r/HPMOR • • Jul 02 '13

[Ch90] Salvaging gender bias in HPMOR

0 Upvotes

The easiest way to fix anything, if you have the time, is to get help from a specialist. When it comes to gender issues, this means handing off your writing to some articulate feminist for a beta test. If Eliezer hasn't been doing this, I think he's yielded the nerd-right to complain about things like movie physics. But I can't imagine that it is being done. Here is how I envision one of these conversations going, at about chapter 60:

Eliezer: So, I'm starting this new arc about how girls can be heroes, too.

Feminist: Awesome! So Hermione is going to start pursuing goals of her own? Sounds exciting. And it will help with the unfortunate implications about destiny, too.

E: Oh, not like that. It's about all the female protagonists at once - sort of in a blob. And it's really more about discussing female heroism than intruding on the main, Harry-focused plot.

F: How does Hermione demonstrate her heroism, then?

E: I prefer heroine-ism, actually, since she's a girl. She dies. Heroically! Well, more like helplessly and gruesomely. But her death inspires Harry a lot.

F: OK. How about you back-burner that...all of that...and stick to that Azkaban plot? What’s going to happen to Bellatrix? She has a lot of potential for -

E: - being completely sidelined for at least 30 chapters?

F: I have to go wash my hair.

The combination of the Female Hero arc with the very literal “Women in Refrigerators” treatment of Hermione has created unfortunate implications so toxic that only a deliberate subversion of the trope can undo them. Basically, Hermione has to bring herself back from the dead, without Harry’s help, and kick major ass. Otherwise HPMOR is setting back much of what it's trying to help.

The rationalist community has trouble with women, and Eliezer has tried to address this. That's about as much as one can say for the effort. The impression so far is like that of a Senator accused of racism who tries to show sympathy with the African-American community by appearing in blackface. HPMOR, as it stands, comes close to saying “for a woman, heroism means dying to motivate your man.”

Apparently Eliezer has had planned the plot in which Hermione dies for over three years. He decided it was necessary because of a rule of fiction that he learned: “make your characters suffer.” I would like him to consider another rule: “murder your darlings.” And no, that doesn’t mean Neville too. It means that sometimes you come up with ideas, and work on them for a long time, and they don’t work out. And then you throw them away.

Eliezer, any plot that involves Harry bringing Hermione back to life has got to go. Just throw it away. You can still work in your views on cryogenics - maybe she cast an enchantment on herself for this very situation, for the low low cost of just $300/year. But she cannot stay dead, and Harry cannot be the one who brings her back. And, for the love of reason, overcome your biases and have someone check your work.


r/HPMOR • • Jun 10 '20

A bunch of people got triggered from my previous post because my video had been sped up 1.5x, so I am reposting about the best Harry Potter book, and it's not written by JK Rowling AT NORMAL SPEED to correct that mistake. If you enjoyed it please like and sub, thanks!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/HPMOR • • Jan 12 '22

POV: You use Legilimency on Harry (Secret of the Patronus meme) (Loud)

0 Upvotes

r/HPMOR • • Jan 25 '13

Calculation by fringeperson: When I read this story; I knew I had to recommend it here.

Thumbnail
fanfiction.net
4 Upvotes

r/HPMOR • • Apr 03 '24

Help! I never tried to bite my teacher. But now she seemed to try to bite me...

1 Upvotes

At my school, there’s this daily news show made by students. It’s kinda the same old stuff every day. We’re always told to “lock and dock” our iPads when it starts, but one day, I decided to read math on mine instead.

I need help with two things: 1) Convincing my teacher to understand that the show isn’t helping us learn much, and 2) Suggesting that maybe we could be allowed to quietly do something else, like reading, as long as we’re not disrupting anyone.

Here’s the scoop from the emails: My teacher claimed I was gaming on my iPad, but that’s not right—I was studying math! She made it sound like I’m always trying to sneak my iPad during the show, but I really only questioned the rule once. When I asked her to actually show me this rule, she got super mad. Later, she wrote that I mocked her, but honestly, I was just venting to a friend because I was upset.

