r/Hamlet • • Aug 30 '26

Shocking study guide

Post image
115 Upvotes

I was looking online at some commentary on one of the major soliloquies. I was shocked at the interpretation provided (possibly by YorkNotes).

'Examples gross as earth exhort me...' to my mind would loosely mean 'the stuff all around me, things as abundant and widespread as the ground itself, all seem to be urging me towards....'

So here, 'gross' means 'abundant, copious, unrefined, available on a mass scale'.

Except the note seems to have been written by some kind of valley girl, or at least somebody very young, who tells the impressionable young reader that gross means 'ewwww' / 'yukky'.

Just what is going on here? I'm confused at how editor has taken at face value the modern, idiomatic meaning of 'gross' rather than the time-honoured, centuries-old meaning.


r/Hamlet • • Sep 28 '22

Come on, why not

Post image
52 Upvotes

r/Hamlet • • Apr 12 '22

Yorick is the key to understanding Hamlet (and why Hamlet is actually a brilliant character) Spoiler

48 Upvotes

Hamlet’s fatal flaw has often been described as “indecisiveness” and I always found that a bit peculiar, but I do not agree Hamlet was weak-willed. I actually think he might be the most noble character in his own titular play. Personally I feel one character in particular helped me reevaluate the dignity Hamlet’s character.

Hamlet is a ghost story, the ghost of Hamlet’s father has been pushing his son to avenge him. I don’t think he is the only ghost, or father we meet. Act 5 Scene 1 where Hamlet comes face to face with Yorick’s skull has been interpreted as Hamlet accepting the futility of his cause, but I think it runs deeper than that. These lines are how Hamlet remembers his jester…

“of infinite jest, of most excellent fancy: “borne me on his back a thousand times;” “Here hung those lips that I have kissed I know”

I don’t recall Hamlet having such positive memories about his father. In fact I don’t think there really is much to say about his father. Hamlet likely spent more time in the company of Yorick than his father, more focused on war with Norway, so Yorick is the surrogate father, the second ghost, and he is a ghost that doesn’t demand Hamlet abide his wishes, he simply remains silent, and “smiles” back while Hamlet can finally pour out his emotions. The scene rightfully is about Hamlet contemplating the futility of his journey, the inevitability of death, but it also is him being reminded that he does not have to put himself through the burden and torturous path his father has driven him down. Yorick is at peace, and Hamlet for a moment can think clearly again. Below is a link to a BBC podcast which was where I first developed this idea from.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b09jqtfs

Remember Hamlet had left his father and the Danish court as a university student, which in the context of Shakespeare’s time, suggests that Hamlet raised to be an intellectual, a renaissance man. His questioning, hesitation and overal indecisiveness in killing Claudius is him challenging a world bounded by archaic ideas, impulsiveness and violence. Hamlet’s tragic flaw was not a personality trait, it was his existence as someone too good for the people around him.

Yorick reminds to not just Hamlet but also the audience that Hamlet has been abused and manipulated to the point of no return. Yet in death he earns the respect of his foil Fortinbras, who honours Hamlet for having the thinking that the impulsive Fortinbras lacked. I do believe in this regard Hamlet challenges the traditional conventions of a tragedy, and I credit Act V Scene I for changing my view.

But that is how I personally interpret it. What do you think about this line of thinking?


r/Hamlet • • Jun 30 '21

My best friend made me a recreation of the famous Ophelia painting by John Everett Millais on a pin for my birthday

Thumbnail
gallery
29 Upvotes

r/Hamlet • • May 30 '25

Gertrude: AITA For Immediately Remarrying After My Husband Died?

20 Upvotes

My husband (late 40s), recently passed away in a fast and shocking manner. He was quite beloved to me and my son (30, who I will refer to as H) as well as the rest of Denmark. 

Shortly after that I wound up remarrying to my husband’s brother, who for clarity I will refer to as C. I know it sounds very fast but it all just happened. I was grieving and somewhat vulnerable. I had been married to my husband for a long time and just did not know what to do. It felt like a part of me was missing.  

In the days after his death, I fell into depression. I lost the motivation to do almost anything. I couldn’t eat, I couldn’t sleep. All I could do was miss my husband. And I realized that I had lost my sense of self, my purpose in life. 

