... at least I hope so. Always open for things to add that I have missed, so please comment!
Some of you will probably have already seen my copypastas "goto" answers for people asking for antenna tips... So here it is, the textwall of doom, which hopefully gets more improvement over time...Bear with me tho on this journey, because I am not the best explainer and no native english speaker- Also I often make typos and mistakes- I am by no means a Scientist or a certified Expert on this, just a dedicated mad boy. As a disclaimer: If you know some HAM radio Nerd in your neighbourhood that will point out something in my explanations as wrong, he is probably right by 99,999%... No one is more proficient into antennas then a long time hobby radio guy... their advice is to be taken as "pure gold" and if you get one of 'em hooked on your project, you got an expert at your fingertips!
So let the ride begin
You should research a bit on antennas, its worth it.
I hope this will help:
===Dilemma===
In simple pictures, less dbi means more ball shaped, high dbi means more flat out elyptic. So while 8 dbi will reach further, 4 dbi will reach higher and deeper. There is no "best" antenna and no "overkill" antenna because it depends on usecase.
case A
flat land, no builings, no trees, few population = "probably" / "maybe" 8bi better
case B
hills, mountains, trees, high buildings, dense population = "probably" / "maybe" 3-4bi better
You (generally speaking, easy & fast) never want an "angle" antenna no 90° no 180° - always omnidirectional !!! (See specific agenda info No.1!!!)
And not Wifi or 2,4 Ghz... always LoraWan - 868 Mhz EU 915 Mhz Us, Mhz range is different for each country.... (again generalizing- there are ofc Antennas that are wlan but can be used but lets keep it simple)
and there are mixed cases- if you live in an area like case A but you got a city near water at -10m level where the other miners are, you probably prefer 4 dbi over 8 dbi... etc.
yeah and if you area is flat but some miners 12km away lie on + 20 altitude, you would prefer a 10dbi antenna on a 12 m pole... then its not overkill, just the thing that you need.
In a dense city with many miners you always want lower dbi like 3. because buildings reflect and anything over 50 miners wont affect you much anyway...
there is not only one answer to this
=== Solution ===
which antenna is the best, can't be calculated beforehand- too many variables.
There is a good and cheap way to do it-
Run the miner with stock antenna for a week so you got solid data. Only then buy a good Antenna 8 dbi- test it for 5 days and if its better keep it, else return it (should be possible within 14 days)- If you return it maybe try a 5,8 or 6,5 dbi- but if thats shit too and you return it, I would not bother testing anything else and simply use the stock antenna.
=== where to buy ===
Also here there is not one answer to this + shilling only certain brands is problematic imo
The basic thing is, you got all the info here (somewhere in my wall of text) to probably buy a working antenna, and the rest is up to personal preference.
I do like cheap noname product Sellers on ebay, but I also like quality products. So while I am no expert on all antennas out there that exist, I can at least give some insight on my personal purchases.
I bought two different antennas from each two different sources. Generally people tend to speak for the rakwireless antennas, because they are from a reputable seller and known to work without issues. Depending on Bundle you can make good deals, especially since they will include brackets and pigtails, but for the sake of comperabilty I will give them following prices only for the antenna (factoring in bundle price)- 5.8 DBI for 50$ and 8 dbi for 60$- I bought 3 each- All fine, they work and look good. Now I also bought antennas from the cheapest on ebay (overall 20 pcs)- 10 dbi for 20$ and 7 dbi for 15$ ... Funny enough as usual there is some "bad advertisement flaws" on those, and in reality- checked with measuring instuments, the 10 dbi only has 8 dbi.. and the 7 dbi only has 5.6 dbi. Well while that might throw shade towards them it makes for perfect comparison. Both 8 dbi's and both roughly 6 dbi's work exactly the same and as a matter of "which is better" theres only left to say that for mining and range, the cheap no name antennas are simply on par with the branded ones. They are far cheaper and yes, the branded ones look nicer and have higher build quality and sealant overall. So if the cheaper are really worse, it will need more time to show. So far after 6 month, theres no evidence yet to prove that the more expensive ones are better on the long term.
It rly depends- if you are willing to take the risk, just try the cheap ones- If you like high quality and want peace of your mind, probably go with branded ones...
=== sacrificing indoor secure placement to gain advantage in less antenna cable length ===
Pretty plain and logic. While you miner gonna be safer indoors and easier to maintain, it introduces cable lenght DBI loss on the antenna.
