r/HogwartsGhosts • u/kemistreekat • Jun 21 '18
Meta REMINDER THAT GHOSTS ARE NOT TO INTERFERE WITH THE GAMES. ITS SAD I EVEN HAVE TO POST THIS. YOU KNOW WHO YOU ARE JERK.
edit: ooh the jerk must be awake, this post now has a downvote.
r/HogwartsGhosts • u/kemistreekat • Jun 21 '18
edit: ooh the jerk must be awake, this post now has a downvote.
r/HogwartsGhosts • u/TrajectoryAgreement • Jun 04 '20
I thought I'd make this thread so we could discuss stuff happening in the big game.
r/HogwartsGhosts • u/MacabreGoblin • May 18 '17
Forgive my thought-vomit, but I want to talk a little bit about a phenomenon that really perplexes me: silence/inactivity in Werewolves. In my opinion there are acceptable types of silence and unacceptable types of silence.
First time players. It's difficult enough to join a group of people who more or less 'know' each other; it's much harder in the context of a game of lies and deceit, where some of those players know how to read some of the other players, and you're just trying to tread water while you get a handle on the whole situation.
Players who have unexpected real-life interference that prevents them from participating at their intended capacity. Real life rears its ugly head for all of us eventually. It obviously gets priority over an internet game.
Villains who are silent in the main sub but active in the villain sub. This isn't real silence, it's strategic silence. It may not be a strategy I agree with, but that's a completely separate discussion. The issue here is blatant inactivity, and a villain who is plotting away in the villain sub obviously doesn't fit the bill.
Townies who try to lay low while they use their abilities to help the town. The introduction of the confessional in Werewolves is probably the best development that has happened in the game, because it allows townies who are active but keeping a low profile to show the facilitators that they're engaged in the game without blowing their cover.
Players who get disillusioned with one particular game and their enthusiasm and participation drops off as a result. This should happen a lot less since hosts disclose the rules and themes of the their games before players commit to play, but we're all human.
Players who know they will be too busy to play but sign up anyway. An unexpected real-life interruption is one thing - flaking aforethought is another.
Players who regularly sign up, never participate, and must be removed for inactivity. Why go to the trouble of signing up?
Repeat players who regularly participate at the bare minimum level to avoid being removed from the game. Players who always vote randomly, rarely or never comment, and are just generally not engaged in the game. We're all human and everyone is allowed a bad game - I'm talking about people for whom this is the regular approach to Werewolves.
Planning a game of Werewolves takes a lot of time and energy - and that's before the game begins. Hosting a game requires dedicated work every day for 2-3 weeks. Hosts are passionate volunteers who have worked hard and spent a lot of time creating a game experience for the players in this community. It is flat-out disrespectful to create more work for the hosts by signing up, never participating, and forcing them to remove you for inactivity. It is also disrespectful to the other players whose time you are wasting and who you are disadvantaging by robbing their team of a body or, Mods forbid, a vital role.
Doing the bare minimum to avoid being removed isn't much better, and is even more confusing to me. While there are elements of logic and puzzle solving, Werewolves is largely a game about reading people and interpreting their behavior. It's one thing that remains consistent from game to game no matter what different mechanics the hosts apply. Imagine how boring this game would be if NO ONE commented, every single game. Would you keep coming back month after month? I doubt anyone would. So why refuse to contribute comments when comments are vital to the game that you ostensibly enjoy so much?
I suppose my real question is: What do you get out of 'playing' without participating? Is it something that you couldn't get from spectating?
r/HogwartsGhosts • u/elbowsss • Mar 11 '20
I enjoyed this immensely and I'm so happy that it was voted in as a big game, because reading everyone's comments was a BLAST. While it seems like eradicating E's from your vocabulary would lead to much of the same cookie-cutter sentences, I was surprised to learn that there were many different strategies or habits that people were using to craft their messages in a way that very much held on to their unique voice. It was very interesting to see.
While I originally expected the omission of E's to cripple the town, I think that it actually ended up boosting our communication for a couple reasons.
First off, there was no real skimming of the comments. Every post required just a little extra thought, so absorbing and retaining the information in them was way easier.
Second, when people were posting game-related comments, they were attentively crafted and proofread so that meaning and intent was clear and easy to understand.
I wish I could have played for longer because I found the personal challenge of AVoid5 to be the perfect amount of thought-provoking and entertaining. I felt like it helped to temporarily expand my go-to vocabulary, and it might have made me talk a little weird in non-game-related situations, but that's okay.
I am looking forward to the merge and the wrap up post!
r/HogwartsGhosts • u/Larixon • May 24 '17
Howdy folks!
This is a totallynot plug because I've seen quite a bit of discussion about using Reddit on Mobile for the purposes of Werewolves.
I'm here to tell you there is an app you can download (if you are on Android - sorry, Apple users!) called Sync for Reddit that can give you literally everything you ever dreamed in terms of being able to use mobile Reddit for Werewolves in the best way possible.
First of all: example video!
