r/IdeaFeedback • • Jul 12 '14

Name An internal investigations police squad name

13 Upvotes

I have finished writing a crime thriller, but still haven't been able to think of a decent name for this squad:

They're a small in-depth 'internal affairs' team in the London Metropolitan Police Service.

I've tried acronyms, and both metaphorical and meaningless words. I just can't think of anything!

Note: Britain doesn't have "internal affairs", so that can't be part of it. This team has been set up by HMIC to investigate more thoroughly than they usually would.


r/IdeaFeedback • • Jul 12 '14

Name Trying to think of a great name for a fictional, ground-breaking drug that ends aging...

13 Upvotes

I'm about 150,000 thousand words into a rather large thriller, the plot of which revolves around an eccentirc billionaire unveiling a drug that ends aging and thus would let people live a very long lifespan... The drug itself is not what the story is about, more the madness of the characters vying for it and the crazy/occult/worlds that collide in the process and the entangled world that the main character finds himself in. Anyways. I've put off giving this drug a name, but I really can't get much further without addressing this issue. Specifically, I'm writing the chapter where they are giving this big, world-changing press release and everyone wants to know what this miracle drug is called.

Some issues:

  1. I dont want it to sound too clinical, i.e. "Abobotulinumtoxin" or whatevs.

  2. It has to sound believable as a name for a drug- I think.

  3. It has to be super marketable- something slightly badass. You're about to release a world-changing technology and you're lightyears ahead of everyone... what do you call it?

Cheers!

Edit: Thanks everyone! The name I am working with is inspired by /u/littlebutmighty who recommended uses the latin "exten" for giving the sense that the drug extends human life. I made a marketing decision and am calling it X-10, as it sounds 'cooler' and more edgy/futuristic and something you could market the crap out of...


r/IdeaFeedback • • Jul 18 '14

Character Villain motivation

10 Upvotes

I'm finding it difficult to shape the proper motivation for a villain.
The common choices are money and power, but I want something unique. What do you think is more compelling: (note the villain is a normal human being)

  • To protect the world from an unforeseen (by normal people) threat through violent means.

  • To fulfill the literal desire for every person on earth to be dead

  • To force the unification of multiple countries, or continents

  • To realistically acquire their own Utopian city, separate and apart from the rules or lack of rules of their home society

Do you have any unique ideas for villain motivation?


r/IdeaFeedback • • Aug 18 '14

Plot Device How do I transfer powers from one character to another?

9 Upvotes

In the story I'm planning out now there are 11 elemental kings and each king gives his power to his successor through some sort of ritual. My problem is I am unsure of what kind of ritual to have them do. My first thought was some sort of blood ritual. But I don't know if I want to go as far as having them drink their kings blood to gain their power. what do you guys think?


r/IdeaFeedback • • Jul 15 '14

Plot Device A Human Turning Into Sea Monster?

9 Upvotes

So I was thinking about sea monsters for my story. If my MC was bit by a sea serpent out in the ocean on a dare by her intoxicated classmates one night, but it would poison (curse?) her and turn her into a cecealia (part human, part octopus), but a. I don't know how to keep her as a sympathetic character/ having to kill to survive? And b. I just think of the Little Mermaid.

It's supposed to be modern, a college-aged marine biology student but aside from the Loch Ness Monster, no one really believes in sea serpents or sea witches anymore.

Any and all thoughts are appreciated! I am at the end of the day tiredness, so I hope this makes sense.


r/IdeaFeedback • • Nov 24 '16

Overall Story Story of where the Heros defeat the Bad Guys, but in reality the Heros are the Bad Guys

8 Upvotes

I've played around with the idea of Evil Council are destroying the world and group of Heroes come in and defeat them through multiple encounters before a final showdown.

However what if the Bad Guys were in reality trying to balance the world from the corruption of humans and all the Heroes were doing was promoting corruption by protecting the corrupted.

