r/IMadeThis • • 4d ago

Comment Page: a live comment thread for every web page

Many sites have no comments. News sites switch them off on the topics people most want to discuss. Site owners can quietly delete whatever they don't like.

So I built Comment Page, where every URL gets its own live thread.

- Paste a link on the homepage, or type comment.page/ in front of any address

- No account and no extension; you get a random nickname

- Site owners can pay to embed the thread on their own site, remove comments (they show as "deleted by owner", never silently), or turn off public threads for their domain

It's live but almost empty, so you'll probably be the first one in any thread you open.

What I'd like to know:

- Would you use it, and on what kind of pages?

- Is typing an address in front of another address handy, or a gimmick?

- What's broken? If a page shows up badly, tell me which one.

1 Upvotes

1 comment sorted by

1

u/Total-Reasonable 4d ago

The hard part here is URL identity, not the UI. The same article shows up as http vs https, www vs bare, trailing slashes, utm and fbclid params, AMP and mobile variants, and anchors, so threads will fragment fast. I'd normalize aggressively and honor rel=canonical when present, but only after checking that the canonical host matches. Otherwise someone can point a canonical at a popular page and hijack its thread. Have you decided how you'll handle that yet?