Personally, what I find most interesting about every single Ramayana (and Mahabharata as well, but we'll address that some other day) debate is that the Raita (because there isn't a true Right-Wing/Conservative wing in India) types get it as wrong as the feminist-Marxists (because, sadly, India doesn't have an honest Liberal wing as well).
The Cultural Marxists (and Feminists, who are just Sexual Marxists), informed by the almost-discredited Aryan Invasion theory and its spawn- the Dravidian movement- project onto Ravana some kind of oppressed, mool nivasi, Scheduled Caste anti-hero when he could not have been more antithetical to that even if he consciously tried- he came from the most blue-blooded Brahmin stock, being great-grandson of Brahma himself, and son and grandson of Vedic rishis. The Marxist haters of meritocracy and masculinity should get an aneurysm on realising that Ravana was the most "Brahminical" and "toxically masculine" product of meritocracy overriding all types of group dynamics considerations.
Similarly, Raita-s, who are but a mediocre cross-breed of fascists and communists in Saffron variant (or as I like to call them 'Saffron Soviets') collapse him into a uni-dimensional, horny old lecher whose only activity worth mentioning was abduction of Sita (they didn't even know about his previous exploits with Vedavati, Rambha et al until Guru-s and genuine scholars like Sri Guru started talking about it). They labour hard to ignore that he was a PhD-level scholar AND polymath in multiple disciplines, ranging from music to astrology to warfare to Ayurveda to occult; he was the second-greatest Yogi in human embodiment after Sri Krishna, and he is legitimately WORSHIPPED- the way we worship Ganapati and Saraswati and Krishna- in certain southern Indian Shaiva traditions as one of the greatest Shiva bhakta-s of all time.
The second folly of Raita-s, who, again, being feminists by instinct themselves and not true right-wingers, forget that the world doesn't start and collapse with sexual agency of individual women, and therefore mistakenly assume that Ravana's greatest folly, his fatal flaw, was "touching" Sita and that the moment he did that, his fate was all-but-sealed irreversibly, because "consent" is the universal holy grail of all time. Nothing in any traditional rescension of Ramayana claims that. Even obliquely.
Ravana's actual folly, as opposed to feminist-sollipsistic interpretation of the story, had very little to do with "consent", "women's agency", or anything remotely sexual; at best, it was like tax rates in a capitalist democracy- be good if you get it right, but tax rates by themselves have never collapsed a civilization, empire, Kingdom, or even a fiefdom of few square miles!
This isn't to say that Ravana wasn't a sexual predator- he surely was- or that he didn't have it coming when he blindedly waded into a death-match with Sri Rama- be certainly did; but this IS to definitely disabuse today's feminists of the notion that the unicorns called "women's agency" and "consent" are such powerful-and-yet-simultaneously-innocent creatures that an offence against them is, in itself, sufficient to upend everything else and condemn everything to hell. And Ravana's own history, when looked at by a non-feminist lens (including that of Raita-s), is the greatest testament to that.
Ravana was a sexual predator-cum-conquistador from the very beginning- but so was every other warrior of his time, and, in fact, all warriors of all times. Look up what war brides are. And how many of Hindu mythological and historical figures had them without the universe falling apart at seems. Even Hanuman witnesses thousands and thousands of war brides in Ravana's harem when he is scouting the place and does.... Nothing about them, because, in the grand calculus of the universe that he was acting upon, they didn't matter. Not immediately or even primarily, at least.
