r/HistoricalRomance • • Jul 10 '24 Heart of Silver

TV / Movies I like Bridgerton’s genderbend change - my perspective on it as a bisexual, genderfluid person

14 Upvotes

ETA: The opinion that the gender change sucks and means Francesca’s season will suck is quite common. This post was just meant to offer a perspective I hadn’t seen included in the general discussion yet. A different, more optimistic way of anticipating her arc on the show from a gender diverse woman’s POV. It wasn’t supposed to be an argument. To most of you, it seems me sharing this alternate perspective was “ridiculous”, “naive” and somehow “gaslighting” (??). Some people, myself included, just genuinely still feel hopeful about the change and genuinely don’t think one’s character is reliant on their gender. The intention of me saying that is “if the change upsets you, here’s another way to look at it.” I appreciate those of you who connected with what I’ve said or engaged with it in a respectful way. To the rest, the vitriol was unnecessary and disappointing.

—

Have a seat, this is kinda long. 😉 TW: discussion of miscarriage/infertility. And spoilers for the show!

As a genderfluid bisexual person, I’d like to share some important angles to Bridgerton’s choice to change Michael to Michaela that I believe the critics haven’t considered. I’ve formatted my thoughts as the general critique I’ve seen, plus how I would address it from a gender/sexuality diverse perspective. It’s important not to get stuck in a rigid heteronormative, cisnormative viewpoint when critiquing this choice.

  1. “This erases the infertility storyline.” Not necessarily. Francesca may still experience her infertility/miscarriage with John. She may continue to struggle/grieve that she won’t ever be a biological mother with Michaela, as is a real lived experience for some sapphic couples (this is of course excluding the possibility of a donor). Francesca’s infertility struggles may well still be very much part of her identity and journey, and won’t just automatically be erased because she’s queer. Another angle - and this is just a thought experiment to help folks remove their cishet thinking caps, because I don’t believe this is the case with actress Masali Baduza - but consider an alternate casting of a trans woman. Just because Michaela is a woman, that doesn’t necessarily mean she and Francesca might NOT try to have a child biologically together and experience disappointment.

  2. “The whole point of John’s death is that it was tragic and that Francesca truly loved him. Not a convenient way to make room for Michael/a.” Also not necessarily erased on the show. People assume that Francesca’s instant attraction to Michaela means she’s gay, thus she never really loved John. Consider she might be bi and her attraction to John/men might feel more comfortable and romantic. Whereas her attraction to Michaela/women might feel more sexual and passionate. These types of love fit in with her experience in the books. Just because she’s queer doesn’t mean she doesn’t deeply love John. All that’s clear in the show is that she doesn’t feel the same passion/spark for him that she does for Michaela. Queerness doesn’t automatically erase her love for John - it just introduces nuance into it.

  3. “Changing Michael to Michaela completely changes the story.” Unless Michaela is genderfluid or nonbinary. We might see - and I personally really hope the show goes this route - that, sometimes or even often, Michaela IS Michael. She might feel and act male sometimes, particularly in her romantic pursuits/relationships. Consider that despite her female presentation when we first meet her on the show, she might not BE 100% female.

In short, the show may very well explore all the same themes that resonated with readers, just from a different perspective.

These are just some angles (I’m sure I’ll think of more) I’ve thought about this morning that I haven’t seen in the conversation yet and I think they should be. Consider - and I mean this gently - that a choice that gives representation/a voice to others doesn’t necessarily take anything away from you.


r/HistoricalRomance • • May 27 '26

Discussion Racism in Newer Novels

4 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I was recently reading A Winter Chase by Mary Kingswood and it had a line in it that I felt was very racist. I understand that novels written in the 1920s, but I feel like modernly written novels can avoid racism. I don't feel like it adds anything to the story. What do you think?

The quote is: "Rosie will marry very well indeed, or I am a Chinaman." It is said by the older brother of the female lead.


r/HistoricalRomance • • Oct 16 '25

Discussion Overly sexual covers?