Then, there’s the whole detention thing. She gave me lunch detention for the iPad incident, and I totally spaced on going. It was a dumb mistake, not me trying to be rebellious. Forgetting about detention made everything worse. She got even madder and pulled me out of class in the afternoon to see the dean. I swear I wasn’t trying to challenge her; I just forgot.

My parents and the school counselor got involved, but it feels like my teacher isn’t really interested in hearing my side. They say we should respect the student-made news show, but why can’t we do something quietly on our own if the show doesn’t interest us?

Any advice on how to deal with this? I know I'm not Harry Potter. There is no Hogwarts or Dumbledore who rely on me as the savior. I don't want to be kicked out by this muggle school. How can I talk to my teacher about giving us some options in the morning, and how do I make up for forgetting about detention without it blowing up even more?


r/HPMOR • • Sep 04 '13

Just rereading a random chapter when suddenly... (Spoiler up to current)

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/HPMOR • • Sep 27 '26

Claude 3D Animation - HPMOR Chapter 1

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

I asked Opus to make an animation for chapter 1 and it made this which I think is nice?.
I probably won't ask it to make the full thing cause it would take too many tokens and I have other projects but could be nice if someone did something like that now that its possible.


r/HPMOR • • Dec 02 '18

I want to enjoy it But I cant.

5 Upvotes

Dont Take this down because I have wrongthink but.....

Elizer I want to enjoy your story but I just can't for the same reasons as many others who have picked up your series and then put it back down.

Harry is an annoying little bastard who thinks everyone with non rational thought should be 'optimised' with heavy prejudice. Not to mention the improperly applied mathematical theorums and the fact of the matter that you blatantly ignore how humans work and consistently jerk off rationalistic thinkers and other types of hyperrationality. You say that only harry has changed whereas everyone has changed in this fanfic. The fact that harry with all his hyper rationalistic thought doesn't realize its a metaphor for war really blows my mind. He doesn't use his rationality and is a all around little twit. Harry in it of its self is a romanticized Gary-stu with no dimensions for his character and is really just an avatar for the author to fix things he saw wrong with the series all while jerking off rationalism though. Your idea was a amazing one but your execution was terrible ending up with one dimensional charachters and boring at best storytelling with no real drive for the characters to truthfully act like humans for once. This is a alright at best piece of fanfiction. And is a really bad renovelization of HP with quote unquote rationalism.

And I really do want to like it. But I just cant.


r/HPMOR • • Nov 25 '14

PSA: The author of Following the Phoenix is a woman

13 Upvotes

People continue to assume that /u/heiligeEzel (or hezzel at FF.net) is a man. That the author of a rational fic is assumed to be a man, despite multiple corrections including by the author, is really sexist and frusterating.


r/HPMOR • • Oct 30 '12

Turned into Rationalist!Harry during a police control Or: I made a huge mistake today.

20 Upvotes

So this is the story: I've been in a railway station today to get something to drink. All I had with me was my small satchel. (Don't call it a purse!)

Two police officers stop me, one of them asks Do you carry any weapons?

Right answer: No.

My answer: No, I don't have any relevant weapons with me. Big mistake.

Of course, he goes on asking what I would call relevant weapons.

Weapons as defined by {insert local legislation here], I answer.

He just had to do it. He asked me whether I had any weapons with me that didn't fall under those laws.

I took a deep breath and described how I could use all the little innocent things I had with me to kill somebody: Breaking a skull with my electric torch, strangle somebody with the strap of my satchel or my belt, using the prong of my buckle to stab somebody in the carotid, burn an eye out with my stormproof lighter...

Thats when he stopped me.

I've been brought to the police station, my small satchel was searched and declared safe, and I've been frisked.

It took me 45 minutes to get my freaking soft drink.

