r/IWasSurprisedToo • • Mar 19 '15

Passing the 'Football' [Science Fiction, Serious]

Thumbnail
reddit.com
24 Upvotes

r/IWasSurprisedToo • • Nov 04 '16

[Series] Shoujo/Hell No! [Trope parody, Comedy, Anime]

21 Upvotes

Part One

Part Two

Part Three

Part Four

Hello, people who've chosen to subscribe to me (for reasons that escape comprehension)!

I'd like to know what you think. Should I continue this in the prompt itself, on my subreddit, or at all? Let me know, please


r/IWasSurprisedToo • • Jul 16 '15

[Analysis] Malcolm in the Middle. [Life is Unfair]

8 Upvotes

This is a new feature I'm trying. Occasionally I'll do a detailed analysis of an existing series for themes and motifs, as well as logical inferences and hidden references,and reaction to them has been positive, so I'm including it here.

If you have suggestions, feel free to send them to me.

I'm including transcriptions as well as in-context links.

Section One is Here.

In response to:

That was kind of the point, wasn't it? Him being a genius and all.

He wasn't, though. He was just bright. But he was also prideful, spiteful, and a neurotic wreck. His entire character was a stunning denouncement against the "gifted kid", the one we all secretly believed ourselves to be, because Malcolm was that character incarnate, and he was the person we were supposed to relate to. Seriously.

Remember when he got a perforated ulcer in his stomach? What kind of kid gets a stress ulcer?! Also, remember how spiteful he was towards Dewey, when he discovered he was a musical savant, and Malcolm wasn't? How he had assumed that he would be good at music too, but since it requires actual inspiration and not rote memorization, he was awful at it?! He deafened his brother with the headphones he was wearing. Malcolm was a pretty miserable kid, because he had confused his intelligence with worth. Just about everyone else in his family got to grow and change, but he never really did. They even introduced a character as a " future Malcolm analogue ", someone who was really miserable, but even after getting a really sobering look at his future, a few weeks later, he was back to doing the same shit.

I could go on and on, but the moral of the story is that that character is... Well. You know.

Section Two is Here.

In response to:

Just because he had a bunch of flaws doesn't mean he can't be a genius. It makes even more sense. Here's a kid who's so smart, but he'll never get ahead because he can't get over himself.

It goes deeper than that.

I'm noticing quite a few comments complaining about analyzing this show to this degree, and also that it was incorrect for me to call Malcolm "gifted", instead of a genius. Here's why I believe I'm right.

First off, the show was produced by Linwood Boomer, who wrote the pilot personally. He's never been shy about talking about his contempt for those kinds of accelerated programs, and their obsession with IQ. He gave Malcolm an absurdly high one to underscore that fact. He loosely based Malcolm's character on the experiences he had in a gifted school program himself. Hell, the episode I referenced above, Dewey's Opera, is one of the few ones that he personally directed.

Secondly, the clues to the actual, deeply judgmental character of the show are present right in the opening credits, if you know to look for them. That clip of a robot head being assembled? That was from a BBC adaptation of a Isaac Asimov short story called Liar!, about a robot that somehow aquires telepathy, but due to the rules of robotics, cannot tell other humans the truth about what it knows, and has to pretend, in many cases, to be something else. However, this ends up hurting people, and the robot itself, anyway. The anime clips? They're from an OVA adaptation of a series called Nazca, where the main protagonist needs to decide if he'll take the role laid out for him (which will make him miserable), or fight against it, which might mean alienating others, and losing approval. Hell, even the theme song is about a youthful rebellion quelled by how "life is unfair".

It goes deeper still. Dewey is actually very intelligent. He's a musical savant, but he also possesses insights that verge into wisdom, despite his young age. He's also the only one of the siblings to escape the cycle of violence directed at the youngest, being a caring and compassionate brother to Jaime. And what happens to him? Well, the very same school system that had held Malcolm's test scores in such high esteem, put him in a class with the "Buseys", A.K.A., the special needs students, because of an error. However, because Dewey is usually offbeat, subdued, and amiable, they never catch their mistake, not even after an innocent offhand remark caused a teacher many years his senior to question her faith, despite the fact that determining the intelligence of children is literally their job.