What are you're thoughts on this idea, an example of what I'm writing is ////// A Jester character goes around killing people. He toys with his prey and plays death games with them, however he always leaves a few people alive and keeps to a promise of never hurting them again.

The Heroes see that the Jester is killing people and slaughtering towns and villages so they confront him, play his games and defeat him.

In his death throes he speaks with a clear voice. "Cry me a river, for your actions speak volumes higher than a voice that shouts. Words can be manipulated, lies woven into truths and truths into lies, when you hear a story from someone else then there is a greater chance that the words itself are lies. However your actions come from the core. Your actions in itself are justifiable of what truly resides. Ponder this. What you've heard of us "Demons", oh did they come from personal experience or did they come from the words of others. Now can you understand if what you have been doing is truly right?" //////

Basically everytime one of the Bad Guys die they leave a message trying to convince the Heroes that what they've been doing is wrong and they are supporting the wrong side. This creates conflict between the Heroes, in themselves and each other.

If you want clarification of what I am trying to say then just comment. Share your thoughts, improve the idea.


r/IdeaFeedback • • Jan 25 '15

Announcement Welcome new people! Subreddit update!

8 Upvotes

The number of subscribers of /r/Ideafeedback have jumped significantly in the past few days, breaking 300! So, welcome!

After a bit of consideration, we've decided to stop the weekly stickied threads, and instead simply post non-stickied questions more often. We will still award flair for the best comment of the week, but it won't be restricted to any one thread. The winner will be announced with a link to the specific comment on Sundays. We hope that this will promote more activity.

And as always: give us feedback! Is there anything you think is odd or should be changed? Anything you particularly like and want to stay? Tell us!


r/IdeaFeedback • • Jan 15 '15

Character How do you humanize a villain without making him actually sympathetic?

8 Upvotes

As usual in my posts on Reddit: I apologize for my English beforehand. I'm fluent and I'd say that I express ideas better in English than in my mother tongue, but it's still not what I speak during most of the day, so sometimes I mix grammars.

I don't like fully bad characters - I feel that there is something as an "anti-sue", in the sense that, even if the world is full of monsters, monsters also have something good inside them (even if it's not in their ethics). So I always try to give them some goodness, even if it's just a little. But there are certain kinds of villains that are... a little dangerous to humanize.

For example, I have a Monster of the Day that is a neonazi. And I am very afraid of giving him good traits because, come on, it's someone who spanks minorities in the streets and is okay with the idea of genocide. People shouldn't sympathize with that. But at the same time, no one is pure evil. Pure evil is not realistic and sounds preachy.

How do you deal with it?


r/IdeaFeedback • • Sep 15 '14

Overall Story What is your character(s) internal conflict?

8 Upvotes

r/IdeaFeedback • • Jul 15 '14

What if...? I have an idea for a man-made island that is positioned off the coast of Brazil.

8 Upvotes

The point of the island is that it will contain the world's most advanced college. The entire endeavor is financed by a privately owned corporation.

I'm facing a lot of logistical problems with this idea. What kind of impact does a man-made island have on it's environment? How much construction would actually go into this? Why would any country (specifically Brazil) allow this to made right off their shoreline? And most importantly, why does it have to be a man-made island in the first place? I mean it's an island because I (the writer) want it to be, but it's becoming hard for me to come up with a reason why (in the context of the story) it can't be located on the main land.

All the specifics of this idea have been making it difficult. I'm considering scrapping it and trying something else, but I'm interested in hearing your opinions. Maybe it's actually worth saving. Any feedback is welcome.


r/IdeaFeedback • • Jan 22 '17

Plot Device [Plot Device]How did the slave chance upon the artifact?

7 Upvotes

The slaves are mostly in their master's houses. They do most of the work of the world, including working in factories, cleaning the world, maintaining their master's houses(except cooking), pleasuring, etc. But they do all of this work either in closed rooms or in chains.

The artifact is in the king's artifact room, which is accessible only by the royal family. The slave which chances upon the artifact works in the king's house. So, how does he enter the artifact room?