TL;DR: Cops tend to ask imprecise questions. Try to answer the question they want to ask, not the one they actually ask.


r/HPMOR • • Jan 17 '15

Hermione Granger and the Goddamn Patriarchy

Thumbnail
buzzfeed.com
0 Upvotes

r/HPMOR • • Aug 13 '25

I give up

0 Upvotes

As Einstein said: "insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results" (I know!).

I really liked the first 10, 15 chapters of HPMOR - but now, at chapter 20, I give up.

My reasons:

  • I miss Ron. It's just not Harry Potter without this friendship.

  • I don't like Harry and Draco as friends

  • and I don't like Crabbe and Goyle Dracos nearly robotic minions

  • I miss Quidditch (but yes, the author is right it's a unfair, stupid)

  • Dumbledore as this crazy old weirdo is way out of line

  • so is "battle magic" (but I like why Harry is the most dangerous student)

  • the author didn't understand the function of time turners or the cloak of invisibility at all

  • I don't like how the author tries to squash the whole saga into one book, it hurts his story

  • and I don't like that the author is obsessed with relations to other fantasy / science fiction

But: I really liked how the author wrote real magic into his fanfic so we can learn from the story.

After all this: is there at least one good reason why I should continue reading HPMOR?


r/HPMOR • • Aug 06 '13

Chapter 89 Am I the Only One Who's Glad Hermione...

3 Upvotes

is no longer in the picture? Her mode of "Good" felt egotistical and boring. She didn't ask herself enough hard questions to qualify as good in Harry's Heroic Estimation, and maybe I'm biased in Harry's favor simply because of his wildcard allure, but I'm skeptical about what Hermione offered, as a plot device and as a person. She was Harry's Role-Respecting foil, and as cold as it sounds, she functions better within the plot as a martyr than she did alive.

Did her axiomatic ethics bother you? How?


r/HPMOR • • Apr 17 '15

Bhutan is a real-world country of deathists. Dumbledore would fit right in!

Thumbnail
bbc.com
0 Upvotes

r/HPMOR • • May 15 '25

hpmor to Ghibli cartoon

0 Upvotes

An example of what it might look like.


r/HPMOR • • Sep 25 '13

Can any of you say they're as smart as Harry? Let's compare our intelligence to Harry's.

0 Upvotes

I don't mean the rational style of thinking. I mean the raw processing power that you need before you even begin to start thinking rationally and evaluate different options quickly.

I'm 21, and Harry in this story is way way above me almost on every level of cognition. The most glaring is how he is capable of making very important good decisions in situations where he has only minutes left to make a decision. The way I think in those kind of situations is something like this "ummm... there is this option, but it has some disadvantage so I should probably do the first thing... oh yeah and I didn't think of this.. shit I have to make decision, well maybe I choose the first option" and then the time has passed. I've read about 50% of the sequences and adopted some of the rational thinking style, so it's not only that the way I think is at fault. I'm just not a quick enough thinker to evaluate different options so quickly.

I know that Harry is basically an author avatar for EY and that EY made Harry and the other characters really smart on purpose, but it's still intriguing to talk about it.

Harry in this story is a child genius and I don't think it's only his rational way of thinking that makes him so good at decisions. Maybe someone like Feynman, Einstein or even Yudkowsky, people like that could have been like Harry as a child, but not regular people.

So what do you think? How does your intelligence compare to Harry's?


r/HPMOR • • Jul 05 '15

why so many books?

0 Upvotes

Every inch of wall space is covered by a bookcase.

...And it still isn't enough. Books are overflowing onto the tables and the sofas and making little heaps under the windows.

After reading the last psychiatrist, the obvious question is...

Why so many books? This isn't "building a library"; this is hoarding behavior. The books represent something...they provide some feeling of security or validation beyond their innate usefulness. The obvious answer is that owning books serves as self-validation, for a professor who wishes he were more famous, a wife who wishes her husband respected her emotional needs, and a son who is driven by his parents to scholarly achievement at the exclusion of all else.

