r/ISTJ • • Jul 20 '24

r/ISTJ Discord Channel

26 Upvotes

Hi all, we have created a Discord channel for r/ISTJ. For perhaps obvious reasons, you can only get an invite by DMing a moderator. We look forward to seeing you there!


r/ISTJ • • 1d ago

Nitpicking Politeness

12 Upvotes

I was at the mall today and had my earbuds on. A couple random ladies approached me and asked a question. I said “what?” and they asked where a certain store was, and I gave them directions. Simple, right?

Before I put my earbuds on, the lady told her friend, “I hate it when people say “what?” to make you repeat a question! It’s so rude!” 😠

Like…what the heck did she expect me to say? 🙄 I didn’t hear her at first. Maybe she wanted me to say “pardon, your highness?” or something lol. She asked a question, and I gave her directions. That’s it.

Anyways, as an ISTJ, I find people who nitpick politeness annoying. I’m all for treating people with respect, but I hate it when people get mad cuz you didn’t respond in the very specific way they deem socially “correct.”


r/ISTJ • • 2d ago

ISTJ, how good are you at naturally pivot easily when facing sudden, unprecedent problems? Naturally flexible and adaptive and solve things immediately right on the spot?

14 Upvotes

Hi ISTJ, can you answer me a question honestly. how good are you at naturally pivot easily when facing sudden, unprecedent problems? Naturally flexible and adaptive and solve things immediately right on the spot?

I really need your help on this, based on your own experience, honest answer.

-------
My husband is someone who just can naturally pivot easily when facing sudden, unprecedent problems. Any hardship, anything you throw at him in his face he will solve the problem immediately right there, as he see no need to wait. He fix it immediately using whatever is available.

Unless he is mistype, but that just how he is naturally. I even show him Te vs Ti articles, and Si vs Se articles, and told him to read it and give me an answer, and he said he use Te and Si

He knows himself best, I just have to go with his answer. But he just so good at pivot easily when facing sudden, unprecedent problems.


r/ISTJ • • 2d ago

Michael Carloz test score 102 tied on ISTJ and ESTJ, how to break tie?

0 Upvotes

Well the ISFJ Type 6 me running on anxiety while complaining about it, has been trying to figure out my husband MBTI.
I guess it best to let him take the test himself, instead of me try to figure out the function and type him.

I gave him the Michael Carloz test and he got 102 score tied of ISTJ and ESTJ

And I just have to accept his answers as final answer. He also Enneagram Type 8 for sure.

I also gave him articles to read on Te vs Ti, and he gave me the answer he use Te
I also gave him article to read on Se vs Si, and he gave me the answer he use Si

And it show on his Michael Carloz test. But how to break the tie? He can't be using both dominant Te (ESTJ) and Si (ISTJ) equally.

eta for more context: His scores is kindda weird but here are his top four

ESTJ score 102, ISTJ score 102, dead tie
INTJ he score 81, and ENTJ he score 79

What I do see, is all of his top four are all contain Te function as the dominant or auxiliary.

Te is the only function shared across all four types, therefore he leading or relying heavily on Te. As INTJ and ENTJ do not have Si

His mistypeinvestigator result, he score 90 on Te, and 85 on Si, so it leading in Te there too.


r/ISTJ • • 3d ago

Oops, I did it again.

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/ISTJ • • 3d ago

Identity crisis

2 Upvotes

Hello sub! I want to open up about something that has been bothering me lately and I am trying to see it from different aspects including MBTI to find an answer.

I always felt like my comfort style somehow goes along with the social norms, like it's just ordinary. I don't feel any pressure from outside to have the lifestyle I have now. I know this doesn't sound bad or anything but when I see people with different styles and very happy and fulfilled in them, I can't help but feel some sort of envy because to me they look like the people who know who they are, what they want, what they like and embrace it. It makes me question who am I and where do I belong in this world.

I've never been able to define all this and seeing people who know who they are and their passions makes me so happy for them that I wish I had that ability as well.

What bothers me about this is that it makes me compare myself to other people and it's a very draining and a depressing loop which is hard to get out of.

I don't really know how to put this in the MBTI sense but I kinda question how can it make sense given my type is this and my functions are that etc.

