines as they could afford. Some men purchased female slaves, whereas Muslim soldiers in the early Islamic conquests were given female captives as a reward for military participation. This not only increased military participation, but also served to rapidly spread Islam & denude the existing population as the sexual slaves could be easily coerced to convert.

In traditional juristic understanding, it is the male's ownership of a woman's sexual organs which makes sex licit in Islam. This is why the woman is called aurat meaning vagina in Urdu. Meri aurat literally would translate to "my vagina." Islamic jurists describe marriage as a kind of sale where the wife's private parts are purchased. However, there are some differences between the rights of a wife and female slave. While a free Muslim woman was considered to be a man's honour, a slave-girl was merely property and not a man's honour The term suriyya (concubine) was used for female slaves with whom masters enjoyed sexual relations. It was not a secure status as the concubine could be traded as long as the master had not impregnated her.

Islamic law and Sunni ulama recognise two categories of concubines:

War Captives:

These are originally free non-Muslims who are captured in battle. The entire population of a conquered territory can be enslaved, thus providing women who are otherwise rare on the battlefield. This paves the path for concubinage. The Muslim military commander is allowed to choose between unconditionally releasing, ransoming or enslaving war captives. If a person converted to Islam after being enslaved, their emancipation would be considered a pious act but not obligatory. Islamic law does not allow enslavement of free-born Muslims.

Islamic jurists permitted slave raiding and kidnapping of non-Muslims from Dar al Harb. South Asian scholars ruled that jihad was not needed to seize non-Muslims nor was it necessary to invite them to Islam before seizing them. Raiders were free to take and enslave any non-Muslim. However, Islamic jurists held that non-Muslims who lived in areas which had formal pacts with Muslims were to be protected from enslavement. Non-Muslims residents of an Islamic state who fail to pay jizya or break their contract with the state can also be enslaved. However, Muslim rebels can not be enslaved.

Slave-girls by descent:

These are born to slave mothers. Owners who would marry off their female slaves to someone else, would also be the masters of any children born from that marriage. Thus, Islamic law made slave-breeding possible.

Status of a female sex slave

The concubines were owned by their masters. The owners could obtain the slave-girls through purchase, capture or receive them as a gift. Islam permits men to have sexual intercourse with them and there is no limit on the number of concubines they could keep, unlike in polygamy where there is a limit of four wives. The master could also sell her or gift her to someone else. The female slave was essentially a chattel. An owner's slave could also be inherited by an heir. While she was under her master's control the slave girl could not have sex with anyone else.

Enslavement was intended both as a debt and form of humiliation. The sexual relationship between a concubine and her master was viewed as a debt of humiliation upon the woman until she gave birth to her master's child and the master's later death. Becoming a slave meant that the person was stripped of their honour. The ulama asserted that slavery was a divine punishment for not being a Muslim. In the words of az-Aziz b.Ahmad al-Bukhari "servitude is a vestige of obstinacy in refusing to believe in one God". Al-Sharif al-Jurjani stated that slavery in Islamic law was a "penalty for unbelief." An Algerian scholar who lived in Morocco, Ahmad al-Wansharisi, described the purpose of slavery as a "humiliation" for previous or continuing disbelief.

The female slaves were traded as chattel.[69] Because female slaves were traded among men and many of them had been owned by up to thirty men consecutively, they had a great deal of knowledge about sexual intercourse and were able to tutor elite adolescent males about sexual techniques.[73] Slave girls were seen as sexual commodities and were not allowed to cover themselves.[75] Before being bought many women's bodies were examined. The Hanafis allowed potential male buyers to uncover and touch a female slave's arms, breasts and legs.[76] Umar prohibited slave girls from resembling free women and forbade them from covering their hair.

Conversion and sexual slavery

Most traditional scholars require the conversion of a pagan slave-girl before sex, even through force if necessary. The majority of jurists do not allow sexual intercourse with Zoroastrian or pagan female captives. They require a conversion of these women before sex can take place. Ibn Hanbal allowed sexual intercourse with pagan and Zoroastrian female captives if they are coerced to become Muslim. Many traditions state that the female captives should be coerced to accept Islam if they do not convert willingly. Hasan al-Basri narrates that Muslims would achieve this objective through various methods. They would order the Zoroastrian slave-girl to face the qiblah, utter the shahada and perform wudhu. Her captor would then have sex with her after one menstrual cycle. However, others add the condition that the slave-girl must be taught to pray and purify herself before the master can have sex with her.

