r/HydrogenSocieties • • Jan 05 '26

BMW: Hydrogen Will Play A ‘Crucial Role’ In The Car Industry

Thumbnail
bmwblog.com
35 Upvotes

As someone with 30 years in the automotive industry, mostly at Fortune 100 companies, I strongly agree with BMW’s position here. Now that I work closely with BMW and other German OEMs, I can say firsthand that hydrogen isn’t just an OEM talking point — it’s expanding rapidly across the Tier 1 and Tier 2 supply chain as well.

Much of the opposition to hydrogen comes from the assumption that battery EVs are already “the solution,” so any investment elsewhere is seen as wasted effort in the face of climate urgency. That framing is flawed. Batteries and fuel cells are not competitors — they are complementary technologies.

Battery EV sales have slowed in markets like the U.S. and Canada because current vehicles don’t fully meet consumer needs, and because the battery supply chain is heavily dependent on imported raw materials and coal-intensive processing. Meanwhile, fuel-cell vehicles have limited sales primarily due to a lack of refueling infrastructure, not lack of technical viability.

Where hydrogen infrastructure does exist — such as LH₂ stations with cryo-compression in California — uptime and throughput have been strong on every Gen4 station built in California (like Baldwin, Mission Hills, Placentia, Aliso Viejo, Burbank/North Hollywood, Orange, and Pasadena). Yes, stations are expensive today and hydrogen supply is limited, but infrastructure always comes before adoption. If stations scale, FCEVs will sell in North America because they align well with consumer expectations.

A few points often missing from the battery-only narrative:

  1. CO₂ alone is a poor environmental metric. Batteries have significant environmental and water impacts that are routinely ignored.

  2. The battery supply chain is deeply dependent on fossil fuels, especially coal and diesel — largely offshore. Outsourcing impacts doesn’t eliminate them.

  3. Battery raw-material constraints are real and increasingly complex. Without the ability to scale coal-powered precursor production like China, North American battery costs will always face structural disadvantages.

  4. Hydrogen enables smaller battery packs, reducing raw-material demand, mining pressure, coal use, and water risk — extending the value of limited resources.

If people truly believe batteries are environmentally benign, the best test is simple: make them at scale in the U.S. and Canada using the same processes used globally. The impacts become much harder to ignore.

BMW and Toyota deserve credit for taking a systems-level view of sustainability rather than treating it as a single-technology marketing exercise.


r/HydrogenSocieties • • Jul 26 '26

Toyota Quietly Fixed One Of The Biggest Problems With Plug-In Hybrids

Thumbnail
autoblog.com
13 Upvotes

I've always thought PHEVs are an important stepping stone toward FCEVs. Conceptually they're very similar: both are electric vehicles with a battery for everyday driving and an onboard fuel source for long-distance range. The biggest difference is simply what fills the tank—gasoline today versus hydrogen tomorrow. As hydrogen infrastructure expands, the transition from a gasoline-assisted electric drivetrain to a hydrogen-assisted electric drivetrain is a much smaller leap than many people realize.

One of the biggest myths repeated online is that "people never plug in PHEVs." That claim is often based on studies of fleet or company vehicles where the driver had little or no incentive to charge because someone else paid for the fuel. It's a poor proxy for private ownership. Most consumers who spend extra money on a plug-in hybrid do so because they want to drive on electricity and reduce fuel costs. Treating atypical fleet behavior as representative of every PHEV owner creates a misleading narrative that has been used for years to undermine the technology.

I also think there's a resource efficiency argument that's often overlooked. If one 80+ kWh battery can instead be divided into roughly four 20 kWh PHEV-sized packs, you potentially enable four households to do the vast majority of their daily driving electrically instead of one household eliminating gasoline entirely. That stretches finite battery materials further while still dramatically reducing fuel consumption and emissions across more vehicles. From a systems perspective, that's a compelling sustainability argument that deserves more discussion.

This is one reason I've always respected Toyota's long-term strategy, even though they seem to absorb constant criticism from some BEV advocates for supporting hybrids, plug-in hybrids, and hydrogen simultaneously. Toyota appears to be optimizing for sustainability measured over decades, not just today's headlines. That means considering not only tailpipe emissions, but also the realities of mining, refining, manufacturing, and eventually recycling critical battery materials. Whether you agree with every decision or not, it's hard to argue they aren't thinking about the entire lifecycle of transportation.

From a hydrogen perspective, I don't see PHEVs as a detour—I see them as part of the evolution. They familiarize consumers with electrically driven vehicles while recognizing today's infrastructure and material constraints. Over the long term, FCEVs preserve the same electric driving experience while replacing the gasoline tank with hydrogen. That's a vision of sustainability that's about balancing technology, resources, and practicality—not treating every transportation problem as though it has only one solution.


r/HydrogenSocieties • • May 24 '26

Why Hybrid Skeptics Are Quietly Admitting Toyota Was Right

Thumbnail
carbuzz.com
0 Upvotes

Hyper-focusing on tailpipe emissions as the only measure of sustainability is a mistake. When you scale BEVs up to the entire global fleet, you have to account for the massive environmental footprint of mining, smelting, refining, and battery disposal—not just CO2.