Does anyone feel the same way? Or anyone has a different view? I'm all ears.


r/ISTJ • • 3d ago

Help regarding post retirement well-being of an ISTJ

0 Upvotes

It's regarding my father who is an ISTJ. He retired earlier this year, since then I feel he is kinda spiralling. I don't think I can talk to him about his sudden restlessness without hurting his feelings.

He is a man working from a very young age everyday to provide for the family. I don't think he would appreciate disrespect. He seems forgetful. He on purpose picks up arguments with me (ENTP) over the most mundane topic, coz he thinks that's the to make me talk to him.(I swear I don't, that's just his perspective). He looses temper often nowadays. He was the most patient person ever. He is more impulsive than before. To me he seems bored.

I have heard as people age their inferior function gets stronger. Is that inferior Ne??

Question: Any older ISTJs who relate to this?? Actually what's going on?? Any idea how to resolve this?? Did you pick up any new hobbies to keep yourself busy?? If you have suggest some.

Even if it's a concern regarding your health how would you like your loved ones to talk to you regarding that??


r/ISTJ • • 5d ago

Who’s your favorite ISTJ fictional character?

26 Upvotes

Mine is Death the Kid from Soul Eater.


r/ISTJ • • 4d ago

ISTJ, what is your Type and Tritype?

0 Upvotes

ISTJ, can you share your Type and your Tritype. I really want to hear what ISTJ have.

Anyone has 864? The "Triple Reactive" Nature. How is a Tritype 864 person is like? Anything you can give me. It an Triple Reactive Tritype.

Thank you so much.


r/ISTJ • • 6d ago

Does this way of viewing the past seem like Si or not really?

0 Upvotes

Like sifting through many layers piled on top of each other. Experiencing something in the present triggers a past memory, which triggers a memory which triggers a memory, etc., until you eventually drift back to the present moment, then repeat forever. Feels somewhat cyclical in terms of the repeated loop

Does this seem like Si or not really? Does this seem like any particular cognitive function in any particular spot e.g. dominant, inferior?

Does Not viewing the past this way point to any particular function or lack thereof?

If you think this could be indicative of any type, to what extent? Would you consider this to be a strong or weak indication?

Do you relate at all to this or not?


r/ISTJ • • 10d ago

Could you tell me how an istj would feel after this?

1 Upvotes

Hi I'm currently interested in an istj but things went south after one evening on the phone I was extremely exhausted and had no energy but didn't want him to feel like I was neglecting him. He was in a very good mood and talking away oblivious to how I was feeling. I tried to tell him I was overwhelmed and I need the most gentle version of him. He kinda brushed it aside just living in his own world. I ended the phone call abruptly and said I need to go eat. I heard the sound of rejection in his voice but I had nothing left in me to give to him.

I sent him this message:

"I am so sleepy - I told u already u can never get mad at me. This wasn't a joke. This is cos my body reacts a lot to peoples anger. When u got mad about the comment about ur dad all my body started hurting and my neck started itching. I tried to be laughy and jokey with u to change ur mood so that I could stop hurting. And then cos of that I couldn't sleep and I am SO SO tired rn.

But even today when I told u I need to be calm you're making jokes and shouting and ur banging pots and pans and I told u I need to be gentle. Just cos I have a more gentle voice doesn't mean I shouldn't be heard.

Shouldn't u be the person I can go to when I'm like that and find comfort in

Maybe sometimes I don't need someone to tell me I'm weird or my hair is showing or I'm getting old - maybe I just need someone that can never think bad of me so even if I think bad of myself I have a home in someone else"

This caused him to lash out at me and now I feel uncertain of everything

I would appreciate your guys feedback if you have any


r/ISTJ • • 11d ago

ISTJ share your your Enneagram Type and Subtype. And how impulsive are you?

0 Upvotes

ISTJ, can you share your Enneagram Type and your subtype, and how impulsive are you? And if you are impulsive, can you give examples. Do you think your Enneagram Type and subtype can drive your impulsive?

Asking this as my ISTJ husband can be hella impulsive, but he is Type 8 SX8, so that explains it, SX8 will drive any MBTI to impulse.

-------

Some examples of his impulsive that just baffled me as he an ISTJ, but the SX8 can really drive it.

