r/HPSlashFic • u/shejnahak • Dec 15 '24
Discussion so i asked chatgpt to roast my favorite ships and this is what it saidš
plus a bonus sub roast at the beginning
r/HPSlashFic • u/shejnahak • Dec 15 '24
plus a bonus sub roast at the beginning
r/HPSlashFic • u/DollopHead35 • Dec 21 '24
I think snarry is professor Snape x Harry Potter right? Why is it so popular? Isn't Snape like 40 something and Harry way young. Like you can ship whatever you want because i dont care, but I'm genuinely curious from where this comes from?? I'm serious I see snarry everywhere on ao3 and I'm super interested why they are a thing. I think maybe it's because Snape loved Harry's mom? And Harry has her eyes? I guess? Please answer thank you!!
Update: Reading the comments I understand why Snarry is popular and I'm glad yall were nice about it. Anyways thanks!!
r/HPSlashFic • u/Abject_Purpose302 • Dec 17 '24
IMHO, I feel this should be mandatory, no? Like certain themes such as MCD, rape/non-con, cannibalism, extreme underage etc if they are in the story, there should be warnings or tags.Ā
I know, some writers want to shock readers and pull out unexpected endings out of their hats like a last-minute magic trick, but not all readers can handle such themes and those who canāt should have the option not toā¦
I know posts on tagging are controversial as many just come here to whine about top/bottom dynamics, but this is a bit more serious concern.
r/HPSlashFic • u/[deleted] • Jan 02 '24
I don't. I remember at one point I tried to read through the books, but I never finished. I only was able to sit through the movies.
My interest with it is only in the fanfiction. Theres so many good fics I've read, and there's just so many fics in general. I like all the different ideas I've seen. Like I did not expect myself to like Snape, but I eventually kept stumbling upon a bunch of snarry (just since it's such a popular ship) and he's my favorite character now lol.
I love it when authors take the story away from cannon, and/or add their own twist on magic/the magical world. The characters are more like general story points, and I prefer it that way. It's more interesting really, and better, I don't want it to be cannon compliant.
r/HPSlashFic • u/Clear-Department-789 • Sep 04 '23
I've asked myself so many times when I'm reading a fanfiction sometimes they will mention blaise Zabini but they always refer him as a she I'm just really confused why people think he's a she but someone tell me why people do this cuz it confuses me but it also like pisses me off you know like I'm not trying to be rude or anything I just I just looks so tired of it I just need to know so can anyone tell me why people do this it's not all people it's just some of them
Help plzzzš„ŗš„ŗš„ŗ
r/HPSlashFic • u/turtleinatrenchc0at • May 06 '24
I do not understand Snarry in the slightest. Not even a little bit. I am usually a Drarry or Tomarry and every the occasional nottpott reader.
Give me a fics you think can change my mind. š
r/HPSlashFic • u/[deleted] • Aug 29 '23
so recently ( i mean just now) i read this utterly beautiful fanfic and ym might know abt it but it was so good. It was based on the four horsemen and there was drarry with enemies to lovers and insane harry. It was unfinished but u guarantee that reading it will make u so happy in life. If u want the link comment
r/HPSlashFic • u/Objective_Poem6027 • Apr 16 '25
i read this crossover fic where since harry had so many ādetentionsā with umbridge the blood quill eventually put a curse on him to where if he lied he would start bleeding from his hand and it would cause pain. i was just wondering if there are any other like that, it doesnāt have to be a crossover and no proships please š
r/HPSlashFic • u/magic8ballzz • Nov 07 '21
Okay, hereās the deal. It's not too often where a plot bunny is longer than some fics, but Iāve been sitting on this idea for well over a year. While I consider myself a decent storyteller, Iām a horrible writer and I found someone to write this but not only is it not what I hand in mind, it looks as though the story was abandoned.
