r/HIMYM • • Apr 01 '14

Hate to say it...

Thumbnail
imgur.com
1.1k Upvotes

r/HIMYM • • Mar 06 '25

The fact that Ted says “I’ve outgrown Barney as a friend” as a response when Robin asks why he’s mad at him and not at her for sleeping together is a crystal clear example why he sucks big time.

10 Upvotes

Barney did a bad thing, yes. Whoever argues “bUT bArnEy slePt wiTh RoBIn” - I’m not arguing against you, yes that’s a dick move. BUT Ted handles the whole thing way worse. Trying to appear to be the bigger man with Robin but then being just hypocritical to Barney is an ass move as well. And this is what I hate about Ted so much, that he paints himself as the good guy ALWAYS, but he isn’t; and shames Barney even when Barney has made progress in his own arc.


r/HIMYM • • Mar 20 '25

Anyone know who plays her? The one on the right btw.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/HIMYM • • Mar 03 '25

San Fransisco... Lily wasn't selfish

55 Upvotes

I keep coming across people talking about it. Did the end result suck? Yes, sure. But what she did wasn't entirely selfish.

She was having second thoughts about the wedding. This was a 25/26 years old woman. She spent the last few years financially helping his boyfriend through law school. During which time, she painted but had to take another job.

In the first season she had a pregnancy scare, she also was afraid how she was fitting to Marshalls family all of which were glossed over by Marshall (to most people it seemed like he handled and fixed it but concerns were never actually addressed) . And when the time came, she did get an opportunity to follow her dreams. Robin spent 9 seasons to follow hers, Marshall got his chance several times, Ted quit his job and so many other options. This was Lily's first and only chance for a really long time. She wasn't sure if that is what she wanted but she wanted to see if she can do it. Ted actually understood and helped.

It all goes to hell when Marshall finds out and refuses to listen. She doesn't wanna cancel the marriage. She just wants to see if she can be something more than just Marshalls wife. Marshall is the one saying either San Fransisco or wedding. He considers her doubts about herself as her doubts about them. Cancelling the wedding late was bad but in the end marrying with that question in mind was worse for their future


r/HIMYM • • Nov 12 '12

I wonder what Lili will say! (x-post from r/funny)

Post image
154 Upvotes

r/HIMYM • • Aug 24 '25

Lily was absolutely right here

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/HIMYM • • Jan 07 '23

Noticing a bad attitude toward transgender people

0 Upvotes

On a rewatch right now and its been a few years since my last. I’m noticing so many of the “worst case scenarios” Ted and sometimes Barney play in their minds is their date/interest “secretly being a dude”.

It happens in the episode with Janet McIntyre (mystery vs history) and when theyre guessing why Robin doesn’t go to malls. And these are just the examples I can think of.

Just a part of the show I’ve noticed is not aging well at all. Kind of a bummer to notice and I wonder if writers have regrets. Thoughts?

Edit: wow I’m super sad to find out how many transphobic assholes occupy this sub. If you can’t understand the difference between having a preference and making sweeping offensive statements and jokes, you need to do some reflection. Or maybe some reading.


r/HIMYM • • Nov 09 '24

Everytime I rewatch the series I hate lily more

12 Upvotes

r/HIMYM • • Feb 12 '25

opening A again due to low response on 1st post and a request (plus i think we can do better), also for some reason all my posts have 0 upvotes but a 47% upvote ratio lol

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/HIMYM • • Feb 11 '25

B is for-

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/HIMYM • • Mar 04 '26

Marshall hiding that he didn’t want to be an environmental lawyer anymore from Lily in season 6 was selfish

0 Upvotes

No one ever brings this up! Marshall knowingly avoided telling Lily about this and just let it play on for years. Lily is completely fair to feel upset by it because it IS who she fell in love with that matters. It’s weird for Marshall to think she just has to accept it. If part of how they fell in love was bonding over their values, for it to change without her knowing I would feel betrayed


r/HIMYM • • Feb 20 '26

Risky q: Is Marshall anybody else’s least favorite character as well?

2 Upvotes

Don’t get me wrong, I love him - bro is a HIMYM character after all. But I find him to be the least interesting one because, for all intense and purposes, he is a pretty stable guy. I am glad he is in the show, he grounds it and is often the voice of reason. He also has some really funny gags. But I also care about him the least and find him a little bland, I’m a lot more invested in the lives and choices of the other characters.


r/HIMYM • • Mar 03 '25

Discovered this big reveal about the mother in season 1

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

This has probably already been posted but in re-watching again I noticed that in S1:E9, when Ted is talking to the stripper on Thanksgiving, she says her real name is Tracy and then Ted tells the kids "this is the true story of how I met your mother".