The scholars significantly lower the threshold of conversion for the girls so that the master may be able to have sex with her as soon as possible. Al-Mujahid and Safiid bin al-Musayyab say the master can still have sex with his Zoroastrian or pagan female slave even if she refuses to convert.

Imam Shafi'i claims that the Companions of Muhammad did not have sexual intercourse with Arab captives until they converted to Islam. But Ibn Qayyim argues that the Companions of the Prophet had sexual intercourse with Arab captives, such as the women of the Banu Mustaliq tribe, without making the sex conditional on the conversion of the women. He also asserted that no tradition required the conversion of a slave-girl before her master can have sex with her.

Little concubinage existed in Middle-East before Islam, but it exploded after Muhammad.

A study of the Arab genealogical text Nasab Quraysh records the maternity of 3,000 Quraishi tribesmen, most of whom lived in between 500 and 750 CE. The data shows that there was a massive increase in the number of children born to concubines with the emergence of Islam. An analysis of the information found that no children were born from concubines before the generation of Muhammad's grandfather. There were a few cases of children being born from concubines before Muhammad but they were only in his father's and grandfather's generation. The analysis of the data thus showed that concubinage was not common before the time of Muhammad, but increased for men of his generation as a result of military conquests.

Muhammad's view on treatment of war victims of Islam.

When Muhammad was informed that the Hawazin had brought their women, children and livestock with them, he smiled and said "Inshaa Allah, all these will become the booty of war for the Muslims.

The Muslim army defeated the Hawazin and captured their women and children. The pagan soldiers fled.[59] The war booty which the Muslims obtained was 24,000 camels, more than 40,000 goats, 160,000 dirhams worth of silver and 6,000 women and children. Muhammad waited ten days for the Hawazin to repent and reclaim their families and properties. However, none of them came. Finally, Muhammad distributed the war booty among the Muslim soldiers. The Muslim soldiers initially hesitated to have sex with the married female captives, until a verse was revealed giving them permission to have sex with them:

Imam Ahmad recorded that Abu Sa`id Al-Khudri said, "We captured some women from the area of Awtas who were already married, and we disliked having sexual relations with them because they already had husbands. So, we asked the Prophet about this matter, and this Ayah (verse) was revealed, Also (forbidden are) women already married, except those whom your right hands possess). Consequently, we had sexual relations with these women."

Quran quotes encouraging female sexual slavery

https://www.reddit.com/r/IndiaRWResources/comments/dcciur/quranic_verses_and_hadiths_that_promote_and/

Consent of female sexual slaves

The classical Islamic jurists make an analogy between the marriage contract and sale of concubines. They state that the factor of male ownership in both is what makes sex lawful with both a wife and female slave.

The Hanafi scholars allow the husband to have sex with his wife against her will, as long as he has paid her dowry. The Shafi'i, Maliki and Hanbali schools do not forbid a husband from forcing his wife to have sex nor do they expressly say anything in favour of it. For all Sunni law schools the concept of marital rape is an oxymoron.[24] According to the Islamic jurists, rape is either a kind of zina or a property crime, which by definition cannot be committed by a husband or master, since he is the owner of his wife and slave's sexual capacity.

According to Kecia Ali "I recall no instance in any Maliki, Hanafi, Shafiʿi, or Hanbali text from the 8th to 10th centuries where anyone asserts that an owner must obtain his female slave's consent before having sex with her. Indeed, I am aware of no case where anyone asks whether her consent is necessary or even asserts that it is not required.

Kecia Ali also add's "It strains logic to suggest that an enslaved woman is subject to being married off without her consent or against her will to whomever her owner chooses but that he cannot have sex with her himself without her consent. It is even more of a stretch to accept that the need for consent within concubinage was so obviously a condition for its legitimacy that no one considered it necessary to say so, but that the absence of the need for a slave's consent to her marriage required explicit affirmation." The Hanafis explicitly state that a man may force his wife to sexually satisfy him.[28] It is mentioned in Kitab al-Maghazi that Uthman ibn Affan had sexual intercourse with a war captive, Zaynab bint Hayyan, and that she "detested" him.

Muhammad and his Companions took for granted the allowance of having sex with female war captives. The consent of the women was irrelevant. Some modern Muslim writers seek to defend Islam by claiming that Islam permits men to have sex with female captives as a way of integrating them into society. But in the case of the women from the Banu Mustaliq tribe who were captured by the Companions, their captors wanted to practice coitus interruptus during sex with them because if these women became pregnant their captors would not be able to return them in exchange for ransom. According to Kecia Ali, modern Muslim scholarship is silent on the implications of this episode and only considers the event in the context of discussing contraceptive practices.