Iām thinking of a 50-100k+ Drarry story titled Phoenix Tears. It begins the summer after the Battle of Hogwarts. Prior to the opening scene, the Malfoys had their trials. Lucius was sentenced to life in Azkaban. Draco and Narcissa, thanks to Harryās testimony, were each only given one year of house arrest. Ron and Hermione stayed at the Burrow long enough for Fredās funeral before traveling to Australia to look for Hermioneās parents. George was going through a depression so deep that he closed up the shop and moved back home spending most of his time holed up in his room and it seemed nobody could get through to him. Harry, between the funerals and trials was staying at the Burrow while trying to avoid Ginny. He had broken things off with her within days after the battle, but for whatever reason, Ginny didnāt get the message. She kept cornering him and talking about plans for their future. Even when Harry had enough and decided to move into Grimmauld Place to get away from her, she got the impression he wanted them to live together and tried to move in with him. It took both Molly and Arthur to get her to stay home. At some point Harry discovered that the boa constrictor he set free had been recaptured and decided to make arrangements to buy it from the zoo. Thatās when he found out he can still speak Parseltongue. Also, Harry was shocked to find one day that Fawkes had taken up residence. This settles his internal dispute on whether he should replace Hedwig. Also Andromeda, getting too old to raise a child on her own, drops Teddy off with Harry for extended periods.
The story begins with Harry coming into the kitchen where breakfast, provided by Kreacher, was waiting along with 4 envelopes and the Daily Prophet. He begins with the Prophet where he reads a story about how Mrs. Zabini was brutally murdered by a vigilante group calling themselves Phoenix Tears. He tosses the paper aside with disgust because this was the fourth such attack. Every one of the victims were killed by an unidentified curse that first paralyzed them before slowly burning them from the inside out. St. Mungoās staff had been unable to identify the curse or find an way to counteract it. They usually fell into a coma after a couple hours but it took days for the victim to finally die. Apparently this group was going after people they felt deserved more punishment than the Ministry gave. All of the victims had some connection to Voldemort, however tenuous. As far as Harry knew the only connection Mrs. Zabini had to Voldemort was that they were both Slytherins and her son shared a dorm with a few of his supporters. He was disgusted because he fought the war to put an end to that kind of behavior.
He went to the envelopes and saw one from Ron and Hermione. It said that they had found Hermioneās parents and restored their memory and should be back within a week. The next one was from Hogwarts inviting him and the rest of his year back to finish their education. He was fairly certain he didnāt want to go back. Yea, he considered it home, but he wasnāt sure heād be able to walk around the castle without seeing all the death. He set that one aside and picked up the third envelope which was from Kingsley informing him that heād have a place with the Aurors if he wanted it. He was rather uncertain of that because, yes, it had once been his goal to join the Aurors, but he also had enough fighting to last him a lifetime. Plus his main reason for wanting to join was to give him a better chance to finish Voldemort. He knew Ron would be disappointed but there wasnāt much he could do about that. The fourth letter was from Ollivander requesting a meeting. It seems that after being imprisoned for the better part of two years had weakened him so much that he was hoping to retire soon and was looking for an apprentice. He figured Harry had a better grasp on wand lore than most, given his experience, and thought he would be ideal for the job. Harry actually considered this. Yes, he did find wand lore to be interesting and he did seem to understand it better than even Hermione. Plus, it seemed like wand making promised to give him the relaxing life he felt he deserved, so he hurriedly replied to Ollivander requesting a meeting. By the way, Ron decides to become an Auror and Hermione goes back to Hogwarts. Theyāre both surprised by Harryās decision. Ron was disappointed but grudgingly accepts it. After all, he didnāt want to go against Hermione who was very pleased that Harry wasnāt going to turn into a layabout and readily accepted his reasoning. (āHonestly, Ronald! Harry deserves a quiet life!ā)
His first meeting with Ollivander was cut short when people suddenly Apparated outside the shop shouting. He immediately recognized the figure of Draco Malfoy surrounded by six hooded figures wearing red and gold cloaks. Before he could process anything, curses started flying. Without even thinking, Harry rushed out of the wand shop and started jinxing the robed figures. He had managed to stun four of them when he heard a shouted Sectumsempra curse from behind just as he felt himself being pushed out of the way. He spun around to see Draco falling to the ground covered in slashes. He immediately stunned the two remaining figures and fell to his knees next to Draco in panic, visions of the bathroom incident flashing in his mind. Despite his panic he still managed to realize Draco had just saved his life by pushing him out of the way. Without knowing what else to do, he grabbed Draco and Apparated to Grimmauld Place.
