r/HarryPotterGame • • Feb 12 '23

Discussion Thoughts?

I'm about 60% through the main story.

Starting to get a bit bored now. The game feels a bit hollow. The "RPG" elements and dialog choices just feel so insignificant.

The game is good, I'd say a 7/10.

What do y'all think?

35 Upvotes

169 comments sorted by

138

u/TheDreamLightDude Slytherin Feb 12 '23

From a little to no interest in Harry Potter perspective it's a 7/10

From the perspective of avid fan I am, 10/10. But only because I can connect so much to the world.

13

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

Thats fair, I loved Harry Potter as a kid. Its a great world they have built for sure!

5

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

I’d say probably a 6 or 7/10 from a non HP fan perspective too. As a BIG HP fan that’s read and listened to the books more time than I can count, it’s a 8.5/10. It’s a great game and i’m really enjoy it but i do have so issues and things I wish they’d done differently.

61

u/TheFlexOffenderr Ravenclaw Feb 13 '23

I've got 42 hours stapled down so far and it's about an 8/10 for me in terms of gameplay and story but from inner Harry Potter fan is screaming with delight at how much lore is really explored and how detailed the game is. If I had to base it off my bias it'd be a 10.

9

u/unluky10 Feb 13 '23

As a longtime HP fan and an avid gamer I really struggled to get through the first few hours of gameplay because it just felt slow to me but once the world opened up more beyond, "go to this class" I really started to like it and now I'm 35 hours in. The world is amazing and the combat can be a lot of fun there just isn't enough of it early. I recently played God of war 2018 and GOW:Ragnarok so maybe I was expecting too much for the story in this one.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

I feel the same way. The game started a bit slow too, but I loved that because it allowed me to soak in how great the castle is designed.

As a Harry Potter fan who loved the first few games, I haven’t had this much fun in a AAA game for a very long time.

79

u/any-name-untaken Feb 12 '23

As a game? Probably 7/10. As an experience (biased as a fan of the franchise), 9/10.

76

u/AdFantastic6606 Feb 12 '23

I think they will improve upon it. The foundation is set, they have all the assets they need.

Hopefully the next game has a morality system and deeper rpg mechanics besides equip the highest gear

-4

u/DShadows98 Feb 13 '23

But how can they improve in the next game? They cant change the map, maybe add some new parts but Hogwarts will stay the same and most of the map. Also they can't add many spells since they used most of the ones that exist in the universe. I guess they could add some new beasts and plants but what else? They could focus and make great and long story, they are very limited with other stuff because they have already implemented a lot. That is my point. I hope we get more games ofc but seems unlikely if you ask me.

29

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

I feel like it's more unlikely that this won't become a series. They can easily add other parts of the Wizarding World plus Hogwarts. Ministry of Magic, Godrics Hollow, Diagon Alley. All the other schools as well. Hell, they could even do London. There's plenty they can do to add to the sequel.

11

u/Useful_Temporary8617 Ravenclaw Feb 13 '23

Yeah, location wise there are a lot of other options, although Hogwarts is certainly the most memorable and important from the books.

I do agree that it’s a bit difficult to add more spells and stuff though, we have the majority of the ones that I can see being easy to implement in a fun way, so the next game would have to be heavily location and story based. Although, I don’t necessarily think that’s a bad thing I love exploring this game, and it would be awesome to have another one!

6

u/Chadolf Feb 13 '23

yep, uoagadou keeps being mentioned (please excuse my spelling). im hoping there is a triwizard tournament in the next one (if there is a sequel with all this backlash) and we get to visit beuxbatons, durmstrang and ouigado along with open maps around those areas, it would be magical

3

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

I have a good feeling we'll see a sequel. The backlash isn't as big as the Twitter echo chamber is making it seem.

18

u/ishouldvoicemario Hufflepuff Feb 13 '23

Better NPC interactions and animations. More variety in gear and cosmetics. Morality system that impacts the story. Consequential decision making. More fleshed out relationship system. QUIDDITCH. Pets. New locations (London, Diagon Alley, etc.).

Just to name a few. There’s always room for improvement.

9

u/gsa9 Hufflepuff Feb 13 '23

I’m really enjoying the game so far, but it’s not perfect. It can certainly use some improvements as mentioned with the morality system which would open up a lot more options. Also could use a better character customizer, quidditch, more accurate facial animations, more spells, and of course more locations.

4

u/Chemical_Zucchini_14 Ravenclaw Feb 13 '23

They could also delve more into ancient magic, like what other forms it can come in, more things it can do, and have the character learn to harness and use it in more variable ways than just being able to see it/interact with it and the ancient magic attack. Maybe predicate more puzzles off of using (various forms of) ancient magic instead of just the "find/interact with the ancient magic" puzzles.

1

u/Lui9289 Feb 13 '23

I’m so disappointed with what Ancient Magic turned out to be, it’s literally just an ultimate attack there’s nothing special about it at all it’s an in game cut scene.

