r/HPMOR • u/_waterlily_ • Jul 02 '13
[Ch90] Salvaging gender bias in HPMOR
The easiest way to fix anything, if you have the time, is to get help from a specialist. When it comes to gender issues, this means handing off your writing to some articulate feminist for a beta test. If Eliezer hasn't been doing this, I think he's yielded the nerd-right to complain about things like movie physics. But I can't imagine that it is being done. Here is how I envision one of these conversations going, at about chapter 60:
Eliezer: So, I'm starting this new arc about how girls can be heroes, too.
Feminist: Awesome! So Hermione is going to start pursuing goals of her own? Sounds exciting. And it will help with the unfortunate implications about destiny, too.
E: Oh, not like that. It's about all the female protagonists at once - sort of in a blob. And it's really more about discussing female heroism than intruding on the main, Harry-focused plot.
F: How does Hermione demonstrate her heroism, then?
E: I prefer heroine-ism, actually, since she's a girl. She dies. Heroically! Well, more like helplessly and gruesomely. But her death inspires Harry a lot.
F: OK. How about you back-burner that...all of that...and stick to that Azkaban plot? What’s going to happen to Bellatrix? She has a lot of potential for -
E: - being completely sidelined for at least 30 chapters?
F: I have to go wash my hair.
The combination of the Female Hero arc with the very literal “Women in Refrigerators” treatment of Hermione has created unfortunate implications so toxic that only a deliberate subversion of the trope can undo them. Basically, Hermione has to bring herself back from the dead, without Harry’s help, and kick major ass. Otherwise HPMOR is setting back much of what it's trying to help.
The rationalist community has trouble with women, and Eliezer has tried to address this. That's about as much as one can say for the effort. The impression so far is like that of a Senator accused of racism who tries to show sympathy with the African-American community by appearing in blackface. HPMOR, as it stands, comes close to saying “for a woman, heroism means dying to motivate your man.”
Apparently Eliezer has had planned the plot in which Hermione dies for over three years. He decided it was necessary because of a rule of fiction that he learned: “make your characters suffer.” I would like him to consider another rule: “murder your darlings.” And no, that doesn’t mean Neville too. It means that sometimes you come up with ideas, and work on them for a long time, and they don’t work out. And then you throw them away.
Eliezer, any plot that involves Harry bringing Hermione back to life has got to go. Just throw it away. You can still work in your views on cryogenics - maybe she cast an enchantment on herself for this very situation, for the low low cost of just $300/year. But she cannot stay dead, and Harry cannot be the one who brings her back. And, for the love of reason, overcome your biases and have someone check your work.