Vedavati was not an ordinary woman that Ravana 'violated' or 'polluted' (I'm not sure if any text bluntly mentions him raping her; as far as my memory serves, he only got as far as grabbing her hand)- she was, at the very least, an extremely powerful Yogini, and one of the Purana-s (I'm forgetting which one) even claims that she was an avatara of Lakshmi herself who was doing tapasya to reunite with Vishnu when he interrupted that. Now, as much as feminists might hate to hear it, disruption of tapasya of a great Yogini and tapaswini, and that too an avatar of wife of Lord of the Universe, is a far greater sin than rape of a mere mortal woman- or even thousands of them. THAT'S what Ravana's folly with Vedavati was- that in his lust, he tried to meddle with the very fabric of universe, for which he was cursed. And even with that, notice how Vedavati's curse (as opposed to the one that he gets later with Rambha and others) isn't very short-term or acute or direct- she swears that she will take a rebirth to 'cause' his destruction and then immolates herself, most likely in the fire of her own Chittagni. Notwithstanding that getting cursed by an avatara and a Yogini in her last moments should have been enough of a wake up call for Ravana to clean up his act, Raita-s who refuse to acknowledge and concede his greatness need to ask themselves why one of the primary shakti-s of the universe not only didn't take him out despite offending her personally and causing disruptions in universal designs, but left him with a curse so anodyne that let alone Ravana, it would be difficult for anyone even remotely tipsy on power and accomplishments to take it seriously! The reason was that this was Ravana's first offense THAT MATTERED, NOT his first sexual offense, because it tampered with universe itself; however, him being the greatest mortal Yogi in existence at the time (Sri Krishna was yet to be born) meant that even when he fiddled with universe itself to satiate his horniness, even one of the primary 'showrunners' of the universe itself could all but threaten him with future consequences, not cause him immediate harm- such was the intensity of his Yoga!
And yet it took two more curses- of Punjikuthsala and Rambha/NalaKubera- to finally make him vulnerable to power of curses enough to make him desist from raping Sita outright and instead forcing him to wait out her loyalty and commitment to Sri Rama.
And those two curses are in thermselves very nuanced (and interesting, from Yogic POV, beyond Dravidian-Raita binary braying). At rhe first glance, they look the same- if Ravana ever raped a woman again, his head would explode in a thousand pieces and even blessings of Shiva, Brahma, multitudes of occult protections extended to him by the loyalty and commitment of Mandodari, and his own Yogic powers will not be able to save him from that fate. But that begets the very basic question that why would two celestial beings need to curse him with the same fate! The reason is that, to the consternation and outrage of feminist-solipsistic and allied Raita worldview, all sexual offenses are not the same and therefore curses inconsummate to the offense can't really do much harm- particularly when the victim of the curse is also not of stature high enough to bridge the gap between gravity of the offense and gravity of the curse.
The apsara (celestial nymph) Punjikuthsala was the first giver of head explosion curse. While she later went on to be born as Anjana, mother of Hanuman, but as Punjikuthsala, neither was she of Vedavati's stature i.e. a Yogini or an avatara, to completely pierce the metaphorical armour of myriad blessings and powers that Ravana wore with more insufferable self-cnogrtulatory smugness than Karna wore his actual impenetrable armour a few millennia later, nor was the offense- merely stripping off her clothes and adordnments but not the actual rape- cataclysmic enough to do the job. Unlike feminists and their raita allies, the universe DOESN'T think that all grievances- however legitimate- to "women's agency" are the same and should carry equal punishement.
Ravana's protection finally gave way to vulnerability to curses when he ACTUALLY committed a full-scale sexual assault/rape against a celestial being in the Rambha/NalaKubera episode. NalaKubera was his own nephew- son of his half-brother Kubera who was also incidentally a Shiva Bhakta (specifically, he is associated with Swarnakarshana Bhairava)- and therefore Rambha was not just a celestial being but his own daughter-in-law which compounded the gravity of his offense exponentially.
However, even then, Ravana was NOT cooked irreversibly- all he got as immediate comeuppance of raping his own daughter-in-law, who also happened to be a celestial being, was yet another future if-but curse, although the wiggle room had shrunk remarkably- the NEXT TIME he would rape a woman would be his last time he raped a woman.
Still nothing in the universe's rulebook said that any woman could retroactively withdraw consent if they gave it in the moment under whatever be the reason- something the Cornell chick, accusers of MJ Akbar, Ujjwala Sharma, and all other women who were NOT pinned forcibly like Rambha and ACTUALLY RAPED need to reflect upon!
Even in the Sita episode, consider a counter-factual: what if Sita had finally given in, or if Ravana had managed to either intimidate or seduce or trick her (I think I did read in some version that he produced fake heads Sri Rama and Lakshmana but Sita refused to believe that Sri Rama could be dead if she herself had not died). Would he still have been the villain of the story? For feminists and raita-s, maybe, but not for the universe.