3

u/Chadolf Feb 13 '23

this is a small thing but i want makeup customization! a fifth year is what like... 15-16? let me explore magical makeup :P

5

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

No need to change the map, so that's already taken care of aside from a few changes to reflect a year's progress. The world is gorgeous, don't want a new map anyways. Its iconic.

They could add all kinds of new mysteries, new enemies, they could add other places we can get to either by train, or other means like Diagon Alley, or any of the other wizarding areas. Uagadou, Durmstrang, Ilvermorny, etc.

New spells can come in the guise of an evolution to ancient magic. There's loads they can do.

4

u/AaronSadler3216 Ravenclaw Feb 13 '23

Yes they can it’s the Wizarding World

2

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

They cant change the map

There are multiple wizarding schools, so they could recreate, for example, Beauxbatons Academy of Magic, which is in France.

1

u/DShadows98 Feb 13 '23

I know but nobody cares about other castles and schools. Hogwarts is enough.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

I guess, but personally I would love to see the other castles.

1

u/khaled_121 Feb 13 '23

they can change how the map and areas look in the next , not a big deal

1

u/Kellar21 Slytherin Feb 13 '23

There's plenty of spells to add, and others to invent.

Expecto Patronum for example.

They can do a whole lot of stuff, like implementing an actual school system.

1

u/SirTeb Feb 13 '23

It’ll take place at a different school. Creating their own lore

1

u/vd3r Feb 13 '23

they did hint lot of other wizarding schools. it would be cool if they design another school for next game.

1

u/kain8m Feb 13 '23

maybe other magic school

25

u/Fantasmic03 Feb 13 '23

I'm thinking it's an 8-8.5/10 for me. I'm loving my time with it but I wish it doubled down on the RPG and school mechanics. If the sequel is also based at Hogwarts I'd like:

Full implementation of the house points system. Maybe increase the amount of secondary classes with questions to answer or spells to demonstrate with house point increases.

A proper day/night cycle with a curfew to get you to go back to your dormitory or use stealth, with the curfew system have a pseudo GTA/Bully system which starts out with prefects looking for you, then teachers. Punishments can be deduction of house points for getting caught at low levels and detention if you get caught at higher.

Quidditch

Morality system - I'm thinking if you get higher in the system you get access to prefect specific areas, or if you go lower you get invited to dark arts clubs.

Specialisation of spell casting with talents making you a specialist in charms, transfiguration, or curses which in turn defines the combat spells you use. I imagine Charms doing things like manipulating the environment like Dumbledore controlling the statues during his fight with Voldy

22

u/ProtectusCZ Feb 13 '23

Curfew sounds cool but it reality it would be annoying.

Just imagine collecting all demiguise statues in stealth. The first mission with introduction of demiguise statues was enough.

3

u/Wookieewomble Feb 13 '23

Wholeheartedly agree!

2

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

They probably wouldn’t need artificial time padding collectathons in the next game if they added the actual RPG elements that person said

0

u/Fantasmic03 Feb 13 '23

I can definitely feel like it might get annoying later down the track in the game, but by then I'd expect you'd pick up a few extra talents/gadgets to make it easier. Maybe make the invisibility potion a later pick-up and have it be much stronger than the spell.

I think with the demiguise the solution would be to halve the amount but make them all a bit more of a challenge

12

u/ZydrateVials Feb 13 '23

I don't like the busywork. The balloons, Merlin trials, etc. I love everything else.

5

u/Chadolf Feb 13 '23

i hate the merlin trials too, i dont know what they were thinking putting so many in the game.

1

u/ZydrateVials Feb 13 '23

Hate is too strong a word for it. I just find them very tedious.

2

u/chaotic910 Feb 13 '23

To be fair that's an open world game problem

2

u/ZydrateVials Feb 13 '23

I just wish it was more clever than "put balls in holes" (hurr) but I understand they need to keep it accessible. I don't know how 11 year olds game but not sure how they could handle the fairly intense and reactive combat.

Also some of them I just legit can't ever find the third thing.

1

u/chaotic910 Feb 13 '23

I've seen what 11yo kids can do in rocket league, the combat is child's play lol.

The nice thing about a lot of similar puzzles is that it has a bigger scale for difficulty, and allows the story to remain super accessible. If there was 1000 different kinds of puzzles with different difficulties, a lot of people would ignore them or completely miss them at the first roadblock, if you're able to complete the easier ones it gives more incentive and drive to finish the more complex ones.

2

u/Lui9289 Feb 13 '23

Honestly yeah, I really hate that it’s become the norm to just fill the world with repetitive stuff. The only open world game I’ve played that the map actually feels meaningful is Breath of the Wild.

12

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

Loving the first 10 hours bit can already tell this game is going to get real boring real fast once i start just trying to do side quests in the open world

4

u/Goldendon1 Feb 13 '23

Jup i sometimes pick up a few side missions but only because im there or near it already but indeed they are noting special most of the time. Best missions are the ones from your friends that send you an owl beside that just filler.

Best filler IMO was the spider termination quest you get somewhere in the winter time in the three broomsticks but more for the story padded to it then the quest itself

7

u/lazergun-pewpewpew Feb 13 '23

Its worth it to keep going just for the Sébastien quest line.