5 years we were at Texas for his Oilfield job, his mom in California had a stroke and paralyze. He dare to demand his boss to relocate him back to California due to his mom. And if he boss not relocate him, he will turn in a resignation letter. And this was a 6-figures job.

Then a year ago his boss promoted him to the Executive position. Before he accept the position, he negotiate a No travel clause in his executive contract. Because he wants to be home with the wife me everyday, he will not leave me overnight, let alone one day.

And if any emergency happen to his mom at her Nursing Home, he can be there right away. So no travel.

And if his boss not give him the No travel clause, he will NOT take the Executive position. And that is a 7-figures job.

His boss agreed to the No travel clause, due to his Stanford degree, and his 15 years of experience at the company. Executive positions usually only give to internally, not to outsider. As they need someone with # of years of experience that know the company inside and outside. And my husband has all that fit.

But his decisions were impulsive. And he said it very clear to me, money is NOT more important than me and his mother.

He said money the Stanford him can make money again, but he only has ONE wife, and ONE mother.

And despite him being impulsive, he is a very faithful husband, 17 years long he gives me his absolute fidelity. Even with our toddler died 7 years ago due to gene defects inherit from my side the mother side. He still chose to grow old with me. He rather be childless in exchange of remain with me for life.

And we talking about this is a man who is a Stanford graduated, with Executive career of 1 million salary a year. He can get any woman easily but he not even bat an eye. But he chose to tied himself to me and a dead toddler.

He just cannot see the big picture can he, he is a very concrete thinker, he see what right in front of him at the moment. He is too impulsive for an ISTJ, but SX8 can drive that. I'm still trying to wrap my head around like how can an ISTJ be like this.

These were impulsive. But he said he not impulsive, he said it choices he make based on what priorities to him.


r/ISTJ • • 11d ago

Are you a maker?

4 Upvotes

Unfortunately I'm not, I'm pathfinder


r/ISTJ • • 12d ago

My ISTJ Dad swears he hates chores

11 Upvotes

So funny because he fucking can't get enough of them


r/ISTJ • • 13d ago

Advice in making an ISTJ happy

Thumbnail reddit.com
18 Upvotes

life update, we're engaged!

thank you for all the advice 2 years ago 🥹


r/ISTJ • • 13d ago

Does this sound more like Judging or Perceiving?

0 Upvotes

I am struggling to understand Judging and Perceiving, as I not sure if my husband is ISTJ or ISTP. Can you help tell me if his styles at work is more Judging or Perceiving.

My husband is an Executive at a corporate. And yah. C-suit level Executive are high up in the corporate hierarchy.

How he is at work as an Executive?

Basically regardless of hierarchy, he listened to all his subordinates ideas, he welcomes new ideas and allows teams to speak freely their innovate. BUT that freedom come with the demand of performance, get him the RESULT.

If you can't get the company the result, cannot drive the company upward slope, then out, give the opportunity to someone else to do the job.

So we back to get the result.

But he is a secure leader for sure, because he lets all his subordinates speak freely, he welcomes all inputs and new ideas. He gives them the voice to innovate, and freedom to think.

But he still want result.

I don't know but he is well respect at work. I guess people want to work for a leader who value their mind, give them a voice, let them speak freely their ideas. I guess they feel seen and value, they have an equal voice even as subordinates.

Is he an ISTJ or ISTP, the Judging and Perceiving really throw me off, I not understand it.


r/ISTJ • • 14d ago

Can you explain the Si function, I have a hard time see it in my ISTJ husband.

2 Upvotes

Hi, I am new to MBTI, I always thought my Type 8 husband is an ISTJ. But I struggle to see the Si function in him. So can you explain me more about SI function for you in your case. Thank you so much.

--------

I feel that my husband is more Ti than the Si in ISTJ, he definately Ti, or else he wouldn't married me.
Because
If he care about what society thinks or social norms, or even what his family thinks, he wouldn't married me, because I'm an "embarrassment" for him (that how I see myself).

But he likes to go give the middle finger to social norms, and he just like Type 8, he likes to rebel, and he challenge authority too, I have see him challenge authority, and even his boss in the 17 years with him.

These are Type 8 traits.

For him it all about control, dominant, and fuck society rules, and he likes to challenge and question authority.
And he big on result, he will abandon and change the process to get the result he wants.

