r/Huel
•
u/AStorms13
•
Oct 16 '25
I’m skeptical of some of the posters in here that are aggressively defending Huel. This is not a light situation. We need more answers, not arguments.
I am very skeptical of some of the people in this sub, specifically u/aschla. Their account was dead for 2 years until this situation, and they have aimlessly defended Huel. Their most recent, long post tries to be structured, scientific and attempt to prove that lead is not an issue, whether that be the amount compared to other foods, or the amount that can actually harm humans. They give sources when convenient, and no sources for the most important stats being lauded as facts.
Below are my issues with the linked post. https://reddit.com/r/Huel/comments/1o7ia53/lead_exposure_and_you_how_to_interpret_the/
u/aschla states that fresh tomatoes have 1.4mcg of lead per 90g. When asked where this number comes from, they gave a source from a polish research paper where produce was obtained IN POLAND. Not the US.
The FDA estimates that the average person in the United States consumes 5.3mcg of lead per day, yet we are led to believe that 90g of tomato has 25% of that amount? Even if we use the FDA’s safe limit of 12.5, 90g of tomato is 10% of the allowable limit? The amount of tomato sauce consumed in the US alone would put people over that number.
When disputed and shown an FDA study that shows significantly lower lead in produce, all they respond with is “there is variance in other studies”.
I am skeptical of the baseless defending of Huel in this sub. Health is not something to mess around with, and this is not a light topic. People consuming a measurably large amount of lead when compared to a national government standard is NOT good. It needs to be investigated. It needs to be looked at. Huel needs to be scrutinized. And CR is an incredibly reputable nonprofit organization that specializes in protecting consumers. They are not profit driven, Huel is.
Until a collaporative effort is put out between CR and Huel that comes to a good conclusion, or a third party comes out with irrefutable evidence against CR, then I will not be consuming Huel.
