r/HumankindTheGame • • Aug 14 '20

Boring?

Is it just me or does the way combat is implemented in the game completely bore off other players as well? I mean, for a 4X 'Civ-like' game, combat takes waaaay to long (and I don't find it that clear and well explained tbh). Played through some of the scenarios multiple times, never managed to win. Do they focus too much on tactical thinking, scaring away the more leisurely players? I feel that combat will become such a drag that eventually it will just prevent you from playing.

0 Upvotes

55 comments sorted by

47

u/JanGuillosThrowaway Aug 14 '20 edited Aug 14 '20

I have my own opinion, and it's pretty strong in this area, so apologies in advance:

I think people are just so used to winning every. single. battle. every time without any effort from Civ V and Civ VI so the prospect of losing a battle makes the game 'too tactical'. I'm really glad that the AI can challenge you through war. I've never been invaded in all of Civ V and VI after the classical era, and repeatedly win battles I shouldn't win. You can defend your empire with two crossbows.

There are a couple of things they could do to explain battles better though, like showing movement range and making terrain/height advantages clearer on the map.

I find that war is much smoother than in Civ V or VI because you don't have to move units on the map every turn, and I don't even think the battles in game take too long time. Essentially, it feels like the battles you play in Humankind more decide the battle in one turn instead of being spread out over multiple turns. Also, with much higher movement speed it doesn't drag out moving your troops from point A to B to set up the battle in the first place.

Hopefully the problem of keeping casual gamers could be solved by difficulty levels instead of lowering the overall tactical level. That way you could have levels where you don't necessarily need to play well but can instead play fast and/or use autoresolve and still usually come out on top while also providing a challenge for those that want it.

I feel with a better UI and with a good auto-resolve system as an alternative both leisure and more 'total war' players can be happy with the game. What I don't understand really is how you can come from Civ and think that battles take longer here, when you factor in the huge amount of troop movement you have to do every single turn.

21

u/Tanel88 Aug 14 '20

Yea I think it's actually an exceptional combat system once you know how it works. It just isn't explained well enough.

The terrain and positioning plays a major role in winning battles unlike in most other 4X games and I love it.

1

u/oomzer Aug 14 '20

I get what you mean and understand it, but its maybe just because I'm not a warlike player. Not in 4X games at least. I never play real agressive in Civ (also the reason why I never play above emperor as military is kinda the only way to win). I get that it is different from Civ but whilst moving your troops around in Civ, the turns do tick on. In Humankind they don't. So: a war in Civ will take you 50 turns (lets say), whilst it will take you 2 turns in Humankind. If both games have the same turn length, Humankind will be a longer game overall (depending on how many battles you must fight in a game). It's just that I fear that too much of the game will be about warfare, which will be a shame imo.

3

u/JanGuillosThrowaway Aug 14 '20

Yeah, I also usually play builder styles for most of the game. (Mainly because Civ V gave no reason to expand your empire, Civ VI is much better in this regard though.) What did you think of the first scenario then?

I also played mostly peacefully in Civ IV, but what I liked about Civ IV compared to later Civs was that you needed a large military as a deterrent to stay at peace. Hopefully there will be interesting gameplay for us builders as well, and the first scenario made me hopeful, but of course there also needs to be a focus on that past the expansion stage that I couldn't tell from the scenario if it was there or not.

And, when you play peacefully in Civ, the turns do tick on, but it's mainly because you don't need an army. As soon as you got one, it turns sloggish very fast. From the first scenario I felt turns were flying by in Humankind as well.

IMO my preference would be that it's better to have one or two 'sloggish' wars when playing peacefully rather than not having to worry about warfare at all, both because it for me is better storybuilding and probably will be more balanced. The peaceful approach to Civ VI is pretty balanced, but it also makes the game very easy when going for an imperialistic approach.

0

u/oomzer Aug 14 '20

I liked the first scenario, but it wasn't that amazing neither. It was just regular 4x gameplay. I do like the outpost mechanic. I just hope there will be non-warlike playtypes.

