r/Huel • • Oct 16 '25 Helpful

I’m skeptical of some of the posters in here that are aggressively defending Huel. This is not a light situation. We need more answers, not arguments.

10 Upvotes

I am very skeptical of some of the people in this sub, specifically u/aschla. Their account was dead for 2 years until this situation, and they have aimlessly defended Huel. Their most recent, long post tries to be structured, scientific and attempt to prove that lead is not an issue, whether that be the amount compared to other foods, or the amount that can actually harm humans. They give sources when convenient, and no sources for the most important stats being lauded as facts.

Below are my issues with the linked post. https://reddit.com/r/Huel/comments/1o7ia53/lead_exposure_and_you_how_to_interpret_the/

  1. u/aschla states that fresh tomatoes have 1.4mcg of lead per 90g. When asked where this number comes from, they gave a source from a polish research paper where produce was obtained IN POLAND. Not the US.

  2. The FDA estimates that the average person in the United States consumes 5.3mcg of lead per day, yet we are led to believe that 90g of tomato has 25% of that amount? Even if we use the FDA’s safe limit of 12.5, 90g of tomato is 10% of the allowable limit? The amount of tomato sauce consumed in the US alone would put people over that number.

  3. When disputed and shown an FDA study that shows significantly lower lead in produce, all they respond with is “there is variance in other studies”.

I am skeptical of the baseless defending of Huel in this sub. Health is not something to mess around with, and this is not a light topic. People consuming a measurably large amount of lead when compared to a national government standard is NOT good. It needs to be investigated. It needs to be looked at. Huel needs to be scrutinized. And CR is an incredibly reputable nonprofit organization that specializes in protecting consumers. They are not profit driven, Huel is.

Until a collaporative effort is put out between CR and Huel that comes to a good conclusion, or a third party comes out with irrefutable evidence against CR, then I will not be consuming Huel.


r/Huel • • Oct 15 '25

Why won't Huel post the results of the 17 reports they keep referring to?

7 Upvotes

"We have conducted 17 tests in the last 3 years on Black Edition Powder and our levels are 1) well within the safe limits of UK, EU and NSF guidelines 2) far less than the numbers Consumer Reports are quoting."

They've published the NSF report. But anyone asking them to share any of the other 16 reports is met with silence. Why?


r/Huel • • Sep 07 '22

Enjoying Huel on my bus tonight

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Huel • • May 09 '24

This is the worst design ever.

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/Huel • • Aug 20 '26

General Discussion Now HUEL just needs to start making Creatine 👀

0 Upvotes

Who doesn't love a fully stocked shelf of HUEL? What's your favorite Black Edition RTD? Mine is the COFFEE CARAMEL or ICED LATTE RTD.


r/Huel • • Feb 25 '24

Thai green curry is DISGUSTING

2 Upvotes

How the hell is this the most popular flavour?! I took it as a recommendation from a friend because I'm on my 2nd month of Huel (powder drink breakfast + pasta/rices for lunch).

I am suffering more than any human has ever suffered.


r/Huel • • Sep 07 '24

Very worried about Huel.

0 Upvotes

So I have been ordering Huel (Unflavored/Unsweetened.)consistently for over a year now. I really love the convenience.

However I am starting to get worried about the quality of testing behind the Huel powder.

The last two batches I ordered have made me very sick. And they both smelled very off.

I talked to customer service, and I got refunded for both. But I’m still very concerned now about the testing involved as there are many vitamins/minerals that could easily reach dangerous levels if not properly tested.

2 days after drinking the powder I am still dealing with terrible symptoms. Fatigue, racing heart, depression/brain fog etc.

It has really made me sick. And it took a good 3+ days last time to start feeling better.

I’m worried what could cause that in the Huel? How good is their quality control?

So far this is the second order in a row, and a total of 3 altogether that have made me very sick.

I’m really starting to worry about their level of quality testing. Has anyone else gotten sick off Huel?


r/Huel • • Sep 09 '24

new lid design sucks

Post image
22 Upvotes

what is up with these new lids on huel ready to drink bottles in the uk the new design of the lid being attached to the bottle is for recycling reasons but means huel gets trapped in the lid when i’m shaking it and then drips onto me while i’m drinking it??? what a stupid design for a drink like this.


r/Huel • • Sep 11 '26

Product Discussion Huel ruined H&S -- anyone know of alternatives?

9 Upvotes

I was a satisfied Huel user a couple of years ago, but took a hiatus. Recently I decided to restock, and after taking a look, I'm left in disbelief at how badly Huel sabotaged Hot&Savory. u/Tim_Huel u/BenHuel PLEASE listen to the People and bring back the big multi-serving bags.

