Hey everyone,
Looking for advice on choosing between **Hilo’s turnkey package** (bridged to Apple Home) vs **buying Sinopé Wi-Fi units directly** for Hydro-Québec peak events.
This is strictly for **secondary heating & load control** (basement baseboards, bathroom heaters, a water heater controller, and a 2-fan garage heater). My primary heat is handled by an Amana S9 heat pump on its native thermostat.
My Dilemma:
I strongly prefer **native Apple Home**. Every single other Sinopé Wi-Fi thermostat I need for my house (the 3,000 W baseboard and bathroom units) **is 100% native Apple Home out of the box**.
My clean, native Apple Home plan gets completely derailed by the garage:
The 4,000 W Sinopé fan-forced model required for my 2-fan garage heater (**TH1134WF**) **is the ONE unit in their lineup that completely lacks native Apple Home support** (and Sinopé's 4,000 W HomeKit models like the TH1144WF use TRIAC switching meant strictly for baseboards and can't drive fan heaters).
This is the real issue: even if I pay top dollar for native Sinopé Wi-Fi across the rest of the house, **I’m still forced to run Home Assistant/Homebridge anyway** just to bridge that single 4,000 W Sinopé garage unit into Apple Home.
Since I have to maintain a Home Assistant bridge solely because of that one garage unit, I'm stuck deciding between:
**Paying out-of-pocket for Sinopé Wi-Fi** (having native HomeKit everywhere else, but bridging the 4,000 W Sinopé garage unit via HA).
**Taking Hilo's turnkey offer** (subsidized thermostats/water heater controller + free electrician install), but accepting that *all* Hilo Zigbee devices will be bridged to Apple Home via HA.
Questions:
**Which path did you choose and why?** What would you do if you were in my situation?
**HA Reliability:** Since I’m forced to run Home Assistant anyway for the garage, how responsive and reliable is **bridged Hilo in daily Apple Home use** compared to native HomeKit?
**Hardware Quality & Aesthetics:** How do Hilo thermostats compare to Sinopé in terms of build quality, display clarity, wall aesthetic, and physical button responsiveness?
**Peak Event Stability:** Has the Hilo HA integration (dvd-dev/hilo or HydroQC) been rock-solid during peak events and water heater shutoffs, or do cloud API updates frequently break Apple Home control?
Would love to hear your thoughts!