r/HorrorMakesUsHappy • • Aug 25 '21

We call upon Reddit to take action against the rampant Coronavirus misinformation on their website.

Thumbnail reddit.com
59 Upvotes

r/HorrorMakesUsHappy • • May 20 '24

Open letter to Patreon about new consent requirements for content creators who've marked their accounts Adult/18+

8 Upvotes

It looks like we've been able to resolve the miscommunication. Leaving this here in case it's useful to anyone else later.

We've submitted a ticket with Patreon, but are posting this here and elsewhere for visibility.

Our initial email:

Patreon,

We've just read your updated consent requirements for Adult/18+ works, and feel it extremely necessary to ask you to create a new, third category to cover creators who aren't involved in sexually gratifying content but want their content to be marked as Adult.

We are a podcast. We interview people in the horror biz - authors, writers, actors, producers, directors, SFX artists, etc. We mark our podcast Adult because talking about the things that happen in horror movies (and sometimes in real life) are either not suited for young kids, or should involve parental discretion. But it makes no sense for us to require guests to sign consent forms and provide copies of their identification cards just for them to talk to us.

We understand you're concerned with confirming the people participating in sexually gratifying content are 18+, as you rightly should be, but there needs to be a distinction between that content versus what we're doing, and the requirements for each.

The consent of our guests is evidenced by the fact that they're talking to us. That alone should suffice for consent. The information on identification cards is considered PII, which might mean we'd have to become PII certified, and deal with the many complications that come with that. That makes absolutely no sense for a podcast that just talks to people.

And then, taking it further, stating that you will refuse to process payment transactions from supporters unless we do this ... it's about three steps too far.

This doesn't make sense for our content, and we ask that you create a new category to cover creators who aren't involved in sexually gratifying content but want their content to be marked as Adult.

VR,
Horror Makes Us Happy


The rest of the email trail below will be in reverse order, with the most recent at the top.


Patreon's last response:

Hi again,

As previously explained, only the account owner needs to complete the Age Verification process, which can be accessed via your account's Notifications Tab.

You can consult our Age Verification FAQ (unrelated to consent requirements) via the link below:

Age Verification: Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Let me know if you still have any questions!

All the best,

Patreon | Trust & Safety


Our seventh response:

Hi Morgan,

As a point of clarification: Reviewing the support pages for 18+ content, it appears the age verification for guests is only mentioned on the consent forms. I don't see it (for guests) mentioned anywhere else.

Am I to understand from your last message that only we, the account holders, need to verify our ages? Or are you stating that our guests don't need to sign the consent form but do need to validate their ages?

If Patreon will still require us to gather PII from our guests just to talk to them we've already outlined our concerns with that.

VR,
Horror Makes Us Happy


Patreon's seventh response:

Hi again,

Thank you for writing back to me and providing suggestions for future improvements in our product - these are highly appreciated and will certainly be passed on to the team.

However, as previously explained, because your page is marked as NSFW, as the account owner, you need to complete the Age Verification process. I want to emphasize once more that the consent requirements don't apply to your content.

As a user, you are free to disagree with these requirements, however, by not completing the Age Verification process as an account categorized as NSFW, your payout access might be impacted in the future.

All the best,
Patreon | Trust & Safety


Our sixth response:

Hi Morgan,

My apologies for the delay in responding.

We must again ask to escalate this issue, and request that Patreon create a category for creators who just want to be able to have adult conversations without running the risk of being demonetized by Patreon for not fitting neatly into their two category system (much less having to worry about being harassed by other people on the internet complaining that our content isn't "Safe for all ages").

We believe this is an exceptionally reasonable request, given the fickle natures of both business management and public discourse.

VR,
Horror Makes Us Happy


Patreon's sixth response:

Hi again,

As previously explained, because the guests featured in your content are not nude or engaging in sexual scenarios, the consent requirements do not apply to your account, however, and separate from this, the account owner still needs to complete the Age Verification process which you can find in the account's Notifications tab since your account is marked as NSFW.

Let me know if you have any questions.

All the best,
Patreon | Trust & Safety


Our fifth response:

Hi Morgan,

We appreciate the distinction, but still do not believe this is an acceptable situation to be in. This would still require us to obtain PII from our guests (a copy of their government ID, with much more than just their DOB on it) and we would have to retain those records.