So there are risks but also alot to gain by outdoor placement... The lenght of the electric power cable or the ethernet cable causes no issues whatsoever, at least not like the antenna cable.
Also there are POE solutions, with power over Ethernet, that can actually mean you only need a long ethernet cable to the miner... probably in some safe weatherproof box on the Antennamastpole. You probably gain the advantage of using a very shot antenna cable with almost no DBI loss...
But yeah you gotta evaluate the easy of maintenance, cost of casing and while not yet much is known about that, measures against too low temperature in winter or to high in summer.
=== indoor miner with indoor antenna ===
You want to place an indoor miner with indoor antenna high and at a window-
You dont use outdoor high gain antenna for indoor usage - like 5 dbi and more because they perform bad- The higher the DBI on an outdoor antenna is, the worse it will perform when used indoors!
There are some tricks to get an advantage without outdoor mounts and holes to drill in the wall... Like using a special flat "window-frame-pass-trough-cable" and then flextape an Antenna outside your window....
But generally speaking, if you are absolutely limited to indoor usage, there is a high chance the stock antenna will perform best for you... potential pofitable gains are involvin a lot of experimentation and testing...
=== height and line of sight above all !!! ===
This info is somewhere infused all over this text I hope, but I want to make it more clearly specificly! If you start to get mathematical on you equipment, tinker with ideal cabling and antenna- again you want to always keep an eye on the simplest of all facts:the higher the better!line of sight matters like... A LOTand funny enough, the higher you place your antenna it usually will get a better line of sight too, so its a double improvement!Probably worth intoucing a bit cable length DBI loss, if you get that badboi higher up!Antenna poles are a good investment!Also again an argument to be made for outdoor enclosures for miners via POE cable- where it wont matter that the ethernet cable is 5m longer if it means the antenna cable is 5m shorter and therefore less DBI loss.
=== dont make it crazy ===
There are many ways to overkill such a project... If you make a Solar powered, Battery backed, Sattelite Net connected, high adanced military grade bullet proof cased, elite antenna whatsoever monstrosity... you gonna probably gain alot of karma by posting us the pictures, but paid ten times more then anyone other mining the same amount...
there are also other ways to kill your own project... like people being so obsessed to not loose DBI on their cable, that they did the ultimate solution- no cable, direct outdoorantenna to miner... And then they cried because a little movement broke the antenna connector out of the miners case.
While there is a huge difference in cable length DBI loss, keep it simple... it is in fact a big deal to have 10 foot cable instead of 30 foot cable... But dont break a leg to go from 5.5 to 5.0 foot.
(See specific agenda info No.2!!!)
Keep things reasonable and dont pay too much!!!
=== related info and copypasta ===
Height and elevation are your friend. You might “overshoot” nearby hotspots (or you might not), but you will cover a much larger area with few obstructions - and in theory participate in a larger number of challenges.
You will lose 0.039 dbi for every foot of LMR 400 cable. So if you can reach all other miners that are within your antennas maxrange anyway, there is no pint in increasing the Mastpole even higher, since it woul increase cablelength to and with it more signal loss. Gaining level at every cost is rather interesting for outdoorsetups without the cable length issue and also introduces again the overshooting problem.
DO NOT overtighten the connectors fom miner to antenna cable, or antenna cable to antenna, or simply antenna to miner! They should be firm, but only handtight... overtigthening often causes bad connectivity with signal loss and also could damage the metal anchored thread in the plastic casing!
DO NOT detach/replace your antenna while your hotspot is still powered on.
DO turn off your hotspot before removing/replacing any antenna on your device.
DONT DO dual antenna setups on a single antenna miner-
you could (technically) but you should not (realistically)-
Using two antennas with some sort of splitter or cloner will give both a relative high DBI loss at least, sometimes even cause interferences between them- therefore simply using one antenna that is best for your locations usecase is far smarter and will give better results in reach and stability.While there is a possibility to actually do that setup with "profit" in gain, its not feasable for most...(See specific agenda info No.3!!!)
=== Connector Dilemma RP-SMA vs. SMA (non RP) ===
Also a thing that happens more often then people think are wrong connectors-
because while you should use RP-SMA female to RP-SMA male and also SMA female to SMA male because thats the only way things will contact, people sometimes dont look properly and funny enough RP-SMA male can be connected to SMA- male or RP-SMA female to SMA female... will fit perfectly but give bad signal
50% of trheads that are like "My new high quality outdooantenna is worse then the stock one" are caused by this very connector poblem.