Best one of the game by far... i honestly wish the entire game was based around this instead of some dumb magic reservoir or whatever.

6

u/StikyIcky Gryffindor Feb 13 '23

I tried to tell everyone this and just downvoted into oblivion. They dropped the ball on way too many things for it to be any higher than maybe a 7/10

2

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

First days on this sub were hell, people were completely blind to the reality of the game and downvoted anyone who had anything negative to say. Seems like people are waking up though, I’ve been seeing more and more critical posts calling out how hollow the game really is. Glad I returned it. I might buy it again in a few months if devs keep updating and don’t give up on the game just because they already got the money

11

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

Probably an 8/10, maybe a 9/10. Will have to finish to fully get a grasp. 10/10 is probably hardcore HP homers. I’m playing without having seen a HP movie or book so purely basing my opinion on the game.

18

u/getmeoutoftax Feb 13 '23

I agree. The game is a solid 7/10. It would be a lot better if the game had random encounters and more interactions with students. It also should’ve looked at Bully for inspiration for side missions.

3

u/PrincessRhaenyra Feb 13 '23

I'm hoping they did what CDPR did with the Witcher 3 and add free side quests into the base game.

9

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

My first few hours its a 9/10, but 20+ hours in the gameplay does become stale, so it’s an 8/10 or 7.5/10 game for me. I like games with big rpg elements, immersion & meaningful side-quests & sadly this game doesn’t have that much of it :(( still a good game though, I especially love the combat & the overall world

15

u/Dis7urbios Slytherin Feb 13 '23

As a game, especially story-wise is mediocre but you add the Harry Potter experience into it and it elevates the game for sure.

12

u/YungRacecar Feb 13 '23

Given the shit being pumped out these days, I'd say it's a bit better than mediocre. Nothing super special though if you take out the HP appeal. It's like S tier world building / environment in a B tier game.

2

u/Dis7urbios Slytherin Feb 13 '23

I mean, just because the industry standards are pretty low atm, doesn't mean that the gamer's standards should lower as well.

Sure, you have a lot of hot garbage being thrown out (Forspoken I'm looking at you) but the game had the potential to be a lot more story-wise and they went for a linear bland story route.

It's not horrible or bad but taking into consideration the source material, it had the potential to be a lot more.

8

u/YungRacecar Feb 13 '23

Honestly the source material is pretty basic and poor itself outside of HP. I do agree that the story is pretty bland, but I can't deny that I'm enjoying it. I think it's clear that their first priority was building a beautiful world to explore.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/Terentas_Strog Ravenclaw Feb 13 '23

But Ragnarok was a success? Why would you put it among other three?

0

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

Theres also all the amazing games that come out each year. Your talking about a small portion of AAA releases that are shit. Why shoot for average when theres already examples of how to do amazing

2

u/chaotic910 Feb 13 '23

'All' is still a really short list if you're only taking AAA into account lol

1

u/StikyIcky Gryffindor Feb 13 '23

Idk I mean we just got Elden Ring not too long ago. I think that game literally raised the bar for games of this genre lol

0

u/throwmyasswaway17 Slytherin Feb 13 '23

do u even know what world building is

0

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

[deleted]

1

u/chaotic910 Feb 13 '23

I honestly don't believe it's rose tinted goggles. They 100% nailed Hogwarts' map and layout, ubisoft would have still railroaded the map, or have had like 3/4 of the areas in the castle locked out permanently.

I wouldn't say it's safe as much as it doesn't break the mold. Most ways you cut it, open world games are just finishing checkmarks at your own discretion instead of a set order. Otherwise it's just a linear game with an open world

7

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

Yep 7/10 for me too, for me the story and combat is very good but the intractability of the world is lacking, NPCs needs work, and PC performance suck.

8

u/Quirky-Ad3721 Hufflepuff Feb 13 '23

Yeah, I'm a bit disappointed as it has a solid base and could be so much better.

  1. Classes are rather lazily done and require little effort/no risk. I'd have preferred a schedule, or at least some harder sections like answering questions for house points.

  2. Roaming around at night outside the school/dorm room is allowed, so there's that

  3. Restricted section isn't really restricted

3

u/hadeskratos Feb 13 '23

I wonder how the game will stand after all the DLC is added. For me right now its around a 7/10.

The story is good and the combat is fun, my only issue is that the player's choice does not seems to matter that much outside of a couple choices(like 3-4). Most of the quest end with the ' give item back', 'give item back but ask for more money', or 'keep item'. I kind of wish that there was more flexibility in the choice and that exploration could change some stories.

3

u/unluky10 Feb 13 '23

As a game it is 7/10 but hopping on a broom and flying across the lake for the first time was surreal for me. 10/10 for that and the music alone

1

u/strohDragoner58 Ravenclaw Feb 14 '23

They nailed the aesthetic and feel of Harry Potter but unfortunately stumbled on everything else.