We believe it's unacceptable to request small businesses like ours to have to enter into the much more complex world of PII storage regulations for doing nothing more than talking about TV, books, and movies.

We must again ask to escalate this issue, and request that Patreon create a category for creators who just want to be able to have adult conversations without running the risk of being demonetized by Patreon for not fitting neatly into their two category system (much less having to worry about being harassed by other people on the internet complaining that our content isn't "Safe for all ages").

We believe this is an exceptionally reasonable request, given the fickle natures of both business management and public discourse.

VR,
Horror Makes Us Happy


Patreon's fifth response:

Hi again,

Thank you for writing back to me.

I believe there might be some confusion regarding two distinct processes and requirements — Age Verification, which is required for all creators marked as NSFW/18+ regardless of the nature of their project, and Mastercard consent requirements which are only required from creators featuring other individuals in a nudity or sexual context.

The emails you sent so far mention the updated consent requirements, which the nature of your project does not apply to, however, I can confirm that by having your page marked as NSFW, you still need to complete the Age Verification process.

I hope this helps. Let me know if you have any questions.

All the best,
Patreon | Trust & Safety


Our fourth response:

Thank you for sharing that link to the policy. Unfortunately it contradicts what you shared with us earlier.

Earlier you said, "Your page can remain marked as NSFW and is in compliance with our guidelines, even if it does not fall within the nudity and sexually gratifying aspects tied to most NSFW pages. Because your content does not fall within the categories encompassed in the consent form requirement updates, you can disregard the email communication you received."

But the policy you linked to says, "If your page is currently categorized as Adult/18+ but contains no sexually explicit content or nudity ... you are eligible to opt out of Age Verification by recategorizing from 'Adult/18+' to 'Safe for All Audiences.'"

Per the policy the only way to be exempt from the consent requirements is to recategorizing from 'Adult/18+' to 'Safe for All Audiences', which we don't want to do, for previously stated reasons. Please escalate this discrepancy, along with our request that Patreon create at the very least a third category for adult content that is not intended for sexual gratification.

VR,
Horror Makes Us Happy


Patreon's fourth response:

Hi again,

Thank you for writing back to me.

This article states that "The requirement specifically applies to creators of Adult/18+ pages that include one or more works containing sexually explicit content or nudity".

Let me know if you have any questions.

All the best,
Patreon | Trust & Safety


Our response:

Hi Morgan,

We appreciate you restating that we comply because our content doesn't contain sexually gratifying content, but as mentioned in an earlier email, "sexually gratifying content" was our verbiage. It doesn't appear in any of the Patreon policy that we've seen. So right now all we have is your word that our content isn't included in the policy. We'd like to know if you can show us where that distinction exists in the Patreon policy.

Thank you,
Horror Makes Us Happy


Patreon's third response:

Hi again,

Thank you for writing back to me. I believe there might be some confusion in this interaction, I'm happy to further clarify.

Your page can remain marked as NSFW and is in compliance with our guidelines, even if it does not fall within the nudity and sexually gratifying aspects tied to most NSFW pages.

Because your content does not fall within the categories encompassed in the consent form requirement updates, you can disregard the email communication you received.

Let me know if you have any questions.

All the best,
Patreon | Trust & Safety


We've replied:

Hello again,

Unfortunately this doesn't help. The other category is called "Safe for All Audiences" (emphasis yours), which we don't believe is true for our content. I believe we must again request that Patreon create one or more additional categories, similar to the ratings for movies.

If we were to move our content to the "Safe for All Audiences" category and someone complains about our content, Patreon would most likely fault us, not yourselves. The outcomes of that could potentially be to terminate our account or deny us the funds collected on our behalf. This would not be an appropriate situation, and we're asking Patreon to address this possibility before it becomes a reality that hurts us or other content creators.

It may be true that none of the other major websites on the internet (like Youtube) have multiple categories yet, but Patreon could be an innovator that influences the entire internet in this respect. The US movie ratings system was the result of an industry self-regulating in order to show they could do so without the need for the government to step in, and now maybe it's time for the World Wide Web to start following that lead.

Thank you,
Horror Makes Us Happy


Patreon's first response:

Hi again,

Thank you for writing back to me.