If they were smarter, they would own fewer books.


r/HPMOR • • Aug 23 '14

PSA: Eleazar Yudokowski

5 Upvotes

is NOT how you spell his name. It is "Eliezer Yudkowsky", and it is printed in the sidebar to your right for your copy-pasting convenience should the need arise.

Sincerely,

Larry Lannie Lanny Heidelburger Hide Heib Heidbreder
Chairman, National Association of Mangled-Epithet Sensitivity


r/HPMOR • • Aug 14 '13

Hermione Granger Versus the Methods of Rationality (Feminist Critique on HPMOR)

Thumbnail
stormingtheivorytower.blogspot.be
23 Upvotes

r/HPMOR • • Feb 20 '25

I have thought of a way to lie in parceltongue.

0 Upvotes

If the universe is infinite as science suggests then there will be infinite amounts of any possible arrangement of atoms.
If the multiverse theory is true then the same conclusion applies.
If the theory of universes being destroyed and created in cycles is true then there will be infinite amounts of any possible thing in the future.

When I say that I will or won’t do a thing which I am I speaking about.
When I sky the sky is blue or green or purple what sky am I talking about.
Etc…

Edit: I said lie in the title because it was more sensational than mislead.
To the target it appears as a lie, to me it appears as sleight of hand. Replacing one thing with another thing that has the same word but a different meaning.
I admit large stupidity.


r/HPMOR • • Feb 06 '14

HPMoR As A Writing (And Reading) Lesson

5 Upvotes

A couple of years ago, before diving into HPMoR, I was talking to a friend, aspiring writer, and we're analysing one work of fiction (I don't remember which one now).

This friend of mine was saying things like "the tension on this scene is chaotic" or "that character is so damn poorly built" or "this dialogue seems fake". At the time, I said, frustated, to him: "dude, I read a lot [of nonfiction], but I just can't see what you see. Maybe I should study more story developement".

It turns out I didn't necessarily need to study anything. Reading hpmor supplied me with a well-built story against which I can compare anything I'm reading. So, today, I can see what "character developement" means, when one dialogue seems off or when the writing is bad altogether.

This sort of ruined most fiction I come accross, since I have a more refined taste now. Although, on a brighter note, I can admire a good work when I see one.

Has anybody noticed something similar?

Edit: confusing phrase


r/HPMOR • • Apr 04 '16

Less Wrong = Eliezer Yudkowsky ???

2 Upvotes

I'm mind blown right now. How could this be?


r/HPMOR • • Jul 16 '15

It's late and I'm bitter. So this is me poking at HPMOR and being snarky about it.

0 Upvotes

This post spoils and is immature and you should probably stop reading before it rustles your sensible jimmies.

In the final arc QQ seals HP in a circle and tells him he will explode if he touches it. Why does the rationalist powerhouse that is HJPEV just accept that and tries literally nothing to protect himself from the explosion?

I mean it is specifically stated to him that if there would be a gush of lava from the mirror both of them would die. Why doesn't he try to make any provisions for himself at all in such a perilous and obvious trap environment?

Why does he just stand there and does nothing but gush at what QQ is seeing in the mirror. Like wtf, you deduced (you little Sherlock you) that at the end of this he is going to kill you. Why wouldn't he do that now? Why not even try to protect yourself? QQ could be like: "I got the stone now bitches, I'm out of here. And btw mr. Potter... BOOM!" and our little hero 'splodes. And QQ just Slytherines out of there through some crack in the stone floor or burns his way to China with fiend-fryed-chicken of doom or some such.

Just transfigure yourself a bunker dummy! make it a super cuntductor doctor aimed at yourself, turn your blood into gasoline. Or go up, its a circle not a sphere! Grab your solidfuelboomstick and hufflehoop out of there.