0 Upvotes

I’m fairly new to this genre, but why does it feel like every book has a very sexual cover? Like some of the books I’ve read that could probably be rated 2-3 in spice levels have very sexual cover / steamy covers and it just throws me off every time because if I saw that in a book store I would likely assume it’s much higher on a spice level and would probably avoid it LOL.

Is this just the nature of these kinds of books? I’m just curious tbh, I don’t really have an issue with it it just throws me off quite a bit haha

I’m not sure if sexual is the right word to use for this kind of topic but I cannot think of another word to explain what I mean.


r/HistoricalRomance • • Jun 16 '24

Recommendation request My (34f) best friend (34m) is interested in having me read sweeping, explicit, long-winded spicy scenes to him…I need recs!!

0 Upvotes

I have been reading romance novels for the last 20+ years, since I was a teenager. I have always experienced the standard eye rolls and eyebrow raises from everyone around me. Regardless, I’ve always unashamedly defended and stuck with the genre, because I love it. I think romance novels are a fascinating window into the sexual mores, expectations, and desires of whatever generation produced them. I’ve also learned a lot about myself using these books as a yardstick. I have always defended them, and always will.

Recently, my best friend (m) told me that he’s always respected my knowledge of the genre and the way I talk about it. He asked me to read a spicy scene aloud to him, and I chose {“The Highwayman” by Kerrigan Byrne} I gave him all of the necessary context for the fist time Dorian/Dougal and Farrah have sex for their first time and…suffice to say, he got SUPER into it!! He loved how visceral and “sticky” the language was, and that the scene has movements, almost like a symphony! He was super thrilled and wants me to read him more scenes just like it!

Problem, I feel like there aren’t very many books like The Highwayman, and I might have started him off at a high water mark. I’ve been re-reading my old favs and have found them oddly lacking. For starters, I thought {Devil in Winter by Lisa Kleypas} would be a next good stop, since it’s super iconic and famous in the genre…But, upon rereading it, I was struck by how overbearing Sebastian is and how boring Evie is. I’ve also revisited some Johanna Lindsey books, and they’re not “sticky” or long-form as I’d like.

So, I figured I’d come to you all and see what comes about!

I’m not amazing with my phone, but I’ll do my best to respond to anyone who can give me recs that meet the following criteria:

1.) sex scenes don’t need to be frequent throughout the book, but when they occur they should burn with desire and be looong. Think chapters, not paragraphs.

2.) the language needs to be explicit, referring to the stimulation of all/various body parts, as well as the resulting subsequent fluids (sweat, saliva, pussy juice, and cum)

3.) No dubcon or noncon. My friend (het. m) finds this difficult to relate to, and I don’t want to make him uncomfortable.

I’m not a frequent poster, so bear with me if I’m not as immediately responsive as people might expect. I’m grateful for this community, and I look forward to continuing to expand my love for the genre!

Thank you in advance!!

Edit: Um, wow! I guess I should have clarified that both my husband and his wife are aware of this and fine with it. Sheesh…the way I think of it, this isn’t any different than watching a movie with a friend that happens to have a sex scene in it. Sorry to the mods! I had no idea this would cause such a kerfuffle.


r/HistoricalRomance • • Apr 27 '25

Rant/Vent Devil in Winter WTF ST VINCENT??????????? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I was already a bit queasy in It Happened One Autumn bc of the way Lillian was SO drunk when they first actually slept together but i was like, maybe its just bc its an old book nd they did heavily makeout and oral sex bf this and she was concious so i guess...

BUT OMG NO FUCKING WAY, I FINALLY GIVE LISA KLEYPAS A CHANCE AFTER SO MUCH DREADING AND IN THE THIRD BOOK SHE MAKES A RAPIST AND KIDNAPPER THE MAIN CHARACTER??????? "oh but he didn't really" NO, ABSOLUTELY NOT.

and i did try and got through about 30% of it but i just couldn't not be enraged by everything he did and said, and also at HER out of every fucking one you go knock down your supposed friend's "would-be-rapist" and kidnapper? some fucking friend you are

how the fuck this is so highly rated ill never understand, and i spent a good amount of time reading the reviews but it just won't make sense to me, theres no way people who gave it 5 stars and rave about this have read the previous book

whatever floats your boat i guess, but boy was i disappointed

edit: I should clarify it the part "theres no way people who gave it 5 stars and rave about this have read the previous book" is not a given or solid fact even in my mind, it's a i cannot comprehend how but as below it, whatever gets you going


r/HistoricalRomance • • Nov 28 '25

Recommendation request Alternatives to Lisa Kleypas without SO much sex?