All four law schools also have a consensus that the master can marry off his female slave to someone else without her consent. A master can also practice coitus interruptus during sex with his female slave without her permission.

Impact of promotion of female sexual slavery by Islam on India.

The Muslim Sultanates in India before the Mughal Empire captured large numbers of non-Muslims from the Deccan. The Muslim masters would impregnate their non-Muslim slaves and the children they fathered would be raised as Muslims. Non-Muslim girls were socially ostracised by their own communities for the sexual relationships Muslim soldiers and nobles would have with them, therefore, many of them preferred to convert to Islam. When Muslims would surround Rajput citadels, the Rajput women would commit jauhar (collective suicide) to save themselves from being dishonoured by their enemies. In 1296 approximately 16,000 women committed jauhar to save themselves from Alauddin Khalji's army. Rajput women would commit it when they saw that defeat and enslavement was imminent for their people. In 1533 in Chittorgarh nearly 13,000 women and children killed themselves instead of being taken captive by Bahadur Shah's army. For them sexual intercourse was the worst form of humiliation. Rajputs practised jauhar mainly when their opponents were Muslims.

Ovington, a voyager who wrote about his journey to Surat, stated that Muslim men had an "extraordinary liberty for women" and kept as many concubines as they could afford. Akbar had a harem of at least 5000 women and Aurangzeb's harem was even larger. The nobles in India could possess as many concubines as they wanted. Ismail Quli Khan, a Mughal noble, possessed 1200 girls. Another nobleman, Said, had many wives and concubines from whom he fathered 60 sons in just four years.

The womenfolk of enemies were captured both to humiliate their men and to use the beautiful maidens for various purposes. Beautiful female captives were mostly used for sex. After the period of Akbar's rule enslavement of women continued to be used to punish their men. Jahangir explicitly ordered the destruction of the domain of the rebellious zamindar of Jaitpur and the capture of his women. Thus, his daughters and wives were captured and brought to the harem. Aurangzeb would enslave rebellious peasants. Manucci records that, during Mughal rule, when faujdars would enter rebellious villages they would take the most attractive girls and present them to the king. The rest would either be sold or kept for themselves. Ahmad Shah Abdali's army captured Maratha women to fill Afghan harems. The Sikhs attacked Abdali and rescued 2,2000 Maratha girls.

There is an academic consensus that the Islamic legal sanction for slavery prevented the emergence of any anti-slavery movement in the Muslim world. But William Clarence-Smith has argued that "Islamic abolitionism" was indigenous and rooted in Islamic tradition. However, Ehud R. Toledano states that abolitionist views were very rare in Muslim societies and that there was no indigenous abolitionist narrative in the Muslim world. The scant evidence that exists of "Islamic abolitionism" shows that such discourse was extremely limited.

Views on sexual slavery of Indian Muslim leaders in 19th & 20th century and impact.

The first anti-slavery views came from Syed Ahmad Khan in the subcontinent. Syed Ahmad Khan and Syed Ameer Ali were primarily concerned with refuting Western criticism of Islamic slavery. However, they did not directly refute the European criticism about female slavery and concubinage. The next anti-slavery texts are to be found, from the 1920s onwards, in the works of non-ulema who were writing outside the realm of Islamic tradition and Shariah. Amal Ghazal has shown that the modernist ulema in Egypt such as Muhammad Abduh and Rashid Rida were strongly opposed by the majority of Islamic jurists. While Abduh took a stand in favour of abolition, he noted that only a gradualist approach, which encouraged manumission, would work because slavery itself was sanctioned in Islamic law.

Female slavery, being a condition necessary to the legality of this coveted indulgence [concubinage], will never be put down, with a willing or hearty co-operation by any Mussalman community.- William Muir, Life of Mahomet.

A group of ulama led by Waji al-Din Saharanpuri gave a fatwa in the 1830s that it was lawful to enslave even those men and women "who sought refuge" after battle. Sayyed Imdad Ali Akbarabadi led ulama in publishing a lot of material in defence of traditional kinds of slavery. Sayyid Muhammad Askari condemned the idea of abolishing slavery.

A conservative Deobandi scholar published a book in Lahore in 1946 in which he denied that the Prophet had ever encouraged the abolition of slavery. After 1947, the ulama in Pakistan called for the revival of slavery. The wish to enslave enemies and take concubines was noted in the Munir Commission Report.