1

u/Salmuth Aug 14 '20

I know for Civ, to avoid confrontations, I'd play certain conditions (like using maps with more land for the same number of players (lakes, inland sea...) so expansion can be done peacefully).

I hope there will be some diplomacy (we haven't seen anything about it I believe so far) and I hope we may buy peace (a bit like in Civ with the demands system).

Now you're never safe from the Mongols being in your game and having to defend (unless you pick every civs before the game starts, but that won't happen in Humankind).

3

u/nameorfeed Aug 15 '20

referring to total war games as complex strategy games lmao

-12

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '20

Your post boils down to "git gud" when this is not the issue at all. The issue is that battles are far too micro heavy for the output you get. The reason why one unit per turn was so controversial in the civ community was because it makes wars just a slog to get through even if you are winning by a landslide.

Its not hard its just tedious so please stop insinuating it is hard when all it is in its current state is just plain tedious.

As for auto resolving if you basically let the player bypass with auto resolve and there is a huge need for it there it means your mechanic is bad in the first place and should be tweaked which exactly is what opendev is supposed to find and address. I would appreciate it if you do not just dismiss others that casually just because it does not overlap with your personal experience and opinion.

10

u/JanGuillosThrowaway Aug 14 '20

What? That's not all what I said, and even in those comments I was referencing the OP, saying he lost all battles, and that the game might be 'too tactical' for casual gamers.

9

u/oomzer Aug 14 '20

Yeah agree with you, don't feel you had a git-gud opinion!

12

u/Salmuth Aug 14 '20 edited Aug 14 '20

I suppose this is why they implement(ed) a feature to simulate the fight (so the player doesn't have to do the battles).

Now what you express is your own opinion which is very valid (you're right battles take more time than what you have in civ for instance) and will legitimate the fight simulation feature. So no worries, you won't have to torture yourself. I didn't understand why they did it but you provide the reason: it may not be for everyone.

I thought the battles were challenging but achievable (since I did, one or 2 in1st try, sometimes after 4-5 tries (looking at you king of the hill)).

I don't know if it was supposed to be challenging because of the difficulty or because we have to learn how the system works. Maybe we were put in challenging situations but I mostly think the difficulty is about understanding the mechanics (terrain, rock/paper/scisors between unit types etc.) and using them at the best of our capacities.

The AI seemed Ok. Watching them helped me understand how terrain is important (because they focus fire on units in bade position which is great!). They sometimes go straight to units they shouldn't go after though (or not from above but turning around to get to higher grounds). So I don't know if it's gonna be like civ (sorry almost 4K hours on VI, it's gonna be my reference) with the AI level (the same whatever the difficulty level + bonuses if you increase the difficulty), I hope it will be "smarter" rather than getting bonuses but I understand how hard this must be to do so I don't really count on it.

As much as I understand how overwhelming or just annoying advanced battles strategies must be for casual players, it's very refreshing for experienced 4X players that look for more depth.

Edit: Maybe a more tutorialist way to present the scenarios would help. I mean something that would advise or even play for you a couple steps to explains mechanics that may not be easy to understand while playing for the 1st time.

Here for instance in one of the scenarios, I restarted turn 1 4-5 times because after every move I made I understood something about rivers, vision, how enemy units may block your movements and so on. A little reminder of the basic mechanics would be great.

5

u/oomzer Aug 14 '20

I think its also down to learning the game. Must say that its easier the second time I play it (or the game adapts, not sure). The ai seems better than civ, but still not the best. I just worry its all going to be about warfare, therefore I have my reservations. Im just playing the river scenario and I'm just clicking defend everytime. Its not very enjoyable I must say lol

3

u/Salmuth Aug 14 '20

LOL I didn't even notice there was a defend button... Though I looked for it and used the "skip" button instead, and I played the 4 little military scenarios (didn't try the last one yet).

I must say I watched a little bit of the livestreams so I wasn't going in totally blind.

About the AI and the play styles, I suppose if the AI sucks at war, it's going to be the players focus if military expansion doesn't get counter by some mechanics (stability for instance).