Also, take a careful look at who Malcolm most admires: his eldest brother, Francis. His defining character trait is rebellion. Fighting against authority. Malcolm can't do that. He's overwhelmed by expectations and ego, about what a 'genius' he is, and what that means. However, the reality is, actual geniuses need to rebel. The have to fight against the status quo in some way, but Malcolm is so hamstrung by his own pride and anxiety, that it will never happen. Not until he changes, which he doesn't know how to do. Look at what was said to him in episode 1 season 7, at the Burning Man festival with Rosanna Arquette. It's one of the few times he's been faced with someone who is genuinely smarter than he is, and she found him wanting.

Look at what he does, too. He's never shown with any real interests of his own. Reese becomes a culinary wunderkind, Dewey has his music, and Francis has his ridiculous pranks, but Malcolm is never really shown with any passions or pursuits of his own. The only accomplishments he has are ones in an academic setting, the same setting which was already impugned earlier in the world of the show. He doesn't care about anything, really. He has spates of infatuation, he cares about academic perfomance, but the ultimate clue comes from the fact that he scored 100% in all areas in a career aptitude test. I don't know about you all, but I have taken several of those tests, and since they ask comparative questions between different fields, as well as baseline functionality questions, the only way to get a result like that is to give multiple, contradictory answers. Either that, or it's another dig at the world of test-based evaluation, which is also possible. When was the last time you heard of a genius, in anywhere except bad fiction, that wasn't deeply passionate about what it is they are so brilliant at? They don't need to be induced to do it, though things like school assignments, they will do it anyway.

Malcolm is more than a comedy, it's also a cautionary tale. It's telling you that, if you find yourself relating to him, it's time to take a good, hard look at yourself in the mirror.


r/IWasSurprisedToo • • Oct 13 '16

Alien Fiction. [Science Fiction, Speculative]

Thumbnail
reddit.com
7 Upvotes

r/IWasSurprisedToo • • Oct 13 '16

A Test of Morality. [Science Fiction, What-If]

Thumbnail
reddit.com
7 Upvotes

r/IWasSurprisedToo • • Oct 13 '16

Cause of Action: Rapture. [Comedy]

Thumbnail
reddit.com
6 Upvotes

r/IWasSurprisedToo • • Mar 03 '15

This is a story about Emily. Emily is six years old, and she is a Space Empress. [Whimsy, Series?]

Thumbnail
reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/IWasSurprisedToo • • Feb 28 '15

The Unveiling of the Fairy King. [Comedy, Fantasy]

Thumbnail
reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/IWasSurprisedToo • • Feb 28 '17

Corona. [Realism, Agony, Joy]

Thumbnail
reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/IWasSurprisedToo • • Oct 13 '16

Spares. [Science Fiction, Existential Horror]

Thumbnail
reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/IWasSurprisedToo • • Dec 31 '15

The 64,000-Drachma Question. [Alternate History]

Thumbnail
reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/IWasSurprisedToo • • Mar 11 '15

The Loneliest Man Under the Sea. [Serious, Strange, Melancholic]

Thumbnail
reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/IWasSurprisedToo • • Mar 02 '15

When Malware Saved the World. [Science Fiction, Comedy, Plugins]

Thumbnail
reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/IWasSurprisedToo • • Nov 02 '16

The Connecting Flight. [Magical Realism, Ache, Redemptive]

Thumbnail
reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/IWasSurprisedToo • • Oct 13 '16

The Defense Calls... The Joker. [Established Universe, In-Character]

Thumbnail
reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/IWasSurprisedToo • • Oct 13 '16

Monkey's Paw? Call WISH-LAW! [Comedy, Established Universe]

Thumbnail
reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/IWasSurprisedToo • • Dec 18 '15

The Hunter's Sign. [Mythology, Fantasy, Series?]

Thumbnail
reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/IWasSurprisedToo • • Dec 03 '15

What Should Have Been Left There. [Science Fiction, Elegiac, Series?]

Thumbnail
reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/IWasSurprisedToo • • Nov 26 '15

Recourse. [Science Fiction]

Thumbnail
reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/IWasSurprisedToo • • Oct 07 '15

The Spy Who... Liked Me As A Friend. [Established Universe, Comedy]

Thumbnail
reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/IWasSurprisedToo • • Sep 30 '15

Keep Smiling... It's Our Only Hope. [Comedy, SciFi]

Thumbnail
reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/IWasSurprisedToo • • Sep 19 '15

No Quests for Me, Thanks. [Realistic Fantasy, Thoughtful]

Thumbnail
reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/IWasSurprisedToo • • Sep 17 '15

TimeSpoiler. [Science Fiction]

3 Upvotes

From this prompt.


They pulled the bag from my head.

