I've noticed that I often struggle to connect with many modern bhajan renditions.
Whenever i search for an old bhajan, a remake version with millions of views is at the top of page replacing the original one.
A lot of newer singers seem more focused on making their voice sound as sweet, polished, and "perfect" as possible, forgetting the main essence of a bhajan. The excessive vocal styling, forced sweetness, autotune, and heavily produced arrangements sometimes make it feel more like a performance than an offering.
To me, the essence of a bhajan is bhakti. It is something sung from the heart, not something meant to showcase vocal skill or impress an audience. A bhajan is sung by the soul, not the vocal cords. You're not trying to impress anyone. You're expressing devotion. Drop the pretense and sing it with your heart.
My issue isn't musical skill itself. There is a difference between a voice that is naturally refined through years of practice and a voice that feels overly manufactured to create an image or emotional effect. What bothers me is when authenticity gets replaced by performance. Skill should serve devotion, not the other way around.
Another thing that bothers me is the increasing use of Bollywood-style music and production. While there's nothing inherently wrong with experimentation, I sometimes feel that it changes the original mood and rasa of the bhajan. The devotional atmosphere gets replaced by something that feels commercial, and the production becomes the focus instead of the devotion.
When I listen to older bhajans, even if the recording quality isn't perfect, I often feel a sincerity and simplicity that allows the devotion itself to take center stage. The singing may be less polished, but the bhakti feels more direct.
A simple test I use is this: after listening, am I thinking about God, or am I thinking about the singer? If I'm thinking mostly about the singer's voice, effects, production, and performance, then something has probably shifted away from the original purpose of a bhajan.
I've also noticed many remakes of older bhajans. Some seem to reproduce the original composition almost entirely, adding modern instrumentation, effects, and autotune. This makes me wonder: if a bhajan was originally composed by a particular person, can others legally record and monetize near-identical versions of it? Is permission usually required, or do many compositions effectively become treated as part of the public devotional tradition?
If it's being done purely as a devotional offering, I can understand it. But can people legally profit from someone else's original bhajan by repackaging it with modern production?
Maybe I'm old-fashioned, but I feel that devotion loses something when authenticity is replaced by polish. A bhajan doesn't need to be perfect. It needs to be heartfelt.
Curious to hear what others think.