r/HistoricalFencing • • Feb 22 '23

Can we please stop the insults?

Post image
12 Upvotes

I was borwsing the internet the other day and stumbled upon a saber sparring match with really thin sabers, I simply asked if those were good enough to cut with, and one of them replied with this


r/HistoricalFencing • • Sep 17 '22

The claim edge blocking and flat blocking doesn't matter because swords will get damage anyway and that its better to just block with edge because its more convenient..........

1 Upvotes

For years the internet has taken John Clements belief that edge to edge parrying and blocking is BS because it damages the sword and its better to block with the flat of the sword because the sword gets damaged. Frequently pointed out is how Japanese styles use flat blocks rather than edge to edge blocking.

Now I know in recent years swordsmen, historians, and HEMAists such as Matt Easton are now calling BS on John Clement's claims because not only is there historical evidence of edge to edge defenses to the point even older schools of Japanese swordsmanship have texts showing it, but also because thesword will get damaged anyway and its much quicker and more convenient to block with the edge.

I agree John Clement's claim is BS at least in regards that only the flat should be used in blocking. However I did an experiment recently. I have an Arabian Scimitar short sword and a machete. I had a friend swing the machete at me which I would attempt blocks and parrying with the Scimitar. Now I notice first of all blocking and parrying using the edge DIRECTLY DAMAGED the sword in as early as the first blow and by the time I was finished the sword was so damaged you can see the once smooth blade had big chips in it. Cutting items became much more difficult and attempting to cut wood and meat doesn't slice it evenly anymore. Instead you see a razor zig zagging result with the cut item and what would take a single slice before would take several because the blade gets stuck in the item.

Secondly blocking and parrying was so difficult. Not only did many machete hits directly break through my blade and contacted my body but even successful blocks felt like it took so much of my strength especially single hand wielding stances. In addition counter attacking was near impossible in edge-to-edge defenses even quick ones like poking and wide regular blows you'd throw if you weren't in clinching swords together were near impossible.

Now I experimented with flat blocking. I was amazed how many hits it took to show any visible damage and even the visible damage wasn't chips or anything that would slightly affect sword usage but simply scratches and ruining the sword's painted art a little bit. In addition it was very easy to "redirect the opponent's force around esp back at them". By this I mean not only did it take minimal effort to block blows with a single hand but I felt it was easy to do further movements such as moving the sword in a circular movement so that you won't feel any impact from the hit. Going hand in hand with this because its so easy to direct the force counter attacks such as hitting with the hilt, slamming the flat on their face, and quick pokes were so so damn easy its ridiculous and I even found myself redirecting blows enough that my friend was wide open to regular wide sword swings. Even with I don't use force direction movements, it was pretty easy to tilt my friend to trip or something simply because blocking with the flat sent physics motion that made him unbalanced, even dropping the machete a few times. Without redirection, I can still easily counter attack with the flap by hitting with the cross guard or flap directly in a brute force push. When you add in using the second hand, it becomes easier done than said to do even advance techniques.

So I am wondering. With all the proponents about how the debate is useless and flat blocking shouldn't be used as primary defense because the sword will get damaged anyway and edge to edge is much quicker and easier to catch a blow in time, my experiment makes me skeptical of the recent counterarguments to Clement's conclusion. Trust me it took a single machete swing to chip my scimitar heavily and it was much easier using the flat for defenses than edge to edge defenses. It makes me think there's a lot of truth to Clement's statement and the recent HEMA experts who argue against it such as Matt Easton are wrong!

Can anyone clarify? I must point out I don't practise HEMA much (though I've been attending a school for 3 years) and my sword was a generic one bought at Ebay for $35. So I'm not sure if the chipping was due to poor quality or my lack of practise in swordsmanship.


r/HistoricalFencing • • Jun 26 '20

Does anyone think Spirtiuality/Magick/Mysticism/Occultism is very neglected in European swordsmanship (and martial arts in general)? Seeing how so much swordsmanship is steeped in Christian tradition such Catholic Saint devotions (esp prior to the Reformation)?

1 Upvotes

I just got a book by mail The Sicilian Blade by Vito Quattrochi.

Quattorchi's main specialization isn't martial arts but occultism. Specifically Catholic devotions. His most famous book is Benedicaria: Magical Catholicism which is basically about local Italian magick all revolving around the Roman Catholic framework.