3

u/Laurelinarien Ravenclaw Feb 13 '23

My only gripe is how lackluster the companion quests feel (except Seb's).. I do hope we get a DLC expanding story arcs.

5

u/AbaramaGolding Feb 13 '23

A lot of the dialogue is unnecessary. Especially the shopkeepers , they repeat themselves and it usually goes on for much longer than it needs to. I

2

u/WebAdditional3828 Feb 13 '23

I think you can say that for so many repeated actions in this game, menu animations in particular

5

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

Very enjoyable game, combat is decent, the story is fun, NPCs are... they are there too, the exploration is a bit lacking in lore, rewards and puzzles. I hoped for a bit more (in wuality, not quantity) there. It's a bit hollow. No interesting sidequests outside those that are somewhat tied to the story. Overall I'd say 7/10. But my love for the books makes me giving it 8/10. Biggest strongpoint is the atmosphere. They nailed it.

5

u/LtCodename Slytherin Feb 13 '23

I was just thinking that story actually not that engaging. Side quests are great, exploration is amazing but the story… quite boring unfortunately.

2

u/Correct_Damage_8839 Feb 13 '23

It's great if you're a fan, but without bias it's a 7/10 without a doubt. I wish the game wasn't given to an RPG rookie studio. Imagine if its quality was anywhere close to something Rock Star makes, it would be a timeless masterpiece for sure, even for people who are not HP fans. Unfortunately, it's nowhere near that level.

Oh, and it still runs like dogshit on PC, which doesn't help lol.

0

u/strohDragoner58 Ravenclaw Feb 14 '23

I think it’s admirable for a first attempt but it’s still a very mediocre game with a lot of room for improvement. But we’re comparing a student band to (literal) Rockstars here. Rockstar has decades of game design experience under their belt and have defined an entire genre. RDR2 is still more immersive than any game released today, 5 years later.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

I love the combat and open world. But the story is incredibly bland. It suffers from being a prequel and it isn’t at all what the game sets up as. I do love the characters even if the dialogue matters very little. And as a Harry Potter fan, I love the world. So I guess I’ll give it a 7.

2

u/Notreallyherenemore Slytherin Feb 13 '23

avada kedavra

5

u/Far_Elephant_1644 Feb 13 '23

I would say 8 or 9 but I was not expecting an old style RPG with important dialogue decisions and “good and evil” choices like fable for example. I was expecting Ubisoft Harry Potter and that’s what I got and it makes me happy for what it is, still it has issues like every game.

3

u/realspitfire69 Feb 13 '23

as others pointed out its very important that you like HP or else its just not that good

8/10 probably

3

u/Choop-a-loop Feb 13 '23

As a game, I think somewhere between 6-7 is fine. The environments & music are great. Combat is pretty good, especially when you get good with the combos.

But once you get past the butterfly stage, you realize it's a linear "Ubisoft Collector" game where most of the other game systems/mechanics are very average.

3

u/sveltepants Feb 13 '23

Got the broom and flew around the map. There's nothing but small settlements and bandit camps out there, reminded me of far cry games. Disappointed with that tbh, I guess I expected something more.

7

u/OZAI-OCE Feb 12 '23

Why are you bored?

I was sceptical because I’m an avid gamer. MMORPGs is what I usually play and they’ve got immense depth to them. Systems, as well.

This is an incredible game, but it really depends on how you play it.

6

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

Well I mean for me as someone who plays a lot of games I haven't found any MMOs I like. And my criticism with them is generally the same as this game: repetitive with a gilded depth that lacks any real staying power for me.

It's fun for me to play through the story and side quests but after 30 hours there isn't any way to continue to play it that's particularly interesting. The combat is too easy, there isn't anything interesting to explore, there is no more progression of my magic skills. What can I do to make it fun?

It's not a bad game just short in terms of interesting content. If there was some increasing difficulty, greater variety of enemies, and distinct rpg elements then it could be more fun and repayable.

I could get 100+ hours out of Witcher 3 and cyberpunk even though those kind of lacked rpg elements, because they had longer and more interesting quests. I could get hundreds of hours out of skyrim and fallout games because I could replay them with different builds. So this game isn't up there with the greats. It's closest comparison for me is shadow of mordor, which gave me a similar playtime and enjoyment. If it didn't review so well (off of the nostalgia presumably) I'd have waited for a sale, but I don't regret my decision to play it.

18

u/realspitfire69 Feb 13 '23

because after doing the 86th merlin trial or the 59th fetch quest it gets a little bit boring

the game has its moments but thats it really

0

u/OZAI-OCE Feb 13 '23

maybe you’re playing too much?

4

u/realspitfire69 Feb 13 '23

its just bloated overworld design

almost like modern ubisoft games

1

u/chaotic910 Feb 13 '23

Like all open world games, they all have a ton of tedium in them.

1

u/OZAI-OCE Feb 13 '23

Yeah idk.

I’m 24 hours in, I leave my game on, but just recently got my broom and I’m level 20.