I want to really showcase this off so that you can see what I mean and why I have zero problems spending 95% of my WW time on mobile.
First and foremost: cached comments! If you're reading the thread and then something comes up, you can leave the thread and come back to it and it will remember exactly where you were so you can continue reading. Seriously, it's a godsend. Especially for players who don't have every waking moment to read the thread likeido this is extremely helpful if you lead a busy life. It's also helpful for loading other links (including links to other phases or other comments) because you can read that link and then swipe back, and still be exactly where you were in the comments.
Secondly: you can refresh and it highlights new comments and you can EASILY jump to them. I showcased this in the video, but if you refresh and use the toolbar at the bottom, you can literally jump to new comments without having to scroll to them. And if you keep your settings the way I do (in which case, I load ALL comments from the start) you won't miss anything.
Thirdly: you can search by author of comment OR by keyword! This is super helpful. Want to see who all said your name without tagging you? Oh yeah, you bet you can search your name with the keywords and it will pop up. Maybe you're trying to find where the lynch pool is? Sure enough, you can search for that too. Looking for someone calling someone suspicious? Yep, have at it! This is really instrumental to being able to play effectively and it's super easy to use.
You can also filter it to jump you automatically to posts with images or with links.
Overall, if you're struggling with playing WW on mobile and you have an Android phone, I highly suggest checking this one out. If you want I can even post what my specific settings are so you can get mine to work like I have. :)
Sync for Reddit on the Playstore if you're interested!
Mods if you don't want this veryvery obvious plug for my fave app feel free to remove.
r/HogwartsGhosts • u/BellaTheStrange • Nov 14 '20
To any wolves I killed with my sweet beautiful delicious poison, I'm SO sorry! I tried so hard to not get you but in the end I did :'(
Playing a wolf killing role in the dark is hard guys, props to all the rest of you out there that were on your lonesome as well! I at least started out knowing some apprentice names.
r/HogwartsGhosts • u/SantaClaritaTribune • Aug 02 '20
RECENTLY DECEASED PLAYERS READ THIS FIRST!
As we get further into the game, you may find your spirit has a way to influence the living and undead, so be careful with what you reveal in this sub! You never know the impact it may have later on!
EDIT - the above warning is no longer relevant, as it had to do with the Phase 12 ghost sub event.
Hello and greetings to all of our new arrivals - spirits, ghouls, and ghosts alike. My name is u/saraberry12 and I'm your cruise director for your journey to the other side. For your own personal safety, I ask that you please keep your hands and feet inside the ride, and remain seated at all times, except when energetically standing up and cheering because something awesome and exciting just happened in the game. We are thrilled that you've chosen to take your journey with Ghost Sub Enterprises, and we hope you have a pleasant stay. Please let me know if you have any questions, but for now, sit back, relax, and enjoy watching the game!
r/HogwartsGhosts • u/bubbasaurus • Jun 14 '20
I love you /u/kemistreekat
r/HogwartsGhosts • u/Nox_Arcana • Oct 16 '18
First, we’d like to thank everyone for reaching out and offering their support. We’re so thankful to be in a community that is so tight-knit and caring. We are not the first hosts this has happened to, yet the community continues to show time and time again that we will not let the toxic actions of a few people spoil what we have built. We, as a community, are much stronger than that. The permamods may further address the specific situation at a later time, but steps will continue to be taken to ensure the integrity of our games. We just wanted to thank each and every one of you, newbie or veteran, for making this group of subreddits a family.
In the spirit of this community, we will not be letting one person ruin this game. We will rewind the game back one phase (so any roles that died in the past phase will return to the game) and re-assign the roles in this 13 player mini game to decide the fate of Holma. All players from the original game (with one exception) will have this game as a win on their records. This mini game is just for fun and to provide resolution to the story of nightmares preying on Holma.
While currently living players will be given priority for the sign ups, players who died earlier in Game B and players from Game A will be allowed to sign up. We welcome sign ups from all players, though we want to remind everyone that this mini game will only be able to accept 13 players total. We’ll have the sign ups open until regular phase close time (11 pm EST) over at /r/HogwartsWerewolvesB, link here. Comments about this post can be made here, but comments on the mini game should be posted on the post in /r/HogwartsWerewolvesB.
Thank you all for your continued support and hugs,
funkimon, Penultima, and spludgiexx
r/HogwartsGhosts • u/qngff • Jul 13 '18
This game has been an unpleasant experience for me. I started off having so much fun but it all came crashing down when I was revealed by the mods. I was playing fine. Nobody except Xoomps was suspecting me of anything and I was thoroughly enjoying my secret role. Then I was revealed. Let me just post what I was going to originally.
I’m a standard arsonist. The 50% above below with Flutie alive was true. I just had four chances to expel a total of 7 people. Literally anyone.
I was really enjoying this game but it just stopped being fun after the mod error. I was backed into a corner and couldn’t go for any other planned lies like only wanting Buffy dead or something.