It was there that a flashback to Snapeās countercurse came to him and he immediately cast it on Draco. He watched as the wounds began to heal, but Draco had already lost so much blood that he passed out. He began to wonder what had happened because since both Draco and Narcissa were under house arrest, neither were permitted to leave the manor. There was even anti-Apparition wards and Auror guards stationed there. It suddenly dawned on him that those robed figures were most likely members of Phoenix Tears and the managed to not only take down the wards from the manor and overcome the Aurors. Then a thought struck him that Narcissa was probably still in danger. He quickly called to Kreacher and ordered him to go to Malfoy Manor and find out what was going on and make sure Narcissa was safe and to bring her to Grimmauld Place if necessary. While he waited, he levitated Draco into one of the guest bedrooms and onto the bed. A few minutes later, he heard the crack of Apparition and rushed into the drawing room to find Kreacher holding onto the nearly lifeless form of Narcissa, who was covered in blood. It was obvious she was close to death. She slowly turned to look at Harry and after affirming Draco was safe, with her dying breath she made him promise to look after her son. He then learned from Kreacher that by the time he got there it was already too late (He tried to punish himself for failing before Harry stopped him.) Aurors came by shortly after and, of course, they tried to charge the unconscious Draco with the murder of three Aurors and the attempted murder of two others as well as for violating his house arrest until Harry with his usual flare for furious outbursts and righteous indignation, prevented that. Kingsley was brought in and after Harry explained what happened, Kingsley agreed that Grimmauld Place was probably the safest place for Draco to serve out the remainder of his house arrest.
Days go by and a depressed and sulky Draco doesnāt speak, eat or even leave his bed. One day Harry finds a miniature dachshund puppy abandoned in Diagon Alley and figured that it might be exactly what he needs to cheer Draco up. When he arrives home, he brings the puppy into Dracoās room and the puppy, in true puppy fashion, immediately tries to endear itself to him by trying to lick every part of Dracoās face it can. Draco, however, is not having it. He just shoves the poor thing onto the floor and turns to lay on his stomach. The next day, however, Harry is in Dracoās room trying to get him to eat when Ron shows up. He walks into the room and immediately the dachshund, who was lying at the foot of the bed, stands up and starts growling at Ron. When Ron just laughs, the puppy jumps off the bed and starts trying to bite at him. Ron quickly leaves followed by a defeated-looking Harry. The puppy finds its way back on the bed where Draco grabs it and holds it to his chest with a satisfied smirk on his face.
Draco is no longer holing himself in his room and is eating regularly. He and Harry are still not on friendly terms, but are at least civil. Draco has taken to wandering around the house while Harry is at the wand shop and occasionally he sits in the library reading with Dewey (thatās what Draco named the puppy) on his lap. The two were inseparable now and he found it immensely entertaining whenever Ron would show is ugly mug only to be chased away by the dog. Draco went into a panic attack when he first saw Carlito (the boa constrictor) slithering through the cat flap in the door leading to the back garden. It took Harry two hours to calm him down after that. Harry had completely forgotten about Nagini and figured he probably shouldāve warned Draco.
At some point before the end of summer, Harry is contacted by Blaise and Pansy to ask if they can visit with Draco. He agrees and during this visit Draco learns that they plan on returning to Hogwarts because they feel safer there with all the attacks going on. He also learns that Crabbe was killed by the Phoenix Tears. That gave him a furious resolve to do something. Harry agreed to give Draco full reign to turn the attic space into a potions lab.
