r/HistoricalJesus • • Oct 26 '20

Discussion Can the four gospels of Mathew Mark Luke and John really be completely thrown out as evidence for Jesus?

0 Upvotes

Okay so the miracle stuff is iffy I can understand skepticism on that aspect. But in terms of authenticity there has often been debate on whether the books actually gave accurate accounts of Jesus' life.

Certainly the fact that many of his sayings and teachings are found in all four gospels proves that he did say the things he is recorded to have said. Which is also backed up by the actions of the actions of the early Christian's who lived at the same time as Jesus.

But there is always a fork in the road when historians and theologians discuss if they were written together or apart. There's so much similar about the books that suggest that they were copied from some undiscovered text. But they are also just different enough in terms of details and stories that it also suggests that they were written separately.

Which do you think it is? There's also the fact that the authors of Luke and Mark personally new The apostles who did live at the same time Jesus lived. And that one of those disciples lived, ate, and walked with Jesus.


r/HistoricalJesus • • Apr 06 '23

Review my research todate

2 Upvotes

I began my search for this historical Jesus in 1990-1 this is what I have uncovered so far:

the first Author of anything "christian" was Paul, who admits he never met a flesh and blood Jesus, but only had "visions" and the hebrew bible to tell him who Jesus was... He claims that all the apostles he knew about knew Jesus the same way.

Marcion (as written by Teltullian) tells us that the very first gospel, the only one he considered valid, was known as the gospel of the lord and was dictated by Paul to Luke.

Papias, who claimed to have known people who directly knew apostles, tells us the very first Gospel he knew about was written by Matthew in Hebrew. (no one has ever found this version as the current Matthew seems little more than an expansion on the current Mark Gospel without any trace of being written in anything but Koine Greek).

Papias further tells us that the Gospel of Mark he knew about was an out of order group of sayings and events that Peter recalled and dictated to Mark.(nothing like our current Mark).

Luke, as we have it today is admittedly not an eye witness account at all and seems to draw heavily on the currently known version of Mark.

The Gospel of John seems nearly universally recognized as a late 1st century, perhaps even early 2nd century invention of a church group completely removed from the original events... the Jesus seminar voted most of it completely alien to anything an historical Jesus would have said or done.

Josephus writes about Jesus... or does he? one of his references is nearly universally seen as at least a partial forgery and many see it as a complete fake.(no church father ever quotes it until after the 2nd century). A 2nd reference to Jesus may be another person entirely(the name was very common) and a 3rd was about a preacher who for seven years said the city of Jerusalem was going to be destroyed by the Romans and ended up killed by a Roman missile(boulder).

I have run across many Christian sources which make the claim that there is more EVIDENCE for an historical Jesus than any other historical personage... this seems to be a complete lie... there is ZERO evidence, only hearsay, rumors and legends... not one verifiable bit of actual evidence.

Was there an historical Jesus? perhaps, but the one in the gospels seems to be completely mythological.


r/HistoricalJesus • • Feb 07 '22

Video Is Jesus Mythicism A Myth? Dr. Robert M. Price

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/HistoricalJesus • • Nov 07 '20

Discussion Jesus as a revolutionary socialist?

5 Upvotes

Hi, I don’t know if this is the correct place to post this so apologies if I have broken any rules. Absolutely no offense intended to anyone by the post.

I recently stumbled across a video by Dr John Crossan on the historical Jesus. I found it fascinating. Now, maybe I’m projecting a bit here given my own socialist tendencies, but I thought the historical Jesus he described sounded a lot like a revolutionary socialist:

  • Born in a stable to a homeless peasant.

  • Born into a land ruled by a colonial power, as a member of a subjugated class.

  • Rome, as colonial powers tend to do, would have been seeking to impose its authority on Jesus’ people with the aim of economic dominance (ie increasing the surplus production of peasants)

  • Jesus preached about a “kingdom of God” as being a more just way of organizing the economic system than the way it was organized under the “kingdom of Rome”.

  • This “kingdom of God” was not some distant thing that would be brought down by God in the future, but was something which had begun and would flourish through the actions of the people (the power was with the people/ revolution (albeit non violent))

  • the kingdom of God could be seen already in early communes where Jesus and his followers met and shared food (which comes from the land)

  • Jesus sent followers (organizers) out to teach and share food with people and to heal. Education, healthcare, welfare.

  • Told his followers to mix with the downtrodden. Said things like “easier for a rich man to pass through the eye of a needle...”

  • The authorities perceived his message as a threat, and killed him as an example.

  • Movement moved underground.

Would be interested to hear what people who have studied Jesus properly think of my back of an envelope analysis.

