r/GreatBritishBakeOff • • Nov 04 '25

Series 12 / Collection 9 Unfair??! Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I’m just so confused how the judging this year was based on the bakes throughout the series! This has never happened before Tom definitely deserved that win


r/GreatBritishBakeOff • • Dec 12 '23

Help/Question How do producers ensure no one catches Covid before or during the competition?

5 Upvotes

Are the contestants isolated for the entire competition? I’m really curious how they pull this off.


r/GreatBritishBakeOff • • Nov 25 '23

Series 9 / Collection 6 Justice for Matt Lucas

18 Upvotes

I know his work on the show wasn't super popular, but I'm rewatching season 9 right now and Noel and his skits and bits keep cracking me up! I find myself enjoying more of his banter with contestants too.

I think he just has a sharper-edged humor that maybe caught people off-guard in the context of Bake Off. But damn, the man is funny!


r/GreatBritishBakeOff • • Nov 15 '24 Bless Up

GBBO Cast Tinned peaches and "Northern portions"

1 Upvotes

I don't hate her overall, but I find it really annoying how Gill has been repeatedly criticized for amateurish moves like her clunky bakes that she excused as "Northern" or the bizarre choice of using canned peaches on her meringue when it seems obvious that fresh would be better. Sure, the contestants are amateurs, but isn't the point of the show for them to rise to a more professional level? It feels like she wants to just do it her way and not be criticized for homely, imperfect traits in a bake even though she's in a competition.


r/GreatBritishBakeOff • • Oct 06 '26

GBBO Cast Danni is such a pure soul absolute breath of fresh air 🩷

0 Upvotes

I just finished watching the clip where the bakers recorded messages to their future selves on Day 1, and I had to come here to post about Danni.

She is truly such a genuine, adorable, and delightful presence in the tent. Walked to the beat of her own drum the entire time and brought so much pure effervescence and positivity to the show.

I’m really going to miss her smiling face honestly, they should bring her back as a co-host or keep her on the show in some way! What did everyone else think of her run this season?


r/GreatBritishBakeOff • • 18d ago

Help/Question Season 17 : Poorest contestants of all time?

0 Upvotes

I was looking forward to this season but so far it’s just meh - previous contestants seem so much more competent, creative and interesting. These ones ( esp bread week!) come across as unprepared and well rather boring…..


r/GreatBritishBakeOff • • Oct 18 '25

Series 13 / Collection 10 What did you think of Ian’s showstopper in the latest episode? Spoiler

15 Upvotes

Ian’ showstopper that was a bin (trash can for the Americans) because the last Ian from Glasgow was the contestant that left the show after throwing his bake in the bin. I’m sure the previous Ian has been embarrassed by this for the last decade, it was one of the more infamous moments from the show. Ian making the bin now just felt like he was making fun of him and didn’t really feel in the spirit of the show. Why bring it up again and torture the poor guy with it?


r/GreatBritishBakeOff • • Nov 11 '23

Meta Tasha saved by production? Spoiler

12 Upvotes

Tasha’s my favorite person on the show and imo the best baker this season… but did production save her in episode 7 (collection 11)?

The technical was basically a wash (Tash edged out but everyone did terrible), the signature was relatively even, with some doing better than others but no one making a clear lead, so it was all on the showstopper.

At the end of the time limit on the showstopper Tash’s bombe was falling so she stopped it from falling with a jar. Remove the jar and it falls down (or at least is sidewise). Quick cut to judging where the jar is removed and her bombe is arranged to not fall, and no one makes a mention of it.

Did production save tasha from losing with a disastrous showstopper? (The question is if. Let’s not speculate why)


r/GreatBritishBakeOff • • Nov 09 '24

GBBO Cast I know we’ve done a so many “Dylan looks like…” but here is my headcannon

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/GreatBritishBakeOff • • Oct 01 '26

Help/Question Accessibility

3 Upvotes

I'm all for my fellow disabled people being treated the same as absolutely everyone else

HOWEVER

What are people's thoughts on Molly having to mix stuff on her lap and the incident in the first episode being caused by the lack of accessibility in the tent

Do we not think she could have at least been given a lowered working top?

Okay maybe she was asked and she said no

But like

Yeah. Just a question aha

And no I'm not disabled person bashing or anything. As I said. Fellow disabled. Was just a query. Anyone else thinking this?

Pls be kind. I'm only human Xx


r/GreatBritishBakeOff • • Nov 01 '25

Help/Question Super pissed 😡 Spoiler

13 Upvotes

If you are in the USA I’m spoiling!!!!!!!!

How in the hell did Tom stay again and they made Toby leave?!! Like I genuinely don’t get it. And don’t get me started on jasmine- it’s ridic at this point. Do they even try to pick a winner or just say Jasmine as a default? Honestly I’m not even mad about her bc she’s genuinely fantastic. But Tom over Toby just pissed me right the eff off. AGAIN
Why is this season such a bummer? It’s like a popular contest and it feels like so weirdly over produced.


r/GreatBritishBakeOff • • Sep 27 '26 Bravo

Series 12 / Collection 9 Nigella eating cake

14 Upvotes

Lol I just can't look past the way Nigella eats cake like it's her first time eating cake 😭 WHY are the mouthfuls so awkward looking 😭

edit: so many things omg

  1. I did not know there were already posts about this

  2. my issue was never with the bite sizes? go girl, eat all the cake u want?! i found it strange because she has been tasting food for a whiLE (i only know her from masterchef au) and it was just funny seeing her take these awkward bites, it's not hate lol


r/GreatBritishBakeOff • • Oct 20 '23

Help/Question is Tasha actually doing real sign language with her hands?