As the CarBuzz article highlights, the industry is finally realizing that Toyota’s balanced, multi-pathway approach was right all along. Hopefully, as people look at the total lifecycle of transportation, they will see that Toyota is right about hydrogen propulsion too.


r/HydrogenSocieties • • Mar 06 '25

EV has failed, hydrogen is waiting to step in

0 Upvotes

🚀🚀🚀


r/HydrogenSocieties • • Nov 25 '24

Toyota Mirai UNBIASED

1 Upvotes

I was banned from the Mirai sub for mentioning I was participating in a class action lawsuit against them..the sub is obviously administered by Toyota…so wack


r/HydrogenSocieties • • Jan 11 '26

Launch of Support for Hydrogen Vehicle and Hydrogen Refueling Station Deployment Programs

2 Upvotes

r/HydrogenSocieties • • Oct 04 '24

Elon Musk's Surprising Shift to Hydrogen-Powered Cars: What It Means for the Future of EVs

Thumbnail
linkedin.com
2 Upvotes

r/HydrogenSocieties • • Mar 24 '26

Bill Gates says Natural Hydrogen is top 3 on his list of energy breakthroughs 2026

24 Upvotes

r/HydrogenSocieties • • Jun 12 '21

The dems DONT have a good record supporting h2.

Thumbnail
motorauthority.com
2 Upvotes

r/HydrogenSocieties • • Sep 16 '21

CA Fuel-Cell Car Drivers All Say Hydrogen Fuel Unavailable, Stations Don't Work (UPDATED)

Thumbnail
greencarreports.com
0 Upvotes

r/HydrogenSocieties • • 22d ago

Company that makes really good BEVs also makes really good FCEVs

Thumbnail fuelcellsworks.com
5 Upvotes

It looks like Hyundai’s executive team completely forgot to subscribe to the Reddit echo chamber before hitting their 50,000 FCEVs sold milestone. They already build some of the best, highly-rated BEVs on the market, but apparently they didn't get the Reddit memo that making BEVs and FCEVs is taboo. Despite thirty years of fuel cell engineering and betting their corporate structure on hydrogen, they obviously still need to read more comments from the thousands of bots here who think building a great BEV means you are forbidden from building anything else.


r/HydrogenSocieties • • Jun 13 '23

Ford CEO Shocks Everybody! | HUGE News!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/HydrogenSocieties • • Jul 27 '20

VDE study finds battery trains 35% cheaper than hydrogen. In addition, the cost of energy and multiple replacement of fuel cells during a 30-year working life means that hydrogen trains are also more expensive to use than the diesel trains they would replace.

Thumbnail
railjournal.com
1 Upvotes

r/HydrogenSocieties • • Jun 05 '22

How do i do it?

0 Upvotes

How do i make my car a hydrogen on demand car. do i have to buy a kit, or is there a in-depth video on how to put one in with any car. pls help very interested in trying to make my car hydrogen/gasoline hybrid


r/HydrogenSocieties • • 17h ago

The EREV concept is 1 step removed from an FCEV - Just swap the gasoline engine with a hydrogen fuel cell. When H2 refueling infrastructure is built out, it's a drop in change with no change to vehicle platform.

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/HydrogenSocieties • • Apr 20 '25

More Evidence It's Hydrogen AND Batteries. Not battery -vs- hydrogen

18 Upvotes

Another example proving it's "not battery -vs- hydrogen", as framed by haters, it's batteries AND hydrogen; always has been. BYD, the largest BEV OEM in the world, who has made more battery electric buses than anybody in the world (and as Trump would say "Nobody even comes close") is making a next gen FCEB. Because "it's both". Anyone who says "vs" is a troll, a shill, has bad intentions, or is energy or vehicle manufacturing ignorant.

https://eladelantado.com/news/byd-hydrogen-powered-bus/

Also more evidence the copy editors usually write the headlines for the author's story. The title "no batteries" is not correct. All FCEVs have a battery. Doesn't have to be lithium-ion, even though most FCEVs have a lithium-ion battery. Only people in the west frame hydrogen and batteries as an either/or proposition because that red herring has been fed by outlets like Electrek, CleanTechnica, Green Car Reports, Teslarati for so many years. Those outlets' sole intent is to promote "BEV only".


r/HydrogenSocieties • • Apr 16 '26

The real bottleneck in scaling clean hydrogen is demand, not technology – here’s why

6 Upvotes

The World Economic Forum article "The real bottleneck in scaling clean hydrogen is demand, not technology – here's why" (published April 16, 2026) argues that the primary obstacle to the global adoption of clean hydrogen is "bankability"—specifically, the lack of secure demand and revenue certainty—rather than a lack of technological readiness.

Core Argument

Despite a surge in project announcements driven by geopolitical tensions and energy security needs, very few reach the Final Investment Decision (FID). The authors contend that while the world knows how to produce hydrogen, it has not yet created the market structures necessary to finance it at scale.