Control is big to him, he must be in the control driving seat of the situations.

He control everything in his life, even his mother life prolong or not is depending on his money.
The wife me better obey him too. Make no mistake, my husband run the show in this marriage not me.

At work? The Executive him already fired 3 people at work, simply because they cannot get the RESULT he wants, they cannot bring the profit of the company go up, so out.

It all about result with him.

For context, he did not hire that 3 people, that 3 people already there when he took on the Executive position. And to him they underperform, so he fired them.

The wife me say nothing, I know what to say and what not to say, and certainly the 3rd grade English me do not qualify to butt in the Stanford graduated him career.

I'm struggling see him a true ISTJ too, he is very result oriented. And too Type 8


r/ISTJ • • 16d ago

Table etiquette is so inefficient.

20 Upvotes

I attended an event recently, and I realized how inefficient table etiquette is.

Why are there 3 variations of spoons and knives for salads, desert, the main dish, etc.? I’m pretty sure I completely messed up which utensil to use, and guess what? Nothing happened, and eating wasn’t even difficult. So what exactly is the point of having all these utensil rules, besides showing the world how ReFiNeD you are for knowing them? 🤔

I also find the table arrangements inconvenient. I was sitting at a large circular table with people I didn’t know. I found it annoying how you had to ask people to push the stuff you want towards you cuz they’re too far away from where you’re sitting. Instead of having two salt shaker at the giant table, why not give everyone a small packet of salt? Why not give everyone a small piece of bread instead of having people push around a bread basket? 🤨 I had to extend my arm to grab the butter in the center of the table just to bypass asking people, and one person apologized for not pushing it towards me. I said, “it’s OK, you’re good,” but it felt unnecessarily awkward.

I said what I said. 💅


r/ISTJ • • 18d ago

I need a last round of gentle souls (same or new ones) to help fine-tuning a promising Typing test. People that know their type with 100% certainty.

11 Upvotes

I created a typing test that works based on what you resonate with, it gives you a feed of cards with statements, quotes, scenario, and you select only the ones you resonate with, this way the cognitive load is very low, also the feed adapt to funnel down your type, you just select what you think is related to you.

I already asked on different subreddits including this one, for the version 1.3, 135 persons sent the report, it resulted with 70% accuracy, not that bad, I used this test session to improve it, I hope reaching 90% accuracy, maybe with this new version 1.5. About the last test session you have all the data analysis on the website.

At the end of the test, in the result page, you will have a frame that ask you to share your result, with a simple button. It will send me the informations I need in my database, it gives me all the cards you selected, the timeline of the guessing of your type, how the algorithm reacted, etc, it helps me to fine-tune the test.

I really feel that this method can work and be more accurate than anything that already exist.

Thank you in advance if you try it, and thank you again for the ones that already tried it, it helped me a lot improving the test.

https://www.mazwiz.com/

PS: I will share the findings in the result page like for the last test session.


r/ISTJ • • 18d ago

ST Empathy

18 Upvotes

STLDR: Certain types of empathy are more difficult for ISTJ so calibrate your expectations accordingly.

TLDR: Hey, I just wanted to point out that ISTJ tend to be better at compassionate empathy and that NFs may expect other types of empathy from STs that are more difficult for STs, and NFs may not notice the empathy that STs are naturally good at, example: https://www.reddit.com/r/infp/comments/1xh4fqv/infp_istj/


More Context

Prompt:

Hey, what are the types of empathy or whatever. Wasn't there like emotional, cognitive, logistical? Isn't one of them where a person does acts of service like changes car oil or dyes hair or helps with diet?

Reply:

The Three Main Types of Empathy

It sounds like you are thinking of the classic psychological framework that breaks empathy down into three main categories. You were spot-on with two of them (cognitive and emotional), but the third one isn't actually "logistical"—it's called somatic, compassionate, or behavioral empathy depending on how it's expressed.

Here is how the three types break down:

  • 1. Cognitive Empathy (Perspective-Taking): This is the ability to understand what someone else is thinking or feeling from their point of view. It’s an intellectual understanding rather than an emotional one.

  • Example: "I understand why you're stressed about this presentation because the client is notoriously tough."