Then C came to check on me. He was kind, caring, and an amazing help. Although he was grieving the loss of his brother, it felt like he cared about me. He wanted to help, and I was a wreck without him. And I felt a renewed purpose in life, closer to the woman I once was.  

One night as we were eating dinner, I realized that I loved this man, and I wanted to spend my life with him. I know it sounds crazy how fast everything happened, but shortly after that we got married. 

Now here is where it gets messy:  

Those first couple days after my husband passed, I didn’t want to lean on H too much because I felt like he needed to process it all himself. But as time passed, it became awkward to talk with H about all of this, so I avoided it. I didn’t talk with H a ton before marrying C.  

Since the wedding, H has been kind of distant and hostile towards me and C. He keeps making cold and cryptic comments about betrayal. Like Hamlet thinks his father’s death was purposeful. I have tried talking to him, but he is so cold to both me and C. It absolutely breaks my heart.  

So Reddit, AITA for remarrying my husband’s brother so soon after his death? 

(It would be funny if people replied in character)


r/Hamlet • • Oct 09 '20

Housekeeping

20 Upvotes

To anyone who happens to wander in here while we're renovating this sub, thanks for your patience while we get it up and running. In the meantime, we'll be looking for top-notch scholarly posts that spark lively discussion, and we want to avoid all the nonsense of petty bickering and homework help. So if you have something you want to contribute, prepare a post, and when we're ready to start being active (soon!) we'll be excited to hear from you.


r/Hamlet • • Dec 31 '24

I drew Hamlet (Barry)

Post image
19 Upvotes

Oh that this too solid flesh would meld

I’ve been studying Shakespeare, specifically hamlet, I thought I’d draw him


r/Hamlet • • Jul 05 '21

Why is Polonius's advice good?

19 Upvotes

Almost everything Polonius says throughout the play is a satire of the almost-smart, educated but foolish advisor. Hamlet calls him a tedious old fool. And yet his advice to Laertes seems uncharacteristically wise and prescient.

Is it supposed to be bad advice, or did Shakespeare just want to give some good advice while he had an ear, or what's going on in this scene?


r/Hamlet • • Jan 20 '26

This game has provided me infinite jest.

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/Hamlet • • Oct 19 '21

Hamlet and Direct Confrontation

16 Upvotes

I have noticed, but can't quite make sense of, a very strong recurring motif in Hamlet. On multiple levels nearly everyone, rather than do the thing they want done, employ (use, send on an errand?) other characters to do something for them.

  • The ghost of course employs Hamlet to kill the King,

  • Polonius and the King use Ophelia to see if Hamlet's mad,

  • Polonius uses some unnamed character to go spy on Laertes to see if he's staying in line,

  • Polonius and the King again use the Queen to discover things about Hamlet,

  • Polonius and the King use, or try to use, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern to try and figure Hamlet's madness out, then they use them AND the King of England to try and kill Hamlet,

  • Hamlet uses the King of England to get R and G killed,

  • Hamlet uses the players to find out if the King's guilty

  • Hamlet uses Horatio to tell his story.

And there are more. But, we see people again and again trying to discern some inner truths/realities through others rather than directly. It seems the ghost is the only one who's unconcerned with that and just wants his revenge, or at least isn't interested in finding that out via his instrument, Hamlet.

I tried looking up some scholarship on "instrumentality," or "passive aggression," and Hamlet have not been yielding anything very illuminating, but I think this is a very interesting motif (and why a great Hamlet spoof would involve family therapy), and so prevalent throughout, it seems like there is something significant going on here.

Any thoughts or ideas on the importance of this to the play or Shakespeare's message/purpose in this play? Would love to discuss.


r/Hamlet • • Apr 25 '25

AITA For Killing My Brother to Be Happy?