Throughout his book on Sicilian knife fighting he frequently mentions prayer to Saint Michael. Even in his Benedicaria and other occult books, frequently he says to call Michael the Archangel not just for defense against demons, but even for physical protection (one of the prayers in the Benedicaria mentions something about praying to Michael to let the enemies knife miss stabbing at you).

So I think this is a very underlooked topic. I'm not a Roman Catholic but I was raised Anglican and one of my relatives specialized in the Anglo-Catholic tradition. So I'm quite familiar with basic Catholic stuff from his tutorship and in Catholicism many Saints are given patronages of not only war but even certain weapons like Sebastian bow and arrows and Maurice swords.

Without going into a ramble about Catholic theology, you seek a saint who is patron of a specific subject like say Raphael for healing and ask them in a prayer to intercede on your behalf (they pray to God asking for your request related to the subject). Hopefully God answers them. The stronger the Saint is a patronage of a subject, the more likely a response from God.

In addition being raised in an Anglican-Lutheran hybrid school of thought in my household, I read through lots of stuff about Protestant Reformation and plenty of stories about prayers to the Trinity for victory not only in battles during major conflicts like The Thirty Years Wars but prayer before and after duels, hanging biblical verses outside of barracks (and so I would assume same for fencing schools), holding the cross while resting, etc in the various stuff I was forced to read, watch, and so on as a child all the way to College Years. Nothing involving saints BTW since Lutheranism normally doesn't believe in intercession of the Saints.

I mean even ISIS are known to have an Imam quote Quranic verses not only before battle but even during training as well as play Adhan before and after training sessions. So if Iraqi swordsmen today are even using Islamic spirituality as part of their fencing traditions, why does HEMA and most Western fighting traditions seem to completely ignore this often very associated part of Asian martial arts?

I mean in a HEMA site they were even pointing out some Medieval and Renaissance schools have patron Saints and not only had prayers and candle devotions but blatantly used Christian symbols as part of their logos as well as Biblical verses in local languages!

If there's one reason that irks me so much about the lack of exploring occultism and mysticism in HEMA and western fighting traditions in general, its not the fact some local familial styles like Vito Quattrochi's family style is steeped with Christian tradition..............

Its the fact in a far away Eastern country in Asia called the Philippines often has devotions to Saint Michael as a common thing across their local arts' schools. Esp schools existing prior to "Eskrima" being created as an all-catch codification of Filipino martial arts, already predecessor styles Saint Michael statues commonly in whatever the Filipino equivalent of a dojo is called.

So why does HEMA as a whole and even Western fighting arts tend to neglect the religious and occultic aspects of European martial arts? Esp since intercessions of the Saints was so ubiquitous in Medieval and Renaissance society it permeated not just swordsmanship and unarmed martial arts but practically all across European society? I mean even illiterate peasant farmers knew about prayers to local Saints and how to light novena and the nobility saw it necessary to honor Mother Mary or else!

Bonus question-anyone who is Christians do you attempt to add back European mysiticism into your practise of HEMA esp Catholic devotions? Do any of you light novenas to Saint Michael the Archangel or read verses from a Calvinistic bible in between breaks at sparring sessions?


r/HistoricalFencing • • Feb 06 '23

Duel-Wielding Sickles

0 Upvotes

How would I go about learning how to dual-wield sickles? I would also like to add flashy elements into it such as spinning (the body) and what-not. Also being very acrobatic such as incorporating grappling, kicks, jumps, etc. I just can't really find anything about it online. Preferably, I'd like to master a mix between effectiveness and "flashy-ness." Of course, if it's even possible at all. From what I can tell, it may not be a thing in the first place. I'd just like some more info regarding this style.


r/HistoricalFencing • • Jul 01 '22

US M1840 Cavalry Saber Review

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/HistoricalFencing • • Feb 11 '21

It is universal esp in the West for knives to be the traditional weapons of Foot Archers. But in Mongolia and Northern China (which was influenced by Mongol warfare) and esp Japan with its Archer Samurai were armed with swords. Why the difference?

1 Upvotes

I saw this post.

If you have ever fired a bow, the sword hanging by your side could disrupt the movement if it is too long. They usually had a shot sword or dagger to counter this. But a knight in armor with a long sword and shield will womp on an unarmored bowman with a dagger any day in 5 seconds of melee combat.

Indeed the above post can be supported by the fact not only did European armies in particular most famously the English longbow men equipment with daggers instead of swords but across cultures from Arab armies to Aztec warriors to American Indian Raider and even within Asia as seen in from India to Vietnam and Java all the way to Korea, most archers were equipped with floaty close quarter weapons that were almost always shorter and lighter than your stereotypical Gladius. Often being pretty small featherweight knives that make the bowie knife feel like a barbell in comparison.