I haven’t played much, but I don’t have time because I own a company and have to work pretty much everyday. The few hours I get here and there have been really fun but also because I’m not sitting there for 8 hours playing games all day

1

u/ratmosphere Feb 13 '23

How are you playing It? I could use some pointers because 20 hours in and I can't find it in me to clear another enemy camp with the same 5 or so enemies or find the next empty "dungeon" for another scarf as a reward.

And don't tell me about another one of those fetch quest or ask me to go pop some balloons....I'm not doing that anymore.

Does it get better?

1

u/OZAI-OCE Feb 13 '23

I’ve only cleared one camp. I play this game like how it should be played, when t brain is ZEN. If I wanted complexity, I play black desert online & PvP when I can. I only play an hour a day lol

1

u/ratmosphere Feb 13 '23

So this game should only be played 1 hour a day? Got it.

1

u/OZAI-OCE Feb 13 '23

It’s a single player game…. There’s no meta to chase and there’s only 35-70 hours of gameplay depending.

35 hours of gameplay is very, very, extremely low amount of hours for a game.

For reference, On BDO I’ve got 6,000 hours over the span of 3 years. There’s no reason to be playing this game for hours on hours every day, it’s literally a single player RPG. 🤣 Why are people putting in 7-8 hours a day on this game when the total run time is 70 hours for completionists? You wanna finish the game in 10 days? 🤣

Edit: I’ve realised Im talking to people who on console, unfortunately playstation & xbox have no where else to go to but these RPGs. On PC, most players play MMORPGs or competitive pvp games so this change of pace is very different and relaxing as a side game.

-9

u/radiusofaproton Ravenclaw Feb 12 '23

The wall of absolute disappointment hasn’t hit you yet but it will esp if you are a fan of games like that and deep in-depth systems because this is not it

9

u/OZAI-OCE Feb 12 '23

I don’t want in depth systems and I didn’t expect it from this game. That’s my whole point.

I’m not disappointed because the game is exactly what I expected to be. Surface-level RPG with minimal systems.

People were overhyped and I could see exactly what the game was going to be, thus why I was sceptical.

But because my expectations were low & I knew what it was going to be, I thoroughly enjoy it because there’s no disappointment.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

[deleted]

2

u/square_tomatoes Slytherin Feb 13 '23

Yeah, my wife and a bunch of our friends are not gamers by any stretch but they’re all playing this because they’re HP fans and want to explore the castle/world. I think the simplicity was intentional on the part of the devs to make the game accessible to HP fans who aren’t gamers because they knew that’s a big chunk of their target market.

1

u/spooblies Hufflepuff Feb 13 '23

Not to mention it would turn a lot of fans who aren't "gamers" away and they wouldn't even try it out.

2

u/BoreDominated Feb 12 '23

I personally find games with in-depth systems tiring, I prefer something more simplistic and fun. I'm the type of person who enjoyed the fact that Mass Effect 2 took Mass Effect 1's foundation and trimmed all the fat.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

I will be disappointed whit the game ONLY if they do not expand it.
I think the game is fine as it is now.
Is it perf HELL NO.
Is it better then 99% of the other junk AAA games released now a day,s FUCK YES.
Its close to eldenring ( although eldenring is way better )
Its close to it cus all the other tipple A releases WHERE ABSOLUTE SHITE.

THIS RELEASE MADE ME GO SO THERE IS STILL SOME HOPE FOR GOOD tripple A releases

3

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

This release gave you hope for AAA.. Did you forgot about elden ring 3 seconds after typing it?

Elden ring showed that going against boring openworld trends pays off. This game only really showd thay even if the gamrplay is generic and the openworld is cookie cutter if you put effort into the world design and atmosphere it still pays off. I dont think that's a good thing

1

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

U forget about the history of games base on movies being absolute piles of junk.
I did not forget about eldenring ( as why i state in the post )
Its close to ELDENRING ( altough Eldenring is way better )
Its close to it cus every other tripple a release was ABSOLUTE SHITE .
There is a difference between eldenring and hogwarts lagacy.
I expect different things from both games.
In eldenring i want kickass bosses and weapons.
In Hogwarts i want exploration goofy shit and nostalgia.
They both hit the mark.
And while u think this game might not be that great.
It actually is great cus the spirit of harry potter is in the game.
U can see it in all the small details they added in.
A lot of love went into creating the world from small side quests to artistical recreations of the books.
Is it a brilliant game for its game play.
NO
Is it a brilliant game for recreating the feel of the books.
YES

0

u/ratmosphere Feb 13 '23

Weird to put elden ring and this game on the same sentence, though. I've got over 1000 hours and counting on elden ring and I can't see myself finishing this one after 20 hours of fetching pointless stuff, collecting scarfs and fighting dull enemies.

Hogwarts legacy went the ubisoft way, completely ignoring what elden ring achieved in terms of open world.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

Weird to put elden ring and this game on the same sentence, though. I've got over 1000 hours and counting on elden ring and I can't see myself finishing this one after 20 hours of fetching pointless stuff, collecting scarfs and fighting dull enemies.

Hogwarts legacy went the ubisoft way, completely ignoring what elden ring achieved in terms of open world.

