r/HomeLoans • • Jul 02 '25

Only refinance if you can drop 1%” is outdated advice

121 Upvotes

You’ll hear people say “only refinance if you can drop your rate by at least 1%.” It gets repeated a lot online, but that advice really doesn’t hold up when you do the math.

The truth is: your monthly savings depend way more on your loan size than the size of the rate drop. A small rate drop on a large loan can save you more per month than a big drop on a small loan.

Let me show you:
• Dropping 1% on a $200,000 loan (from 7% to 6%) cuts the monthly payment by about $131
• Dropping just 0.5% on a $600,000 loan (from 7% to 6.5%) cuts it by around $199

So which saves more? The 0.5% drop.

It’s all about monthly savings, not just the rate. If you plan to stay in the home long enough to recover closing costs — or you’re using a no closing cost refinance — even a small drop can be worth it.

Moral of the story: don’t focus on “how much lower” the rate is — look at the real math for your situation. And if you’re unsure, I’m happy to run the numbers for you.

Check current mortgage rates here: Reddit Mortgage Rates


r/HomeLoans • • 4d ago

Mortgage Rates Homebuyers are cringing at a 7% interest rate, and their parents can’t relate. Why it’s so hard to afford a home now

Thumbnail
finance.yahoo.com
98 Upvotes

I recently had the opportunity to share some thoughts with Moneywise for an article published on Yahoo Finance about mortgage rates and housing affordability.

One point I think gets overlooked is that a 7% mortgage today is very different from a 7% mortgage 20 or 30 years ago. Home prices have changed dramatically, and the monthly payment matters just as much as the interest rate.

Thought it was worth sharing here. Curious how everyone else is looking at affordability in today’s market.

Check mortgage rates right here on Reddit

Collin Donahue | NMLS 236801
Alliant Credit Union | NMLS 197185
Contact Me & Apply Now Link
⌂ Equal Housing Lender | Federally Insured by NCUA


r/HomeLoans • • Nov 12 '25

The math behind Trump’s 50-year mortgage idea…

91 Upvotes

So Trump’s floating this 50-year mortgage idea, and everyone’s debating whether it’s a game changer or a debt trap. Let's forget the politics for a second... here’s what the numbers actually look like.

Scenario:

  • Purchase price: $400,000

  • Down payment: 20%

  • Loan amount: $320,000

  • Interest: 6% (same for both terms just to compare apples to apples)

30-year fixed:

  • Monthly P&I: $1,918

  • Total interest: $370,682

  • Total repaid: $690,682

  • Principal Balance after 5 years: $292,473

50-year fixed:

  • Monthly P&I: $1,684

  • Total interest: $690,697

  • Total repaid: $1,010,697

  • Principal Balance after 5 years: $312,698

So yeah… payment drops about $234/month (roughly 12% lower), but you’re paying almost double the interest over the life of the loan. And after 5 years, you’ve barely chipped away at the balance compared to a 30-year.

And that’s assuming the rate stays the same... which it probably won’t. A 50-year term would almost certainly carry a higher rate (I think +1% or more).

Bottom line: It makes the monthly look better, but the long-term math is brutal. Most people sell way before year 50 anyway, so the real question is whether this helps affordability or just kicks the can down the road.

Check current mortgage rates here: Reddit Mortgage Rates


r/HomeLoans • • Aug 02 '25

Feeling Trapped in $600K ARM Loan — Payments Jumped to $5,100. What’s Our Best Path Forward?

83 Upvotes

Our situation isn’t unique, but it still feels crushing. Like many others, we left our pre-COVID mortgage rates behind — first a townhome at $955/mo, then a starter home at $1,300/mo — and now I feel like I may have destroyed my chance at financial stability and happiness with one decision: signing for our current house.

Loan Details: • Balance: $600,000 remaining • ARM at 5.75% (2.5 years left before it adjusts or we refinance/sell) • Monthly payment: $4,655 → $5,110 this year (PMI included)

The Dilemma: Every option feels bad right now: 1. Wait it out — Hope for a big drop in rates in the next 2.5 years. But rates may never even get as low as my current ARM “deal.” 2. Sell and downsize — But even buying a home $100–200K cheaper might not save much with today’s higher rates. We’d lose space and our backyard for minimal financial relief, unless we move far from family. 3. Sell and rent — Rent is insanely high in our area. We’d give up building equity entirely and just feel like we’re throwing money away.