1

u/oomzer Aug 14 '20

Lol. Just now going through scenario 3 a second time, being absolutely destroyed by the elephants. I just fear it will eventually be the same as in civ: just one way to wage war against certain enemies because the AI is just programmed that way

2

u/Salmuth Aug 14 '20

Well it kind of makes sense gameplay wise.

If you have a light cavalry focused civ, you know you'll need anti-cav units. To me that's very much normal. The difference is that at every Era, you'll have a special unit (like the AI) so everyone will have his special ability to use.

Though I like that here you can make armies of multiple kinds of units. I like the frontline thing with the positionning phase.

I will try to play the scenario 3 tonight. I heard a lot of things about those elephants, I hope they won't be too harsh on me.

1

u/Tanel88 Aug 14 '20

All the scenarios are built requiring the player to exploit terrain, positioning, flanking and other bonuses in order to win so that can be frustrating when you don't understand the mechanics well yet.

As a veteran strategy game player the tactical and strategic depth really felt refreshing.

13

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '20

I like tactics games quite a lot and so Humankind‘s combat is very intuitive to me. It‘s also the reason i win almost all Battles (except for the Imjin River). I agree with you that 5 rounds a turn is quite long, i would like to try out battles with 3 rounds to see how much of a difference it makes. But overall I enjoy the battles immensely.

2

u/oomzer Aug 14 '20

I get what they're trying to do and the idea isn't bad, it just takes too long imo. 3 rounds would be better perhaps yes.

8

u/Tanel88 Aug 14 '20

I think 5 is good. Decreasing it to 3 would make most battles last multiple turns and allow more reinforcements to be brought in.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '20

huh, hadn't thought about that, great point.

9

u/Orzislaw Aug 14 '20 edited Aug 14 '20

I agree with what others said. In Civ micromanaging all the units on the world map while at war was a nuisance, especially since pathing often sucks and you spent most of the turn trying to move units where you want, because some city-state troop blocked previous path. It was especially weird when unit tried to find the way through the terrain where there's obviously water, but it's still under fog of war so AI is pretending your units can go through this. It was horrible and main reason I rarely play militaristic game.

Making units stack is great way to prevent these nuisances while still offering tactical decisions for the players that want them. I agree that in Civ5-6 there weren't too many tactical decisions and you could easily win against significantly stronger enemy. So harder battles are better, ESPECIALLY since the game offers auto-resolve, which work similar to stacks of doom fighting in Civ4 and earlier. If you don't like tactical battles, just go with auto-resolve every time.

1

u/oomzer Aug 14 '20

I get what you mean, I just fear it will be too much about warfare. Also don't think that auto-resolving everything is the best option. I just hope they lower the difficulty.

8

u/Orzislaw Aug 14 '20

I agree with that. The best possible solution would be to separate difficulty setting for warfare from the rest of gameplay. SO people who like more challenging exploring, expanding and exploiting wouldn't have to deal with also challenging extermination.

2

u/oomzer Aug 14 '20

That would be a good solution imo

1

u/Talmiam Aug 14 '20

When you say "Lower the difficulty," are you talking about the decisions of the AI, the impact of combat strength bonus/malus from terrain and other circumstantial influences, or something else?

1

u/oomzer Aug 14 '20

I guess a mix of those? That you can make mistakes / not choose the best tactics and still win

4

u/xNasior Aug 14 '20

I get what you mean, but i would actually say to increase difficulties so you can actually loose a war not like in civ that after classical era you can just easily defends city and steam roll everything.

However that would make a lot of people afraid of picking up the game, so overall the difficulties setting for combat could be good enough solution.

1

u/oomzer Aug 14 '20

I just think that devs shouldn't overestimate the skill of their player base. Of course there are players who are really good, but its also mostly just casual players who will indeed shy away from a huge challenge. Making it too difficult can have negative effects

1

u/Tanel88 Aug 14 '20

That's why you need to get difficulty settings right. If you just flatly lower the difficulty the more experienced players will not find it challenging enough.