The most widespread raptio in modern times was the kidnapping of tens of thousands of girls during the Partition of India. These women were kept as captives or forced wives and concubines. For instance, one account from Kirpal Singh mentions how Pakistani soldiers in Kamoke took 50 Hindu girls after killing most of their men. After being taken, Hindu and Sikh girls would be forcibly converted to Islam to be "worthy" of their captors' harems. Pashtun tribesmen captured a large number of non-Muslim girls from Kashmir and sold them as slave-girls in West Punjab. In Mirpur, many of the Hindu women captured by Pakistani soldiers committed jauhar, the old practice of Hindu women to escape Muslim soldiers. Eyewitness and official accounts describe how Hindu girls in West Punjab and Mirpur would be distributed among the Muslim Military, National Guards, police and ruffians. The non-Muslim girls from Punjab and Kashmir were sold in different parts of Pakistan and the Middle East and were forced into concubinage. They were kept as slaves, forcibly converted to Islam as soon as they fell into the hands of their Muslim captors and were used for sexual pleasure. During the fighting in Kashmir, the government put 600 Hindu women in the Kunja camp in West Punjab. The Pakistani army used all of them before returning them to India. Gopalaswami Ayyangar accused the Pakistani government of holding 2000 Hindu women.

The Pakistani elite blamed the Hindus for the Bengali revolt in 1971 so Pakistani army officers operated with an intent to drive out the Hindus. Mullahs and a West Pakistani fatwa declared that Bengali Hindu women could be treated as war booty. Tikka Khan ordered that Bengalis be turned into "slaves and concubines."Pakistani soldiers kept female captives as sex-slaves inside their cantonments and military camps. The Pakistani Army and their allies mostly raped Hindu women. The rape of Hindu captive girls was part of a policy to "dilute" their "religious community's bloodline."

https://archive.is/9KMtv

Islam's recognition and promotion of sexual slavery affirmed by Shabir Ally, a Canadian Muslim preacher and Imam, with a PhD on Quran.

https://twitter.com/prasannavishy/status/1298675567940603904


r/IndiaRWResources • • Apr 11 '21

HISTORY Blood on the hands of Marxist historians and the secular media of India: Hundreds of Hindus who were killed, thousands raped & thousands of temples destroyed in response to the disinformation in RamJanmabhoomi case that there was never a temple under Babri.

101 Upvotes

Dr. Koenraad Elst has also written in his book “BJP vis-à-vis Hindu Resurgence” (Voice of India, 1997):

“You wouldn’t guess it from their polished convent-school English, their trendy terminology, or their sanctimoniousness, but the likes of Romila Thapar, Irfan Habib or Gyanendra Pandey [our comment: Marxist historians in India who have indulged in negationism-denying the crimes of Islamic rulers, and denying that a temple existed at the spot of the disputed structure] have blood on their hands. The wave of Muslim violence after the Ayodhya demolition (and the boomerang of police repression and Shiv Sena retaliation) was at least partly due to the disinformation by supposed experts, who denied that the disputed building [our comment: Babri Masjid] had a violent iconoclastic prehistory [our comment: i.e. been built after demolishing a temple], and implied that Hindus can get away with concocted history in their attacks on innocent mosques. This disinformation gave Muslim militants the sense of justification needed to mount a ‘revenge’ operation and to mobilize decent Muslims for acts of violence, which they never would have committed if they had known the truth about Islam’s guilt in Ayodhya”.

There were around 100 temples demolished in Kashmir (under Indian control) and 400+ temples demolished in Bangladesh BEFORE the demolition of the illegal structure called Babri Masjid in Ayodhya. There were around 400 temples demolished in Bangladesh in the year 1989 itself in light of the Ayodhya movement, including around 200 temples demolished in October-November 1989 in light of the Shilanyas of 9 November 1989. Thousands of Hindu homes and businesses were destroyed. Many Hindu shops were looted and burnt.

At least 45 temples were demolished in Bangladesh in 1990, in light of the kar sewa of 30 October and 2 November 1990, at least 34 in Dhaka district and at least 11 in Chittagong district. Hundreds (at least 550+) of Hindu shops and houses were looted or burnt in this violence in Bangladesh too.

Since these attacks happened in Bangladesh on such a large scale in both 1989 and 1990, it is absolutely certain that such anti-Hindu violence would also have occurred in Pakistan. However, this writer has not been able to find out the exact number of temples demolished in Pakistan or Hindus attacked there in 1989 or 1990. He found a report that at least, one Hindu was killed and 4 temples were damaged in November 1990 in Pakistan.

