r/IOPsychology • • Jan 22 '25

Trump is revoking EO 11246 (LBJ)

653 Upvotes

MASSIVE HR news outta the White House this morning (within last hour) - Trump has revoked EO 11246 (LBJ) which is the EO that required govt contractors to have Affirmative Action Plans  (to be ended within 90 days). OFCCP (the agency) shall immediately cease (basically) everything they do.


r/IOPsychology • • Jul 27 '25

[Discussion] Anyone else so disheartened by all the recent back sliding?

250 Upvotes

Not so long ago we were having real discussions about permanent remote work, 4-day work weeks, real actions that we could take to improve the lives of workers.

Now we are seeing articles about companies embracing '996' schedules (9am to 9pm, 6 days a week), rolling back remote work, and doing their absolute hardest to replace as many workers with AI with no evidence on the ROI of those AI tools.

To be honest, it feels so discouraging. From my own experience, none of these decisions are coming from HR, they are just left to deal with the aftermath. It feels like unless IO can magically convince the entire c-suite that treating people well is good for people AND business, we are doomed to backslide every time the economy shifts to favor companies over job seekers.


r/IOPsychology • • May 06 '26

Farewell SIOP

188 Upvotes

Like many of you I returned from our annual conference a few days ago. It was nice to see some old friends, but it also made me realize that I don’t want to be part of this field anymore.

Let me explain.

Fifteen years ago, I was an assistant professor just a few years out of graduate school when a colleague at another university e-mailed me to ask me to about a paper that had just been published in one of our leading journals. He was concerned that the results seemed wrong and wanted my quantitatively inclined eyes to take a look. It was very easy to confirm that the results were indeed entirely, dramatically, (and demonstrably) wrong, and I quickly e-mailed the first author to make them aware of the error. He denied that there was a problem. What followed quickly turned into a nightmare. I soon realized that the same author and his collaborators had repeated the same “errors” and mathematically impossible claims in many dozens of papers in our leading journals across more than a decade. Many of those papers ended up getting retracted after I made editors aware of the issues but I ended up getting threatened in a variety of unpleasant ways and some of the editors spread absolutely appalling rumors about my motivations for alerting them to the issues (the correspondence among editors was anonymously forwarded to me by someone on the e-mail chain). Many of the papers were never corrected. The stress eventually led to me being admitted to the ER.

This three-year episode was horrible but also opened my eyes to how widespread research misconduct is in our discipline and how many editors were unwilling to do anything about the apparent fraud being committed in their journals. Some of these editors have been presidents and leaders of SIOP. One editor asked me why I was “picking on” this set of authors when everyone knew that fabrication was widespread across the discipline. He seemed to think that I was nuts to even draw attention to the matter. Another editor (and past SIOP president) told me that I was “obviously correct” that the results that I flagged where mathematically impossible and central to the thesis of the paper but refused to even issue a correction (and yes, I still have that e-mail).

Around that time a lovely group of graduate students gave me a coffee mug with the wonderful quote from Terry Pratchett that “Sometimes it is better to light a flamethrower than to curse the darkness”. My collaborators and I have done our best to live up to that idea, and we’ve written a lot about these issues, in the hope that we might make the broader community aware of the problems in our discipline. We naively thought that a critical mass of IO scholars could be persuaded to give a damn.

After 15 years of advocating for change it has become clear to me that these efforts have been wasted. The most influential members of our society who are often editors in our journals don’t seem to care; perhaps because many of the offenders are their friends and colleagues. Two very recent experiences (from the past few months) are emblematic.

In the first instance I noticed that the highly publicized inferences drawn by the authors of one recent paper published in a leading journal were entirely incorrect and that the correct conclusions were actually the exact opposite of what the authors claimed. I reached out to the editor of the journal who quickly agreed that I was right that the reported results were incorrect (and hence also that the title, abstract, discussion section, and press releases for that paper were all wrong) and that the exact opposite finding was correct. However, he also noted that he was reluctant to correct the record because doing so would be embarrassing for the authors. The paper remains uncorrected.

In the second case I noticed a (to me) serious misreporting of SEM fit statistics in two articles published in a leading journal by the same set of authors. Here too I reached out to the editor of that journal. I was promised an investigation even though the accuracy of my claim could have been confirmed on the back of a napkin within 5 minutes. It took more than a year for the “investigation” to unfold. The end result was the publication of two corrections in which the authors 1) admitted to the errors, 2) stated that they no longer had the data on which the results were based, and 3) that the conclusions of the study would not have changed.

