r/IRstudies • • 10d ago

Democrats Have a Historic Opportunity to Rethink Capitalism

Thumbnail
foreignpolicy.com
0 Upvotes

r/IRstudies • • Feb 27 '25

The US buddying up with Russia is the biggest Russia diss. Russia is no longer a great power

17 Upvotes

As great powers attempt to counter other great powers, or emerging great powers, the US would not be looking to boost Russia's relative power, if they were a great power.

Russia has fallen greatly in perception since their war with Georgia, and with their inability to achieve all war objectives in Ukraine despite its great cost, its apparent they are no longer a great power.

Russia is now a minor power and a tool to be used to counter the emerging (or current) great power, China.

Nice one Putin, you killed your great power.


r/IRstudies • • Dec 01 '24

What are good places to read about IR from a leftist/anti-imperialist perspective?

1 Upvotes

Pretty much what the post says. I can't stand the pro-US stance that pervades media outlets like the Economist.


r/IRstudies • • Dec 02 '24

Book Review Stephen Walt: Noam Chomsky Has Been Proved Right

Thumbnail
foreignpolicy.com
0 Upvotes

r/IRstudies • • Jul 22 '25

Ideas/Debate Does anyone outside of the West actually believe in their narratives of moral superiority against their adversaries like China, Russia, or Iran? Or is it only for internal consumption?

0 Upvotes

It seems like China, Russia, Iran, etc, just play the old games of great power politics without morality mixed in, while the US and its allies (before Trump, and perhaps post-Trump) keep trying to lecture everyone about how "evil" they are.

EDIT:

I just watched parts of the recent Aspen security conference, and the Anglo-American guests keep talking about democracy and freedom, with regards to China, and why they must be confronted.

Meanwhile the Latin American, Southeast Asian, Middle Eastern, and African guests were far more balanced. The most important points they made was probably that 1) China is not a problem for them, they have far more pressing local issues and/or adversaries to deal with, and 2) they don't see this as a zero-sum game between autocracies and democracies.

The Mexican guest (a former foreign minister), made it clear that Mexico will absolutely stay out and not take a side. The African guest questioned why the Western media keeps painting Chinese activities as "debt traps", when other countries are also investing, and indeed, the problem is that China has stopped lending since COVID.


r/IRstudies • • Apr 29 '25

The reason why the Global South and the Developing World doesn't trust Liberalism

0 Upvotes

The reason why the Global South and the Developing World doesn't trust Liberalism

A lot of Western liberals find it unbelievable that the rest of the world doesn't want liberalism. It's unbelievable to them that they don't want liberal values that are built on individual rights and freedoms, democracy, and human rights. However, they don't seem to understand how much the hypocrisy runs deep and how much infuriating it's. They don't feel themselves indulging in their own hypocrisy to understand why those countries refuse those values. It's because the Western liberals demand them to follow values that they don't follow them themselves. They speak like liberals and act like realists. Their actions never live up to their words. They talk about rights, freedom, and equality then throw it away when their national interests need to be protected. They speak about democracy and human rights while they supported many oppressive dictatorships and they even installed many of those dictatorships themselves. Once a democracy decide something that isn't to their interests, they overthrow it and replace it with a dictatorship. They speak about human rights while starting wars that killed countless people and butchered countless women and children. Is it a shock that the peoples of those countries have abandoned all hope in liberals and are now following nationalist leaders? Nationalist leaders aren't morally better but at least they prioritise the interests of their countries and the liberals were no better which is why the peoples of those countries are now following the nationalist leaders. The Western countries that claim to speak for liberalism follow their own interests so why can't the rest do the same? The Western liberals refuse to understand that and as long as their actions don't live up to their words, no one will follow their beliefs. If they can understand this, then they better start actually living up to their values, and if they can't understand this, then they should shut up and stop preaching because their words will only fall on deaf ears.


r/IRstudies • • Aug 02 '26

Opinions | Episode 1: Origins of the War In Ukraine

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, have you seen this episode on offensive realism featuring John Mearsheimer?

I had not paid much attention to his views on the war in Ukraine before. I broadly knew that he linked the war to NATO enlargement and Western refusal to guarantee that Ukraine would never join NATO. He makes the same argument in this video.