After the demolition of Babri Masjid on 6 December 1992, it is reported that there were at least 245 temples demolished in Pakistan, and 3600 (Three thousand six hundred) temples demolished in Bangladesh. In the 1992 anti-Hindu pogroms in Bangladesh post-Babri, 28,000 non-Muslim homes were destroyed, 2,700 Hindu businesses, 3,600 temples and other places of worship were destroyed. The estimates of the total loss amounted to 2 billion (200 crores) Bangladesh Takas. More than a hundred temples were also demolished in Kashmir under Indian rule, and also other temples in some other places in India like Bhopal, Assam.

95% of all Hindu temples in Pakistan have been destroyed or converted since 1990. As per the 2014 survey report of the All Pakistan Hindu Rights Movement (APHRM) out of the total 428 minority places of worship in the country, 408 are converted into toy stores, restaurants, government offices and schools after 1990 and only 20 Hindu temples are remaining there. It is possible that a lesser number of temples were attacked in Pakistan than Bangladesh after 6 Dec 1992. It doesn’t mean that Pakistan was more tolerant, it was because of the low number of temples existing there by 1992. Thousands of temples had already been destroyed by that time since Pakistan came into being in 1947.

Sikh religious places are usurped too. Many of the places of worship of Sikhs have also been decimated by Pakistan. The most prominent among them was Guru Duwara Gali, a Sikh religious place, that has been converted into a garments shop in Abbottabad. Around 171 Gurudwaras in Pakistan are either destroyed, are close to collapsing, have been converted into mosques (or schools, police stations, etc.), or were demolished in order to build homes.

The government of J&K officially said in 2012 that 208 temples were destroyed in Kashmir in 20 years since the early 1990s. But its true number may be much higher. According to the Kashmiri Pandit organization Kashmiri Pandit Sangarsh Samiti (KPSS), the actual number of destroyed temples is around 550. The Government of J&K admitted that its summer capital Srinagar tops the chart in the destruction of temples with the number of such destroyed temples being 57 there. However, none of the mosques was destroyed in this vandalism. Many of these temples are now converted into mosques.

This article gives just an indication of what happened in Pakistan in just 1 day after Babri demolition- Pakistanis attacked 30 Hindu temples. A lot more happened after that too. Police forces did not intervene when the temples were attacked, nor did they act when a crowd stormed the Air-India office, dragged furniture into the street, and set the office on fire as reported by The New York Times on 8 December 1992. At least 24 people (safe to assume, mostly Hindus) were killed in Pakistan and at least 100 temples were attacked by Muslims as reported by The Dallas Morning News on 15 December 1992.

Pakistani journalist Reema Abbasi and photographer Madiha Aijaz have travelled across the length of Pakistan and documented the state of Hindu temples. Reema wrote a book titled “Historic Temples in Pakistan: A Call to Conscience”. Reema notes that nearly 1000 temples were targeted during that frenzy spate of vile destruction of temples in Pakistan which took place after the Babri mosque’s destruction in the early 1990s. This same number of 1,000 temples being attacked was given by this website giving information on Hindus of Pakistan.

Just read one report of the Associated Press dated 31 October 1990 on the violence in Bangladesh in 1990 in light of kar sewa in Ayodhya headlined Moslems Attack Hindu Temples in Bangladesh:

“CHITTAGONG, Bangladesh (AP) _ Gangs of Moslems, many armed with knives and clubs, attacked Hindu temples, smashed idols and set fire to hundreds of homes in response to clashes in India, witnesses said today.

Angry mobs took to the streets late Tuesday on hearing news of an attempt by fundamentalist Hindus in India to take over a mosque and replace it with a temple at the holy town of Ayodhya. More than 150 people have been killed in India in fighting related to the dispute…

A crowd of about 100 people defied the curfew imposed at dawn today and assaulted a Hindu shrine. In all, at least 11 temples have been broken into and vandalized since Tuesday, according to officials and witnesses.

The worst violence flared at Kaiballadham, site of the Chittagong’s largest temple. Witnesses said 2,000 people with knives and iron rods rampaged through a residential district around the temple at midnight and burned at least 300 houses.

Police fired into the air to disperse a mob that was preventing firemen from approaching the area. Sushil Gosh, one of 500 displaced people who set up a camp on a hill above the temple, said four men were missing.

Police also fired at Reazuddin Bazar and Chittagong Medical College when mobs of up to 200 people tried to storm temples and burn Hindu-owned stores. One group destroyed about 50 mud-and-straw houses inhabited by low-caste Hindus, mainly fishermen. Another group attacked a garage owned by a Hindu and damaged five vehicles.