Note- A theory I created was that the slave would be a pleasure slave to the king's young daughter(different kind of society), he would have a craving to see artifacts and she would let him enter the artifact room on his request. But this would not be fit for a young adult book. So, any other ideas?


r/IdeaFeedback • • Jul 12 '15

Character How do I get this character to communicate?

7 Upvotes

So. Character. At first it's an enemy (it's not human), then people find out why it's there, turns out it's helping. But I don't know how this thing is supposed to be able to communicate.

Do I make it completely silent? Only showing it's intent with movements? It's supposed to be a mysterious (humanoid) creature for pretty much the entire story as it looks right now.

Do I make it control a person and let it speak through that person? Is that too cliché? (I know Falling Skies does it, but that's just the first one that comes to mind.) Maybe only one exact person can communicate with it?

Do I make it talk? Telepathically? I'm really not sure at all.


r/IdeaFeedback • • Oct 28 '14

Overall Story How cliche is this?

7 Upvotes

I've had an idea floating around about a detective that grabs his case. For reasons unknown to the reader, the detective took a 10 year hiatus from duty, and recently came back to the force. He takes a seemingly simple case of a theft, but as the case comes along, more and more parallelisms to a previous case (one that was actually traumatic enough for him to leave the force) remind the detective of a huge mistake he made in the older case, such as convicting the wrong suspect. So after all the details of the old case are revealed, the new case becomes a device for the detective to absolve his mistakes from the older case.

Is this something that's been beaten down before? Or is it interesting enough to put some real work into?


r/IdeaFeedback • • Oct 20 '14

Character General musings about Death and the Reaper.

7 Upvotes

This is not exactly one idea, but rather a collection of a number of interesting concepts I've come up with. For a long time I've found the Grim Reaper to be an interesting character in stories. He's so strange, as he could have a lot of different appearances and personalities.
I'm trying to collect as much information here as possible, so that it can also help other people struggling with this.

1. How does Death work?

  • Does the Reaper actively kill people? Or does he wait for people to die and then pick them up and bring them wherever they have to go?

  • Is the date of a person's death fixed? In other words, is there such a thing as fate? Can people successfully avoid death and escape the waiting reaper or does he always know your unavoidable date of death?

2. What happens after Death?

  • Death is the End. The Reaper simply collects the dead and in some way destroys them

  • Heaven and Hell. The Reaper brings the dead to some sort of trial, and from there they go to the afterlife they deserve.

  • Only one kind of afterlife. (Rebirth, some kind of realm of the dead)

  • If the Reaper „kills“ the dead, does he also accompany them afterwards? Or does he just kill then and then leave the souls find their way on their own?

3. What kind of personality does the Reaper have?

  • Is he a friend of the living? A friend of the dying? A friend of the dead?

  • Is he evil? Does he enjoy to see people die and suffer, does he enjoy killing?

  • Does he maybe have any ties to good or evil deities? Or is he neutral?

  • Is he a funny person? (Skulls are always grinning!), or more of a solemn type?

  • Does he have hobbies? Does he have free time, and if yes, how does he spend it? Playing the fiddle seems to be rather common.

4.How do people perceive the Reaper?

  • Every second, people die. If the Reaper spends more than a brief moment with his victim/client, how can he manage?

  • Possible options:

  1. The Reaper can be at different places at the same time.

  2. There are many reapers, not just one.

  3. Every mortal has a personal Reaper, and they can only see their one.

  4. ??? The Reaper is a very enigmatic character. He doesn't need an explanation.

5. What does the Reaper look like?
You can go all-out on this one. Endless possibilities. I'll list a few.

  • This would probably be linked to his personality. Is he scary? Or is he more reassuring and familiar.

  • Of course, there is always the typical image of the skeleton in a black cloak and with a scythe. But this can go many ways. Is it a simple cloak and a scythe that actually looks like a piece of farming equipment? Or does he wield a big-ass badass monster of a weapon that only remotely looks like a scythe?