The first of September brought a surprise. It turns out that while the Dursleys were in hiding, Dudley had hooked up with a muggle-born witch and that morning a basket bearing a baby girl was placed on the Dursleys doorstep with a letter saying that the mother died in childbirth and Dudley was the father. That led to a huge fight with Vernon. (āI WILL NOT HAVE ANOTHER ONE IN THIS HOUSE!!!ā) That ended with Dudley standing outside with a crying baby not knowing what to do. He realized that Harry may be his only hope even though he had no reason to expect any help from his cousin. He didnāt know where Harry lived now but remembered Harry left for school every year on that day from Kingās Cross. He had no idea if he would return to school this year, but he was hoping that maybe some of those people would turn up and maybe one of them knew Harry enough to be able to tell him where he lived. He got lucky because when he got to the train station, he recognized Mrs. Weasley as she came back through the barrier after seeing off Ginny and Hermione. She brought Dudley and the baby back to the Burrow until Harry got done at the wand shop. (She couldnāt take him to Grimmauld Place because it was under a new Fidelius Charm and Harry was the secret keeper). Harry, of course, allows them to stay with him until Dudley got on his feet. Dudley decided to drop the Dursley name and use his motherās maiden name. He named his daughter Heather Sue Evans.
Time goes by, Harry is occupied with his apprenticeship, Ron is in full swing in Auror training, Hermione writes frequently regaling Harry and Ron on her studies, Draco spends a great deal of time in his potions lab trying to figure out how to save the lives of those being cursed by the Phoenix Tears and Dudley spends his time between fussing over Heather, looking for work, and working on the MMA training he picked up while in hiding. Harry and Draco are becoming more and more relaxed around each other and one might think they are becoming friends. Of course, Dracoās to stubborn to admit that anything of the sort can happen despite his insides squirming whenever Harry is near and while that fact amuses Harry, heās too oblivious to think anything more of it. Every so often a Prophet article mentions another attack.
As Christmas comes near, Mrs. Weasley agrees to have Christmas at the Burrow because Draco wasnāt allowed leave the house and Harry doesnāt want Draco to be alone. Harry also invites Luna to stay at Grimmauld for the Christmas holidays because her father passed away in Azkaban before the war ended and had no one to spend Christmas with. Of course, in true Luna fashion, she forgives Draco and thoroughly confuses Dudley. However, she and Dudley slowly become inseparable, bonding over little Heather. On Christmas Day, Harry gives Arthur a wrecked airplane with a builderās manual along with flying lessons (earning him a glare from Molly). He gave Draco Snapeās old potions book that he managed to save while looking for the diadem. Draco almost looked like he was about to cry at that. He gives a still depressed George a Hogwarts toilet seat, much to the disapproval of Molly and Hermione. George just looks at it for a full minute before bursting out with laughter. He stands up and pulls Harry into a hug saying a heartfelt thank you. This earns George a glare from Draco that Harry didnāt understand and Draco didnāt want to understand. George opened the shop back up the next day and proudly displayed the toilet seat on the wall above the till.
Over the next few days itās learned that Lucius Malfoy was attacked in Azkaban. The Aurors actually had the gall to charge Harry with his murder because one of the guards claimed they had seen Harry visiting Lucius. But as Harry was also seen by dozens of people in Ollivanderās that day and his want was proven not to cast that spell, he was let go. This gave Draco even more resolve to find a way to prevent the curse from killing its victims.
On New Yearās Eve Harry has a party at Grimmauld. Heather and Teddy are both shipped off to the Burrow and he invites his friends as well as Pansy and Blaise. He is surprised to find that Blaise and Neville are now a couple. He was actually happy for Neville, although he could have gone the whole night without walking in on them in a guest bedroom with Blaise on his knees between Nevilleās legs. Dudley and Luna are found more often than not curled up next to each other After a night of drinking, he finds himself alone with a Draco. After a drunken conversation, they end up kissing. And kissing. And kissing. It shattered both their worlds in the best possible way. That is until Kingsley comes through the Floo to arrest Harry for the murder of Lucius Malfoy. It turns out Lucius was found dead in his cell. He had the Phoenix Tears curse used on him and no one noticed. One of the guards claimed they had seen Harry visiting Lucius a couple days earlier. But as Harry was also seen by dozens of people in Ollivanderās that day and his wand was proven not to have cast that spell, he was let go. This gave Draco even more resolve to find a way to prevent the curse from killing its victims.