7 Upvotes

I ask this as someone who's already read probably 90% of Lisa Kleypas's HR novels. Mind you, I really enjoy her writing, and I find myself reading them for the era, the escape from modern day, the snappy conversations between the characters, all that fun stuff. I also enjoy seeing how the women do what they can to express themselves and exert independence within the stifling confines of 19th century England. But the endless sex scenes are just getting booooooring for me. At first, I liked her sex scenes too, but by the 50%-60% mark of my way through each book, it becomes a sizeable share of each chapter, or at least it feels like it.

I'm no prude, and can enjoy a good sex scene when there's been a long build-up to it. But eventually, her books have become so repetitive...I mean, there are only so many ways to describe what a typical man and woman can do to each other before it becomes almost clinical--and clinical is how it felt as I read the last one. I am also weary of the perfect specimens, with all the men being SO TALL or if not tall at least SO MUSCULAR and carrying the teensy virginal women around, out of danger, into the bedroom, lifting them like dainty feathers and skipping about with them in their arms. *insert eyeroll here* Honestly, please give me a scrawny man with a brilliant mind once in awhile, or a larger woman who doesn't have a tiny waist or who is not a virgin who climaxes the very first time she has sex when she didn't even know what sex WAS until a few minutes ago...

Okay, that was a bit of a rant. But I'm just feeling frustrated I guess. I know, probably most of her audience loves all of it, and I'm not criticizing anyone who does love it--she's a good writer, and her plots are otherwise quite creative and interesting. But...the nonstop perfect sex between perfect specimens is wearing on me.

I first got into the HR genre through Julia Quinn, and I DID seriously read every last one of her books. Yes, there was sex in every one, but not AS much, or with as much clinical detail. But there are no more of her books left to read, alas, and I've heard she isn't working on anything else at the moment.

So...after all this, I would love recommendations for authors/books in this genre without as much sex, or at least not between such astonishingly beautiful/handsome and orgasmic main characters. Thanks in advance! :-)


r/HistoricalRomance • • Mar 16 '24

diversity in HR sapphic recs with trans-woman main character(s)

Post image
21 Upvotes

I am looking for a absolutely sapph-fest fruity HR with trans woman x cis woman (would also take trans woman x trans woman) ;  and also YES if the cis-woman gives off major alpha top woman vibe.

I just saw the movie The Danish Girl - based on the book The Danish Girl by David Ebershoff and the Memoir Man to Woman (1933) which was based in Lili Elbe's diaries- and I have  GOT to talk about it  !

It's the story between Lili (previously called Einar) and Greda (Einar's wife)

"For a man to submit to a woman's gaze, it's unsettling. Although I believe there's some pleasure to be had from it, once you, um, yield" .. Greda is the ultimate top woman.

[I have used the pronoun he/him for Einar, and she/her for Lili cause that's how they have used in the book and the movie; and I have put quotes from the movie in spoiler tags, they are not essentially spoilers, but could be !]

"God made me a woman, but the doctor is curing me of the sickness that was my disguise"

So a little bit of summary for the Movie. Set in 1920s Copenhagen. So, Gerda and Einar (then Einar , now Lili) are a married couple, both are painters, Gerda paints Portraits and Einar Paints landscapes; Einar is extremely successful and everyone loves his work, Gerda is struggling and she's getting there. One day, one of the models for her painting cancels, so she asks Einar to pose for her, the subject matter of the painting is a ballerina dancer, Greda tells Einar to wear the stockings and shoes and pose for her. That's where the story starts.

So, Einar, takes the stockings, and kind of touches it, as if trying on a new skin; more than about wearing women's clothes, it was more about Einar feeling comfortable and like his true self (Lili) wearing the stocking, and also the scene is extremely good, cause stockings looks like skin, so it was as if Einar was trying on a new skin and finding it more comfortable than his own.