I don’t have a crystal ball, and I honestly don’t know what the best path forward is for our family of five. Any insight, advice, or even just perspective from others who’ve been in a similar situation would be greatly appreciated.


r/HomeLoans • • Nov 09 '25

Trump’s floating a 50-year mortgage term…

75 Upvotes

President Trump posted a graphic hinting at 50-year mortgages… FHFA Director Bill Pulte mentioned it as well calling the idea a "game changer."

The overall idea: stretch terms to 50 years to cut the monthly and widen access. Reality check… today Fannie/Freddie only buy up to 30-year new loans; 40-year exists mainly for modifications, not fresh originations—so rules/investors would have to change.

Critiques of this idea: slower equity build and higher total interest… risk of propping prices vs fixing supply. Supporters say it’s optional flexibility if you plan to prepay or refi. (Both can be true depending on use.)

A simple example... at 6%: per $100k, 30-yr ~$600/mo vs 50-yr ~$525/mo… ~10-15% lower payment, much more lifetime interest.

In the overall market we see stress signals are mixed.. searches are up for mortgage help as well as interest in ARMs

Also in play… more talk (this has been discussed for YEARS) about moving Fannie/Freddie toward privatization again. Timelines are fuzzy, as is tradition.

TL;DR: 50-year terms are being discussed… not live. If it happens, it’ll lower payments a bit but trade time for interest. Use case-by-case.

I offer free, no-hassle mortgage rate quotes here: 

Check current mortgage rates here: Reddit Mortgage Rates


r/HomeLoans • • Sep 12 '25

Fed’s Rate Cut Is Coming but Mortgage Rates Already Moved

75 Upvotes

Next week The Fed’s cutting rates... but don’t expect your mortgage rate to drop because of it. Why? Markets already priced it in weeks ago.

The real trigger was weak jobs data on Aug 1 & Sept 5. That’s when bond yields (MBS, which drive mortgage rates) dropped. Since then, rates have mostly held steady.

Next week’s Fed cut is just confirmation. If you’re watching for movement, focus on 2 things:
- The Fed’s “dot plot” (shows how many more cuts they expect this year)
- The October jobs report—if it’s strong, rates could spike again like they did last year

Bottom line: mortgage rates respond to expectations, not headlines. The real action’s already happened.

Check current mortgage rates here: Reddit Mortgage Rates


r/HomeLoans • • Aug 25 '25

Everyone thinks housing prices are going to fall, but that doesn’t add up

62 Upvotes

Many online seem convinced housing is about to crash… but I don’t see it. In most desirable markets, prices are more likely to keep climbing and maybe even double over the next 5 years.

Asset prices across the board are inflating. Stocks and gold are far more liquid, so big money has already piled in. Housing is different—it’s messy, less liquid, and harder to scale. You can’t just click a button and buy or sell thousands of homes. But that doesn’t mean large players aren’t working on it. Blackstone, Invitation Homes, and pension funds are already building systems to own and manage homes in bulk.

When institutional money decides housing is an asset class, prices don’t go down. It’s not about individual buyers anymore—it’s about a flood of capital looking for a return, and homes are the next frontier.

I also don’t believe rates are falling anytime soon, but that’s a separate discussion I’ll post on later.

So while the popular view online is “just wait for the crash,” the bigger structural forces suggest the opposite.

Check current mortgage rates here: Reddit Mortgage Rates


r/HomeLoans • • Oct 04 '26

The “Marry the house, date the rate” Fallacy

52 Upvotes

I think homebuyers should be careful with common phrase uttered by realtors and lenders alike...

It sounds clever/catchy but it can easily become a sales pitch for buying a house today with the hope that you’ll refinance later down the road.

The problem is, you can sell a house. You can’t change the interest rate market into cooperating with you. None of us can.