I'd like to clarify that although you prefer to have your Patreon marked as Adult/18+ for the reasons you previously shared, and have all the right to do so — this page categorization was mainly created for works that feature nudity (real or illustrated), or any adult themes that fall within the sexually gratifying content sphere as long as they don't violate any of our guidelines. The updated consent requirements apply to content featuring real people within the context described above.

This Help Center article may be useful to you as you decide what course of action you'd like to take: Should my campaign be marked as Safe for All Audiences or Adult/18+ and how do I recategorize?

I hope this helps. If you have any questions in the meantime, don't hesitate to let me know. I'm happy to help.

All the best,
Patreon | Trust & Safety


We've replied:

Hi Morgan,

We didn't actually see any verbiage in your policies that mention sexually gratifying content - those were words we used to describe the difference between what we suspected Patreon's intent was as opposed to content we are not providing. As far as we saw, Patreon's policies only use the terms "Adult" or "18+". If you can show us where in the policies it specifically only requires these consent forms and PII for sexually gratifying content, please share that with us so we can keep that for our records. If that's not an explicit part of Patreon's policies regarding Adult/18+ content then we ask that be added.

Thank you,
Horror Makes Us Happy


Patreon's first response:

Hi there,

Thanks for reaching out. This is Morgan from Patreon’s Trust & Safety Team, and I’m happy to help.

If your Adult/18+ creative works on Patreon do not visually feature real human participants, then the payment partner requirement to document participant consent does not apply to you. In other words, there is no consent to be obtained from any animated, illustrated, written, or video game-type characters that you may feature on your Patreon or content that doesn't fall within the sexually gratifying definition of Adult content.

Should you ever decide to visually feature a real human participant in a future Adult/18+ creative work, this Help Center article contains the consent documentation form that you should use, along with additional details on that requirement.

Thanks again for contacting us, and if you have any other questions, please let me know.

All the best,
Patreon | Trust & Safety


r/HorrorMakesUsHappy • • Apr 22 '21

Feel so god damned true sometimes. Just gotta keep on keepin' on.

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/HorrorMakesUsHappy • • Apr 14 '23

Living next to a graveyard, birthday in October, and his mom was a horror fan? Jonnathan Janz (The Dismembered, Children of the Dark, Marla) may have been fated to love horror, but there's more to his story than that...

Thumbnail
horrormakesushappy.com
3 Upvotes

r/HorrorMakesUsHappy • • Feb 04 '23

Today we talk to founder of Rue Morgue magazine, Rodrigo Gudiño! Join us as Rodrigo talks to us about paranormal experiences in a funeral home, chasing down ghosts in his dreams, and the language of the unconscious.

Thumbnail
instagram.com
3 Upvotes

r/HorrorMakesUsHappy • • Jul 10 '22

This week on HMUH: Nikki Williams (Slumber Party Massacre podcast, Foresight Channeler) - Nikki's got a dark side! Well, a Shadow, technically. But don't we all?

Thumbnail
horrormakesushappy.com
3 Upvotes

r/HorrorMakesUsHappy • • Apr 29 '22

This week on Horror Makes Us Happy: Mister Ken Foree (Dawn of the Dead, Halloween, The Devil's Rejects) !! In this episode Mr. Foree helps us understand not only what he gets out of horror, but maybe out of all other genres, too!

Thumbnail
horrormakesushappy.com
3 Upvotes

r/HorrorMakesUsHappy • • Sep 24 '21

We're happy to announce: Our first Halloween contest!

3 Upvotes

Here's your chance to win a free t-shirt and sticker from our Redbubble store!

For details check out our most recent bonus clip at https://HorrorMakesUsHappy.com. If you're not familiar with our designs, check out the Merch page.


r/HorrorMakesUsHappy • • Aug 26 '21

This subreddit is no longer restricted.

3 Upvotes

I don't remember setting it up to restrict submissions but I guess I did. Someone just requested permission, which brought it to my attention. I've removed that setting, so anyone should be able to post now. Go forth and multiply! :P


r/HorrorMakesUsHappy • • Mar 21 '21

New excerpts up on Soundcloud: Stephen Biro, Eric Savino, Chris Woods, Bill Oberst Jr, Chris Alexander, and David Howard Thornton

Thumbnail
soundcloud.com
3 Upvotes

r/HorrorMakesUsHappy • • Jun 28 '26

The Best Horror Podcast Sampler - 1700+ episodes from 340+ different podcasts.

