r/HistoricalJesus • • Aug 28 '20

Meta Proposal for a ban on all Carrier-related posts.

23 Upvotes

Richard Carrier is not a serious scholar. His book, "On the Historicity of Jesus," did not undergo proper peer-review.

I suggest that we not let people post about Carrier. It pollutes this sub with ideologically-motivated garbage. We need to stick 100% to objective scholarship. And that means no more Carrier posts.

Carrier even has a sexual harassment allegation against him, so there's a social justice aspect to this as well.


r/HistoricalJesus • • May 24 '20

Discussion The qualities of Historical Jesus. Feel free to debate.

19 Upvotes

After much reading (here are some of my primary go-to’s: Ehrman, Crossan, Sanders, Goodacre, Marcus), this is what I feel like are the aspects of Historical Jesus that are the most widely agreed upon in scholarly circles. But please feel free to dissect or refute any of them. I just wanted to put out my understanding for the sake of discussion and hopefully to be schooled and educated. I’ve numbered them not because they are ranked, but just to make it easier for anyone who wants to discuss a specific one (eg. “actually I disagree with 4 and 7 because...”)

  1. Likely born in Nazareth, NOT Bethlehem.

  2. Mother, probably named Mary, was NOT a “virgin.” He had brothers and sisters.

  3. Was baptized by and likely followed the teachings of John the Baptist before John was killed.

  4. DID, like John, teach against divorce.

4 1/2. (I numbered this weird because I added it later, and didn’t feel like renumbering everything) He often taught in parables.

5. Likely DID claim to have the ability to heal and exorcise demons through prayer and was possibly experienced by others as effective at it.

6. Probably did NOT do any of the nature miracles and or they were greatly exaggerated.

7. Likely Did NOT preach that he was “the son of God.”

8. He probably considered the “Son of Man” to be a separate entity from himself. An angelic being that would come to set things right for the arrival of the Kingdom of God.

9. Likely DID preach that the end was nigh (like imminently nigh) and that some would be saved to live forever in the kingdom of God here on Earth, and some would not.

10. Likely did NOT teach that those who didn’t get to enter the Kingdom would live forever in conscious torment. Rather, they would face total, permanent, annihilation.

11. Likely followed Kosher laws and honored the Sabbath.

12. Likely DID consider himself a messianic figure, and thought his closest followers would help rule over the 12 tribes with Jesus ruling over all.

13. Probably DID cause a stir at the Temple that led to his arrest.

14. Likely was betrayed by one or more of his followers and possibly one named Judas.

15. Probably did NOT teach that he would die and be brought back to life.

16. Was crucified for sedition.

17. Was very likely experienced by some of his close followers as having come back in some way.


r/HistoricalJesus • • Jun 30 '20

Article (PDF) Same-Sex Intercourse Involving Jewish Men 100 BCE-100 CE: Sources and Significance for Jesus' Sexual Politics | Christopher B Zeichmann

Thumbnail
academia.edu
15 Upvotes

r/HistoricalJesus • • Oct 21 '21

Book New historical Jesus book from Crossley and Myles

Thumbnail
robertjmyles.substack.com
14 Upvotes

r/HistoricalJesus • • Dec 30 '20

News Remains Found at Gethsemane: Ritual bath found from 2,000 years ago, when Jesus would have visited, as well as church from the Byzantine period.

Thumbnail
biblicalarchaeology.org
14 Upvotes

r/HistoricalJesus • • Aug 19 '20

Article On Richard Carrier’s Doubts: A Response to Richard Carrier’s On the Historicity of Jesus: Why We Might Have Reason for Doubt

Thumbnail
brill.com
14 Upvotes

r/HistoricalJesus • • May 04 '20

Question Does knowledge of the historical Jesus undermine belief in the traditional Jesus of theology?

Thumbnail self.askbiblescholars
14 Upvotes

r/HistoricalJesus • • Nov 24 '20

Article Open Access- Mowbray, J. (2020). Why Did Jesus Surrender to the Cross?: The Historical Evidence. Journal for the Study of the Historical Jesus, 18, no. 3, 244-266

Thumbnail
brill.com
13 Upvotes

r/HistoricalJesus • • Jul 05 '21

Video In this video, we do deep historical research into the most important mentions in Latin about Jesus of Nazareth by non-Christian authors such as Roman emperors, magistrates, lawyers, military officers, etc.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
12 Upvotes

r/HistoricalJesus • • May 23 '20

Book (PDF) THE QUEST OF THE MYTHICAL JESUS: A History of Jesus Skepticism, ca. 1574 to the Present | Christopher M. Hansen

Thumbnail
academia.edu
12 Upvotes

r/HistoricalJesus • • Jun 12 '20

Question Historical Jesus Criticism

11 Upvotes

Hi there, I'm relatively new to reading historical Jesus scholarship having only read a few books by JD Crossan, Paula Frederiksen, and EP Sanders. I recently learned that there are folks that view the historical Jesus quest as irrelevant, methodologically flawed, and useless. This was tough for me to hear cos the historical Jesus material I've read has been, by far, the most interesting stuff I've read of biblical scholarship.