I found the analysis unconvincing. It seems that he is trying to make the Russo-Ukrainian war fit his theory rather than fully examining the history and political relationship between Russia and Ukraine.

His first argument is that the Russian force used in February 2022 was too small to conquer and occupy all of Ukraine. According to him, this shows that Russia never intended to carry out a blitzkrieg or take control of the entire country. His second argument is that Russia asked for negotiations almost immediately after the invasion and demanded a guarantee that Ukraine would not join NATO. From this, he concludes that the common Western belief that Russia’s blitzkrieg failed is false because conquering Ukraine was never Russia’s goal.

I think there are several problems with this reasoning.

First, even when we accept that Russia may not have intended to occupy all of Ukraine permanently, that does not mean it had no intention of changing the Ukrainian government or determining who would govern the country. Imagine that President Zelenskyy had fled, the Ukrainian state had fallen into chaos, and a pro-Russian government had later come to power. That would have been a highly favourable outcome for Russia without requiring a long-term occupation of the entire country. Russia pursued something similar in Georgia in 2008, although it also failed to remove the government there.

Second, Russia’s early request for negotiations does not necessarily prove that its original goal was limited to Ukrainian neutrality. Another explanation is that Russian leaders quickly realised that their initial strategy was failing. Negotiations could have helped them freeze the conflict while keeping occupied territory, giving Russia time to reorganise, rearm and develop a more stable long-term strategy. It could also have created opportunities for future provocations and pressure, similar to the methods Russia used after its intervention in Ukraine in 2014.

Overall, I think Mearsheimer moves too quickly from “Russia did not have enough troops to occupy all of Ukraine” to “Russia never intended to impose political control over Ukraine.” Those are not the same claim.

What do you think? Have you seen the video, and how convincing did you find his argument?


r/IRstudies • • Jul 30 '26

How is Jeffrey Sachs able to maintain international prestige AND a legitimate post at Columbia despite numerous unfounded claims?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

I know the answer to this question is largely rooted in the bureaucracy of higher education, given Sach's high-ranking position and tenure, though his presence in the academic community as well as the international political sphere is puzzling. I'm aware of the open letter written by a handful of economists criticizing Sachs's view on the Russo-Ukraine conflict, and the occasional Reddit threads featuring numerous critics of Sachs; however, over the past year or so, I have yet to come across any discourse evaluating Sachs's claims relating to topics including Russia, COVID, Iran, U.S. intelligence, etc.

I know the easy response in this sub is to cast Sachs as a Russian propagandist and attribute the lack of commentary on his views to the fact that he's been widely discredited and ostracized within the academic sphere. While I generally agree that Sachs is guilty of double standards given his consistent support for Russia while simultaneously criticizing similar actions carried out by the U.S., I think merely dismissing Sachs obfuscates his cultural impact and ability to spread propaganda.

While Sachs has been shunned by most legacy media outlets and IR podcasts, he still does weekly interviews with alt-right hosts including Judge Napolitano and Glenn Diesen. While both hosts spew blatant propaganda (Diesen most notably), these videos rake in hundreds of thousands to MILLIONS of views when Sachs appears as a guest. Furthermore, I've noticed numerous "leftist" creators on Instagram citing Sachs in their critiques of the U.S./Nato operatons. I was even at a bar recently (near the University of Massachusetts/Amherst College), where I stumbled into a conversation with a visiting professor of economics who, upon inquiring what his views on Sachs were, defended Sachs, claiming the Russian Propaganda label gets attached to anyone who critiques U.S. policy and that Sachs's views are supported across the developing world. Furthermore, Sachs continues to be taken seriously by world leaders despite being condemned within the U.S. higher ed sphere.

All of this to say, given Sachs's ability to capture wide audiences, why has there been little examination of his views?

EDIT: I am not taking a stand against Sachs but rather critically analyzing his commentary. I discovered him last fall and watched nearly every interview of his since then because he's a fascinating figure. I agree with nearly all of his critiques of US imperialist policy, and his views on Russia-Ukraine shifted my views on the conflict; however, his commentary is riddled with double standards. First off, his COVID-19 analysis is ridiculous and debunked by international investigations. Secondly, he completely ignores the friendly relationship between Russia and Israel while casting the Russian Federation as the adult in the room. Thirdly, associating yourself with Glenn Dieson, whose party receives funding from neo-nazis, is rather questionable.


r/IRstudies • • Jul 15 '25

Omer Bartov | I’m a Genocide Scholar. I Know It When I See It.