1

u/oomzer Aug 14 '20

I think someone else in this thread mentioned a sliding scale in which you can up or down the difficulty for differing mechanics, such as building and warfare.

1

u/Tanel88 Aug 14 '20

Yea that would probably be a good idea.

2

u/xNasior Aug 14 '20

unfortunately yea, that's why a difficulty bar can be good in these case, but things is that if you will have technological advantage it my be much easier to win battles, so we will have to wait and see to more open beta.

i said it before and will said it again what i most like about the whole combat system is that is not taking so many turns, and think that is optimal solution as adding element of realism, as when war in civ can take 30-50 turns and in world time is 300 years let say, when here when you will have 5 turns war is easier to believe for story telling that war take 10 or 20 years and there was multiple smaller battles at few strategic points and eventually evolving in like world war 1 or 2 events, when you will be reinforcing battles for few turns.

8

u/hellshake_narco Aug 14 '20 edited Aug 14 '20

dude, it's not a demo but a playtest, an opendev like they said, to take a look on mechanics and help them with feedback survey

It's evident than they intentionally create hard combats, to tryhard the mechanics, find the problems (of Ui, exploit, OP mechanics, Ai bugs, etc ...) but than there is a lot of WiP.

Litterally the scenario 3 is about a handmade Last Stand, situation you will never or rarely have in the real game.

Constructive opinion about lenght :

The battles seems to be really decisive in the game, so yes a single huge battle is longer than civ, but the management of all your armies to accomplish something (like conquering cities or territories) seems to be faster (again because battles seems to be REALLY decisive, in 3 turn, you know which player get the city).

In mid/late game on Civ, if you exploit all the passive, bonus, counter, promotion tree, and all the tactical thinking of Civ, it's a loooot of time too. You need to micromanage a lot of units on all the map.

In HK you can manage the cities and territories in same time than a battle occurs. So if you auto-resolve with fast animations (because the battle is not important or decisive) , it's really chill, you don't need to manage your 20 or + single units like Civ.

4x game are basically slow game, which need patience and tactic. There is not only Civ in the 4X verse, Shadow Empire for exemple have really tactical battles.

And it's not because there is some Civ-like things (the historical settings) than they need to do the same things than Civ

There is the city building genre in the gaming world, if poeple don't want warfare.

Even Grand Strategy game (Paradox game) can have relatively complex battle system (HoI 4)

And I can suppose than like a lot of 4X you will be able to play peacefully with diplomaty, to decrease the amount of warfare.

But the purpose of this opendev now is apparently to check the battle mechanics. And nobody obliges you to manage to win if you don't care about battles, but it's missing an opportunity to help with our Civ experience. (about readibility for exemple, adding instant animation for Mp, etc )

10

u/xNasior Aug 14 '20

100% agree with you, the presented system is much better than in civ as when in end game you have 50+ units to move around across half of the glob it taking long time when here all seems to put a nice pace, without dragging and other thing is like you mention i prefer 5-10 turns of heavy fighting then a peace, which is even more believable as wars in real life was long and takes usually multiple battles.

1

u/oomzer Aug 14 '20

I get what you mean, don't get me wrong. I just feel that they focus too much on warfare (but that might just be the opendev). I hate playing Civ on higher levels because it's just all about war (and I'm not an agressive player). Maybe it's just that I need to play more, but I still feel that it's not completely clear which units do what and how terrain and combat work etc.

4

u/hellshake_narco Aug 14 '20

Just thing about the OpenDev concept itself. Don't block on the superficial things; just check the concrete things than offer the game, is the readibility ok, is it buggued, is Ai ok, is Ui ok, etc ...

If the first openDev help them, maybe we will have new OpenDev, about modern warfare, diplomacy, economy, religion... :) Maybe.

I understand than if you are not a warmonger player, you must be disapointe than 80% of the prealpha is about warfare.

But I think it's the spot which they need the most of help.

I think than the citybuilding part, political part and economy part are already less problematic for them.