The movie also goes into the nuances of being a trans person, where there is plenty of distress associated with not being in their own body, or the feelings of physical dissociation.

"it dosent matter what I wear, cause when I dream, they're Lili's dreams"

Like in the movie there's a scene where Greta and Einar, tell their friends how they met, and Einar says "She was flaunting her ankles"; like Greda's ankles that were the first thing Einar saw about her, the way Einar says it, almost as if in a longing way, almost as if he wishes it were his; and Greda says something like "Kissing him was like kissing myself" It's almost as if Greda sees Einar as herself, and Einar longs to feel what it would be like in Greda's skin.

There was a scene, when she takes Einar's clothes off, Greda finds Einar wearing women's underclothes, and they just continue; and you can tell she understands and Greda proceeds to touch Einar in ways she wants to be touched herself and it is one of the hottest scenes I've ever seen, it happens at around 18 minutes into the Movie (in case u want to watch it) ; I rewatched it so many times !! It is currently running rent free in my mind as we speak .

This movie also to a degree depicts the psychological turmoil that they go through. Like the guilt that they feel when reaching completion in a body that is not theirs.

"I feel as though I'm performing myself" Einar says this .. Meaning  Einar feels as though he's playing a role when being Einar. I just love that it's not on my face , like the movie does not go into a drivel of information, but rather it's each and every little things that Einar and Greda do , that just makes sense in retrospect and that made me think ahhhhh, that's why.

There's another scene where Lili asks Greda , "Am I pretty enough?" ugh why do they have to be THAT PERFECT FOR EACH OTHER

Every thing about Greda and Lili was just so pure ! It gave me butterflies ! They made me FEEL THINGS !! I ship them so hard !

"you've always sketched me better than I was. But what you draw, I become. You made me beautiful. And now you're making me strong. Such power in you" Lili says this to Gerda ! Ugh the way I cried !

P.S. In the movie ( and in the book) neither Lili nor Gerda are lesbians, Lili is a trans woman and she is attracted to men; and Gerda is a cis woman also attracted to men; hence my rec request, cause I really ship them so hard !

Also if you're interested I just read {The Companion by EE Ottoman} , it's a poly romance between two trans women and one trans man (f/f/m). Set in late 1940s New York,  in upstate New York and gives off cottagecore vibes , also set behind the art scene ! and it's open door, would give it 3/5 spice score.

Please give me all your saphhic HRs with trans-character ! Can be closed or open door, dosent matter !

Thanks in advance !


r/HistoricalRomance • • May 09 '26

Fluff / Just For Fun! Can poor mmc's be attractive?

0 Upvotes

I read a very unusual (to me anyway) story about a poor barrister or solicitor who is kidnapped and trapped in a room with a fellow captive, a woman. Abducted by Mihwa Lee-Enhanced version. I think it has a different ending than the original or something. I haven't read the original.

They're both blindfolded and chained so can't see each other. He's extremely protective of her, does what he can to ease her mind. She gradually falls for him while in captivity. Especially when they're forced into intimacy by the kidnappers and she's an innocent and is scared.

They eventually escape and the story takes lots of turns, some action packed, includes his friend group that's lackadaisical about his safety, etc. A lot of fun.

In the third act, the secret identity of the solicitor is revealed. It turns out he has immense power, and he's definitely not poor. At this point, I was relieved. I've only been attracted to wealthy or powerful mmcs.

Then I grabbed The Proposition by Judith Ivory and haven't started. I'm hesitating still after a week. Can I find a rat-catcher mmc attractive? I know this is an extreme example because a rat-catcher mmc doesn't only mean destitution in those days but also diseases, lack of skills and ambition.

  1. Could you find a poor mmc with no title attractive in your historical romance? And I mean their prospects don't improve. The HEA includes forever worrying about money but loving each other and living happily in their own way.

  2. And can you think of a hero you love who would suck at being poor? To the point you wouldn't find them attractive at all if they didn't have the title and wealth?