Time continues to go by. But now with Harry and Draco finally coming to terms with their feelings. They find themselves looking at each other more frequently than necessary and even sharing a quick kiss or two But with Harryās apprenticeship, Dracoās potions work and two babies in the house, even with Dudleyās help, they didnāt have much time to explore this new dynamic. Until Valentineās Day. Harry takes off work and Dudley offers to take the kids out for the day and Harry sets up a picnic in the back garden for a ādateā with Draco. This ends up in with them having sex in Harryās bed in the late afternoon. Harry wakes up from a post-coital nap to find Hermione in his bedroom door with a stern yet amused look on her face. He forgot she had come back from Hogwarts for a date with Ron and was coming over to get ready beforehand. Harry tries to say that itās not what it looks like which earns him a glare from Hermione (who obiously knew before they did that this would happen) as if to tell him to explain. He then says that someone took Polyjuice Potion to turn into Dracoās evil twin and c ast a Patronus which takes the form of his evil twin. That earns him an exasperated scoff from Hermione and a chuckle from the naked blond lying on top of him.
Harry and Dracoās relationship grew from there. Just after the Easter holidays, Pansy is killed at Hogwarts No one knows how the Phoenix Tears had infiltrated Hogwarts, but she was found unconscious in the girlsā bathroom and taken to the hospital wing died a few days later in St. Mungoās. Draco was sinking further into despair. His mother, his father, Goyle and now Pansy, his bet friend. Fawkes landed on his shoulder as if to provide comfort. He looked up into the birdās eyes. He noticed the phoenix seemed to be crying and he had a sudden inspiration. He quickly grabbed a flask to gather up some of Fawkesās tears. He can combat the Phoenix Tears with phoenix tears.
Sometime near the end of June, Draco came down from the his potions lab where he had just completed a prototype of his phoenix tear potion. Harry was still at the wand shop, Dudley was out with Luna celebrating the end of her schooling and Molly had Heather and Teddy so he was alone. Yet he thought he heard someone coming through the Floo. He reached the kitchen to find Ginny standing there in red and gold robes. This would be the part of the story where itās revealed that Ginny had formed the Phoenix Tears. When Harry broke up with her, she figured all she needed to do was become the hero she saw him as and sheād win him back. So this vigilante group was her attempt at being a hero. Itās also revealed that Ginny was the one who killed Lucius. She had taken some of Harryās hair at Christmas and used Polyjuice potion to get into Azkaban. She figured that no one would question why Harry was there. Harry happened to walk into the kitchen just as Ginny was about to cast the Phoenix Tear curse. He quickly shoved Draco out of the way and was hit by the curse. He had enough time to tell Draco he loved him before passing out.
That is the end of the main story. The epilogue would begin several years later with Draco attending a ceremony where he accepts an Order of Merlin for inventing a cure for lycanthropy. When he arrives back at Grimmauld Place, he wakes up Blaise and Neville who were sleeping on the sofa and thanks them for keeping an eye on Teddy. He walks up the stairs and to Teddyās bedroom. He looks in to find the boy sound asleep. He then goes into his bedroom to change into his pajamas before going up to his potions lab. He looks at the picture on his desk. Itās a picture that someone had taken of him and Harry sometime after their first ādateā in the garden. He feels a pain in his chest at the memory. He goes to his work bench and grabs a potion before he goes back downstairs. He stops at another bedroom and opens the door. On the bed is the unconscious form of a black-haired man with a lightning scar. The prototype he finished making that day wasnāt enough to completely counter the effects of the curse. It did, however, halt the burning and prevent the inevitable. It didnāt restore the damage already done or bring him out of his coma. Heād been working hard the past few years perfecting his potion, hoping with each new batch that it would be the one to work. He opened the flask in his hand and, hoping that same hope, poured it into Harryās mouth. After fifteen minutes Draco sighed and put the flask on the bedside table and walked out of the room. Moments after the door closed Harry opens his eyes.