And refinancing later is not guaranteed. Rates might not fall. You might not qualify. Your home value could change. Or the refinance simply might not save you enough money to make sense.

Buy the house because you can comfortably afford the house and payment today.

If rates fall later and refinancing makes sense, great! If not.....?

But don't buy a house you can barely afford today because someone tells you to “date the rate.”

A refinance is a possibility, not a plan.

Check current mortgage rates here: Reddit Mortgage Rates

Collin Donahue | NMLS 236801
Alliant Credit Union | NMLS 197185
Contact Me & Apply Now Link
⌂ Equal Housing Lender | Federally Insured by NCUA


r/HomeLoans • • Sep 19 '25

Mortgage Rates Jumped After the Fed Cut Rates... Here’s Why That’s Not Crazy

Post image
52 Upvotes

Saw a bunch of headlines this week saying mortgage rates dropped after the Fed cut rates. Not true. Rates actually spiked... and it’s not as weird as it sounds. 

Quick breakdown:
The Fed cut the Fed Funds Rate, which isn’t the same thing as mortgage rates. Fed rate changes only happen 8 times a year, but mortgage rates move daily (sometimes hourly( based on bond markets and economic data.

So why the spike?
Mortgage rates had already dropped before the Fed meeting because the same economic signals that led to the cut were already priced in. Once the Fed made it official, there wasn’t much left to push rates lower. In fact, they bounced higher midweek.

Also, ignore the Freddie Mac survey saying rates are down. It’s based on data from last week, before the Fed announcement. Real-time rates are now higher than they’ve been in over a week.

Bottom line:
Mortgage rates and Fed rates can move in the same direction... but not always at the same time. This week, mortgage rates moved first… and then reversed.

Check current mortgage rates here: Reddit Mortgage Rates


r/HomeLoans • • Jul 19 '25

Mortgage Rates: What Happened This Week

42 Upvotes

Markets were focused on Tuesday’s inflation report (CPI), which came in higher than last month but lower than expected. That was good news at first—mortgage rates dropped briefly. But once traders looked closer, they saw signs that tariffs might be raising prices in some areas. That made the Fed less likely to cut rates soon, and mortgage rates moved back up.

Then on Wednesday, news broke that Trump had talked about firing Fed Chair Powell. Even though he later said he wasn’t serious, the headlines caused a spike in bond market activity and pushed long-term rates higher.

By the end of the week, retail sales data showed mixed results. After adjusting for inflation, consumer spending looked weak—slightly good for rates, but not enough to change the bigger picture.

Bottom line: Rates are stuck in a higher range for now. The next big update will come in early August with the jobs report. If unemployment rises, that could finally push rates lower.

Check current mortgage rates here: Reddit Mortgage Rates


r/HomeLoans • • Nov 01 '25

Mortgage rates moved higher... after the Fed cut rates. Yes, really.

Post image
39 Upvotes

So here’s the deal... not all rates move the same way, even when the Fed makes a rate change. The Fed cut its rate this week, but mortgage rates? They went up. Why? Timing... expectations... and a little bit of drama.

First off... mortgage rates and the Fed Funds Rate aren’t twins. The Fed rate is for super short-term loans (like overnight lending to banks)... mortgages are more like 30 year loans (although they rarely last for more than ~6years). So they don’t always react the same way.

Also... mortgage rates can change daily (sometimes multiple times a day)... the Fed only moves ~8 times a year. So by the time the Fed actually cuts, mortgage rates have already priced that in... like weeks ago.

Now here’s where it got interesting... Powell’s press conference. Many people thought another cut was coming in December... but Powell basically said "meh... maybe not." That shift in tone hit the market hard. Expectations flipped... and mortgage-backed securities (MBS) took a hit. Rates jumped Wednesday afternoon and kept climbing Thursday.

The Freddie Mac’s weekly survey didn’t catch any of this... their data cut off before the spike. So if you’re seeing headlines saying rates dropped... those don't reflect what actually took place.

Big picture... this rate spike wasn’t massive, but it’s a reminder: if we want rates to really drop, we need weaker economic data. And with the government shutdown still clogging up the data flow... that’s gonna be tough.