  3. Have you read a book about two humble mcs who decide that their love is enough and it's not about money?

NOTE:

I feel that this post was misunderstood by some so here’s the clarification: I’m talking about fiction, fantasy, fluff, not my personal values. I’m sure we can all agree we are not what we read. And I was commenting on what’s been written in this genre, not my reading preferences.

it’s a fact that there has always been more written about MMC’s with money and power. Look at all the billionaire contemporary novels and all the titled dudes in HR. I dare say women are more attracted to these men than ones without influence, not because of money but because of their competence and the opportunities they can provide in an era when women had no power of their own.

When I posed these questions, I was referring to two poor MCs. I meant an MMC with no prospect also meant an FMC with no money. I haven’t read any stories where the couple was poor but found happiness anyway.


r/HistoricalRomance • • Nov 28 '25

Rant/Vent Lisa Kleypas - are all her books so hypersexualized? A rant about Again the Magic.

24 Upvotes

I can’t think of a better way to describe it. By hypersexual, I don’t just mean it has lots of spice. Most HR romances have lots of spice.

I just read Again the Magic and I was so excited to read it because I’ve heard that it’s the most amazing, angsty second-chance romance reminiscent of Persuasion by Jane Austen.

Sadly, I have to disagree. I was expecting drawn out, built up longing (and it started off strong in that respect!) and what I ended up getting was a brute caveman who used sex as a mechanism for everything. Revenge, courtship, grief, and love. I understand that he was torn up and bitter. But I wanted to feel him giving her the cold shoulder and giving us a chance to experience/witness those feelings come to light, and then to finally have that amazing moment where they succumb to their longing. Instead, he immediately turned into a jerk who wouldn’t stop bullying her into sex. There was one genuine conversation between them at the end, yes, but everything else about their reunion revolved around sex. Him threatening her with it, her obsessing about it, the gritty and harsh scenes (up against a tree in the dark, really?). He was giving “me Tarzan, you jane” vibes the whole time. Are all her books like this?? Even at the end when they had that amazing conversation, it was quickly ruined for me when she didn’t want to have sex and he forcefully persuaded her to do it anyway. Not romantic. And after all that, the epilogue wasn’t even about them! I’m just so annoyed.


r/HistoricalRomance • • Dec 01 '25

Rant/Vent Nakoa’s Woman (Gayle Rogers) - I hate this book…

Post image
0 Upvotes

As the title says.. If what you are looking for is epic amazing love story you will be very dissapointed, most likely. This book is anything but romantic. Yeah the FMC is annoying but Nakoa the MMC is a jerk, he’s abusive. I don’t buy it at all that they loved each other… this book is not romantic, its just… tragic and depressing. But maybe that’s how it was meant to be. Still… no, not for me. I can’t write a review since I don’t remember much about it anymore, I read it many years ago. Maybe this is for you who are not looking for a romance but something realistic, I guess. If what you are looking for is something romantic, look elsewhere…there are way better native american man/white woman books out there that actually are very romantic, for exemple Dancing on Coals by Ellen O'connell.

I think this book was written in 1970s, so it does feel outdated. Its a very angsty book , I love angst but this is not the angst I like. I was expecting a wonderful love story but it’s not what I got! I was Reminded by this book after finishing Dancing on Coals because it’s also a native american man/white woman romance .. its just that unlike Nakoa’s Woman it actually feel like a real romance , you totally feel that they love each other + both characters are so awesome! I didn’t root for the MMC and FMC to be together in Nakoa’s Woman, and I didn’t care about either of them… this is my opinion ofc, have you read this book? You agree or disagree with me?

I do love the cover tho, its very intense and not typical kind of cover like in most vintage native american romances. I guess i bought the book (i can’t find it anymore and thats totally fine since I can’t stand the book xD ) because of the beautiful cover and how it says ” swept into a brutal , Alien world. A captive white woman Discovers a love she never imagined” and ”a story that will haunt you forever ” so Yeah .. but like i Said, maybe its very realistic book?


r/HistoricalRomance • • Aug 31 '26

Recommendation request Hand necklace?

0 Upvotes

Any recs where the MMC loves choking the FMC?? Not just during sex, even just while they kiss or cuddle?
(Not super hard or anything, they both just enjoy it)

I’ve never read an HR with this😫. I don’t want any BDSM, degradation or rough elements, although pinning down, a soft dom MMC and praise (inside and outside the bedroom!) would be a huge bonus.