In recent years my co-authors and I have continued to document the appalling lack of methodological rigor in our journals: widespread results that appear fabricated, results that don’t replicate, and the almost complete lack of open science practices or basic methodological principles (like replication or power analyses). I had not been to our annual conference much in the last 10 years because of financial constraints and I attended this year in the hope that things may have changed. Unfortunately, I was left even more depressed. Dozens and dozens of posters and papers in which folks presented causal mediation analyses on the basis of observational data, almost no adherence to basic methodological principles (like power analyses, pre-registration of hypotheses), seemingly no interest in or knowledge of why these issues are important, and editors who (in one editor panel) seemed to indicate that adherence to Open Science practices was a cute but entirely unnecessary feature of research while strict adherence to APA formatting was the sine  qua non of high quality research. I went to one fantastic session on Open Science issues that had about 12 people in the audience – most of them probably friends and family of the presenters.

[It is perhaps worth noting that I never sought to “catch” someone in the act of engaging in any kind of dodgy practices. I am simply reading papers and these errors and issues just jump out at me. How papers can already have been cited 1000s of times without anyone noticing these issues before me is perhaps worthy of some discussion because the problems seem so obvious to me].

I have loved IO psychology ever since I stumbled across a class on it during my undergraduate education. I have met some truly wonderful people through SIOP and am lucky to call some of them my friends, but this no longer seems like a serious scientific discipline. I've also given up my hope that things might get better. It seems to me that IO practitioners have probably correctly figured out that what IO academics publish cannot be trusted or is irrelevant to what they do, and IO academics are perhaps so focused on hopping on the b-school gravy train that they don't want to call out the worst offenders for fear of offending those who might be their future colleagues.

It is clear to me that the grifters, frauds, and hacks have won. so I am going to take my toys and play somewhere else.


r/IOPsychology • • Jan 21 '22

IO Psych officially recognized as STEM (US)

Thumbnail federalregister.gov
188 Upvotes

r/IOPsychology • • Sep 15 '19

[META] I think we need a sticky on why you might NOT want to be in I/O.

186 Upvotes

We've gotten an uptick in posts lately from people who can't find work, or who regret their choice to go into I/O. In some cases, their problems seem to stem from some misconceptions that could have been avoided with greater honesty about the limitations of the field. (My theory is that we're feeling the echo of all of the media attention that I/O received for the first time when it was a "growing and hot" field in the late '00s and early '10s.) Note that this is a very US- and Master's-centric thought process simply because most of the "regret" posts seem to come from US grads with terminal Master's degrees. That said...

Don't go into I/O Psychology if:

(1) You are most interested in HR. HR managers oftentimes don't recognize the I/O label or know enough to value your skill set, and the barriers to entry in HR are so low that you are competing against people with more recognizable degrees. You're better off going to work with your Bachelor's for 2-3 years and then deciding if you want a grad degree, like a MBA or Master's in HRM, or a professional certification from HRCI or SHRM.

(2) You are unable or unwilling to live near a major metro area. SIOP salary surveys make it pretty clear that most of the respondents, and the best pay, is around very big cities, such as New York, Chicago, DC, and LA. This is because internal I/O jobs are mostly found in large corporate headquarters or public-sector agencies, and external/consulting jobs are mostly located close to those same kinds of clients. If your life circumstances and values make that kind of location impossible, I/O isn't right for you. Some people in smaller regional hubs have gotten lucky, and remote work is increasingly possible, but it's not likely to come together at the beginning of your career.

(3) You aren't interested in learning about industrial-side topics, research methods, statistics, and (increasingly) computer programming. These are the knowledge bodies and skills that add value and get you jobs. Students who are mostly interested in organizational-side topics, like attitudes and teamwork, and/or would rather not engage with technical material, are going to have trouble competing against other I/Os, let alone demonstrating their value relative to people with HR-related degrees.