Now you set yourself up for a sequel where Harry is paralyzed from the waste down doesnāt remember anything after Bill and Fleurās wedding. Naturally finding himself in the care of Draco Malfoy doesnāt sit well with him. Ron and Hermione are married and have a daughter. Ron had been made Head Auror and Hermione is the Head of the Department of Law enforcement. Dudley and Luna are married and expecting a child of their own. They live in a flat above Dudleyās MMA studio where each year, in addition to his Muggle clientele, he gives muggle MMA training to third year Auror trainees. Ollivander had postponed his retirement for the time being until Harry is well. Harry and Draco now must find a way to reconnect while trying to bring Harry back to full strength and full memory.
As I said, I'm horrible at writing, so please, someone write this.
r/HPSlashFic • u/Emilysouza221b • Nov 24 '21
Harry throughout the books is closest to Ron more than any character. Ron is literally the center of his universe. They are always together and very close. Draco is a kid who bullied him and was racist to his other best friend. The Fandom always wants to shine Draco and hate Ron to the point of "Draco in leather pants" and "Ron the death eater" are the name of their tropes on TV tropes. Now there is something to be said about liking redemption stories but it's rarely much of a redemption story, and shockingly common enough it's Harry who needs to redeem himself for being "prejudiced agaist "Syltherin/purebloods" I think the more accurate reason is simple. Folks like Draco because he is rich, he is artristocratic, and Ron is bad because his family is poor. What Ron did during the 4th and 7th books combined isn't comparable to what Draco does consistently every single book. I don't even hate Draco although I'm sure at this point folks have stopped reading to tell me not to hate Draco. Draco deserves redemption, he was a child, at 17 still is basically a child, and can learn and grow. However, we never see that growth. This isn't anti Drarry btw as much as it is a call to the Fandom to consider that maybe they should stop fantasizing about racist elitism because of the "aesthic". Also if you have a Death Eater tattoo, that is gross.
r/HPSlashFic • u/Mxxnlitdream • Apr 19 '25
I mean I'm not into this pairing, but I know there are so many out there who like this particular pairing more than anything else. I'm just curious to know the reason and how it works between the characters.
r/HPSlashFic • u/lola20169878 • Nov 14 '23
At first, I thaught this is ridiculous, Snape is a grumpy, rude man, who would never be interested in Harry they have a huge age gap, but after I read my first fic, where Harry trully admired him as a war hero (whitch actually makes sence based on the books too) and Snape was in love with Lily, their patrons are matchingā¦. I never had problem with the gay thing, bc I think in the wizard world the sexuality is much more free, so I can definetly see the real conection between them now.
But I want to read more opinions, so go ahead.š„°
r/HPSlashFic • u/Interesting_Tutor766 • Sep 23 '25
Ok so a while back I saw a post discussing who youād visualize as certain characters, and Iāve always been one to go for the ficās description rather than picture anyone specific (aside from Snape because I have to work as hard as Harry in an occlumency lesson to get Alan Rickman out of my head, which is why I donāt much go for pairings involving Snape)
Ramblings aside, I was struck by the fancasting Cupidās arrow this week and I have to say, I get it now. All of you with your person in mind? I get it. So this is a bit of a hear me out, get it out my chest sort of post, but my fyp has been inundated with these two lately and I was like gosh, these are Sirius and Regulus! Jamie Roy, from the new Outlander show and Harry Collet from HoD.
r/HPSlashFic • u/MonicaEvans96 • Feb 07 '25
r/HPSlashFic • u/Abject_Purpose302 • Feb 05 '25
I don't mind gen fics that only has platonic friendship/no-romance but I absolutely hate it when fics have characters that obviously have chemistry but end up ''just friends''.
We already have queerbaiting in TV. I have no patience for it in fanfic.
r/HPSlashFic • u/CalligrapherLong5064 • Aug 25 '26
I had such a horrible nightmare that you absolutely need to go read my fic. But first please laugh at me šš
I dreamed someone came up with a George/Hermione/Lee ship and wrote a fic about it. Then they made a Reddit post about the fic.
AND THAT POST GOT MORE UPVOTES THAN MY POSTS.
AND IT HAD THE EXACT SAME CONCEPT AS MY FIC.
HELLO??? WHAT THE FUCK š
I actually woke up earlier than usual because I was so offended.