  • Maybe, the appearence of the Reaper changes according to culture and time. In the middle ages, he wore a black cloak, nowadays he wears a black suit.

  • How does he know who dies? Maybe he has a book with everyone's date of death in it.

  • If each one has a „personal“ Reaper, maybe this Reaper reflects the human's cause of death? For example, a smoker who will die of lung cancer would see death as a chain smoker. (Side note: Imagining the Grim Reaper as morbidly obese seems really weird. But intriguing!)
    Is he a skeleton? An unassuming human? Maybe a gaunt, dried-up dead creature?

  • Last but not least: Is the Reaper male? Why should he have to be male? In French for example, „Death“ is female (La Mort). And so is the Reaper (La Faucheuse). On the other hand, why should the Reaper have to have a gender in the first place? If they're only a skeleton, how would anyone judge their gender?

This isn't complete. Just a few ideas, I might keep updating this if I come up with more. Enjoy! I'd love to hear if you have anything interesting to add!


r/IdeaFeedback • • Oct 13 '14

Character What makes your villains evil?

7 Upvotes

What makes them the bad guys, not just the antagonist?


r/IdeaFeedback • • Oct 06 '14

Name I need a faction name.

7 Upvotes

In my alt history project, the Sino-Soviet Treaty of Friendship, Alliance and Mutual Assistance did not break down as it did in real life, leading the Soviets and PRC to form a powerful alliance that was capable of taking on NATO and becoming the dominant world power.

For a temporary/starting name, I came up with People's Coalition Army (PCA) as a name for the faction, with a possibility that it commonly referred to simply the People's Coalition for short. The problem is that I don't feel this name/acronym really does much...and it feels awkward ("Oh look, its a People's Coalition soldier...a PCA soldier...a...yeah...that sounds stupid.") I think a big reason it sounds so awkward could be because it can't be turned into an adjective, e.g. "Soviet tank" or pluralized noun, e.g. "the Americans"

So I would like to hear any suggestions or thoughts people might have for what sort of name a combined Russian/Chinese alliance would go by. Some more context FYI:

In the time of this story (2020 or so) the PCA is in control of over half of the world's landmass and is the only clear superpower. It presents itself to the international community as a Coalition of communist nation-states, but is in reality a mostly-centralized authoritative government with a relationship much like the real-life Soviet-era Russia and the rest of the USSR.

Internally, China and Russia are clearly the dominant powers. They have tensions with each other, but they have been "in bed" together so long (greater than 60 years) that they can't afford to piss off the other too much.

One other thing to chew on, if anyone reads this far; most if not all of the PCA participants in this story will come from Russia or PCA-governed England...I'm not sure if that should have an impact on what people refer to them as.

Thanks!


r/IdeaFeedback • • Sep 01 '14

Name Names for bars/clubs/taverns

7 Upvotes

What are your best names for any bar/cub/tavern? Any type of setting.


r/IdeaFeedback • • Aug 21 '14

Overall Story Would this have an audience?

7 Upvotes

I am beginning to write what I would deem a postmodern YA novel, but i feel like its structure would turn away most YA readers and its YA status would turn away postmodern readers. Basically, would this either find a niche, or would it be approachable for people?

The story is about a high school kid who wants to make a movie with classmates, but when the classmates argue over what the movie should be, he secretly uses the footage to create an amateur documentary about making the movie.

The story would begin with the main character and his friend beginning to watch the movie. Every further chapter, up until the last, would alternate between the contents of the documentary and the main character's account of what actually happened.

I know that some YA authors, like Riordan, have somewhat weird narrative styles, but will this find a place? Am I worrying over nothing?


r/IdeaFeedback • • Jul 27 '14

Magic System What is the price of magic?

7 Upvotes

Welcome /r/IdeaFeedback,

This will be the first experiment for weekly discussion prompts. Interpret the prompt however which way you like. The prize for winning these weekly threads is a special flair next to your username. We'll announce how the winner will be determined later. I can tell you now that the winner does not necessarily have to be a top level comment. So don't shy away from putting effort into your replies. Share your idea or build off of someone else's.

