Hi everyone,It seems that the series of defeat against the Flames combined with the Canucks coming back strong is putting this subreddit in DEFCON 1.By reading the comments, it looks like there are some main points often raised, and I think about combining them into this post, that way it can look like a mega rant one, instead of having each post filled with negativity.I'll start by saying I'm on the optimist side, but as everyone on this sub, I am not happy with the situation, and yes, I don't enjoy losing, but let's talk about the issues:
I probably have forgot some, feel free to add them here, but let's focus on these point by point:
Ducharme: He arrived in the middle of the season. Now I know people would have liked things to change, but he said it in his 1st interview, he simply can't change to many things.Now there's an excellent video from u/ScotianCanadien43 that explains Ducharme style of play.Why not for the Habs. Simply because he doesn't have the players he want for it. And because he arrived during the season, he does what he can with what he has. I am sure during the interseason, if he stays as the head coach, he would have a discussion with our GM to ask for a certain type of players to fit his style, and together work on the acquisition. That said, is everything perfect. Absolutely not, but again, keep in mind that he does what he can with what he has.
Weber: His contract wasn't made by Bergevin. And if not him, we would have PK at the moment. Even though Weber plays badly at the moment, imagine having PK instead for 1 million more.Price: It was a lose lose situation. If Bergevin doesn't give him his contract, Price would have find it elsewhere (look at Bobrovsky). The fans would have blame him for not doing everything he could to keep a player of his caliber with the club, (we blame him for not overpaying Radulov, the Roy trade is in everyone's memory), so he did a choice. Yes the contract sucks, but it was that, or letting Price go.Bergevin and the orgainsation: Well, this interseason Bergevin recruited Allen, Edmundson, Toffoli, Anderson, and Perry that are great addition to the team, no one can deny that. He fixed some of the holes we had (scoring, size, goal tandem), and these players have a great season. He then recruited Staal who, at the moment, is clearly a mistake, then Gustafsson (who we have barely seen) and Merill (who seems to be doing good), and let Mete go for free.On the draft, it seems that though at the beginning of his tenure, the drafts we bad, since 2018, we managed to get Kotkaniemi, Romanov, Primeau who have now played in NHL, and the other prospects are flourishing in AHL under Bouchard. Because there was a problem with Laval, and Bergevin fixed that too. So yes, his first years have been bad but recently has been much better. That said, he should leave if we don't go very far in the playoffs or miss them.
No goals: We have Byron, Tatar, Gallagher, Drouin injured at the moment. Gallagher being the heart and soul of the team, he's the player you don't want to et down, and follow to the battle. Clearly, him being out has a negative effect, not only because he scored, but because he would force people to play better. Toffoli and Anderson still score regularly but the rest, indeed, is very bad.
Suzuki: Just like Kotkaniemi last year, sophomore slump, look where Kotkaniemi is now. Just chill, Suzuki is a good player. Having Drouin underperforming on is wing didn't help him a lot either.
Staal: Yes, he's bad, clearly a mistake at the moment. If we miss the playoffs, that's the nail in the coffin for Bergevin. If we go there, let's hope he wakes up and becomes a leader. Otherwise just keep writing (BuT sTaAl SuCkS) doesn't bring any value to the conversation.
Caufield: It has been said countless time, he can't come due to the cap reason and rules for the players getting recalled. Baring anymore injuries (that might happen considering our current luck),he won't play. Get over it.
Drouin: well, yeah, he's injured, was playing with a wrist not fully healed, scored only 2 goals. Yes, he's not the hero we expected him to be. He needs a center who can put up the goals, and we don't have one at the moment in the team. As long as we will miss a true 1st center, Drouin won't fly.
Elite talent: Yes, it's obvious we miss. Tank to get a good pick? Go watch how Buffalo plays at the moment. Generational talent? Oilers like Leafs still don't have a cup. If we tank, we lose our identity, we are the Montreal Canadiens goddamn it, we should aim for victory not tanking. Being in a culture of loss to get better doesn't necessary goes well.
Playoff: For the more pessimist. If we miss them, be happy, it means Bergevin is out! You should be happy we suck at the moment then since it means the GM will change.If we make it, well, it's the anything can happen, nobody was seeing us winning against the Pens, and we did it, and Philly was among the favourites, and struggled very hard to beat us. So if you are so sure the Leafs would sweep us, I invite you to bet your current bank account on that and show us the ticket.
TLDR: Yes, the current situation sucks, nothing goes right, and it seems doomed. But if we try to rationalize and take a step back, we can see thatWe have an AHL club leading the league with a great coach, and great prospects playing for it.We still are in a playoffs spotWe play bad but know we can play better (and when we do, we are a very good team)We have Hockey, and in this current period of Covid, at least for me being able to watch my favourite sport really help me with the mental struggle of life.
"Rome ne s'est pas faite en un jour". It means let time do his job, and be patient. I know it's easy to say that because Bergevin and the organization keeps repeating it for years now, but this time, there has been a real change (notably the draft and the AHL team) that made believe that yes, we will be great in the future. Anyway, take care, and Go Habs Go!
Edit: It looks like my post was partially misunderstood. The issues I exposed don't represent my personal beliefs, it's more about what comes over and over on this sub. The second part is my attempt to debunk them or put some perspective onto them.