So I can believe the quoted post that the nature of bows and the hamper on pull and draw movements was the reason much lighter and less complete armor and light stuff like 1 lb 10 inch warclubs and 6 inch knives were the backup weapons of archers. But there is one loophole to this theory.................

Mongols as well as the foot archers of many Northern Chinese armies use regular length swords that are comparable to arming swords (well in the mongol's case they classically use sabers around the size of typical two handed blades like European longswords and katanas).

While the argument can be made that the Mongols rode on horseback thus negating the need to keep a sword by your waist and Chinese archers still used shorter lighter swords that are more similar to the short Gladius, the simple fact that the Samurai used bows that had similar power to European bows (with the most powerful drawing similar weights to English longbows and even being similar in size esp height) but still also used two handed blades like the katana and some even used longer Japanese swords sorta makes the quoted post a bit questionable.

So I have to ask why these cultures esp the Samurai footarchers are able to shoot fluidly without hamper despite having a proper sword by the side and often wearing armor? I mean I can easily believe the theory of daggers and similar short weapons being the main weapons of archers because of obstruction in movement because of how it is a universal pattern all across the world.

Yet the Samurai as well as Mongol cavalry and Chinese infantry contradict this pattern and are able to operate in formation of shooting volley fire after volley fire nonstop despite having swords as their backup melee. Why is this?

In particular what makes the English longbow so different that even a typical Gladius length weapon would make it unwieldy and many recruited yeoman even have knives less than a foot long?


r/HistoricalFencing • • Feb 10 '25

Myamoto Musashi vs Donald McBane

0 Upvotes

I'd pay millions to see that duel.


r/HistoricalFencing • • Apr 10 '22

Is a hammer + gauntlets (such as these pictured) viable to be fight against swords and other weapons?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/HistoricalFencing • • Nov 29 '21

理性探讨 传武群体擅长的 圆滑世故 体现在哪些方面?(附带太极剑技击对练)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/HistoricalFencing • • Mar 31 '25

our take on sprechfechten

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/HistoricalFencing • • Sep 10 '22

WAS THE STEREOTYPICAL GLADIUS COMPLETELY USELESS WITHOUT THE STEREOTYPICAL SCUTUM OR SOME OTHER RECTANGULAR SHIELD?

9 Upvotes

So many Sword Reconstructionist like ScholaGladiatoria Who Runs a Youtube Channel claim that the Gladius is one of the least effective swords on its own..... That a Gladius user will lose to other sword styles 95%+ of the time according to another Sword Revivalist Metatron on one of his Youtube videos........ But ScholaGladiatoria and Metatron and practically every other Historical European Martial Arts enthusiast online states when you add a rectangular Body size shield into the equation, the Gladius becomes one of the flatout most effective swords and easily a contender for most noob friendly with minimal moveset (think attacks commonly used in formations like stab stab maybe a few cuts stab so common in shield wall fighting)..........

But this brings one single but extremely significant detail.....................

What about infantry Scouts? And lone defenders in a military building like sentry towers and a small 3 story barracks? Cramped camps?

I bring this up because a o you can find on Reddit and Quora multiple users pointing out that Scouts not only would have been used to disorganized combat outside of formation but even single one on one fighting but a lot of times they'd even drop out shields because they'd be too difficult to bring across wild environments like rocky roads full of potholes and caves. Another user also pointed at during the Siege of Rome after the disaster at the Allia Battle, the Celts manage to sneak into a Rome past the watchtower and the Roman miltiai were int for a surprise and had to rush last minute to the hidden pathway the Celts were sneaking into, many of them leaving their shields behind as they rushed. They managed to hold off and force the more heavily armored Gauls who all had shields and other heavy stuff because they were fully pumped up for battle to retreat,killing a surprising so many that ultimately it was the straw that broke Brennus's back and after a female days with some skirmishes in between, he made truce to leave Central Italy in exchange for Gold.

So it makes me wonder how much the claim that a shield was necessary to fight with a Gladius even outside o formation is true? Considering the accounts of foot scouts in wars in the Middle East foot scouts would travel much lighter because of the heat including dropping large straps of armor and still defeating more individualistic warrior cultures like the Hebrew Zealots and Armenian cavalry harassers in unorganized out-of-formation fighting and a lot of sieges fighting in places too cramped for shields to be used like stairways across towers or inside a bedroom in a Roman barracks or at a bandit's lair climbing a steep hill into caves but Roman infantry still wininig without shields...........