So tell me /r/IdeaFeedback, what is the price of magic?


r/IdeaFeedback • • Jul 24 '14

Name Ryan Everett or Randy Everett?

7 Upvotes

I need to pick a name for my MC, but the problem is that I like both names and I dont know what name to pick. Can you help me??


r/IdeaFeedback • • Jul 19 '14

Announcement Subreddit update incoming! Please read!

7 Upvotes

I'm thrilled with how well this subreddit is going and the contributions made. So YAY!

As of right now, the sidebar is very empty, and maybe it shouldn't be. But before I make any changes, I wanted you guys to have a say in what I propose.

RULES

So far we haven't had any formalized rules, but I figure there should be a couple for future reference. Essentially, I just want to officialize how things have already been functioning. This is a working list, so let me know if they should be changed or you have another to add.

  1. All posts should be text self-posts.

  2. Links to articles or blogs are not allowed, even within a text post. This place is for ideas, not the actual writing.

  3. Short excerpts or samples of stories for the use of explaining the idea in question are fine. The sample shouldn't exceed 500 words.

  4. Linking to a document for people to read on their own time is fine, but please don't ask for writing critiques.

  5. Don't be a dick.

TOOLS

I was thinking of having a list of generators as tools on the sidebar, in different categories depending on focus. If you know of a good generator that I don't have listed, link in the comments with a short description and I'll add it to the list. These are the ones I've used:

  • Rinkworks. Awesome random algorithm, probably my favorite. It has several premade sets, but if the ability to input your own stipulations in the randomized names is really useful.

  • Seventh Sanctum. Lots of different generators, some as names some as conceptual things.

  • Cult of Squid. LOTS of generators and all focused on different types of names. Most are fantasy of some flavor.

  • DonJon. Fantasy generators, from names to dungeons or anything else. Also has a fractal world generator in the site, but I've not played with it too much.

  • The Forge. Four different generators, fairly simple and using words for various things.

  • Behind the Name. Huge generator for names of different ethnicity or languages, including mythology and a couple of 'other' subsets.

TAGS

I was thinking of having a system of tags or flair for posts to indicate what the subjects within might be. For example, [CHARACTER] or [NAMES], [PLOT] to add to the titles. On one hand this sounds cool, on the other maybe not necessary. And I don't know the CSS code to make fancy flair work yet, so it would have to be in text form at first. What's your opinions?

Last note: If anyone wants to become a mod, message me. Especially if you are familiar with CSS.


r/IdeaFeedback • • Jul 17 '14

What if...? Alternate History: If the Manhattan Project had been shelved.

7 Upvotes

I'm in the early stages of a story where history diverges from ours around the 1930s when a lighter than air "super-material" is created, leading to a world where armored airships are the backbone of military force. World War II ends with a Air Fleet supported land invasion of Japan - the Manhattan Project was cancelled and nuclear weapons become no more than a fantasy (they could be compared to how we think of sci-fi weapons or fusion reactors).

Does that sound at all interesting?

Here is a rather general overview of the world that I am cooking up. I would love it if you kind folks would be able to tell me if you think the historical events and descriptions of society sounds plausible or interesting.

What I haven't mentioned on the blog is a major plot device of the book - nukes are finally developed (about 90 years "late") and used.

Shelving the Manhattan Project:

The difficulty of course is that I have to find a way to get the Manhattan Project cancelled and not restarted by governments before the events of the story, but still have enough information intact for the technology to re-emerge eventually, for the sake of my plot.

The working theory

The leading scientists on the project have moral reservations about creating such a terrifying weapon and decide to falsify certain things, such as calculations of costs ("this will require 5x the energy output of the world") or the effectiveness of the weapon ("costs 2x as much as conventional weapons for same effects").

