r/Gymnastics • • Feb 25 '23

NCAA I don’t know if I’m the only one that feels this way but I’m getting really fed up that Alexis Jeffrey is competing week in and week out, suffering zero consequence for her actions.

0 Upvotes

It’s kind of disgusting that she got picked up so quickly and feel bad for team members that may have heard about what happened only to end up on the same team as her.


r/Gymnastics • • Jun 01 '24

MAG/WAG Hot take: How many times does Jessica have to be right to stop accusations of making things up?

4 Upvotes

Every time Gymcastic releases a new and interesting piece of information, every other post on this sub is qualified by "...well it came from Jessica so maybe she is just making it up."

It is stale and unfair at this point. While Jessica will never be a person who isn’t ridiculous and cringe sometimes, she has earned our respect as a journalist and it is just lame at this point to devalue her reporting.

Consider the following.

  1. Look at the company she keeps. Her co-host, Spencer, is widely loved and respected throughout the gymternet. The relationship you have to have to produce a podcast as prolific and labor-intensive - as well as one that is delivered in multiple media (live, for example) - is a relationship based on trust and respect, and some fondness. He is in business with her.

There is no way Spencer would keep so closely associating himself with a product that is unreliable or frivolous. He frequently and rightfully finds Jessica ridiculous. None of that has caused him to become less of a partner to her, except in the ways that are personally necessary for him, like not traveling to meets. He is clearly a person who is very selective about who is in his circle. Jessica must be among his closest relationships at this point.

Before Gymcastic made the business decision to stop covering MAG, Gymcastic reporting was shaped by Kensley Behel. Kensley Behel is an actual scholar and a deeply thorough reporter. She doggedly pursues the answers to questions that aren’t immediately available or which seem to be purposely obscured, or if something is overlooked or contradictory.

Listen to one single segment on MAG she's done on the podcast. It is immediately a apparent that she is a serious person. There is no way a serious person would associate themselves with someone who is known to be unreliable and untrustworthy.

Gymcastic frequently works with Deanna Hong. Deanna Hong is an award-winning video journalist and has her choice of media outlets to associate herself with. She chooses to work with Gymcastic. She is comfortable tying her professional tying her professional reputation to this outfit.

Jessica’s husband, Steve Cooper, is a serious legitimate journalist who is involved with several projects that involve a deep level of trust. He ghostwrote Miss Val‘s book and his currently working with Aimee Borman to ghostwrite her memoirs. There is no way those people would trust Steve Cooper to tell their stories if he was associated with a frivolous, unreliable, and irresponsible outfit. His role in the production of Gymcastic has expanded considerably, not the opposite.

Scott Bregman is among the most popular and trusted personalities in gymnastics reporting. He is a true insider and professional. At big meets, you will often find him sitting next to Jessica and participating in her live shows after the meets end. There is no way Scott Bregman would tie his professional reputation to Gymcastic if it were not bona fide. Associating himself with a frivolous media outlet would water down his professional credibility and he simply would not do that. He could be going to the bar or taking a shower and going to sleep after the meet is over and the media zone has closed. Instead, he has signed on to the Gymcastic live recap and even appears on camera sometimes.

He even attends their weekly behind-the-scenes shows. He considers them his peers.

Scott, Spencer, Deanna, Kensley, Miss Val, and Aimee Boorman trust Jessica. Why can’t you?

2. Journalism relies on trusting relationships that are not always public.

Have you ever read a story reporting something and then saying the information is "according to a person close to the situation"?

These scoops that you are so suspect of? That’s what she is reporting. People tell her things they give her permission to say on the show, as long as they personally are not named.

It is clear that she also does not report those things unchallenged. She has said this before, and based on a random interaction with Steve Cooper I believe, that she tries to get three sources total to validify information before she says it on the show. That is proper journalistic practice.

She also clearly does what she can to get on the record quotes whenever possible. You will often hear her say that she has placed a call to USAG about something. When she reports something, she seeks out the other side for an on the record statement. That is proper journalistic practice.

Have you ever heard about a journalist protecting their sources? A source has to trust a journalist to be responsible with the information they share with that journalist before they will continue to share information with that journalist. If it gets around that a journalist is irresponsible with information sources share with that journalist, people will stop talking to her. That is clearly not the case. It sounds like her bank of sources has grown a lot since she started the podcast.