Key Obstacles to Scaling

• Revenue Uncertainty: Unlike oil or gas, hydrogen lacks liquid trading hubs and transparent price benchmarks. This makes it difficult for lenders to predict long-term cash flows.

• Complex Execution Risk: Projects are often highly interdependent (requiring simultaneous development of renewable power, electrolysis, and transport), which increases the risk of "stranded assets" if one part of the chain fails.

• The "Policy Gap": Current government subsidies often focus on lowering production costs (e.g., tax credits) but do not address the need for revenue stability or guaranteed buyers.

Lessons from History

The article draws a parallel to the development of Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG). It notes that LNG only became a global commodity after decades of relying on long-term, fixed-price contracts. Clean hydrogen is currently in this early "contract-heavy" phase, and expecting a liquid global market too soon is unrealistic.

Recommended Shifts in Project Design

To move projects toward financial closure, the authors propose four strategic shifts:

  1. Prioritize Offtake: Secure long-term agreements with creditworthy buyers to provide revenue visibility.

  2. Stabilize Revenue: Policy should move toward instruments like "contracts for difference" (CfDs) that guarantee minimum prices or provide downside protection for investors.

  3. Better Risk Allocation: Clearly define which risks are held by equity investors versus debt providers, as lenders cannot be expected to absorb market-level risks.

  4. Target Regional Clusters: Instead of aiming for a global commodity market immediately, focus on developing regional industrial "hubs" where production and demand are physically close.

Conclusion

The article concludes that while the geopolitical case for hydrogen is stronger than ever, its potential will remain theoretical until the financial challenge is solved. Success depends on designing projects that can attract massive capital by proving they can generate stable, long-term returns.

--

Original article: https://www.weforum.org/stories/2026/04/bottleneck-scaling-clean-hydrogen-technology-finance/


r/HydrogenSocieties • • Apr 22 '20

Daimler discontinues the GLC F-Cell hydrogen electric vehicle, axes plans for all future hydrogen fuel cell cars

Thumbnail
translate.google.com
0 Upvotes

r/HydrogenSocieties • • Sep 29 '22

Gas Companies Are Promoting Hydrogen to Heat Homes. But the Science Isn’t on Their Side

Thumbnail
news.yahoo.com
0 Upvotes

r/HydrogenSocieties • • Feb 27 '20

On what basis is hydrogen not useless except for niche uses like seasonal storage?

0 Upvotes

r/HydrogenSocieties • • Feb 18 '24

Motorcycle runs on Water 💧 100% Working Trick

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/HydrogenSocieties • • Sep 14 '26

U.S. Dams Could Unlock 15.2 Terawatt-Hours of Untapped Hydropower

Thumbnail oilprice.com
9 Upvotes

Over the years a lot of disingenuous things were said to try to stop hydrogen technology for energy from progressing. Ten years ago it was fuel cells go bad too fast and platinum loading of catalysts. Those arguments were eventually overcome, but for about 10 years there was also the standard sentence in every hydrogen article: “Hydrogen burns clean but it does not exist on earth naturally. Most of it is produced with natural gas.”

And while it’s true that most hydrogen today is still made with natural gas, it is misleading to talk about hydrogen as though it somehow requires natural gas when virtually every other form of energy has its own dependence on coal, oil, natural gas, or some other resource somewhere in the chain.

Now we know hydrogen is found in many places naturally, and efforts have been underway for years to figure out how to unlock subsurface hydrogen. But one of the pillars of the anti-hydrogen argument that still endures, and is no less ignorant, is the hydrogen efficiency argument.

The argument goes something like this: why make hydrogen with electricity, only to turn that hydrogen back into electricity or use it in a vehicle? Why not just use the electricity directly?

It sounds convincing until you start asking a more basic question: what electricity?

We routinely have energy resources that are available but aren't being used. Solar panels produce nothing at night and can produce more electricity than the grid can use during the day. Wind turbines sometimes have to be curtailed because there isn't enough demand or transmission capacity. And, as this article points out, there is enormous hydropower potential sitting behind dams that isn't being fully utilized.

That unused energy isn't made more useful simply because hydrogen isn't 100% efficient.

If a dam has the ability to produce electricity that otherwise isn't going to be produced, using some of that electricity to make hydrogen can turn an otherwise wasted resource into a storable, transportable energy commodity. The same principle applies to excess solar and wind.

The efficiency argument makes much more sense when you're talking about taking scarce electricity that could be used directly and deliberately converting it to hydrogen instead. But that isn't the only situation where hydrogen can be produced.

Sometimes the question shouldn't be “What is the most efficient way to use this kilowatt-hour?” Sometimes the question should be “What can we do with the energy that would otherwise go unused?”

Hydrogen is one answer.


r/HydrogenSocieties • • Aug 15 '22

#waterasfuel

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/HydrogenSocieties • • Jun 12 '21

Am I the only one that thinks this is silly?

Thumbnail
grist.org
0 Upvotes