O i get what u mean but i rate games based on what i want to get out of them.
Some games i play for a challenge and others i play for the experience.
If i would rank games i played whit over 1000 hours.
Path of exile would be leagues and bounds over eldenring.
But in mij mind eldering and path of exile are on the same level.
Although poe will last me way longer as eldering ever will.
Its more of a compare 10 trippel a games for the last 5 years.
And the only games that come to my mind right now are.
Eldenring, cyberpunk, Hogwarts, rdr and well i cant remember any more.
I enjoyed cyberpunk cus i rushed the main story ( witch was amazing )
But

0

u/ratmosphere Feb 13 '23

Oh. I loved cyberpunk. I don't remember being asked to pick up 100s of meaningless collectables in order to progress in that game but I do remember a lot of those amazing side quest and cast of characters that I met during my playthrough. It's like every time I went to do a boring quest I was surprised and rewarded with awesome content. It was probably not the rpg everyone was expecting but I wasn't expecting anything, so I got a great cdpr game, much like the Witcher but with a better setting, for me.

Hogwarts on the other hand only rewards me with landscape, boring cut scenes and cute moving paintings but I can't name you one character and I already forgot what was the story about.

But hey, to each his own. Glad you're enjoying it. It's just not my kind of game.

4

u/DrySausage Feb 13 '23

6/10. It’s not amazing. But I don’t dislike it.

6

u/radiusofaproton Ravenclaw Feb 12 '23 edited Feb 12 '23

You are def not alone. I was fully prepared to put 100 hours into this game and they really really fucked up the endgame. Your money, gear upgrades, gear, potions, plants and beast products become useless. You also can’t sell anything besides gear so even your room of req items and vivariums become cosmetic and serve no purpose. The season stays in spring you so can’t freshen up the gameplay with sandbox settings. That means all seasonal gear and items are again…useless. No reason to do side quest or anything, no quest rewards. I can find the same thing in little jimmy’s hut that’s in the legendary spiders cave. Why would I? I’m trying to do a 2nd playthrough and it’s just a damn slog and there isn’t anything new. It’s the same story told the same way slightly different. And that would be ok if the game had you work towards something. But the end just falls off a cliff. They would have been better off just letting the credits roll and call it a day.

Basically this game is a sweet short story and after that it’s a digital art installation of Hogwarts and nothing more.

This def was a linear open world Ubisoft style game. Def not a real open world rpg rdr 2, Skyrim, fallout or any of the great big rpgs. Like even if you truly complete 100% of Skyrim, technically there is still things you can do. You know what I mean? It’s that type of end game loop i was looking for. Doesn’t mean it has to be EXACTLY like Skyrim, that is not what I’m saying.

I’m complaining about basic level RPG shit this isnt even next level or next gen gaming stuff this has been in games for years and years.

It’s still a decent game but it did not live up to the hype. At least for me. I’m a huge rpg fan and it didn’t scratch the itch for me unfortunately. I will say it’s a beautiful game but that’s about it. It’s pretty but the mechanics are absolute dog shit. Like it’s that pos movie inspired blockbuster game you rented and it’s god awful. I’m putting that lightly. It’s 2023 like come on we know what’s good and what isn’t by now. We have plenty of good games for inspiration. Pisses me off lol even the fans know what they want how do these developers not know. I just really feel like again this huge corp fucked us and made mega millions off of peoples nostalgia similar to nintendos shit. But hey I can visit Hogwarts like it’s a digital museum so I’ll drink to that….but that’s it 😂

Gameplay 3/10

Ole Happy potter nostalgia 10/10

1

u/strohDragoner58 Ravenclaw Feb 14 '23

They put all their time and resources into creating the world and while it is impressive and stunning to look at, that’s just not enough. The main problem of the game is that there is simply no gameplay loop. There is nothing that keeps you coming back gameplay wise. There is no real point to doing anything besides getting random gear that’s maybe +2 in defence or something.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

Amen bro

2

u/Forsaken-Thought Ravenclaw Feb 13 '23

Are you hitting every side quest and puzzle or blasting through the main story?

2

u/Zenyks Feb 12 '23

I agree. The combat is very repetetive, the cutscenes and voice acting feels dead, the npc’s feel dead and so does the world itself

2

u/mackbulldawg67 Hufflepuff Feb 13 '23

Easy 9/10 for me. I don’t see how anyone can give it less than a 8.

1

u/Smintini Feb 13 '23

8/10. Every rpg based on past lore should follow the Hogwarts legacy formula.

RPG elements such as story, gear, traits, spells etc.

mixed with;

the love for a franchise such as accurate lore, details, expanding the world etc.

Only things missing is quidditch (Witcher 3 gwent), a deeper rpg morality/outcome system, and multiplayer.

8/10

1

u/ninjablader78 Feb 13 '23

It’s an okay game it’s fun enough but let’s be real it’s main appeal lies in it being a Harry Potter game. While this game is just ok I definitely feel like a sequel could make it genuinely amazing for everyone not just hp fans. If they leaned more into the rpg aspect gave people actual choices and more dynamic dialogue it could be so much better.