In addition to telling something to a journalist not for attribution, which in journalistic parlance is called talking to someone "on background," trusted journalists will also have a bank of sources who will talk to them off the record. That means they will share information with that journalist without giving that journalist permission to report the information, with or without attribution.

If a journalist is irresponsible with off the record statements, people will stop giving that journalist off the record statements, and that journalist may even be blackballed. It is clear that Jessica has built up a solid bank of sources who are talking to her off the record. She cannot say exactly what she has been told, but she can use it to shape the questions she asks on the record.

Jessica has not even remotely been tarnished due to irresponsible actions. In fact, her access has grown considerably. She is expected to be at media zones, and at this point it seems like USAG has come to anticipate questions she will ask and be prepared with some kind of PR-speak response.

The only podcast that comes close is All Things Gymnastics, and I will say more about them later. They are doing amazing work and the only thing stopping them from being more well-known is time.

I truly do not understand what it will take for people to start taking Jessica and Gymcastic seriously. They have more than earned our respect as a media outlet with sustained rigorous reporting.

You all listen anyway, no matter what you say. You listen to and you like the podcast, but you don’t admit to it. Let's all agree to stop being weird now, while still recognizing and holding Jessica accountable when she messes up. Her mistakes are due to a lack of personal discipline, not a lack of journalistic integrity.

Back to All This Gymnastics. I still can’t tell their voices apart, and I don’t know which sister it is who worked for Inside Gymnastics magazine, but their experience in professional journalism shows. They have their own lane that they have made their own, which is outstanding interviewing. They book some serious names.

They recently created a graphic for a meet, I forget which one, that was based on the roster of participants. They noted for each name the colleges they attend or are committed to, and international meets they have attended and what if any medals they won. They created a true resource and I give them all the credit in the world for that. It is the kind of infographic magazines love to print and would be at home in the highest tier of media publications. I love how they have blossomed and wish them all the success in the world.


r/Gymnastics • • Dec 08 '21

WAG Did MyKayla Skinner declaw her cat?

2 Upvotes

In her newest Instagram story you can see her cat Melo sleeping and trying to extend her claws but nothing is there. Considering that MyKayla has asked about declawing in November 2020 on her IG and Twitter (I think), I'm wondering if she went through with it even though so many people told her about the consequences and how horrific it is for a cat.

I really hope I'm wrong!


r/Gymnastics • • Aug 16 '24

Other "The bronze medal received by Ana Barbosu not the same as the one awarded to Jordan Chiles. Jordan choose to keep it"-Romanian media

Thumbnail
digi24.ro
2 Upvotes

r/Gymnastics • • Jun 04 '24

MAG/WAG Covid at the Olympics

2 Upvotes

Someone mentioned in a thread on the alternates that there is no Covid testing in Paris. One even suggested that in case someone felt sick, but well enough to compete, they should just not test themselves and go in anyways. I am honestly speechless about both this attitude and, if true, the organizer’s irresponsibility. Yes, I know most people only suffer cold-like symptoms. Why should they miss out on their lifelong dream? Quite simply: because they are a biohazard to everyone they meet, who has also worked their entire lives for this opportunity and there is no telling how bad it will be for those. I‘ve had 2 really severe covid infections myself. If someone had injured me and I‘d been bedridden for several weeks each time, with health issues months later, I could have sued them for severe bodily harm. But those selfish @ssholes who showed up at the venue in Antwerp, coughing, not wearing a mask etc. got off scot-free and it still makes me angry. I don’t wanna get into the general political debate on masks/quarantine etc. But for a mass event such as the Olympics, I think there should be some basic health measures in place. Daily temperature checks and mandatory testing for anyone exhibiting symptoms and mandatory isolation/ exit from the village after a positive test would go a long way - at least for anyone in the Olympic village/around the athletes. If worn correctly, masks for the spectators would also decrease risks. Imo, there is a reasonable middle ground between no spectators at all like in Tokyo and no safety protocols. What measures would you like to see? Also happy to hear from anyone who has definitive info on what is in place to protect people in Paris.


r/Gymnastics • • Aug 12 '21

WAG MyKayla Skinner: thoughts on retirement and life after gymnastics

2 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PaBDwpSzn-8
NB The video was recorded a week before she left for Tokyo. Enjoy!


r/Gymnastics • • Aug 21 '26

MAG/WAG Gymnasts with autism

0 Upvotes

Something I've been pondering is top level athletes who are open about having autism.

I'm not looking for people to guess or speculate, rather just share what they know.

I'm currently in zagreb and I'm leaving. One of the men's teams is on my flight and I'm observing one of the athletes and he had some behaviors that someone with autism exhibits. I'm not suggesting he is, but it's got me thinking.

We know people with autism can be extremely successful and prodigal in specific areas. Yet, I've never heard about autistic athletes. Any insight?


r/Gymnastics • • Aug 11 '24

WAG Nadia gave Sabrina her Olympic bronze medal

Post image
14 Upvotes

With all the negativity going on, I thought this was cool to read! Imagine getting Nadia’s Olympic medal!


r/Gymnastics • • Aug 09 '24

WAG Genuine questions about people opinions of the romanian team

0 Upvotes

I have a genuine question about how people see the romanian team, and I genuinely do not mean this with any tongue in cheek. I clearly have a view, but I'd want ti understand the other

I've been seeing a lot of comments saying that "Ana is the only adult, everyone else is unprofessional"

I have the feeling people would see the romanian team as unprofessional for fighting a clearly unright decision. Like what would be the professional choice, to accept the wrong results without putting a fight? I feel like if the tables were turned, the anger of the gymnasts would be justified

Regarding Ana, I completely love her. But while her professionalism is admirable, she also is having less of an angry response because she understands she didn't actually get a score to be on 3rd. Meanwhile. Sabrina would actually have had a score to be on 3rd

I feel people are turning on the Romanian team for fighting back. People seem to give flowers and feel bad for those who were wronged who don't fight, but if they fight back they get labeled as making a circus

And also about Nadia "using her power." We all have our causes, and I haven't seen her be disrespectful. At the end of the day, she's fighting for someone who was wronged, why is that bad?


r/Gymnastics • • Jul 03 '24

WAG Can’t get excited…

5 Upvotes

I know this is lame but I just can’t get excited about the Olympics with Shilese out. I ended up not even being interested in trials once I found out she wasn’t continuing.

I’m very happy for the other team members and I know this is a sad reality of the sport, but I’ve never been so gutted about an injury like this! Anyone else feel similarly?


r/Gymnastics • • May 13 '26

NCAA Livvy on Jimmy Fallon

Post image
1 Upvotes

Congratulations Livvy!

(Here) is the interview.


r/Gymnastics • • Jul 29 '21

WAG Post AA final blues?

1 Upvotes

I’m not in the least bit unhappy with the results, but my emotions aren’t where I would have expected.

I think the restraint in the arena while Jade went on floor may be a factor, I’d quite like to see the final rotation have each group in reverse order.

No 14s in the final rotation on floor and only one in the penultimate rotation on beam I think also made the finish a bit underwhelming - though it seems a bit weird that the top four being so close at the end to same that.

Maybe it’s even just having to wait three days for event finals.

Anyone else got post AA final blues?


r/Gymnastics • • Oct 02 '21

WAG Should Silivas, Bicherova, et. al Be Stripped of Their Medals? An essay

0 Upvotes

There is quite a bit to unpack here, so I will do my best to do write this as clearly and concisely as possible.

I come at this issue from the perspective of someone who is ambivalent about age limits in gymnastics. If there must be one, I'd be in favor of it being 14 or 15. But I wouldn't be opposed to not having an age limit tbh. When it comes to the history of federations falsifying ages, my issue has always been the lack of fairness it inherently caused. Everybody should be held to the same rules and standards, obviously. Cheating goes against the very nature of what sports are about to me.

So getting to the point.. 😂 I really have a problem with how and why Dong Fongxiao was singled out in 2010, and Team China being stripped of both their 1999 World and 2000 Olympic team medals.

Not coincidentally, this medal snatching happened in the shadow of an IOC requested FIG investigation that failed to find any hard evidence of age falsification by the gold medal-winning Chinese gymnastics team at the 2008 Olympics. Sadly hearsay is not valid evidence, but it is a fact that prior to the Games, several people recall hearing sources within China lamenting over what a shame it was that they had a girl who was out of this world on bars but was only 13/14 and wouldn't be age-eligible for the upcoming Games. But just a few months later, she miraculously turned up at those very same Olympics anyway. Her name was He Kexin.

When you have an authoritarian regime determined to make a good impression in front of the entire world and bring home as many medals as possible for said Home Team, it's not so surprising when athletes suddenly become whatever age they need to be. Along with the accompanying passports or documents that are needed to verify it. Once you have the government in collusion with such a practice, it's basically a non-starter when it comes to getting caught.

Unless, that is... you wind up getting caught up years later, which is exactly what happened to Dong Fongxiao. It's tough to keep up a ruse like lying about your age for nearly a decade, and she made the mistake of giving her actual date of birth whilst working as an official at the Beijing Games.

The year she gave in 2008 didn't match the one that she had competed under during her gymnastics career (including meets like the 1999 Worlds and 2000 Olympcs in Sydney). She was actually only 13 at the 99 Worlds and 14 at the 00 Olympics—years below the requirement of being 16 years by December 31st of the current year (or 15 in a year preceding the Olympics which used to be an exception that has since been done away with). And in just a manner of seconds where Dong probably wasn’t even thinking, she had given them the ammo they needed and we were off to SCAPEGOAT CITY.

Now Dominique Dawes is a 3 time Olympic team medalist! And poor Fongxiao is just another casualty in a cruel system she had no say in who just did what she was told to do.

This is the backdrop for an alarming issue that has been spreading like wildfire in recent years.

Many younger fans have accused many longtime fans (i.e. basically anyone who thinks He Kexin was 14 and underage in Beijing) of being racist against Chinese people. As someone who was a whole grown-ass man in 2008 and not a zygote or small child, this seems incredibly offensive.

Those of us with critical thinking skills remember a pretty staggering amount of evidence at the time showing He was underage. And we didn’t take much stock in potentially fabricated passports from a totalitarian regime, for obvious reasons.

Even though it may be hard to believe, the internet of 2008 wasn’t quite the animal it was today. Facebook was still in its infancy. Twitter had barely been launched and Instagram didn't even exist yet. There definitely was not the same level of divisive rhetoric and games of telephone that go on now.

The information about He was certainly not "fake news" or the sort of bullshit that partisan internet users will take as fact nowadays (e.g. the 2020 US Election was rigged with mystery Biden votes coming out of nowhere).

I honestly am not sure why there is so much vitriol towards fans who feel the Chinese cheated in 2008. Perhaps the idea that multiple girls were underage gives more fuel to the accusations of racism? Or the misguided naivite of youth and wanting to believe that a federation wouldn’t lie and cheat like this? I understand being a fan of a program and giving it the benefit of the doubt when it comes to following the rules, but doing the equivalent of sticking your fingers in your ears and burying your head in the sand so you don't have to hear or see the facts is not the way to go about it.

Whatever the motive or reasoning, it is very insulting to be called a racist when the conclusions you’ve come to have nothing to do with race and everything to do with logic, reasoning, and the history of the issue in the sport.

I absolutely understand the viewpoint that targeting the Chinese team in Sydney was unfair, although I wouldn't go as far to say it was racist. And while no fewer than three other countries have either admitted or had evidence provided of age falsification, none have any allegations as recent as China. Again, I don't think this is racist, it's just pointing out facts. Logically, it’s just not that much of a stretch to think China would have been falsifying ages in 2008 if they had been just 8 years prior to that. There is also evidence of Cheng Fei's age being falsified in 2004.

This is not racism. It's a pattern.

When it comes to federations besides China or North Korea, the last gymnast I can recall being proved underage was Romanian Alexandra Marinescu in the mid-90s. (If there are others, hopefully someone will point them out in the thread below.)

The rules regarding punishment for age falsification are incredibly confusing. My knowledge of the FIG over the past 29 years gives me a hunch that that is not accidental. I've heard there is a statute of limitations, which would have to be the case considering the vast number of gymnasts known to be underage who comfortably still have all their medals in their possession.

Even after North Korea submitted multiple different years of birth for the same athlete and ended up being banned for a time, I'm not sure any attempts were made by the FIG to actually, you know, UNCOVER THE CORRECT BIRTHDATE OF THE ATHLETE IN QUESTION? I imagine there is a chance that Kim Gwang Suk was still underage in 1991, but she was allowed to compete and won the gold medal on bars.

So while I resent being called racist for not thinking He Kexin magically aged 2 years in a manner of months, the devil's advocate in my head is saying if Dong Fongxiao and Co. had to give back their medals, why not everybody?

I am even willing to volunteer to be the one to personally go to the home of Daniela Silivas-Harper and collect her beam gold and team silver from the 1985 Worlds. I'm not sure where Kati Szabo is living these days, but I would be overjoyed to hand her the beam gold she never was able to physically win at an actual World Championships. Thirty-six years later is better than never.

And while I love my Soviets more than life itself, rules are rules. All the individual and team medals won by and with gymnasts who were underage should be stripped as well. That includes MANY of my idols such as Ilienko, Mostepanova, and even poor Yurchenko by association. I would be crushed, but what's good for the goose has to be good for the gander. I can’t be hypocritical about this.

I wonder if maybe because these Chinese fans can't yell at the FIG for taking away the 2000 team's medals that accusing us of being racist somehow makes up for it? In any case, it's very disturbing and I wish there could be some sort of resolution. The collective well-being of the Gymternet at large could certainly benefit from better communication and a deeper understanding of fans’ differences.


r/Gymnastics • • Nov 25 '21

NCAA Why are top gymnasts still going to LSU?

14 Upvotes

With Amari Drayton's commitment to LSU recently, it just made me curious. They have Konnor McClain, Zoe Miller, and Kylie Coen as well for that 2023 class.

Maybe its just me but I don't get it. Sure their facility is nice but I don't understand how any gymnast or someone with values could want to attend LSU as a school or be coached by a Trump supporter like Jay. Plus all they do is shove religion down everyone's throat. My friends daughter who was recently there for a recruiting visit talked about how extremely uncomfortable it was.

LSU and OU may be the most unlikable programs in NCAA.


r/Gymnastics • • Jun 02 '24

WAG Too Strong of Doubt in Josc Here

6 Upvotes

Listen, I don’t think she’s likely to make this Olympic team and I think she’s throwing messy skills right now, but this subreddit has been BRUTAL to Josc. Every time she comes up everyone’s so aggressive saying that she just has absolutely no chance no matter what. Her difficulty is high and if she can pull together her E score tonight and at trials I think she might be a little bit more in the conversation that people think. Again, I’m not saying she has a good chance at making the team at this point at all, especially with Skye’s cheng, but I think IF she steps it up and starts hitting, she still has a decent chance at being an alternate.


r/Gymnastics • • Aug 24 '22

WAG Anyone else really worried that Valeri Liukin is not pacing Konnor well and she’s going to have a hard crash like Rebecca Bross did?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Gymnastics • • Mar 26 '22

WAG Carlotta Ferlito Receives Her Bachelor Degree In Communications

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/Gymnastics • • Apr 16 '23

WAG Mykayla & Jonas podcast

0 Upvotes

Anyone listening? I have so many thoughts. In their most recent episode, they went on and on about how they can just scoop up some social media collabs to find their baby shower. Yet all they do is complain about social media. Seems like Jonas is super opportunistic. Especially considering that he has “husband of Olympic gold medalist” on his LinkedIn page ☠️


r/Gymnastics • • Jul 07 '21

WAG MyKayla was not being unsportsmanlike for liking the tweets

41 Upvotes

I've been reflecting on this post lately about MyKayla being a bad person for liking some tweets from fans that wanted her on the team.

Unpopular opinion, but I don't think it was unsportsmanlike for MyKayla to like tweets saying that they are "disappointed" she didn't make the team...

I mean, can't a girl be disappointed?! MyK lost out on a chance at a team gold medal! It's disappointing!! We shouldn't expect every athlete to just be all smiley and say "I am so grateful for this individual spot".

Is it a privilege to be able to go to the Olympics? Yes, and I'm sure MyK is grateful for that! But I can also imagine how frustrating it must be to work your butt off and know that only 3 tenths of you separated yourself from a team gold medal at the OLYMPICS.

None of the tweets attacked Grace in any way, just expressing their wish that MyK made the team. She's liking the tweets for the support she gets from her fans


r/Gymnastics • • Aug 13 '24

WAG Sabrina’s score

7 Upvotes

Has the deduction for Sabrina been verified?? I know there have been many assumptions that it was the OOB for her heal, but she did downgrade her routine. Why is everyone focusing on the OOB? I keep hearing that her score was miscalculated but I don’t think it was. She asked for an inquiry and it was reviewed at that time and didn’t change and she appealed her inquiry which was dismissed. In my eyes her score is legitimate, why is she still being brought into the conversation? If we have no facts about her situation why are we assuming she was underscored? 13.700 is a good score!


r/Gymnastics • • Aug 09 '25

MAG/WAG Xfinity gripes

0 Upvotes

Why does this event always look like someone pulled it together with $50 and a day's notice? Is it just me?

The announcer is grating. These men doing the audience interactions and things in the breaks are cringey. The music? Why am I hearing a Taylor Swift song from 10 years ago while Claire Pease is on beam? Can she hear that?

The entire thing just seems so unprofessional and it makes me mad for the athletes.

EDIT: I'm not saying it should be quiet. I just don't think the quality of this event stands up to the level the athletes are at.


r/Gymnastics • • Jun 23 '24

Rhythmic Missing the Elegance of Pre-1997 Gymnastics

1 Upvotes

I've been thinking about how gymnastics has changed and I really miss the elegance of the routines before 1997, especially during the 70s and 80s. Back then, the sport focused more on graceful, fluid movements.

Today, it feels like routines are just powerful, disjointed moves strung together. While the athleticism is impressive, it often lacks the elegance and seamless flow that used to define gymnastics. I miss the artistry and storytelling in the performances of gymnasts like Nadia Comăneci and Olga Korbut. Their routines were not just technically impressive but truly beautiful to watch.


r/Gymnastics • • Nov 10 '22

WAG Alice Kinsella vs Jessica -- All around bronze

0 Upvotes

Okay after a week of digestion of the 2022 Worlds results and seeing how the EFs are being scored, we can re-visit the super controversial AA competition between Alice and Jessica.

For me, it's Alice who should have won and y'all can break it down further by scores but I am just doing it by event--

Vault: Alice should be scored way higher than Jess here (I think Alice only had a 0.1 hop and stayed center, but was appropriately scored at 14.166 whereas Jess was off-center, had a huge step, got out of bounds and had a slight squat and should not be 0.2 lower than Alice here at 13.833)

Bars: I think scores are fair for both here. Jess improved and Alice scored consistently with team finals, etc.

Beam: Okay, the difference between Jess' score and Alice's score should not be that different. Jess had a pretty flawless routine but had a slight squat and 0.3 step on the landing so she should not score above a 8.0 execution + leaps were not perfect. Keep in mind, Jess has the best execution score here in the all around competition on beam. She scored a 12.933 in quals. I think Jess is overscored and Alice was scored pretty appropriately - the gap between them here is too wide.

Floor: Okay, Jess is clearly overscored here... 14.1-2 would be more appropriate. I feel like Shilese would not have scored a 13.7 (both her turns should not be credited imo so should score lower than TF/Quals if Jessica did not get that 14.4). I think Alice was appropriately scored (she had a really good routine) and Jess was a couple of tenths too high.

Ultimately, the argument can go either way. I am not saying Alice deserves Bronze but I thought she had a more comprehensive set of routines on that day. Jessica had some really large errors on her dismounts and had a terrible vault. This is going to be Gabby vs Komova 2012 and Mustafina vs Shang 2016 again, and honestly it's okay. I just hope people aren't too heated in this discussion


r/Gymnastics • • Jan 24 '26

NCAA OU Gymnastics Hate?

2 Upvotes

I'm new to the NCAA scene (really started watching closely last season), and it seems like OU has the most hate of any of the top teams. The other top teams all seem to have large fanbases and followings to offset some of the criticism they get (LSU, UCLA, Florida) or they kind of fly under the radar and don't receive a ton of good or bad feedback (Mizzou, Bama, etc.). Is there a reason why OU gets this hate? Is it just because they're good? Is there more of a backstory to it? Or maybe I'm just imagining things! Would love some insight!!