3

u/oomzer Aug 14 '20

Yeah thats true, but it just gives off a wrong first impression for me. If the warfare part is the only thing they really want to know if they've done it right, I just fear the rest is not very innovative, which would be a shame imo

3

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '20

The way I see it, it doesn't necessarily mean that the rest isn't innovative, it's just that an unbalanced or broken combat system has the most potential to cause frustration in players - and even be game ending, either in an "I quit" or "Game Over" way.

It's also the easiest to test in a limited opendev format. I'd love to see how the culture changing across eras works, but that would probably require much longer playtime to really get a feel for.

0

u/oomzer Aug 14 '20

Yeah I like the open dev approach they take, but it also means people will get certain bad impressions

3

u/BluegrassGeek Aug 14 '20

Honestly, I'm right there with you. While I like the idea of tactical combat (I used to adore Myth: the Fallen Lords), in this game I have no idea what I'm doing, so it's just "click until I'm dead." This OpenDev does nothing to help me understand how to conduct combat, so I just keep dying.

The only combat scenario I won was the Viking one, and I only one that because I got lucky and the AI accidentally moved its last unit in range of my siege engines. If it hadn't done that, I'd have lost, because all my other units were dead.

1

u/oomzer Aug 14 '20

It does get better over time, but in the end I feel like I only could win the battles in scenario 2 because the enemy made some stupid moves (like moving in range of the siege engines) or just not attacking. Maybe its supposed to be like that, but still

9

u/Rifraxa Aug 14 '20

You can auto-resolve.

-10

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '20

If you prefer to bypass one of the core mechanic something is terribly wrong with that core mechanic, and that is what opendev is supposed to adress.

18

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '20 edited Aug 14 '20

But in this case the problem doesn't seem to be that the core mechanic is "bad" (The commenter who enjoys tactics games found it intuitive after all) and more that a certain player doesn't personally like it.

And speaking as a Total War player, autoresolve is an important quality-of-life feature when you're dealing with ragtag bands of survivors from the epic battle you just fought and random garrisons of 2 trash-tier units.

3

u/Lorcogoth Aug 14 '20

I agree that auto resolve is important but please don't mention auto-resolve and total-war in the same sentence.

I really like Total war but their recent auto resolve calculator is... well its not something I would write home about.

1

u/TerryBerry11 Aug 19 '20

Auto-resolve is meant to bypass easy to win battles. Otherwise it’s best to fight it out on the battlefield. In Total War I’ve fought battles the auto-resolve feature said were a guaranteed loss, and won, just by using hills and choke points.

1

u/Lorcogoth Aug 19 '20

my problem with the total war auto resolve is that its stupid, there are battle that I should win with ease that the auto resolve considers "impossible" to win.

and I am talking about battle that are take army attack command enemy battle line win.

12

u/tarkin1980 Aug 14 '20

It's a matter of taste. The fact that some people prefer to skip the tactical battles doesn't mean there is something wrong with them. Tactical battles is not a "core mechanic" of any 4X, it's just one way of resolving battles. Many games have had auto resolve options.

Your argument is on the level of saying that because some people choose not to play Civilization/League of Legends/Chess or whatever, it's a bad game and needs to go.

8

u/Wall_Marx Aug 14 '20

You can't please everyone. If someone doesn't like it and want to bypass it it's not a proof that the core mechanic is broken.

5

u/Kinderschoko23 Aug 14 '20

But we are just talking about one reddit post. A lot of players liked it. so the mechanic is definitally not bad.

-6

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '20

That is a narrow way of thinking about it. I did not just reference this thread. I speak of what is said on the discord and the community at large as well and in all the youtube and twich coverage.

1

u/Shurdus Aug 16 '20

OP, do you worry about the time it takes to complete combat, or you not winning? The latter seems like a huge plus to me because a victory should not be pretty much a guarantee.

1

u/oomzer Aug 16 '20

Well mostly the time. At first I wasn't winning, but after some time I did win some of the scenarios. However, most I won because of the AI being ineffective or not going for the win, so that's got me worried as well

0

u/Fudgeyman Aug 14 '20

Simply don't agree at all