Police said about 1,500 Hindu fishermen at central Chowkbazar district fled their homes during the night attack but returned in the morning when the situation was brought under control…”

If the media had repeatedly mentioned these attacks on Hindus (killings of 24 people, mostly Hindus, in Pakistan), destruction of thousands of temples before and after Babri, destruction of thousands of Hindu houses, loss of property of Hindus of 200 crore Takas only after 6 December 1992, and a lot in 1989 and 1990 too, there would have been no (or at least, lesser) infuriation among Muslims, and it is quite possible that the bomb blasts of Mumbai and Kolkata of March 1993, and subsequent acts of terrorism could have been avoided.

After this anti-Hindu violence in Pakistan, Bangladesh and Kashmir, there were the deadly 1993 bomb blasts in Mumbai which killed 257 people, injured 1400+ and damaged property worth more than 100 crore rupees. There were bomb blasts by Islamists in Kolkata as well, killing 69. After this there was a bomb blast by Islamists in August 1993 in the RSS office in Chennai, killing 11 including 6 high-level pracharaks. Then on 6 December 1993, there were blasts in various trains. On 6 December 1997, there were again blasts in trains in Tamil Nadu killing 10 people and injuring 70.

But the Indian media covered up these temple demolitions, as well as these bomb blasts by Islamic radicals in India (except the 1993 Mumbai blasts), and focused only on Babri Masjid-that too ignoring the fact that it was built after the demolition of a temple, on a site very sacred to the Hindus (the birthplace of Lord Ram), and a slaughter of hundreds of Hindus by Babur’s soldiers in 1528 at that place before demolishing the temple.

Besides this, it is entirely obvious that a Hindu sacred site (Ayodhya) belongs to Hindus; no one, whether a religious Western or East Asian or a Muslim will ever agree to give up his own sacred sites to others. There are dozens of mosques in Ayodhya. Forget temples, not even non-Muslims are allowed in Mecca and Medina. Here, we will not even consider the historical context of the demolition of thousands of temples including sacred ones like Somnath, Puri, etc, and slaughter of millions of Hindus in medieval India. Seen just in the context of the pre-and-post 6 December 1992 violence, the construction of a Ram temple in Ayodhya is a very tiny atonement for the acts of Islamists.

And here we are again not considering the lives sacrificed by kar sewaks (the death toll of kar sewaks in the 30 October 1990 kar sewa was more than 120, nowhere near the official figure of 16) in Ayodhya in the 1990 kar sewa, as well as 1992 kar sewa (some kar sewaks lost their lives on 6 December 1992 in Ayodhya too, e.g. one man named Dinesh Chand) and in the Godhra massacre of 27 February 2002. Ram temple is a very small consolation, in light of all these facts.

Seen in the correct context, Babri demolition itself was absolutely nothing Muslims should have had infuriation about had they truly known the reality- as Koenraad Elst said. But here it is a large section of the media which is guilty of reporting inflammatorily by needlessly infuriating Muslims even more. It is not that there would have been no sense of infuriation. Because the terrorists who attack and kill do so thinking that it is their duty to ‘convert or kill’ all non-Muslims, and especially believe that worship of idols and more than 1 God (polytheism) are unforgivable sins. Hindus who are idolators and polytheists are to be severally crushed, according to this ideology.

Bhure Lal, former IAS officer who had also served in the Army in Vigilance Commission and is a highly respected expert wrote in his book “The Monstrous face of ISI” (published in early 2000 just after the 1999 Kargil war) on pp 44-45:

“The ISI resorts to the following:

…5-Infiltrate and capture mass media and identify pro-Islamic newspapers and asking them to write pro-Pakistani and pro-Islamic articles.

6-Spreading disinformation through media that Indian Muslims are victimized.

7-Indentifying Indian politicians who thrive on Bangladeshi Muslim vote bank so that they can be protected against police and other administrative action…

12- The agency had set up a ‘disinformation’ cell and planted ‘stories’ designed to denigrate India. The ISI has funds placed at its disposal to manipulate news. …

15-The ISI employed tens of thousands of agents, “including at least every other newspaper reporter”…”

Who gains by the repeated painting of Muslims as victims, whitewashing their fanaticism completely? It only helps our enemies across the border and Islamic radicals inside.

Taken verbatim from:

https://www.opindia.com/2020/08/destruction-of-temples-killing-hindus-india-pakistan-bangladesh-after-babri-masjid-demolition-ram-janmabhoomi/

Violence which has happened since then on Hindus in the name of Babri:

From last 6 months:

Rinku Sharma of Delhi lynched to death by over a dozen Islamists for daring to collect funds for Ram Mandir. He died screaming Jai Shree Ram even as he was being beaten.

https://www.reddit.com/r/indianews/comments/li67xw/rinku_sharma_had_donated_blood_to_save_the_wife/

15 days back, too another boy collecting funds for Ram Mandir was lynched in Gujarat.

https://www.reddit.com/r/AgainstHinduphobia/comments/l5o7yn/hindu_man_killed_stones_pelted_on_ram_mandir/

Ujjain: Stonepelting, including by women & children from rooftops, on RamNidhi Sangrahan rally for collecting funds for building Ram Mandir.

https://www.reddit.com/r/AgainstHinduphobia/comments/kkip5v/ujjain_stonepelting_including_by_women_children/

After Begumbagh stone pelting, Hindu rally in Indore that was collecting donations for Ram Mandir attacked. Reports say that communal tension was flared up because of Hanuman Chalisa chanting near a mosque. The rally was attacked with stones and sticks by locals in the area.

https://www.reddit.com/r/AgainstHinduphobia/comments/kmja42/after_begumbagh_stone_pelting_hindu_rally_in/

Assam: Ram Mandir Bhoomi Pujan celebration by Bajrang Dal attacked by Muslim locals, curfew imposed

https://www.reddit.com/r/AgainstHinduphobia/comments/i4pat2/assam_ram_mandir_bhoomi_pujan_celebration_by/

Miscreants from a ‘particular community’ for attacking Hindus celebrating Ram Mandir Bhoomi Pujan in Sultanpur

https://www.reddit.com/r/AgainstHinduphobia/comments/i5d9ny/uttar_pradesh_fir_filed_against_miscreants_from_a/

"Farmer Protests": Rioting mob destroyed Ram Mandir and Kedarnath tableaux from Republic Day parade

https://www.reddit.com/r/AgainstHinduphobia/comments/l60vfp/farmer_protests_rioting_mob_destroyed_ram_mandir/

Meanwhile, Khalistanis in Silicon Valley of USA are protesting with posters like "Ram Mandir = Horror House" and your usual Anti India and Anti Modi Lafda.

https://www.reddit.com/r/AgainstHinduphobia/comments/l7tfr4/meanwhile_khalistanis_in_silicon_valley_of_usa/

https://www.opindia.com/2020/08/ayodhya-ram-janmabhoomi-movement-sacrifices/

Godhra: 59 humans, 10 of them children, were burnt alive in a train when Islamic terrorists from Godhra set on fire the bogey containing karsevaks returning from the inauguration of the Vishwa Hindu Parishad's 100-day 'Purnahuti Maha Yagna' in Ayodhya. Congress affiliate councillor Farooq Bhana, the key conspirator of the massacre was convicted 14 years after he hatched conspiracy with others to burn the S6 coach of the train at Godhra Railway Station on February 27, 2002. Conspiracy which involved stacking of petrol from the previous night, gathering Muslims in 5 min with huge cache of weapons and announcement from a nearby mosque.

The court agreed with the prosecution case that the perpetrators had collected the stocks of petrol the previous night, after the meeting at Aman Guest House.

Had petrol not been kept ready in loose form in carboys the previous night near Aman Guest House, “it would not have been possible to reach with carboys containing petrol in a huge quantity immediately, that is within 5 to 10 minutes, near coach S-6,” the court observed.

The court found a ‘pre-planned conspiracy’ to target the Hindu pilgrims because otherwise “it would not have been possible to gather Muslim persons with deadly weapons within five to six minutes and reach near “A” cabin on the railway track” after the train was made to stop by chain pulling a second time.

The court further observed that the attack was not a random attack on S-6, but was specifically targeted at the kar sevaks returning from Ayodhya.

“Shouting of slogans by the assailants and announcement over a loudspeaker from a nearby mosque also clearly suggest motive and pre-plan,” it noted.

https://swarajyamag.com/news-brief/for-godhra-it-wasnt-first-case-of-burning-alive-hindu-community-members-the-event-that-triggered-2002-riots

https://www.firstpost.com/india/accused-of-burning-sabarmati-express-farooq-bhana-imran-sheru-given-life-sentence-by-gujarat-hc-incident-led-to-2002-godhra-riots-5059231.html


r/IndiaRWResources • • Mar 18 '21

HISTORY My retort to a Pakistani who claimed that India is a false nation created by the British

100 Upvotes

No, I have to respectfully disagree with your preposition. I have read similar claims from individuals attempting to somehow de-legitimize the Republic of India's existence as a united entity and polity. The truth is, a civilization is composed of many different elements. Political unity is not an absolute requirement for a civilization but even here there were moments where Bharata was unified under local and indigenous-rule, such as during the Mauryan and Gupta dynasties. The Maratha empire was also quite large at its territorial zenith. In-fact, one can argue that the Delhi Sultanates and Mughal empire were Indic polities. Sure, their rulers followed a foreign faith but it was syncretized extensively with the cultural milieu of Bharatavarsha - examples such as Akbar or Dara Shikoh come to mind. The Sufis themselves were extensively and fundamentally influenced by Indic philosophy and practices.