Why do some view the quest this way? What are some criticisms of historical Jesus methodology? Have scholars here that are focused on historical Jesus studies faced these accusations before? I recognize that there are limitations to the field but I'm not sure that means that it should just be completely discarded and deemed irrelevant. The reconstructions I've read so far seem to be the product of diligent research despite the differing conclusions.


r/HistoricalJesus • • Jan 17 '24

Question Hi, I'm an outsider and I hope I'm not intruding

10 Upvotes

I am an Orthodox Rabbi who chose for religious reasons to live anonymously for the past for 21 years so I'm as yet unfamiliar with the pathways of social media.

Our sages told us many moons ago, "Chachma bagoyim tamin, Torah bagoyim al tamin. -- If you are told that the other nations have human-gained-wisdom, Believe it! But if you are told that I, The One True God bestowed my personal instructions to any other nation, Do Not Believe It."

And this is how Judaism has been for 3,500 years.

Nobody respects Sir Isaac Newton more than our physicists, and no one loves Darwin more than our geneticists.

But while our every yeshiva boy knows that our grandest sage, Moses Maimonides, considered Aristotle to have been in many ways nearer to God than anyone who ever lived, even historian rabbis like myself can't easily come up with examples of even 4th rate historical rabbis studying the religious works of other faiths -- other than to refute them, of course.

My own view is one nearly impossible to thread the needle on.

To do so I would need to be like Paul, a Jew to Jews, and a Greek to Greeks.

But publicly. In the TikTok generation.

That seems an impossible thing to do as a single individual against the mob of a billion trolls, especially as I am, in a way, new to the internet.

It appears to me that The Christian Bible is, in reality, a slightly tampered but otherwise magnificent collection of Judaism Documents.

This "torah" among "The Goyim" may not be torah but it is an outgrowth of Torah, and that at least 95% of it originated in Judaism, and the closer you get to the Sermon On The Mount, the closer to an astonishing person and group whose words speak to us Jews alive in this world with you today.

At the same time, our appreciation to the Christian nations in general and to Christian individuals in particular extends only so far as our vast appreciation for your having had the WISDOM to preserve texts, traditionals, practices, and sentiments (to varying degrees across the ages, lol) that we Jews would have definitely otherwise lost.

So long as we are Israelites however we can never accept the idea that the ultimate GOD can be trifurcated, nor that the disappointedly imperfect world we see around us is one that post-dates the death (or "obscuration") of The Messiah, nor that "sin" is something that can be understood, quantified, punished or cleansed of through any means but the heart.

It's important to me in my communication with you to be as sincere and understandable possible while also emphasizing my own vulnerability.

This makes it nearly impossible for me to know the right words to use to describe the person I was when I made the following video.

For some communities the word "prophecy" implies nearly nothing, while in other communities it's nearly the equivalent of explaining to be the Alpha and the Omega, or else the surest sign of stupidity.

So I will let the video speak for itself.

Growing up ultra-orthodox, neither I nor any of my friends had ever danced. And certainly not tangoed, square-danced or salsa'ed.

And now, whether in one of your dens if iniquity (I kid!) or over at my place with all the men and women separately holding hands and almost-rhythmically sing-chanting as we run around and our separate circles, I'm asking you to please come and dance.

I have no idea how to reach the sort of Christians who would be interested in this letter and video.

Social media is a foreign language and Christian media, whether live, broadcast or on social media is to me a foreign language spoken with an accent.

So, having just joined reddit a week ago, I'm doing my hopefully efficient best asking you if you find this video interesting and worthy of your fellow's consideration to please do what I can not do, and take my message where it wants ro be heard.

I thank you my friends, with all my heart.

MY JEWISH JESUS: an urgent message


r/HistoricalJesus • • Dec 30 '21

Question What is the best book as a lay introduction to the historical Jesus?

10 Upvotes

I am not a historian. I am also not super interested in speculation of the form "historical Jesus was ____ which coincidentally aligns with my worldview". I am looking for an approachable but rigorous book laying out the case for why we believe Jesus existed. Thank you in advance.

Edit: the title should have been "historical evidence for Jesus" not "Historical Jesus".


r/HistoricalJesus • • Jan 02 '21

Book The Resurrection of Jesus: Apologetics, Polemics, History: Dale C. Allison, Jr.

Thumbnail
bloomsbury.com
10 Upvotes

r/HistoricalJesus • • Oct 22 '20

Discussion I find that I like the historical Jesus

10 Upvotes

I grew up in the Christian religion all my life and I was always skeptical of the idea of accepting Jesus as a real person without believing him to be God.

But after some time I've actually come to understand and admire a more practical Jesus who had a lot of good teachings besides miracles and theology.