Check current mortgage rates here: Reddit Mortgage Rates


r/HomeLoans • • Aug 01 '25

Mortgage Rates Dropped After a Messy Jobs Report

35 Upvotes

Last week, everyone was waiting for Friday’s jobs report—and it didn’t disappoint. The report showed fewer new jobs than expected, but the real surprise came from big downward revisions to past months. That made the job market look much weaker than we thought.

Why does that matter? A slower job market makes investors more likely to buy bonds, which helps push mortgage rates down. It also makes the Fed more likely to cut rates soon. Mortgage rates don’t follow the Fed rate directly, but they do react to what markets think the Fed will do.

By Friday afternoon, lenders were offering some of the best rates since early April. Some even dropped rates mid-day as markets kept improving. The average 30-year fixed rate fell about 0.125%, putting us close to the lowest levels since October 2024.

Looking ahead, the next jobs report and inflation data will be key. If the slowdown continues, rates could drop even more. If not, this dip might not last.

Check current mortgage rates here: Reddit Mortgage Rates


r/HomeLoans • • Aug 21 '26

A lot of buyers are asking: “Should I buy a house now or wait for mortgage rates to come down?”

32 Upvotes

I think there’s a better question:
What specifically are you waiting for?
If the answer is lower rates, remember that you’re probably not the only buyer waiting.
If rates come down, more buyers could enter the market. That can mean more competition, fewer seller concessions and potentially higher home prices.
That doesn’t mean you should buy now.
It also doesn’t mean you should wait.
Run both scenarios.
For example:
Buy now:
What is the payment? How much cash do you need? Can you comfortably afford it?
Wait:
What happens if the rate drops but the house costs $25,000 more? What if there are five offers instead of one? What if your rent increases another year?
Also remember that buying today doesn’t necessarily mean keeping today’s mortgage forever. If rates eventually fall enough and refinancing makes financial sense, that may be an option later—but it shouldn’t be assumed or guaranteed.
The decision should really come down to:
Can you comfortably afford the home?
Do you have enough savings after closing?
How long do you expect to live there?
Does owning solve a problem or accomplish a goal for you?
What are the potential costs of waiting?
Nobody can perfectly time mortgage rates and home prices at the same time.
I’d focus less on finding the perfect market and more on figuring out whether the numbers make sense for your situation today.


r/HomeLoans • • Oct 11 '25

Mortgage Rate Quote Megathread

26 Upvotes

New Rate Quote Thread:

Check current mortgage rates here: Reddit Mortgage Rates


r/HomeLoans • • Jul 30 '26

Can we afford this part2 [Bay Area] [1.35M]

Post image
25 Upvotes

We made a post a while ago and everyone told us to stay away from the previous loan of 1.65m, so the wife and I are looking at buying our first house. No kids yet but we're planning. Our combined income is about 320k/year in the Bay Area. No debt. The home we are looking at now is 1.35M and quite a bit further away from our office, we'll have to deal with a 40-50 minute daily commute, but we're willing to make that sacrifice. We’re going to put 20% down which should leave us some savings. Starter homes are frustratingly expensive. Were paying about 6k/month in rent now for our 2bedroom.

edit: loan details here: https://www.loan.tools/#1350000,20,5.97,30,16200,2500,150,0,202609,0


r/HomeLoans • • Sep 24 '25

Mortgage Interest Rate vs APR – What’s the Difference?

25 Upvotes

Quick breakdown for anyone confused by these two terms (and yeah, lenders throw them around like they’re the same thing—they’re not).

Interest Rate is the cost you pay each year to borrow the money. It’s just the percentage of the loan amount. Think of it as the base price.

APR (Annual Percentage Rate) includes the interest rate plus other costs—like lender fees, discount points, and closing costs. It’s the “all-in” number that gives you a better idea of what you’re actually paying over time.

Here’s the key:

  • Monthly payment is based on the interest rate, not the APR.

  • APR shows the true cost of the loan over time.

 Also—watch the gap between the two:

  • If APR and interest rate are close, the loan has low extra costs.