  • 2. Emotional Empathy (Affective Empathy): This is when you actually feel what the other person is feeling—almost as if their emotions are contagious. If they are sad, your chest tightens; if they are excited, you feel a rush of energy.

  • Example: Crying when a friend receives devastating news, or feeling your heart race when someone is panicking.

  • 3. Compassionate Empathy (or Action-Oriented Empathy): This is the one you were describing with acts of service! This goes beyond just understanding or feeling someone's emotions; it compels you to do something to help relieve their burden.


Why Your "Logistical" Instinct Was Spot On

While psychologists usually call it compassionate or behavioral empathy, your instinct to call it "logistical" makes a lot of sense.

This type of empathy often shows up through practical, hands-on acts of service:

  • Changing someone's car oil when they are overwhelmed.

  • Helping a friend dye their hair or putting together a tricky piece of furniture.

  • Prepping healthy meals or grocery shopping for someone who is on a new diet or recovering from an illness.

Instead of just saying, "I feel your pain" (emotional) or "I see why this is hard" (cognitive), compassionate empathy rolls up its sleeves and tackles the logistics of the problem to make the other person's life easier.


r/ISTJ • • 19d ago

How do ISTJs behave in a friendship vs romantic relationship?

17 Upvotes

Hi all! First time ever here and with little experience regarding ISTJ, so I thought people out there could help clarify the distinction.

I know with some types it is rather easy to confuse their friendliness with being in love, say like in the case of INFPs or ENFPs.

Does it work that way with ISTJs? How do you usually behave when you become romantically interested? How to differentiate that from friendship? And what I myself can do to demonstrate interest to an ISTJ?

Sorry if this sounds like an interrogation, but I wanted to make this post as structured as possible.

Thanks all!


r/ISTJ • • 20d ago

don't call me

Post image
127 Upvotes

r/ISTJ • • 21d ago

Apologies

17 Upvotes

Hi, I wrote a post here 5 months ago trying to understand a person who was confusingly hostile to me who was an ISTJ.

(I was mistyped as ENFP back then.)

To begin with, I'd like to thank the ISTJ's who kindly explained to me that it was less a matter of mbti and more of a maturity issue.

Every MBTI has negative and positive traits, and these traits may seem good or bad depending on the person taking it in and depending on the situation. The person I met was an ISTJ, and I thought for a while, perhaps it's the mbti type that has something wrong, or perhaps it's a natural thing and I was just too ignorant to understand.

I realize now that such thought is not at all a valid idea nor a very understanding one.

I found that the people I initially thought were hostile due to 'mbti traits' were people that had been talking about me behind my back maliciously and had been spreading false information about me to my friends to isolate me and make me dependent.

That isn't a personality trait, that's malice.

I should not have assumed it was part of the ISTJ personality, and I wanted to apologize that I ever thought it was so. I am truly sorry for possibly implying that ISTJ's as a whole are all like the one toxic ISTJ I met before; I generalized my opinion on one person to an entire community.

And thank you for those who commented on my post five months ago; you guys helped me feel a lot better.


r/ISTJ • • 22d ago

What the heck is wrong with me?

31 Upvotes

My BIL collapsed yesterday and was transported to a hospital where immediate lifesaving measures were implemented. He has been in a medically induced coma since. It is not good. Even if he lives it is likely bodily paralysis and mental incapacity. Basically even the best case scenario is horrible.

My SIL is an emotional wreck and my wife is barely keeping it together. We are currently taking care of their 8 year old son.

And through this, I’m sad, I want to cry but I remain my normal stoic self because I don’t want my nephew to see me break. Right now he really doesn’t know how serious things are and he’s not allowed in ICU. I’ve never had kids of my own but take my responsibilities towards him and other important children in our life very seriously.

As soon as I figured out how bad things were, my mind didn’t go to OMG or an emotional state…I was instead immediately starting to try in figure out the remaining puzzle pieces and how they would fit together. And this time it feels wierd. Like I’m some kind of robot or something. My wife thanked me last night for being who I am and being the rock in the family. And that’s something I usually pride myself in..that I can remain clear minded even in the most emotional of situations. But here it feels off. I’m not scared of what the future brings…life is life and one of us control it as much as we like to thing we do. But I feel awful for my SIL and my nephew. I just am not entirely sure how I’m not breaking down emotionally like my wife and SIL.