There is quite a bit to unpack here, so I will do my best to do write this as clearly and concisely as possible.
I come at this issue from the perspective of someone who is ambivalent about age limits in gymnastics. If there must be one, I'd be in favor of it being 14 or 15. But I wouldn't be opposed to not having an age limit tbh. When it comes to the history of federations falsifying ages, my issue has always been the lack of fairness it inherently caused. Everybody should be held to the same rules and standards, obviously. Cheating goes against the very nature of what sports are about to me.
So getting to the point.. 😂 I really have a problem with how and why Dong Fongxiao was singled out in 2010, and Team China being stripped of both their 1999 World and 2000 Olympic team medals.
Not coincidentally, this medal snatching happened in the shadow of an IOC requested FIG investigation that failed to find any hard evidence of age falsification by the gold medal-winning Chinese gymnastics team at the 2008 Olympics. Sadly hearsay is not valid evidence, but it is a fact that prior to the Games, several people recall hearing sources within China lamenting over what a shame it was that they had a girl who was out of this world on bars but was only 13/14 and wouldn't be age-eligible for the upcoming Games. But just a few months later, she miraculously turned up at those very same Olympics anyway. Her name was He Kexin.
When you have an authoritarian regime determined to make a good impression in front of the entire world and bring home as many medals as possible for said Home Team, it's not so surprising when athletes suddenly become whatever age they need to be. Along with the accompanying passports or documents that are needed to verify it. Once you have the government in collusion with such a practice, it's basically a non-starter when it comes to getting caught.
Unless, that is... you wind up getting caught up years later, which is exactly what happened to Dong Fongxiao. It's tough to keep up a ruse like lying about your age for nearly a decade, and she made the mistake of giving her actual date of birth whilst working as an official at the Beijing Games.
The year she gave in 2008 didn't match the one that she had competed under during her gymnastics career (including meets like the 1999 Worlds and 2000 Olympcs in Sydney). She was actually only 13 at the 99 Worlds and 14 at the 00 Olympics—years below the requirement of being 16 years by December 31st of the current year (or 15 in a year preceding the Olympics which used to be an exception that has since been done away with). And in just a manner of seconds where Dong probably wasn’t even thinking, she had given them the ammo they needed and we were off to SCAPEGOAT CITY.
Now Dominique Dawes is a 3 time Olympic team medalist! And poor Fongxiao is just another casualty in a cruel system she had no say in who just did what she was told to do.
This is the backdrop for an alarming issue that has been spreading like wildfire in recent years.
Many younger fans have accused many longtime fans (i.e. basically anyone who thinks He Kexin was 14 and underage in Beijing) of being racist against Chinese people. As someone who was a whole grown-ass man in 2008 and not a zygote or small child, this seems incredibly offensive.
Those of us with critical thinking skills remember a pretty staggering amount of evidence at the time showing He was underage. And we didn’t take much stock in potentially fabricated passports from a totalitarian regime, for obvious reasons.
Even though it may be hard to believe, the internet of 2008 wasn’t quite the animal it was today. Facebook was still in its infancy. Twitter had barely been launched and Instagram didn't even exist yet. There definitely was not the same level of divisive rhetoric and games of telephone that go on now.
The information about He was certainly not "fake news" or the sort of bullshit that partisan internet users will take as fact nowadays (e.g. the 2020 US Election was rigged with mystery Biden votes coming out of nowhere).
I honestly am not sure why there is so much vitriol towards fans who feel the Chinese cheated in 2008. Perhaps the idea that multiple girls were underage gives more fuel to the accusations of racism? Or the misguided naivite of youth and wanting to believe that a federation wouldn’t lie and cheat like this? I understand being a fan of a program and giving it the benefit of the doubt when it comes to following the rules, but doing the equivalent of sticking your fingers in your ears and burying your head in the sand so you don't have to hear or see the facts is not the way to go about it.
Whatever the motive or reasoning, it is very insulting to be called a racist when the conclusions you’ve come to have nothing to do with race and everything to do with logic, reasoning, and the history of the issue in the sport.
I absolutely understand the viewpoint that targeting the Chinese team in Sydney was unfair, although I wouldn't go as far to say it was racist. And while no fewer than three other countries have either admitted or had evidence provided of age falsification, none have any allegations as recent as China. Again, I don't think this is racist, it's just pointing out facts. Logically, it’s just not that much of a stretch to think China would have been falsifying ages in 2008 if they had been just 8 years prior to that. There is also evidence of Cheng Fei's age being falsified in 2004.
This is not racism. It's a pattern.
When it comes to federations besides China or North Korea, the last gymnast I can recall being proved underage was Romanian Alexandra Marinescu in the mid-90s. (If there are others, hopefully someone will point them out in the thread below.)
The rules regarding punishment for age falsification are incredibly confusing. My knowledge of the FIG over the past 29 years gives me a hunch that that is not accidental. I've heard there is a statute of limitations, which would have to be the case considering the vast number of gymnasts known to be underage who comfortably still have all their medals in their possession.
Even after North Korea submitted multiple different years of birth for the same athlete and ended up being banned for a time, I'm not sure any attempts were made by the FIG to actually, you know, UNCOVER THE CORRECT BIRTHDATE OF THE ATHLETE IN QUESTION? I imagine there is a chance that Kim Gwang Suk was still underage in 1991, but she was allowed to compete and won the gold medal on bars.
So while I resent being called racist for not thinking He Kexin magically aged 2 years in a manner of months, the devil's advocate in my head is saying if Dong Fongxiao and Co. had to give back their medals, why not everybody?
I am even willing to volunteer to be the one to personally go to the home of Daniela Silivas-Harper and collect her beam gold and team silver from the 1985 Worlds. I'm not sure where Kati Szabo is living these days, but I would be overjoyed to hand her the beam gold she never was able to physically win at an actual World Championships. Thirty-six years later is better than never.
And while I love my Soviets more than life itself, rules are rules. All the individual and team medals won by and with gymnasts who were underage should be stripped as well. That includes MANY of my idols such as Ilienko, Mostepanova, and even poor Yurchenko by association. I would be crushed, but what's good for the goose has to be good for the gander. I can’t be hypocritical about this.
I wonder if maybe because these Chinese fans can't yell at the FIG for taking away the 2000 team's medals that accusing us of being racist somehow makes up for it? In any case, it's very disturbing and I wish there could be some sort of resolution. The collective well-being of the Gymternet at large could certainly benefit from better communication and a deeper understanding of fans’ differences.