The two videos really helped me out on this journey. https://youtu.be/XIBTi3wGrCc https://youtu.be/i2dZSMhMo9c

They aren't necessary to watch but they helped me a lot to come as far as I have in seeking the truth.

I would also love to have a discussion about how you came to believe that Jesus was an actual historical figure.


r/HistoricalJesus • • Nov 14 '19

Video Bart Ehrman & Robert Price Debate - Did Jesus Exist?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
10 Upvotes

r/HistoricalJesus • • Nov 08 '19

Book A Recent Response to Richard Carrier

10 Upvotes

For those interested, Richard Carrier was recently responded to, in depth, in a new publication by Dr. Litwa in his book How the Gospels Became History (2019). The dismantling is actually very sound and shows a lot of the methodological problems with Carrier's argumentation, such as his problematic and incorrect use of the Rank-Raglan (whose academic value he shows to be rather nihl), his complete misinterpretation of the Ascension of Isaiah, and his misuse of the dying-rising gods, who really don't even exist that much. It also critiques Bruno Bauer and Thomas Brodie as well.

I highly suggest picking the book up, as it definitely muzzles the bite of Carrier's argumentation.


r/HistoricalJesus • • Mar 10 '23

Article Jesus: a product of the class struggle in Galilee

Thumbnail
morningstaronline.co.uk
9 Upvotes

r/HistoricalJesus • • Jan 14 '23

Question Is there any film closest to the Historical Jesus?

9 Upvotes

I know that there are films which approach the story of Jesus from a more humanized perspective, thus distancing themselves from the Gospels (such as 'The Last Temptation of Christ' and 'Jesus Christ Superstar'). Even so, I believe these productions are more reinterpretations based on biblical texts than necessarily historical approaches to the real Jesus. Are there any films that can be considered the closest to the Historical Jesus?


r/HistoricalJesus • • Feb 15 '22

Video Did Jesus Make a False Prediction?

9 Upvotes

I just heard it claimed -- by Dr. Ali Ataie on "Blogging Theology" -- that Jesus' prediction of an imminent 'coming of the Son of Man' is something Mark put into Jesus' mouth, and not something that Jesus himself said.The claim was that Paul came up with the idea of an imminent return of Jesus, and Mark borrowed it from Paul and put it in Jesus' mouth. Thus, we can absolve Jesus of making a false prophecy.What do you all think of this explanation?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cJA_vXm8nEk


r/HistoricalJesus • • Jan 11 '21

Question What are all the secular none Christian sources for Jesus?

9 Upvotes

Hello, while doing my own research, I've seen somewhere that there could be as many as 12-18 early none christian sources for a historical Jesus, which even I find to be a massive stretch. If I remember correctly, I think there were 7 early sources for Julius Caesar when also using his letters as a source. (Please correct me if I am wrong)

Does anyone know what these lesser sources might be? I only know of the basic ones, like Josephus, Tacitus, Phlegon, Celsus, ect. What be interested to see what I could have missed and why they don't come up (assuming these supposed sources are true) when searched for online.


r/HistoricalJesus • • Dec 21 '20

Book Jesus the Apocalyptic Prophet: Cecilia Wassen & Tobias Hägerland

Thumbnail
bloomsbury.com
9 Upvotes

r/HistoricalJesus • • Nov 30 '20

Question How common was it for a first-century Jew to claim to be a descendant of David?

9 Upvotes

The Gospels of Matthew and Luke include separate genealogies of Jesus that claim him to be a descendant of King David. I'm not so concerned with how these genealogies came to be or how accurate they actually are. Obviously, they are included to bolster the messianic claims about Jesus. But I am curious about how common it would have been for people to claim to be a descendant of David, and how such claims would have been perceived and received.

  1. The way the Gospel of Luke presents it, Joseph, a common carpentry worker, has to travel to Bethlehem for the census because he is a descendant of the house of David. Would it have been unusual for a Jewish commoner to think of himself (or be thought of) as a descendant of the royal line? I think of, for example, a friend of mine who's an insurance agent who says he can trace his ancestry back to George Washington.

  2. Did other messiah claimants make similar claims? Were such claims a common political tool? If so how effective and powerful were they?

  3. Did Herod and his family claim to be descendants of the Davidic line? As I understand it, Herod was not really seen as a continuation of the House of David, but that had more to do with his relationship with the Romans.

  4. I'm curious about how such claims would have been perceived. Were they a dime a dozen? Would such a thing have actually been a big deal, or would it have been kind of similar to the way I react to the insurance agent friend of mine who says he can trace his ancestry back to George Washington (like, oh wow, that's cool, but I don't assume that mean you get to move in to Mount Vernon).

I cross-posted this question to /r/academicbiblical here: https://www.reddit.com/r/AcademicBiblical/comments/k411l1/how_common_was_it_for_firstcentury_jews_to_claim/


r/HistoricalJesus • • Oct 11 '20

Article Jesus Mythicism 7: Josephus, Jesus and the 'Testimonium Flavianum'

Thumbnail
historyforatheists.com
9 Upvotes