For clarity, Dr Crossan didn’t make the exact claims mentioned above, I put my own bias on them. I’m also from a catholic background, so that no doubt shaped my interpretation too.


r/HistoricalJesus • • Apr 06 '23

Video Where is the Tomb of Jesus?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/HistoricalJesus • • Apr 14 '23

Discussion Was Mary a absent mom in The life of historical jesus ?

2 Upvotes

in the gospels of Matthew and Luke, Mary has a fundamental part in the life of Jesus, but in the gospel according to Mark, which is the first to be written, we only see her once and that is when she says that he is out of his mind, so it would be Mary a mother absent from the life of Jesus and his ministry and the gospels are trying to fix this?


r/HistoricalJesus • • Feb 23 '24

Discussion Name Changing in OT and NT

2 Upvotes

Why Jejus changed the name of Simon to peter? Why shaul name changed to paul in OT jacob become israel? any specific meaning of this ?


r/HistoricalJesus • • Jan 10 '24

Video Would God Sacrifice Jesus for Humanity’s Sins?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/HistoricalJesus • • Dec 18 '19

Article Why do historians rely on hearsay as evidence for Jesus?

Thumbnail
nobeliefs.com
5 Upvotes

r/HistoricalJesus • • Jul 22 '22

Video Announcing "The Unknown Gospels: Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John" - A New Online Course by Dr. Ehrman

Thumbnail
youtube.com
6 Upvotes

r/HistoricalJesus • • Jan 24 '23

Video Creating Jesus: The Gospel of Mark | With Dr. James Tabor

Thumbnail
youtube.com
7 Upvotes

r/HistoricalJesus • • Jul 30 '21

Discussion Is the disagreement over Jesus' appearance a proof for Christ Mythicism?

8 Upvotes

I was talking with one Mythicist, and he claims that Church Fathers dissagree about Jesus's appearence so much that He must have just been their invention.

On Celsus's claim that Jesus was ugly and small, Origen agrees. Tertullian and Irenaeus said something simillar. John of Damascus and Hierosolymitanus say Jesus was unibrowed and crooked. Some bishops sent letters to byzantine emperor Theophilus and described he was three cubits tall and Ephrem Syrus also said this. In short, earliest Church Fathers generally agreed that Jesus was short and nothing special in look.

However, later Church Fathers describe Jesus completelly differently.

"When Jesus saw great crowds around Him" (St. Matthew 8:18) wrote: "The people were really attracted to Him and they loved Him and marveled at Him, desiring always to be looking upon Him. Who would want to leave while He was doing these marvelous deeds? Who would not want to simply get a glance at the face and the mouth only when He was doing wonders, but even when He was just looked upon, simply He was just full of grace." This is what the prophet David meant when he said that He was the most beautiful among the sons of man.

Now if the physical body of sweetest Jesus was so beautiful then when He was bearing a corruptible body, how much more beautiful is it now that it has become incorruptible and glorified and His divine face is shining in heaven infinitely more brightly than the sun? This is why St. John Chrysostom has sought with his eloquent homilies to move us to do everything we can so that we may achieve and enjoy the sweetest vision of the glorified and most beautiful and most desired divine face of Jesus. For if one is to be deprived of the vision of the most beautiful and most desired face of Jesus, this is truly a worse calamity than a thousand hells." St. John Chrysostom

Unauthentic letter of Publius Lentulus describes Him this way:

"He is a man of medium size (statura procerus, mediocris et spectabilis); he has a venerable aspect, and his beholders can both fear and love him. His hair is of the colour of the ripe hazel-nut, straight down to the ears, but below the ears wavy and curled, with a bluish and bright reflection, flowing over his shoulders. It is parted in two on the top of the head, after the pattern of the Nazarenes. His brow is smooth and very cheerful with a face without wrinkle or spot, embellished by a slightly reddish complexion. His nose and mouth are faultless. His beard is abundant, of the colour of his hair, not long, but divided at the chin. His aspect is simple and mature, his eyes are changeable and bright. He is terrible in his reprimands, sweet and amiable in his admonitions, cheerful without loss of gravity. He was never known to laugh, but often to weep. His stature is straight, his hands and arms beautiful to behold. His conversation is grave, infrequent, and modest. He is the most beautiful among the children of men."

Even Muslim hadiths describe Him differently:

"The Prophet mentioned the Massiah Ad-Dajjal in front of the people saying, Allah is not one eyed while Messsiah, Ad-Dajjal is blind in the right eye and his eye looks like a bulging out grape. While sleeping near the Ka'ba last night, I saw in my dream a man of brown color the best one can see amongst brown color and his hair was long that it fell between his shoulders. His hair was lank and water was dribbling from his head and he was placing his hands on the shoulders of two men while circumambulating the Kaba. I asked, 'Who is this?' They replied, 'This is Jesus, son of Mary.'" Sahih Bukhari Volume 4, Book 55, Number 649

Gospels don't describe His appearance, but they say Jesus could easily be lost from he sight in the crowd and that the soldiers divided his garments and cast lots for seeing who will get His clothes, which implies He might have been somewhere of their (soldiers') height.