=== resources ===
Here are some resources that might help you visualize your situation
rough placement guide = https://kyk13.com/a-rough-guide-to-helium-hotspot-placement/
antennas for helium = https://kyk13.com/antennas-for-helium/
Mhz in my country? = https://www.thethingsnetwork.org/docs/lorawan/frequencies-by-country/
Coold guy with cool setup = https://www.reddit.com/user/SFMBB/
using mapping tool = https://youtu.be/42KkIQubgSo
=== specific agenda added info ===
### No. 1 ###
Always omnidirectional-
While living at a beach a 180° angle might logically be enough, a good lorawan 180° angle will be far more expensive then an omnidirectional...Depends on the specific antenna, but AFAIK, at the current moment in our time space continuum... its not about logical facts or physics here, it is only about Price!!! (could change ofc any moment and ofc maybe I missed something but:)
I mean not just far more expensivebut faaaaaaaaaaar more expensive
while technically a focussed antenna "could" reach further, just if you compare a high quality product like the rakwireless 8dbi antenna for roughly 70 bucks... the current cheapest 180° I saw with roughly thesame reach costs like 2k. So yeah dunno where the benefit is there... there are not many models out there, also they are sold for industrial purpose. One I saw like two month ago was 140° and had impressive stats like a impact median of 10km and max range at 35km... pretty dope, could be yours for a measily 25k haha just the cabeling and electric powersupply would cost another 2k.
Its simply currently not feasable. The only thing that might be interesting might be yagi antenna to snipe that one single other miner at 7km, but then again I think the miner might register it and block it... since thats not the idea of coverage- in terms of the HNT Networks greater goals.
Generally the miners are known to reject too high power antennas (so it remains the peoples network an is not abused by big tech) so you really don't want to go too wild with antennas- just take somehing that is known to work an cheap.
In fact there are some cheap angle antennas, like 40-70° but again you really want to know what you do here!!! It may need adjustment (to "aim") or has only niche application (long streched valley with high mountains)... you might want to setup an omni antenna maybe also for future reliabilty (now you may only have two miners north, but maybe you will get another one south too, etc)
### No. 2 ###
This is a very scientific complicated topic, usually something probably a HAM radio Nerd could answer far better then me.
The answer is kinda "yes but no"
but rather accept is as a no..
Becaues while in fact lets say a 8 dbi antenna with a very flat elypse signal, will loose reach and even "gain some height an depth", it is proportionally no where near the pure dbi Signal and also some distortions are introduced. It wont affect Signal density which kinda is also bad.
Or I try a different approach on this:
To make it easier lets say we got a 4 dbi antenna vs. a 8 dbi with -4 Signal loss.
So the pure 4 will have over all still a better and "rounder" ballshape then the 8minus4... and while the horizontal reach is almost the same, the 4 is more stable and denser in signal which will effectively introduce more randomness with the 8minus4 when it comes to "targets" at maxrange...
Generally speaking, Signal loss is really not worth to get mad over if the difference is like 0,039 vs. 0,082 .... but yeah, if we are talking like -2 or -3 dbi, thats the point where you have to go a different route, that is the absolute no fun zone.
### No. 3 ###
I have briefly mentioned the dual Antenna setup, but to further elaborate: See, generally speaking if you put "any" two Antennas on the splitter, theres like a 97% chance you will have 20%- 30% dbi loss on both antennas...
While there are ways to achieve "potential 3 dbi gain" it is something I know but do not want to bring it up... to save us all frustration and the decend into madness
Its not only you need perfect cables, perfect length, perfect potential balancing- you also need to choose two very specific antennas and really get technical and mathematical to pull this off.
But it is simply nothing for the "avarage HNT miner".... so I leave that to the people who got that one crazy HAM radio nerd friend... To quote my friend https://www.reddit.com/user/SFMBB/ here: "RF engineering is *definitely* the dark art of electrical engineering... it's exhausting to research and experiment with."
Because while it is possible, its not probably feasable- people here will want it and get frustrated....
- theres simply too much to go wrong on this
Finally:招財進寶 aka: Bring in wealth and riches... Happy mining and let the Helium be with you!