2 Upvotes

If you like horror-themed podcasts and are looking for a new one to check out, this should keep you busy for weeks!

I'll continue to add to this as I have time and find more podcasts to add to it, so feel free to bookmark it and share it wherever you see people asking for horror podcast recommendations!

https://open.spotify.com/playlist/5GbitHgkO2BmvlEXmjH1q1


r/HorrorMakesUsHappy • • Apr 10 '26

New one's up! Kintsugi, Raw Meat, and analog horror with Darin Read (Final Destination 5, The Conjuring 2, IT Chapters 1 & 2, Final Destination: Bloodlines, Amusement)!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/HorrorMakesUsHappy • • Jan 04 '26

Horror book and DVD giveaway!

2 Upvotes

This Fri we released our 150th interview with FX artist Howard Berger! And we've got 15 books we'll be giving away this year (about half are signed by the author), to register for the book giveaways sign up for our newsletter: https://horrormakesushappy.com/join_list.html


r/HorrorMakesUsHappy • • Nov 07 '25

Today with Richard Chizmar (Cemetery Dance, Gwendy trilogy, Boogeyman series, Memorials), alligators, candy corn, and Bigfoot's muff!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/HorrorMakesUsHappy • • Mar 28 '25

New one's Up! NoSleep, Creepypasta, drinking games, and the dangers of raising children... with Viidith22 (Voice Actor, Content Creator)!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/HorrorMakesUsHappy • • Dec 25 '24

Merry Christmas!!

2 Upvotes

That is all.

Hope you all have a good day, whether you celebrate or not.


r/HorrorMakesUsHappy • • Aug 17 '24

Tonight on Horror Makes Us Happy: aliens, fainting couches, and New Edition fan fiction with RJ Joseph (Into the Forest, The Dead Inside)!

Thumbnail
horrormakesushappy.com
2 Upvotes

r/HorrorMakesUsHappy • • Aug 03 '24

We'll be watching The Conjuring (2013) on Discord in about an hour, if anyone wants to join!

Thumbnail
discord.gg
2 Upvotes

r/HorrorMakesUsHappy • • Jul 07 '24

Out now: Love and war, and shelter from the storm with Joe R Lansdale (Bubba Ho-Tep, Hap and Leonard, and Love, Death, and Robots)!

Thumbnail
horrormakesushappy.com
2 Upvotes

r/HorrorMakesUsHappy • • Jan 06 '24

This week with Michael Allen Rose (Jurrassichrist, Boiled Americans, The Last Five Minutes of the Human Race) - video game logic, being eaten by a grue, and the wonder that is Bismarck, ND!

Thumbnail
horrormakesushappy.com
2 Upvotes

r/HorrorMakesUsHappy • • Dec 03 '23

Every Sunday we host Listen Parties where we stream an episode, hang out, & chat. This week's will be Garret Cook, and Mr. Cook might be joining us as well!

Thumbnail discord.gg
2 Upvotes

r/HorrorMakesUsHappy • • Jul 07 '23

"True horror is about ruining a specific thing, for a specific person, forever." Ariel Schulman (Paranormal Activity 3/4, Viral, Nerve) is on Horror Makes Us Happy!

Thumbnail
horrormakesushappy.com
2 Upvotes

r/HorrorMakesUsHappy • • Mar 31 '23

New one's up! Mr. Cody Goodfellow (Radiant Dawn, All-Monster Action, Shameless) has to be one of our more accomplished guests. Join us as he regales us with tales of meeting the devil, inventing Neutrogena strips, and working with John Skipp!

Thumbnail
horrormakesushappy.com
2 Upvotes

r/HorrorMakesUsHappy • • Feb 19 '23

If you're on TikTok, add us! We'll be posting longer excerpts than we can on Instagram. Also, re-recording them to use the original audio.

Thumbnail tiktok.com
2 Upvotes

r/HorrorMakesUsHappy • • Jan 29 '23

Everyone please join us @ 7pm eastern tomorrow (Sunday) for the Listen Party for HMUH S1E03: Jasmine Martinez (Bitches of Horror Youtube Channel)!

Thumbnail
discord.gg
2 Upvotes