r/HistoryofIdeas • u/wwsvent88 • Jan 27 '15
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/Mynameis__--__ • Apr 07 '18
Video Jordan Peterson Doesn't Understand Marxism
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/anthonycaulkinsmusic • Aug 21 '24
Is Judith Butler's project in gender deconstruction ultimately revolutionary?
In our podcast this week, we were discussing the final section of Judith Butler's book, Gender Trouble. During the talk a question came up regarding whether Butler's project is essentially revolutionary, in it's deconstruction of gender discourse down to the grammatical level of subject/object - or if the project has more to do with building upon the continuity of human change (building on rather than destroying).
My take is that it is ultimately revolutionary in that it proposes a radical deconstruction of all understandings of sex, gender, and sexuality - positing societal taboos as generative of them.
My co-host and guest had some thoughts and disagreements on the matter though.
What do you all think?
For a little context - here is a passage from the end of the book:
The deconstruction of identity is not the deconstruction of politics; rather, it establishes as political the very terms through which identity is articulated. This kind of critique brings into question the foundationalist frame in which feminism as an identity politics has been articulated. The internal paradox of this foundationalism is that it presumes, fixes, and constrains the very “subjects” that it hopes to rep- resent and liberate. The task here is not to celebrate each and every new possibility qua possibility, but to redescribe those possibilities that already exist, but which exist within cultural domains designated as culturally unintelligible and impossible. If identities were no longer fixed as the premises of a political syllogism, and politics no longer understood as a set of practices derived from the alleged interests that belong to a set of ready-made subjects, a new configuration of politics would surely emerge from the ruins of the old. Cultural configurations of sex and gender might then proliferate or, rather, their present proliferation might then become articulable within the discourses that establish intelligible cultural life, confounding the very binarism of sex, and exposing its fundamental unnaturalness. What other local strategies for engaging the “unnatural” might lead to the denaturalization of gender as such?
If you're interested, here are links to the full episode:
Apple - https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/pdamx-26-3-consensual-categorization-w-mr-tee/id1691736489?i=1000666069040
Youtube - https://youtu.be/2sZmbo0xsOs?si=MljVKTM8yjHRrE2w
Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/episode/33WlTmatuJtpZ43vmDNLcK?si=bb7fefd742ed4f61
(Note: I am aware that this is promotional, but I do encourage engagement with the topic over just listening to the podcast.)
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/phileconomicus • Feb 19 '13
"A World Without Jews: An exhilarating new intellectual history argues that anti-Judaism is at the heart of Western culture"
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/kazarule • Apr 22 '23
Video Was U.S. Slavery Different? Responding to Candace Owens & Ben Shapiro
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/American-Dreaming • Mar 21 '22
META Meta-conservatism: The Last Hope for the Right
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/brandon-is-on-reddit • Mar 11 '19
Leave John Locke in the Dustbin of History
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/2br-2b • Mar 06 '22
Discussion A blog post I wrote applying Plato's logic from the Republic to virtual reality. I conclude that Plato would be against VR as it is "very far removed from the truth."
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/[deleted] • Oct 29 '19
Review Why the liberal West is a Christian creation
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/smnokey • Mar 24 '13
History of upboats in meatspace *applause*
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/michaelconfoy • Jun 09 '14
Americans Can't Even Stomach An Apology For Slavery, Much Less Reparations
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/Mynameis__--__ • Sep 02 '18
Video Decolonizing the History of Philosophy
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/sweaty_cunt67 • Mar 22 '17
Murray Rothbard: An Exceptional American
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/CJAXMURRAY • Apr 21 '22
Video Did you know Thomas Paine is the only Founding Father not buried in the United States? Check out why on my new episode!
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/skalloworti • Jun 10 '14
The State of Capitalism: The Nation's Demise is Greatly Exaggerated
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/Bereder • Jun 30 '13
How Jean-Paul Sartre's Existential Angst Got the Better of Him
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/anzenko • Jul 31 '22
Why we should stop defending the past tradition of wearing corsets
While i have nothing against the aesthetic value of corsets, wear them myself and support Vivienne Westwood's contribution to the emergence of the corset-trend, I still can't come to terms with the recent trend of justifying the culture of wearing corsets as a primary layer of clothing throughout the history. I have studied history of fashion throughout my education and finished a diploma on the late corset of 1900. Here are some things I came upon my study.
Corsets as a patriarchal issue
Corsets arose and flourished in a patriarchal environment. Corsets were tied to beauty standards and beauty standards were dictated by men, which in itself is a strong example of gender inequality and men's economical superiority over women at that time. Example: During the regency of Eduard VII the fashion silhouette started to gravitate toward the form of an hourglass. This was due to his preferences, he liked the hour-glass silhouette on women, which first transferred to the woman in court and later became the ultimate beauty standard. The waist was getting thinner and worked towards the silhouette "sans-ventre" which in its form resembled the letter S.
2. Corsets were not just what bras are to us now.
What always was clear to me throughout my education is that corsets did demobilise women. My diploma partner described the whole daily routine of women wearing corsets in the late 19th century.The essence of it is that wearing the corsets, the woman couldn't even be a housewife. In the house she served more as a role model and had only perfunctory functions. She could merely serve tea. Of course this only applied to women of higher circles. The middle and lower classes were beginning to wear more free garments at that time and tended towards less restricting versions of the current corsets. Still, the corset can not be compared to bras since it did not just affect the breast but restricted the whole torso down to the hips.
3. The clothes made woman a woman. Women (especially women of higher circles) were the measure of their husband's success and a luxury object. How a female presented herself was not only a reflection of her husband's success but what gave her value as a human being. As a prominent french poet, crytic and assayist of the 19th century Charles Baudelaire wrote:
"à paraitre magique et sumaturelle; il faut qu'elle étonne, qu'elle charme; idole, eile doit se dorer pour etre adorée. " meaning: she(the woman) has to style herself to become a living artwork according to the man's expectations. Only through the merging of makeup and clothes is the woman to turn from animal to a dainty. The man of the late 19th century despises the nature and seeks artificiality, due which the woman portrays his desire. The corset was a tool . The corset was a tool to transform the woman into an object of man's desire, a tool to uphold these beliefs and sustain the gender norms. So no, I don't support the tradition of women wearing corsets at that time. P.S.:All of the arguments are based on the literature I had to read for the diploma, so I can give some links and share my sources. Also, I didn't know where to share this, so if you have abetter Idea, let me know.
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/snide42 • Dec 23 '14
Karl Rove discusses five books that define for him the essence of American Conservatism today
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/RazFilms • Dec 14 '16
Hegelian dialectics in a minute - a short film attempting to visualize Hegelian dialectics
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/SocialDemocracies • Jun 16 '22
Progressive books that you can borrow and read online
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/[deleted] • Apr 30 '13
The Many Faces of Neo-Marxism
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/kazarule • Dec 31 '22