Now, this Mythicist argues, that, if Jesus existed, then people would remember how He looked like, even though it's unimportant or not described in the Gospels or, at the very least, there wouldn't be so different extremes. Now, he can accept these descriptions that Jesus is beautiful as simple exagarations. However, what both me and this Mythicist find strange is that if He was really small and ugly, then Jesus wouldn't simply get lost in the crowds, He would actually be noticeable and Judas wouldn't have to kiss Him for soldiers to recognize Him.

It is not just like some Church Fathers exaggarate Jesus' beauty. It is that Church Fathers take twp extremes, that He was beautiful and that He was hideous. So by this, he argues Jesus never existed and Christians simply weren't sure how to paint Him, since there wouldn't be so much variation

Is this argument for non-existence legit and how to respond to it?

Also, is there any other historical figure whose appearance has been described so differently by everyone?

Thanks in advance!


r/HistoricalJesus • • Oct 11 '20

Article Jesus Mythicism 7: Josephus, Jesus and the 'Testimonium Flavianum'

Thumbnail
historyforatheists.com
9 Upvotes

r/HistoricalJesus • • Aug 28 '20

Meta [#2] What are the rules here?

2 Upvotes

This will serve as the second discussion when considering the development of rules for /r/HistoricalJesus. These discussions will be added to the sidebar, under Rules, for reference moving forward.

Please, feel free to express anything that you believe would contribute to the advancement of this community.


r/HistoricalJesus • • Nov 14 '19

Video Bart Ehrman & Robert Price Debate - Did Jesus Exist?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
10 Upvotes

r/HistoricalJesus • • Apr 17 '20

Question Historical Jesus on being Messiah

3 Upvotes
44 votes, Apr 20 '20
16 Historical Jesus almost certainly DID teach that he was/is the Messiah.
16 Historical Jesus likely DID teach that he was/is the Messiah
7 Historical Jesus likely did NOT teach that he was the Messiah.
5 Historical Jesus almost certainly did NOT teach that he was the Messiah.

r/HistoricalJesus • • Nov 26 '19

Question A document containing all the agreed sayings of Jesus?

4 Upvotes

Hi, I remember a while back reading a document that had 13 or so sayings that were all agreed to be 100% said by Jesus. The methodology was for official people (not sure who) to all vote on sayings that they were completely sure were said by Jesus.

Only 10-20 verses remained as being verifiably said by Jesus, the rest were ascribed to later followers. Does anyone know of this document or something similar? Thanks.


r/HistoricalJesus • • Nov 06 '20

Video The Quest For The Mythical Jesus- The History of Mythicism: Christopher Hansen Part 2

Thumbnail
youtube.com
4 Upvotes

r/HistoricalJesus • • Dec 25 '19

Question Witness to Jesus? - Philo of Alexandria

Thumbnail
jesusneverexisted.com
5 Upvotes

r/HistoricalJesus • • Jan 10 '20

Discussion The Netflix series: Messiah

6 Upvotes

Messiah is a cleverly written and provocative program. I thought it would be interesting to compare what we know from historical Jesus studies to the portrayal of the messianic figure in the show.


r/HistoricalJesus • • Feb 26 '21

Video Did Jesus Exist?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
6 Upvotes

r/HistoricalJesus • • Sep 04 '20

Article A Response to John Pickard and his View of Jesus

Thumbnail cmepshansen9.wixsite.com
6 Upvotes

r/HistoricalJesus • • Apr 19 '21

Question Is there an historical core to the story of the Syrophoenician/Canaanite woman in Mark 7/Matthew 15? What does it tell us about Jesus' views on gentiles?

7 Upvotes

r/HistoricalJesus • • Aug 28 '20

Meta Proposal for a ban on all Carrier-related posts.

23 Upvotes

Richard Carrier is not a serious scholar. His book, "On the Historicity of Jesus," did not undergo proper peer-review.

I suggest that we not let people post about Carrier. It pollutes this sub with ideologically-motivated garbage. We need to stick 100% to objective scholarship. And that means no more Carrier posts.

Carrier even has a sexual harassment allegation against him, so there's a social justice aspect to this as well.


r/HistoricalJesus • • Apr 14 '23

Question in what location must the historical Jesus have been born?

8 Upvotes

Since there was no hospitals in acient world and If there was hospital they should be for rich people ,in wich place was jesus born ? In home ? In a Synagogue or Jewish shrine?or what ?