I read Hills Like White Elephants in class recently and throughly enjoyed it. But when we were discussing the story after the fact I found there were points of contention between me and a couple of girls in the class.
I subscribed to the idea that it was a love story about two people having a disagreement. The two didn't seem to hate each other. They mentioned things were fine between them before the pregnancy. Further, The Amercian didn't want to pressure Jig into doing something she didn't want to do, while Jig didn't want to go against her boyfriends wishes. Overall, despite obvioues tension in their relationship, it seemed to two did love eachother and were just trying to work through this hard decision. In other words, I thought the stories core theme was about how romantic relationships are often complicated and divisive.
The two girls however had a diffrent interpriation. They found the American to be an abusive figure who was controling Jig. They noted he seemed older than her, and found his insisting going against her wishes. They didn't find any chemistery or passion between the two. This could perhaps be supported by the fact Jig mentions all they do is drink instead of talk, the fact that the American clearly met her on the road while visting Europe, and her name suggesting she is some sort of dancer or even a sex worker.
At first I thought my interpretation was misfounded. Since I didn't really understand the story was about abortion at first and because my teacher liked the girls interpreation more. But after rereading the story on my own a couple of times, I felt that I was indeed correct. I didn't get the impression they hated each other. I do think the Amercian loved her and was being as supportive as possible while making his stance clear. The two seemed mixed on the matter. I don't think either was completly sure. My therapist agreed with this analysis when I asked her about it.
So that leaves me with a question. Which interpretation is correct? Mine or the girls? I admit gender might lead too a bit of a bias here. Men may be more likely to sympathize with the man while gals are more likely socrn him. I also think your stance on the abortion debate will have something to do with it. But I'm open to all opinions, along with links to essays on the story.
Edit-I misspelled relationship in the title. I hate myself.