The individual packets make zero sense to me, for several reasons:

  1. There is more package waste and more storage space in my pantry, for no reason. There was a beautiful minimalism to having a simple bag full of calories that I could scoop out.

  2. 400 calories is not a meal. It's blatant deception that they are advertising these boxes as "$3.95 per meal", given who their target audience is. 2800 total calories in the box is 3-4 meals, not 7. But regardless, the point is that the consumer should be able to choose their calories themselves. When I had the big bag, I simply scooped out however much I wanted. The idea that I now need to open and discard two individual packets to have an 800 calorie meal, every time I eat Huel, is nonsensical. Or, if I want a 650 calorie meal, I still need to open and discard two packets, and then transfer the remainder of the powder that I'm not eating to a ziploc or whatever. That's nonsensical.

  3. The issue of the meals being poorly mixed is fictional for everyone but idiots. It was never that hard to shake the bag, look at the contents of your scoop and be able to intuit whether it was well-mixed or not. If you are really worried that a big chunk of your consumer base are incompetent children who can't handle that, then fine, you're probably right. Offer the individual packets for them. But to discontinue the big bags outright is crazy. Please at least offer both.

But really, there is an even more sensible solution to the mixing problem... Just sell a big bag of the savory mix! Seriously. We can all buy noodles from the store, and we don't need them from Huel. I would love to buy a big bag of the Mac n Cheese powder. Mixing problem gone.

Huel H&S fills such a unique niche in the protein market that has no real competition in the US, as far as I know. So I'd love to continue buying it. But the individual packets are such an egregious misstep that I cannot buy any Huel H&S until the big bags come back.


r/Huel • • Oct 18 '25

Amazon Returns

1 Upvotes

Just as an FYI for everyone here. Knee jerk reaction I know but I was able to return a few bags of Huel black I got in bulk during a sale to Amazon after explaining the study and lack of transparency.

I know I’ll be downvoted because there is a suspicious amounts of “I get my blood tested for lead all the time” comments but I’m more concerned about the cadmium and lack of transparency from them. I’ll be disposing of the few bags I have but if it changes I’ll just buy more.

And no “we looked at this 6 years ago and it was fine” while also giving validity to the consumer reports test isn’t transparency. It’s just refuting the claims and being nice about it. As a company they have always been great but that doesn’t negate concern when most of us who are so into it is because we are athletes or take care of our bodies. Consumer reports is not a scientific organization and more like an activist group but their claims being met the way they were is my cause for concern.


r/Huel • • Apr 25 '22

$50 t-shirts are now a cornerstone to Huel’s business model - doesn’t look like they even claim to be a food company any more. Not that I was ever a fan, but this is cray.

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/Huel • • Jun 05 '23

So I heard there’s a RTD shortage…

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Huel • • Mar 18 '24

Does anyone else put cheese in their Huel pot?

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/Huel • • Oct 21 '25

Huel alternatives

0 Upvotes

Do yall know of any alternatives to huel that provides similar nutrition in terms of macros and also micronutrients? From what I understand, the pea protein is the culprit in the higher than desired lead levels. I drink 2 shakes a day for lunch so I would like to lower that. Just want to know what other options are out there. Huel seems to do it best though and is the most convenient/cheap.

Huel being vegan does not matter to me so whey protein would be fine too.


r/Huel • • Nov 08 '21

Message from Julian - we’re introducing some price updates - please read

2 Upvotes

Hey guys, many of you would have got an email today, or will shortly, announcing some price changes. Below is a message from Julian we want to share here too. If you have any questions, just drop them below and we will do our best to answer.

------

Dear Hueligans,

Huel’s founder, Julian, here. First, I want to thank you for using Huel. We would be nothing without our loyal Hueligans and we’re always going to use the best ingredients in the world to create the delicious, nutritionally complete meals that you know and love.

Unfortunately, the cost of all the good stuff that goes into Huel has increased significantly in the last year, which means your subscription is going to increase from December 8th (GMT).

Here is why:

  • We froze our prices at the start of the pandemic to support our Hueligans during a difficult time, but global events have made it more expensive to make, stock and ship your Huel

  • So that we can continue on our mission to make it easy to eat well while protecting the planet, the price of all our products is changing

  • From December 8th, any subscription you receive will have new prices

The below information is for the US only. Different countries have different price changes and this is just to give you an idea. To ensure you all have the right information we have emailed everyone with a subscription about this with the same information here - as well as anyone who has purchased Huel 3 times or more.

If you need more information, this article explains everything you need to know about the changes.

Read more here:

https://uk.huel.com/pages/price-change-dec-2021

Can I change my subscription?

Of course. Our subscriptions are still as flexible as they have always been. If you would like to make any adjustments to your subscription before the increases take place, simply log into your account here.

We ask that you make any changes before December 8th so that we can confirm them before the new prices come into effect.