I prefer 3/5🌶️ and slow, slow burn please!


r/HistoricalRomance • • Aug 25 '26

Recommendation request Looking for authors like Tessa Dare, just less...

3 Upvotes

Hi, I've been rereading Lisa Kleypas and it was so much fun. From the Wallflowers down to the last Ravenals.

I really like the funny, quick witted MMC's and just overall a funny book even if it's angsty.

The only other author I could think of was Tessa Dare to jump into, also rereading, but I struggle because she blasphemes way to much for me after reading the Duchess Deal. And, from what I can remember when I read it way back it's just the way she writes in all her books. So I don't want to continue.

Are there any historical romance authors who writes really witty, yet good/funny stories but tones down the swearing and blasphemes, also I don't care for a lot of spicy scenes, but I can just skip so that's fine.

Please don't recommend Elizabeth Hoyt-I can't get past the first chapter of any of her books.

Thank you!


r/HistoricalRomance • • Oct 19 '25

Rant/Vent Shonda Rhimes and people of colour in historical romance business

60 Upvotes

Shonda is a big hypocrite. If she really cared about diversity, representation and opportunities of and for people of colour she would’ve adapted another book series. A book series that already contained poc main characters (instead of Racebending white characters which is just lazy hand me down representation and caused an unnecessary outrage) and was written by a poc author, like Beverly Jenkins. And I’m not saying that Julia Quinn doesn’t deserve an audience just bc she’s a white cishet author, but this „fame“ and bigger audience could’ve been given to a poc author. Instead all the attention was given to a racebend Netflix version of a book series that only contained white cishet characters written by a white cishet author. I gave Beverly Jenkins a try and read one of her books (although in English bc her books aren’t available in German) and it was soo good and exciting to read, it has potential in my opinion for a show or movie


r/HistoricalRomance • • Apr 18 '24

Discussion Thoughts on disliking popular authors?

0 Upvotes

I was talking with one of my writer's groups yesterday and we got into an interesting debate about disliking popular authors.

She's not historical (because she was writing in the time her books are set, aka she's contemporary) but I don't think Jane Austen is as great as everyone thinks she is. Okay, this might be a case of Seinfeld Is Unfunny and I had the misfortune of being assigned not one but two of her weaker works (Sense and Sensibility and Mansfield Park) for school. But I just don't see what makes her so great. Her characters in those books are annoying at best (Elinor is a noble and long suffering Angel In The House, Marianne is a flighty and melodramatic hormonal teenager and Fanny is a stick in the mud who thinks she's better than everyone else). Pretty much the only character I liked (and was rooting for) was mean old Mrs. Norris.

I also have the same issues with Julia Quinn. Now, I liked Bridgerton as a series. It's actually what got me into the series by Julia Quinn. The show's got good production values, I love the costumes (even if they aren't historically accurate) and the acting is top notch. The books on the other hand? They're not horrible but they're just...meh?

What are your guy's thoughts on disliking popular authors?


r/HistoricalRomance • • Oct 15 '25

Discussion Do you think a good coloniser/colonised romance can be written?

3 Upvotes

Hey all! In the mood for a discussion on a pretty tricky subject so wanted to hear your thoughts.

As the title suggests, do you think a good romance can be written between a couple where one of the MCs is from the coloniser group and the other from the colonised group? Because let's face it, with HRs there are multiple such possible scenarios, and usually the issue is that either the colonialism is whitewashed or ignored, or the colonised is exoticised and not looked at from more than just the coloniser's lens (or usually, both cases).

Obviously it's the reader's personal choice to not be bothered by these things and that's perfectly fine because everyone has the right to read the way they wish, but I wonder if it is possible to write this dynamic well where you create this beautiful romance without ignoring the harsh historical background behind it.

There's been a lot of debate on romance novels between these kind of couples (I remember one of some Mexican FMC falling for a white supremacist MMC, and romantasy I think is filled with such dynamics), so want to know what you think!