First time I caught this.


r/HIMYM • • Oct 02 '23

Robin ain’t that hot

0 Upvotes

Tbh Robin is kinda mid. I get annoyed when he character says she’s hot. Like she’s alright I guess. She’s not ugly but there are a lot more attractive chicks on the show.


r/HIMYM • • Apr 01 '14

After reading the finale discussion post...

Post image
829 Upvotes

r/HIMYM • • Nov 27 '12

I'm done with this subreddit

1 Upvotes

This is one of my favorite shows. I still love all the characters and I'm enjoying season 8. But after EVERY episode I check out the discussions and all I see is complaints and criticism over the tiniest things. The negativity of this subbreddit is seeping over into my view of the show, so i'm going to have to unsubscribe.


r/HIMYM • • Sep 23 '23

It’s quite ridiculous Bob Saget had to be the voice of Ted in the future

0 Upvotes

Like they say, on Family Guy he’s already an adult, so it’s not like he’s gonna grow into Bob Saget. It’s even sillier when you notice that Bob Saget’s voice didn’t sound much different than when he was younger on Full House. Even worse is how the finale it’s still Josh Radnor with aged makeup and still with his normal voice.


r/HIMYM • • Jan 13 '26

Ted Moseby 🙄🙄

0 Upvotes

I recently started watching the show with my husband who watched it pretty early maybe when he was in college.. And I keep saying.. oh my god, Ted is such a jerk.. and I still haven’t completed the show. And my husband also is slowly realising how shitty Ted is actually. He’s like a wolf disguised in Sheep Skin, and yes Barney does it but he owns it and also mostly I’ve seen Barney do 1 night stands with girls who also just wanted the s*x, so it was consensual. Ted has emotionally abused many women, he breaks up badly with Natalia, I’m currently at the scene where he breaks up with Victoria because of the whole Robin Fiasco.. I slightly disliked Robin for how she treated Victoria, like girl make your mind ok, if you want Ted or not. And I’ve a feeling that the rest of the series won’t put sense into him at all. I mean do ya’ll feel the same or is it only me!!!!! Ugghh 😤😤


r/HIMYM • • May 07 '24

Lily didn't deserve Marshall .

13 Upvotes

I feel bad for Marshall for being so in-love with her. He should've rejected her permanently after she left him. I also hate her in general but that's a whole other thing - The way she didn't keep a secret (and acted like it wasn't in her control), The fact she broke ted up with 6 different girlfriends, the way she acted with weddings with the whole "the bride is always right" thing (it just felt so toxic) etc.

Am I the only one that doesn't like her whatsoever?? Also obviously the writers did an amazing job writing her and she was absolutely essential for the series, this isn't a critique of her writing.


r/HIMYM • • Feb 26 '23

Lilly is the worst character Spoiler

0 Upvotes

She really has no redeeming qualities. Most of all she acts like a child. She throws tantrums. She punished people by stealing. She acts like a narcissist on her birthday. She doesn’t appreciate marshall. She left him to go to San Francisco. She wanted to uproot the entire family to be an art nerd In Italy instead of letting Marshall be a judge, which is a real future. She’s very selfish and immature


r/HIMYM • • May 23 '13

Has anyone ever noticed this before? Top-left corner newspaper article...

Thumbnail
imgur.com
0 Upvotes

r/HIMYM • • Nov 04 '25

Why do people hate the ending? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

hello everyone, I have just finished the show after 3 weeks of binging it non stop. I was just wondering, why do many fans hate the ending?

I think it’s one of the best endings that could’ve happened. We see Ted finally find this love of his life in Tracy, but he also eventually gets to live the rest of his life with Robin who he’s been wanting for the whole show. I do wish they elaborated more on Barney’s character since after he has his child they don’t really touch up on him anymore but aside from that I think there wasn’t much of a problem with the ending.


r/HIMYM • • Jul 27 '22

Screw y'all the HIMYM ending and finale season were perfect Spoiler

1 Upvotes

I know this is an unpopular opinion, at least on this sub, but after rewatching the final season for the uptenth time it has to be said as HIMYM is my favourite show and I'm sick of all the hate my fave shows ending gets when it was actually perfect.

All the scenes where they hint that Tracey was going to pass away and that Ted and Robin would get together afterwards were so well done and still make me well up - they managed to tell two great love stories together without ever undercutting the importance of either one of them to any of the parties involved (Ted, Tracey and Robin).

If you have a different opinion, fine. But for this true fan the ending and final season were perfect and I wouldn't change a thing.

Edit - This is intended to be a post for the unspoken few of us who like the ending and final season. If you don't like it, that's fine too. But please don't bring your toxic negatively to this thread, it's not welcome. There are already too many hateful posts on this sub about the ending and final season, got comment on one of them - this thread is not for you. Peace out hombres