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
78 Upvotes

r/IRstudies • • May 28 '25

Ideas/Debate If a Democrat gets elected in 2028, what should they do to repair America’s soft power?

8 Upvotes

r/IRstudies • • Oct 10 '25

The Gaza Deal Is Not Too Big to Fail: How Israel’s Military Dominance Could Undermine America’s Quest for Regional Peace

Thumbnail
foreignaffairs.com
5 Upvotes

[SS from essay by Joost R. Hiltermann, Special Adviser for Middle East and North Africa at the International Crisis Group; and Natasha Hall, Nonresident Senior Associate at the Center for Strategic and International Studies.]

With the announcement that both Hamas and Israel have signed on to the first phase of U.S. President Donald Trump’s plan for Gaza, a rare opportunity has emerged to end two years of terrible violence. Under the U.S.-brokered agreement, Hamas has promised to return all the remaining hostages it seized in 2023 in exchange for Israel’s release of nearly 2,000 Palestinian detainees and pledge of a partial withdrawal of its forces from the territory. In addition to life-saving relief to Palestinians in Gaza and the families of hostages, many hope the deal could bring renewed stability to the region.

If history is any indication, however, expectations of a durable peace or even sustainable relief for Palestinians may well be disappointed. Trump returned to the White House in January intent on replacing his predecessor’s failing Middle East policy, and he did so in ways that departed from the policies of his own first administration. His second term got off to an impressive start, helping secure—even before his term actually started—a Gaza cease-fire. In his first few months in office, more bold moves followed, including opening a precedent-breaking direct channel from the United States to Hamas, restarting nuclear negotiations with Iran, reaching a truce with the Houthis in Yemen, and waiving U.S. sanctions on Syria.


r/IRstudies • • Oct 19 '24

All States and international organizations, including the United Nations, have obligations under international law to bring to an end Israel’s unlawful presence in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, according to a new legal position paper released Friday by a top independent human rights panel

Thumbnail
news.un.org
0 Upvotes

r/IRstudies • • Oct 12 '22

Did NATO expansion prompt the Russian attack on Ukraine?

1 Upvotes

https://comw.org/pda/did-nato-expansion-prompt-the-russian-attack-on-ukraine/

IR are rarely, if ever, black and white (as most media outlets nowadays seem content to portray them as). This article illustrates how this invasion in particular is grounded in real, complex geopolitics going back decades.


r/IRstudies • • May 29 '26 Regret

How China is breaking apart a people and its culture: The campaign of repression against the Uyghurs has entered a new phase

Thumbnail
ft.com
110 Upvotes

r/IRstudies • • Jul 07 '25

Ideas/Debate Given the increasing likelihood of economic collapse in russia, what are the short/long term effects on Iran and NK?

3 Upvotes

Changes in economic and political alliances, greater nuclear threat, more open to the rest of the world in the face of the inevitable or perhaps closer ties with china?


r/IRstudies • • Apr 22 '25

What does Europe want from the Arab world in the future?

2 Upvotes

What does Europe want from the Arab world in the future? Now, that the USA showed off their claws and fangs to Europe and Europe no longer having follow their foreign policy, what will be their policy with the Arab world?

I don't know but I hope they will just leave us be. We don't want to hear about them lecturing us about values especially liberal values. They speak as liberals and act as realists. They speak words that their actions don't live up to. At the same time, they aid the dictatorships that oppress us and form alliances with them. They invade countries. They aid apartheid regimes. They kill millions and displace tens of millions. They forced us to live for two centuries of murder and theft. They led to the radicalisation of our people. They turned us into the monsters that we are today. At this point I don't want them to even repay their debts. I just want them to leave us be. I am fine with trade but I want no interference.