For context: I write fanfiction about a ship I literally invented for myself and then got way too attached to. And at some point I wrote a Friends With Benefits AU about three idiots who get high and fuck while desperately avoiding their feelings for each other.
AND MY SUBCONSCIOUS DECIDED THAT THE WORST POSSIBLE NIGHTMARE WOULD BE:
someone takes that concept
puts it on a different ship
uses THE WRONG WEASLEY TWIN
and adds Lee
A PERSONAL NIGHTMARE.
The funniest part is that if you replace George with Fred, George/Hermione/Lee is actually not even a bad concept.
BUT NOT IN MY DREAM.
IN MY DREAM WE WERE AT WAR!!
Anyway if you want to support me emotionally after this devastating experience go read my fic. I have suffered enough.
r/HPSlashFic • u/No-Establishment9260 • 4d ago
Does anyone have a pdf of this fic or something i can download to read kindle. I am constantly thinking of this fic and it pains me so much that I cant read it on Ao3. Anything to last me thru until Ao3 is back. Please and thank you!!!!!!!!!!!!
r/HPSlashFic • u/CocoRobicheau • Nov 25 '22
I was thinking about my history as a Harry Potter fanfic reader, after going down a rabbit hole of reading some of the older HP slashfic recs and meta, recently. And I concluded that my fic preferences, and the way I currently perceive many of the characters in HP, are the results of reading fic and meta. My opinions and views have changed quite drastically in some cases! And this is because writers have caused me to reflect on the series and characters!
I have felt, for several years, that fic writers have written better stories about Harry and company than JKR did. And recently, I began to recognize the power of fanon to change my mind about the characters and plot, as well! Itās fascinating, or scary, that I have read so much fanfic! And I believe my changes of heart reflect the quality of fic and meta writersā work.
Here are a few examples!
āWhen I read of Dumbledoreās fate in Book 6, I cried my eyes out! Dumbledore was one of my favorite characters in the series. Today, I fucking hate Dumbledore. The fen convinced me that he is a tyrannical asshat whose āgreater goodā was in fact his own narcissistic agenda, and he gave 2 fucks about all of the people he manipulated. I wish he had gotten what he truly deserved/had the Elder Wand shoved up his ass.
āWhen I read the canon, I didnāt feel strongly about James and Lily Potter, one way or the other. Like most of the minor characters in canon, I felt like I didnāt know them, as we never got much about them from JKR. Today, I despise them both, and I hate Sirius Black as well. They just fucking suck. Lily is a total bitch, first toward the Marauders and then toward Snape. She died? Who cares? Sirius fell through The Veil? Thank Merlin lol!
āI adored Ron and Hermione in the books. Now I think they both sucked as friends to Harry.
āIām a huge fan of Severus Snape, and of the Slytherin students! Vilified and demeaned throughout the canon, they have become the characters that I now want to read about (and Harry!).
āI hate the way Rowling kept referring to the kids of Hogwarts as āchildrenā. Iām sorry, a 17 year- old person is a student, a teenager or a young adult. I hate it when fic writers refer to the kidsā or worse, have the characters refer to themselvesāas children. Itās fucking annoying. āA school full of children lā: if I have to read this phrase one more time, just, ugh.
Forgive me if I bashed on your fave character (s) or something, in my examples; I realize that each person has a different view of the story and characters that we love reading about!
If fanworks have significantly affected your views and perceptions of HP, please share! I would love to hear from slashers who love the Marauders, Dumbledore and some of my peeves. As you can see here, my opinions are pretty changeable!