And also of the topic of aspects I thought were just really underdeveloped was the combat maybe it was just my opinion but it felt shallow mechanically and visually. Alot of spells look, feel, and do the same thing. Then there’s the fact that more than half of combat spells just straight up don’t do anything to some enemies or have most of their effective completely ripped from them. This also just breaks the fun of the combat because most of it revolves around using control and force spells to create combos to deal bonus damage so any enemy that isn’t usable on them means your literally just spamming basic attack and attack spells. Then the upgraded versions of most spells seem so niche you barely notice the upgrade.

1

u/Wonderful-Change-751 Feb 13 '23

As a gamer 6.5-7 for the game, with some nostalgia( although I’m getting older) an 8. Would be better if the issues and glitches are fixed asap.

1

u/mikkelnl Feb 13 '23

Just started but struggling with the controls in fights to be honest.

1

u/RoxieSaysPew Feb 13 '23

I've got 67 hours by now, but I've just unlocked the vivarium. I am taking things way too slow and I think I'll only finish the main story in like a week.

I might be enjoying this game a bit more than most players lol

1

u/Oledman Feb 14 '23

From what I have played so far I would say its a 7 or 8 out of 10, but there are some elements that are an easy 10/10 such as design and exploration. Hogwarts castle, Hogsmeade all fantastically created, even the small little hamlets out in the sticks are beautiful. But like with any open world game there can be flaws and some repetitive stuff.

It's a difficult thing to juggle when creating a huge open world like this.

When you start to feel bored with any repetitiveness, that's when its a good time to just crack on with the main quest line .

1

u/magvadis Ravenclaw Feb 15 '23

It's a 6/10 game frontloaded as an 8/10.

The last half is pretty terrible.

Not sure why the reviews were so good. It's as if the pretty backdrop that is Hogwarts was the only thing reviewers cared about.

Really weird, especially when identical games like Gotham Knights got way worse reviews.

The only truly enjoyable thing outside of aesthetics was the RoR stuff like taming and the focus on animals.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '23

To me personally 6/10. i just dont find any of the sidequests besides Sebastian’s good. Also feel like most of the missions for the main story are the same

1

u/BlindBandit988 Feb 13 '23

I agree. If it wasn’t a Harry Potter game I think it would be middle of the road, 7-8/10, but because they did such a great job recreating the world and adding more onto it than we’ve ever seen it makes it a 9/10 for sure. I’m enjoying it well enough, but I don’t think I’d be putting this much time and effort into it if I wasn’t a fan of Harry Potter.

1

u/square_tomatoes Slytherin Feb 13 '23

For years I’ve said I wanted a full-scale virtual Hogwarts that I could just explore, and this game nailed that, so as far as I’m concerned everything else is just icing on the cake.

7/10 is my overall rating as well, because I agree there’s a lot of gameplay elements that could’ve been fleshed out more. But I rate the exploration aspect a 9.8/10 and that’s all I really cared about anyways.

1

u/Rowan_As_Roxii Slytherin Feb 13 '23

Why are those who are praising the game are getting downvoted lmao. Is someone going on a hate train? Downvoting every positive opinion about this game? If you like the game then you like it, if you don’t then you don’t. It’s a real shame though… I enjoy the combat tbh and the variety of combos and spells I can do. The dialogue… needs tweaking though… other than that, it’s a fun game to pour hours into.

1

u/visualcharm Feb 13 '23

I agree -- as a game, it feels very linear. However, I read someone's post in this sub about being an undercover auror and it really changed the way I'm playing. I really do see the rpg choices, dialogue, and setting, as just supportive to my auror mission's success and see them kind of as a background buzz to the beautiful scenery and end goal of getting to 100%. Do I think I'll make a new character and replay? No, not until we get expansions/updates. But the release is solid and sets a good base for different interactive features, functions, and quests in the future.

1

u/Skrip77 Feb 13 '23

9/10. The artistry is unmatched

1

u/NyabCaitlyn Gryffindor Feb 13 '23

This game does indeed have the infamous "ILLUSION OF CHOICE" that I'm not a fan of. But the combat feels good and the setting is beautiful. I'm more of an RPers when I play these sort of games, so if they add sitting and sleeping, along with students sleeping in the common rooms, I'd rate this almost perfect.

0

u/Calm-Consideration25 Feb 13 '23

Average, but since HP fans are like Sonic fans when it comes to video games, a half decent game is a masterpiece to us.

-2

u/guardian416 Feb 13 '23

For me, as a game 9/10. Imo it’s positives outweigh some of the negative.

0

u/AverageCowboyCentaur Feb 13 '23

Movie fan, like seen them 20 times each easily. Games fanatic, not bored at all. 20 hours in and I just did the first trial. Only a few Merlin things and still missing like half the spells lvl 20 though, I'm having an absolute blast.

My only concern is I heard lvl 40 is the cap, and I'm already half way there.