So I will ask again. What does Europe want from the Arab world in the future? What will their foreign policy be like?


r/IRstudies • • Jul 09 '24

Discipline Related/Meta A brief introduction to Queer Theory in IR, by IR Illustrated.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/IRstudies • • Feb 12 '26

It was never charity - Was Europe a beneficiary of a strong US? We should not believe this false narrative. In fact, the Americans gave nothing to the Europeans

Thumbnail
zeit.de
142 Upvotes

r/IRstudies • • Mar 04 '25

Discipline Related/Meta China is on course for a prolonged recession | The Strategist

Thumbnail
aspistrategist.org.au
0 Upvotes

r/IRstudies • • Jun 21 '25

CMV: it's physically impossible for Israel to dominate the Middle East & North Africa

11 Upvotes

I was just crunching some numbers and here they are

ME & NA has a population of about 500 million, while Israel has a population of about 10 million (only 7 million Jewish Israelis, but whatever), so that is 2% of the region's population.

2% of the US population is about 7 million, which is about the size of Arizona, Tennessee, or Massachusetts. If you do the math with just Jewish Israelis, you get into Alabama and Wisconsin territory. The idea that states of that size could dominate the entire US and dictate terms across the board is just kind of preposterous


r/IRstudies • • Mar 06 '25

Now what?

1 Upvotes

So now that T***p is back and made it clear that diplomacy and international relations are of little concern to him, what are people in the field and entering the field doing? The state dept, USAID and more are being gutted into oblivion and the remaining jobs will be hella competitive. So, what to? Translate your talents into something else? Find a country that wants your skills (assuming you didn't have security clearance that would make the intelligence community give you a hard look)? Is there work to be had in Canada?

Also sorry if this is the wrong sub to ask in.


r/IRstudies • • Feb 04 '24

What Withholding Funds to UNRWA Means for Gaza – After 12 employees of the U.N. agency were accused of participating in the Oct. 7 attack against Israel, some donor countries have suspended funding. But more than a million people in Gaza depend on the agency for aid.

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
0 Upvotes

r/IRstudies • • Jul 14 '25

Ideas/Debate Regime change in Iran, and Israel's strategic interests

0 Upvotes

I'm going to propose an argument that the status quo with Iran may suit Israel's strategic interests, potentially even more than regime change.

The first thing is to look at Iran's power projection. If Israel only degrades Iran's MRBMs and associated TELs, and retains freedom of action to sustain this, then Iran is no longer a threat to Israel, but Iran's threat to the Gulf remains: Iran's drones and SRBMs are still deadly to these closer neighbors, deadly to US bases, and deadly to international trade via Hormuz, creating a local MAD that does not extend into Israel itself. This creates a reality where the Saudis have a security incentive to become an Azerbaijan-like patron to Israel to counter-balance the Iranian threat. But in the absence of this threat to the Gulf, i.e. if Iran's regime collapsed, then there is more likely to be Saudi-Israel regional competition as they are the two remaining powers (excluding Turkey who is relevant but more on the periphery), along with reduced incentive for the Saudis to join the Abraham Accords.

The second thing is to consider what could happen to Iran itself if there is regime change. Iran is a large country with capable individuals. The regime itself is weakening Iran from the inside. If Iran became a normal democratic country, it would eventually be a major regional power, possibly even stronger than Israel in the long-run. It may not be hostile to Israel, but why would Israel want to take that gamble? In this sense, the oppressive IRGC that weakens Iran from within is a strategic asset to Israel, as long as it cannot maintain power projection into Israel. Iran's revanchism becomes purely rhetorical and not of strategic relevance to Israel if they cannot back it up with MRBMs.

The third thing to consider is the interests of the EU and US in regional offshore balancing. In general, great powers would prefer that a regional hegemon does not emerge, even if they are allies. This creates unnecessary competition and risk and reduced strategic depth. In this sense, a tokenistic Iran is useful for Israel, to create the reality in which Israel is not a clear hegemon and therefore still worthy of support in the self-interest of the great power.

Underpinning this thesis is the assumption that Israel can maintain the current status quo, where Israel maintains a veto over Iran's MRBM supply chain and launch platforms via the freedom to act due to the option to retake air supremacy at the time and place of Israel's choosing. I see no reason why Israel cannot do this. If Iran starts to reconstitute its air defenses, such as via purchasing China's platforms, there will be a time window of vulnerability during which Israel can act and revert back to the current status quo by degrading the small handful of acquired platforms. None of this would require a high intensity war of attrition that is beyond the cost that Israel is willing to pay.


r/IRstudies • • Jun 22 '25

America slides into totalitarianism — and it won't be easy to reverse

Thumbnail
salon.com
0 Upvotes