However, one or a couple scientists can't stand to destroy all their work; so, while the false results and information is sent up the chain, one "real" copy of the information is secretly sent to a trusted, close friend not related with the project. The rest of the information is destroyed - the official line on the Manhattan Project is that it was a wild goose chase.

One of the primary characters is a descendant of that scientist; he knows about the project and knows that something about its conclusion was fishy. Suspecting nuclear weapons are actually possible, he gathers enough correct information from surviving scraps of various WWII nuclear programs and enough new knowledge from "free-thinking" scientists to get close. But the final clue (I'm thinking formulas-in-code or some shtick like that) only exists at the archives in a small town where the secret information ended up being dumped and forgotten.

I feel like I've written way too much already - so thanks for looking! I can answer more details if you'd like to help me test this idea, and there's also a 5-sentence summary of the plot on the blog if you would like to see that.


r/IdeaFeedback • • Jul 15 '14

Plot Device Help thinking of names of imaginary Mountain Dew flavors rejected by focus groups in the 90s

7 Upvotes

One of my characters works in a secret Mountain Dew test lab. A lot of the flavors never make it past focus groups or even to focus groups. I have some names already but I'm not crazy about all of them. Keep in mind this part of the book is set in the mid-90s.

What I have so far:

Extreme Skater Orange, Crystal Blue Explosion, Gnarly Nacho Nirvana, Radioactive Red and Phat Fresh.


r/IdeaFeedback • • Sep 17 '16

Plot Device 80k words into a novel and I need a device to fit the plot: The main character is trying to open a 'portal' but has to sacrifice a hundred souls. I'd like to have a sort of meter he can keep with him to check his progress... (more inside)

6 Upvotes

To cross into another world, the main character is charged with sacrificing a ton of people in order to open the 'portal', so to say, and gain safe passage. The demon guarding the door, whom he barters with exacts this price, and I want him to give the main character some token or device in order to keep tabs on his progress. It's set in modern day but draws on some global myths and legends. On one hand he could just use a bloody sheet of paper and a pencil and keep tally marks, on the other it could be an amulet with gems that light up or whatever else can be imagined. Any ideas!?


r/IdeaFeedback • • Oct 25 '15

What if...? What steps might a Government Agency or Facility take to prevent being monitored by Aliens?

6 Upvotes

Particularly, aliens it knows almost nothing about.

Lets say the conspiracy theorists are right, and the U.S. government (or some other government) actually is aware of some kind of “alien” activity on or around Earth. Maybe they’ve recovered remains from a crash site, or maybe they've just investigated a little more into the UFO phenomenon than they’re letting on. Either way, they have reason to believe the Earth is being monitored by some kind of other worldly intelligence, and they’re keeping the knowledge from the general public. But here’s the thing, the general public isn’t who they’re really worried about, the secrecy is to prevent any aliens that might be watching us from finding out how much we know about them.

So, if you’re forced to operate under the assumption that you may be monitored by technology far beyond your own understanding, what do you do? What kind of protocols, technologies, and tradecraft would be developed and used in that state of total paranoia?

Some Ideas:

  • To eliminate nonessential personnel, everyone would have to be trained to perform necessary maintenance work, and take turns doing janitorial duties.

  • To avoid regular schedules, individual “shifts” might last anywhere from hours to months, and be assigned by a randomized lottery.

  • Facilities may have to be somewhat self-sufficient, so they might include farms and greenhouses where employees grow their own food.

  • To prevent anything being hacked, they might try to keep everything as low-tech and “off the grid" as they can. Such an organization might try to use computers as little as possible, relying instead on “old-school” methods of record keeping (index cards, etc.), analogue media formats (microfilms, etc.), mechanical typewriters, and a system pneumatic tubes for sending documents and mail. It’s a bit of a stretch, but they might even develop advanced mechanical computers using extremely small, intricate mechanical components engineered at a micro scale.

  • Long-distance communication would have to be accomplished through trusted couriers… or maybe pigeons.