P.S. By coloniser and colonised I don't mean only white and non-white, I also mean for example, English and Irish, or like in Stormswept by Deborah Martin, English and Welsh (I consider this book a good example because the Welsh MMC is fighting for his language and the English MMC isn't exoticising him but rather, loves the Welsh language before even meeting him and recognises their struggles).

P.S. The only other 'good' novel at the moment which kind of comes to my mind is Duke of Shadows. The colonialism is not whitewashed but brutally shown, the mixed race MMC is not exoticised by the white FMC as far as I remember.


r/HistoricalRomance • • Jun 20 '23

Covers How beautiful would these AI images be as book cover!

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

Just came across a TikTok by @lexiaworlds of American life in the mid 19th century. She has one for every state. Here’s my favorites.


r/HistoricalRomance • • Jul 27 '25

Rant/Vent Update: Still Peeved

Post image
41 Upvotes

I wanted to post an update on the {Duke of Sin by Elizabeth Hoyt}, mostly because of the amount of comments I got assuring me the overuse of italics was character based and not throughout the book, which I found to be inaccurate, but also because I love talking HR and this is the only place I can do that to people that care :)

Though I have resounding criticism for almost every aspect of the writing (like how juvenile I found the dialogue, how it sounds more like an angsty stage play than a mature novel, or how I didn’t find the steamy scenes depicting a lover of his proclaimed caliber) and storytelling, I’ll save you the negativity and just focus on my most important two points.

  1. The Italics

In the picture attached, I had opened to a random page to prove my point, and it did. At least 7 words are italicized and Val is not speaking. That is not good writing. A good author is able to dramatize and emphasize using vocabulary, not “drawings” (for lack of a better word [because I’m not a good author!]). Pretty much every single page had at least one word in italics, most had a minimum of 2 and 3.

2. His Evil

I went for this book specifically because I was looking for a MMC that is truly not a good guy and then love brings him ‘round. Val is bratty and vain but evil? The word is overused and I don’t believe it fits him, by definition. Not once is he cruel for the sake of cruelty - or even selfishness. Every instance of his seemingly bad behavior is justified by trauma or in the defense of himself or others. This is connected to my broader criticism of the writing style, of it coming off as juvenile, and I think it’s because the word choices are dramatic and ill applied. However, I’ll leave it at the point about his lack of evilness.

It wasn’t my taste for many reasons, but if you enjoyed it, she has a plethora of similar titles to enjoy too, and thanks for reading my thoughts.

If what I described would bother you too, and you’re also seeking a real “bad guy” MMC, I highly recommend {The Conqueror by Brenda Joyce}. I find her writing style excellent, her storytelling highly compelling, and her historical commitment better than most HR authors. It’s /deeply/ problematic, and I was scandalized and horrified in turns, but the turns of events are also much more believable for being a love story in the 1100s England.


r/HistoricalRomance • • Sep 18 '25

Discussion There’s no room for POC in Regency Romance

0 Upvotes

That’s what it feels like. Do HR readers like South-Asian or desi representation in regency? If not (like it not being realistic - why?)

I haven’t seen Bridgerton but I think they have a brown women playing a role there too, the one famous for her pouty eyebrows lol. What would people like or dislike in a desi/south Asian regency book?


r/HistoricalRomance • • Aug 13 '26

Discussion Am i being oversensitive of this? Spoiler

3 Upvotes

Heyieee, just a quick question

I'm about 100 pages into {Love Forever After by Patricia Rice}, and I need to discuss or vent g to vet some perspective.

Spoilers ahead!

So The FMC is in this book is in marriage of convenience with the MMC. About halfway through, she starts developing real feelings for her husband. But then she meets his cousin, who looks identical to her husband but has the total opposite personality. (My guess? It’s probably the husband in disguise).... After one single meeting, she’s instantly attracted to this cousin. She craves his attention, lets him touch and kiss her, and says he makes her feel "womanly" to the point where she completely forgets she’s even married. ....... Her main justification seems to be that her husband doesn't spend enough time with her or allows the intimacy that the cousin allows

Now to discuss:

1.Isn't this basically cheating? Even if it turns out to be her husband in disguise, she doesn't know that. In her mind, she is atively pursuing and welcoming physical and emotional intimacy with another man while married? ....