I was just going to wait until I could definitely get 7 people but town and especially Xoomps weren’t willing to work with me. It was so incredibly disheartening to see people wanting to instalynch me on a mod error when 1. I’m neutral not evil and could work with town and 2. I wasn’t on really anybody’s radar. Especially after how well the community conducted itself during last month’s game.
Coming here and reading everyone calling out town for wanting me dead was so heartwarming. I nearly cried reading all of it. There are good people here. <3
I was about to post that when I got an error saying I couldn’t post in this subreddit. I was confused so I copied down my message and refreshed the page to see that I’d been banned from commenting and posting here for posting a goodbye message with words. I hadn’t seen the message about only SHH and !!! being allowed even for goodbyes. Even if I had I fail to see why I should be restricted to a GIF after all I’ve dealt with this game. From a mod error revealing and ruining my game to the town killing my experience by wanting to lynch me anyways and the fact that it required literal begging to stay alive I feel like I should be allowed an actual sentence.
All of this in combination has soured me on this game as a whole. It started off so well, and there are some good ideas, (this phases theme not being one of them) but all the problems with who did and didn’t die and messed up PMs have really turned what could’ve been great into something that I will look back upon with poor memories of.
I’m very displeased with being banned from commenting and the large amount of errors the players have had to deal with. I do hope that the hosts read this and are more careful in the future with PMs and making sure that everything is correct. I get that mistakes happen, I’ve hosted before. I’ve made mistakes. I do thank the hosts for being gracious with me in PMs on the day of my reveal, but the fact remains that they revealed me. Not the players and not myself. I hope for the players that the game can be error free through the end because I don’t want them to deal with what I dealt with.
And I’m still pissed about being banned from commenting for an hour. The restrictions being applied to ghosts are unnecessary and made me feel that my goodbye was meaningless. I know that there is to be no Game related comment, but other ghosts were able to type out full sentences. We are allowed a goodbye comment and since I have things to say to Town, I feel disrespected and ignored because they felt that I should be forced to go by the phase’s theme despite being dead.
There’ve been Games I’ve played that I wasn’t a fan of, but never before have I felt so disheartened and personally kicked in by a game. I’ve never thought after a game that I might not want to play again next month, but now that’s something I’m considering. And that’s nothing against next month’s hosts. It’s just that I really really have not enjoyed this month’s experience.
And going out with a whimper rather than a bang just furthered that. I never even got the chance to set off an expulsion. That’s on the hosts. I had my strategy laid out in confessionals and the error forced me to change it. I couldn’t play how I wanted to, and that’s the biggest issue. I’ll take some time to think it over, but I might miss playing in August.
If you took the time to read this whole thing, not just skim but fully read, thank you.
r/HogwartsGhosts • u/Chefjones • Nov 17 '20
Normally I have more to say when I die, but yeah here I am. Its been a long time since I've gone out like this. Actually I think this may be my first time withdrawing. I guess I can supply my full investigation list, but the only relevant bits are that stock didn't move N3 and em killed N6, which is already known.
r/HogwartsGhosts • u/Milomi10 • Jun 14 '20
This is my first game and since I claimed my stats to be low which they are, people thought I'm a cheater. Then kemistreetkat pulled some weird stuff and got himself nominated so she was immune to the lynch. And she had 19 votes. The few of us who had only 1 vote had tied so all of us were banned. And I am an ATHLETE. Edit: WE WERE ALL ATHLETES Also, I'm Milomi, and it is nice to meet you! :)
r/HogwartsGhosts • u/saraberry12 • May 11 '20
Elbowsss made a Zero Escape Hype Thread last game and it was lots of fun to participate in while we watched the game play out, so I figured I'd make one for this month, if anyone want to discuss!
editing to add: spoilers are present, read at your own risk!
r/HogwartsGhosts • u/elbowsss • Apr 14 '20
Townies on a roll! Five reapers in a row! Get hype, guys! This game is 🔥🔥🔥
r/HogwartsGhosts • u/elbowsss • Jun 17 '19
I just wrapped up my game, so I wanted to give you all an update on how it went! (posted with permission from the ongoing game's hosts)
The first three phases
I was nearly voted out every single day, sometimes surviving by a vote being swapped within the last 30 seconds of the phase. This was mainly due to my tunnel-vision on a player called Dan. He was shady as fuck. When discussing my fate, there were a couple conversations along the lines of, "I think this is just how elbowsss plays?" I told them that you guys often voted me out for the same reason, and so I kept skating by.
The third night and fourth day
I had a one-time use seer ability, only available on the third night. I managed to live long enough to use it, AND I found a wolf with it!
We (the town) were being annihilated by the wolves, but they believed my claim (mostly). I led the town to lynch the wolf - our first wolf! It was very exciting. Fabulous day!
The very next phase
I then immediately went after Dan again. He looked soooo guilty after defending the known wolf the previous day. I was so excited to finally have an excuse for everyone to vote for him, and so I led the town to lynch him! I was so confident that I pushed us to end the phase early (something that can be done by majority vote). It was glorious! Dan was finally dead! Go me, I was leading the town to victory!!! Gotta make my HWW friends proud!