15 Upvotes

This is a throwaway account, I just need advice. I, (M49), murdered by brother, (M50), in his sleep. I then married his wife, (F45), and took over the throne instead of their son, (M30). Look, I know in hindsight this sounds bad, but really, it was for my sanity and happiness. Can you really argue with that? I do feel bad, don't get me wrong. Am I sorry? No. Do I really only care about God's forgiveness? Possibly. I would love to pray and get on my knees for Him, wishing for Him to wash away the blood from my hands. However, I think I could live without His forgiveness if He requires me to give up the throne and the queen, or more importantly, my power. Man do I love my new power. Made murdering my brother very worth it. But I also really need God to forgive me, to rid me of my guilty conscious. I simply just cannot part ways with my power. I'm man enough to admit that I'm hungry for power and status.

(This is fake and based off of the King's Speech in Act III, Scene III).


r/Hamlet • • Jun 19 '24

The missed joke between rosencrantz and guildenstern

14 Upvotes

It’s always depicted that none of the principal characters knows who is who and that they get each other’s names mixed up because Rosencrantz And Guildenstern are minor characters and just pawns in Claudius plan to spy on hamlet.

While that may be partially true, I believe the intended joke is they are supposed to be (and played by) twin brothers, and that’s why no one can tell them apart.

It’s stated that they are school friends of Hamlet, not that they are friends of each other, because they’re siblings.

Also, as the joke is traditionally depicted now, it makes Rosencrantz and Guildenstern the only characters to die that aren’t related to anyone else in the play, but being siblings keeps that theme.


r/Hamlet • • Apr 21 '21

[Oc] Ophellia Spoiler

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/Hamlet • • Dec 16 '25

Quoting Polonius

13 Upvotes

When looking at some of the most famous quotes from this play, many of them are from Polonius.

However, in the play Polonius is generally regarded as foolish and almost always wrong.

Therefore, it seems pretty perverse to quote someone like this. Why do people do it so often?

Does Polonius genuinely have wisdom to share or should people quoting Polonius be regarded just like Polonius himself - as essentially blowhards?

Just food for thought - I’m just another former high school student who’s still a bit confused about what they read years ago.


r/Hamlet • • Dec 04 '25

Eternal recurrence in hamlet.

13 Upvotes

First I want to express that im no expert on hamlet. I barely understood or liked the play on a first read through. But it has ocupied a very obsessive corner of my mind that I find myself going back to again and again.

Eternal recurrence is a concept mainly popularized in the west by Nietzsche. The idea is that we are trapped in a loop of living out our lives for eternity in the exact same sequence we have lived it. We are not aware of this loop because our memories reset. The only time we become aware of this loop is when we read Nietzsche. The idea is supposed to empower us to live the kind of life we could accept for eternity.

Hamlet is a play. It can be read again and again and the characters will never know it. They will live out the same sequence of events for eternity as long as we chiose to act it, see it, remember it. None of the characters will know their fate, except for Hamlet.

Hamlet is scarily aware of the potential existential consequences throughout the play. His fear of what comes after is often what holds him back from acting in the first place. In the legend his character was based on, he kills his uncle. Therefore his role is already determined before we even read the play. Hamlet has to stain his hands with the blood of Claudius. It is already written. It his god given role by the legend and Shakespeare himself.

What's interesting is that the acceptance of this role is what determines his fate. After Hamlet finally accepts his duty and kills Claudius he dies too and the play ends.

To be or not to be is not just a matter of accepting existence. It's accepting his role and fate of Eternal recurrence. Hamlet tries to delay this role, but everyone in his life suffers deepley for it. Upon accepting his own character, as an avenger of his father, he is aslo accepting the fate of never being forgotten, of Eternal death, and eternal life.

This is why he tells Horatio to tell his story. So he won't be forgotten, so he will live on in our minds which secures the timeloop he entraps himself in. Hamlet has achieved Amor Fati. Studying his story keeps him alive.

I got chills watching a video on YouTube of three different actors portraying his charter on screen simultaneously. It felt like a soul was possessing them. Like their bodies were a vessel for Hamlet's tormented consciousness. It was like watching him tear at the four walls that trapped him, beging the universe to release him from his story before finally not only accepting it, but creating it too.


r/Hamlet • • Nov 21 '23

RANT: Denmark Monarchy in Shambles, Incestual Marriage, Epiphany, Annoying Ex-Girlfriend, Accidental Murder, and the things that come within