Thank you all for sharing all that you love about slashfic and HP in our marvelous sub! I am grateful for all of us, and for our diversity!ā¤ļø
r/HPSlashFic • u/Wooden-Medicine-5521 • Mar 18 '25
r/HPSlashFic • u/ksiazkowy_molll • Mar 31 '24
Hi Iām new on here! Looking for fanfic recommendations because I feel like during all the years Iāve spent in the fandom Iāve read everything thatās good ( probably bc Iām picky ) TwT and I want to find if I missed any good fanfics or if any good new ones appeared. Don't worry if you rec me something Iāve already read.Ā
It can be Gen or can have hetero or slash ships ( except f/f ). Looking only for finished fics that have at least 40,000 words and preferably 100,000 and up ( but donāt go over 700,000 )
For pairings/ships I can go along with canon especially if itās Romione ( RW/HG ). No Remadora ( NT/RL ) please tho, I canāt stand it š
For non canon I love Harmony (HP/HG ), Huna ( HP/LL ) and Harry x Fleur ( dunno the name of the ship ), Drarry ( HP/DM ), Adult Wolfstar ( SB/RL ) and Grindeldore (AD/GG ) is okay
I do not want any ships with Snape, and preferably the fic to not be Snape centric. Dramione ( DM/HG ) or Tommary/Harrymort ( TR/HP ) ( LV/HP )
Also I donāt really want to read any ships with a big age gap.
Timetravel ships that have characters be similar age are okay tho!Ā For example currently Iām reading āDelenda Estā
Preferably no smut, or little smut that isnāt too graphic. Not looking for fics focusing on sexual relationships of the characters. I prefer reading for the story/plot ^^Ā
No Harem. No fem!Harry or other genderbent characters, Not looking for WBWL fics. Not the biggest fan of the Marauders fandom ( Iām talking about fics focusing on/from the POV of James, Sirius, Remus or Peter ) but if you feel you have something rlly rlly good from this you can rec too!Ā No bashing or minor bashing that doesn't make the characters too OOC
Not looking for heavy AUās, major changes to the way wizarding world works, no-magic/muggle AUās, or anything that has to do with A/B/O
The story can be from any characters POV but Iād rather it not have much POV switching. Itās okay between 2-3 characters but not more.
No first person writing
Also for slash fics if they have smut no bottom/sub Harry please ^^ and if they donāt for Harry not to act like a āstereotypical bottomā in the relationship or take the submissive role in the relationship. Iād much rather he be a top, or be hinted as the top if thereās no smut
If you have any good fics focusing on one of those 4 characters you can rec them too! Surprisingly I actually like those characters: Lucius Malfoy, Gilderoy Lockhart, Percy Weasley and Sybilla Terlawney. These ones don't have to be long, I'll even read a one-shot if it has a good characterization of those characters!
TY in advance to everyone who will reply
r/HPSlashFic • u/Entropy843 • Jun 05 '20
This pairing always reminds me of Lolita.
r/HPSlashFic • u/JaguarSweaty1414 • Mar 21 '25
Posted this on another subreddit and got removed for hating on other's ships
I have only been in the HP fandom and only start reading maurauder's fics recently but it does seems some people In the fandom like to insists their ship are canon like in r/wolfstar seems loads of people thinks wolfstar are canon where they like to think they are canon, and downvote people who regard Rowling's writing (? as much as I like them in the books they are never stated together and i think Rowling hated it and never intended to let readers think them together (? Well I mean people can ship whatever they wanted , maybe there's some signs in canon but technically they weren't a ship in canon (? My problem with some people is that they'll keep insisting the fanon ships are canon which is my problem to it as they are clearly not canon
Not hating on other's taste in ships though, myself read a lot non canon ships as well but I know that they aren't canon
r/HPSlashFic • u/South-Method5979 • Jul 09 '22
First book was published in '97 and JKR finished writing it sometime in '95. So it's been more then 25 years since
This may be a controversial opinion because I don't think it aged well. It's always a challenge with urban fantasy where some literary choices are dictacted by the society norms of given era. High fantasy can be much more detached from these norms
What I think did not withstand the test of time
facede diversity with characters just being used as the background (Parvati twins, Cho)
epilogue marrying most of the protagnosit off to one another (all cis all school sweethearts)
the focus on marriage and bringing children to world despite risk and being middle of a wizarding coup - Remus and Tonks, Lilly and James. The single characters are killed off: Sirius, Bellatrix, Voldie
no LGBTQ character in school gathering wizards from all over the UK
unsettling attitude towards house elves enslavement with Hermione being ridicullued for taking action
colonial approach to non-human races
The last can go on and on
I still enjoy HP and I love the fandom. But it's also a frozen in time relict of the 90s
What do you think? What irks a modern reader?