Who is gonna see you, Hogwarts air control tower? You think they've got them in the constant changing architecture of the castle? Or maybe Peeves got himself a job as one to navigate Fawks?

For that matter why doesn't Doubledoor try to flame in and grab HP in like a jizzminute? You pop in, you pop out, right? It seems like it would be a non-issue for "the only sane person all along".

But what do I know, I have never been an All-with-the-bus. Though certainly not for lack of trying, I still have burn marks all along my dipstick...

But anyway, what happens next is probably the most confusing thing ever written. We've got some building up forces ( I don't know maybe the constant changing of Hogwarts architecture is just the set of Bob the Builder), and dis time it's the dark lord that gushes all over HP and strips him of his cloak of dignity.

And maybe Harry is spent at that moment, after all that peeping on the Tom and Bus-unity action, and doesn't try to make a grab at Lord Queef-a-lot.

However, it seems to me to be counter-intuitive that even through a surprise child grab, the child does not try to get his toy cloak back (maybe there wasn't ever any dignity to begin with?), or make any external reaction what-so-ever, just like if all the action was still in the minor.. I mean mirror. You know, like when Harry was supposed to go behind the mirror in his cloak of dignity, and if the mirror turned around to face him he was supposed to in a jiffy moan about it, or gush to professor dark farts about it, I forgot which was it. I'm sorry...

I'm sorry I must have focused too much on the stroking bit. You know... The one when they stroke each others egos with talk of seduction of intelligent enough minds that you could never fully control the urges and the polygamy, and looking into each others eyes and kissing, (or was it hissing?) with tongues that were Slythering around in forbidden chambers, and corridors, and... Visiting some bushes on detentions with your Ruby hot and Hairy teachers... Mmmmmm...

Now, some say on such visits lights of rainbows appear, others have said it's raining men, and one was even rumored to have a thing for trees and horses, and some destruction from behind with sticks that produce "go" traffic lights. I wouldn't know, like I said I got very confused. You could almost say confounded. I say almost because my robes didn't turn any brilliant color.

Heck, I don't wear robes and I am not a world's most powerful stick stroker. But if I was I don't think my strokes would expire after a couple of minutes. I'm pretty sure even an eleven-year-old child would out-stroke me if that would be the case. I think I even read somewhere that such a child could produce a stroke for more than an hour and even could renew it in the before stated time! It might have pursued later-on a career in veterinary field because believe it or not, such stroke was performed on a horse, no less!

But hell, maybe with age the strokes get more complicated and as far as I have understood that it was a seventy-year-old man preforming it on a hundred-something-year-old man and I can see sense in that. In such case it probably was complicated.

However, even with all that confusion my suspicions remain. That power thing and experience of doing something for decades has got to count for something. I am not siting here polishing my pouc to amount to nothing in life, dammit! Maybe somebody else could explain it all to me. A more masterful person ought to know more about different strokes for older folks.

That is all I had weighing on my heart for today thank you for your attention and prospect replies. The tipping point for me was the masterful audio version of HPMOR by maestro Eneasz Brodski/y I recommend it very much because it was how I got into the HPMOR, and I think it has a magic all of its own. I am sure master Yudkowski would be proud of how they have portrayed his conquest... I mean subjugation... I mean all in all you're just another brick in the wall.

Gobble, Gobble!


r/HPMOR • • Apr 28 '15

Current events relevant quote in Chapter 74

7 Upvotes

"Those bullies were attacking victims long before this year," Harry said. Despite his best efforts, his voice was starting to rise. "But nobody seems to have taught the students that they're allowed to fight back. I know it's much harder to ignore a two-sided fight than some helpless victims getting hexed or almost pushed out of windows, but it's not exactly worse, is it? I wish I'd read more of Godric Gryffindor's writings so I could quote him, there's got to be something in there about this. Open battle may be louder than the victims suffering in silence, it may be harder to pretend that nothing is happening, but the final result is better -"

-Chapter 74