If you’re happy to keep receiving your Huel as usual, you don’t need to do anything. You’ll automatically pay the new price on your next order.

I can’t thank you enough for being part of the Huel family. We’ve been on this journey for six years and I am confident the best is still to come. I hope you choose to stick with us so that you can continue to enjoy our convenient, plant-based, nutritionally complete meals. We can’t change the world without you.

Love ya,

Julian x


r/Huel • • Jul 20 '20

Tip: Water first powder second

2 Upvotes

When you put water into the shaker and then add the powder, the chances of the powder clumping are reduced :)


r/Huel • • May 15 '25

What are the best alternatives to Huel?

0 Upvotes

I’ve had enough. They’ve changed every single product I use for the worst. Chocolate powder is now sickly and awful. The new single meal bags all have those horrible rubber chunks in them. Portion sizes are getting smaller.

What are the best Huel alternatives? I’m sick of giving these people my cash for products that used to be great but now taste horrendous.

Edit: Oh, and when you contact them to ask why they’ve changed the recipe, they gaslight you and insist they haven’t changed anything, despite massively obvious changes (presence of large white chunks that didn’t exist before; pasta pieces literally being half the size and a totally different type of pasta; taste completely changing overnight).

Screenshot evidence


r/Huel • • Aug 25 '23

Is This The Biggest Con In Nutrition? - James Smith reviews Huel

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/Huel • • Oct 15 '25

The Huel Mods Are Censoring Memes & Posts About the Lead Controversy

0 Upvotes

If this community is just going to become a corporate coverup that stifles free discussion and memes criticizing the product, I've got no reason to be here. If you guys want this place to continue to benefit you, you need to let people speak freely.


r/Huel • • 21d ago

General Discussion Are most Hueligans Vegan or Not?

0 Upvotes

I myself am not vegan, but I prefer a more vegan focused diet with some fish, dairy, and lean meats here and there.

785 votes, 14d ago
187 Vegan
513 Non-Vegan
85 Vegetarian

r/Huel • • Oct 08 '26

Product Review The hot meals are god awful

7 Upvotes

I got the mixed selection of pasta and grains and they are truly nasty so far. I wasn’t expecting gourmet, but they all have this slightly odd smell and the texture is pretty grainy.

I’m surprised anyone likes them. I’m still holding out hope as I’ve only had a few flavours so far, but at this rate, I think Huel in general just isn’t for me sadly.

Can certainly attest to the satiety factory and them being super balanced, I’m just unsure how they manage to make all their products so bland but unappetising too.

Anyone else enjoyed or not enjoyed them?

Edit: thanks all for the advice. The overwhelming consensus seems to be to add things like MSG which I will do. I’ll say they definitely fill a hole, just not sure my tastebuds can cope. It does seem like the actual meals taste wise are inadequate hence people adding things! But appreciate all the same and see a market for them!


r/Huel • • Oct 17 '25

How many of you are gonna stop taking Huel ?

6 Upvotes

Quick survey after the "leadgate", how do you feel about Huel now ?

A/ I will continue to take Huel.

B/ I am stopping Huel immediately or after my last bag, this is a serious issue.

C/ I will continue drinking Huel, but I am still a little bit worried by their lack of transparency and their suppliers.

Personally I am C. I will not stop because I got reassured by the blood tests posted in this sub. But still, I hope Huel will listen to the community, release all their data and switch from a Chinese supplier to a US or EU one.


r/Huel • • Jan 25 '25

Does anyone else mass prep?

Post image
0 Upvotes

My brain is pretty warped from studying economics, so I tend to apply economies of scale to all of my processes. I found that doing the scooping 2-3 times/wk was time consuming and reduced my likelihood of making future day’s shakes. Each soup container contains 4sc Huel Black and 3sc whey, which I blend with water for three shaker bottles. On lift days I’ll drink 4, on rest days 3. These meals cover all of my macros for meals except dinner. My coworkers think I’m a monster, but I’m just ahead of the curve


r/Huel • • Sep 13 '23

Huel (Scam or Tested)?

2 Upvotes

I have yet to find any testing of Huel products to verify its claims of nutrients within its product. Has anyone seen where Huel undergoes testing? Also, pasteurization kills a lot of nutrients, and I would really like to see something verifying that Huel's products are legit.

A recent study showed that an exceedingly high percentage of the major brands of vitamins have significantly less of the product's stated quantity of the vitamins.

--------------------------------------------

UPDATE

So, I have finally found a study funded by Huel, but using an independent lab. Looks to be that this stuff actually works. It's a good study and worth reading for those on the fence. It's also peer reviewed.

Is Huel healthy? We Did a Study to Find Out


r/Huel • • Oct 14 '25

I’m so pissed right now. Lead, really?

Post image
0 Upvotes