(4) Your grades, GRE scores, or other personal circumstances prevent you from getting accepted to a strong I/O graduate program (or relocating to attend one). Demand for I/O has resulted in a great deal of program expansion, especially at the Master's level, and many of these programs are extremely weak. They don't teach the skills noted in (3) above, and many times the faculty aren't qualified to teach I/O courses. Do not confuse undergraduate institutional prestige for the quality of a graduate program! Some "elite" and highly-respected universities have very weak I/O (or I/O-adjacent) graduate programs.

(5) You're looking for "safe" or guaranteed employment. No such thing exists, let alone in I/O. Your job prospects are a lot better than those in other areas of Psychology, but true I/O jobs can also be hard to find for all of the reasons noted above. I/O work also declines hard during recessions and other economic slowdowns, and you need to be able to live with the possibility of layoffs or other setbacks.

Thoughts?


r/IOPsychology • • Jan 14 '22

[Jobs & Careers] Common Federal Government Job Titles for I-O Psychologists

Post image
174 Upvotes

r/IOPsychology • • Mar 06 '22

[Jobs & Careers] I made a Boolean string for your next job search!

163 Upvotes

Most job search websites work with Boolean searches. So all you have to do is copy-paste this!

“organisational psychology" OR "organizational psychology” OR "occupational psychology” OR "industrial psychology” OR "work psychology" OR "people strategy" OR “people science" OR “talent management" OR “people advisory" OR “human capital" OR “employee engagement" OR “workforce planning" OR “psychometric" OR “behavioural scientist" OR “behavioral scientist" OR “performance management" OR “diversity" OR “DEI" OR “employee relations" OR “people and culture" OR "people analytics" OR "consumer behaviour" OR "consumer behavior"

Please feel free to share more suggestions of things I could include here!


r/IOPsychology • • Oct 19 '25

As an adjunct who’s watched three years of I/O M.A. students struggle to find jobs, its a problem.

152 Upvotes

I’ve been teaching in an I/O psych master’s program for a few years and almost none of the grads can even find jobs. Like, not bad jobs, any jobs. Every year it’s the same thing: they graduate, apply everywhere, and end up back living at home or working retail while programs keep pretending everything’s fine. It feels like we’re just cranking out degrees for a job market that doesn’t exist anymore.


r/IOPsychology • • Apr 24 '25

US Executive Order calls for ending "disparate impact liability"

Thumbnail
whitehouse.gov
141 Upvotes

Highlighting some key texts:

On a practical level, disparate-impact liability has hindered businesses from making hiring and other employment decisions based on merit and skill...because of the specter that such a process might lead to disparate outcomes, and thus disparate-impact lawsuits. 

...all agencies shall deprioritize enforcement of all statutes and regulations to the extent they include disparate-impact liability...

Within 45 days of the date of this order, the Attorney General and the Chair of the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission shall assess all pending investigations, civil suits, or positions taken in ongoing matters under every Federal civil rights law within their respective jurisdictions, including Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, that rely on a theory of disparate-impact liability, and shall take appropriate action with respect to such matters consistent with the policy of this order

Seems like one aim is to dramatically reduce concern about lawsuits for facially neutral selection practices, which will likely have downstream effects. Maybe this means companies will become less interested in conducting validation studies? Maybe this will make companies more open to pursuing psychometric assessments.


r/IOPsychology • • Mar 26 '20

Failing at psychological detachment while playing the new Animal Crossing game—whoops

Post image
141 Upvotes

r/IOPsychology • • Apr 30 '21

psycModel: A new R package for statistical analysis related to IO psychology

134 Upvotes

Hi r/IOPsychology. I am the author of this package. If you have seen this in r/rstats, I am sorry to bother you again. This is actually design for psychologists. I will prioritize supporting more statistical analysis that is commonly used in psychology since I am also a junior researcher in IO psychology. Hope you guys enjoy

TLDR:

  1. It is a beginner-friendly R package for statistical analysis in social science.

  2. Tired of manually writing all variables in a model? You can use dplyr::select() syntax for all models

  3. Fitting models, plotting, checking goodness of fit, and model assumption violations all in one place.

  4. Beautiful and easy-to-read output. Check out this example now.

Support models:

  1. Linear regression (i.e., support ANOVA, ANCOVA), generalized linear regression.

  2. Linear mixed effect model (or HLM to be more specific), generalized linear mixed effect model.

  3. Confirmatory and exploratory factor analysis.

  4. Simple mediation analysis.

  5. Reliability analysis.

  6. Correlation, descriptive statistics (e.g., mean, SD).

I am also planning to support much more types of statistical analysis in the future.

