Introduction
So I made my first batch of beer ever. I looked at a billion recipes, and decided to just try coming up with my own with random grains I impulsively bought beforehand because “they looked good” at the grain store.
Recipe
In a brewers edge mash and boil I picked up for 60 bucks at my local grain store (hell of a steal imo)
7 ibs merris otter
2 ibs cherrywood smoke malt
1 ibs of Weyermann caaramber
1 oz chocolate malt
0.5 oz cluster at 60 min
0.5 cluster at 45 min
1 oz Willamette at 10 min
1 packet of the blue S04 English ale yeast
Brew Process
Strike temp 152 for an hour with a grain basket and grain bag. I used both together because in my prior experience… making other delicious stuff… the screen on the grain basket still let particles through leading to a scorching situation.
Lifted grain basket and carefully squeezed as much liquid as I could out of the grain bag. Removed grains and brought vessel to a rolling boil around 204 degrees (I’m at a high elevation).
60 min boil - hops
I didn’t have a wort chiller at the time so I sanitized a large metal pot, transferred the boiling liquid and put it into a tub with cold water, stirring the wort and replacing the cooling water in the tub as it warmed up. This took about 2 hours.
Ferment Process
Sanitized anything and everything that the beer touched obsessively upon transfer into a 5 gallon carboy. Pitched S04 English ale yeast at 70 degrees, maintained 67-68 degree ferment for 7 days.
Day 1 - Lots of bubbles
Day 2 - Came home to what I can only describe as mount Kilauea (fermenter was too small).
Day 3- violent ferment began to stabilize and healthy yeast cap sat on top
Day 4 - yeast dropped to bottom
Day 5-7 - Diacetyl rest
I read S04 ferments quickly so I figured 7 days was fine. My initial gravity reading was 1.056, unfortunately during my excitement of brewing my very first beer, I dropped the gravity meter in the tube and shattered it.. lol I sanitized my wort pump and pulled 8oz to taste test. It was absolutely delicious! The caramel/toffee was present, it had a bitterness that was just what I was looking for. The grains shined through perfectly.
Transfer Process
Pumped c02 into pin lock five gallon keg, dropped sanitized transfer tube into bottom. Filled, did 24 hours at 40 psi. Released pressure, refilled to 10 psi.
3 days in the kegerator went by and I started noticing the grain and toffee notes going away. It became more bitter. It’s still drinkable, and still a tasty beer, just not that exciting first couple of glasses that I thought it was going to be the remainder of the 5 days in its keg (I got overly excited and consumed it quickly between myself and my wife).
The Question/s
Did I miscalculate the hops?
If so, and I want that delicious sweet and grain flavor what hops should I use next time and at what intervals in the boil?
Was it the failure to cool rapidly?
Am I some sick twisted psychopath that just enjoys the taste of semi-flat room temp beer and the carbonation and temperatures mask the grain more?