0

u/Caleger88 Hufflepuff Feb 13 '23

As a gamer it's definitely 7/10 would have liked some features in it like sitting, sleeping, eating in the great hall, playing gobstones, more dueling in school, a curfew system at school. To name a few.

I've read only one book and that was the 3rd one but my partner and I are watching the movies and catching up on the ones I haven't seen like the goblet of fire onwards. So I can't say I'm a fan.

0

u/Javonte102 Feb 13 '23

Can someone please tell me how to get a broom? I been playing 6hrs lvl 9 and nothing

2

u/bluberihedgehog Feb 13 '23

It's a side quest after you have your first flying lesson.

1

u/Javonte102 Feb 13 '23

I just did the library restricted area quest do you know how many more main quest i have left before my first flying lesson?

2

u/bluberihedgehog Feb 13 '23

I think you get it right after Jackdaws Rest. If I remember right you still have to do herbology and potions before you get to jackdaw. There are a lot of walk throughs you can find that will be more specific.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

The games core gameplay is a tad on the weak side. Exploring the harry potter locations has been pure joy. But the farther from the castle you get the less the game leans on harry potter and more on its core gameplay and thats when you notice the weakness. I feal like the open world outside of the castle grounds is to big and the castle itself and its grounds should have been made larger with less little hamlets everywhere. The games story inside the castle when the game is screaming harry potter is a easy 10/10.

-6

u/LeratoNull Feb 12 '23

What game do you feel the dialogue choices felt significant in?

6

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

Witcher 3, Skyrim, Mass Effect, Fallout.

-16

u/LeratoNull Feb 12 '23

Oh, okay, the post is bait, go home everybody, I did think so.

9

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23 edited Feb 12 '23

Sorry what? Those games do have significant dialog, as in your choices make a huge difference to the outcome of quests and story.

Not sure how thats bait.

-3

u/fltlns Ravenclaw Feb 12 '23

Skyrim certainly doesn't. Mass effect yes, but only the first two. The first dragon age, outer worlds, new Vegas and fallout 3 only but to be fair I hated 4 and didn't finish. Then "real" RPGs like divinity

1

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

🤡

-1

u/LeratoNull Feb 12 '23

Bro said mfin Skyrim has impactful dialogue choices my guy 😭

4

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

Have you not played Skyrim or something? Its not the best game by any means but you can certainly have a huge impact on quests, based on the dialog. Are you okay mate?

3

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

Even if Skyrim doesn’t (which it does), why completely ignore the rest of the comment?

2

u/BoreDominated Feb 12 '23

It... does... ??

1

u/TheLehis Feb 13 '23

You really haven’t played skyrim have you

8

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/LeratoNull Feb 12 '23

I wasn't sure until the dude said Skyrim and Fallout have meaningful dialogue choices, man truly be wildin

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23 edited Feb 13 '23

I say 9/10. I hate RPG's (or the likes) that tie leveling/XP to quests and objectives only. I like fighting random mobs, with at least a small reward. This makes it so that it's pointless to fight random mobs unless you are wanting a specific ingredient.

Also this is very miniscule, but the fact I'm set on being the start of an evil wizard and all the voices sound like angels who can do no wrong... is upsetting.

Also that if you get stuck in certain story missions you have to end up redoing the whole mission and any progress you gained since the game tells you to "Level up or get better gear," then doesn't let you leave the area.

-1

u/DieBunteMango Feb 13 '23

How do you know when you hit 60% of story?

-1

u/Malfell Hufflepuff Feb 13 '23

I'm actually a little surprised that folks on this thread are solid 7's, for me it's an 8/10 for the game itself, a 9 with the nostalgia.

The main plot I think is fairly decent, some specific events are downright cinematic. It's not as strong as something like last of us, but it's pretty good for open world fare. I find it a lot more engaging than a game like Ghost of Tsushima which has the most cookie cutter plots and quests imaginable.

Hogwarts is one of the coolest video game buildings I've ever seen. The combat is actually quite fun. Personally I think the visual and audio presentation is also overall very good.

Not saying it's perfect, the game does have some obvious issues. Rather than see it as a harry potter game that happens to be good, I think of it as a good game that happens to be harry potter.

-2

u/LVL12Boss Feb 13 '23

I think we have a plant

-3

u/Brilliant_Savings161 Feb 13 '23

All the crybabies in here. If you want a lootgame go play Diablo. If you want a full open world game play Skyrim or rdr2. People said all I want is fly around Hogwarts and the castle and the lands. And explore some magic. Thats what you got. Now you all see the negative sides and what it is lacking. It can’t be a rockstar game because it is not rockstar. They laid down a good foundation for future expansions. And they will definitely improve. This 3 day after release rage is ridiculous, because you don’t get your dopamine now once finished. If you took the game for what it is and enjoyed the beautiful land of Hogwarts and took it slow it becomes another game. You are just stupid. The game is 9/10 Harry Potter game.

7

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23 edited Feb 13 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Lukeuntld072_ Feb 13 '23

Yea same here. Im still in my first playtrough but i cant see myself doing a single merlin trial after this. They need to do something about that.