13 Upvotes

The title says it all, but I guess since this is Reddit, I will need to elaborate further. I (30 M) have recently lost a loved one, aka my father, aka the former king of Denmark, aka the REAL king of Denmark. The man, the myth, the legend, not that goat that got with my mother, I mean what was she thinking really? To abandon my father like that to get with his brother, my UNCLE. Imagining them embracing each other literally makes me want to hurl, I mean what a disdain to the country, what an embarrassment. Their entire incestual marriage symbolises the dire state the country is in. How is the country secure from its enemies when they are doing things God and I and the people don’t want to hear? The corruption spreads. I’ve been seeing my father lately, his presence is still here. He guides me onto the foreboding future and what it has to offer if I seek retribution. To summarise, he just basically told me I needed to kill my uncle because he poisoned my poor father’s ear. His wish is my command. And flame my mother too, just because. I think it’s a brilliant idea. I couldn’t care less if he was just a figment of my imagination, let alone a demon. If it makes sense to do it, hell I’ll do it. Claudius can literally just choke and die in a fire. Let me bow down to his grave a thousand times, but never when he still stands. As for my mother, she can just be damned like all women in the world. God will take care of her.

And because I am myself, I don’t stop, I need to put on a show: a physical demonstration of my so-called parents’ guilt, my very own written play, The Mousetrap. All that work just for my mother to feel indifferent about it, she is so insufferable. At least my uncle felt bad. But that woman just does it for me. Every woman is deceptive with their layered beauty and layered lies, I shall never let one get in my head. I forgot to mention, Ophelia dropped a bomb on me, giving me back my letters. Ok? We had an on and off thing, and it was never really official, and it was just a very low commitment thing - but I’m grieving my father’s death and she just had to do this? And she did this right after she stumbled across me reading a book, as if she knows how to read. Literally hop off my groin, and GET THEE TO A NUNNERY.

Life shouldn’t be this hard, but it is. And I need to kill my uncle, because that is what I should do. He confessed that he killed my father after he stormed off from my well-executed play. How dare he feel bad not going to heaven when he killed the man I honoured most? My vision was red, I needed to do what I had to do, but before then, I had to make my mother feel bad about what she did first. Oh I roasted her, guilt has never painted her face better, that’d teach her. The rustling of the curtains made my murderous instincts act and I stabbed the figure behind it. It was Polonius. I guess his experience acting as Caesar paid off. But for what it’s worth, his death will mean something. I just don’t know how yet. Maybe take it as a warning.


r/Hamlet • • Dec 07 '20

Was Hamlet ever truly mad? Did he become mad? When?

12 Upvotes

As the title suggests, I’m interested in hearing whether you think Hamlet was never mad, always mad, or became mad throughout the course of the play. Do you guys think there is a pivotal moment when he became mad or his madness was truly shown

Personally, I think that by the time he killed polonius, he was mad. To leave Laertes fatherless in his own grief about his father’s death and Hamlets inability to recognize this irony indicates to me that he had lost his mind at this point. To cause another pain in the way you experience pain because of that pain and then go on to not recognize or care enough to give polonius another look seems especially cruel.


r/Hamlet • • Jul 31 '26

Favorite Line

11 Upvotes

What’s everyone’s favorite line from the play of all plays? In giving you an impossible task, I’ll go ahead and tentatively answer mine to be “Words, words, words.” Iconic.


r/Hamlet • • Mar 30 '26

AITA for leaving my boyfriend after my dad told me to?

11 Upvotes

So I was seeing this guy, Hamlet, and I thought things were going good, until he began acting kind of weird after his dad died. My dad told me that he doesn't truly love me and that I should take a step back, so I did what I was told and I stopped talking to him.

Now he's acting super upset and confused, and maybe leaving him hurt him hurt him very bad, but I must obey my dad. If I don't obey my dad, I do not want things to go down and bad. I would much rather have a good relationship with my dad rather than a boy who doesn't even truly love me for me rather just for his own pleasure.

I truly care about Hamlet, but lately the strange the strange way he's been acting has been really strange. For example, pushing me away, but maybe it's because of the passing, but also it could be because of me. I was told to be carful, so with that news I distanced myself, but because of my distancing, am I wrong for trusting my family? I ghosted him, but like that's no big deal right? I think he's overreacting to be honest, but I could also be overreacting as well.