  • If APR is much higher than the interest rate, the loan is more expensive (fees are eating into it).

 Bottom line:

  • Interest Rate = Borrowing cost

  • APR = Borrowing cost + fees

Check current mortgage rates here: Reddit Mortgage Rates


r/HomeLoans • • 19d ago

Are these numbers insane for a first home purchase?!

Thumbnail
gallery
24 Upvotes

So, I’m self employed and had to do a conventional loan type. I do not qualify for fha. Are these number egregious or am I being extremely frugal? (There will be no seller credits given)


r/HomeLoans • • Sep 05 '25

Mortgage Rates Just Took a Dive

23 Upvotes

This week started with rates going up a bit, but things flipped fast. By Wednesday, rates were already hitting 11-month lows thanks to weaker job data. 

 

Then Friday’s jobs report came in way below expectations—only 22,000 new jobs vs. the 75,000 forecasted. That’s a big miss and shows the job market is slowing down. 

 

When job numbers are weak, investors buy bonds. That pushes bond prices up and rates down. Mortgage rates followed suit, with the biggest one-day drop in over a year. Top-tier 30-year fixed rates are now back to where they were in Fall 2024.

Check current mortgage rates here: Reddit Mortgage Rates


r/HomeLoans • • Oct 17 '25

Mortgage Rates Are Near 3-Year Lows and Here’s What’s Driving It

22 Upvotes

Last week looked pprrreettyyyy quiet until Thursday afternoon. No big economic reports, markets were calm, and the holiday and the government shutdown kept things slow. But then things took a turn… 

It started with Trump announcing a 100% tariff on China late Friday, which tanked stocks and bond yields. He walked it back later, but not before we saw some serious swings.

Then Thursday... Zions Bancorp said it lost $50M in Q3 from bad loans and Western Alliance followed with similar news. Those spooked markets, especially with some bigger Wall Street firms involved. Rates got… volatile… short-term funding markets looked unstable/confused, but broad economic signals actually helped rates drop.

Bond yields fell, and since mortgage rates follow those (mortgage backed securities), we saw rates dip too. That pushed us below the tight range we’ve been stuck in since the Fed cut rates in September. Now we’re close-ish to the lowest levels we’ve seen since late 2022.

Looking ahead, CPI data drops this week. It’s one of the very few major reports still coming out during the gov’t shutdown. It’s not as big as the jobs report, but it could still move rates. As is tradition, there’s no way to know if it’ll help or hurt until it lands… if there was I would be doing something else 

Check current mortgage rates here: Reddit Mortgage Rates


r/HomeLoans • • Sep 11 '25

Trump Signs Law to Stop Mortgage Spam Calls

21 Upvotes

Good news for homebuyers: President Trump just signed the Homebuyers Privacy Protection Act into law. Starting March 5, 2026, credit bureaus won’t be allowed to sell your info after you apply for a mortgage — unless you give clear permission. 

This means fewer calls, texts, and emails from lenders you never contacted.

The law targets “trigger leads,” which happen when your credit report gets pulled and then sold to other mortgage companies. Now, only your current lender, bank, or credit union can reach out — unless you say otherwise. 

Mortgage pros have been pushing for this change for years. It’s a win for privacy and a smoother homebuying experience. 

Check current mortgage rates here: Reddit Mortgage Rates


r/HomeLoans • • Oct 29 '25

Powell Nukes December Rate Cut Hope and Sends Mortgage Rates Higher

Post image
20 Upvotes

Fed cut rates and killed Quantitative Tightening today… no major shocker there... markets barely skipped a beat. But then Powell steps up and basically says “don’t count on December” — which is way off from what everyone thought (market had that cut priced in like it was a done deal).

Cue the fallout: Fed Funds Futures tanked, 10yr yields popped about 8bps, and MBS dropped roughly 3/8ths. Negative reprices? Still rolling in.

Lock/Float Thoughts:
This move could have legs into Thursday. Risk-averse folks? Already locked. Risk-tolerant? Might see this as the sign to lock now before things get uglier. Personally, I’m not calling risk/reward balanced until we see this momentum fizzle later in the week.