2.I’ve realized that whenever a new third-party character is introduced in a romance novel, I instantly get anxious.... Like I'm hyper-vigilant about emotional infideltly ... I feel emotional drift breaks the core trust of a romance story just as fast as physical cheating does .. Do you guys feel the same way about scenarios like this or i need to take therapy

3.And honestly... should romance books have a mandatory content warning or separate tag specifically for emotional cheating?


r/HistoricalRomance • • Feb 03 '26

Recommendation request MMC gets turned on by the thought of watching fat FMC eat. NSFW

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/HistoricalRomance • • Jun 12 '24

Discussion Is this book clean?

1 Upvotes

So I was at the library today and I found a book called ana maria and the fox by liana de la rosa. I only read clean historical romance and nothing came up about the spice for this book. so can someone tell me if this book is spicy or not


r/HistoricalRomance • • Oct 29 '25

What did I just read??? From ‘Not That Duke’ by Eloisa James - is she implying that these English aristocrats are Catholic???????

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/HistoricalRomance • • Aug 25 '24

Discussion Does Mary Barlogh have something against pretty people ?

38 Upvotes

I'm so sorry if I sound superficial. But I like my MCs to be somewhat attractive I guess.

I had never read Balogh but I kept seeing Slightly Dangerous mentioned here. Since it's the sixth and last book of a series I thought I'd start with the first one. I enjoyed the first half but by the end it was really hard not to dnf. Balogh is a great writer, it was just not for me. I started reading the second one and I realized, Balogh keeps saying her characters are not pretty. "She's handsome but no one would call her pretty" excuse me what ?? What do you mean NO ONE would call her pretty ? Am I reading about a troll ? "He's tall and his hair is wavy, his skin is fair, but he is not a pretty" What do you mean ??? Am I supposed to picture an ugly man ? I like to picture the characters in my head. I don't want to picture ugly people having sex I'm so sorry.

And pretty is so subjective, like why doesn't she describe them more so I can make up my own mind about their prettyness ?? What do they actually look like Mary ?? It's all blank faces in my head.

Please is there any book in this series where BOTH MCs are somewhat attractive?

Again I'm really sorry if I sound like a superficial bitch.


r/HistoricalRomance • • Jun 16 '25

Recommendation request Happy Pride Month! 🌈 In part 1/4, I’ll be asking everyone their favorite lbtq+ historicals. My first ask is what’s your favorite historicals with trans representation? 🏳️‍⚧️

Post image
28 Upvotes

Happy Pride Month from a bisexual girlie to all the girls, gays, and theys! I wanted to put together a set of posts asking everyone their favorite queer historicals romances from L to T. Today, I will be asking everyone their favorite historical romances that full under the trans umbrella. Above I’ve provided a graphic to help people in the distinction of the trans umbrella.

Unfortunately, I have not read many trans historical romances, but I’m reading one right now that I just have to recommend!

I’ve recently discovered Alexis Hall (who does also write queer contemporary). I’m currently reading {A Lady For the Duke by Alexis Hall} and it’s so good! It’s definitely going on my favorite queer romances list. The heroine is trans (MTF), and was previously best friends with the hero before her transition. She faked her death to become her true self, and meets up with the hero again two and a half years later. The hero is still grieving the death of his friend, but is immediately smitten with the heroine (not knowing she’s his dead best friend). The angst is so intense in this book, but the sweet emotional pay off is fantastic! I have about 10% left and I am loving it! My only complaint is it’s a little long and the pacing is a little fast in places and slow in others, but overall, such a great book.

Aside from my recommendation, I’ve not found many books in the genre with trans rep! So please comment below what your favorite historical romances are with trans umbrella rep!

Next up will be bisexual rep (I’m going from back to front just for fun 😂)


r/HistoricalRomance • • Oct 23 '24

Recommendation request Books where the MMC is a servant/worker/slave on the FMC’s plantation (or something similar)

2 Upvotes

Basically where the relationship is that she is the social superior.. and that causes angst and friction among them.. usually leading the MMC to want to dominate!