AITA for cutting him off and ghosting Hamlet?


r/Hamlet • • May 06 '24

Women in Hamlet

11 Upvotes

I think the depiction of women in Hamlet is that of an interesting one in terms of Shakespeare's plays but Gertrude and Ophelia just seem to be weak characters. I understand they are opposite in characters as Ophelia was a purely good character and Gertrude seems to have more malicious intents. I'm interested to know your opinions on the depiction of women as i think its an aspect to the play I don't fully understand.


r/Hamlet • • Jun 20 '22

Ophelia vs Hamlet's madness

11 Upvotes

Just an interesting dynamic I only recently twigged to. Ophelia is well and truly mad by the end of the play, and is hinted to have killed herself. " Her death was doubtful, And, but that great command o’ersways the order, She should in ground unsanctified been lodged Till the last trumpet. " Here the priest argues she shouldn't be buried in hallowed ground, as suicide is a sin. However, Hamlet later disavows his supposed madness and murder of Polonius to Laertes, " Was ’t Hamlet wronged Laertes? Never Hamlet.If Hamlet from himself be ta’en away, And when he’s not himself does wrong Laertes, Then Hamlet does it not; Hamlet denies it. " Hamlet in essence saying since he was mad, he can't be blamed for Polonius' death.

It just struck me as an interesting juxtaposition, that what Opheilia did in her madness, she should be punished for, but what Hamlet does in HIS madness, he should be excused from, especially as whether or not Hamlet actually is mad throughout the play, or just feigning, is a major talking point.


r/Hamlet • • Jun 08 '21

The gravity of Laertes' and Polonius' warnings to Ophelia...?

11 Upvotes

When I look back at I.iii, it strikes me how heavy-handed these warnings are. We're being introduced to the family dynamic between Polonius, Laertes, and Ophelia, and Shakespeare devotes almost all the interaction with Ophelia to warning about Hamlet. As far as I can tell, most audiences brush this off as the men simply showing paternal/fraternal protection, and of course it foreshadows her tragedy later on. But it seems much more consequential to me that Shakespeare chose to have these characters warn against Hamlet's potential fickleness or divided loyalty -- a character whom we're still being introduced to, and whose prior soliloquy shows that he's struggling with his emotions (and arguably ruled by them).

I can't seem to find much discussion or academic analysis of this beyond a general interpretation of, "Her father and brother are just looking out for her. So anyway..."

I'd like to think that someone, somewhere sees this as an indictment of Hamlet. Thoughts?


r/Hamlet • • Jan 19 '21

Francisco

11 Upvotes

Here's a Hamlet question I love to ask people, because it's not one you see that's been analyzed to death over the centuries.

Act I, Scene i -- Bernardo relieves Francisco at his post. Francisco's got the "not a mouse stirring" line. Francisco exits soon after, and is not in the play at all anymore.

So here's my question. Do you think Hamlet's father's ghost appears to him? Unlike Bernardo and Marcellus, Francisco is alone. So he doesn't have somebody to validate what he's seeing, and he could be terrified to bring it up to anyone else.

Just something I like to think about from time to time. Hamlet's been rewritten from just about every character's perspective, but what's Francisco's story?


r/Hamlet • • Dec 29 '20

What are the worst choices commonly made in Hamlet movie adaptations/stage productions?

11 Upvotes

r/Hamlet • • May 02 '26

Amir Khan on Hamlet and procrastination

10 Upvotes

Why should a well-educated young man have second thoughts when it comes to killing a close relative who also happens to be the king of the land and the husband of his own mother? This is some enigma indeed, and the problem is not that a satisfactory answer has never been found but that we should keep looking for one. Should our enormous critical literature on Hamlet fall someday into the hands of people otherwise ignorant of our mores, they could not fail to conclude that our academic tribe must have been a savage breed, indeed. After four centuries of controversies, Hamlet's temporary reluctance to commit murder still looks so outlandish to us that more and more books are being written in an unsuccessful effort to solve that mystery. The only way to account for this curious body of literature is to suppose that back in the twentieth century no more was needed than the request of some ghost, and the average professor of literature would massacre his entire household without batting an eyelash. - Amir Khan