At its core, this package allows people to analyze their data with one simple function call. For example, when you are running a linear regression, you need to fit the model, check the goodness of fit (e.g., R2), check the model assumption, and plot the interaction (if the interaction is included). Without this package, you need several packages to do the above steps. Additionally, if you are an R beginner, you probably don't know where to find all these R packages. This package has done all that work for you, so you can just do everything with one simple function call. 

Another good example is CFA. The most common (and probably the only) option to fit a CFA in R is using lavaan. Lavaan has its own unique set of syntax. It is very versatile and powerful, but you do need to spend some time learning it. It may not worth the time for people who just want to run a quick and simple CFA model. In my package, it's very intuitive with cfa_summary(data, x1:x3), and you get the model summary, the fit measures, and a nice-looking path diagram. The same logic also applies to HLM since lme4 / nlme also has its own set of syntax that you need to learn. 

Moreover, I also made fitting the model even simpler by using the dplyr::select syntax. In short, traditionally, if you want to fit a linear regression model, the syntax looks like this lm(y ~ x1 + x2 + x3 + x4 + ... + xn, data). Now, the syntax is much shorter and more intuitive: lm_model(y, x1:xn, data). You can even replace x1:xn with everything(). I also wrote this very short article that teaches people how to use the dplyr::select() syntax (it is not comprehensive, and it is not intended to be).

Finally, I made the output in R much more beautiful and easy to read. The default output from R, to be frank, look ugly. I spent a lot of time making sure it looks good in this package. But, it is difficult to describe how it looks in a post, so you can take a look at the example. I am sure that you will see how big the improvement is. 

If you feel like the members of another subreddit will be benefited from this package, I would really appreciate if you cross-post this to that subreddit.


r/IOPsychology • • Jun 12 '21

Something tells me there is some truth in this humor...

Post image
133 Upvotes

r/IOPsychology • • May 27 '25

Harvard has revoked tenure from Francesca Gino

Thumbnail
nbcnews.com
128 Upvotes

r/IOPsychology • • Dec 12 '20

Alright, which one of you IO Psych consultants created this gate for their selection process?

Post image
127 Upvotes

r/IOPsychology • • Jun 28 '19

“It’s the same damn thing!” (Campion, 2019)

Post image
121 Upvotes

r/IOPsychology • • Mar 01 '23

[Meme] ChatGPT has become an IO psychologist

Post image
119 Upvotes

r/IOPsychology • • Dec 01 '20

Just a quick laugh

Post image
119 Upvotes

r/IOPsychology • • Jul 01 '25

[Jobs & Careers] Job market is so bad

116 Upvotes

That is all, its just incredibly bad


r/IOPsychology • • Mar 28 '19

Does anyone else regret getting their Masters in I/O Psych?

111 Upvotes

Even with a masters in org psych, 4 internships in HR and data analysis, two years as a research assistant, and an assortment of contract assignments, I can’t even land entry-level employment in HR.

The field is too saturated to break into. I thought my education was in an emerging field, but openings are few and far between. The ones that are available require years of prior experience that even internships can’t address.

I can’t break in my field and my academic pursuits to make myself an ideal candidate now feel like a waste of time.

All my time and effort was for nothing.


r/IOPsychology • • Apr 09 '24

[Discussion] Are HR folks delusional by justifying this to be added in their job posting?

Post image
108 Upvotes

Maybe the right word I am looking for is “detached from understanding the applicant’s perspective” on how well they perceive this.


r/IOPsychology • • Mar 05 '21

SIOP's official response to the HBO Max Documentary Persona

Thumbnail siop.org
105 Upvotes

r/IOPsychology • • Aug 20 '20

Made a deck explaining Org Psych to non-IO’s

Thumbnail
imgur.com
104 Upvotes

r/IOPsychology • • Aug 18 '21

When Bosses Are Respectful, Young People Are More Resilient At Work And Enjoy Their Jobs More

Thumbnail
digest.bps.org.uk
101 Upvotes

r/IOPsychology • • Jun 17 '20

Black in I/O group hosting community call to brainstorm how the I/O community can help. We don’t have all the answers. It is our responsibility to bring our members and allies together to start the discussion. Link in comments.

Post image
101 Upvotes