Bottom line: MBS lost ~40bps… rates just got higher.

Check current mortgage rates here: Reddit Mortgage Rates


r/HomeLoans • • Oct 21 '26

Is buying points a good idea right now?

19 Upvotes

Context:

Loan amount of $670K. Current locked in rate is 7.375%, considering paying 3 points to lower it to 6.7%. Breakeven point is about 5.5 years, this is intended to be our forever home so don't see that being a problem at this time. Leaning towards paying points to guarantee a lower rate rather than banking on rates coming back down before we hit the breakeven point. Is this solid reasoning or should we feel more certain that rates will come down to at least mid-6s in the next few years. TYIA!


r/HomeLoans • • Mar 21 '26

March flipped on mortgage rates… and it happened fast

Post image
19 Upvotes

Hi all… quick breakdown after reading through the latest rate commentary.

March really does look like a turning point for rates. We had a pretty steady run from last May through early March, then things shifted hard over the past few weeks.

Here’s the simple version.

What the old rate environment looked like:

  • Economic data was mostly stable (labor still a little shaky)

  • Inflation was cooling, slowly but steadily

  • The Fed was expected to start cutting by September

  • Other central banks were leaning the same way

  • Treasury supply wasn’t growing much (good for rates)

What changed:

  • Inflation is still too high for comfort, even before recent events

  • Energy, oil, and materials prices jumped, which fuels inflation fears

  • Labor market uncertainty is still there, just not enough to help rates

  • Central banks are no longer talking cuts… hikes are back in the conversation

  • Treasury issuance is expected to rise due to war funding and tariffs

Oil has been a big driver all month, but rates didn’t move just because oil moved. Central banks changed their tone too… and markets listened.

Powell basically said progress on key inflation areas has been disappointing. Rate hikes aren’t the base case, but they’re not off the table either. That alone pushed rates higher.

Then Europe piled on.

  • UK bond yields jumped to the highest levels since 2008

  • EU yields hit levels not seen since 2011

  • European markets depend heavily on imported energy, so the reaction was sharp

When the global bond market is under pressure, mortgage rates usually feel it… and they did.

We were near 5.99% just three weeks ago. Now top tier averages are back over 6.5%, the highest since early September 2025.

Big picture takeaway: When rate “regimes” change, they usually don’t snap back quickly. You might get a good day or even a good week, but the first real sign of improvement is boring… rates flatten out and stay there for a while.

Translation… expect some volatility, and don’t assume quick reversals just because we get a green day or two.

Check current mortgage rates here: Reddit Mortgage Rates


r/HomeLoans • • Oct 06 '26

This selling my mortgage to another company all the time is for the birds

18 Upvotes

The one house I've had for four years has sold our mortgage 4 times. Literally. We are on the fourth company.

My other mortgage which I've had for 17 years is through Wells Fargo and for the first time they sold my mortgage to some shit company. For me to get any info, I have to sign up and agree to sell my email and phone "for marketing purposes" (to get out of this agreement I have to call some number)

Screw these scumbags. I'm so sick of this.

(I'm good with the downvotes)


r/HomeLoans • • Jan 08 '26

Trump’s $200B Mortgage Bond Play.... Will It Really Push Rates Down?

18 Upvotes

Hi all … big headline today:

Trump says he wants the government to buy $200B in mortgage bonds to push rates down. The idea? Lower monthly payments and make homeownership more affordable at a time when prices have been climbing faster than incomes (for awhile)

A few quick notes:

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac would use their cash reserves for the purchase.

  • The idea is this will drive mortgage rates and payments down … but economists say it might only shave off about 0.25% to 0.5%.

  • Current 30-year rates are hovering around 6.00%, and they haven’t dipped below 6% since late 2022.

  • The bigger issue? Home inventory.... Even if rates drop a bit, the housing shortage isn’t going away.

Translation: This could help on the margins, but it’s not a silver bullet. Plus, spending those reserves adds risk if the market turns south.

What do you think … short-term relief or just a Band-Aid?

Check current mortgage rates here: Reddit Mortgage Rates