But oh yeah, he also ended up being a townie, and I had fallen right into a trap set by the living wolves.
That move immediately lost us the game. 😂
Whoops.
Anyway, thanks so much for the vote of confidence, guys! The people I played with were very talented. I felt a little out of my league, so I just concentrated on having fun, and fun was had! Multiple times I found myself thinking, "I should tell this person about our sub in case they want to come play with us! ....Oh yeah, they came from their own community."
We are currently voting on the best overall player to see who will advance to the next round, and that will certainly not be me. There is a small chance that I'll grab a wildcard spot, but it's a very small chance, as I would generously place myself mid-tier in that game. More than likely, HWW's representation in this championship will be coming to an end. There's always next year though!
Also one of the players made this with some quotes from the game. As you might be able to guess, I'm on the upper right.
r/HogwartsGhosts • u/bubasaurus • Nov 19 '17
Alright, y’all. Come on a wild ride with me.
Before I start this, I want to be clear that while I am being harsh on several players and on the mods I would like everyone to keep an open mind. This is only one side of what happened and everyone should listen to all sides before making judgements.
Hear Ye Hear Ye! Welcome to the heart of Scotland ruled by Queen Mary. Long live the Queen! You are a Clansman which means you can do "The Clansmen would die for their Queen. Each night they will vote together to take one person hostage. During this night, the person may not make any comments. ". You practice the religion of Protestantism. In order to win the game your Queen must have the most loyal subjects at the end of the game. Your passcode is bag pipes and will need to be used for all forms. Please confirm you are playing by responding to this message. Long live the Queen!
_
Long live my and no one else's Queen!
_
Confirmed.
The game starts. Woooooo, private sub! We’re one big happy family. Someone isn’t here despite being tagged a bunch and commenting in the main sub!? Oh… They never got added to the sub. Whoops. But the mods have apologized and he’s here now! But… something still isn’t right. Our Queen was here yesterday, but no one was killed despite him asking which lady to send out and coordinating with us? And now we’re tagging him repeatedly… And he isn’t coming back… Wait, we revealed alts to each other yesterday. He’s the one who dropped from last game because he didn’t like his role?!? Seriously!?! WHERE THE HECK IS HE? He comes back for a second… And says literally one word and poofs again. Mods, can we please advocate for his death so that we can have a lady in charge who actually gives a rip? Is that against our role? Oh, whew. The mods are deciding to remove him, as he’s apparently submitted his kill for himself after refusing to respond to a ridiculous amount of pings and panicked summons. We get to pick someone to be promoted to Queen and they can take over effective immediately for this second kill… Let’s pick Pen. She’s a vet without a history of inactivity and clearly inactivity (and malicious intent) have been very unkind to our sub. We’ll be okay with missing our first kill. We’ll be okay with having one less lady than everyone else. We’ll just… we’ll be okay. It will all work out in the end.
Several days pass. Things are on the up and up. We’re killing and silencing and investigating. Good thing we got rid of that one player!
Something visited you this evening. It spoke to your heart. You finally see clearly now. You have become Pagan. You are now aligned with the Pagans.
_
Does this change my win condition? Is it possible for my win condition to change again?
_
You would now win if the Pagans win. There is not a chance for this to change.
_
Am [spelling fixed from original] I still in the Scotland sub?
_
your role and country have not changed.
_
Do I still want to help Scotland, or is that now irrelevant? Additionally, can I win if I'm dead?
_
¯\ (ツ)/¯
_
Did you know your shrugging guy is missing half of his arms?
_
¯\ __(ツ)/¯
_
LOL. Now one arm is extra long and the other is still missing the top half but I appreciate the effort.
Okay… So… At the beginning of the game, we discussed that we might have to give up our queen at some point. Are we actually willing to do that? Not me, said a courtmember. Well, when we discussed it the other day people said it was fine… Crickets Well then. I guess I have to do this myself!
Hey, main sub. Take out Penultima. Kthxbai.
Sorry private sub. Don’t hate me please.
We hate you.
:(
Let’s kill you and be done with it!
Nope. I’d still be able to watch you from the ghost sub and out whatever I wanted for Anne Boleyn to see.
That’s totally not fair! Mods!
You can’t do that. - Mods
That makes absolutely no sense, but fine. I am a rule follower. If that’s how you want to be about it I can deal. Glad you’re stepping in to clarify.
An actual quote from a comment I reported for being a personal attack:
I don’t care that you did it, but I do care that you’re making excuses for yourself. It’s okay, you can embrace being selfish.
Some more things that were said about the general back and forth banter:
If only we weren’t concerned about comment scores…
_
Please. I want all of your real identities so I can guild you, lol.
_
I totally forgot who your main was and looked it up because I wanted to remember who was being so excellently sassy.
Hellooooo! Mods! Save me! This is too much.