18 Upvotes

Let me start off by saying, I do not mean to be rude or offensive.

But at various times throughout the season, I’ve noticed that Tasha seems to be doing the same 7-10 signs while she’s talking. By contrast, the interpreter they’ve hired for the season seems to be using quite a bit wider range of signs.

I’m not fluent in British Sign Language, but can anyone who is confirm for me that she’s actually signing correctly?


r/GreatBritishBakeOff • • Oct 23 '21

Meta Hosts should stop preambling the announcement of who is leaving by saying "I've got the horrible job of announcing who is going home"

2 Upvotes

The person leaving is the one feeling horrible and having such a huge blow to their dreams so I don't like how the hosts make it all about themselves by mentioning their dislike of needing to announce it. It dilutes the impact of what is the real horribleness- that a person has to leave. All I can think when a host says something like "I've got the horrible job..." is "Get off the cross. The baker who is leaving needs the wood."


r/GreatBritishBakeOff • • 27d ago

Meta hey excuse me but

0 Upvotes

the skill ceiling is on the floor this season. Producers/casting missed the mark and the magic of the show is suffering because of it.

Hands down, hardest season to watch to date.


r/GreatBritishBakeOff • • Jul 16 '22

Current Series/Season Why did Giuseppe go to belgium?

0 Upvotes

Why?


r/GreatBritishBakeOff • • Nov 01 '25

Help/Question Who would you pick to replace Paul?

0 Upvotes

I find myself in agreement with a lot of the observations around Paul's behavior and biases. I've even begun to wonder if he is simply tired of doing this job. If you were able to select Paul's replacement, who would be your pick, and why? What other changes would you make about how the bakers are judged?


r/GreatBritishBakeOff • • Oct 14 '26

GBBO Cast Poly representation! Spoiler

163 Upvotes

When I saw that Gabe was introduced as one of the members of a three-person relationship in Week 1, I was overjoyed at the representation of alternate relationships. Gabe seems like such fun, and meeting Ellis, one of his partners in Week 3 (another part of "boyband") made for such delightful watching. We need more of this out in the world!! Healthy, fun-loving representation of non-monogamous relationships was not on my GBBO Bingo Card but oh so very welcome!


r/GreatBritishBakeOff • • Oct 27 '25

Series 12 / Collection 9 Aaron has dirt on the judges Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Not really, but something is up. They BARELY covered him in the episode, and this is the third week now that he completely got a flipflop judging.

  1. He won the Star Baker, out of pity, they even mention it in the episode. He didn’t deserve it, even remotely.

  2. He did terribly in last weeks episode, and the judges changed their mind like a 180. Saying that he did really well with his pastry, despite it being terrible. Seriously, go back and watch it. They criticized it, then praised it.

  3. Then this week. It was a trifle challenge, and a gelatin layer is essential. He absolutely screwed up his one layer it was like rubber. The second gelatin layer was too wet. Then the sponge was super dry. Then, when discussing the results, they did he did really well and that it was great.

Tinfoil conspiracy, there is something up and he’s got dirt on someone…


r/GreatBritishBakeOff • • Dec 03 '23

Fun How would you improve Bake Off next year?

17 Upvotes

Reading the interview with Michael Chakravety (former contestant) in the Guardian today, he makes the point that Bake off's contestants are "its beating heart" and the reason we come back to watch the show every year. I've always felt this way too. I love GBBO because of the characters and the camaraderie and not the increasingly staged drama (and this year was better for having less of it), the hosts, nor the judges even.

For this reason, I've always felt that GBBO shouldn't have a weekly elimination. Instead, it should be a league.

As a league, we get to see all the contestants compete (and support one another) until the final week. How would it work? Each week, someone wins one of the 3 weekly challenges and gains a point for each challenge won. Handshakes are also awarded a point. At the end of the competition, the person with the most points wins.

It gives everyone a chance to shine. Like when Prison Governor Paul made his Bread Lion. Plus, it forces the producers to cast a more consistently talented group of amateurs (no more Stuart's).

One limitation could be that someone wins before the final but - as a solution - more emphasis could be placed on other prizes e.g. 'best decoration', 'best show-stopper', 'most original bake', etc. These could all be contested for up to the final week and would encourage contestants to pull out all the stops for one of these secondary/runner-up prizes.

Anyway, this is just how I would 'improve' Bake Off - how would you do it?


r/GreatBritishBakeOff • • Oct 20 '24

Help/Question Why does Paul cut such big slices when trying the bakes?

7 Upvotes

I can't imagine people are eating the slices after he cuts them, and then he and Prue take such small bites. It seems like so much waste to me.


r/GreatBritishBakeOff • • Nov 20 '23

Help/Question Tagging as a spoiler because I don’t know if everyone has seen it. Did (Someone) cheat? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Was is not cheating when Cristy used Dan’s crumbs?


r/GreatBritishBakeOff • • Oct 30 '24

Help/Question Where are you watching the show? - No Spoilers

1 Upvotes

Hi all! I keep catching posts on here that are posted a couple days before I see the episode. For example I haven’t had Episode 6 become available on Netflix yet and it says it’ll air Nov. 1st. Are people watching the episodes come out somewhere else?


r/GreatBritishBakeOff • • Nov 05 '25

Help/Question Anyone else notice that in the finale’s technical… Spoiler

0 Upvotes

…the judges had nothing nice to say about Jasmine’s (“total mess” “lackluster” “no hump on the madeleines” “underbaked”) until it was revealed to be Jasmine’s? (“It tastes fantastic though!😍”)

Wouldn’t have been praised at all if it was Aaron or Tom’s and Paul was the one revealing the result instead of Prue.