Even after Sita's abduction, he was offered multiple off-ramps by Sri Rama, Hanuman, Angad et al- and if he had taken them, he would have gotten away with Sita's abduction.
His mortal sin, that did him in (sorry, could not resist), was neither Sita's abduction nor Rambha's rape- like I said, universe gives a lot of rope to Yogi-s of hsi stature, at least in the shorter terms. His death came from the refusal to return Sita, because returning Sita meant accepting Sri Rama's martial superiority over him, which was something he was unable to comprehend. Like Sri Guru said in one of his famous analyses of Ravana, his was the failure of imagination.
In a story, the main job of the villain is to bring out the greatest qualities of the hero by the ways of contrast- and if Sri Rama is the maryada Purushottama (which is NOT monogamy purushottama, consent purushottama, morality purushottama, etc.), then for appreciating his maryada, it is equally important to understand the places where Ravana failed to uphold the maryada, which was ultimately his fatal flaw- the apamaryada, transgression of maryada.
Ravana failed in the maryada of the king- a king is supposed to keep his subjects safe, even at the cost to his person, in exchange of the subjects' total surrender of sovereignty to him, not endanger their lives for his own personal gain. He failed the maryada of a military commander- a general should ask his soldiers to go and die in the battle in defense of the country only when all other options of keeping civilians safe have been exhausted- that was not the case with Lanka and he could have easily kept the civilians of Lanka safe without needing to send his soldiers to the meat grinder that was Hanuman, if he had returned Sita. He also failed the maryada of a father and older brother- he sent his sons and younger brother to die before him, that too when they had nothing to gain from the cause of the war aka Sita and they were consistently against her abduction and repeatedly exhorted him to return her and save the family and country from total ruin and extinction. Hard as it is to believe that this would count, he failed the maryada of a husband as well- on one hand, Mandodari was a sati totally devoted to him and in love with him so much that her love had been one more additional layer to his armour, and on the other hand, he constantly kept offering to Sita that should latter accept his proposal of discarding Sri Rama and marrying him, he would set Mandodari aside and make Sita his primary queen. I don't have any scriptural backing for it, but I would like to think that among his various levels of apamaryada, paying back loyalty and commitment with this level of disregard and contempt was his worst sin, and if there was one single mortal sin that should have done him in, it ought to be this.
The point of this essay is neither to excuse Ravana's bad behaviour nor to argue against Ramayana's fundamental proposition that by the time Sri Rama slew him, he was more harm than net good in the universe. But Ravana is inarguably a success story of this culture, of Hindu civilization, of Yoga itself- we don't know which Yoga was Ravana's primary sadhana, but we do know that it was Yoga that he did. Through Yoga, and his own efforts, his relentless pursuit of power and excellence and ambition, he went from a mere mortal chieftain of a tribe of defeated asura-s to elevating himself to a status where the greatest of the gods like Lakshmi had to bide their time to exact their vengeance upon him or had to push down a whole mountain to prevent him from carrying them back home with himself. He also created an empire that was as successful and glorious among empires as he was among individuals- and a personally accomplished and talented king being able to create and lead an empire as successful as himself is in itself a feat very rare, if not totally unheard of.
He is THE villain of Hindu civilization, of Yogic worldview, for sure, but he is also exhibit 1A of the accomplishments of the very same. He is as much an inspiration of what we can accomplish as he is a cautionary tale of the ways in which we can fail despite succeeding.
And to throw him away lock-stock-and-barrel just because cultural Marxists or Dravidianists are trying to appropriate him is just foolish, and emblematic of how we fail to understand our own culture and literature.
It also shows how afraid are we to own success if it does not come in good-boy straitjacket that feminists and other weakness-worshippers have taught us to be the only kind of success worth embracing and celebrating- or even acknowledging. Adn what else can such a culture, neurotically terrified of success and its shadows, produce except the likes of MK Gandhi and his followers, whose every concept- from "ahimsa" to "celibacy" and "truth experiments" is nothing but a terrified pervert's philosophical inversion of success and accomplishments?
#ramayanaruminations
#mythologymusings