Nope not right now.
^ 0 v I’m done with this sub. This is too much vitriol and I am done commenting here. See you on the other side.
(Thanks for the immediate downvote whomever did it. It was real mature.)
Hey! I still have the ability to silence. One of these people is planning on using their Pagan counts… Can’t silence them. One of them has a chance of being dead next phase as an outed queen… Let’s silence the 3rd.
Wait, not so fast…
The action you've submitted could be considered as actively working against your team and violation of rule 3. We'd like to give you another chance to submit an action and remind you that you are still of Scotland in this game. Your religion has changed, and part of your win condition, but that doesn't alter your role or team.
_
Okay. Thanks for the heads up. I was not aware I was still aligned with Scotland's win condition, as when I was asked I was not answered. Could you please clarify what you mean by part of my win condition? What is the other part? I seriously feel lost here. If it is still in my Role's best interest to work with Scotland, I am seriously angry for not getting more than a shrug in response when I asked in the first place. Putting me in this position sucks.
_
you will win with the pagans if they win. you can also win with your queen if she had he most supporter. regardless of your religion you must support. Queen.
sorry mobile fucked me. it should say. “regardless of your religion you must support a queen.”
_
Why the fuck would you not tell me that in the first place!? I would have played this very differently. I specifically asked if I still wanted to help Scotland and was only given a shrug. That is deceptively misleading.
_
we are not going to dictate how you play this game. so we could not answer that question.
_
That's a bullshit answer.
_
your country and role did not change which you were specifically told.
There are mechanics at play that no one is aware of and if we were to have clarified any more than we did, it would have given you more insight into the game than anyone else has been given.
You were explicitly told that your religion changed to pagan, but your country and your role have not changed. Looking at the win conditions, Queens win with the most loyal subjects for herself and her supporters. You are still a subject of Queen Mary and Scotland. This win condition did not change when your religion changed. To reiterate, the pagan win condition is to have all three Queens dead by the end of the game. We cannot direct you one way or another, it is up to you how you play from the point of your conversion onward.
We understand your frustration. We cannot please everyone, especially when conversions come into play - there are very loud mixed feelings when it comes to conversion roles. However, this does not give you the excuse to be rude to the mods. You were given as much information as we could give you. That's fine if you don't agree with it, but you also have to realize that the mods are human and this is ultimately a game and it does not give you the right to speak to anyone the way you have been speaking to the mods.
_
I'm sorry for my swearing. I said what I have said in anger.
Regardless, I do not think it is fair to rebuke me for being rude when I have made it clear in comments, in confessionals, and in comment reports that I am beginning to feel personally attacked by comments of other players and, to my knowledge, nothing has been done about this. No one has the right to talk to me, another human being, the way you are allowing people to talk to me and about me in your game while giving each other pats on the back and joking about guilding each other. I think if that was the case you'd want them to stop talking for a phase, too.
Everything about this absolutely sucks and I feel very deceived by the way you chose to answer my questions. I feel it directly shaped my game play and directly informed my actions. By not answering my question you left it to my discretion to decide if I had a win condition with Scotland. Turning around and telling me I'm breaking rule 3 because I was trying to silence a member of the Scottish court calls into question my integrity, as if I were purposefully going against my role. I was not - I was only doing what I thought would be best for my role with the information I was given by you.
I felt bad enough when told earlier I was discussing, not even actively, breaking other rules which I still don't see as what I was discussing. I've never played a game with a medium role before but I do not see how revealing information I was privy to in the ghost sub would be considered communicating with living players or morally gray. Regardless, someone else thought it was morally gray, and so my instinct was immediately to ask for clarification. I try my utmost to play and live with integrity.
_
There’s a lot going on behind the scenes which is making this a very weird situation. We have seen the discussions in the Scottish sub. We are going to post a comment to the Scottish sub about discussions verging on making things personal. We hope this alleviates some of what you are feeling.
We wish we could go into more detail, but it would require divulging information given in confessionals.
A lot of this game involves an incredible amount of variables and a lot of luck. We are supplying you with as much information as we possibly can. We have in no way deceived you intentionally, maliciously, or negligently. It sounds like we all agree that integrity is a value we all hold in very high regard, so I hope any part of this conversation has not gotten personal in any way.
We are not trying to confuse or mislead you. We are trying to maintain order as much as humanly possible without interfering with the game. In games with 75 people, we cannot please everyone. We are sorry if this tarnishes this or future games for you, as this was not our intent. We are doing the best we can and our goal is always trying to give all players a great game.
_
Confessionals or no confessionals, I do not understand how this could make what went on in the Scottish sub yesterday okay. I feel the comment posted is too little too late. It does not address anyone specifically. It is well after the fact. No one has responded to it or discussed it in the 5 hours after it went up. It doesn't make me feel better at all. Regardless, I appreciate that you are doing something rather than nothing.
This has tarnished this game for me, greatly so, although I will try to not let it tarnish future games. Regardless if that was the intention or not, I feel directly mislead about my role and what my intentions should be. If you cannot tell me if, from the perspective of my role, that I still have a stake in the Scottish victory (and I do not believe that telling me I am still Scottish is the same thing, as there had been lots of discussion on if the country of pagans meant anything and if they could win with their country or not), I do not see how I am breaking rule 3 for attempting to merely silence one of them. I am glad this came up before I seriously considered outing them all, as I would not have felt that went entirely outside of the bounds of my role. I am struggling now how or if I should even approach talking to the Scottish sub. How or if I should approach talking in the main sub. I am not going to, as I do not want to do that to my fellow players, but I really just want to quit.
Cut to Scottish Sub:
ATTENTION SCOTTISH SUB:
Conversation in the last phase was verging on getting personal. This is a warning to make sure to keep all conversation civil. We have to remember that this is ultimately a game and there are real people playing.
It is our goal as mods that we interfere as little as possible. However, we will step in if things get too out of hand.
_
Last night I attempted to silence one of you. I was fed up with what felt to me like incredibly hurtful and vitriolic [spelling fixed from original] comments from some of you, including but not limited to comments directed at each other talking about how great what you were saying was and comments directed at me, and I did not feel like it was outside of the bounds of my role given what I had been told by the mods. I was sent a message that my action violated Rule 3, and resubmitted with the silence targets I received from you all. After some clarification I now believe I can win with either the Pagans and/or the Scottish. I am still not sure if that applies as an and or an or.
While the mods insist they were not being intentionally misleading I feel misled. I have been entirely honest with you all yesterday, although I now recognize that I apparently misunderstood the intentions of my role. I would not have approached the game the way I did if I had not truly believed that my win condition had not been added to but rather changed in my conversion. This was not made clear to me until a PM that I received after I fell asleep last night.
Consider your sub to be back to you. I am not planning on outing any of you. I really don't want to have any part of this game. I feel like my actions have been awful, if I am truly still a member of the Scottish court to the level that even silencing one of you could be seen as working directly against my role. Please know that I did not intend to hurt anyone and what I did was out of a misunderstanding of my role and not out of a place of malice. I am truly sorry for any damage that I caused while I was under this false impression.
I guess I am just going to continue to submit votes and actions, as dropping from inactivity or quitting is not my style and something I view as a last resort. I do not want to penalize my team(s) any more than I already have. Regardless, I do not intend to be an active participant in this game any longer. If you all have a specific target you want me to silence please tag me when you decide so I know what to submit. If there is a lynch vote you'd like me to submit you can tag me as well.
I have not yet decided how or if I should say this to the main sub. Saying it as clearly and honestly as I have posted here is obviously not going to be conducive to staying alive and as a subject of Scotland I apparently want to do that. So.
I am tired. I did not sleep well. I feel my integrity has been called into question, which is something I value greatly. I am also just not invested anymore. And I feel like the relationship with most of you has been sabatoged in both directions, at least for this game. I truly am sorry. Please be gentle, as I cannot handle more vitriol [spelling fixed from original] right now.
What’s this? Another PM.
I don’t know how much more we can say to you without revealing mechanics of the game. We are sorry the game has been tarnished because of this.
I do want to make this very clear - we are not nor have ever questioned your integrity during this game. We can only clarify as much as we can without giving you information that is not readily available to everyone else. We told you specifically that your country affiliation did not change. The only thing that changed was your religion. We literally cannot give you any more information than that. We also hold integrity in the highest regard and by you saying that we intentionally misled you, even after we have told you multiple times that is not the case, you are calling our integrity into question. Please afford us the same respect that we are affording you.
We did not address anyone in particular in the message to the Scottish sub because we don’t want things more divisive than they are or appear to be now. You don’t know what we have done behind the scenes, so please do not make assumptions. We cannot help that no discussion was made after our comment as we cannot control what the other players are thinking. You also have to take into consideration that we each have lives and we are not spending each second of each day on these subs. We are trying our very best to manage 75 players in this game with multiple subreddits.
As for your action trying to silence a Scottish teammate, we sent you a message to change it because we wanted you to know it went against your win condition as a Scot. We didn’t give you an inactivity strike or boot you from the game. We wanted to use this as an opportunity to clarify your specific win condition(s). This was also not meant to question your integrity - it was purely a warning and we allowed you to change it. We are trying to address a very weird situation as best as humanly possible. We stand firm in our assertion that your integrity has not been questioned by the mods and that we have also not intentionally misled you in any way, shape, or form. We are so very sorry you feel like you want to quit, but we respect the fact that you are continuing to play because quitting is not in your style. We are sorry it has come to this point and we are trying to minimize the damage as much as possible without interfering in the game more than necessary. There are so many things we wish we could tell you now to help alleviate some of what you are feeling, but our hands are tied by the mechanics of the game, both known and unknown.
_
Saying that I feel misled and saying you misled me intentionally are not the same. I do not think you all misled me intentionally, but I do believe I was misled.
I respect that you all have lives. I still do not think the response was swift enough. We will have to agree to disagree.
I look forward to seeing more information after the game, but I do not think it will overly change my opinion.
Seeing more information now that the game has ended and I am in the ghost sub, my opinion is actually changed… But not in the direction the mods were hoping. If my win condition was to pick whomever I wanted as my Queen, why would I have to be loyal to Queen Mary in game? If another private sub member was allowed to make a lady kill themselves (albeit on accident), why would they not receive the same warning? Why would you not just tell me that I still had stake in the Scottish victory when I asked? Maybe everything will suddenly become clear when the wrap-up goes up in a few hours, but I am not holding my breath.
The mods never assumed my silence could be strategic. While I was not using it for the Scottish sub, I was using it to get a break from the vitriol that the mods did not (at the time) seem to care about stemming, I definitely could have made the argument that the player I silenced was getting too adamant in the main sub about the Scottish cause and was going to get herself killed. I definitely could have made the argument that it was in my and Scotland’s best interest to silence her. But I didn’t get that chance. I did choose her strategically. I didn’t want to silence the person who could get information about how many Pagans there were, because I still wanted that information. I didn’t want to silence the queen, as I held out a small sliver of hope that she would be dead the next day.
Quite frankly I think it is despicable that the sidebar rules were not enforced until after the fact. Can we start a petition to get not enforcing sidebar rules to be reason for a facilitator strike? Confessionals or no confessionals, if you’re acting like a bully and the other person doesn’t know you’re acting, you’re being a bully. This should not be allowed to happen in any game. It should be addressed swiftly and directly. Someone acting like a bully needs to be called out for it or they can do mental gymnastics to justify why the general statements aren’t really about them. I believe I am owed some real, genuine, 3 part apologies from many of the people involved who have sort of claimed ownership but have not provided restitution, and some who haven’t taken ownership at all. Sidenote - if in the same sentence as your fauxpology you asked me to do something for you, it doesn’t count.
It seems even the people who were so hard on me to begin with agreed that this was too far:
I didn’t know what you meant by rule 3 warning, so I checked her comment history. I hadn’t seen her post here yesterday before. This mechanic really made me want to stay away from this subreddit. The whole conversion mechanic turned this place toxic - certainly i was a part of that, but I don’t see how the mods didn’t foresee that this would be the result of turning a player against their team and then forcing them all to stay in a subreddit together. After reading what buba had to say...ugh. This is even worse. It’s hypocritical to let her out our queen to the other queens but then say that silencing one of us is breaking rule 3.
Anyway. I agree, tag her for the silence. I hope I’m the one she tried to silence, because I’m inclined to oblige her.
_
Agreed. I like the idea of this mechanic in theory because it really flips the game on its head, but in practice, it has been awful, and that's even with me eliminating as much of my bias as possible. If this had happened to the french or the english I would feel horrible for them. Even knowing that I don't know how this game is structured, this puts the converted player in a really terrible position, essentially hamstringing them. I think I understand the way the facilitators are thinking: As a pagan buba is perfectly within her right to out the identity of a queen that is known to her, but she's not allowed to silence any of us because that ability comes from being Scottish, not pagan. If that's the case, it's a very thin line to force her to walk, and raises a bunch of issues I'm not going to outline here while the game is still ongoing, but it's incredibly unfair to the player in that position.
I'm trying to keep an open mind until the end of the game when we will know what the facilitators had envisioned, but I don't know how they can honestly say they couldn't anticipate this reaction from any of the countries. In a game in which tensions and paranoia have been increasing steadily over the last several months, they had to know that this would not go over well. I'm glad that my schedule prevents me from playing for the next few months because this has really turned me off. I like cool game mechanics, but sometimes even when you have what you think would be a really great idea, you have to toss it because of how it will play out.
Regardless, I'm here, and I'll play until I'm killed off. And I doubt you're the one she tried to silence, lol. I think I probably got that honor.
So then you all saw went on in the main sub afterwards. Besides some downvote manipulation and some awkwardness, the private sub was generally okay after that. Q - I am especially sorry for how heavily I reacted to your comment in the main sub. After everything that went on this game when I read your comment I saw red and I went after you way too hard. I was definitely out of line.
I am going to stick around for a while to respond to comments, and then I am going to logout of this account. I can’t wait to be rid of it off my phone and from my life. I’ve found that I don’t like the person I become when I am backed into a corner. I think I have apologized to everyone I snapped or cussed at, but if I missed you please know that I am deeply sorry and it is not my usual nature. I have dropped more F bombs in this one game on this account that I think I have in the entire history of my main account. I definitely need to be introspective and have some amends to make as well.
Mods, I hope you can read this as an honest appraisal and me being as impartial as possible. I do not mean it as an attack and I recognize that you all poured lots of time and your hearts into this game. It wasn’t my cup of tea, but all games can’t be everyone’s cup of tea. Before this game I really respected all of you as players and as people and I hope that we can move forward without hard feelings. I don’t want this in any way to change our relationship. Afterall… You all were on my tribe in the very first game I played of Hogwarts Werewolves! I hope we can all move forward and let these things go.