I tried to blink in the sudden glare of halogen bulbs. One of my eyes was swelling shut, and my lip had split from hitting the bare metal floor of the panel van they'd thrown me in.

It tasted like a mouthful of pennies. I tried to spit, but I couldn't lean forward far enough, and it hit my neck and collar wetly.

A file folder hit the desk in front of me, and I recognized the glossy photo paper-clipped to the front.

I was buying a large coffee, at the neighborhood Starbucks. I did that a lot. It always amazed me, like when heroin was still made by Bayer, and it could be bought from a drugstore.

Damn it. I guess I wasn't careful enough.

"You paid with a dollar bill from 2013, Mr. Ryan. A genuine dollar, one that looked like it'd been in circulation for years. That was all I needed."

...I could kick myself. Fuck. I'm better than that! No wonder caffeine is illegal...

I heard his chair scrape back, as he stood, and walked around the table. "It's alright, we understand. Mornings, huh? Don't they suck?"

"Now, Mr. Ryan, though that's not your real name, you have a real problem. See, the government's going to want you real bad, once we tell them about you. So, let's talk."

...What?

"Wait!" I said, trying to enunciate past my balloon of a lower lip, "You're not the government!?"

"No, Mr. Not-Ryan. I'm a television producer. And I know all about your little scam. It's... original." He tapped the table several times, thoughtfully. I caught a flash of square-rimmed glasses. "It might be the only original thing about you, come to think of it. Is this how people from the future spend their time?"

I shut my mouth quickly.

"Oh, give it up, you idiot. We know! Did you really think people from the past wouldn't figure it out? That we were idiots? I'm a television producer. I spend my days with my head filled with improbable notions."

"Y-you can't prove-"

"-Oh?"

He held a red-filled vial in front of my face. Blood? I'd passed out after they hit me with the cattle prod the third time, it was possible it was-

"-Yes, it's yours. What happens when we put this under a microscope, find antibodies for an influenza strain that's still twenty years out from happening, you schmuck? You think you can spin that?! Or rhinovirus, or some future vaccine, or anything else? I write TV for a living, motherfucker. You think I haven't thought about time travelers?"

My mind raced. He had me. "-FUCK! Fucking fuck!"

I heard the grin in his voice. "Good. You know where you stand." He said smugly. God, I hated him for it.

"I do mean it, by the way. Clever scam. Write down the endings before the writers think of them online, on websites you know the writers read. Make them think you're some kind of genius. Attack with their feelings of inadequacy. Make them pay you for their own endings, they would have written on their own. Spares them writer's block, the whole creative process, all of it. The stories end how they're supposed to, anyway, so the timeline hardly shifts at all. No 'Biff Tannen' for you, huh?"

He leaned in hungrily, and I could see his face clearly for the first time. High forehead, dark hair, cupid's-bow lips that, in other circumstances, would have given him an attractive, Mediterranean look, were instead rendered malevolent and harsh by clinging shadow.

It occurred to me, for the first time, that he wasn't here to punish me. He wanted something.

"You got greedy, Mr. Ryan. But we can still help each other out. Otherwise-" He nodded to one of the man-mountains flanking him, who held up the black bag and cattle prod.

"W-what do you want?"

"Well, my name is Jeff, Mr. Ryan. I'm a very successful man, mostly because of one singular idea, which I based a show off of. It's made me fantastically rich. As you can see, it's also made me very connected. Very powerful! I write a great show! But, well, all good things come to an end, you see."

His look changed, and a ghost of desperation haunted his eyes.

"In this business, how you end them directly affects whether or not you get to work again. And, I'm stuck."

"So, here's my deal. You tell me how my show ends, and I don't hand you over to the government, who'll probably have you filling 18 different mason jars when all's said and done. You do that, and I let you go, though I'd recommend finding a new racket. Otherwise, we taze you until your bowels let go, and then we stick you in a sack."

Shit. Shitshitshitshitshi- "Oh. Okay. Fine. Fine. What's the show?"

"It's on ABC. It's called LOST."

My one good eye became a dinner plate. I felt my heart do the jitterbug in my chest.

I'd never watched that show.

Next to Jeff, one of the goons smacked the shaft of the cattle prod against his palm.

I licked my lips, and grinned nervously. "Ok... S-so, there's this cloud..."

THE END


r/IWasSurprisedToo • • Sep 14 '15

Turbulence. [Comedy]

Thumbnail
reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/IWasSurprisedToo • • Sep 14 '15

Impeach Me, Already! [Comedy]

Thumbnail
reddit.com
3 Upvotes