It can also be said that the Indo-Gangetic plains is the core-region and birthplace of Indic civilization (where the Indus Valley Civilization syncretized with the Steppe migrants and formed the Vedic culture). This is analogous to other civilizations like China (Zhonghuo) where the region surrounding the Yellow river and down until the Yangtze river were the birthplace and core territory of what scholars and academics refer to as China proper. Thus, one can argue that the Indo-Gangetic plains region is India proper. If empires that controlled most of China proper can be considered a unified China (such as the Qin and Song dynasties), then dynasties like Harshavardhan's or the three polities of the tripartite struggle (Pratihara, Pala, and Rashtrakuta dynasties) who each have controlled nearly-all of this region at various times in this period of history can also be considered a unified India proper. Thus, this clearly refutes the claims made by a certain group of people who want to place doubts in the sanctity of Indian union by claiming there is no historical precedence for its occurrence.

But that is merely political unity, we have not discussed cultural, religious, linguistic, familial, musical, artistic, genetic, phenotypical, and other elements in-which the subcontinent of India demonstrates a clear and concise overlaying unity and grand form - sometimes on a cline but definitely part of a greater cultural structure.

Even in ancient times, Indians knew we belonged to a certain civilization that was distinct from others. Let me quote a passage from the Vishnu Purana:

ऋषभो मरुदेव्याश्च ऋषभात भरतो भवेत् भरताद भारतं वर्षं, भरतात सुमतिस्त्वभूत् Rishabha was born to Marudevi, Bharata was born to Rishabha, Bharatavarsha (India) arose from Bharata and Sumati arose from Bharata.

    —Vishnu Purana (2,1,31)

ततश्च भारतं वर्षमेतल्लोकेषुगीयते भरताय यत: पित्रा दत्तं प्रतिष्ठिता वनम (विष्णु पुराण, २,१,३२) This country is known as Bharatavarsha since the times the father entrusted the kingdom to the son Bharata and he himself went to the forest for ascetic practices.[31]

    —Vishnu Purana (2,1,32)

uttaraṃ yatsamudrasya himādreścaiva dakṣiṇam varṣaṃ tadbhārataṃ nāma bhāratī yatra santatiḥ

उत्तरं यत्समुद्रस्य हिमाद्रेश्चैव दक्षिणम् । वर्षं तद् भारतं नाम भारती यत्र संततिः ।। "The country (varṣam) that lies north of the ocean and south of the snowy mountains is called Bhāratam; there dwell the descendants of Bharata."

    —Vishnu Purana

Sanskrit was our lingua-franca, language of academics, arts, and statecraft. When the Arab caliphates invaded western India, the local Indian rulers put aside their fights and squabbles to unite as a common force to protect this land from the mleccha (foreign) invaders - they were successful at repelling the Arabs. Thus they clearly saw themselves as belonging to the same civilizational entity and were able to distinguish the Arabian Muslim armies as outsider to this civilization. In-fact, outsiders since ancient times have also recognized and seen India as a single cultural and geographical supra-entity. Whether it was the Persians, Greeks, or Chinese.

When the Bhakti movement begun in modern-day Tamizh Nadu, its influence spread far-and-wide across Bharata Varsha and led to the emergence of Sikhism in the northern plains of the Panjab. This has always been a civilization entity in-which even peripheral regions interact and influence one another in often unexpected ways.

Even if your preposition was true (it is not but lets entertain the fantasy of it being a reality) than the United India you see today is not a product of the British but rather of Sardar Patel painstakingly ensuring a mostly-united Bharata (Nepal and Sri Lanka have developed their separate Westphalian-state identities due to the influence of Westerners) - not the Brits. The colonialists always tried their best to divide-and-conquer us and they left India as a shattered land with over 500 states. It was Indians themselves who came together after and fought to be united - do not discredit the work of our independence leaders and mock them in the worst-way by claiming the Brits were responsible for their success when the opposite is the case. There is a reason that India built such a massive statue for Sardar Patel and christened it with the name of 'Statue of Unity'.

Jai Hind. Bharat Mata ki Jai.


r/IndiaRWResources • • Jan 02 '21

Use the phrase "Grooming Jihad" instead of "Love Jihad"

100 Upvotes