With love,
Not actually Bubbasaurus
Editing to add a PS:
A very heartfelt thank you to the many people who messaged me or tagged me at some point throughout the last week and a half to check in and make sure I was okay. I have learned that, for the most part, this community is awesome and full of some loving people. I am grateful for all of you and glad to be a part of it.
r/HogwartsGhosts • u/elbowsss • May 23 '17
We have the comment scores hidden, but mods can still see the scores. We know what you are doing. Players can still see their own scores. And they notice when it fluctuates. They can tell when they are pushed to the bottom of the page. They can tell when their score goes from a 10 to a 3.
Ghosts should have NO AFFECT ON THE LIVING PLAYERS (unless stated specifically otherwise by the facilitators).
I understand that it is frustrating when the living players are not working in the best interest of your team, but they are doing the best they can. You are here in the ghost sub so that you can discuss it with the other dead players. That is the extent of your role as a ghost.
As facilitators, we should not be forced to downvote the upvoted and upvote the downvoted in order to undo the rankings you have created.
At this moment, a living player has noticed your interference. They made a confession about how it put them in an awkward position. They didn't know how to act because they felt like they had outside information and as though it was unwanted cheating.
Please keep this in mind for future games.
r/HogwartsGhosts • u/CantaloupeCommune • May 19 '20
Alright ghosts, ghouls, and Melon Lovers! Let's hear your thoughts! Person who gets the closest to correct end results will get a shout out in the wrap up post!
Which team do you think will win, Cults or FBI?
what Phase do you think the game will end on?
(if you don't already know) who do you think the remaining wolves are and which do think will make it to the end?!
r/HogwartsGhosts • u/Rysler • Feb 14 '20
Disclaimer: This song may or may not accurately reflect what actually happened. PS: Links included for historical accuracy!
[Intro]
Oh, no
Oh no no no no no
Oh no no no no no
[Verse 1]
Looks like you did it again
You fractured the vote, you misled the train, oh oompsie
It might seem like a breeze
But it doesn’t mean we should be at ease
[Bridge]
‘Cause to fool all our Townies
That is just so typically you, ooh oompsie oompsie
[Chorus]
Oomps! You did it again
You played with our brains
You’ve mastered the game
Oh oompsie, oompsie
Oomps, we thought this was clear
That there’s nothing to fear
[Verse 2]
You see our problem is this, we’re voting away
Hoping that tie votes, they do not exist
We smile, counting the poll
Never thinking our plan, could have any holes
[Bridge]
That is just so typically you, oh oompsie
[Chorus]
Oomps! You did it again
You brought on the pain
This Town is aflame
Oh oompsie oompsie
[Interlude]
Oh yeah, yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah
Oh yeah, yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah
[Chorus]
Oomps, you did it again to this Town
Pulled off crazy tricks, oh oompsie
Oomps, you (oomps you) say that you’re not in a clique
Oomps, you did it again
That play was insane
Oh oompsie, oompsie
And left mystified
Oomps, you did it again
You hijacked the train
Oh oompsie, oompsie
r/HogwartsGhosts • u/[deleted] • Jan 09 '20
That hurt. Wish I’d known how the game works better.
r/HogwartsGhosts • u/ZeroTheStoryteller • Jun 16 '19
Hey all, just a notice to let you know I'm being physically care for!
r/HogwartsGhosts • u/MacabreGoblin • Jun 04 '17
So basically, I was Princess Leia Organa.
Phase 1 I investigated /u/kingjaime_, and was told that he is either Darth Vader, the Surgical Droid, or Master Yoda.
Phase 2 I investigated /u/kingjaime_ AGAIN, because I wanted to see if the 2 false roles were randomly generated or if they would be the same every time. Since one of the possible roles was Darth Vader, I thought it was worth it to potentially waste one night of investigation if there was a possibility that the false roles were randomized and, therefore, I might be able to get his exact role by investigating twice in a role.
They're not randomized. I got the same results.
And then I died.
RIP me.
r/HogwartsGhosts • u/[deleted] • May 22 '17
This is looking like the town's 4th (!!!) loss of 2017, 5th if you count Turtle and Bear games as separate. Yet, this stands out as more painful than the other town losses to me. Jillie is in the FINAL THREE and has not had to claim a role all game. And I wouldn't be surprised if she doesn't have to claim one this phase either. Pretty embarrassing that the town is probably going to blow a 9-1 lead.
Why would they lynch Kabubum? It was IMPOSSIBLE for him to the the DB killing role based on Pizza's investigations. I am angry.
r/HogwartsGhosts • u/Moostronus • Jan 15 '17
And that tribe is Ogoden. There are five people left from Ogoden, and three of them are villains. This will have no bearing on the final results, of course, but I thought it was a cool little factoid to share with all y'all.
HOORAY FOR OGODEN! <3