Is this claim so common among HEMA and other historical sword recontructionists a massive hyperbole?


r/HistoricalFencing • • Jan 05 '22

Can you try something out for me?

1 Upvotes

Dear Hema comunity, we know very litten about the Group fighting that battles where. Which is the reason why there is an endless debate about it. The topic spear and shield is a battlefield on its own. Its all theorie and one person experiments. It would be awsome if sombody could just try it out.

Phalanx vs Phalanx. What Grip do you use? What depths? How does the gap width change the battle? What about swords? How effective can the second row acctually Support the first with spears?

Videos would be awsome.

Overhand Grip:


r/HistoricalFencing • • Oct 18 '25

Sparring critique please. I'm the guy with the painted mask.

0 Upvotes

r/HistoricalFencing • • Nov 09 '22

Historial Fencing international championship match! These two fighters are some of the best.

Thumbnail
imgur.com
4 Upvotes

r/HistoricalFencing • • Dec 17 '22

Be thankfull, for I have blessed the internet with this meme

Post image
53 Upvotes

r/HistoricalFencing • • May 20 '22

so any tournaments to use a claymore?

4 Upvotes

Just what the title says, i loooove that weapon.


r/HistoricalFencing • • Jan 15 '24

If you do HEMA learn foil! basics of European martial art- Uncomfortable truth for historical fencer

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

r/HistoricalFencing • • Nov 13 '23

Longsword vs rapier - for one shot

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/HistoricalFencing • • Mar 26 '22

title

1 Upvotes

Anyone know of any good hema schools in Hungary? I've been wanting to get into it, but I don't know where to find a practitioner, especially one that speaks english cause I don't understand hungarian.


r/HistoricalFencing • • Jan 14 '22

Have you ever wanted to see yourself immortalized as a cartoon character? Check out my comission portraits @ www.halbschwert.de/shop

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/HistoricalFencing • • Jan 06 '23

Way of the Sword: Battojutsu sparring duel best moments

Thumbnail
youtu.be
13 Upvotes

r/HistoricalFencing • • Jun 17 '25

Does holding the the upper part of the blade (if not the tip) with the offhand to manipulate the blade and aim with precise and stronger thrusts and stabs a thing actually done with rapiers?

0 Upvotes

I'm too lazy to look for real life examples and to get into verbose details of needless pargraphs to describe a specific technique from Katana styles. So I'll just link a vclip from a popular animated series from Japan (which in turn came from a popular comic book by a sword enthusiast).

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wa3no6yMx8s

Now the clip explains everything. Use your other hand to hold the sword's blade at its uppermost section if not even the tip of the sword itself, to add precision, leverage, and more powerful to thrusting and stabbing attacks. Even use the same exact grip on the blade to manipulate more specific techniques as shown in the above exaggerated and unrealistic cartoon fight scene! With various different ways of holding it with your non sword-wielding way as one of the fighters did in vid from holding it at its flat side to holding it from the top part of the blade and inversely on the bottom side. If not even at the poky tib itself .

Which is an actual real techniques from Japanese sword arts to the point some styles specialize in it (and thats the basis of where the author of the original comics the linked animation came from based the policeman's fighting methodology).

And I seen similar things in random Medieval fight texts esp for arming swords. Also seen it done in Hong Kong Kung Fu movies. Which makes me wonder.........

Did this kind of offhand grips exist in rapier martial arts and other similar weapons from which modern olympic fencing originated from? If so then how come it doesn't seem to be emphasized? I find it strange the translated beginner's stuff I seen don't feature similar use of the non-dominant hand holding the uppermost of the blade for more effective thrusts and to manipulate specific techniques considering how much the rapier is deemed as the epitome of thrusting swords. If this actually was a thing in rapier and other sibling weapons like the epee and smallsword, who are some masters who emphasized this approach and what are goo HEMA texts on these kind of techniques?


r/HistoricalFencing • • Sep 09 '23

Fireblood has been practicing for two big tournaments in October and November!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/HistoricalFencing • • May 01 '26

Learn Real Sword Fighting in Lower Kingswood & Epsom Surrey - Train in a Living Martial Tradition

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/HistoricalFencing • • 27d ago

Huntsfeld dagger lower attacks

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes