Disclaimer: Yes, I know this is breaking the NDA. Before I would have been as appalled as a lot of you are when people break. But sadly, I just don't care anymore. I don't care if they ban my account.
I went from a GW2 megafan that read every single post in this subreddit for the last month, to someone that is done playing the beta, in the span of one day. Some of you who are in the beta will disagree with me, but I think a lot of people will agree.
I was basically frothing at the mouth to play this game, and I was very excited to finally log in. My expectations were kept in check, but it was hard not to be excited about all of the promises Anet had made. The cash shop fiasco didn't bother me and I had a lot of faith in them.
The game is good. A lot of what they've done is pretty innovative. However, a lot of their innovative selling points just don't live up to the hype --- not even close. And of course these selling points are the ones that people are REALLY excited about, so when you try to tell people about them the usual response is that "you don't understand", "you're playing wrong", or "that selling point is the best part!".
I've played WoW, I've played Conan, I've played WAR, etc etc. When GW2 came along and promised to revolutionize the genre that those games all fell in to, well of course I was excited. But to my surprise, I don't know if it really does. All that I had heard about GW2 made me actively NOT want to play other MMOs; GW2 gave me a sense that after it you just could never go back to a normal MMO. I realized how tired the MMO formula was and I entered a monogamous relationship of expectation with GW2.
Here's the thing though. After playing the beta, I feel like GW2 is in actuality one of those games that I "could never go back to". There are a lot of good things about the game, but then other things ... The main promise I feel was blown WAY out of proportion was the whole "You use your skills at the right time! You have to use them in the best situation" design philosophy. It just isn't true, at least in PVE. Against "normal" mobs, the numerous conditions and effects you affect the mobs with are completely unnecessary and pointless. The best way to play is to use every cooldown the second it becomes available. And without any resource system to manage, this is just too easy and too mindless. Sadly the same thing goes for the "hard" mobs and minibosses - you just have to keep everything on cooldown, and run and dodge if you feel like it.
The bread-and-butter button hitting of the game disappointed me. Not in that it's worse than other MMOs. It's just the same. I was expecting so much more. I found myself growing bored, hitting the same buttons without ANY active thought on my part, and it's not like I was failing or having a hard time. I played for a while, and then to my astonishment, was bored. "I should go browse Reddit for a bit" was never a thought I expected to have while playing the game, but I did.
The combat just feels a bit ... mindless. Look, it's not that I expected or wanted a DPS "rotation". No, I completely agreed with the hype that not having a rotation was one of the best parts about GW2. But the thing is ... you DO have a rotation in basic PVE. This promise was just not fulfilled, and I don't see how anyone who has played the beta could disagree with that (but I'm sure some will).
The one area where I my problems with the game could be solved is in competitive PVP. I don't think it's a good idea to do your normal strategy of keeping everything on cooldown in PVP -- and that's great. Obviously you won't want to use your damage + blind skill when you don't need to blind the target, as it would obviously be better to save it for when you need it. This is because you know you are playing against a human who can react to what you are doing. This doesn't happen with PVE mobs. You just use your damage + blind skill whenever it's up because why the fuck not? I've realized that the system Arena Net is after almost necessitates PVE AI that is much more diverse and reactive that it is. The PVE mobs are just like those in any other MMO you've played. They'll come and auto-attack you and maybe do one ability like cast a fireball or knock you back or something. But it's not like it takes any intense reactive gameplay for you to kill them --- no, you just keep everything on cooldown and cycle through your damage abilities as mindlessly as before.
When I noticed this, I realized I just didn't want to play. It became the same game that all of the Anet promises had ensured I could never return to again.
Oh well. I'm done for now, but I'm still interested in seeing what the game turns out like at launch. I'll probably wait and see if it's worth buying (something I couldn't have fathomed doing 24 hours ago). I just don't know if they can fix this aspect of the game, as it seems so ingrained into everything else they've done. And hey, it might not bother some people. But me, I'm out for now.